India's take on BBC's Modi documentary
Вставка
- Опубліковано 24 січ 2023
- This is how the spokesperson of India's foreign ministry handled some pointed questions about the BBC documentary on PM Modi's Gujarat riots past.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Brut India is the fastest-growing digital video publisher in the country. We're a young, independent platform producing compelling journalism in new formats.
You can also find us here:
Facebook: / brutindia
Instagram: / brut.india
Twitter: / brutindia
Snapchat: Brut India
Snapchat: Brut India Stories
![[柴犬ASMR]曼玉Manyu&小白Bai 毛发护理Spa asmr](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/0TsXQ7z2Dh4/mqdefault.jpg)
As India grows, you will see more such documentaries coming out.
Hope bbc does not Release documentory on Palestine...come back then..
@@Vancqa He's Right. Why are you so Angry??
@@sunnymitra6372 where is anger in my question? Lol
@@sunnymitra6372 he replied him with same answer,as one grows better than other , other try to defame
@@sunnymitra6372 He is a J!hadi that’s why that stupid question on Palestine…
This guy is a slightly calmer version of Arnab Goswami but he is.
Coz he a diplomat IFS
He's just a lapdog . Politicians are always more powerful
Nah! More like khadus math teacher
@@darthvaderibioles lapdog? all the frameworks of all policies are made by bureaucrats only lol they are just in the name of politicians. diplomats have to be neutral towards any government ruling. it's their duty.
Correct 👍🏻
the irony is that this documentary was banned from viewership as its considered as a propaganda film" but at the same time movies like kerala story (which as it"s director said is a movie which pursued creative liberty) are being pushed out to the public with the support of the government
So true mate , people are so blind to see the truth
Just look at the indians in the comments dickriding that guy by making excuses for the loopholes in his story
the documentary was blocked not banned, it was screened in universities in Kerala
@@vivekudayakumar5039 can you explain what you mean by blocked” and how is it different from the word i used. The documentary was screened in many universities across the country as a protest against the govt’s decision to take it down from all available platforms. Come up with a better argument next time oki?
@@shebin8240 if it was banned it would be illegal to screen the content & one can be arrested & put in jail for the same. the content was blocked from access in India.
Even General Dwyer was given a clean chit
Dyer and Warren Anderson living free lives are testimony of how West values Justice and Lives of Indians.
India will respond respond to these false propaganda, drama, and false allegations and show the truth to the world. India is the most ethical country with great values, and it's not long before the world realizes it.
Power or material progress can not beat the truth. Satyam evam jeyathe. India has always done what's best for the Greater Good in every situation.
Unlike West India, it doesn't need false propaganda, or unlike China, it neither needs information suppression. We will face it openly and prove it and tear all masks.
@@pxrthj
Rubber stamp rather than a clean chit.
Even mata sita faced criticism
@@pxrthjelected in name of religion🤡
BBC please do a documentary on Jalliawallan bagh massacre, Cellular Jail Horrific and many more such subjects.
What about bengal famine ,Tamil famine........
What happened in Cellular Jail ????
And in India people should have courage to make documentary on Babri mosque demolition and showcase the role RSS,VHP,BJP
They havent banned the viewing documentaries, movies made on the same in their country.
@@garimabisht459 All mosques which have been constructed on by razing temples should be reclaimed back and these should be given land elsewhere. Period. Nobody is against a community, but historical corrections need to be made.
@@hemantbavle920
So you compare events happened within Republic of India with events took place in Subcontinent of past????
Wow
Then also make a documentary on how Brahamical movements devoured Buddhists and how Vaishnava,Shivaite temples were constructed over Buddhist and Jain temples.
And also documentary on innumerable communal,caste riots happened in India since 1950.
So he hasn't watched the documentary... But he knows all the words spoken in it. 🤣🤣 Very smart
He literally said "of what my colleagues have seen"
I guess you are quite smart eh? 🤣
they should not be able to watch the propaganda. but they are asking questions on it. breaking rules and thinking they can get away with it?
So he's working on Chinese whispers..
Ahh.. Welp!
Given the respondents prior to me are at pains to make that case: It's relieving that he got to rip-off 'something' from the ancient China, too. And not just the contemporary mainland-China ruling CPC( "iNtErnAl mAtTeR" & "won't tolerate any tHrEaT to nAtIoNal sEcUrItY & tErRiToRiAl-InTeGrItY" & {yadda-blach-bloop}) is lacking in inspiration of the incumbent-regime of "world master"_ Bhārat - the regime which also managed to effortlessly usher in "true-independence" mere 8½+ years ago.
*Edit Note:* Expanded for clarity.
There are something called "Diplomats" it's not one person but it's a chain of persons/ institutions working for GOI
@@swapnilnayak2449 poor bagchi... had to depend on what his colleagues say. May I remind u he is the spokesperson of the External Ministry of the country. He cannot hold a PC on heresay.
He is so nervous and so guilty
"I have not seen the documentary."
"We have seen it and we feel its a propaganda piece."
By 'We' he means his colleagues
he has said that in the start
He clearly says his colleagues in his department....
He personally has not seen it
bbc should do documentry on churchill and his thoughts on india
💯👍
They did
@@mudassirahmed4492 did they show how he was resposible for 3 million indian people starved to death
@@mando3621 Maybe they will release that after 20 years.
Yes waiting for that
The ultimate quote of this diplomat is 'Do not ask about the documentary'
😂😂
Talk about Godhra Train that caused this should be the question
@@iamnotable1 so if someone looted your house you will fire all the people around u. What nonsense logic is this. Godhra train incident
😆😂🤣😅🤣😆👏👏👏👏👍👍👍
He is just like Gautam Adani who does not want to even hear or look into the issues. Adani is saying similar things like it but look how much his wealth has fallen and those of companies. People are literally questioning both Adani and the present government and this is a democratic right of every Indian.
