Harry was present during the duel between Snape and McGonagall in the hallway, he and Luna were under the invisibility cloak as Snape tried to reach/search out for them.
I know at the wedding enemies were able to find the borough, it’s only because I think Shacklebolt sent his patronus to warn them that they had a chance to escape.
My favorite movie change is the conversations with Sirius in Order of the Phoenix (the one in Kings Cross and more importantly the one in the family tree room). Sirius in the novel was mostly sullen, and didn't inspire as much hope in Harry. Made his death all the more painful
I would soo love to see snape teaching the slytherin students how to dance 😂. Even tho most probably know how to because of their pureblood families, there had to be some that didn't know how, so he would have to teach them. That would be awesome to see
As a fan and book reader, the Burning of the Burrow, in fact the whole attack on the Burrow, which had been given every Ministry and Order of the Phoenix protection, made it completely clear to me that, whatever story the movie makers wanted to tell, it wasn't the story I had read. Thus for me, and I suspect most of the reading fandom, the Attack on the Burrow made a mockery of the reading Fandom. Further, if the Burrow was so unsafe that it could literally be burned to the ground, why was Harry taken there the next July? Nonsense on nonsense - for a cheap thrill...
The dance practice seen reminds me of pe in high school when both class came together and we had square dancing! Me an my guy friend in the boys class...picked each other to dance. We were following instructions but we were abit to much... We were made to sit down because we were making it fun!!!!😅
Do not consider the film and the book to be the same story. They might be close, but they are not perfectly the same. For example, Stanly Kubrick and Arthur C. Clarke set out to make the perfect Science Fiction movie, with Clarke writing the book. 2001 a Space Odyssey The original plan was for the USS Discovery to travel to Saturn and to have the moon Iapetus turn out to be a stargate. Iapetus is a moon of Saturn is is very strange as one side of the moon was black and the other was white. However Kubrick could not find a way to make the rings of Saturn look good, and so Kubrick decided to change the destination if the mission. But the book, they still go to Saturn. Clarke then points out that the sequel, 2010 Odyssey II point out that this book is a sequel to the movie, not the book.
Films are Incomprehensible, many scenes don't make sense. You need to read the books or some summary of the chapters. 4th movie is probably part of the series by accident, its creation was accident and by accident you have revival of Voldemort in the middle of some strange teenage movie about something, we didn't fully get to see. There isn't Quidditch world Cup, but you hope, it will be seen, then you hope it must have been somewhere else and in the end, you are sure, It's not the single Cup in the series. You expect magical technology, maybe steampunk(ish) world with cyborgs like Aleister Moody. When you read the book, you expect a lot and you are heart broken. It's empty!
Harry was present during the duel between Snape and McGonagall in the hallway, he and Luna were under the invisibility cloak as Snape tried to reach/search out for them.
I know at the wedding enemies were able to find the borough, it’s only because I think Shacklebolt sent his patronus to warn them that they had a chance to escape.
My favorite movie change is the conversations with Sirius in Order of the Phoenix (the one in Kings Cross and more importantly the one in the family tree room). Sirius in the novel was mostly sullen, and didn't inspire as much hope in Harry. Made his death all the more painful
I would soo love to see snape teaching the slytherin students how to dance 😂. Even tho most probably know how to because of their pureblood families, there had to be some that didn't know how, so he would have to teach them. That would be awesome to see
As a fan and book reader, the Burning of the Burrow, in fact the whole attack on the Burrow, which had been given every Ministry and Order of the Phoenix protection, made it completely clear to me that, whatever story the movie makers wanted to tell, it wasn't the story I had read.
Thus for me, and I suspect most of the reading fandom, the Attack on the Burrow made a mockery of the reading Fandom.
Further, if the Burrow was so unsafe that it could literally be burned to the ground, why was Harry taken there the next July?
Nonsense on nonsense - for a cheap thrill...
My favorite movie only scenes is hermuone wiping her parents memories at the start of deathly hallows pt1
The dance practice seen reminds me of pe in high school when both class came together and we had square dancing! Me an my guy friend in the boys class...picked each other to dance. We were following instructions but we were abit to much... We were made to sit down because we were making it fun!!!!😅
Book Snape in the Whomping Willow was insane, he was so driven to try and have his childhood tormenters ended, he was not rational.
I wish we could see each house do it own traditional dance activities
Do not consider the film and the book to be the same story. They might be close, but they are not perfectly the same.
For example, Stanly Kubrick and Arthur C. Clarke set out to make the perfect Science Fiction movie, with Clarke writing the book. 2001 a Space Odyssey
The original plan was for the USS Discovery to travel to Saturn and to have the moon Iapetus turn out to be a stargate. Iapetus is a moon of Saturn is is very strange as one side of the moon was black and the other was white.
However Kubrick could not find a way to make the rings of Saturn look good, and so Kubrick decided to change the destination if the mission. But the book, they still go to Saturn.
Clarke then points out that the sequel, 2010 Odyssey II point out that this book is a sequel to the movie, not the book.
Maybe they wanted to tap into Lord of the rings, burning of the shire
"I Should Not Have Said That"
Rest in peace helen
Nice job Helen
Nice job beltrix lestrange
Because the filmmakers know that humans have an innate desire to watch things burn.🤔
Would Snape still stand against the werewolf if it was Neville who was at risk?
I believe so, yes.
This is stupid because they didn’t destroy the Weasley house because the movies aren’t canon maybe read a book
Films are Incomprehensible, many scenes don't make sense. You need to read the books or some summary of the chapters.
4th movie is probably part of the series by accident, its creation was accident and by accident you have revival of Voldemort in the middle of some strange teenage movie about something, we didn't fully get to see. There isn't Quidditch world Cup, but you hope, it will be seen, then you hope it must have been somewhere else and in the end, you are sure, It's not the single Cup in the series. You expect magical technology, maybe steampunk(ish) world with cyborgs like Aleister Moody. When you read the book, you expect a lot and you are heart broken. It's empty!
This was my most hated scene in the whole half blood prince and up there in my top 10 most hated scenes in the whole movie series
I feel thiswas a statement about the christian nationalists