I'm an Urdu-speaking Muhajir from Hyderabad, Sindh, and have a good command of the Sindhi language. Although we are Urdu-speaking, 80% of our relatives can understand and speak Sindhi. We learned it over time, but jb sy Karachi shift hua hun meri Sindhi Kamzor hogye. is me koi shak nh Sindhi ak both mithi zaban hay.
Alhamadulillah sindhi is well preserved language Throughout centuries First translation of Quran is in sindhi in subcontinent urdu translation of Quran is after 700 hundred .....
@@ghufranaa No, It was Akhund Azizullah Soomro, whom translated the Holy Qura'an in Sindhi (First translation in any other language of the world), Molana Ubaidullah Sindhi's original name was Butta Singh Uppal (a Punjabi Sikh) before converting to Islam, and he took the honorary title of "Sindhi" because of the support, he and his "Silk Letters Movement" (a movement against british occupation) got from the people of Sindh specifically in Hyderabad Sindh in the british colonial era.
دراصل زبان کی اصطلاحی سائنسی اصولوں کے مطابق زبان صرف اور صرف اُسے مانا جاتا ہے جو بولنے کے ساتھ ساتھ لکھی بھی جاتی ہو! یعنی جس زبان کا اپنا ذاتی رسم الخط ہو، دراصل وہ ہی زبان زبان کہلانے کا حق رکھتی ہے۔ باقی جن زبانوں کا کوئی رسم الخط نہ ہو وہ وقت کے ساتھ ساتھ آھستہ آھستہ بدل جاتی ہے یعنی وہ زبان اپنی اصل حالت اور افادیت وقت کے ساتھ ساتھ کھو بیٹھتی ہے اور اپنی اصلیت گنوا بیٹھتی ہے! شکریہ
I am a sindhi and very happy to see this video which is very informative,please prepare and share also the videos regarding sindhi language which is spoken india
I'm a proud Sindhi from Hyderabad, Sindh, I personally think that Sindhi language doesn't have any threat of being not spoken by its native speakers, the problem is that I have noticed that alot of native Sindhi words are being replaced by either urdu or English, especially in urban areas, also its very recent thing, as I myself am student of matric and I observed that few words which we used alot 5 or 6 years ago are not used in present, which seems very concerning. Ever since I had this realization, now I always try to use pure Sindhi words.
@@user-ix7zp5gt2y actually no one, but this puts more responsibility on native speakers to try using their native language vocabulary than the dominant language, and this problem is common in every language in the world.
@@ScindianLad You 've hit the bull. Its natives' responsibility to ensure that they get more and more education. Only that is the way to protect local culture and language. No Urdu speaking will ever be able to dominate the natives. See the example of Punjab. Urdu speaking Mohajirs and Urdu is not a threat to Punjabi language and the Punjabi people. Its education and not easy money that gives you awareness and strength
@@user-ix7zp5gt2y right, but in Punjab, KPK, and Balochistan, there are very few urdu speaking population, so they don't need to communicate with them into their language, but in urban Sindh you have to.
@@ScindianLad You know what, Urban Sind (Karachi to be specific) has always been predominantly populated with Parsis and Memons (Gujaratis). They are the ones who actually made Karachi glorious under and even after British rule. Even much before arrival of the Mohajirs in 1947, Karachi was almost alien to local Sindis (other than the native Gabul, Jokio, Palari and Shedi tribes). It sounds as if the Mohajirs should gracefully and voluntarily move out of the Urban Sind to places elsewhere in Pakistan or back to their ancestral provinces from where they migrated to Pakistan
دل خوش ھوگیا آپ نے 80 پرسنٹ بھترین خلاصہ پیش کیا ۔سندھي ٽوپي اجرڪن وارا ماڻھو ۵۰۰۰ سال کان الله پاڪ محفوظ رکيا آھن ء تا قيامت محفوظ رھندا مشڪل ٽائيم وقت سر ايندا آھن سندھي زبان منجھي جان مھرباني
The main reason of Sindhi language survival is its 52 letters alphabet and lots of books, magazine and print media availability. kaawish, koshish and many other small newspapers are being read widely throughout the province on daily basis and there are at least, 7-8 media channels which includes news and entertainment since 24 years. Sindhi's generally are art loving people so there attachment to the culture is very strong too. it is evident that in many areas of Balochistan, Sindhi alphabet is used on sign boards and visiting places.