The hypocrisy is his voice is outstanding
They will promote films which are in their favour like kashmir files, the kerala story.
They will ban which are not in favour like the BBC documentary.
Hypocrisy ki bhi seema hoti hai...
"India is the mother of democracy" 🤡
true
Lol what? BBC is the mouthpiece of Western propaganda known to be very selective and biased which was exposed not only by India but other foreign news channels as well. Even Piers Morgan has had the same views. Get your facts right.
My poor leftist boy you need to learn what is Reality and what is Propaganda
Why you guys follow bbc..to watch poverty porn of india? If you want to criticize the government then do it why held on to foreign media who only portray the whole nation as a poor dangerous illiterate country
Indian govt. Has right to file protest against this documentary but they can't prohibit others from watching it or giving thier viewpoint after reviewing it, because free will is the essence of indian constituion and also of divine nature ... !
Let that be with credible proofs and logic. The same gentleman had been banned from entering UK, US , Europe for more than a decade for the same crime. Truth is more than a cleanchit.
Promoting National integrity is also part of fundamental element of Indian Constitution.
@@manoganesh1567 when someone wants to show their cruel actions its not meant to be breaching integrity
Lol....
Hindu mualim ladhai karenge toh tera baap jaake sambhalega
When ever government ban something, makes me want to watch it.
it's natural instincts of criminals you know, doing illegal things.
I watched it and saw what a monster he is
@@abhinavd_lol chup bey dubey
@@abhinavd_lol There is two things, as you said that right. but that is view of one side rupee. you need to see second side also. my question why is bbc raising this doc for now. shall we have any uncertainty. are we in beggar stage by that situation. if you want truth, you need to research and think logically. then you got truth. the youtuber gets more views and bbc gets high rating for controversy. oh, you got syco satifaction ah.
@@buzztime8199 hey where I can watch this documentary
He is being very specific for the questions and equivocally vague in his answers.
the famous QUOTE by PM modi " Dosti bani rahe"
😂😂😂
Or ED at your home?
Please come I'll welcome ED. Going to donate 10 cr to bjp electoral bonds I'll be free the next day 😂😂😂😂
@@mowlik5640 😂😂😂
20 years is not a huge time.. It's the average time people have to spend to get a verdict for their cases in India..
Do they have any questions about ethnic clensing of Kashmiri Hindus which just happened 30yrs ago?
@@Blurufoodaz jisne kiya kashmir me..usko saza mila..
Gujrat me saza kaha mila.
@@yasminjamal4437 Ghanta saza mila
@@tanishkkhurana9011 jhooth mat bol...
@@tanishkkhurana9011 jinhone kuch nahi bhi Kiya unko bhi abhi tak saza mil rahi hai smh.
Basically his response: don't ask me any questions. 😅
@@Kukhyaati judgment of Supreme Court can also be questioned in a democracy. Don't know from where you get this notion that it cant 😅
@@Oceansta sure file a case. Executive Govt is within its powers to ban things that can disturb peace.
@@kartikpepakayala8389 ofcourse they can . that's why they are able to do it. And the entire world is watching. BBC is not your local GODI media. They carry global credibility. Get well soon.
@@Oceansta lol. It's the last days of bbc my friend. No one cares, no one watches regular TV. I live in the west. All bark no bite. Only works on colonial stooges like yourself.
Propaganda after propaganda on every step just proves of Ill motive. It's not about questioning him anymore, it's about blindly showing everyone that hes evil. Which is a lie, every sane Indian including muslims support and love him.
Finally…a comment section that is full of mature, intelligent, sensible people and isn’t littered with brainwashed BJP fanboys
Have you seen the documentary?... And why would we bother with something created by the likes of 'BBC'
Love how every time someone tries to question or needs a clarification against Mr. Narendra, things are banned, broadcasts are stopped, people are jailed or banished. The panic and agitation in his voice says a lot. Why is not fair to question a govt or a govt leader?
its a question from britishers who looted our nation of its money and culture, what do you expect from them? they're jealous that the country that they drained resources from has a stronger gdp than uk
😢 I also want to see documentry from BBC on 1984 sikh genocide, emergency era, forced sterilization during that time, why India lose to China 2 times and surrendered thousands of sqkm land in North East to China over what?? Expensive war in 1971 for Bangladesh and I still think what we got from that 😢, and ofcourse documentary on 26/11 attacks 😢 please request them to make one...
@@greatminds6843u do the documenary.. nobody is stopping you.
@@noral342 left liberandus : when they don't have any answer 🤡
This is literally pushing our country towards dictatorship. People refuse to accept or see. Also because they are probably not given the chance to see.
“How can you say that it’s a propaganda?”
“Because I can say , I can feel it’s propaganda “
He clearly stated that it's the High Commission of India in UK which has done the assessment. Also, why are these reporters continuosly asking questions about a thing which is supposedly not available in India?
Also, propaganda stuff in the name of a documentary is pretty common.
Logical fallacy at its finest!
If that was propaganda what about Kashmir files wasn't it a propaganda movie??🤔🤔
Funny thing is British people started talking humanity, who kept world under their foot. 😅😂😂😂😂
Once a wise man said, "Yes, one area I have been very, very weak in is how to handle the media."
They have 303 seats, Libs have moral superiority.
They'll have political victory, you can have moral victory.
I can already see the godi media puting title of their episode as "Hypocrisy of the west" 😂😂😂
@@rushabhshah.2768 Ya ya ya. It's better to be so-called "Godi Media" instead of being a Traitorous Sepoy Media.
