How I Designed a Free Music Font for 5 Million Musicians (MuseScore 3.6)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 14 січ 2021
  • This video covers how I designed a music notation font for MuseScore 3.6, in collaboration with my friend Simon Smith, a professional engraving expert. Apart from MuseScore's 5 million users, this font is available for free for anyone to download and use. Along the way, I also discuss the inspiration for our font: an application called SCORE, created by Leland Smith.
    Please consider supporting me on Patreon
    / tantacrul
    Twitter
    / tantacrul
    Discord
    t.co/a3oYi1Rbnc?amp=1
    ---
    Learn More about Simon
    oktophonie.net
    / ingemisco
    ---
    GET MUSESCORE 3.6 (FREE)
    www.musescore.org
    ---
    GET OUR MUSIC FONT: LELAND
    github.com/MuseScoreFonts/Leland
    ---
    www.scoringnotes.com/
    ---
    SCORE & LELAND SMITH
    Leland interview:
    www.namm.org/library/oral-his...
    Scoring Notes Obituary
    www.scoringnotes.com/news/lel...
    Stanford Obituary
    news.stanford.edu/news/2014/j...
    Bill Holab on Leland Smith
    www.scoringnotes.com/news/bil...
    Thomas Brodhead on Leland Smith
    www.scoringnotes.com/news/tho...
    ScoreBox
    www.scorbox.com/
    Machines of Loving Grace (Composition by Leland Smith)
    • CCRMA Fall Concert 2013
    Original History of SCORE (Wayback machine)
    web.archive.org/web/201906020...

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,3 тис.

  • @justinma
    @justinma 3 роки тому +3259

    tantacrul: you can see some obvious differences
    me: hmm yes

    • @zenobardot
      @zenobardot 3 роки тому +183

      Once I had my eyes surgically replaced with bionic super-eyes, it all became quite obvious.

    • @powerlucario
      @powerlucario 3 роки тому +48

      This was me pretty much the whole video but I still enjoyed it

    • @PrinceWesterburg
      @PrinceWesterburg 3 роки тому +67

      My dad was a printer, I was in DTP from the 80's and animation from the 90's. To me they all looked hugely different. Wow, NOW I discover my super power!

    • @rohiogerv22
      @rohiogerv22 3 роки тому +67

      @@PrinceWesterburg I know what you mean, but if I were being deliberately obtuse, "my dad was a printer" might give me a good giggle.

    • @seumemel
      @seumemel 3 роки тому

      Kkkkk

  • @hamman91
    @hamman91 3 роки тому +3066

    MuseScore is turning into the Blender of music notation. Not taken seriously at first, yet slowly becoming the dominating application, despite being free.

    • @billylauwda9178
      @billylauwda9178 3 роки тому +33

      Yes

    • @ur.kr.2814
      @ur.kr.2814 3 роки тому +104

      I think DaVinci Resolve is similar for video-editing.

    • @p4u1
      @p4u1 3 роки тому +225

      @@ur.kr.2814 But MuseScore and Blender are Open Source

    • @tams805
      @tams805 3 роки тому +99

      @@ur.kr.2814 DaVinci Resolve is great and all, but it's not open source. They're a great and generous company, but there's no guarantee that the software won't one day get locked away unlike* Score.
      Blender can do some video editing for what it's worth.
      *edited to 'unlike' as 'like' was wrong.

    • @MCLooyverse
      @MCLooyverse 3 роки тому +24

      Yeah, but still my dad tries Sibelius and Dorico. Stop it. Get some help.

  • @DBruce
    @DBruce 3 роки тому +4511

    Musescore and UA-cam and the Internet and the World are lucky to have you.😄

    • @JBergmansson
      @JBergmansson 3 роки тому +49

      It couldn't have been said better!!!

    • @Dominik-K
      @Dominik-K 3 роки тому +5

      Can only agree!

    • @twingnagna
      @twingnagna 3 роки тому +7

      David You are the best 😘

    • @UniversalDirp
      @UniversalDirp 3 роки тому +2

      yes

    • @CosmicTeapot
      @CosmicTeapot 3 роки тому +40

      Seeing David compliment Tantacrul in the comments is as pleasantly surprising as a Picardy Third

  • @DavidLovrien
    @DavidLovrien 3 роки тому +2141

    15:06 Putting a tremolo on a 32nd or 64th note should carry legal penalties

  • @AdamNeely
    @AdamNeely 3 роки тому +1613

    As somebody who has regularly half-assed engraving in Sibelius for big band charts to give to players to sight-read, this whole video gave me lots of anxiety.
    Great job!

  • @kirjian
    @kirjian 3 роки тому +569

    Tantacrul: this looks okay...
    Simon: it's not good
    Tantacrul: it's not good
    Me: it's not good

    • @OrangeC7
      @OrangeC7 3 роки тому +63

      Me: wow that looks cool
      Simon: it's not cool
      Me: wow that treble clef SUCKS who would design something like that

    • @Brunosky_Inc
      @Brunosky_Inc Рік тому +24

      So-called "free thinkers" when Simon says it's not good

    • @BirdThatEatsPrometheussLiver
      @BirdThatEatsPrometheussLiver Рік тому +22

      @@Brunosky_Inc I mean, but, Simon Said

  • @DBruce
    @DBruce 3 роки тому +2332

    I think we need a t-shirt with Simon on it.

  • @cartoonpower0
    @cartoonpower0 3 роки тому +1261

    Tanta: Shows symbol
    Me: oh, yea that looks pretty good
    Tanta: and this is a horrible atrocity
    Me: oh yea youre right that sucks
    Tanta: heres the 2nd version i made
    Me: ok now thats perfect
    Tanta: and that was also a horrible mistake
    Me: 😐

    • @beepbeepimasheep237beepbee3
      @beepbeepimasheep237beepbee3 2 роки тому +5

      386 likes lesgo

    • @suomeaboo
      @suomeaboo Рік тому +11

      @@beepbeepimasheep237beepbee3 The number of cents in a 5/4 interval (rounded off to the nearest whole number).

