Ok, but Reacher is effectively immortal. He can only die of old age, because the author is too predisposed to making him a surrogate for who he wishes he was. This is not to say that the show isn't fun as hell, but my god the books are baaaaaad.
That is part of why he would get killed by them in a street fight or a gun fight or a weapons fight. The WRITERS of Reacher were trying to make him stronger and tougher than most people maybe bordering on "peak human" but NOT off the charts super human like the other 3 in this video. In some of his fights he got hurt and his opponents put up a somewhat decent fight before he took them down and he was never tested (so far maybe season 3?) against REALLY HARD opponents as the others were. He is basically beating up punks and thugs. The ONLY advantage he has over the others is size and strength and due to them all being pretty strong its not as big an advantage as he would have against a regular person the "gap" is smaller.
@Zurround Clancy actually wrote an insane character in Reacher unfortunately this is not the book adaptation it should be. Edit: I read these books back in middle and high school. Im now closing on 30yrs old. So that was around 10-12 yrs ago. I remember some incredibly brutal sequences that would've landed both men well into Tyler Rake levels of lethality. Without Remorse in particular was a wild ride. Regardless the point is that was a while back and memory isn't perfect. 2nd Edit: yes yes lee child
@@Henesie-yf6ty Reminds me of Jean Claude Van Damme's friend Raymond Jackson in the late 1980s action movie BLOODSPORT. In the movie the main villain, Chong Li did what should have been a fatal stomp on his head but he survived (but got knocked unconscious and had to be hospitalized) due to having an abnormally thick skull.
I had Wick winning from the moment I read the title. Got a lil worried at points that that wouldn’t be the case tho lol. My reasoning was “Wick has taken down these dudes’ equivalents in his own movies already.” And I honestly forgot about him falling off the building. Dude has some left over Neo powers.
@@KiwiOfTruth1880 we see some of that in the show especially when he lays things out and talks but reacher is usually just brawling to win fights thatd be much easier for him realistically
The numbers do not lie. The four John Wick movies took place over a week...and amassed HUNDREDS of kills, most of which have the same specs as the other three contestants..and still wins. And that one week takes place after being retired for some time, and all the history of Wicks skill before retirement. Baba Yaga wins.
If it took place during a week how does his hair go from short to long to long to shorter. Just something I've noticed that bothers me because it is SUPPOSED TO take place during a week
John wick ppl forget this is John wick outta his prime do the movies he said to be in his mid sixties early seventies Keanu himself being 59 Imagine how op prime wick would be
Well in the original “Scorn” screenplay, John Wick is meant to be a long retired assassin in his mid 60’s & super attached to his elderly dog who is killed by Iosef immediately following his wife’s funeral, thus dragging him back into the FAFO game. Keanu obviously had a strong influence on the plot & overall franchise, hence changing the films name from “Scorn” to “John Wick” cuz that’s what he kept calling the 1st movie & it stuck like superglue.
John wick was suppose to be in the newest mk game but it got dropped because keanu said he didnt see john wick being in mk and didnt wanr to be fatalitied
People has been sleeping on Jack Reacher since season 1 and after season 2 .That guy is too legendary, he's the combination of brains and brawn. Big as hell , Strong and Smart also Brutal too.
@@kanielabarcai6182 Of the 4 men in this video he is the LEAST likely to win a fist fight because in a fight SPEED is the most important thing. Strength may play a factor and he is the strongest and he would crush me like a bug but being that they ALL are pretty damned strong the GAP in strength between him and the others is not as extreme as it is for most of the punks Reacher throws around and being the SLOWEST of the 4 he is the least likely to win a fight. The human body is delicate and the faster 3 all know just what pressure points to aim for.
The overall winner will probably be John Wick...but my favorite one here has got to be Deckard Shaw (I mean, it's Jason Statham...that guy evaporates badass vibes just by walking!)
Honestly, I think Tyler Rake can take this. Yes, John Wick is hard to beat in a shootout but if anyone can do it, it's him. And I think an unarmed fight would come down between Shaw and Rake
I rank Reacher dead last in fist fight because SPEED is so much more important than STRENGTH and of the 4 he is the slowest, probably because the ACTOR could only move so fast with his big bulky body and possibly no training and that was the best they could do filming his scenes. The BOOKS the show is based on might have him faster.
@@Zurroundthe main difference is the fact that reacher isn’t even from a mainly action show it’s a mystery show that’s why he doesn’t compare but at the same time it’s impressive af
As much as I love John Wick’s fighting and shooting abilities I have to go with Tyler Rake, he’s tall, strong and can shoot and fight all at the same time. He is just a master at what he does.
Agreed, Wick vs Beekeeper would be very interesting, Dude literally took on everyone in America & won including Police, Mercenaries, Assassins, FBI, CIA & Secret Service😂
@@hunterkenway6212 LoL Wick took out Death Squads made up of Special Ops Guys tactically 1 by 1 meanwhile Beekeeper over here walking in the middle of a Special Ops Team casually shit talking them and then starts just dismantling them like they some back alley Thugs with no Combat Training at all. xD
I think if I'm honest the fight between the four would be very inconclusive since all four are all highly trained & show a great mix of close-quarters combat, stealth, durability & training. Personally, I think in this fight Reacher's tactical prowess is also a factor that is underestimated as Reacher was an accomplished Major in the US Army. He can identify others fighting styles and find a capable counter for them in the moment as we saw in series 1 of the Amazon series where he identified a South American special forces fighting style.