@@Anime_account1 bro you don't have a time limit to think while commenting. At least use 0.5 % of your brains while writing something 😂.what you have written makes no sense 🤣
@@rushabhshah.2768 if you are still pointing out a befitting title of a article is godi media repersentation, then its like you are in favour of the west.
Every citizen had the right to see and learn about the real facts .
Did anyone else struggle to make out what he is saying?
Yeah ppl like you ..
@@ChaitanyaSampgaonkar Please grow up 😊
No. Listening is a skill most people have.
1:15 "I have heard ; My colleague have seen ". Cut to 4:58 "we have seen it"
means his team has !! WE 🖕🖕
@unique portal Here WE refers indian agency or indian officials which means his colleagues.
That we was a reference to the indian diplomat agency and not himself personally. You are an amateur as you do not understand how a diplomat speaks
This minister was doubling his own answers 😂 . First he says he is giving the views based on which his colleagues have seen and when he was almost unable to answer further more , he said he has seen it and he thinks it's a propaganda ideology
ofcourse it's british who drained india from all resources and bharat is still a stronger GDP than uk, britishers are just jealous of this fact and has a colonial mindset, spreads fake or biased propaganda, he was only spitting facts!
India doesn't give any relevance to the BBC documentary as it's proven they work on an agenda mostly for islamic appeasement, which can be traced to the heavy immigrants in the UK
Yes it is propoganda, modi is now great leader & all western countries want him to be out ... Want a puppet like congres to rule india again... So my brother this will never will gonna happen 🙏
He said we have seen it, as in the ministry or authority he represents.
India will respond respond to these false propaganda, drama, and false allegations and show the truth to the world. India is the most ethical country with great values, and it's not long before the world realizes it.
Power or material progress can not beat the truth. Satyam evam jeyathe. India has always done what's best for the Greater Good in every situation.
Unlike West India, it doesn't need false propaganda, or unlike China, it neither needs information suppression. We will face it openly and prove it and tear all masks.
Its right of people to watch it.
BBC is making documentaries and on the other hand, we didn't shortlist Sardar Uddham because we were thinking about the portrayal of British. Atleast happy RRR is doing well in west and tight slap for British.
RRR was given 0 nominations in BAFTA, I wonder why 🤔
@@okayaresd cuz rrr is shit
@@okayaresd bcz u r pakistani hindu who does not want to see progress of indian people
@@rajashreer01 dont comment if you dont know the context. RRR has no nomination in BAFTA and BAFTA is a british award show
@@okayaresd because British are cowards and they can't make a documentary on millions of Indians massacred intentionally
Basically thanks to BBC, BJP just increased its vote share in upcoming elections. Great.
In the long run it's going to hurt them
The more Modi haters try to bring him down, the stronger he will become.
2019 seats were greater than 2014.
2024 seats will be greater than 2019
Another promotion campaign for Modi😄
Jai Shree Ram.
Exactly bro. BBC has just lost all credibility. What a pity.
Ignoring questions!! That says a lot !!
Let the Congress govt comes in power. BBC please keep your documentary ready to publish.
Hope soon we will have the truth behind gujarat riots, lohiya murder and why the Muslim community killed ????
Be ready
And what about The burning of a train in Godhra on 27 February 2002, which caused the deaths of 58 Hindu pilgrims and karsevaks returning from Ayodhya,
@@soumyajitmodak4900everything will be covered
Stretegy 1: Hide the truth.
Stretegy 2: if the truth is exposed, curb it from being widely exposed.
Stretegy 3: if our efforts to curb the truth are failing and the truth is prevailing, take control of those who have known it and are in your range.
Stretegy 4: keep them under your control.
Stretegy 5: repeat the stretegies 3 and 4.
I wish Modi ji should regain his originality on specific community who are intolerant and kick those asses out of India
Why the f@@k aren’t u speaking about the main cause of this riot ? The burning of the gothra train ?
Ever heard about the SIT report examined and scrutinized by Supreme Court. Teesta Seetalvad, RB srikumar etc who were charged of faking narratives and influencing witnesses and blatantly producing false evidences in court.
Lekin hume kya, hum toh lota leke hugne aae the, aur hug diya.
Tel Lagake Dabar ka, naam mita do Babar ka
Phle pandit phir labarjhandis
@@DrUK93 Don't try to justify violence . Those muslims who killed pilgrims were punished... But those hindus who killed thousands didn't even arrested.
This guy: I don't want to answer any questions but i want to do a press conference 😅
That's the reverse action of his boss... I like to answer questions but i don't want to do press conference.. u know who I'm talking about 😅
@@kalebj7001 I mean what else cud he say if certain idiots have already made an answer in their minds....u know wht I'm talkin abt right?😅
@@mg9854 exactly.. remember the Karan Thapar interview 😅 Modi's worst nightmare
@@siddhinathkharade156 if we can question on british govt than we can do on modi govt too
@AH Against all odds Karan Thapar interview was not based on BBC documentary.. it was way before he even became PM
He is funny while being serious, which makes it hilarious.
if muslims thinks india is not safe please leave our country dont shout here "azadi azadi" 😅
The word KARMA comes to my mind……they will pay for their deeds
They paid for their deeds in 2002
they already paid for their deeds when they burnt the train in 2002
@@Joerogan-cm5ll well someone learnt about the riots, sadly these guys disregarded moplah and kashmir pandit genocide, how hypocrite of them to now use this documentary to show how humane we are
If that was propaganda what about Kashmir files wasn't it a propaganda movie??🤔🤔
The urban naxalites in media still have their fathers in colonial kingdoms. But that won't help them anymore. India is a free country, we have an independent judicial system which has acquited Sh Narendra Modi ji of all charges against him in Gujrat riots post Godhra carnage (where 59 hindus were burnt alive by a fanatic Muslim mob).
