WW2 From the Japanese Perspective | Animated History
Вставка
- Опубліковано 29 вер 2024
- Exclusive! Grab the NordVPN deal ➼ nordvpn.com/hi... and get +1 extra month. Try it risk-free now with a 30-day money-back guarantee!
Armchair Historian Video Game: store.steampow...
Support us on Patreon: / armchairhistorian
Sign up for Armchair History TV today! armchairhistor...
Promo code: ARMCHAIRHISTORY for 50% OFF
Merchandise available at store.armchair...
Check out the new Armchair History TV Mobile App too!
apps.apple.com...
play.google.co...
Discord: / discord
Twitter: / armchairhist
Sources:
"Chinese Victory: Changteh is Lost and Won in Battle Called Most Decisive in Three Years". LIFE. 21 February 1944.
Grand Strategy and Military Alliances (United Kingdom: Cambridge University Press, 2016).
Japanese-German Relations, 1895-1945: War, Diplomacy and Public Opinion (United Kingdom: Routledge, 2006).
The Japanese Navy in World War II: In the Words of Former Japanese Naval Officers, Second Edition. (United States: Naval Institute Press, 2017).
Boyd, Carl. “The Berlin-Tokyo Axis and Japanese Military Initiative.” Modern Asian Studies 15, no. 2 (1981): 311-338. www.jstor.org/s....
Dickinson, Frederick R. World War I and the Triumph of a New Japan, 1919-1930 (United Kingdom: Cambridge University Press, 2013).
Ienaga, Saburō. The Pacific War, 1931-1945: A Critical Perspective on Japan’s Role in World War II, 1931-1945 (New York: Pantheon Books, 1978).
Iriye, Akira. The Origins of the Second World War in Asia and the Pacific (United Kingdom: Routledge, 2013).
Kuromiya, Hiroaki. Stalin, Japan, and the Struggle for Supremacy Over China, 1894-1945 (United Kingdom: Taylor & Francis Group, 2023).
Marston, Daniel (ed.). The Pacific War: From Pearl Harbor to Hiroshima. Oxford: Osprey Press, 2011.
Matsusaka, Yoshihisa Tak. The Making of Japanese Manchuria, 1904-1932 (Cambridge: Harvard University Asia Center, 2001).
Mimura, Janis. Planning for Empire: Reform Bureaucrats and the Japanese Wartime State (United States: Cornell University Press, 2011).
Paine, S. C. M. The Wars for Asia, 1911-1949 (United Kingdom: Cambridge University Press, 2012).
Porter, Edgar A. and Porter, Ran Ying. Japanese Reflections on World War II and the American Occupation (Netherlands: Amsterdam University Press, 2018).
Rottman, Gordon L. and Anderson Duncan. Japanese Army in World War II: Conquest of the Pacific 1941-42 (United Kingdom: Bloomsbury USA, 2005).
Tanaka, Toshiyuki. Hidden Horrors: Japanese War Crimes in World War II (United Kingdom: Rowman & Littlefield, 2018).
Thorne, Christopher. The Limits of Foreign Policy: The West, the League and the Far Eastern Crisis of 1931-1933 (United Kingdom: MacMillan Press Ltd, 1972).
Wetzler, Peter. Hirohito and War: Imperial Tradition and Military Decision Making in Prewar Japan (United States: University of Hawaii Press, 1998).
Wright, Derrick. Pacific Victory. Tarawa to Okinawa 1943-1945 (United Kingdom: Sutton Publishing Limited, 2005).
Music:
Armchair Historian Theme - Zach Heyde
Paths of a Samurai - Mandala Dreams
Monarch of Fate - Christoffer Moe Ditlevsen
Made of Shadows - Lalo Brickman
Andersen Apparitions - Christian Andersen
Hunger, Thirst - Johannes Bornlof
Top Patrons:
Jonathan Woody
Nep Nep
MatsMan
Hilgy
Avery Mullins
Kure
John R. Merlino Jr.
CPTTanker Joe
Christoph Wißmann
Alden Simmons
The Demon Lord
Exclusive! Grab the NordVPN deal ➼ nordvpn.com/historyvpn and get +1 extra month. Try it risk-free now with a 30-day money-back guarantee!
Armchair Historian Video Game: store.steampowered.com/app/1679290/Fire__Maneuver/
Support us on Patreon: www.patreon.com/armchairhistorian
Sign up for Armchair History TV today! armchairhistory.tv/
Promo code: ARMCHAIRHISTORY for 50% OFF
Merchandise available at store.armchairhistory.tv/
Check out the new Armchair History TV Mobile App too!
apps.apple.com/us/app/armchair-history-tv/id1514643375
play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=tv.uscreen.armchairhistorytv
Discord: discord.gg/thearmchairhistorian
Twitter: twitter.com/ArmchairHist
What the hell are you doing....you are irritating us too much....I am told this matter for every day by every day! Is your brain have mental problem?
Please do a video about Bangladesh war.
Please, otherwise I will curse you
:D
You should do napoleons invasion of russia
*imperial to fascist imperial*
Can you do a Video on Mexican Army Uniforms?
Imagine being a Japanese soldier and remaining isolated on a small isle unaware of what's happened to the rest of the world till the 1970s.
Why do I feel like this either will be adapted into a movie or already has?
@@Stratoneticyou're not the only one
@@Stratonetic it already have since he’s talking about a Japanese soldier named Hiroo Onoda that continued fighting ww2. 30 years after it ended and there are already movies/documentaries about him.
@@sulaymanbah123
Yes, I understand that there's documentaries but has there ever been like a movie with actors acting out the story?; Other war time events have been dramatized on the big screen but I have not seen this specific event, yet it wouldn't surprise me if it was or will be adapted into a movie.