    • @baksoBoy
      @baksoBoy Рік тому +4

      @@suomeaboo my brain is melting trying to process that

  • @BrianKrock
    @BrianKrock 3 роки тому +393

    “You might think this looks ok, but, no. It’s actually a malformed atrocity.” Typography Dysmorphia Disorder is real- seek help, Tantacrul. We love you!

  • @FrostKiwi
    @FrostKiwi 3 роки тому +1773

    As a programmer, who is mostly divorced from the Design aspect, this is Gold.
    I cannot thank you enough for this one-of-a-kind insight into artistic minutia, as this helps me think about my interface design a lot more. Stuff like this is really hard to come by.
    Also it is endlessly funny to me, how you went from shitposting software critique with comical amounts of blood and gore, to being involved with design, to straight up being a project lead. I love the 21st century.
    I was a musician and composer in my past life and now work in software. Seeing how you manage both is a true inspiration.

    • @quatricise
      @quatricise 3 роки тому +60

      Tantacrul used to work for Microsoft and probably some other companies too. He isn't just some random guy who started complaining about software on youtube.

    • @FrostKiwi
      @FrostKiwi 3 роки тому +112

      @@quatricise Fully aware. I meant the progression from critiquing MuseScore from the outside, to leading it from the inside.

    • @quatricise
      @quatricise 3 роки тому +38

      @@FrostKiwi It caught me off guard too, when I first learned that. Wasn't expecting at all.

    • @Beakerbite
      @Beakerbite 3 роки тому +37

      @@FrostKiwi "I challenge you to do better", and he did.

    • @simpumoon
      @simpumoon 6 місяців тому

      What was your name in your past life?

  • @mikeoas
    @mikeoas 2 роки тому +281

    Just spotted what the music in Simon's SCORE demonstration actually is: the top line is from Shostakovich's 9th symphony, while the the bottom line includes Tantatheme, a couple of DSCHs and an enharmonically-spelled licc. :)

  • @wug876
    @wug876 3 роки тому +908

    Designing your own font really is taking 'New All' to a whole new level!

    • @abdaf8706
      @abdaf8706 3 роки тому +69

      Yet it become easier when you Quit Sibelius

    • @miatra4954
      @miatra4954 3 роки тому +7

      i like ur wug pfp

    • @nickpatella1525
      @nickpatella1525 3 роки тому +6

      An all new level

    • @RedHair651
      @RedHair651 3 роки тому +7

      Now there are two of them

    • @arrabax
      @arrabax 3 роки тому +2

      WUG

  • @EpicTyphlosionTV
    @EpicTyphlosionTV 3 роки тому +912

    Musescore Vol. 2: Muse Harder

  • @icebearisicebear
    @icebearisicebear 3 роки тому +2306

    Tanta: I think this looks cool
    Simon: No it doesnt
    Tanta: What should I change then?
    Simon: NEW ALL
    Edit: thanks for 1.8k+ likes means a lot!

    • @padraicfanning7055
      @padraicfanning7055 3 роки тому +156

      Dear Werner,
      I considered our recent design issues with the Parts dialog, and I feel I have a solution… it's a button titled… 𝔑𝔢𝔴 𝔄𝔩𝔩. I feel this is far superior to any visible options that might populate our right panel.
      Its value is in its simplicity - combining, as it does, the essence of user desire… both the New and the All!!!

    • @trollbreeder2534
      @trollbreeder2534 3 роки тому +72

      Dear Nicolas,
      I'm *_delighted_* by this suggestion and I propose we make it into our company mantra
      *ℕ𝕖𝕨 𝔸𝕝𝕝*
      I feel it speaks to our newness, to say nothing of our all-ness!
      ...and I'd like to celebrate by getting some *New All* stationary and let's get some *New All* T-shirts printed too...
      ...so i can shove a *New All* SPIKE STRAIGHT THROUGH MY FACE!

    • @YoutubePizzer
      @YoutubePizzer 3 роки тому +5

      yeah when are the new all icons gonna be designed tanta wtf

    • @nodezsh
      @nodezsh 3 роки тому +25

      If I had it my way I'd fancy a New All button be hidden somewhere in MuseScore.
      It would do nothing. Perhaps it would allow you to press it only for it to dissappear or worse, stay pressed! Forever mocking you for your curiosity and making you hope you didn't break anything since whatever you did, it can't be undone.
      …Is this too much? Am I being too evil? Perhaps it's a good thing I'm not in charge of anything important.

    • @padraicfanning7055
      @padraicfanning7055 3 роки тому +13

      @@nodezsh W- What do you mean ‘New All?’ What sort of copywriting is that? It feels like the person responsible was in the middle of trying to get the phrasing right, and then just had a stroke!

  • @BenLevin
    @BenLevin 3 роки тому +491

    Simon seems like a character!

    • @yetanothermetaname1118
      @yetanothermetaname1118 3 роки тому +9

      Do you mean a fictional character? We have no proof he is real.

    • @simondavidsmith
      @simondavidsmith 3 роки тому +55

      @@yetanothermetaname1118 I met him once. He was awful.

    • @mxchael_the_edamame
      @mxchael_the_edamame 3 роки тому +11

      @@simondavidsmith are you him?

    • @simondavidsmith
      @simondavidsmith 3 роки тому +25

      @@mxchael_the_edamame Yea, verily

    • @GRBtutorials
      @GRBtutorials 3 роки тому +3

      @@simondavidsmith IDK why, but I get the feeling you met him more than once...

  • @SGresponse
    @SGresponse 3 роки тому +219

    "An Unfortunate Mixture of Procrastination and Oversight" - there's an indie rock band name in this.

    • @musescore
      @musescore 3 роки тому +18

      AUMPO

    • @SGresponse
      @SGresponse 3 роки тому +11

      @@musescore
      Nope. It'd be either "UMPO" or "UMoPaO".