If they hadn't blocked. It would have not been a sensation.
yep, tab Godhra k sabarmati express ka kand bhi sabko pata lag jata jo G hadiyo ne kiya tha aur jiske wajah se danga huye aur itne nirdosh log mare gye
@@siddharthbhattacharya8931 bhakt khud promotion Karte hain Har cheez ka. Or han agar modi itna masoom h to film Kyung nahi dikha rahe
@@radheaaa
Tu film dekh, ham tab tak modi ko vote de kar aate hai 👍
@@radheaaa Matlab tujhe SC clean chit de de or koi padosi aake tujhe chor kahega to tu manlega aur jail chalajayega ...Aisa hi hai na😂
@@radheaaa Supreme Court ne Clean chit de diya hai
Tu kon hai? Supreme Court ka justice se upar hai kya tu?
Truth will always prevail finally however hard you try to hide it
Democracy is a joke in today's India.
Cool bro...
Don't panic...
Might this be the reason why Modi never face critics...
He might have heart attack when right questions were asked
Apparently the opposition is having one rn.
Bro the right questions don't exist, bro remember there is no One culprit in Politics, If One lights a fire the opposition turns it into a Hell fire🔥
Well said 🎉
Especially if those questions are asked in English...lol
He already ran like a coward by drinking water when he was interviewed by Karan thappar.
The lady was good. She asked the right question.
He gave right answer as well, how do he have access to some UK report
This minister was doubling his own answers 😂 . First he says he is giving the views based on which his colleagues have seen and when he was almost unable to answer further more , he said he has seen it and he thinks it's a propaganda ideology
Once he says he didn't see it and then said he saw it.
Smita Superb Question
Colonial mindset, best answer to avoid difficult questions.
He is 😱scared to ans
@@gracemelroy502 faxx 💯
Indeed it is. And you saying this is slaves attitude. If the same documentary was made in India come back would have been different. Mind you question is not at all difficult. Because Modi did it. Yes I support it. But was it ethnic cleansing. Nope just communal clashes.
@@anandpatel1896 wow it's a communal clash were particular group of people are targeted killed raped and even there houses and markets set to the fire
And police and force didn't even tried to stop it.
At least accept the truth....
Don't be so ignorant just because u r following certain ideology....
Let me just say this to all my fellow Indians just take a moment and think why BBC have decided to release this documentary now when the issue have been there for a long time the simple ans is the modi government defiance against USA and Europe words Indias strong stand on topics like Russia Ukraine war and reviving its culture which was suppressed by Britishers by lies and manipulating our history books and what not it's clear they don't want modi government which is not gullible to any one rather they will be glad if congress gov who always listen to what they say comes power in India because it means they indirectly have contron on India so please don't be fooled by such manipulative media specially western media thanks for reading jay hind
Truth will prevail.. Atleast someday!!
Yes, definitely, Britishers must be held responsible for everything they've done in India. How did human rights violation occurred during their rule
Yes! Lets hope so 💪
@@omkarupadhyay406 "During their rule" exactly. The leaders are different now. How is them being responsible for their ancestor's crimes justice? Wake up. Go back to elementary school kids
@@UnchainedTerror did you forget about a dozen of invasions that happened recently?
Weapons of mass destruction, Iraq. Afghanistan?
Now this documentary about a topic that belongs to 2002 and that too just before 2024 general elections.
Is it a coincidence? "Russian is meddling in our elections" says the same lot!
Even right now British own falklands and Diego Garcia, Americans own hawai.
British queens and kings are still there.
Who are you trying to fool here with that bullsht of they are not here?
If that's the case then why the fck nobody talks about crimes of Churchill like we do of Nazis and Hitler?
Mfrs
British will fall yes
Why there is no documentary about the riots that was created by the British in India during the partition of 1947 by BBC?
What business does any British foreign agency have in investigating a communal riot in a foreign country that kicked the British government out decades ago?! The colonies have freed themselves of the British, but the British have not yet freed themselves of their colonial mindset.
Whether the Indian Government believes its propaganda or not, that's their problem. But blocking it shows their ulterior motives and fears around it. They should just let the public watch it and let us decide. Democracy is for the people, BY the people. We will decide what we want to see
When you say for the people, it is government's job to maintain peace in the country, our own agencies and organizations have looked into the riots, why can't we trust them? Or only some other TV channels that thrive upon viewership are trustworthy in your opinion? And such contents obviously create stir among people and government doesn't want that and I think that's fair.
If tomorrow the BBC releases a 'documentary' saying that chennai is a slum district entirely, Bangalore is the most technologically deprived state in India and other inaccurate information, isn't it the responsibility of the government to block these lies or half-truths from spreading in the country, or else their own citizens would start believing in these things
@@ankushmishra229 what are your thoughts on kashmir files and its marketing done by modi ji himself? Doesnt that create a stir?
@@SOL1tude420 Is it wrong for Modi to ask people to see what was done to hindu people in kashmir and dig up more content like that, obviously it is wrong, just like it is wrong to show documentaries created by channels like BBC that have always been agenda oriented. From where i come from we have probably equal number of Hindu and Muslim people, I've seen that none of these ever help,
@@ankushmishra229 you restored my faith in people with that response. Even though i do not agree with your opinion about the bbc documentary, i respect your opinion. Jai Hind.
He panicked. He initially said he hasn't seen but in then end he confirmed he saw🤣
No, he didn't. He says WE saw it and it was OUR conclusion that it is a propaganda piece. He clarified that we have a high commission in the UK (and that is a part of the ministry of external affairs). Their job is to keep an eye on issues pertinent to our country in a foreign land and inform the ministry of their assessments, because of which the spokesperson has access to the assessment.