They literally went from Banzai to Kawaii, which is a huge culture shock
How did Japan go from war crimes to cute anime girls it's like they pulled a Michael Jackson on the world lol
how they go from 'emperor will important' and 'samurais are good' to 'military good, conquer' and new animations genre and 'emperors will not important
propaganda and extreme nationalism can make people do all sorts of crazy and horrific things. Japan was very liberal and very progressive after ww1. But Military eventually took power and pushed their influence on people
@@PH7NTOM that explains it live in Finland 🇫🇮 and I don't know to much about it
The Imperial japanese army and citizens are two different things
The atomic bomb mutated them.
I love your channel keep up the great stuff
@TheArmchairHistorian...... what? I don't get it
12:19 the general was wrong, because Yamamoto predicted that we can run as we like for 6 months after that i can't guarantee.
Despite his warning, they attacked US
I thought forsure we were going to get a “D Day from the Japanese perspective” video 😂
It's Ya-Ma-To not Ya-Mo-Tou
No-one-cares
@@Harib_Al-Saq True
Not trying to be a nerd or anything but uh, your team misspelled Musashi, the name was Musashi not Mushashi
The Young Officers coup failed, its impact led the Control faction of the military to gain more power over the Imperial one (Kodoha), I understand the limited time available, but there are many inaccuracies in the explanation of the wars' outbreaks
Would be interesting to see how the end of WW2 played out in the eyes of Japan, whether the US and/or the USSR caused the unconditional surrender.
The Emperor gave slightly different speeches announcing the surrender...in the one for the Home Islands, he mentioned the atomic bombs, but did not talk about the Soviet invasion of Manchuria, but in the one that went out to the troops in China and Korea and the rest of the mainland talked only about the invasion and left out the atom bombs. That is a pretty definitive indication that it was both the atom bombs and the Soviet declaration of war that went into the Emperor's decision to finally support unconditional surrender....I think.
It was very likely both.
The Military that basically had control over the nation didn''t care about the atomic bombs, it was no different than the firebombing of Tokyo to them, thousands of casualties and a ton of destruction. They knew about atomic bombs, they tried it themselves and were pretty unsuccessful, but knew America had the capability to make a small amount of them. So when the bombings did happen, the military reacted little towards it.
The Soviets entering the war was a big threat to them, however, they thought they could squeeze a more favourable peace Treaty if they deal enough casualties to America, but that plan went out the window when the Soviets came into the picture, Soviets don't care about casualties, and the soviets would destroy their culture with Communism if given the chance.
So I Imagine the the emperor took advantage of the situation of the Military struggling with the soviets and the general fear of the Atomic bomb that everyone else had, to call for peace, but despite this, many in the military still wanted to fight and attempted a coup.
The time line is pretty easy to follow, as the 6 ministers in charge of Japan at the time actually had meetings on whether to surrender or keep fighting for each of the atomic bombings and the Soviet invasion.. Hiroshima on August 6th, 4 Ministers voted to continue the war against 2 who voted to surrender. August 7th would see the Soviet War Declaration and invasion, with again a vote on the matter of surrendering ending up 4 to 2. The 2nd Atomic bombing that occurred on the 9th would finally bring the vote to a 3 to 3 tie, with the Emperor being asked to intervene and be the tie breaker. Most likely both the Atomic bombs and the Soviet invasion played a role in Japans surrender, with the bombs probably being the greater reason.
People who argue that it was the Soviet Invasion and not the bombs that caused Japan to surrender, I personally find to be the weirdest bunch. They plainly ignore that the Japanese ministers didn't even flinch and continued to for in favor of fighting on. The Ministered most likely realized a rather simple fact... the Soviets did not have the naval capability to invade Japan.
Even then, the surrender almost didn't happen, as a large force of Japanese Army soldiers attempted to capture the Emperor and destroy the recordings he had made of his surrender speech. This was called the Kyūjō incident.
Both did - it’s like the surrender of Germany - no single cause was the reason for its surrender but the massive pressure being put on it on all angles.
My great granddad Feser was at Pearl Harbor on the USS California. After the bombing, he was reassigned to the USS Aragon, and saw action at every battle of the Pacific except for Guadalcanal and Iwo Jima. He later went on to fight in Korea. I never knew him, sadly, as he died before I was born
For a second I thought that the ship was called aragorn
*imperial to fascist imperial*
@C.A._Old I reckon? Hey wait a tick. Just to clarify, you're talking about the factions he was FIGHTING, right?
@@C.A._Oldwhich side are yuo saying it as fascist imperial?
@@C.A._Old ohh bugger of will you? He's just telling a cool story
You should do the Napoleonic retreat from Russia from the french soldier's perspective. I think that would be very interesting. Keep it up Griffin 🙏
(Edit): OMG thanks for all the likes, hopefully Griffin could one day make this happen 👍
if it was from the average soldier’s perspective, it would be a very quick video
Starving The Documentary
I was here
“Turning a cold shoulder”, the retreat from Moscow.
Or maybe how napoleon failed from the start and how it effected the morale of France it’s neighbours
I was waiting so long for a video on Japan, and I'm kinda mixed. The full documentary on Germany takes 1h30 but this video on Japan is a 17min one-shot. Sure it is very well made and sums up everything very well, but it kinds of feels rushed. Even the end is kind of abrupt. I don't think this video does enough to really highlight the Japanese role in WW2. It's even shorter than the video on Italy (one of the best btw).
I hope that this was just a summary video and that the team plans on other videos on the pacific theater that will go more in-depth, like a video on the quality of the Japanese navy like you did on the Kriegsmarine.
Although I'm honestly tired of the WW2 videos, you are right, it was going in depth and near the end it started rushing like mad, not even the aftermath of the wars were discussed or maybe the tokyo trials.
cry about it
@@yikes6969 ok neckbeard
@@yikes6969he is
@@yikes6969they were just giving constructive criticism about how the video could be better, your reply adds nothing and is unnecessary
I was kind of surprised not to see any mention of the incident between Japan and the USA that involved the USS Panay river gunboat. It definitely caused a lot of anti Japanese sentiment in the USA, and could have led to war between the 2 if FDR had felt the USA was ready to fight.