    • @blendomatik1368
      @blendomatik1368 3 роки тому +5

      @@SGresponse or : AnUMi OPAnO

    • @santoriomaker69
      @santoriomaker69 3 роки тому +3

      Sounds like a good album name for my life

    • @sierravanriel6906
      @sierravanriel6906 3 роки тому +1

      @blendomatic Sounds like pseudo-Latin. Would make a perfect metal band

  • @Lamadesbois
    @Lamadesbois 3 роки тому +223

    Man, as a typomaniac, musician and computer geek ; this…
    This struck every sweet spot in my nerdganism.

    • @Testgeraeusch
      @Testgeraeusch 3 роки тому +8

      May i have a chat with you about our great Lord and Saviour, Donald Knuth?

    • @Lamadesbois
      @Lamadesbois 3 роки тому +2

      @@Testgeraeusch indeed! What content do you recommend?

    • @Testgeraeusch
      @Testgeraeusch 3 роки тому +5

      @@Lamadesbois In chemistry lab; did all the equations and structures with chemfig; even for biochemistry. Put intermediate pages with quotes in yfont gothic in between chapters of my thesis. Set up a talk on differential interaction cross sections with coloured trajectory bundles because it made the steel ball target look like it was wearing a rainbow wig. Made a 32 by 18cm fanart gif in tikZ because i was too lazy to get into photoshop. That's roughly my level of TeX.
      Prior to that i had spend two years writing music in ascii fo a selfmade chiptune emulator, so i was already used to the wysiwym. I'm still a bit mad that i couldn't get lilypond syntax running with XeTeX.

  • @quinnouyang6050
    @quinnouyang6050 3 роки тому +254

    Let's Play "Simon Says"!
    Simon: "It's not nice."

    • @Tantacrul
      @Tantacrul  3 роки тому +153

      Yes. We've made that joke once or twice ;)
      That is to say I have. Incessantly.

    • @JairajSinghPatil
      @JairajSinghPatil 3 роки тому +4

      @@Tantacrul was this rhyme intentional?

    • @UberIsland
      @UberIsland 3 роки тому +2

      @@JairajSinghPatil Wait, did he edit out the ryhme? I am so confused.

    • @JairajSinghPatil
      @JairajSinghPatil 3 роки тому +6

      @@UberIsland Simon : "it's not nice"
      "Yes. We've made that joke once or twice"
      Was the rhyme 😂

    • @UberIsland
      @UberIsland 3 роки тому +10

      @@JairajSinghPatil Haha, I was trying so hard to get twice to rhyme with incessantly but it just would quite work

  • @ThatOneIrishFurry
    @ThatOneIrishFurry 3 роки тому +78

    Its like i accidentally walked into an font production class with no prior knowledge and stayed beacause it entertaining

  • @ListeningIn
    @ListeningIn 3 роки тому +125

    I’m going to call all treble clefs ‘Damien’ from now on. David’s right - the musical world is very lucky to have your astonishing attention to detail! Also, I finally understand why Boosey scores looks so good.

  • @brookerose1312
    @brookerose1312 3 роки тому +317

    babe wake up new tantacrul

    • @twingnagna
      @twingnagna 3 роки тому +4

      The best comment ever 😍

    • @wallabra
      @wallabra 3 роки тому +9

      new all

  • @BrianSantero
    @BrianSantero 3 роки тому +63

    Gotta love the transcribing of Shostakovich 9 in Score at 4:00 in a line of code. What a crazy world.

    • @Tantacrul
      @Tantacrul  3 роки тому +12

      There's more there than just that :)

  • @zednotdead
    @zednotdead 3 роки тому +79

    Tantacrul: notices tiny errors in typography that make the entire font look out of whack
    Me: hmm yes, the note is made out of note

  • @Jrez
    @Jrez 2 роки тому +12

    I love the way Leland named his software, "Score" and "Draw" its just so brave.

  • @rainerzufall8928
    @rainerzufall8928 3 роки тому +295

    so score is basically vim for musicians

    • @cshairydude
      @cshairydude 3 роки тому +43

      With its line-based approach it seems more like ed for musicians, honestly.

    • @WhoWatchesVideos
      @WhoWatchesVideos 3 роки тому +89

      Not just vim, writing TeX in vim with no autocomplete.

    • @yonatanbeer3475
      @yonatanbeer3475 3 роки тому +14

      @@WhoWatchesVideos I thought it reminded me of TeX too!

    • @leleogere
      @leleogere 3 роки тому +15

      You should have a look at Lilipond if you're interested in writing music in a tex-like way!

    • @iluan_
      @iluan_ 3 роки тому +1

      @@leleogere I will just because I love TeX

  • @mapsynth1596
    @mapsynth1596 3 роки тому +130

    it's incredible how many things we common mortals take for granted whenever we use a piece of software or anything really.

  • @LinusBoman
    @LinusBoman 3 роки тому +152

    Unflattering charicatures, tales of abandonware, font design? This video has something for everyone 😂 Brilliant work as usual mate. Since your aspirations are so humble, I'd still love to see variable font technology used in a future release to enable a master slider to control the thickness of thin and thick strokes throughout in real time! 😉 But I guess the "Helvetica of notation" is a modest goal to start. Well done!

    • @qwertyTRiG
      @qwertyTRiG Рік тому

      Rewatching this video after becoming acquainted with your work, I was thinking of you. Glad you've already seen it.

  • @bennyk384
    @bennyk384 3 роки тому +77

    Now that’s a flex. He didn’t like the current fonts so he just hit us with the classic “fine, I’ll do it myself”

    • @denelson83
      @denelson83 Рік тому +1

      With help from Simon, of course.

  • @projectno5
    @projectno5 3 роки тому +70

    i would watch a cartoon that features your animated dad, jankman, your animated photo of shostakovich and simon.

    • @Tantacrul
      @Tantacrul  3 роки тому +30

      That's a great idea!

    • @OrangeC7
      @OrangeC7 3 роки тому +13

      We can call it, "Tantacrul and Friends"

    • @LILProductions
      @LILProductions 3 роки тому +3

      You can’t forget Humpty.

    • @projectno5
      @projectno5 3 роки тому +4

      @@LILProductions i think humpty should be a character who they just randomly pan to once an episode like "i wonder what humpty is doing?"