Which part of his speech says he has seen it? Please enlighten us Sir.
@@kishore314 4:01 "We have seen it and I feel it's propaganda piece" . Note that, questions are being asked to representative of the government, not the person it self.
When he said that I have not seen that in the first take, he wasn't supposed to answer that like a personal Q&A. He has to answer on behalf of the government. I haven't seen gravity personally; doesn't mean gravity doesn't exist.
Are you stupid or somethin?
He said we have High commission out side country. You are an Idiot
The reporter asked about the Jack Straws report but he ignored the question all together.
But the great MODI still humiliating the past honorable prime ministers of India such as Nehru and Indira. But most of the people india still have the opinion about the involvement of MODI in the 2002 riots. As the prime minister of India now, for every constructive actions he and his party members are hailing him as the sole contributor. But as this riots had destroyed more than 10000 people lives why his supporters are not discredit him,
Answering back with confused questions is a talent to evade the truth.😄😄
No....
That's the strength of BJP government....
Don't think whole india is like that ....
I'm from tamilnadu...
And we too agree with the documentry.....
Modi is a criminal and destroying India in name of religion
Yeah. He's extremely defensive. 😂🤣😅 They need to stop using " colonial mindset" phrases everytime they're questioned. Need to get over their past history. Plus it's extremely insulting calling this investigation a propaganda. Have they done their research?
True😂
Yes and using cliched responses.
THIS IS WHY HE IS A DIPLOMAT, KNOWS HOW TO ANSWER AND HOW MUCH TO ENGAGE, HE'S NOT A NORMAL LOOSER LKE YOU SAYING ANYTHING AND EVERYTHING, EACH WORD THEY UTTER HAVE CONSEQUENCES
Basically he is saying ' I have made up my mind so don't confuse me with facts'. Biggest achievement of BJP is that it saved us from Mughal invasion 🥳
So Indian Judiciary and Diplomats are waste.. what BBC or any Western news outlets utters will be acceptable
He is clear about bjp winning in 2024. And giving burnol to Modi's hater.
Facts why BBC didn't gave this fact to Congress , congress should have proved Modi guilty naa, why BBC holded back till if they had proofs and Facts 🙄🙄
yeah facts, like earth is flat.
if we talk facts, islam will cease to exist in this world. Without lies islam dies. Why Muslims and Librandus are angry after Nupur Sharma told facts from authentic islamic literature.
Nicely explained/answered
Firstly he said he heard the gist from his colleagues but then later says "on what I have seen"
He said "on what we have seen"
Documentary should be released in all over in india
That's what every jihadi is saying from.pak 😂
It's being shown in JNU
Do u want us to repeat 2002? 😂
pakistan chale jaa waha dekh liyo
@@avinishtiwari2906 you need to go to school 🙄
I saw the part 1 of BBC documentary on Gujarat riots. At the end of the video I feel sheer pain for the officials who spoke out on what happened and are now indefinitely jailed claiming they made false allegation. What can be more evil that this.
Whatever maybe the plot of the violence , people claiming facts should never be punished for speaking the truth. There is no greater evil than this on earth.
Can you explain y this gujarat riot happened cz u do understand everything happens for a reason
@@letmynamebeequaltox2961 what happened in Gujarat is a different and what happened in Kashmir is different. Don't confuse both. Modi was not in Kashmir. The topic of focus is on Modi here. Not hindu, Muslim problem . What should a responsible leader do. Is the question here.
@@jollygood4819yes Kashmir was a Genocide .. Gujarat was reaction to provocation by a certain peaceful community. By the way if the Supreme court of India has given Modi a clean chit why are you still using Soros Funded Media like BBC to target anyone
@@letmynamebeequaltox2961 Well! That's not banned. And btw u understand the difference between a movie and an actual documentary?
@@letmynamebeequaltox2961 dont bother my friend, people love to victimize the muslims even though in Gujrat they were the trigger, but yeah somehow Hindus are at fault be it retaliation or suffering, why do you think Ajmer kand by moulanas is not a big issue even to this day and a sudden bulli bai app got publicity throughout the west ? the leftist media is corrupt and have their own agenda of ganging against Hindus in India and white males in West. They don't care about anyone's life, if they do then they would've shown how Hindus were burned alive in the train by muslims but they chose to make it an allegation instead of a fact. Let the seculars and others cry Modi 2024 is a fact no propaganda documentary is stopping that
My question is why is it not being screened here..pls answer
Because of modiji and his fake personality development
He is so nervous while answering...that means this documentary is true and reveals a lot of uncomfortable truth..
Why did UK supported Pakistan in doing ethnic cleansing in Bangladesh.
BBC should do a documentary on Jaliawalla bagh massacre as well no?
I'm Indian Muslim and this documentary should be release.
oh yea, we will all get to see the atrocities muslims in gujrat did along with the riots and killing of innocent people, let the truth come out!
I support you but before that watch another documentary called the Kashmir files….
@@neonzeke no one cares …. Hahaha
@@anvishrivastava9766 propaganda
Gujjus are frauds, including Gandhi, Modi and Amit Shah are frauds with double faces. India is always falling in trap of Gujjus. Before it was Gandhi/Nehru. Now it is Modi/Shah.
He has so much to say although he has not SEEN the documentary ... genius spokesperson
Buddy he is a SPOKESPERSON he doesn’t make the decisions they are made by an enquiry he says so himself. People failing their 12th judging people who have cleared upsc is peak wokeism
Broda respect the Supreme court judgement and not a documentary because britishers are so jealous when India became 5th largest economy after beating UK they got shaken and people like you are the culprit of This nation being modern is good but stupidity is the worst
Dont be like Rahun Gandi...He is a spokes person , all his opinions are Indian Government's opinion,not personal !