It is also surprising that there was no mention at all of the Soviet-Japanese Neutrality Pact of April 1941. That had a huge impact on the course of the war, and I am frankly a bit shocked that Armchair would leave it out entirely.
Yeah, but there's only so much you can put into a 17 minute video
What were you doing between 1933-1945
@@matthewgillespie2835 then make a 20 minute video
It definitely would have been pretty easy to at least mention both events, and it should take no more extra time than it took you folks to read the couple of sentences of my post. I would be amazed if it would have taken even as much as 30 seconds of extra script read time.
@@tigerabraham5582 Not born yet...why?
The stupidly fast rise of japanese naval force is scary as hell. They went from nothing to competing with Britain and the US. Would like you to do a video centered about it like you did with the Kriegsmarine.
😂 Brother the US didn't exist and the Britains couldn't write when japanese and Chinese civilizations were at it's peak 😂
@@AnasKhan-sr2flChina? Yes. Japan? No. Japan was always a illiterate shithole that leached off China for culture. Europeans civilized them
@@AnasKhan-sr2flthen Japan had to stupidly challenge US. And one little boy and a fat man later here we are.
@@SJ-qd6ev then there is this one insensitive comments
@@mekksviews9843 don't worry this is nothing compared to war crimes committed by Japan, pretty sure literally them would be violate community guidelines
Japan: "Comits unspeekable war-crimes against the people of China"
USA: Could you stop that?
Japan: No!
USA: Okay, then we will stop selling you war-materiel...
Japan: THIS MEANS UNRESTRAIND WAR!!!
Somehow there are people that think Japan was a victim in ww2...
なんだそのお笑い論理は。そして事実でもない。それにはもっともっともっと長い話が必要だろ。
そして、なんだ？そのデタラメを語り我々を不当に辱しめた同じ口で日本文化を語るのか？それは道化なのか？？？
ふざけるな。盗人猛々しい。
I am Chinese, my understanding is a little different from what you described, before the US sanctions Japan, China and Japan have been fighting for nearly 10 years, during which the US-Japan trade has broken records every year, until the Japanese invasion of Indochina the US embargo on oil, in the middle of Chiang Kai-shek received economic aid from the US, but a large part of the purpose of applying for aid is to anti-communism
@@ffff4290ofc it was for anti-communism but in the end it was for the Chinese, and it does matter if those aid were used against an ungrateful invader.
Technically, the US did forcefully open the country under the threat of Cannon fire. So what choice do they have but to take resources from their neighbours?
I’ve always thought a civil war from the slaves perspective would be interesting and important as a relatively overlooked subject
Damn, now that would be a spicy and interesting video. Plus a good chance to disprove the whole “black confederate” myth
@@23tovarm5 Oh boy did you know that the last states to give up slavery were all union states
@@Johnnyupside what!? Your probably thinking of the neutral states such as Delaware and Missouri.
@@23tovarm5 Nope it was union states as Texas the last confederate state gave it up in June 19th. It was only until September if I recall correctly did the rest of the union states abolish it
@@Johnnyupside Texas and the rest of the Confederate states only gave up slavery earlier because they had to be forced to do so, if not they wouldn't have even been readmitted to the Union. The rest of the country was already Free Soiler territory and only signed on last as the Amendments came later.
Slavery was already illegal in the Unionist Northern states and California way before June 19th though. They only made it Federal instead of individual by state.
It should be noted that at the battle of midway, the divergence of forces to the Aleutian Islands may have been a secession to the army who wished to expand the defense perimeter. The army and navy did NOT get along or agree in the Japanese government at the time and bothe of them often had to sacrifice parts of their plan to the other just so the plan could be carried out.
*imperial to fascist imperial*
"The rise of the japanese empire"
from backwater to global powerhouse on par with European powers would be an interesting topic.
@@khalidmusicshorts ayo lmaoooo
@@khalidmusicshortsthat was a bright joke mate
@@khalidmusicshortsthat was a bright joke mate
Almost as bright as a nuclear bomb
Japan remained closed until 1854, with the port of Nagasaki being the only point of contact for trade. However, an American warship came to Edo and demanded the opening of the country. That was Commodore Perry's visit to Japan. Since then, Japan has tried to build superior warships like those of the United States and Great Britain. The defeat of the Qing Dynasty by the British in the Opium War had a great impact on Japan. I thought that Japan would become a British colony if things went on like this, and then Japan proceeded to expand its armaments. Until then, Japan had been asleep.
'Atrocities against Chinese civilians' doesn't even come close to covering the magnitude of crimes against humanity committed across Asia by imperial Japan.
What do you want him to say he said they commited atrocity in china just like any other nation in ww2 so what are you trying to get out of this.
@@Gaminglife-sf1oz"Just like every other nation in WW2" lmao nah
Only the Nazis were as bad. The Japanese even managed to make Soviet Gulags look tame
@@ramadansteve1715He's right. The populace remains ignorant on the full scope of what happened, (intentionally)so that we can morally justify our bombings of children, women, and elders.
Are you ignorant on what happened at Berlin with occupying allied forces...? Much worse than anything Japan has been accused. What about in Tokyo? +1 million Wehrmacht POWs after the war and under Eisenhower were intentionally starved in an effort to "denazify" Germany when most of those men were not even part of the NSDAP.
I'm not downplaying war crimes by Japan or Germany but the hypocrisy is painful and the lack of accountability is a disgrace.
@@user-pn3im5sm7k
I feel like you need to remember that war is literally the most savage thing imaginable, it is organized murder. So to declare actions as “good” and “evil” is honestly despicable, it is objectively evil, all of it.