    • @arigadatred5395
      @arigadatred5395 3 роки тому +1

      @@projectno5 Still sitting on that wall.

  • @aarongrooves
    @aarongrooves 3 роки тому +160

    Your mastery of typography is only rivaled by your video editing skills!

    • @jackyjess7273
      @jackyjess7273 2 роки тому +5

      YO AARON! I see you are a tantacrul fanboy aswell

  • @semibreve
    @semibreve 3 роки тому +87

    Absolute legend for the "too poor for Sibelius" community

    • @Testgeraeusch
      @Testgeraeusch 3 роки тому +7

      My friend and i were so fed up with sibelius we started writing music in ascii instead. Works.

    • @SianaGearz
      @SianaGearz 3 роки тому +1

      @@Testgeraeusch I wonder, Lilypond got smufl support a year or two ago, right? So you can write music in ascii and still use proper engaving and Tantacrul's font.

    • @Testgeraeusch
      @Testgeraeusch 3 роки тому

      @@SianaGearz talkin' 'bout 2010 :/

  • @Blackenwhitkaeys
    @Blackenwhitkaeys 3 роки тому +29

    this era must have done something right to produce a dude who
    - has intense attention to detail and visual artistic skill
    - crosses over with music and software design
    - has an interest in making UA-cam videos
    - and has a charming tone to deliver it all in

  • @demantim
    @demantim 3 роки тому +25

    My God, that's a lot of moving parts in a sheet music font! Am looking forward to the new MuseScore version.
    I switched to MuseScore last year after more than a decade of cursing (and occasionally using) Sib. It's a great pleasure to say that cursing and using in MuseScore are about even in occurrence which is a big improvement!

    • @kuwitt7941
      @kuwitt7941 3 роки тому +5

      Have you meanwhile realized that the new released version from today already includes the new fonts, so it's ready for use?

  • @GVDub
    @GVDub 3 роки тому +21

    I was extraordinarily fortunate to be able to hang with Leland Smith at a couple of NAMM and Musik Messe shows back in the mid-'90s when I worked for Midiman (Leland was a friend of Midiman founder, Tim Ryan). We talked AI and music, and made bad jokes. I still have his card from the Stanford AI Lab, carefully preserved.

  • @dreikelvin
    @dreikelvin 3 роки тому +59

    In theory classes, I was always proud that I could draw *perfect* clefs with a pencil. this video shattered all all of this. Thank you, Tantacrul!

  • @azzahnoble
    @azzahnoble 3 роки тому +577

    So when you say “that’s coming next year” near the end, does that mean 2022 or 2021? I know you’ve likely been working on this video since last year, but given your upload schedule I’m 50/50 on it.

    • @Tantacrul
      @Tantacrul  3 роки тому +801

      Oh darn...
      Yes. This video was delayed by a few months.... I meant this year. OH WELL!

    • @nat6639
      @nat6639 3 роки тому +124

      @@Tantacrul oh thank God, I was worried I'd have to wait a full year haha

    • @worlds1qwopfan93
      @worlds1qwopfan93 3 роки тому +89

      ​@@Tantacrul It would be tantamount to cruelty to tease an update due for the following year in January!

    • @JBergmansson
      @JBergmansson 3 роки тому +8

      Also guessing that this video went out on Patreon before new year, so "next year" was probably correct then.

    • @musescore
      @musescore 3 роки тому +52

      @@worlds1qwopfan93 Wow. One of my oldest viewers!
      Can't forget that username! Anyway, it's not coming out in 2022. It'll come out 2021. A video delay oversight!

  • @tonygemayel3801
    @tonygemayel3801 3 роки тому +36

    On behalf of all 5 million musescore users: THANK YOU AND EVERYONE ON THE MUSESCORE TEAM!!

  • @kennyholmes5196
    @kennyholmes5196 3 роки тому +111

    Ah, so Leland Smith's opinion on Score was like Johann Schleyer's opinion on Volapük and James Cook Brown's opinion on Loglan: He didn't want anyone touching it. Fittingly enough, it's suffered the same fate as both of those conlangs: It's been abandoned in favor of competitors and offshoots.

    • @df09ify
      @df09ify 3 роки тому +13

      Yes, that's most unfortunate, it's still far better than anything else available today in terms of control and output. I still use it for my own music and there are thousands upon thousands of files at work (GS/AMP) that we work on all the time; right now I'm working on a large publication for work in Score.

    • @kennyholmes5196
      @kennyholmes5196 3 роки тому +7

      @@df09ify I wish you luck on your work.

    • @2xsaiko
      @2xsaiko 3 роки тому +4

      I actually just watched videos about both Volapük and Loglan today, and then I come across this comment. Funny how that happens.

    • @qwertyTRiG
      @qwertyTRiG 3 роки тому +6

      @@2xsaiko I wouldn't be surprised if jan Misali did a video on this at some point. That lad has surprisingly broad interests.

    • @LILProductions
      @LILProductions 3 роки тому +3

      Why I’m an Esperanto speaker and a Musescore user

  • @TheAgamemnon911
    @TheAgamemnon911 3 роки тому +90

    Oooh, Sibelius is in treble now.

    • @Brynbo
      @Brynbo 3 роки тому +8

      That hit my funny bone off guard.

    • @squibble311
      @squibble311 3 роки тому

      PUN

  • @MazeFrame
    @MazeFrame 3 роки тому +16

    That "type command, send off, see result"-design strikes me as extremely clever.
    Add some modern real-time rendering of the input command and you are good to go in my books.

    • @Olivia-W
      @Olivia-W Рік тому

      @James Ross Latex is love, Latex is life, I agree. Add something like Overleaf for online, seamless package management and real time rendering in an easy to use platform agnostic way, and it's the goat.

  • @theswime945
    @theswime945 Рік тому +5

    Way back when I was at Music College, we had calligraphy lessons. I'm talking way before computers. We had to buy a massive arsenal of stationary which cost a fortune (I still have it all as keepsakes), but more than that we were taught the inherent myriad subtelties . To this day I can knock up a very decent lead sheet quickly by hand. This is a fascinating vid and project, thank you very much for all your efforts, you've made a difference. Cheers.

