STARS 2:50 KEYS TO MY LIFE 11:26 PAID 20:20 TALKING 27:43 BACK TO ME 38:34 HOODRAT 51:20 DO IT 1:01:47 PAPERWORK 1:08:37 BURN 1:13:47 F*K SUMN 1:19:00 VULTURES 1:24:28 CARNIVAL 1:33:30 BEG FORGIVENESS 1:43:30 GOOD (DONT DIE) 1:53:59 PROBLEMATIC 1:59:20 KING 2:03:40 2:08:30 end concussion - fivio foreign (featuring kanye) 49:10 (1:00:10 ty dolla sign donates)
Guy went into this expecting a 0 and never even tried to fairly review it lol DO IT just isn't a 2, heard Kanye on BURN and instantly frowned and stopped bopping his head. Yes some songs are dogshit yes the fans are obnoxious but come on lol
@@nut311aman the reaction was genuinely unfair. Not every song is incomplete and unlistenable, like brad would not be reacting that way if it was JUST a ty album or literally anybody else. It's low for kanye standards but brad was projecting by calling it insufferable. More than half of the songs are just as listenable as anything off of cruel summer and less cringe inducing than some dated songs off watch the throne
yeah, my problem with this whole discourse - i don't care if people actually liked the album or disliked it, as long as they were honest with themselves and others. Just say you find the album horrible because of the lyrics, and Kanye verses, what's the point of acting as if all songs sound unlistenable
not sure i want to, was at the height of all the drama and he paused very often talking about stuff related to it and it isnt a very enjoyable reaction imo
@@spaceashes i saw the stream and i did find it enjoyable although i agree that yes the drama stuff in it isn't the best however i think it would be good to have it reuploaded here but edited as not to hind or ignore the drama but take away some of the long parts.
Might be the most biased review I’ve ever seen. Is YE not supposed to say Jews? Like is he supposed to not talk about his biggest controversy? Also the album is mid but ain’t that bad. Comparing this to V2 is like night and day.
he was being incredibly negative because of the controversial lines (you can see his whole demeanor change as soon as he sees the jews line in stars). It's alright if he doesn't enjoy it because of the lines but it doesn't make for a good reaction
Man. People are still pushing the "he's secretly enjoying it" agenda. INSANE coping
Goated pfp, Project Pat's a legend
STARS 2:50
KEYS TO MY LIFE 11:26
PAID 20:20
TALKING 27:43
BACK TO ME 38:34
HOODRAT 51:20
DO IT 1:01:47
PAPERWORK 1:08:37
BURN 1:13:47
F*K SUMN 1:19:00
VULTURES 1:24:28
CARNIVAL 1:33:30
BEG FORGIVENESS 1:43:30
GOOD (DONT DIE) 1:53:59
PROBLEMATIC 1:59:20
KING 2:03:40
2:08:30 end
concussion - fivio foreign (featuring kanye) 49:10
(1:00:10 ty dolla sign donates)
NO NO NO NO
THIS AIN’T GOOD IT’S UNLISTENABLE
SHE HATE THIS SHIT CALLED “CARNIVAL”
THEY DONE MADE THIS TERRIBLE
I can’t believe said talking was one of the high points of the album I was ready to shut it off at that point
Ty Dolla and Kanye ruin Stars so bad. The beat makes me feel like I’m touching hands with God, it’s unbelievable
I get not liking Ye on it but Ty has an amazing performance on that song to me.
@@xamp_exclammark Ty ruins it for me. I should have made it less objective because music isn’t objective.
Guy went into this expecting a 0 and never even tried to fairly review it lol DO IT just isn't a 2, heard Kanye on BURN and instantly frowned and stopped bopping his head. Yes some songs are dogshit yes the fans are obnoxious but come on lol
Ye stans will do anything to mitigate how boring the album is
@@nut311aman the reaction was genuinely unfair. Not every song is incomplete and unlistenable, like brad would not be reacting that way if it was JUST a ty album or literally anybody else. It's low for kanye standards but brad was projecting by calling it insufferable. More than half of the songs are just as listenable as anything off of cruel summer and less cringe inducing than some dated songs off watch the throne
@@nut311aman You said it yourself lol it might be boring at points not unlistenable or the way Brad's acting like it's the worst album ever
yeah, my problem with this whole discourse - i don't care if people actually liked the album or disliked it, as long as they were honest with themselves and others. Just say you find the album horrible because of the lyrics, and Kanye verses, what's the point of acting as if all songs sound unlistenable
@@roboctual bro its boring ass music with antisemitic comments what do you expect? I bet the casual listener doesnt even finishes the album
1:48:20 sepihroth feature?
Didn't Brad say you shouldn't upload this or am I being dumb?
wouldnt know when or where he said that if that's the case
i'm pretty sure it was from a comment way before brad's "meltdown". I forgot
@@Tacoz3AM i think brad wanted to keep the vod of this up but it got heavily copyrighted so he couldnt
@@ggunkp1 most likely the case
How can you hate on stars
easily, because it’s a bad song. hope this helps 💜
A lot of vultures 1 reviews were bad faith. But tbh Kanye isn't really deserving of it after 2022
I can’t believe people said talking was one of the high points of the album I was ready to shut it off at that point
Can you drop his reaction to eminem the death of slim shedy
not sure i want to, was at the height of all the drama and he paused very often talking about stuff related to it and it isnt a very enjoyable reaction imo
@@spaceashes i saw the stream and i did find it enjoyable although i agree that yes the drama stuff in it isn't the best however i think it would be good to have it reuploaded here but edited as not to hind or ignore the drama but take away some of the long parts.
@@gew43 well either way i just checked brads channel and that vod seems to be deleted anyways
@@spaceashes yea unfortunate
Might be the most biased review I’ve ever seen. Is YE not supposed to say Jews? Like is he supposed to not talk about his biggest controversy? Also the album is mid but ain’t that bad. Comparing this to V2 is like night and day.
Yeah Vultures 2 makes this one look like a 10/10 in comparison
Not like that he isn't
This album sucked ass yall coping
Crazy to think that Vultures 2 was even worse💀💀
Que pesado es el notas
im a fan of brad but the burn reaction was insufferable ngl
i will defend talking with my life
this hurts to watch, bro is forcing the hate so hard, you can tell he's secretly enjoying it
Weirdo. Its an opinion. If you like it thats great. Not every one has your taste
cope
Oh and you know him better than he knows himself, do you?
this is the worst album ever made
This reaction was awful
explain
he was being incredibly negative because of the controversial lines (you can see his whole demeanor change as soon as he sees the jews line in stars). It's alright if he doesn't enjoy it because of the lines but it doesn't make for a good reaction
Bad reaction for a bad album, who would've guessed
@@nut311aman mid album, not bad enough for everything to be red headphones
@@Comatose_Rat he is jewish himself. u cant blame him