So then the only thing that matters is why the war was fought, and for that the Pact of Steel was fighting to continue and facilitate literal genocide - and for that the Allies are objectively - not subjectively - OBJECTIVELY, in the right.
@@Gaminglife-sf1oz
Logical fallacy gaming.
I'm disappointed that this video doesn't actually cover the Japanese perspective during WW2. Just some things that the Japanese military branches were involved in that could easily fit into other videos. Barely any mention of how civilians thought and felt at the time, and barely any input from the soldiers or the men who led them. You can do better.
After the surrender of Japan Americans hid imperial Japan war crimes and they never mentioned it also Japan itself destroyed all of its war crimes documents
Yea they were tryna make Asia for the Asians and the west with their Asian collaborators didn’t like that
@@Ffiffijs Biggest lie ever, Imperial Japan truly saw the other Asians as lesser to them, and their territories for their taking, they never cared about the Asians whose territory they took from, as evidenced by the slaughters carried out by them. I believe there is a saying out there from one of the Asian countries overtaken by Imperial Japan, it goes something like this, in a few years Japan has done horrors that took Europeans decades to achieve.
@@diegoquezada3193 today tawain is ran by drug dealers and China is ran by the communist. Both ran by Europeans. Imperial Japan was against both and both worked against imperial Japan trying to put the emperor of China back in power. Then it spread from China to all Asia. Asian Communist and drug dealers have killed and persecuted more people than Japan ever did
@@diegoquezada3193それが嘘だよ。当時のアジアの首脳らは真逆のことをいっている。チャンドラボースなどは特に。
しかし、彼はその後、飛行機の墜落という典型的な死を遂げた。
A description of WW2 from the Japanese perspective is incomplete without mentioning indoctrination about specifically racial superiority. The Japanese viewed themselves as the "master race" of Asian peoples. In contrast, the peoples conquered in the "Co-prosperity Sphere" were viewed as subhuman, justifying the atrocities committed against them. This explains why Japan killed arguably more civilians than Germany while actually fighting - and killing enemy soldiers - far less.
In summation, presenting the "Japanese perspective" without mentioning the view of racial superiority is akin to describing Nazi Germany's actions without including also Aryan supremacy: incomplete and historically misleading.
This is very true. I've lived in Japan for 21 years now. I've had some Japanese openly express their belief that even today, they are superior to all other Asian races, especially the Chinese and Southeast Asians.
The Japanese Empire was against racism. The Japanese definition did not exist in the Japanese Empire. The concept of ethnic cleansing did not exist in Japan, and Japan's assertion of superiority over Asia was not about race but about spirituality and social systems.
A law based on superiority was enacted in 1948 by the influence of the United States after the war.
少なくとも大東亜共栄圏において、体面上では皆平等な関係でした。
あくまで表面上はですが。
@@使用停止アカウント 殺されそうになったら表面は何の意味もない
@@杉乃かふん The Japanese Empire was certainly not above using racism. Maybe the concept of ethnic cleansing did not exist, but the concept of ethnic replacement certainly did. Look at the resettlement policies in Japan.
If it was truly about only spirituality and social systems, Koreans, Chinese, and Malays who adopted Japanese customs should have been treated on par with Japanese citizens right? And yet they were deprived of healthcare services, employment opportunities, and subject to random massacre.
Sometimes I think the scale of the Pacific and Sino-Japanese theaters get overshadowed by the war in Europe and Africa, but man, WW2 was just horrific all around. Thank you for another interesting episode.
God be with you out there everybody. ✝️
This glossed over the atrocities in Nanking and Manila. I don't think that's acceptable.
I mean this video is supposed to be from the Japanese perspective and as far as they're concerned they didn't do that
As a Japanese, I would like to say that there is a minority of Japanese who do not recognize war crimes such as Nanking.
With right-wing Japanese forces (called Netouyo) going around on the Internet claiming that Japan did not commit atrocities, and the lack of official apology by the Japanese government to Korea and China, there seems to be a growing trend in the West and in the US that Japanese people do not admit to war crimes. But we, the average Japanese, know of the war crimes committed by Japan and do not deny them. The government has not apologized, but it does not deny that there was a massacre.
It is sad that as Japanese people we are perceived as a people who do not acknowledge the past. I repeat, the majority of Japanese do admit to war crimes.
Make your own video
@@romuser6248interesting insight
@@romuser6248
I don’t know.
I’ve been living in Japan for over 15 years now and when China or Korea bring up comfort women, Nanking, Yasukuni Shrine, disputed territories like islands, most japanese politicians, news outlets and japanese people I know go nuts and feel personally attacked and offended.
I don’t think that the majority is as crazy as the netouyo but I also don’t think that the majority believes or even knows about japanese war crimes.
my great grandfather was drafted to the imperial japanese army, he escaped through a small sewer few hours before his unit was sent to the Battle of Okinawa, he told my dad that none of his comrades came back home (he is from korea)
why would ur great granddad have to fight for a country that occupies it?
@frankyfeuilles3511 The Japanese government started conscripting Koreans to the Japanese army from 1944.
@@snowade how does that work if the koreans hate japan?
@@frankyfeuilles3511 wdym, korea was part of Japan until 1945. They had no choice because they'll be punished if they resist
@@frankyfeuilles3511 Korea was occupied by the Japanese at the time
Damn, I'm always amazed by how good the artwork is. Let the artists know their hard work doesn't go unnoticed.
"While this situation is often chalked down to imperial aggression, the subject of Japan's expansion is a complex, and often overlooked story."
*Proceeds to explain exactly how it was, in fact, totally due to imperial aggression.*
And what was the Allies oppression of India, Africa, Southeast Asia, etc due to?
Come on, go ahead and tell me, don't be shy. What exactly were European countries doing in places that definitely weren't europe? What caused them to go to those places? Care to explain that one, Einstein?