  • @JoshuaKilimnik
    @JoshuaKilimnik 3 роки тому +20

    As a casual yet extremely frequent user of MuseScore let me just say thank you for all the majestic work you do for this app. I don’t know anyone in my life who uses the app (let alone the way i do) and finding people talking about it on the internet always excites there hell out of me !

  • @lulairenoroub3869
    @lulairenoroub3869 3 роки тому +55

    10:15 "you might think this looks good" actually my first thought was "you've completely missed Helvetica and landed on comic sans"

    • @xmlthegreat
      @xmlthegreat 3 роки тому +4

      Yep that was my reaction. I have no knowledge of typography but my instinct said "that looks kinda bad"

    • @thefakepie1126
      @thefakepie1126 3 роки тому +4

      comic sans gang
      comic sans gang

  • @MapleMilk
    @MapleMilk 3 роки тому +20

    Man, I guess the Musescore team LOVED the Sibelius video

    • @jt_jeetee
      @jt_jeetee 3 роки тому +11

      We loved the MuseScore video even more ;-)

  • @jonasmostert3294
    @jonasmostert3294 3 роки тому +34

    I would really really like to see a 5-10 minute screen capture of Simon laying out a complex sheet in score! Please ask him, that would be so cool. Also, your videos are really entertaining an educational, thanks!

  • @lelluc
    @lelluc 3 роки тому +33

    Can't wait to find jankman included as an easter egg within the font!

    • @Brunosky_Inc
      @Brunosky_Inc 3 роки тому +11

      Like how funny lil drawings being added to Japanese character sets lead to emoji being embraced by Unicode and all sites using it, jankman hidden in this new font could lead to jankmotes becoming standard in all notation software

  • @ChevronTango
    @ChevronTango 3 роки тому +30

    There is almost certainly some in-joke with Simon that we are all missing here.

  • @Vlad-pz1oh
    @Vlad-pz1oh 3 роки тому +8

    Me after like 15 mins: FONTS ARE SCARY AF.
    I now appreciate the font artists, thank you.

  • @groowy
    @groowy 3 роки тому +9

    while Tantacrul might not be the hero we deserve, he's a hero that we all need and love

  • @darraghchapman
    @darraghchapman 3 роки тому +16

    Looking forward to this! Fair play to Musescore for not only taking your criticism on board, but taking *you* on board to sort it out :)

  • @markuskopter
    @markuskopter 3 роки тому +167

    One dislike. Maybe, Simon didn't like how he's represented in this video at all. 🤔

    • @brunoflorentino1278
      @brunoflorentino1278 3 роки тому +26

      "it's not nice"

    • @renyhp
      @renyhp 3 роки тому +14

      Same for me. It's super weird that he calls it awkward for Simon to want his privacy. He should've dealt with the problem differently than sort of making fun of him.

    • @Enerjy
      @Enerjy 3 роки тому +1

      Better wording: "Maybe Simon didn't like how he was represented in this video after all."

    • @totallycarbon2106
      @totallycarbon2106 3 роки тому +12

      @@renyhp I think this might be a tad presumptuous of their relationship and I'm sure Tantacrul wouldn't put out something making gentle fun of a collaborator without knowing it would be ok to do so / without running it past him.
      It reads more as a joke between friends to me, than some kind of hostile attack, and if it really were the latter I'm sure this font would never have made the light of day!

    • @renyhp
      @renyhp 3 роки тому +3

      @@totallycarbon2106 I hope you're right about this being a joke between friends. But even then, it felt like he was specifically making fun of him *because he cares about his privacy*. While they are completely free to make fun of each other, especially if it's a joke, it sort of sends a wrong message, as if caring about one's privacy is something weird. Sure I hope this wasn't his intention, but that's definitely what sounded like to me.

  • @antonkirchhoff9841
    @antonkirchhoff9841 3 роки тому +8

    Plot twist: Tantacrul actually did everything by himself but went insane in the process so he invented an imaginary friend - Simon

  • @Digital-Dan
    @Digital-Dan Рік тому +3

    Incredible. Great to see the pix and descriptions of Leland Smith. He and I co-resided at the Stanford AI Lab in the late 60's and early 70's. I recall many conversations where he showed off his notation software, including the fonts. At the time he was printing to a pen plotter, and later to a crude laser printer. Later, I learned he was also an accomplished Contrabass bassoonist. One of my favorite people ever. Indeed, he never claimed his system had the best user interface. He was interested in providing the ability to get an output as beautiful and authentic as possible. I believe it about experts, though.
    At the same time, I was researching some of the underpinnings that informed the creation of the modern user interface, but I guess I didn't share it with Leland. 🙂
    Unbelievably, later my colleagues and I tried out some of our new UI ideas in work that we did for Ginn and Co. Odds?

  • @mikego2611
    @mikego2611 3 роки тому +8

    People that develop open source software have a special place in my heart. Even more so when the software being developed is so well crafted.
    I cannot thank you enough nor even say the legacy people like both of you leave on the digital world.
    I hope I can contribute too with any open source software, not matter how small it might be.

  • @hannahmccall446
    @hannahmccall446 3 роки тому +6

    I can read music notation about as well as a 4 year old can read War and Peace, but I love these insights into the design process. I'm a media content producer, and your videos have many useful takeaways that I can apply to my own work. And where there is no crossover I just enjoy your video style and humour.

  • @swankykoala4836
    @swankykoala4836 3 роки тому +4

    19:09 "NEW ALL" in the captions. I appreciate these little easter eggs that you put in knowing that only 1 or 2 people will find it to have a good chuckle over.

  • @_ikako_
    @_ikako_ 3 роки тому +280

    imagine not just using ms paint to write music with. damn amateurs.