John's whole shtick is dominating the world's best killers and assassins in a world composed of killers and assassins. I admit in a hand to hand fight he is probably screwed but, with guns he if far more than capable enough to win.
Yeah. We even see him lose a few hand to hand fights. He is good, but not as good at close rang as some of the others. He easily wins a gin fight though
There's one thing that wasn't mentioned though. Reacher has an ability to prep a battlefield that the other 3 don't possess, and a highly tactical mindset that wasn't really touched on. His job in the military was to hunt down and capture or eliminate Spec Ops soldiers, arguably the best in the world at disappearing, and he was able to do that through keen investigative skills and tactical knowledge. He's kinda like Batman in that regard. I'm not saying that it would change the outcome, but it's definitely worth mentioning.
Prep is an interesting point. Arguably shaw is just as good as reacher in that area by feats. John and rake dont have prep feats cause everywhere they go they have no idea who or what is waiting for them. If given the chance i think all of these characters would be even in this area
Dude shaw is some character fast n furious just threw in because they ran out of their action movie ideas.. only one who is being truly considered here is Wick against Reacher and if we talking physical + skills... Reacher hands down.@@AbdulAzeez-up4nw
@@getemguapo_tv what kind of argument is that? It doesnt matter why shaw was added in . This is a fight between characters so u use their feats to see who wins and shaw is as tactical as reacher if not more and he has shown this multiple times. As for john vs reacher purely hand to hand would probably go to reacher only because he is bigger and muscular. John has beaten bigger muscular dudes before but always using weapons when he fights without weapons he struggles against the bigger fighters. But ofc if john has any weapon in his hand then reacher is dead
Jason Bourne, John Wick, James Bond, Equalizer, Jack Reacher, Tyler Rake, Decard Shaw, Batman, Bruce Lee, Agent 47, Beekeeper and Punisher all are put into the hunger games wth all their weapons. It would be the greatest battle in history. Who wins?
@@aldrichaguilar2295we’ll use Christian bale’s Batman just cause he’s the most realistic while also being decently above a average human. We’ll use Netflix punisher as well since comic book punisher and Batman are too OP
Achilles is the best fighter with Maximus right behind him. Leonidas is a better leader and probably takes the physical attributes in this. I love Wallace and all but he just isn’t as good of a fighter compared to the others
well, two of them have the power of fictional plot armor while the other two have the power of realistic plot armor. so i would say it depends on whos making the movie or script or whatever that would pit all four of them against each other
I pretty much agree with you Dan but here's my take. Random encounter in the middle of a city John takes it with ease. If Tyler can get some prep time a la Batman. He's going to snipe everybody and it'll be over before it can start. If we're in say a Russian bathhouse no one has weapons every man for himself Shaw's going to take it. If someone from 110th is murdered or framed Reacher putting everybody in the ground. Overall John is definitely going to win because he's the most suited for any random situation but it's mentioned above there are going to be very specific times when he's getting rocked.
Should've made it Beekeeper. Thought the movie would be a joke but honestly one of his better movies tbh in terms of pure action and world building. I kinda hated the girl who looked sexy with a gun but never used it and knew exactly what he was doing and why but still wanted to stop him cause of "Law"
Robert would lose without prep time. I love him but he's never beaten anyone we've seen on the level of these guys. Most of the people he's beaten are average CIA ops or average gangsters for hire.
@@H.K.5 Deckard Shaw took on a Super Solider. John Wick beat two ninjas at the same time and a death squad of assassins after more devastating injuries. I love Robert but he ain't Wick
Wick is fighting the world to just get out and retired/retirement Shaw is like a hornet on cocaine, attacking everything that moves Reacher is a bomb tank that is trying to end the war Rake is the desperado bodyguard keeping the threat away or dead ...in the end they all end up like "Nobody"
It's coming down to Deckard Shaw or John Wick and if it is the final fight ends up being hand to hand my money is on Deckard Shaw 1000% but in the more likely scenario that weapons guns and environmental awareness is involved involved I think John wick takes it
When your playing a badass fighter in a movie, of course your going to gain some real life fighting skill. But when you've tirelessly put in so much work into your character that your own stuntboss/choreographer says that you've gone so far beyond acting that you're a real life threat/dangerous man, then you know the other challengers in this video stand no chance. Im of course talking about Keanu Reaves/John Wick.
@@jasonturner4269 He might also beat anyone Wick has beaten but against John Wick himself my money is on John, but it would not be an easy victory for him.
@@rayvonvelez3129 the less said the BETTER 😅 The South African guy in the yellow vest 🦺 seemed like a Neil blomkamp character. Like he'd be in hippo's gang
John Wicks immunity to injury is over the top. Almost turns the movies into SciFi. You can’t get hit by cars and fall like he does and walk away. It’s too much. Reacher all the way.
What a great video. What a great comparison. I do agree that John Wick would probably win it all. The numbers listed for John Wicks, do not include the people before he went into retirement. As for Reacher, are you going to include the Tom Cruise movies in those numbers? He did some pretty awful things in those movies.
That's a really great one. Honestly I think a prime levi is bodying everyone lol Him getting ambushed by Kenny and the scenes after are still my favorite if aot
John wick shouldn't even be on this list he not fair. He label as "human" but except maybe the first movie he's not. He is 100% not. I know in movies there the rule of suspension of belief but John takes that to a whole new level in his movies especially his sequels. Like look how the third movie ends. After having non-stop attacks since the first movie less than 3 weeks. He falls off a building hitting multiple mental bars and lives. Black widow (who lives in a superhero comic book world) goes through 25% that in her movie and everyone like "it makes no sense". There a super bais with John Wick. You got to stop putting him on these list. It unfair.
