Tesla's Parking Face-Off: Vision Park Assist vs Ultrasonic Sensors
Вставка
- Опубліковано 13 жов 2024
- We compare the all new Tesla Vision Parking Assist features in the latest 2023 holiday software update, VS. the Ultrasonic Sensors in older model Tesla cars or USS. Tesla Vision Park Assist vs Ultrasonic Sensors: Which is Better? Comment below and let us know. Is this really 3D High Fidelity Park Assist? Could this be a glimpse of FSD Beta V12?
NOTE: Both cars are on software version 2023.44.30.5.1
Join Tesla Tips and Trips to get access to perks:
/ @teslatipstrips
Please subscribe to our channel! www.youtube.co...
TESLA REFERRAL CODE IS BACK - ts.la/kerry15109
These tips are based on our experience with our 2019 Tesla Model 3 SR+, and 2022 Tesla Model Y Performance. Use at your own discretion.
Find us on Facebook & Twitter
/ teslatipstrips
/ teslatipstrips
#Tesla #TeslaModelY #TeslaModel3
Our Favorite Tesla Accessories
MagBak
Grab 15% off of iPhone Wireless Charger
creators.magba...
Coupon Code: TeslaTips15
MagBak RimCase for Tesla Model 3 and Model Y
creators.magba...
Coupon Code: TESLATIPS&TRIPS15
Basenor (Direct)
www.basenor.co...
Basenor (Amazon)
amzn.to/3StWuQw
Basenor Floor Mats (Model Y) amzn.to/47QFQio
Basenor Floor Mats (Model 3) amzn.to/3N0CrW4
Basenor Armrest Cover (Model 3&Y) amzn.to/3uFPHZR
Basenor Mud Guards Model Y: amzn.to/3N2WX8K
Spigen Glass Screen Protector: amzn.to/3ReBgFa
Samsung T7 SSD Drive for Sentry Mode: amzn.to/40U0POO
Logitech F310 Gaming Controller: amzn.to/3uFPHZR
Jowua Roof Sunshade Model Y: amzn.to/47NJuJR
Jowua Center Console USB Hub: amzn.to/40Ta2qN
Jowua Foldable Desk Tray: amzn.to/47SKkoL
Jowua 100w USB Laptop Charger: amzn.to/47TX925
Jowua Center Organizer: amzn.to/3N2SGC1
Tesla Road Trip Accessories Featured in our videos
Modern Spare: amzn.to/47sXN6B
Fanttik Air Compressor: amzn.to/47NojaB
Tire Plug Kit: amzn.to/3QXeQ9T
Lectron CCS: amzn.to/3MXTUOQ
Basenor Frunk Cooler: amzn.to/3MXTUOQ
Basenor Model Y Trunk Inserts: amzn.to/3Gk1Jed
Extension Cord: amzn.to/40Tmwyw
Autosock: amzn.to/46yAXcL
Johnson and Johnson First Aid Kit: amzn.to/4a4yD06
Snow Brush / Ice Scraper Kit: amzn.to/49Q7FZY
Sleeping Bags: amzn.to/3Rhp5rh
Double Ice Packs: amzn.to/3sPjqPG
Jump Starter Battery: amzn.to/47wLlmq
Large Blue Ikea Bag: amzn.to/49Q6OIL
Our Favorite Video / Audio Equipment
iPhone 14/15: amzn.to/3SYWSXj
GoPro Hero 12: amzn.to/3QQpxeu
GoPro Suction Mount: amzn.to/3GkwnEh
Spigen Magsafe Suction Mount: amzn.to/3N2trQt
Movo Vlogging Rig: amzn.to/3ReB7l6
62” Tripod: amzn.to/3QUojih
LED Clip On Lighting: amzn.to/49QBcCL
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases
Topics We Cover:
tesla
tesla news
tesla updates
tesla rumors
tesla leaks
new tesla
tesla model y
model y tesla
tesla model 3
tesla model y
tesla model s
tesla model x
tesla details
cybertruck paint
model y mini
new tesla
project highland tesla
ev battery
ev batteries
tesla batteries
2024 model 3
new model 3
tesla model 3 highland
highland model 3
juniper model y
highland model y
2024 model y
new model y
model 2
25000 tesla
cyber robotaxi
Disclaimer:
Due to factors beyond my control, I cannot guarantee against improper use of the information I share in my videos. (Tesla Tips & Trips) assumes no liability for property damage or injury incurred as a result of any of the information contained in this video. Use this information at your own risk. Any injury, damage, or loss that may result from improper use of these tools, equipment, or from the information contained in this video is the sole responsibility of the user and not (Tesla Tips & Trips) or any business affiliated to (Tesla Tips & Trips).