سندھی زبان پاکستان میں انگریزی اور اردو کے بعد سب سے زیادہ محفوظ ہے۔ انگریزی اور اردو اخبارات اور کتابوں کے بعد سب سے زیادہ اخبارات اور کتابیں سندھی میں چھپتے ہیں۔
I am a Sindhi speaker. I think we are cousin brother of Punjabi language in terms that both belong to North Western branch of Indo Aryan languages. I appreciate how you are focusing on one of the most under rated topic of Pakistan i.e. the Negligence of local languages in the mainstream identity. You have done very nice research but one important point you forget to mention sister is the use of Sindhi language in Sindh Assembly that boosts the pride in native Sindhis unlike the Punjab Assembly which rejects Punjabi & demotivates it's native population to speak Punjabi with pride in Punjab !!
🎉 First of all i am very glad to know about your research in sindhi language.Sindhi language is the greatest and ancient language about 5000 years the best civilization of Mohan Jo daro.The nicest poet shah Abdul Latif bhitai is the creator of sindhi language who wrote his collection in the light of the holly quran.besides this sachal sarmast was the poet of seven language.Ubaidullah sindhi, The Quid-e-Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah,two Men that were title the sun ☀️ of knowledge,Mirza qaleech baig and UMER bin daud potta The first wise chànçlor of Sindh university,àllama II KAZI the husband of Elsa KAZI who German lady. تواڈے رشتیدار دے علاوہ پورے ملک دے لوگ نالے بنگالی تے افغانی وی اتھے رہںدے نے۔ آپ نے بہت ہی خوبصورت انداز میں سندھی زبان کو بیان کیا ہے ؟
Mashallah an excellent video my sister. I want to add one thing to it, which is that the graph you showed of high-income families, where a certain percentage of sindhi people shift from the Sindhi language to another language, is due to outcast marriage. Mostly, high-income Sindhi men marry Urdu, Punjabi, or Pashto speaking women and because of this, their children speak their mother tongue at home instead of Sindhi. Two of my uncles married urdu speaking women, and in their homes their children speak Urdu. This is the reason that certan percentage of sindhi people speak urdu, other wise we Sindhi People always give first priority to our beloved sindhi langugae ❤
Sindhi Bhasha ko maintain karne ke liye Sindhi log tareef ke hakdaar hain...Pakistan mein Haryanvi zabaan ke baare mein bhi ek video banao please. Manoj Malik, Panipat, India
I really enjoyed your content and found your research on the Sindhi language to be quite insightful. It's absolutely true that we Sindhis, regardless of our education level, always prefer to speak in Sindhi. I've met many Pakistani Punjabis in Europe, and I've noticed that they often speak Urdu with their children, even during gatherings. It's wonderful to see such a strong cultural connection maintained through language. Keep up the great work!
Sindhi is not the main language in Rajasthani regions you mentioned. It's mainly dhatki and marwari both of which are dialects of Rajasthani. Sindhis living in Rajasthan are mainly Hindus who migrated from Sindh during partition and even in kutch only the western part is kutchi while eastern part is Gujarati speaking region
@@msr7373 Sindhi is historically one of the main languages in western most Rajasthan I.e Jaisalmer and Barmer. In Jaisalmer the western part of Jaisalmer city, people are majority Muslim Sindhis, they speak Sindhi at their homes, but definitely they can also communicate in Marwari. To the south of Jaisalmer is the dhatki, and no dhatki is not merely the dialect of Rajasthani, dhatki has many of its variations, I personally think Dhatki is more similar to Sindhi than marwari or Rajasthani. In the east side of Jaisalmer people speak Thali which is again mix dialect of Sindhi and Marwari, but it has over time became more Rajasthani, infact very few people today are able to speak Thali dialect. I have read somewhere that Thali is basically one of the variation of dhatki with more inclination to Rajasthani. In Barmer also the western part speak Sindhi and dhatki and in East its Marwari. Kutch presently has more Gujarati population but back in time it was majority Kutchi populated region, infact in the western most of Kathiawad for example in Jamnagar and Dwarka kutchi was a significant minority. Also in Mumbai many kutchi, kutchi kayasthi and memoni were spoken.