Strength= Tyler Rake (he ripped that guys hand open),, Jack Reacher (headbutted and broke the guys elbow), but cant beat Rakes'... Speed = Unless you Chinese, You can't be faster than Deckard Durability = Rake (got shot and cut a few time,, even caught a bullet to the neck),,, John Wick (Got shot at, knifed, hit by the car, thrown into glass, ate punches from giants,, Fell from a back, neck, waist breaking, and head busting building and could still say "yea"),,, so wick takes it Stamina = Tyler Rake (the oner) Agility = Deckard shaw Accuracy= Wick Guns= Wick Dangerous = Wick Body-count= Wick Experience = Wick Brutality = Wick Wick is the guy they all wanna be
Umm shaw has shown to have more weopons than the dam military hes also known on the most wanted hit list in his series and was a ghost till they got gods eyes, meaning he was off grid despite the tech those guys have Experience could also go for both since Shaw also has fought many people with less effort than john. Or he plans it out and it just works
It depends on where they fight or if it was with no weapons or with weapons If it comes to H2H I would either say Shaw due to skills or jack reacher due to his strength and size if it was a gun fight it’s either wick or rake but I’m going with wick due to him being more skilled with guns if it was a prep time battle Shaw might win If the fight takes place in a house Tyler rake wins mid to high diff unless if wick gets the drop on rake If the fight is at stairs John wick extreme diff If the fight is at a forest it’s either Shaw or rake
giving rake gun fight over wick is crazy but that's your opinion tho, rake is a beast but only had a little taste of what John had to go through in his entire movie franchise
The most trash takes I've ever seen. H2H/physical combat, Wick beats everyone here. Size has nothing to do with it, and Wick is more durable than Shaw, as well as having more/better feats. Gun fight/CQC with weapons is Wick for anyone with half a brain. Prep time is rightfully Shaw. In a house, because of lack of context, would go to Shaw because of superior arsenal. Stairs fight is meme-worthy. Forest fight probably goes to Rake.
@@jesuschrist7645 biggest cap in my existence jack reacher broke a man leg easily John H2H sucks so reacher wins if you wanna argue with me then I would say this Thomas Shelby > John wick John wick > Thomas Shelby
I say we have to split them in different categories and compare thier points overall in the end. Strength and power: Rake, Reacher, Shaw, Wick Speed and agility: Shaw, Rake, Wick, Reacher Durability and endurance: Wick, Rake, Shaw, Reacher Skills and intellect: Shaw, Rake, Wick, Reacher Combat skills and martial arts: Shaw, Rake, Wick, Reacher Guns, Accuracy and precision: Wick, Rake, Shaw, Reacher Overall, if its close quarters combat, Shaw should come on top. But if its a gunfight then wick should be first.
@@issasaadiq794hes not lacking in either, speed and ability plus power is what makes a difference in the fight when you guys are dam near just as skilled as each other
Why stop with just these four? Let's throw in Bryan Mills from Taken, Robert McCall from The Equalizer, Black Widow from the MCU, Shaft, Hutch Mansell from Nobody, Riley North from Peppermint, Anna from The Protégé, Machete and the world's most greatest and famous secret agent... Johnny English.
John Wick wins mid difficulty. Tyler Rake is a good second. Jack Reacher might be the best hand to hand fighter but that would mean nothing in this 4 way gun fight. Decard Shaw isn’t even a factor here. John Wick wins with minor cuts and bruises (almost all given by Tyler Rake).
While I know John will win and voted John, I got to say you got it all wrong, Decard will be his biggest problem mainly because of his Deadpool personality that leads him to do unpredictable shyt. He'll find some way to do incredible damage on John but that'll only happen if he's able to make it to that round. Most likely he would because Tyler and John would be going after eachother while they leave decard to beat down Jack, which decard wouldn't really have a struggle with.
Idk man Deckard is a wild card. What makes him so special is he's not afraid to cheat in a fight. He’ll literally throw a bomb at you. At the very least, Shaw beats Reacher.
Forget them going against each other, can you imagine the carnage in a crossover movie of them teaming up!!! Now that is a movie I'd pay good money to see!!!
People in this fukin comment section all underestimate John Wick. Look like they are Family guys and MARVEL fanboys Marines/ SEALs >>> British and Australian special services combines.
In any kind of gunfight, Deckard Shaw and John Wick and Tyler take it. hand to hand, is where it gets harder for everyone all of these guys are excellent in hand to hand.
John Wick: 442 kills (+3 men in a bar with a pencil)
Jack Reacher: 52 kills
Tyler Rake: 126 kills
Deckard Shaw: 75 kills
A f***** pencil
Let’s also add that this was over the course of a few days💀💀💀
Don’t forget the people he killed before retiring and his last job
How accurate are those numbers because it sounds accurate
Ok, but Reacher is effectively immortal. He can only die of old age, because the author is too predisposed to making him a surrogate for who he wishes he was. This is not to say that the show isn't fun as hell, but my god the books are baaaaaad.
I honestly feel bad for reacher. Despite some superhumman showings in the second season he is the most grounded to real earth of all of them.