I understand that Tesla is breaking ground with the technology it's developing with Teslavision. However, as a consumer, I don't like that my 2023 RWD struggles to help me park. I'm coming from a 2012 335 and that car, though 12 years old, had 360 camera views that effectively helped me park. I never hit a curb having a 360 camera view but yet, I hear about wheel rash on much more modern Teslas because the parking system is not great. Instead of reinventing the wheel and pushing out blobs before the new wheel is invented, Tesla could easily place cameras in the front bumper and below the mirrors to give us proper 360 camera views. At least in the mean time. I mean does anyone really prefer blobs, parenthesis, or models jittering around instead of a live camera feed? Take the coolness aside and think practical, when it comes to assisting you to park, the optimal solution already exists but Tesla refuses to provide it because of a bigger picture goal. If Elon were my personal freind, or I was a Tesla employee,(maybe even of I owned a lot of stock), I would say yeah, Tesla vision is the future, lets all tolerate the now for the greatness that is coming later. But I don't really care about what's coming 5-10 years from now, I'm trying to park my car that I paid for with today's money. I love my new car BTW, but I can also be objective. Rant over 😊
of course they could add additional cameras and bring back the senors but I guess they wont since their main goal is to save money.
Coming from a car with no cameras or sensors I am appreciating the blobs helping me park. I might have felt different if I had sensors first.
That makes sense, thanks for watching!
Thanks! Yeah I was wondering what was wrong with my camera system. Unfortunately scratched a wheel because it’s not very precise.
IMHO both systems seems kinda bad? Will they work at all in snow/rain? My cheapo Ford Focus' sensors works well here in Sweden, even when I got like 10" of snow around the car
Agreed
Hello. I notice id you switch to FSD, you will see more (2 way traffic). When on just cruise control, it only diaplay 1 side of traffic (driving side)
@TeslaTipsTrips was wondering if you have done a video on best types of storage devices? I have a off brand ssd in both my teslas but seems to be slow pulling up the footage each time.
i just wish they'd bring back USS (and retrofit models that are missing it)
That would require drilling 8 holes, and a ton of extra work, I don't see that happening unfortunately. Thanks for watching.
Are those of us who have the parking sensors ever going to get these capabilities as well? I could definitely use help with the positioning of the car within a parking spot.
nope. don't the sensor work ok for parking now?
@@cheesun124 Nope. Side views pretty nonexistent. I have trouble centering.
lol you weren’t even that close to that car in front of you at 7:00min you are far too paranoid when parking
what you are seeing is the raw output of occupancy network. it looks less refined but it is far more accurate to where things are in relation to the car. this is more important for fsd or seeing lines/curbs on the ground for parking
Ok, still needs to look nice for the humans ;)
Getting rid of ultrasonic sensors was a mistake, imo. Cameras can't see if they are blocked in snow, ice, fog, heaving rain, especially at night. Might be better if instead of 'blobs' you actually see a live feed on the display, especially when parking in forward movement.
Interesting to be sure.
I have a ‘21 M3 SR+, so it has the sensors and radar.
I’ve always figured the cameras are an integral part of what’s shown on the screen. The radar and the sensors don’t “see” trash cans or cones or vehicle types or pedestrians - all of which have always shown up on my screen, driving or parking. Those details must come from the cameras.
Also, as you have a ‘19, do you know if the radar is still functioning in those Teslas which were equipped with that hardware? Or did Tesla “disable” radar with an OTA update?
Great video! Thanks for showing us the blobs/sonograms!
When it rains, the camera for parking or low speed will be useless
Probably
It is definitely really hard for me to fully trust it. Our other car (non-Tesla) has a camera 360 surround view that I trust completely and is wayyyy better.
Umm atleast Tesla isn’t showing a distorted view I hate 360 view because it’s so distorted as you look around the car and it’s different cameras
@@Tylerbb8122not if it’s done correctly then jt isn’t distorted at all
obviously getting rid of the USS was a bad idea, same for the stalks. I think I will hold on the Highland until this is fixed. great demo, thanks
I appreciate that, thank you!
I think the park assist really shines in a parking lot. It shows you the line so it possible to center your car.
This shows compelling reasons to just keep my current car with the sensors for longer than I anticipated before getting a newer model
Tesla Vision is getting better and better. At first I was a bit annoyed that I didn't have a USS because of the endless delivery time of 10 months. But Tesla Vision is pretty good now. The version in the video is already outdated.
Definitely a big improvement and more to come from what it was before. More accurate. I compared bumper to bumper and it was pretty much spot on.
Good to know, that's has not been our experience with it so far. Thanks for watching!
Agree. Very accurate for me as well.
The “blobs” visualization is fine. I’m not sure what people expect to see, it’s not like they are going to make icons and sprites for every object in a garage. The switch to remove USS before vision was on par is total crap. I was considering trading my 2021 MY LR for a performance but this alone holds me back. It’s fine if they think it can eventually reach parity but you can’t rip out the sensors prematurely just to claim a cost reduction to bump the stock price for a quarter. Sigh
Switch to reverse gear for blob mode. Then you can stay in blob mode if switch back to drive if stay at slow speed (2mph?) if I remember correctly
Interesting, makes sense, I suppose. That's the behavior I noticed, thanks for watching.