@@msr7373 Kutch is historically South Sindh just next to Thatta & Tharparkar. Kutch is made up of 90% Sindhi tribes (Both Hindus & Muslims). Ofcourse today it's politically a part of Gujarat hence there is more Gujarati Influence but still the fact cannot be distorted that Kutchis are actually Southern Sindhis with little variation from mainland Sindhi Language.The Gujaratis that you mentioned being present in Eastern Kutch are latest immigrants from Kathiawar & Mainland Gujarat. Moreover, the Gujarati medium schools & absence of recognition of Kutchi/ Sindhi as an official language has further pushed the Gujaratification of Kutchis !!!
I am from city of lakes Udaipur ! Your way of talking is very unique. I am impressed by your style of talking ! There are many Sindhi people in my city who talk in Sindhi language in their homes and when they meet each other they have separate panchayats, I have read the names of Jacobabad panchayat and Balochistan panchayat in newspapers which organize Sindhi cultural programs. !!!
I studied in urdu medium school where we only spoke urdu and english. In the school most of the students were urdu speaking and teachers as well so, i remeber we made habit to speak in urdu me and my sister at our homes as well. So my father started teaching us sindhi, bought us sindhi books and made us able to read and write in sindhi. Which he felt is important for us and i am proud that my father felt responsible to preserve sindhi language in next generation with his little efforts. No doubt sindhi is a beautiful language like others. Proud sindhi! ❤
My wife and I were born in Kandiaro Sindh, after partition moved to India. Visited Karachi and Sindh in February 24. Karachi proper few Sindhi speaking , but few miles outside to Thatto, Bhumbhore all spoke Sindhi. Further north, Hyderabad, to nawabshah, Sukkur everyone spoke Sindhi, very exciting. Loved the visit…
سندھی زبان کا پنجابی سے زیادہ کثرت سے استعمال ہی شائید اسکی وجہ ہیکہ سندھی بولنے والے صرف سندھ میں ہی رہنا پسند کرتے ہیں یہ لوگ بقریہ پاکستان میں کہیں نظر نہیں آتے جبکہ پنجابی کثرت سے اردو بولنے کے سبب ساری پاکستان کی قوموں کیساتھ کاروبار اور سوشلائیز کرنیکے قابل ہی نہیں بلکہ سارے پاکستان میں کہیں بھی جاکر رہ سکتے ہیں اور نوکری کاروبار بھی کرسکتے ہیں۔ اس سے ثابت ہوتا ہیکہ پنجابیونجو اردو میں مہارت کے سبب پاکستان کے کونے کونے میں کسی قسم کا روزگار تلاش کرنے میں کوئ مشکل نہیں۔
I am Urdu speaker from Karachi and I am thankful for my Sindhi brothers for keeping their language alive and teaching us. It is a very beautiful language. There is a saying in Farsi that says: "farsi shakr ast" which means Farsi is sugar. I can definitely say that's true for Sindhi too. I am also sad at the state of other regional languages. I think, the most hurt is Punjabi and I strongly believe that we should preserve these extremely beautiful languages for coming generations.