That is part of why he would get killed by them in a street fight or a gun fight or a weapons fight. The WRITERS of Reacher were trying to make him stronger and tougher than most people maybe bordering on "peak human" but NOT off the charts super human like the other 3 in this video. In some of his fights he got hurt and his opponents put up a somewhat decent fight before he took them down and he was never tested (so far maybe season 3?) against REALLY HARD opponents as the others were. He is basically beating up punks and thugs. The ONLY advantage he has over the others is size and strength and due to them all being pretty strong its not as big an advantage as he would have against a regular person the "gap" is smaller.
@Zurround Clancy actually wrote an insane character in Reacher unfortunately this is not the book adaptation it should be.
Edit: I read these books back in middle and high school. Im now closing on 30yrs old. So that was around 10-12 yrs ago. I remember some incredibly brutal sequences that would've landed both men well into Tyler Rake levels of lethality. Without Remorse in particular was a wild ride. Regardless the point is that was a while back and memory isn't perfect.
2nd Edit: yes yes lee child
insane how? @@IDirtyMangoI
Reacher was told that his skull is as think as a neadrathals which was the only reason he didn’t die in one book I think the second or third
@@Henesie-yf6ty Reminds me of Jean Claude Van Damme's friend Raymond Jackson in the late 1980s action movie BLOODSPORT. In the movie the main villain, Chong Li did what should have been a fatal stomp on his head but he survived (but got knocked unconscious and had to be hospitalized) due to having an abnormally thick skull.
I had Wick winning from the moment I read the title.
Got a lil worried at points that that wouldn’t be the case tho lol.
My reasoning was “Wick has taken down these dudes’ equivalents in his own movies already.”
And I honestly forgot about him falling off the building.
Dude has some left over Neo powers.
Neo John wick he he
Reacher got did dirty, I've read his books and he is a lot more than just punching. He knows everyone's weaknesses by talking to them.
@@KiwiOfTruth1880 we see some of that in the show especially when he lays things out and talks but reacher is usually just brawling to win fights thatd be much easier for him realistically
he hasnt though. and Wicks greatest asset is plot armor. He could be killed by a sniper with very low difficulty
Horrible lack of diversity in this list.
Terrible.
This is 2024!
The numbers do not lie. The four John Wick movies took place over a week...and amassed HUNDREDS of kills, most of which have the same specs as the other three contestants..and still wins. And that one week takes place after being retired for some time, and all the history of Wicks skill before retirement. Baba Yaga wins.
If it took place during a week how does his hair go from short to long to long to shorter. Just something I've noticed that bothers me because it is SUPPOSED TO take place during a week
First 3 movies take place over the course of 1-2 weeks. 4 takes place ~6-8 months after 3.
I was about to say that if I hadn't seen yours@@MISSING-4O4-
JW 1-3 is 2-3 weeks, JW4 takes place like 6 months after JW3
No the first 3 took place around 2 weeks and the 4th one too place from months to a year after the events of 3
John wick ppl forget this is John wick outta his prime do the movies he said to be in his mid sixties early seventies
Keanu himself being 59
Imagine how op prime wick would be
Dude fr, so many people miss that point
John Wick is like twice their age
He's roughly 50 in the movies that has been confirmed. Not in his prime but nowhere near 60s or 70s
60s or 70s? What? Late 40s or early 50s
Well in the original “Scorn” screenplay, John Wick is meant to be a long retired assassin in his mid 60’s & super attached to his elderly dog who is killed by Iosef immediately following his wife’s funeral, thus dragging him back into the FAFO game. Keanu obviously had a strong influence on the plot & overall franchise, hence changing the films name from “Scorn” to “John Wick” cuz that’s what he kept calling the 1st movie & it stuck like superglue.
Tyler Rake is a monster. I can rewatch his movies over and over.
i watched both the Extraction movies with a lady friend back in August and by the end of the 2nd movie she was googling to see if there is a 3rd movie
It will be @@TheFirstInjun
I respect Cris hemsworth performance but in this race John wick take the easily
the scene in the second movie that is just one 21 minute one take of Tyler brutalizing any and all enemies in his way is just peak cinema.
I have never found someone so relatable.
We need them all as Mortal Kobmat characters.
What about Batman?
For real!
John wick was suppose to be in the newest mk game but it got dropped because keanu said he didnt see john wick being in mk and didnt wanr to be fatalitied
Netflix's Punisher would also be a perfect fit for this list 🔥
That's what I'm sayin
How about Yujiro Hanma
@@NDSTRUCTIBLE1 a person that can wrestle that can tank a nuke and wrestle with hundred ton monsters vs these guys, real fair lol
A better fit than shaw.
Yo Jason Bourne don’t ring a bell at all?
People has been sleeping on Jack Reacher since season 1 and after season 2 .That guy is too legendary, he's the combination of brains and brawn. Big as hell , Strong and Smart also Brutal too.
He almost died in a pool from a no trained mama's boy
GREAT 👌👌👌 DANCO EXCELLENT WORK.
@@samuraiblack8840 huh?
Tbh yes Jack reacher is strong and smart but we mostly see him fight a bunch of nobodies
@@kanielabarcai6182 Of the 4 men in this video he is the LEAST likely to win a fist fight because in a fight SPEED is the most important thing. Strength may play a factor and he is the strongest and he would crush me like a bug but being that they ALL are pretty damned strong the GAP in strength between him and the others is not as extreme as it is for most of the punks Reacher throws around and being the SLOWEST of the 4 he is the least likely to win a fight. The human body is delicate and the faster 3 all know just what pressure points to aim for.