It would be nice if you posted the version number.
Both cars are on 2023.44.30.5.1, I'll put that in the notes. Thanks!
Thank u buddy
I hate the blobs. I did like when it was more refined. When driving into a parking spot my model Y will tell me to stop. But when I look in front of the car. I’m about 24 inches from the curb and the butt is close to the end of the white lines. I hate leaving my car sticking out that much.
I am using this feature for some weeks now, i feel it is more accurate and is a good addition in terms of a 360 view. It is not perfect yet, but i believe it is a very good update.
Park assist is improved but it is still not 100%
My understanding for the reason for the lack of a true birdseye (360 view) is that the feature is patented. I believe Nissan owns it. Tesla is loath to pay licensing fees when they have so many of the best engineers. So they implemented birdseye as an animation, but still needs refinement. Also needs a camera on front bumper.
Makes sense, since it's such a horrible implementation.
reviewer goes I'm about to hit this car !!! lmfao 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
lol Tesla trying to spin its lack of a basic 360 camera as some revolutionary technology. My bmw self parks itself perfectly every-time, something none of our teslas have ever done successfully
Yup
Bring back sensors. Period
Yup
Cars with HW v4 have cameras only, but the cameras are 4K, whereas HW v3 has 1080 cameras and sensors. For the cameras only, the system is using real time video analytics to analyze each frame and run it through a machine learning trained model to make decisions. Tesla is pushing this envelop far more than anyone else in the analytics industry (my small company is doing the same analytics but for security cameras). My personal feeling is they shouldn't have dropped the sensors (LiDar iirc), but I understand the reasoning to drop them. Chip shortages are a real issue for the EV industry, and removing the sensors solved the shortage issue they were having in 2021-2022 (6+months delayed deliveries). Yes, the models need improvements (blobs), but this is all software. Training models in my industry takes months for a new analytics model (we have early smoke detection, loitering detection, PPE detection for construction sites, etc), and these are working with static cameras (security cameras mounted to fixed locations). Having a model that works with moving cameras is extremely difficult (we tried to train a drone camera feed - being a small outfit it was estimated to take ~2 years given the compute resources we have available to us).
Thanks for adding a ton of information here, much appreciated!
In other words, the product is not ready for use by the public. Once the shortages eased, they should have resumed production of vehicles with the appropriate sensors that provide the experience the customer expects nowadays, while simultaneously continuing to collect the data from all of the cars' cameras, further developing the Tesla Vision models (possibly even using the lidar sensors to help refine the accuracy of the visual-based system), and only switching exclusively to cameras only once the system was really sorted out. Instead, we have this approach, which damages Tesla's reputation with the mainstream, who are not willing to be used as beta testers, and actually holds Tesla back from quicker development to stay ahead of competitors and move the game ahead even more. Sorry for the rant, it just frustrates me.
Just to correct you, tesla never had lidar, they do not have rain sensors, radar and USS.
people don't fall for the Tesla Kool-Aid I own a Tesla and yes there's some things I really love about the car it has an amazing stereo after I spent $2000 to upgrade it it handles really well after I spent $10,000 on my suspension so yes now it's an OK car but removing sensors not having Lidar not having radar is a complete mistake!!
You said " uterus " 🤣🤣
Tesla vision doesnt work properly. It is totally useless.
Try this: park your car, leave the car, put a large barrel type of stuff front and rear of the car. go back the car and start it. it needs to move to see the obstacles. what if it is too late?
11:29 that's not wierd. that is tesla vision's normal.
it is almost impossible to parallel park the car to a narrow spaces.
By the way why everyhing -blobs- around vibrates? are they moving ? is it an earthquake ? :)
Love people like this reviewer who isn't scared to tell the truth about how flawed tesla vision is this is an absolute complete joke this is just beyond even worse than what I thought
My current car has 360° camera view, and depending upon the relative colours and ambient lighting, it's difficult to assess my cars positioning when parking, and my USS system can't detect curbs at all.
Tesla's new system clearly outlines the nearby objects that matter which is all I need to know about, and seems capable of doing so in the dark, whereas my current car's camera system is essentially blind.
More detailed graphics would be nice, but IMO don't really add functionality.
In October of 2014 Elon began this journey to have his car drive itself
It was 10 years ago, and it still looks cartoonish and amateurish.
and I paid $10,000 for FSD
good god...
Tesla removed the ultrasonic sensors to save cost and to keep production up. That is all it was.
Most Tesla fans refuse to acknowledge that Tesla would do something like this.
These decisions were made during the covid 19 supply chain crisis. Tesla did not want to stop manufacturing cars when parts became unavailable, so they simply removed radar and ultrasonic sensors in order to keep production up.
They then tried to place all the functions of radar and ultrasonic sensors on the vision system. It has been catastrophic ever since.