I’m fortunate to be born in Sindh, the cradle of Indus Valley civilization. Being Hindu family moved to India but have kept close touch with Sindh, besides I speak Hindi, Urdu, Punjabi, Some Bangla, good Russians and of course English. But still in my eighties, my thought process is in Sindhi, which consider as sweetest, peaceful and humble language..so proud to be Sindhi
میڈم اپ کا پروگرام دیکھا بڑا پسند ایا بہت اچھا تھا خاص کر سندھی لینگویج کے اوپر اپ نے جو بات کی ہے ہر وہ زبان زندہ رہتی ہے جو اینوویشن کرتی دیتی ہے نئی نئی الفاظ کی اگر کسی زبان کو اپ اس طرح چھوڑ دیں گے اور نئے نئے الفاظ اس میں داخل نہیں کریں گے جس طرح انگریزی اپنے الفاظ داخل کرتی جاتی ہے یعنی کہ وہ لینگویج بڑھتی جائے گی اگر اسی طرح سندھی ہو پختون ہو پنجابی ہو کوئی بھی لینگویج ہو اس میں اگر وہ الفاظ جو ترقی دلارہے ہیں کوئی نہیں کریں گے نہیں نوشن نہیں ائے گی الفاظ کی تو وہ لینگویج اہستہ اہستہ ختم ہو جائے گی سندھی بھی اب چل رہی ہے بہت اچھی لینگویج ہے مگر وہ اینوویشن نہیں کر رہے جو ریسرچ ہونی چاہیے یہ فقدان ہمیں اردو میں بھی نظر ارہا ہے سندھی میں بھی نظر ارہا ہے پختون میں بھی نظر ارہا ہے سب میں اور رہی بات اب ہم جو بھی زبان استعمال کر رہے ہیں زیادہ تر اسی کے اندر انگریزی کے الفاظ زیادہ استعمال ہو رہے ہیں اور یہ قسم کا غلط کام ہو رہا ہے کسی بھی زبان کو ختم ہونے کے لئے
Sindhi might be a beautiful language, but 99% of Urdu-speaking Karachiites HATE it due to the PPP's discriminatory policies, especially the unfair quota system targeting them. Forcing Sindhi into the academic syllabus only intensifies this resentment, leading them to vent their frustration on the language. I know it's not right, but it's similar to how, at one point, everyone in Pakistan assumed Urdu speakers were terrorists due to ISI-sponsored MQM policies. Similarly, in Balochistan, people hate Punjabi Language due to oppressive policies. Get your facts straight. Thanks.
You didn't choose me from Thatta/Karachi hence reject your research 😂. BTW; In Pakistan; Sindhi are much sensitive when it comes to language, culture, topi ajrak, Karachi, heritage and anything else breathing for centuries like I have been living in Karachi for decades but I always prefer speaking Sindhi here I have applied a rule in my life I always initiate conversation in Sindhi either it's office, court, market or anywhere else but my first words are always in Sindhi and in case listener is unable to understand afterwards I continue it in Urdu/English but priority is always Sindhi and this doesn't mean we are some superman or prioritizing our nation over others but this only meant to protect our language as much as possible. Moreover; I have visited almost all areas of Punjab, KP , Balochistan etc I observed people from KP & Balochistan who are from villagers hardly knows Urdu and very few speak Urdu but here in Sindh despite we prefer Sindhi but our people from villages speaks Urdu perfectly. At last; I love speaking Urdu and always curious to learn Punjabi, Pashto, Balochi. We are one❤ Thank you for this video!
In the linguistic landscape of Pakistan, the Sindhi language stands as a proud emblem of cultural defiance and resilience. While many other linguistic communities in Pakistan have gradually adopted Urdu, the national language, often at the price of their native tongues, the Sindhi people have remained steadfast in preserving their linguistic heritage. This resistance to linguistic assimilation has, however, subjected them to systemic biases and ongoing challenges, particularly from the Urdu-dominated media. Since the inception of Pakistan, powerful circles have sought to make Urdu the sole national language, associating it with the Islamic identity of the country. This decision was made despite the linguistic similarities between Urdu and Hindi, both of which are essentially the same language differentiated mainly by their scripts-Urdu using the Persian script and Hindi using Devanagari. In contrast, Sindhi, a language deeply rooted in the region's history and culture, has its own unique connection to Islam. It was the first language in which the Holy Quran was translated, and it holds the distinction of using the Arabic script rather than the Persian script. The Sindhi language, with its rich literary tradition, has been a fundamental part of the region's history for centuries. It predates the establishment of Pakistan and has a profound cultural and religious significance. Sindhi is not just a means of communication; it embodies the identity, heritage, and spiritual life of the Sindhi people. The Sindhi language’s association with Islam is profound. It was the first language in the Indian subcontinent to have a complete translation of the Holy Quran. This translation dates back to the early Islamic