The close combat scenes in both extraction movies are amazing
He killed me with the family force 😂
Frrr
They should all team up and make a movie.
Amen and The Equalizer should be their “handler”.
The overall winner will probably be John Wick...but my favorite one here has got to be Deckard Shaw (I mean, it's Jason Statham...that guy evaporates badass vibes just by walking!)
Deckard shaw wins for me personally hands down
@@jrjunior8468 Same
Don’t rate statham at all against the others
Winner fights the final boss, The Equalizer.
@@dalegallacher7074 You mean Keanu Reeves is significantly stronger and fitter than Jason Statham.... Man, people take films much too seriously.
Honestly, I think Tyler Rake can take this. Yes, John Wick is hard to beat in a shootout but if anyone can do it, it's him. And I think an unarmed fight would come down between Shaw and Rake
I rank Reacher dead last in fist fight because SPEED is so much more important than STRENGTH and of the 4 he is the slowest, probably because the ACTOR could only move so fast with his big bulky body and possibly no training and that was the best they could do filming his scenes. The BOOKS the show is based on might have him faster.
@@Zurroundthe main difference is the fact that reacher isn’t even from a mainly action show it’s a mystery show that’s why he doesn’t compare but at the same time it’s impressive af
No unarmed would be John in there too John can literally match and beat ninjas in h2h while already injured and tired
As much as I love John Wick’s fighting and shooting abilities I have to go with Tyler Rake, he’s tall, strong and can shoot and fight all at the same time. He is just a master at what he does.
I completely disagree
Jason Statham as the Beekeeper is honestly a great match for Baba Yaga!!
Agreed
Agreed, Wick vs Beekeeper would be very interesting,
Dude literally took on everyone in America & won including Police, Mercenaries, Assassins, FBI, CIA & Secret Service😂
Bro hell no lmaoo
@@hunterkenway6212 LoL Wick took out Death Squads made up of Special Ops Guys tactically 1 by 1 meanwhile Beekeeper over here walking in the middle of a Special Ops Team casually shit talking them and then starts just dismantling them like they some back alley Thugs with no Combat Training at all. xD
I think the legend of Wick is just too much.
I think if I'm honest the fight between the four would be very inconclusive since all four are all highly trained & show a great mix of close-quarters combat, stealth, durability & training. Personally, I think in this fight Reacher's tactical prowess is also a factor that is underestimated as Reacher was an accomplished Major in the US Army. He can identify others fighting styles and find a capable counter for them in the moment as we saw in series 1 of the Amazon series where he identified a South American special forces fighting style.
Jason Bourne (Bourne Franchise) vs Christian Wolff (The Accountant)
I think Jason Bourne is the best...
They would have so much fun making that movie
It would be Jason Bourne, he would win.
Yujiro or Baki
James bond
Finally a really good narrow showdown, also have a look at reacher s1 and 2 its very good
Instead of Shawl I would have put his character from the beekeeper
This!
John's whole shtick is dominating the world's best killers and assassins in a world composed of killers and assassins. I admit in a hand to hand fight he is probably screwed but, with guns he if far more than capable enough to win.
Not against Shaw
He beat people with hands , knives and guns lots of guns
@@jacobharris954 i ment to say specifically against rake and shaw. Vs reacher he actually has a chance in hand to hand.
Yeah. We even see him lose a few hand to hand fights. He is good, but not as good at close rang as some of the others. He easily wins a gin fight though
Spoiler alert....
The Goat Wins 🏆
Mr Wick
There's one thing that wasn't mentioned though. Reacher has an ability to prep a battlefield that the other 3 don't possess, and a highly tactical mindset that wasn't really touched on. His job in the military was to hunt down and capture or eliminate Spec Ops soldiers, arguably the best in the world at disappearing, and he was able to do that through keen investigative skills and tactical knowledge. He's kinda like Batman in that regard. I'm not saying that it would change the outcome, but it's definitely worth mentioning.
seriously they sleeping on reacher. Wick is a beast but idk if he can seriously handle Reacher
Prep is an interesting point. Arguably shaw is just as good as reacher in that area by feats. John and rake dont have prep feats cause everywhere they go they have no idea who or what is waiting for them. If given the chance i think all of these characters would be even in this area
Dude shaw is some character fast n furious just threw in because they ran out of their action movie ideas.. only one who is being truly considered here is Wick against Reacher and if we talking physical + skills... Reacher hands down.@@AbdulAzeez-up4nw
@@getemguapo_tv what kind of argument is that? It doesnt matter why shaw was added in . This is a fight between characters so u use their feats to see who wins and shaw is as tactical as reacher if not more and he has shown this multiple times. As for john vs reacher purely hand to hand would probably go to reacher only because he is bigger and muscular. John has beaten bigger muscular dudes before but always using weapons when he fights without weapons he struggles against the bigger fighters. But ofc if john has any weapon in his hand then reacher is dead
Shaw is trash bro simple@@AbdulAzeez-up4nw
Would anything change if you add Agent 47 on the list? I feel like he's top tier in all aspect. Stealth, hand-hand combat, guns, assassinations, etc
Even has a regen enhancement he would definatly take the victory
Wick has beaten all the best of the worlds assassins, apart from 47, it would be a balanced fight.