@@kumarshubham2275 Broda ... But he must at least see the documentary to say all this stuff .... I mean how can he say all these things ... without even watching half of the documentary ? .. it doesn't make sense. I respect judgement he should have just said ... It's not allowed in India. but our justice system has blocked it for some reason and I respect that ... Rather than passing judgement in a nonsense manner and be very combative ..makes it feel may be something is in there in a documentary that government is afraid of ... If they did nothing wrong then why ban it.
@@scarshreyasgholap stil he uses the word "I" A LOT SO. I GOT Confused
Thank you
WHY MODI FEARS TO LISTEN/WATCH BBC ?
Looking forward to documentary on Bengal famine and direct action day in 1946 👍👍
And Mopla Massacre too
And don't forget the G€noc!de of the Chitpavan Brahmins done by the Congress party itself
First of all get your dates right. That was 1943
it's like Russia saying war is not wrong because everyone else is also doing the same. thing. but blaming each other will not end war. hence modi topic is more relevant for now and blocking a doc { even if they were in wrong } is not free press
@@ItzIndianKrisp
Not that I am good with the dates but very sure 16 August 1946 this was the day
@@bruhh4331
Kashmir Hindu genocide was very much prevalent last year when tkf released. Did they bother to blame the Islamists for that and release a documentary
Haha it was 20 years back ..he just smiled for that statement and how deep pain would that be for those who lost n still suffer from that??
so you have been moping around for the victims these past 20 years? I was able to stop moping about my father after 5 years. Though still I am sad at times.
Yes, you conveniently forgot about Godhra, Malda, 1984 riots, Kashmir Genocide...much more to unearth. What a chimp.
@@re-alm9731 I'm waiting for that time, porkistan is already receiving theirs I'm waiting for indian leftists to get their shares
@@user-cr6rh7ml3x why not in Gujarat again since you enjoyed 2002.
@@re-alm9731 Gujarat don't feel like doin it again, they're developing in the other hand bengal, kashmir, bihar is drowning
He said he didn't see the documentary as it's not shown in India, then how is he confidently saying it's a propaganda film? What drug does he take?
Wow he way h handled is amazing
I think as a democratic country everybody has the right to watch the documentary. They can't just not let it air here in India.
It stopped being a democratic country since 2014
Oh so Kashmir Files and Ajmer 92 were undemocratic?
@@atulsi2681gov is manipulating the content according to there benefits only. And this is not with our current govt but all previous did the exact same thing, but the thing is people are totally blindfolded and unaware of the ground realities. All politician make fake promises and normal people are just trapping themselves in this trap. Just go on road and ask people about modi, rahul or kejriwal. They will just start talking about what modi did, what rahul did or kejriwal did in past. But at last ground reality is totally different.
@@yashptel go watch Martin Scorsese's Last Temptation Of Christ (1988)
@@dakshdolka800your hypocrisy 😁if govt promote something then it is manipulating something....if banned something then it's hiding something 😁
You guys changed your logic as per your convenience 😁
😂😂it’s not propaganda man it’s really, no use for blocking documentary. We all have downloaded pice. And we shared to lot of people through online 😂😂😂
And increased BJP's vote share by doing so.
Left has been trapped in Modi's bait once again.
So you mean, what some 2₹ diplomat inquired was true but the sc of India is wrong?? You are the type of guys who will gladly lick white mans boots… it’s 2023 wake up from colonial dreams
It's completely a propaganda, bbc's takes on Bharat have always been propaganda. Supreme Court has given the clean chit.
So let the fake news spread and instigate violence?
Sepoys of British
SUPREME COURT already gave judgement. Now why again?
Don't criticise our "Supreme Leader"
The art of uttering a lot of words without saying anything.
The art of not being able to see things that don't suit your agenda
@@aryamansaxena4613 I am sure supreme court(the biggest judge when it comes to judging people in india cuz they are paid literally to do that) said modi is innocent, then who are you to say that he is involved?
@@adityabahl He's blinded with his biasness but he'll still call you andhbhakt 😂
If Modi murdered so many Muslims so what this India is hindu rastra follow the Hindu rules or else Modi will take revenge.
@@adityabahl lmao dude the judgement of the sc is not the word of God, it abides the constitution and gives judgements, he may be wrong we don't know that, he may be proven innocent due to insufficient evidence, or due to some loop holes in law.he is saying modi was involved based on the proofs shown in documentary.Wo ek world wide reputed channel he, documentary banyenge to kuch bhi fake masala Dalke thodi banayange, just to disturb peace. Jo he wahi dhikhayenge na.
Truth will triumph one or the other day😁
Truth is already out my dear modi is acquited by supreme court. Truth would come out from a propaganda documentary based on some "internal report" of country sitting 1000s of km away. 🤣 And they won't show how the riot started. Sabarmati train burning by muslims need to be shown in mainstream.
Man thinks that he can do anything with power,money and even challenge the God.
🤷♂️🤷♂️
Yes kashmiri Hindus who were cleansed from valley will get justice 👍
@@nitlover8319 👍
I heard Babu Bajarangi and had to say I am in not in need of any Supreme Court. Thanks
If they feared people watching it, there is something in it. As a viewer I can confirm 100% that it's highly objective.
The BBC's documentary should be allowed to be viewed in india. The idea is about the people, the citizens of our country itself to determine what is truth and what is propaganda. Both the Supreme court judgement and the documentary should be introduced to the public domain.