@@akihikosakurai4013Woe to the vanquished. That which you reap, so shall you sow.
@@akihikosakurai4013 It's not about what the European countries were doing - colonising through imperial aggression, but how Griffin contradicted himself in the video. Despite stating that Japan's expansion was due not only to imperial aggression, his video goes on to funnily explain how it was entirely due to imperial aggression. If it is purely imperial aggression, then he should've just said so instead of perpetuating some niche narrative. No hate on Griffin, just a small point-out 😄
And got wrong the divisions inside the army and navy as well as a oversimplification of "liberal government" vs "imperialist military" who was actually not the case as both were divided and subdivided in a terrible complex manner but by no means applies to issue unstained claims about the Navy wanting to go to war against the western powers, when it was indeed the idea of part of the army who was strengthened after the retirement of Araki and the 2-26 incident.
Have you taken a look into World War Two from the Norwegian perspective? You should also try taking a look at the fighting in Myanmar and Thailand.
You should talk about the rivalry between the Imperial Japanese Army and Imperial Japanese Navy.
People forget that despite US condemnation of japan and assurances to China, US still trade with Japan even peaked in war material. It is until that Indochina was attacked by Japan, US (and the west) began to react and sanction Japan and helping china.
The one that really mattered was the oil embargo. Japan wouldn't have done any of this had the American oil kept sailing.
@@user-pn3im5sm7k And the US wouldn't have embargoed them if they hadn't refused to compromise on the invasion of China.
I always find the Japanese perspective about WWII the most fascinating. The Pacific definitely interests me greatly! Thanks for the video!
Then watch The Pacific🙃😐
@@foxtrotbibiunderrated series. I liked it more than BoB
The Pacific Theater was definitely my favorite out of the 2nd world war. So interesting what everyone had to go through. I’m glad we made friends with Japan and set em straight afterwards.
@@FoxNation18 yep! I find their tactics just so interesting and fascinating. Especially their military doctrine and the infighting what always occurred and how they manage to become a big major power in Asia. Very impressive.
I highly recommend listening to the Hardcore History series on the subject, "Supernova in the East". The military basically took over and acted unilaterally. The goverment just went along with it because they were so successful. It was wild.
anyone get kicked out for watching the invasion of Afghanistan and told the video is private?
Yup
You should do WW2 from the latin american perspective. It’s a usually glossed over part of the event but still interesting and important
Besides right after the war, I'm embarrassed to say that I don't know anything about South America during WWII. I'm all for this!
Even just a segment on Mexico or Brazil would be fascinating. On the Mexican side the air squadron that participated were extremely controversial because the very existence of the unit violated Mexican government policy but showcased just how willing the then Socialist government of Lazaro Cardenas was to its own principles, this is the age where you'd see bilingual slogans like "Americans All, Let's Fight for Freedom" or the song "Viva Mexico, Viva America". Back then Mexico was also the only country aside from the Soviet Union to willingly provide economic and military aid to the Spanish Republicans, going so far as to evacuate over 20,000 and the French president when Franco rose to power and the Nazis invaded France.
Epic as in the war could not have been won without them?
awesome video but i missed the mention of japans UNIT 731. That horrendous stuff they did should atleast have a mention imo.
We know about it no need to mention things already known
@@Gaminglife-sf1oz many dont know about it and even in japan its not really mentioned at all.
@@semiramisubw4864 pfft yeah right they already know it even in japan just look at kohei horikoshi's mha controversy on naming a character after an historical reference to WW2 Japan's involvement
@@Gaminglife-sf1ozwe know about ww2 no need to make any videos or media on it whatsoever
The video did mention it, though.
Your videos are amazing! You really should have more subs and you earnt one from me!
Plus, I would love to see a video on the Emu war in Australia that would be funny!
That would make amassing April fools video
I’m glad to see armchair historian make the Japanese side. Most history channels never do Japanese sides but mostly American German or Britain.
I agree. Any time someone mentions WWII, it’s always Allies vs Nazi’s but it’s called a WORLD war for a reason. Pacific was my favorite side definitely.
Yeah, it's annoying how most Americans know basically nothing about the war with Japan between Pearl harbor and the atomic bomb, which is largely because most overall war histories only talk about those two events plus maybe midway. It's a shame because I personally find it a much more interesting conflict.
Yeah, it's annoying how most Americans know basically nothing about the war with Japan between Pearl harbor and the atomic bomb, which is largely because most overall war histories only talk about those two events plus maybe midway. It's a shame because I personally find it a much more interesting conflict.
They hardly do the Soviet side when it was them who destroyed most German forces
@@JDDC-tq7qm true
Co-prosperity seems so outrageous when knowing what they really did.
It's a shame that the Japanese invasion of Manchuria and the Second Sino-Japanese War aren't talked about in western media
Basically the Fire Nation in a nutshell:
Stop being cringe
I mean, the Fire Nation was literally based on Japan.
Its crazy to think that in the short time Japan industrialized, they made such a large impact on countries around them, and against them
A record! The new video was taken down in FIVE MINUTES hopefully by him
Yep just saw the notification but it said the video was private
Worth noting early in WW2, Japan had one of the best Air forces worldwide. The US was forced to play catch-up after Pearl Harbor
Absolutely. One of my favorite topics to discuss at Air Force UPT (flight school) were the aviators of WWII. The Kido Butai had essentially housed the world's best pilots at the time, with the average Japanese pilot having many more flight hours than their Western counterpart.
It is also not a coincidence vast majority of aces in the war were either German or Japanese. The former had much easier foes (Soviets). The one day the Japanese fought Soviet air forces, a Japanese pilot got 11 kills in a day
Worth noting that the U.S. absolutely obliterated Japan in this war.