They'd probably look at each other and say: What about we just sit down and have some beers. 😁
Jason Bourne, John Wick, James Bond, Equalizer, Jack Reacher, Tyler Rake, Decard Shaw, Batman, Bruce Lee, Agent 47, Beekeeper and Punisher all are put into the hunger games wth all their weapons. It would be the greatest battle in history. Who wins?
In that case it would take the entire world's army to just stand stand chance against them, and most likely not one soilder will survive the slaughter
The Battle will Remain as Agent 47 vs Batman... Both are Superhuman (Depends on Batman Version you use)
@@aldrichaguilar2295we’ll use Christian bale’s Batman just cause he’s the most realistic while also being decently above a average human. We’ll use Netflix punisher as well since comic book punisher and Batman are too OP
Batman, obviously.
Can you do Achilles (Troy) vs Leonidas (300) vs Maximus (Gladiator) vs William Wallace (Braveheart)
Pretty please
Achilles should win this. He has a cheat code.
Maximus was just a great fighter, Leonidas is also a great fighter, dunno who the other dude is. But Achilles would likely win
Achilles is the best fighter with Maximus right behind him. Leonidas is a better leader and probably takes the physical attributes in this. I love Wallace and all but he just isn’t as good of a fighter compared to the others
@@Just_a_Piano_ did you say you don't know who William Wallace is?
@@millennium677 yes, yes i did
well, two of them have the power of fictional plot armor while the other two have the power of realistic plot armor. so i would say it depends on whos making the movie or script or whatever that would pit all four of them against each other
I pretty much agree with you Dan but here's my take.
Random encounter in the middle of a city John takes it with ease.
If Tyler can get some prep time a la Batman. He's going to snipe everybody and it'll be over before it can start.
If we're in say a Russian bathhouse no one has weapons every man for himself Shaw's going to take it.
If someone from 110th is murdered or framed Reacher putting everybody in the ground.
Overall John is definitely going to win because he's the most suited for any random situation but it's mentioned above there are going to be very specific times when he's getting rocked.
The winner gets the honour of being destroyed by the equilizer...
Let's goo Robert McCall 💪🏽
Just said that
Probably true lol
(Sets watch timer.)
Then Bourne calls to tell McCall his time is up just as he snipes him from the building across the city🤣🤣🤣
Thanks, Dan! Thoughtful as always!
Holy shit this is the exact video I’ve been wanting. Me and my brother have been having this exact discussion for months.
9:50 "just a bunch of bald dudes going at it..." 😂😂😂😂
That had me rolling 😂
Should've made it Beekeeper. Thought the movie would be a joke but honestly one of his better movies tbh in terms of pure action and world building. I kinda hated the girl who looked sexy with a gun but never used it and knew exactly what he was doing and why but still wanted to stop him cause of "Law"
John Wick. Most op unrealistic "human" character ever.
Batman?
@@TheProphesor Yes if we are including comic characters. Than definitely yes.
at this point, hes basically the deadpool of his verse
Who said he was just a "human"?
@@gofoatsfr bros has hit all criteria to be a superhero:
- Orphan (i googled it he is)
- Tragic backstory
- Powers?
- Plot armor
I would absolutely love it if Extraction 3 ended with Tyler Rake sliding a gold coin across a counter for some kind of good/service!..
I asked you to include Reacher and here he is. Thank you Danco. We just need some Blue Eye Samurai on the channel.
Ok, mister narcissist.
Definitely John Wick For Me No Doubt 💯
💀💀
I am so tired of him using John Wick he shouldn't count his basically superhuman.
@@theinsurance2450the power of plot armour
Robert McCall from The Equalizer should definitely be in this line up.
And Jason Borne.
Robert would lose without prep time. I love him but he's never beaten anyone we've seen on the level of these guys. Most of the people he's beaten are average CIA ops or average gangsters for hire.
And Jason Bourne
@@zaiah9252 None of these guys have beaten anyone on Robert’s level so you can’t really use that logic.
@@H.K.5 Deckard Shaw took on a Super Solider. John Wick beat two ninjas at the same time and a death squad of assassins after more devastating injuries. I love Robert but he ain't Wick
Bryan Mills (Taken) vs Robert McCall (Equalizer)
Wick is fighting the world to just get out and retired/retirement
Shaw is like a hornet on cocaine, attacking everything that moves
Reacher is a bomb tank that is trying to end the war
Rake is the desperado bodyguard keeping the threat away or dead
...in the end they all end up like "Nobody"
It's coming down to Deckard Shaw or John Wick and if it is the final fight ends up being hand to hand my money is on Deckard Shaw 1000% but in the more likely scenario that weapons guns and environmental awareness is involved involved I think John wick takes it
When your playing a badass fighter in a movie, of course your going to gain some real life fighting skill.
But when you've tirelessly put in so much work into your character that your own stuntboss/choreographer says that you've gone so far beyond acting that you're a real life threat/dangerous man, then you know the other challengers in this video stand no chance. Im of course talking about Keanu Reaves/John Wick.
None of these guys would last more than a movie in the John wick franchise
none of them would even last the first 5 minutes, he's 2x's as strong and fast as any of them and has YEARS more experience than all of them.
@@michaelgamble2848I wouldn't say strong but everything else I agree
Tyler Rake would clear the John Wick universe
@@jasonturner4269 He might also beat anyone Wick has beaten but against John Wick himself my money is on John, but it would not be an easy victory for him.
Shaw would easily clear
After watching the Beekeeper i think Mr.Clay would take the dub if he was included
Take the what?
@@RRSmurf haha you must be old lmao it means win short for W
I can only assume your keyboard is missing some letters.