If the76कार सेवक were not brutally burnt in which most of them were childerns, nd women then गोध्रा would have not exixted ,so culprits are those who burnt them alive ,and instigated ,outraged the other party to do the same ,,
Think if today they try to burn hindus alive wat will happen???modiji भी नही बचा payenge is देश को, न3only hindus owe to have bhai chara, secularism ,the other side is also responsible for it, even hindus are heart by गोध्रा not only मुस्लिमस,
Dont test our passions
I disagree... Propaganda can be used as a weapon to facilitate someone with rage for wrongful reasons. People tend to think it's their own thoughts but actually their mindset is affected by what they consume.
@@adequatestuff8144 Isn't that the case for everybody? We form our opinion based on the different views we get exposed to and deducing what's right and wrong. There is nothing wrong with the BBC Documentary. What is wrong is wrong and vice versa.
@@adequatestuff8144 You are aware of propoganda brother but this is documentary and that is done by BBC.And they dont have any gains from this as UK current prime minister is Indian.
@@quodcaptiosus9741 it's because of people Ike you BBC, NYT produce such kinda documentary and growing in india whereas their global followers are falling drastically. Why you want to see a documentary by BBC when it's only agenda is bashing india. It's not about modi or any other politician but nation. Views are based on free journalism not by propaganda piece. Show me even a single documentary where they are praising india. Even when we launched Mars mission they were against it
The funny part is....after they have banned the documentary, more people in India have the urge to watch and it is available on various platforms and viewership is high. So what the govt has done has had an opposite effect of what they intended...and the documentary is a masterpiece
Nobody want to seen I am indian because I know action ka reaction
The Streisand effect
@@shubhamjaiswal9495 well we want to watch it and will watch it surely next for myself too
@@shabahfarook7527 Yeah because for you your religion is more than Nation. Like I wonder how you people burn your ass to stop Narendra Modi😂😂
@@shabahfarook7527 if you want to watch you are free to watch but we don't want to watch it ...we don't want take lecture from the country which itself made by looting other country and stealing all wealth and resources of my country...
It is our time now. Let the colonialists rant about what happens here. There the ‘peacefuls’ are holding their nation ransom and they want to preach to the world. This is not the ‘coolie India’ which they ruled by guile. This is Bharat …….Rising …….✌🏼💪🏽
India in the hands of perpetrators. God save India.
Thanks brut, always providing what's needed,unbiased.
The documentary will be reviewed by censor board first, then any harmful things identified will be removed and then it will be published.
@@raman87910 yeah harmful things organized by Modi and his karyakartas
@@nihalmartin4098 Yeah... as if a train full of Hindus wasn't burnt to death by the most peaceful people on earth
@@nihalmartin4098
Peaceful community are never at fault whether it is partition or Moplah or Kashmir Hindu genocide. Obviously Hindus would have started it
Unbiased? Pathetic Bjp 🐑🐑🐑
Nothing to do with bias or colonial mindset, such heinous crimes should not be forgotten.
@@funvids5592 So true man..
Uyghur Muslims be like: 🤐
The question is not that did the riots start or not but whether Modi had a hand in it. If you study, he was newly appointed as a chief minister for a few months before this happened. It must be too much for him to handle as things just tumbled out of hands. Supreme Court gave him a clean chit for a reason and when BJP was not in power so that kinda answers the question
100 million Indians finished of by the British. They have not paid reparations yet or even returned Kohinoor. Question is, why do they have money to fund BBC, but not pay back Indians?
@@funvids5592 definitely not the one's who died or faced injustice in the riots
ACTUALLY A VERY
RELIGIOUS MAN AND SPECIALLY SOME ONE WHO CLAIMS DAIYVA SHAKTI SHOUD HAVE KNOWN
IMMEDIATLY THAT HIS SINNS ARE RUNNING BEFORE HIM .THE COMING IF THIS DOCUMENTARY, WAS THE BEGGINNING OF MODI'S FALLING IN THE EYES OF THE WORLD .AND IF ONE TAKES THE RIGHT OF KILLING BY WILL AND CHOICE ,WILL NO WAY BE SPARED BY THE ALMIGHTY ,WHAT
EVER HIS NAME OR DESIGNATION .
Accurately said by Arindam Bagchi..
His tone of voice, phrasing, micro expressions and mostly the vibe says everything xD
Remember not dare to harm any one.
Pak jaoge ? atta nahi hain
Yeah It says that he doesn't care much about that boobc documentory as it is a propaganda cartoon made by British 🤡
@@mysterious_____ Yea cos Indian media fails to criticise Modi ofc the west has to. Tum sab behte raho while Modi destroys India under your noses. Everything from the west ko colonial mindset bana dete ho to continue living in a fake reality.
@@aritrabhattacharya1530 China jaao agar democracy aur questions se problem hai
I don’t understand why people are mad. They made a documentary from their findings and perspectives if you don’t like it or think it’s just plain propaganda why give it so much importance in first place? Just let the people watch decide for themselves.
exactly .......this documentary is getting unnecessary hype now....we are having more topics to discuss......Indian media is the worst media ....they always discuss unnecessary topics...thats why international media gets A chance to interrupt into the internal affairs !
We clearly know it's propaganda shit . We should snap out of our colonial mindset and inferiority complex. Without any evidence, you can't prove anything. There are anti Indian elements to that , which can spark anti indian element, people's mindset will be changed. That's the agenda of such films. The west always try to destroy our nation.
Right Wing Cancel Culture is topic
It is easy to sway people through carefully crafted propaganda. Commom people have no means nor time to verify facts. This issue has been debated in Supreme court for years and facts were presented by competent lawyers from both sides following the proper processes. If BBC was in posession of any additional information, they had ample time and resources to surface that in front of the Supreme court of India.
People aren't mad, the left needs some masala for 2024
whatever such questions come up they just answer with Britain's colonial past or colonial mindset.
The question is not whether it is propaganda or not but why is the public not allowed to see this piece and judge for themselves?