@charliewilson3390 yes but it took a while
@@charliewilson3390That’s why the OP said, *”early* in WW2
@@charliewilson3390your lack of reading comprehension is astounding
Nice video!!! Also I would love to see a video about Korean resistance fighters during ww2 , I fell like they get no mention in western history books.
Where is the video on the Western invasion of Asia and the US invasion of Hawaii?
To The Armchair Historian: could you do the subject relating to the Mexican American War, I feel like it’s an overlooked war in American history
Mishima’s novel ‘runaway horses’ provides great insight into the Japanese mind and psyche during the interwar period .
The battleship Mushashi should be "Musashi" instead.
Dan Carlin’s Supernova in the East podcast goes into great detail about the war from Japan’s view. Highly recommend the listen.
One of the best historical pieces I've ever listened to was Supernova in the East. It was also one of the hardest things iv ever listened to.
Here is a story. My father was acting in a college play about the history of my country. His club was playing about the atrocities and the savagery of the Japanese occupiers of my country. When this play is being played, the Japanese students stood up and scolded at my father's club saying that they were "tainting their history". The two groups of people did argue, but it was understandable seeing the Japanese don't admit to these atrocities during the 2nd World War. The funny part is the American college decided to stand at the Japanese students side and asked my father and his club to not include that in their play. Really weird.
Yep, after WW2 ended, The US were desperate to get any leeway on the USSR in preparation of the cold war. They decided to absolve Japan of their war crimes if they agree to support the US in the cold war. So it's understandable why they would support the Japanese students.
Ayo, that ain't no loli! I've been bamboozled...
@@DakotaofRaptors you what
@@DakotaofRaptors Why would troller lolion do this to us?
@@X-SPONGEDThe US didn't want to be countersued for their own warcrimes against Japan on an international level so they executed high profile Japanese officers & politicians before swiftly occupying the country. It's more nuanced than merely gaining leverage, the US didn't want to anger the Japanese people because they knew a guerilla war in Japan would be unwinnable. Same reason the emperor stayed alive; if only we applied the lessons we learned against Japan elsewhere in Asia the modern US military wouldn't be such a laughingstock.
A very refreshing video in that it focuses on Japan. It wouldve been more wonderful if an explanation had been given as to why democracy was developed and collapsed in Japan after WWI and how the latter relates to the West
There was also an attempted coup to prevent the Japanese surrender from being broadcast. Its a great example of the unwillingness to surrender.
It's an even better example that Japanese don't have some kind of hive mind like many seem to think they do.
Please, consider a video about the battle of khalkhin Gol, it's a very important battle that chaped ww2
As a Japanese, I would like to say that there is a minority of Japanese who do not recognize war crimes such as Nanking.
With right-wing Japanese forces (Netoyo) going around on the Internet claiming that Japan did not commit atrocities, and the lack of official apology by the Japanese government to Korea and China, there seems to be a growing trend in the West and in the US that Japanese people do not admit to war crimes. But we, the average Japanese, know of the war crimes committed by Japan and do not deny them. The government has not apologized, but it does not deny that there was a massacre.
It is sad that as Japanese people we are perceived as a people who do not acknowledge the past. I repeat, the majority of Japanese do admit to war crimes.
how do you know and decide which one is the majority and vice versa?
日本人として、それは認識している！ しかし、日本が東南アジアや中国にしてきたことは支持しない。 なんてひどい日本の戦犯なんだ...。
Even tho the average japanese solider fought for a strict Monarcho fascist military regime his average height was 5’3 and weight was 100 pounds he was ready to tear into the world and then some.
Smol men but much ferocity.
The sailors stationed in Hawaii were twice warned before the Pearl Harbor event happened, in 1934 when a R.Adm told CNO “hey this is real” and 1941 when early radar picked up hundreds of enemy planes a long time before, right before it happened
Gulf of tonkin, babies being gassed in Iraq, 9/11 things never change.
That's false, the usa wasn't even a top 5 military power until long after peak Harbour, they attacked Peralta Harbor Because us sanctions and blockades
@ollyx2 the fact you think these are inside jobs except for babies is crazy, you know iraq sent boys to be killed in war
8:05 Slight Error, you show Yamamoto with a full set of fingers, but he had actually lost 2 at the Battle of Tsushima.
Well yamamoto having full fingers is actually better lol. Imagine him without any fingers at all
Disappointed to not see Nanking called out specifically. More people need to know about that. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nanjing_Massacre
Ikr? Seems like a pretty big oversight.
the propaganda of US and other white, communists. made out of lie.
you never do not distribute those lie.
I would almost feel bad for the Japanese if it werent for the gruesome treatment they inflicted on civilians in conquered territory. At some point they went so far that even the nazi's were shocked by it.
Tbhf that was just only one nazi and the nazis in general wouldn't care about it infact the guy who help save many Chinese civilians in Nanking was said to be silent and arrest by the nazi SS or gestapo I not sure tho can't remember who silent and arrested but that's what happen for sure
It’s sad people remember the Japanese as suicidal banzai fanatics
Can you please make WW1 from the Italian perspective?🇮🇹
He already did
@@azatooth1 He made "Why was Italy ineffective?", but not the perspective.
Disappointing video that is far too biased towards the war against the Americans and the island hopping strategy. Only a relatively brief mention about the war in China, No mention about how the Soviets declared war on them and pushed south into Manchuria later in the war. Absolute no mention of the Burma campaign which saw some of the worst defeats of the Japanese army. No mention about the Japanese raids into the pacific ocean and how doing so caused the invasion of Madagascar. Yeah title is dishonest and should be called the pacific war and even then seems ore of a general overview rather then from a Japanese perspective.
Amazing video as always, I am filipino with japanese and american blood, and I find perspectives from both sides facisnating and amazing!
Mr worldwide.
Muggle
Like native American?