    • @pseudotaco
      @pseudotaco 3 роки тому +33

      Imagine not using a text file that describes, in full sentences, which pixel is supposed to have what color to write music
      Edit: specified "in full sentences"

    • @thezipcreator
      @thezipcreator 3 роки тому +16

      @@pseudotaco that is exactly what a bitmap is
      edit: he changed the comment to add "in full sentences" so this comment is now invalid

    • @dz4k.com.
      @dz4k.com. 3 роки тому +19

      @@pseudotaco imagine not using a hex editor to manually create a jpeg of each page of your score

    • @markusTegelane
      @markusTegelane 3 роки тому +13

      @@dz4k.com. imagine not manually changing the state of each transistor inside a NAND chip to write binary data that can eventually be decoded as an image that can represent a page of your score

    • @htesreyzaw6114
      @htesreyzaw6114 3 роки тому +3

      Imagine not telling your friend where each pixel is to draw on a chalkboard which then a person takes a picture of and prints out. Amateurs.

  • @bigmistqke
    @bigmistqke 3 роки тому +12

    This is an intersection of so many of my interests

    • @bigmistqke
      @bigmistqke 3 роки тому +3

      Ok i would love a 5 hour deep dive into the intricacies of the new design

  • @Snavels
    @Snavels 3 роки тому +21

    After trying out Finale and Sibelius, surprisingly, for the most part, I actually still prefer Musescore. It's easy to use, and great for easy sketches. However, part formatting can be a chore sometimes and I do a lot of extra work getting the parts to be picture esque and looking readable

    • @Snavels
      @Snavels 2 роки тому

      @@jeffhrsn I'll certainly give it a try. For simplified big band sketches, I like to actually go the old school method and play the piano and write the parts down on a grand staff.

    • @wolfetteplays8894
      @wolfetteplays8894 Рік тому

      @@Snavels good. We shouldn’t be bastardizing notation and putting composers out of work. Old school is of the highest form of art and among the most ethical

  • @bjordan429
    @bjordan429 3 роки тому +3

    As an outsider (RF engineer) entering the music theme, , I love your approach. Thank you for respecting privacy.
    Please, never change your approach; you are on your 'A' game.

    • @glipk
      @glipk 2 роки тому

      aged like milk

  • @danihk2872
    @danihk2872 3 роки тому +18

    i cannot express how much i love just how the notes, their stems, and their flags look. beautiful work

    • @danihk2872
      @danihk2872 3 роки тому +4

      also, the accidentals !!!!!

  • @kerbonaut2059
    @kerbonaut2059 3 роки тому +8

    I’m here from your video on the update on the Musescore channel, and I’m dying at the fact that even at your most professional, you put a joke on Feldman’s Yeast in there.

    • @twingnagna
      @twingnagna 3 роки тому +1

      I bet he couldn’t help it 😂

  • @dubbynelson
    @dubbynelson 3 роки тому +5

    With the whole "manually programming shit in", I wish this was still a thing in applications. It’s so, so cool and seems so much more lightweight. I think that’s why I find trackers so intriguing :)

    • @thezipcreator
      @thezipcreator 7 місяців тому

      I know this comment is 2 years old and I shouldn't bother but:
      hardcoding shit is a really bad practice. it makes the program way less extensible, which is annoying both for people trying to improve the program and for the original maintainers.

  • @undisclosedmusic4969
    @undisclosedmusic4969 3 роки тому +4

    As a computer scientist and musician I feel a very high affinity towards both you and this video ❤️

  • @user-et3xn2jm1u
    @user-et3xn2jm1u 3 роки тому +6

    Now this is the kind of video UA-cam was originally intended for.

  • @mahrinui18
    @mahrinui18 Рік тому +3

    Wow, Score was really ahead of its time! It had a "type slurs" input even before 4chan!

    • @calliioa
      @calliioa Рік тому

      The Technolo/g/y of the 1980s!

  • @andrewwiele5091
    @andrewwiele5091 3 роки тому +2

    I think the most fun part of the videos is to look at the music on screen and figure out which piece is being played. It just dawned on me what the score at 7:30 is because I've just started working on the piece.

  • @aleckunkel3705
    @aleckunkel3705 3 роки тому +12

    "which you continue for 64th and 128th notes...for those people who are into that"
    looking at you, scojo

  • @CosmicTeapot
    @CosmicTeapot 3 роки тому +37

    As a Finale user, I've been on the edge of my seat for a while now waiting for you to give it what it deserves. Can we expect a good ol' ass-whoopin' in the near future?

    • @notafeesh4138
      @notafeesh4138 3 роки тому +4

      I’m pretty much married to Finale at this point and I’m wondering if it would be worth it to use a free app instead, so such a video would be great for me.

    • @CosmicTeapot
      @CosmicTeapot 3 роки тому +3

      @@notafeesh4138 Same, I've been using it for years and half of those years went into learning everything so, now that I "mastered" it (if I can say so), the idea of switching elsewhere pains me... it really is the best notation software I've worked with but it can be so incredibly frustrating some times so it's a love/hate relationship. And the fact that one must pay for upgrades even though it's quite expensive to buy in the first place is quite annoying.

    • @rainbowkrampus
      @rainbowkrampus 3 роки тому +4

      @@CosmicTeapot I'm in the same boat.
      I'm not waiting on a critique. I have plenty of my own tl;dr Finale sucks.
      What I'm waiting on is the big revision Tanta mentions in the video. Then I'll dive into Musescore.

    • @thepowers100
      @thepowers100 3 роки тому +2

      I started with musescore before getting finale... it caused me so much pain and rage that I quit finale. Later, I watched Tantacrul’s review of Dorico and I fell in love. Whilst still not “perfect”, it really feels like a 21st century piece of professional software, as opposed to Finale. Musescore still holds a special place in my heart, though. Great for getting ideas out fast, not pretty

    • @CosmicTeapot
      @CosmicTeapot 3 роки тому +4

      @@thepowers100 Yeah, I gotta admit that Dorico kinda caught my eye too since Tantacrul's video on it but I'm waiting for it to get fixed. I mean the whole system with the switches and the buttons that cancel each other out seemed like a fever dream to me lol.