@@RRSmurf ummm no there is no error in that comment lmao you must be way too old to understand a modern slang term
@@RRSmurf ohhh sorry I’m assuming you don’t know what lmao means it’s another modern term meaning laugh my ass off
EVERYONE needs to go see _the bee keeper_ immediately.
Was it really that good?
@@elijahalbiston ok the op was a bit dramatic but the urgency is bc I want ppl to see it before it flops out of theaters
It was ridiculous fun. But it was fun. I did not see him taking on the entire US government in that film 😭😭
@@rayvonvelez3129 the less said the BETTER 😅
The South African guy in the yellow vest 🦺 seemed like a Neil blomkamp character. Like he'd be in hippo's gang
Very good video, you fleshed out each character very well
shaw is the least durable because he got shot two times and was knocked out while everyone else can take a lot more
He also took a lot of punches from an enhanced cyborg
John Wicks immunity to injury is over the top. Almost turns the movies into SciFi. You can’t get hit by cars and fall like he does and walk away. It’s too much.
Reacher all the way.
This should be the new cast of the Expendables.
What a great video. What a great comparison. I do agree that John Wick would probably win it all. The numbers listed for John Wicks, do not include the people before he went into retirement. As for Reacher, are you going to include the Tom Cruise movies in those numbers? He did some pretty awful things in those movies.
Best "W vs X vs Y vs Z". And you got it right with John Wick, Tyler Rake, Deckard Shaw and Jack Reacher... Kudos!
03:14 Man: "He's more of a grappler" but throws in "Judo" and "Jiu-Jitsu"
Mikasa Ackerman vs. Levi Ackerman vs. Kenny Ackerman
That's a good one.
That's a really great one. Honestly I think a prime levi is bodying everyone lol Him getting ambushed by Kenny and the scenes after are still my favorite if aot
Who the fuck is that?
John Wick is the only true and Undisputed Baba Yaga
John wick win 100%
Because he op and not realistic human at all.
I agree
No not john because just one slap of hammer of THOR John is dead😂
@@Relax-lh7ueThis has nothing to do with Thor, so why does that matter
You should do one with John Reese (Person of Interest), Michael Weston (Burn Notice), and Eliot Spencer (Leverage)
John wick shouldn't even be on this list he not fair. He label as "human" but except maybe the first movie he's not. He is 100% not. I know in movies there the rule of suspension of belief but John takes that to a whole new level in his movies especially his sequels. Like look how the third movie ends. After having non-stop attacks since the first movie less than 3 weeks. He falls off a building hitting multiple mental bars and lives. Black widow (who lives in a superhero comic book world) goes through 25% that in her movie and everyone like "it makes no sense". There a super bais with John Wick. You got to stop putting him on these list. It unfair.
Do Henry Brogan (Gemini Man) vs Agent 47 vs Wesley Gibson (Wanted) vs Rambo
My prediction before watching.
Whick, Rake, Shaw, reacher (idk who that is tbh)
He wins because John Wick is really NEO!
Ironman vs hydra stomper
I think ironman wins with his mark 88 armor or even the hulk buster
He is forgetting about reacher intelligence
Wish you’d included frank Castle
Movies: Wick
Real life: Statham
Strength= Tyler Rake (he ripped that guys hand open),, Jack Reacher (headbutted and broke the guys elbow), but cant beat Rakes'...
Speed = Unless you Chinese, You can't be faster than Deckard
Durability = Rake (got shot and cut a few time,, even caught a bullet to the neck),,, John Wick (Got shot at, knifed, hit by the car, thrown into glass, ate punches from giants,, Fell from a back, neck, waist breaking, and head busting building and could still say "yea"),,, so wick takes it
Stamina = Tyler Rake (the oner)
Agility = Deckard shaw
Accuracy= Wick
Guns= Wick
Dangerous = Wick
Body-count= Wick
Experience = Wick
Brutality = Wick
Wick is the guy they all wanna be
Umm shaw has shown to have more weopons than the dam military hes also known on the most wanted hit list in his series and was a ghost till they got gods eyes, meaning he was off grid despite the tech those guys have
Experience could also go for both since
Shaw also has fought many people with less effort than john. Or he plans it out and it just works
I would've went crazy if you added Frank Castle The Punisher in this video
Ofc john wick wins in a gunfight. bro is a human aimbot💀
AS soon as I saw the title I knew John Wick as gonna win.
The Battle of the Robins
Dick Grayson vs. Jason Todd vs. Carrie Kelly vs. Tim Drake vs. Stephanie Brown vs. Damian Wayne vs. Duke Thomas
Rake has intelligence... Reacher has brute Strength... John has unmatched marksmanship and Shaw has Family... dont need to watch the video
Meh...Steven Seagal sweeps them all while not even moving. Aikido is lethal!
Can I laugh in your face - Segal. 😂😂😂
It’s just another Tuesday for John
It depends on where they fight or if it was with no weapons or with weapons
If it comes to H2H I would either say Shaw due to skills or jack reacher due to his strength and size
if it was a gun fight it’s either wick or rake but I’m going with wick due to him being more skilled with guns
if it was a prep time battle Shaw might win
If the fight takes place in a house Tyler rake wins mid to high diff unless if wick gets the drop on rake
If the fight is at stairs John wick extreme diff
If the fight is at a forest it’s either Shaw or rake
giving rake gun fight over wick is crazy but that's your opinion tho, rake is a beast but only had a little taste of what John had to go through in his entire movie franchise
The most trash takes I've ever seen.