@@FrankGhal no irish or german
Another thing : before you put trust into your own Japanese education system, remember that
you live in a country that lionized and celebrated a serial killer Issei Sagawa.
That alone shows just how twisted your society is, as well as the thinking process of its citizens.
Japan's historical distortion, historical revisionism, is too absurd
Germany reflects on itself
Germany teaches history accurately
The Japanese should emulate Germany
Come to Korea and study
There is a lot of historical evidence
Every country has a dark history. That's one thing. Whether they are ashamed and regret the wrong doings in the past and not cover it up is another
the Asian Holocaust
the Asian Nazis
the slaughter of civilians
Japan should reflect on itself
Germany knows how to reflect on itself, but Japan doesn't
Japan denies everything
I always forget Japan had been fighting for almost a decade before the US entered the war
Can you please do WW2 from the Australian Perspective???
"We've had one warcrime, yes. But what about second warcrime?"
Japan, 1944.
Those Japanese soldiers were also brutalized into savages by their own indoctrination and punishment by their superiors
As always well made and highly educative video !!! I've always been interested in WWII history from the Japanese and Chinese perspective and you guys always make it so catchy! You just never disappoint me. Please keep them coming...
I’m glad you at least mentioned Gen. Kuribayashi. Easily one of the most honorable and intelligent Japanese generals of the war, with a very tragic story and fatal mission which he fought for to the end on Iwo Jima.
Do you not know what the he and his forces on Iwo Jima did to a POW? Hardly “honorable”. Very few in the Japanese military actually had any “honor”.
If you don’t know btw. Look up “Ralph Ignatowski”
@@thunderbird7020 are there very few truly honorable Japanese within the IJA and IJN aside from the well-known ones.
It’s surreal seeing the battle sites that still remain on Oki today. It’s part of what convinced me that some of that island that I was stationed on for 3 and a half years was haunted. I used to see all sorts of weird things when I was working night crew. That being said I loved the island and had a great time there.
Your not wrong sites like auchwitz are haunted but auchwitz has a strict no entry after dark rule because of how dangerous the ghosts are they are hostile and attack people.
My grandpa fought in ww2 on the side of japan as a pilot he was a good man I was sad to hear he die 11 months ago but hey I shouldn’t be dwelling on it. But he is now with grandma
According to my historian friend, history on WWII written by many Japanese historians depict the war drastically differently from how main stream historians depict the war.
There we were, just minding our own business when suddenly we were atomic bombed with no warning! (IOW, it’s self congratulatory fantasy writing).
@@p.strobus7569 no no, more like "we are destined to rule ASIA, we are the chosen one, we are the superior race therefore we will do war crimes and not get punished"
@@p.strobus7569wait weren’t they warned though? It was to my understanding that pamphlets were dropped to tell the citizens to gtfo before they were bombed, that’s what I was told anyway so I’m not a historian by any account so please tell me if I’m pulling this out of my ass or not
@@arandomvideoman3848 The pamphlets dropped before the atom bombing listed ten (IIRC) cities that were subject to destruction. The problem is that most people ignore those sort of thing. Caen was pamphleted twice after D-day and, with the sound of the guns on the beachhead clearly audible in the distance, the people didn’t leave.
軍から「パンフレットは読むな」と言われていたのもあります。無視せざるを得なかったのです。
That early intro with the rising sun's beams shining over Asia is so menacing but cool at the same time!
Japanese preferred to fight till the end
William Spaniel, Armchair Historian and Warographics in 1 hour. The analysis tools do be like that
My family knows I cry a lot at media, so they showed me some music video from Grave of the Fireflies and while its a sad story, its not an antiwar movie, its a "Dont join the Nazis" movie. Was really hard to get caught up in the emotions of it unless you think the Japanese were the victims of WW2. Sad movie, but my family doesnt get that I cry at bravery and self sacrifice, not traditionally sad things and its hard to feel bad for the Japanese the more you know about WW2. I told my family, just replace that Japanese boy with a Nazi boy and the little sister with a little Hitler youth camp brother, and see how bad you feel.
Japan at the end of WW2:
“My name is Azai, I’m ready to die, tenno heika banzai!”
Emperor Hirohito: "It's time to stop the war."
Azai: "This is what I sacrificed my life for?!"
Day 3 asking armchair historian to do the Chinese civil.
I feel like it should be noted again that the Japanese did try to pass a war declaration to the US about an hour before the attack. They were foiled by most of the staff being drunk and having gone home. Either way, they did try and I feel that is important to note
I've heard how horrified Yamamoto was when he heard his attack went ahead before the declaration.
Thats actually a myth
@@texmj123 It is not actually. That actually happened. Some time back I thought it was a myth too so I did some research on my own and found that it's actually true.
There was real possibility that if Japan had attacked Pearl Harbor when the carriers were docked and took out the fuel tanks then the Pacific War would have been prolonged by several years. They would have likely still lost but US would have had to divert resources from the European Theater and it does take time to built more aircraft carriers. After Japan lost it's aircraft carriers at the Battle of Midway it was pretty much game over.
@@stoda01 I 100% agree. Once the Japanese Navy got neutered at Midway it was just a matter of how long they could hold out and they knew it. They actually hoped for it by that point, they wanted the US to land on the home islands so they could make Iwo Jima look like a joke and convince the US that taking them out totally wasn't worth the lives they would lose
Interesting video...sad to see no mention at all of the fighting in Burma/India, with the battle of Imphal being the greatest Japanese loss up to that date (July 1944). I understand brevity is necessary, and due to the US not being involved, it's not that well known, but surely this is from the Japanese perspective. The fact the Japanese lost many of its men from starvation shows how poorly they were supplied.
What happened at Imphal?
@@Squitwort448 Japanese Army got stopped cold in its tracks and pretty much starved to death due to poor supply logistics.