  • @FredNagel
    @FredNagel 3 роки тому +5

    Dear Tantacrul, thank you for the effort you put into packaging your videos. The long black gaps between segments gives the same experience as reading a well-constructed academic paper, consisting of chapters that are related but distinct. Also, such as at 16:13, dropping in along with the beat - it's such a neat touch that I greatly appreciate. Also, literally everything else.

  • @JulioHerrlein
    @JulioHerrlein 3 роки тому +2

    Musescore and UA-cam and the Internet and the World are lucky to have you.😄 !! We are lucky !!

  • @enricodemeo
    @enricodemeo 3 роки тому +2

    Mr. Martin Keary, I really, wholeheartedly, think that you are a treasure for the UA-cam musician community. Your videos are on one hand incredibly well and thoughtfully researched, inpeccably produced and edited (I wish I had some kind of resemblance of your After Effects skills), and on the other hand absolutely bonkers and unhinged in a really scary way. That's THEE mixture that I like. I really hope you do read this comment, because you really are an inspiration and, I think, a great dude. Keep up the work, there are a lot of people who really appreciate you and your work. Have a good one!

  • @wilh3lmmusic
    @wilh3lmmusic 2 роки тому +4

    I see that you used Shosty 9th symphony when showing how SCORE works. Very cheeky!

  • @ardathbelzer9891
    @ardathbelzer9891 3 роки тому +9

    Thank you so much! Love the new font and love MuseScore. As a teacher for an inner-city orchestral program, MuseScore has been my partner in remote learning. Some of the kids have enjoyed composing as well! It's been a tough year! Remote learning is like driving down a highway at 60 MPH, all while building the road and designing the car. I would not have made it so far without MuseScore!
    Just one little annoyance: Isn't transpose by Octave the most common? Why ever would we transpose by perfect unison? I know it's a little thing but sometimes when I'm trying to get a score up for my kids, I need every second. Overall, love it.

    • @jt_jeetee
      @jt_jeetee 3 роки тому +6

      Transpose by octave is so common that it has it's own default shortcut: Ctrl/Cmd+up/down

    • @ardathbelzer9891
      @ardathbelzer9891 3 роки тому +3

      @@jt_jeetee Thank you so much! What I don't know is a lot! Just searched for other shortcuts and downloaded the file, printed it and it's in my teaching data binder. musescore.org/sites/musescore.org/files/MuseScore%20Shortcuts.pdf

  • @1980rlquinn
    @1980rlquinn 3 роки тому +2

    As an amateur musician and amateur typesetter, I cannot tell you how much I appreciate the attention and effort you've give this project, as well as for this video covering it!

  • @Nanananaheyhey1
    @Nanananaheyhey1 3 роки тому +2

    I accidentally clicked on this video, and sat through the whole thing. It’s ironic because I’m a composer and recently I just got into scribing and what it takes to make a professional looking score! This was very interesting, and I learned a lot! Thank you!

  • @christophermcmahan1628
    @christophermcmahan1628 3 роки тому +4

    Woke up saw new Tantacrul video and literally leaped for joy. I’m not involved in the music industry at all just enjoy these videos

  • @LasseKarhu
    @LasseKarhu 3 роки тому +3

    As someone with slightly poor hearing it's always nice to hear well articulated speech in a video. The visuals were top quality too. Musescore team is lucky to have you in their ranks.👍

  • @RonSonntag
    @RonSonntag Рік тому +1

    This was such an awesome presentation! Funny and wickedly informative. I especially appreciated the meticulous attention to font design. Many decades ago, I created the first solid-filled fonts (using B-Splines and based on the URW Hinterberger licensed fonts that I converted and hand-modified for the microcomputer incorporating kerning and hints that were missing from the purchased fonts) for the microcomputer (Windows). The font system was programmed in C and Assembler and was sold as the "ASI Font System". Software Publishing Corporation was the first company to license the font system and incorporated it into Harvard Business Graphics - a Windows PC program. We later used it in our own G-Wiz Graphics, a scientific graphing program sold by my company Analytical Software, Inc. (closed down in 2001). Good memories and an appreciation of this artistry!

  • @kuwitt7941
    @kuwitt7941 3 роки тому +2

    Thanks for being part of the MuseScore project.

  • @leleogere
    @leleogere 3 роки тому +6

    For people interested in typing music as text, like you had to do in Score, I suggest you to have a look at Lilipond, which is still maintained today.

    • @joshuapettus6973
      @joshuapettus6973 3 роки тому +2

      Fun fact, the Lilypond symbols were originally the default font used in Musescore as the font Emmentaler. That's now replaced by Leyland. Therefor Id imagine score's output was better.

    • @TheVoitel
      @TheVoitel 3 роки тому +1

      @@joshuapettus6973 Not really. The notation symbols of Score were quite bad in some cases, I mean accidentals just look horrible in Score. But the thing is: Lilypond is the absolute opposite of Score, although it shares some similarities. Lilypond follows the TeX idea, that is: Lilypond is the Engraver, and knows how to do most things. You can get Lilypond to do exactly what you specify, but it defaults to being intelligent. Score on the other hand follows the idea that *nothing* is done automatically unless you specify it yourself. The reason Score has been popular with Publishers is that it gives a lot of control of exact positioning. But unless you are an experienced Engraver you will probably not make good looking scores with it.

  • @jestemqiqi7647
    @jestemqiqi7647 3 роки тому +8

    Everytime Tantacrul posts a new video, it feels like Christmas.

  • @convoliution
    @convoliution 3 роки тому +1

    I've seen this video drift through my recommendations for a couple days before clicking on it, and I'm shocked that this still has so few views! An intersection of music, software history, and graphic design was a crossover I never knew I needed.

  • @webfischi
    @webfischi 3 роки тому +1

    I was really amazed when I saw the new font first, because 2 years ago, someone complained that the notation of musescore doesn't look very professional compared to more pricy composition software like Finale.

  • @arthur822
    @arthur822 3 роки тому +88

    When you say the new Musescore interface is coming next year, do you mean 2021 or 2022?