Once this is released there is possibility to launch several investigations to verify the authenticity, the media themselves will take this up.
The act of censoring feels for us the act of covering up.
Asking the journalists to be SPECIFIC while he beats around the bush and didnt actually answer anything 😂
He is not a politician..Why he should answer everything !?? He answer ,what he wish ..live with it
@@sureshpoduval6951 haha when you don't have an answer
@@sureshpoduval6951 - because he is a representative of India and gets paid to do so 🤷🏽♀️
@@sureshpoduval6951 then why he was sitting there?,if he dont have the authority or the answers to give then wtf he was doing there..
Why this documentary is not shown in India? We all know the answer to this question.
Yes because Supreme court has already given its verdict. That's why.
All those who wants to see this documentary are no less than traitor to this country.
Yup.. we know.. but we have to aslo understand that India is the fastest growing economy in the world and our rivals are just making up some documentaries to disturb the peace of our country
This is Anti-India propaganda
The govt is censoring criticism, just shows their authoritarian mindset. India is better than this
Govt is within its powers to ban things that create enmity between groups. If you have a problem file a petition against the judgement. Don't spread baseless accusations.
We have entered the decade of " Report Warfare " !
People of india against this massacre man
Who doesn't learn from history become history you south people doesn't know how north survived from Jihadi I pity for you open your eyes they divide our country into 3 still creat problems wake up
Master in Business this guy gave perfect answers 😂😂😂
He didn’t it seem.he just buff it out and ignoring there questions
It will be Modi/BJP vs Rest of World 2024.
Fabricated
@@KusanagiSounds777 there is a difference between ignoring and saying what you actually know as truth
@@singhdeepak10 in your imaginations 😂😂 but he's grown different now I think he is one of the perfect leaders but bjp needs to be on hold, cause it's power is increasing 😳
So train burning is fine, but newtons law in response is the problem? Welcome 2 India 🙏
muslims started it, fact
and they forget the day babri was demolished in india, 1000 plus temples were vandalized in pakistan but not even one news outlet covered it
There is literally no denying on what happened to the karsevks it was inhuman and epitome of religious intolerance, but the people who died in the riots had no role at all in the burning of the sabarmati express they were innocents juts living thier some fucker decided to kill them just because they were born muslims and you talk about Newton's 3rd law so listen ( i don't want to compare the number of dead people all of them were innocents) but the people died in the sabarmati express were 59 and the people died in the riots were about 2000 do you really consider it equal
You became the same as those who killed the people in train
Lol kill innocent people who did nothing agar itna hai ja na kashmir ke border pe jihadiyo ko marne ?, Dam hai ? Nai hai
i have not seen it , we have seen it -- says it all
Where can I watch this documentary?
Truth is like a seed no matter how deep you bury it, it will eventually grow and come out
But that also applies to Godhra
Yeah,definitely ppl should know how it was started by burning train by some muslims
Sounds like kashmiri hindu genocide
@@hiiiiir The world has seen it , it's time for Godhra files now
@@valhalla1792 yeah it should be on hindus who died in train burning. Godhra roits was the most based thing done by modi . But he has become molana modi nowadays
No one had the guts to cross-question him when he was speaking rubbish and had already claimed that he had not seen the documentary and made judgments about it. God save Indian Media . By the way , "Jai Shree Ram "
Point is they themselves were not supposed to be able to see it. He is humouring them. And it ain't a "documentary". It's propaganda. Jai Shree Ram, indeed. May Ram guide their lost souls to Moksha.
Modi terrorist is sole responsible for Muslims genocide in gujrat riots.
@@abdulsamadshaikh1374 who is responsible for genocide of kashmiri pandits
So he barks that “I'm gonna come back hard at you” like a rabid-dog, and that too - at the face of a ciswoman-journalist..
...Asks insane rhetorical-questions like *why would a sovereign State would need to exercise diplomatic means to ensure repatriation of citizens ‘killed’, and not "dead by natural causes" - followed by justice by sentencing the perpetrators?*
And above all..
The way he defines “colonial mindset” is straight outta the playbook of "IT Cell" for world-master _Bhārat._
Nevermind his ‘post-colonial’ terminology for ‘killings’ and that too: A pogrom which magically occurred elsewhere across state of Gujarāt than its supposed epicentre.
“India's take”: Indeed it is. Just not in the ideal-sense. In the rigorously-honest Freudian sense.(
*Fun fact:* By mid-2020, BBC®'s subsidiary in World News/Service subsidiaries agreed to surreptitiously change their editorial-style for referring to the _de facto_ Indian-ruled territories( aka Kashmīr) as indoctrinated by the Indian Establishment/State - in all of official-languages their vernacular services operate in, save for Urdū & their own variant of International English, both of which reach primarily other audiences, as well - in order to keep their South Asia HQs remain open in any Indian-controlled territory, and not just HT Media's building owned by 'the other Birlās'.)
It's good that you're already doped off, Ms "@@richasaikia7694".
This question was an Achilles hell for that bureaucrats.. How he handled the question show his insecure feeling.. You cannot hide the truth... 😁😁
Request to BBC Please make a documentary on Manipur.
I hope the people who asked questions dont get arrested under UAPA.
It’s Modi government not sadam Husain
@@suhascs8248 I think you are unaware of what has happened in the past. Why ti compare Our PM with Saddam Hussein.. I am worried about our country but people like you will always steep low. Kamse kam Modi ka comparison Saddam se mat karo saddam tyrant tha.. World knows whatever he deserved he got it.
@@tanveeryeahyeah5259 don't worry he ain't leftist who got several bots to mass report, hope you got the reference
@@suhascs8248 yep worse
@Tanveer yeah yeah go to pak and worry u belong there