period in the region, underscoring the deep roots of Islam in Sindh. Unlike Urdu, which uses the Persian script, Sindhi uses the Arabic script, making it unique among the languages of the region. This script not only aligns Sindhi more closely with the script of the Holy Quran but also emphasizes its historical connection to the broader Islamic world. The promotion of Urdu as the sole national language has had significant implications for linguistic diversity in Pakistan. The Sindhi community, in particular, has faced numerous challenges as a result of these policies Following the creation of Pakistan in 1947, Urdu was promoted as the national language, ostensibly to foster national unity. However, this policy often overlooked the linguistic diversity and the strong regional identities within the country. While many provinces began to shift towards Urdu, the Sindhi community maintained a strong attachment to their native language, ensuring its continued use in education, administration, and daily life. The Sindhi community's refusal to abandon their linguistic heritage in favor of Urdu has not been without significant repercussions. The most glaring manifestation of the challenges they face is the biased behavior of the Urdu media. The Urdu press and electronic media have often targeted the Sindhi community, perpetuating negative stereotypes and marginalizing their legitimate concerns. The Urdu media frequently portrays Sindhi issues in a negative light, focusing disproportionately on problems such as political corruption and lawlessness. Positive contributions and the cultural richness of the Sindhi community are often ignored, leading to a skewed and unfair representation. There is a noticeable absence of Sindhi intellectuals, writers, and activists in mainstream Urdu media. This exclusion limits the visibility of Sindhi perspectives and deprives the national discourse of a more balanced and inclusive narrative. The dominance of Urdu in media and education has contributed to the erosion of Sindhi culture, particularly among younger generations. The pervasive influence of Urdu-language television, films, and literature has led to a gradual decline in the use of Sindhi, threatening the preservation of its cultural heritage. The Sindhi language is a vital component of the cultural identity and historical legacy of the Sindhi people. Despite facing systemic biases and challenges, the Sindhi community’s dedication to their language remains unyielding. Promoting linguistic diversity and cultural respect is essential for fostering an inclusive society in Pakistan. It requires concerted efforts from policymakers, media, and civil society to acknowledge and address the injustices faced by linguistic minorities like the Sindhi community. Only through such efforts can Pakistan achieve a truly unified and diverse national identity where all languages and cultures are valued and celebrated.
Well explained .... as a sindhi i saw that many other people like pinjabis are hassitated talk in punjabi with their punjabi colleague but we sindhi proudly talk to another non sindhi person with sindhi . And they like it which shows we are proud of our langauge .
All punjabis speak Punjabi and are proud of it but they learn urdu as a second language which is the lingua franca in all provinces. That is why punjabis are functional and prospering in all provinces.
Hey Misha, I appreciate your Research content and enthusiasm for the Sindhi Language, especially by a lady who comes from a Punjabi-ethnic community. You know, our language is as beautiful as your eyes. :))
❤👏🏻👏🏻🎉 A very well analysed and presented... a comprehensive study. An urgent need for the same study on Sindhi Language /Cultural behaviour of Sindhi people in India.
Nice information on how sindhi language develop and use in daily life of sindhies in pakistan when government or rulers use specific language for their administration communication then automatically this language flourish develop and becomes everyone's government of sindh pakistan support sindhi is best thanks
سندھی بہت ہی خوبصورت میٹھی زبان ہے ہندوستان کی بہت ہی قدیم ہزاروں سال پہلے سے سندھی قوم سندھی زبان موجود ہے سندھ ہی سے ہند بنا ۔حلانکہ میں سندھی نہیں ہوں میں گرجر ہوں مجھے سندھی زبان بہت پسند ہے
What do you mean despite the fact Urdu speakers call Karachi and Hyderbad their home? They too have a right to call it their home and they are not conspiring against Sindhi language. You appear to be some random Indian dude who wants to create rifts between ethnicities in Pakistan. Apnay desh mein Muslims aur Urdu Kay khilaf zehar ugalna kaafi Nahin that you have to bring your toxic behaviour here as well?