@@Squitwort448 The Japanese attempted to invade India, but suffered about 55,000 casualties. It broke the back of the Japanese Army deployed in Burma and SE Asia. The battle was fought by British, Indian and Gurkha troops, against Japanese and some Indian troops.
If the Japanese had been successful, the American aid to China would have been cut off, allowing the Japanese access to more resources, allowing them to better resist US moves in the Pacific. Their defeat stopped them gaining access to a resource base.
@@Squitwort448the tides were turned in the burmese front in allies' favour
Well it’s hard to fit everything in a 20 minute video
Griff, love what you do! However, it's Musashi not Mushashi.
"If men can be convinced to fly a plane into a metal boat sacrificing himself because of their imagination and belief, so too can young boys be made to believe they can be young girls with just their imagination."
Good quote
0:11: 🌏 Japan's expansion during World War II and the complex factors behind it.
4:07: 🌍 Japan's expansion and militarization in East Asia and the Pacific during World War II.
8:16: 🌊 The events leading up to and including the Battle of Midway during World War II.
12:21: 💥 The Japanese military faced numerous challenges, including inter-service rivalries, material shortages, and superior firepower from the Allies, leading to their eventual defeat.
15:50: 💣 The Allied Forces closed in on Japan, leading to heavy casualties and the use of atomic bombs, ultimately resulting in Japan's surrender.
Recap by Tammy AI
Well done you guys should do a video on the Wager mercenaries, something like “Russia’s shortest civil war.”
I don't think that's enough to make a entire video
That is journalism and not history. We dont need another history channel going to modern events just for views.
Speaking about Russian civil war remember when the western allies intervene and lost to the Red Army of Lenin
well he could talk about the red and white russian during tsar nicholas reign
@@stc3145He's already done it before, so yea...
Please revisit the Spanish civil war! My great grandfather fought in it and I know surprisingly little about it, so I’d love to learn some family history!
I just wanted to add something, because the west condemned the atrocities committed by imperial Japan but these same countries had colonies in Africa and committed many atrocities as well ,so like, BRUH for them.
In fact, the idea behind Lebensraum was directly inspired by the American Manifest Destiny, so Germany's attempted expansion into the east was a manifestation of European-style colonialism on European soil.
European hypocrisy was omnipresent back in the day. At one point, Japan even asked for a treaty that recognized all races as equals. European nations, shockingly, declined because that would then mean they'd have to see their colonies as equal to themselves and that wouldn't do
rules for thee, not for me
This is revisionist horseshit. Comparing Nanjing or Manila to any American "war crime", especially during WW2, is absolutely laughable.
Interesting how this video never mentioned the fact that The Japanese Empire supported the Polish Government in exile after it was invaded by Germany (which it didn’t support, but neither did Italy)
Huh, Yamato and Musashi's names got butchered
I'd love to see WW2 from the Danish perspective.
Does anyone know the music playing from 9:12 to 12:12.
I love all these videos, so educational and interesting! Please keep making more ❤
Video idea: The Civil War from the slaves perspective.
I freaking love WWII Japanese content. Keep it coming for sure man
Mark Felton Productions has tons of great videos on WW2 era Japan.
E
It is important to stress what is noted at the beginning of the video. Japan was moving towards democracy in the 1920s. They curbed back on the expansionist policies that had preceded WWI. Moreover, the country implemented universal male suffrage, a multi party cabinet government, and expanded education. Japan was also a member of the League of Nations. However, all these efforts were undermined by the economic instability of the Great Depression. The crisis led to the rise of Ultranationalism and a shift back towards imperialistic views, allowing the military to take control of the government.
You and your team make some of the best content on UA-cam. Keep it up!
Japan didn't ignore the ultimatum but they were hoping to get some conditions. Ironically one of their main concerns (keeping the Emperor) would actually happen anyway.
Japan’s hand into World War II against the United States was forced once the United States cut off oil from them. With that being said, The country and military did many atrocious things to the countries that they invaded or attacked. And they paid for it in the end. 👍🏾
They were the worst. This why, even now, the neighbors whom they invaded and brutalized laugh at and then get royally pissed when Japan claims victimhood in WW2.
The US wouldn't have needed to cut off resources from Japan if didn't commit warcrimes in China.
The US cut off oil to get the Japanese to stop committing a genocide…
@@joseherrera2338
Not nearly.
If they’re playing the victim hood card, then why does Godzilla and Kamen Rider exist?
Those Japanese franchise always show their country’s war crimes which ironically where Chinese, Korean, and Filipino learn, especially Unit 731.
It’s those franchise that pisses off the Japanese ultranationalists.
That wasn't even forced. The embargo was put in place due to Japan's aggressive expansion harming American lend lease in the region, and would have been lifted if Japan pulled out. The last time Imperial Japan was a victim was the Washington Naval Treaty, every bad thing that happened to them after that was self inflicted.
Imho their empire could have been bigger before WW2 as well as during it, but they were doomed to lose to USA/USSR.
Next up:
WW2 From the British Perspective
WW2 From the American Perspective
WW2 From the Soviet Perspective
WW2 From the Italian Perspective
WW2 From the French Perspective
And maybe even WW2 From the Canadian Perspective 😍
Ww2 finnish perspective is already done
@@danlomanalo4161 You are correct, I shall amend my comment.
@@MrXenon1994 oh don't. Its actually fine if you are new to the channel. Anyways have a nice day exploring the channel! 😃
@@MrXenon1994 but it woukd actually be nice if they did a Winter war from simo hayha's perspective
@@danlomanalo4161 As someone with Finnish roots myself, I did a quick UA-cam search of this channel from WW2 perspectives and I didn't see the Finnish one lol! I saw your comment and did a more specific search and sure enough, somehow I found it. So I did ament my comment, still looking forward to the other ones.
I would like to see an episode made about my awesome country. As reward, I will send you a pleasure squad. 😘