    • @Tantacrul
      @Tantacrul  3 роки тому +119

      2021. This was a bad editing / delay oversight :)

    • @Akkordinator
      @Akkordinator 3 роки тому +3

      You can already take a peak at it and download a nightly (meaning not at all polished!) version of it to see where it's going:
      ftp.osuosl.org/pub/musescore-nightlies/windows/4x/nightly/?C=M;O=D

    • @analytomaniac
      @analytomaniac 3 роки тому +5

      @@Tantacrul phew, good. was about to say.

    • @CieMaKat
      @CieMaKat 3 роки тому

      You can see the work in progress by downloading nightly builds. **By no means** they should be used to create or edit any important project with.
      For windows check out: ftp.osuosl.org/pub/musescore-nightlies/windows/4x/nightly

    • @GerharDTeach
      @GerharDTeach 3 роки тому +3

      @@Tantacrul thank god I almost threw my computer through the window when you said "next year" hahahha

  • @herrstruppi4948
    @herrstruppi4948 3 роки тому +37

    How can you be good at composing, playing lots of instruments, software/icon/font design, and probably a lot of other things at the same time? (Edit: And making videos, obviously)

    • @foxjacket
      @foxjacket 3 роки тому +1

      Because he's Ling Ling

    • @namkedi
      @namkedi 3 роки тому

      @@foxjacket long long 40 hours

    • @SianaGearz
      @SianaGearz 3 роки тому

      Is he good at people, cleaning, washing up, cooking, keeping a healthy sleeping schedule, keeping a healthy eating schedule? Maybe he is, maybe he isn't. There are millions of little things normal people are generally pretty well skilled at, ordinary skills. Sometimes extraordinary people sacrifice the ordinary skills for the extraordinary ones.

  • @wohdinhel
    @wohdinhel 3 роки тому +2

    Wow, you know, so much of the sheet music publishing industry still relying on 20+ year software really explains SO MUCH

  • @Jack-cq9pv
    @Jack-cq9pv Рік тому +1

    Back from seeing the new Musescore 4, and WOW you’ve done a fantastic job!

  • @justanotherpiccplayer3511
    @justanotherpiccplayer3511 3 роки тому +17

    God I hope musescore takes over sibelius as the industry standard already, my god do I rage at sibelius but its what we have to use at uni

    • @rainbowkrampus
      @rainbowkrampus 3 роки тому +4

      I found Tanta just as I was making the switch from Sibelius to Finale. Foolishly thinking that the grass would be greener.
      They both suck. But each in their own special little ways.
      Even if Musescore does become better (nicer appearance, more intuitive UI, etc.) than these other programs, it's still going to take a long time to be adopted because there's a sunk cost fallacy involved with software for most people. Once you put in the effort to learn to work with something, even if it's objectively bad, you're not going to want to abandon it.

    • @Tokkemon
      @Tokkemon 3 роки тому

      It's got a long way to go before that would happen.

    • @arinetic5538
      @arinetic5538 3 роки тому

      I honestly think it has the potential to be industry standard eventually with Martin as head of design, but agree with other commenters that there's still a long way for it to go. One thing that still really bugs me is the lack of VST support (which is available for basically all other notation apps), as well as playback issues like the inability to add ritardantos/rallentandos. But I do hear inklings that these may be introduced soon with the next major design update. Fingers crossed!

    • @jt_jeetee
      @jt_jeetee 3 роки тому +1

      @@arinetic5538 VSTs are indeed on the menu for MuseScore 4
      ralls could be, but so far no developers/contributor has picked up any work effort on that; There is a plugin that automates the manual workarounds for MS2 and MS3 available.

  • @joywolfe.
    @joywolfe. 3 роки тому +4

    that font literally makes my brain feel at ease after looking at so much nauseatingly thin, unbalanced notation in my schooling days lol

  • @CyrusandAurelius
    @CyrusandAurelius 3 роки тому +1

    Just started my younger son on Musescore. That's how we found you! So happy to see musescore takes constructive criticism positively and reaches out!

  • @Merthalophor
    @Merthalophor 3 роки тому +2

    This is great, can't wait to see what you'll do with the software! It's somewhat satisfying to see someone burn a bad product; it's immensely satisfying to see it being polished by that same person.

  • @yarlodek5842
    @yarlodek5842 3 роки тому +7

    A great UA-camr, a great composer, and a great graphic designer?

  • @darksaiyan2006
    @darksaiyan2006 3 роки тому +3

    Oh hey, I responded to one of your tweets about the treble clef - I'm glad to see that a first version is coming out! Keep it up!

  • @eti313
    @eti313 Рік тому +1

    As a person who's designed a few fonts, and has a basic understanding of notation, I really appreciate this. I've also watched a few more of your videos and started noticing a few typographical ın-ȷokes. Subscription earned!

  • @Alfred_English
    @Alfred_English 2 роки тому +1

    last week i watched a 20 minute video on the math behind bezier curves, and now i'm here. i gotta admit sometimes this youtube algorithm is simply fantastic

  • @computer_toucher
    @computer_toucher 3 роки тому +3

    I am impressed by your dedication, and also your skills and sensitivities in both design and composition. I also like your humour. A true polymath scholar, you are.

  • @mysteryfish2043
    @mysteryfish2043 3 роки тому +4

    I damn near shit myself every time you upload, your videos are HIGHLY underrated, and way more people need to see your channel.

  •  3 роки тому +1

    I used Sibelius as default notation program since 2007 (version 5) until 2018 version. After that, a friend told me that an open source project was available (MuseScore) and with an easier learning curve compared with Lilypond. I took the decision to do the migration (2019), it was very easy to change to the new music notation program due similar GUI and features.
    Until now, in my opinion this is the best improvement on layout (very impressive) because as Simon, I'm very critical with layout presentation - for me the default font (Plantin MT Std) used by Sibelius - it was a little bit better for printing.
    Brilliant video as well!
    The portuguese community is not so large but I'm preparing a dedicate channel with tutorial lessons.

  • @leworthin
    @leworthin 3 роки тому +2

    "Why would I want to see this video?" I asked myself... until I started watching this fascinating and informative story! Many thanks!