H2H/physical combat, Wick beats everyone here. Size has nothing to do with it, and Wick is more durable than Shaw, as well as having more/better feats.
Gun fight/CQC with weapons is Wick for anyone with half a brain.
Prep time is rightfully Shaw.
In a house, because of lack of context, would go to Shaw because of superior arsenal.
Stairs fight is meme-worthy.
Forest fight probably goes to Rake.
@@jesuschrist7645yo bro chill it’s my opinion like dang it ain’t that deep 💀
@@Optimusprimeisachad You don't need an opinion on something that is already proven.
@@jesuschrist7645 biggest cap in my existence jack reacher broke a man leg easily John H2H sucks so reacher wins if you wanna argue with me then I would say this
Thomas Shelby > John wick
John wick > Thomas Shelby
Good on ya for acknowledging the ‘family force’ it IS very apparent in the F&F universe and all of our main cast has it 👏👏👏
Im going with Shaw his Skill alone can handle most if not all of them and he can use guns well enough to contest Wick.
How about.
YUJIRO VS HITACHI.
I agree with you on the outcome of this fight! It would be a blood bath at least until Frank Castle shows up!
Jobbers and goons is screaming and crying rn
Reacher also punched another person so hard their heart stopped
I say we have to split them in different categories and compare thier points overall in the end.
Strength and power:
Rake, Reacher, Shaw, Wick
Speed and agility:
Shaw, Rake, Wick, Reacher
Durability and endurance:
Wick, Rake, Shaw, Reacher
Skills and intellect:
Shaw, Rake, Wick, Reacher
Combat skills and martial arts:
Shaw, Rake, Wick, Reacher
Guns, Accuracy and precision:
Wick, Rake, Shaw, Reacher
Overall, if its close quarters combat, Shaw should come on top. But if its a gunfight then wick should be first.
Can you do Robert McCall vs Adam Clay?
Hand to Hand I think John Wick vs Deckard Shaw would be one hell of a contest. Though I'll admit I don't know enough about Reacher
Shaw would beat Wick easily.
@@H.K.5only thing Shaw has over Wick is agility and slightly more speed, but weapons and fighting techniques is still John Wick’s strength
@@issasaadiq794hes not lacking in either, speed and ability plus power is what makes a difference in the fight when you guys are dam near just as skilled as each other
Shaw beat a super soldier literally lol with the help of Obs@@issasaadiq794
You Forgot The punisher 💀.
Instead of Jack Reacher they should’ve put Jason Bourne
Why stop with just these four? Let's throw in Bryan Mills from Taken, Robert McCall from The Equalizer, Black Widow from the MCU, Shaft, Hutch Mansell from Nobody, Riley North from Peppermint, Anna from The Protégé, Machete and the world's most greatest and famous secret agent... Johnny English.
Wick went through platoons of mercs so it's not close,he is comparable to punisher except punisher uses any weapon that exists pretty much but still
Hey nice Video! I really enjoy watching your Videos! Btw, can you do a Video about Hancock?
John Wick wins mid difficulty. Tyler Rake is a good second. Jack Reacher might be the best hand to hand fighter but that would mean nothing in this 4 way gun fight. Decard Shaw isn’t even a factor here. John Wick wins with minor cuts and bruises (almost all given by Tyler Rake).
While I know John will win and voted John, I got to say you got it all wrong, Decard will be his biggest problem mainly because of his Deadpool personality that leads him to do unpredictable shyt. He'll find some way to do incredible damage on John but that'll only happen if he's able to make it to that round. Most likely he would because Tyler and John would be going after eachother while they leave decard to beat down Jack, which decard wouldn't really have a struggle with.
Idk man Deckard is a wild card. What makes him so special is he's not afraid to cheat in a fight. He’ll literally throw a bomb at you. At the very least, Shaw beats Reacher.
Deckard is a factor here. He can and will in in a pure H2H battle....but the problem for him is that this will not be just a close quarters battle.
@@bobitzathegodofcomedy5979 Deckard at the very least beats Reacher in a fight. He could even beat Wick. Tyler would be a tough one though.
What a brilliant idea for a video!
agent 47 claps all of them
Fun fact: Nightwing is Agent 37.
"This is the ultimate showdown of ultimate destiny.."
John Wick vs Bryan Mills vs James Bond vs Hitman
Forget them going against each other, can you imagine the carnage in a crossover movie of them teaming up!!! Now that is a movie I'd pay good money to see!!!
Reacher deserved more respect
Suggestion: Hank Schrader vs Mike Ehrmantraut vs Lalo Salamanca
Mike wins extreme diff lalo wins with prep
Just give John wick a pencil or a gun and watch him destroy all of them.
People in this fukin comment section all underestimate John Wick.
Look like they are Family guys and MARVEL fanboys
Marines/ SEALs >>> British and Australian special services combines.
I feel like a better fit would be John Wick v James Bond v Ethan Hunt v Jason Bourne
In any kind of gunfight, Deckard Shaw and John Wick and Tyler take it. hand to hand, is where it gets harder for everyone all of these guys are excellent in hand to hand.
Misty Knight vs The Question (Renee Montoya)!
lol Ayoo never click on these usually but with all these big names I’m curious 😂
I already knew John was gone win😂I like decard but it wasn't one of his other characters so I knew this was gone end quicck.
Also maybe some expendables… jet li vs dolph