@@msr7373 do you understand English less or are you high on being a keyboard warrior? When did I say that who has the right or no right to call Karachi their home? The Urdu speaking Muhajirs call Karachi their home is a fact because most Muhajirs from India settled in Karachi. Isn’t it a good thing that both Urdu and Sindhi are thriving in your province? I consider it a good thing, that’s what being cosmopolitan is.
@@msr7373 “despite the fact” specifically means the tolerance of Urdu speaking Muhajirs of Karachi who are the majority in the city, and yet didn’t suppress the Sindhi language, and in fact helped it flourish. nobody has got time for conspiring against Pakistan on UA-cam comments. come out of India America Israel ki saazish mentality and start seeing things with a positive light, it will help reduce the toxic load of your brain.
Thank you, Ma'am, for the well-researched work. I appreciate that most of the parameters are agreeable. The only thing I want to mention is the state of academics in the Sindhi language, which is declining as we advance towards modern and higher education. Unfortunately, after secondary education, our textbooks are mainly not in Sindhi. As a Sindhi person, I wish that we had college-level education as well as official office work in the Sindhi language too.
Very true, but still its commendable how hard the Sindhi community is working to promote their language, but of course there is always room for doing better 💕
I am Sindhi since 5000 years . and I am proud to be Sindhi
You are 5000 years old ? Congrats 😅
I'm an Urdu-speaking Muhajir from Hyderabad, Sindh, and have a good command of the Sindhi language. Although we are Urdu-speaking, 80% of our relatives can understand and speak Sindhi. We learned it over time, but jb sy Karachi shift hua hun meri Sindhi Kamzor hogye. is me koi shak nh Sindhi ak both mithi zaban hay.
سر حیدرآباد سندھی اور مہاجروں کی یکجہتی کا گڑھ ہے، ہمیں خوشی ہوتی ہے جب ہم سندھی بولتے ہیں اور زیادہ تر مہاجر ہمیں سندھی میں ہی جواب دیتے ہیں۔
I'm urdu speaking muhajir from Karachi, but know basic sindhi and want to be fluent in my provional language
Ok, i am also from thatta.
بھترين توھان ڪوشش ڪيوسنڌي سکو۽ڳالھائڻ جي ڪوشش ڪيو سلامت رھو 💖🙏
That is a good effort, keep it up
Insha Allah you will be
❤
اوھان جو اھو پروگرام ء ریسرچ Accurate آھی ۔۔۔ مھربانی ۔۔۔
Sindhi is our First language.❤
Proud to be Sindhi Hindu
From Umarkot
Bahut Achchi baat hai Saain..... Mere vichaar se is Shahar ka asli Historical naam Amarkot hai, Umarkot nhin.....
@@manojmalik5464 G han bilkul.. hum bolchal m Amarkot hi kehte hien
You language is dhatki not Sindhi
Alhamadulillah sindhi is well preserved language
Throughout centuries
First translation of Quran is in sindhi in subcontinent urdu translation of Quran is after 700 hundred .....
@@dont.c Oh sorry, you said you are from amarkot so I thought you are dhatti, my bad
سندھی ایک قدیم زبان ہے جس میں سب سے پہلے قران کا ترجمہ کیا گیا
مولانا عبیداللہ سندھی صاحب نے سب سے پہلے قرآن پاک کا سندھی زبان میں ترجمہ کیا۔
@@ghufranaa No, It was Akhund Azizullah Soomro, whom translated the Holy Qura'an in Sindhi (First translation in any other language of the world), Molana Ubaidullah Sindhi's original name was Butta Singh Uppal (a Punjabi Sikh) before converting to Islam, and he took the honorary title of "Sindhi" because of the support, he and his "Silk Letters Movement" (a movement against british occupation) got from the people of Sindh specifically in Hyderabad Sindh in the british colonial era.
@@shahbazqamar8775 There are more reasons for that. Maulana Ubaidullah Sindhi also recieved his training in Tasawwuf from Sindh.
دراصل زبان کی اصطلاحی سائنسی اصولوں کے مطابق زبان صرف اور صرف اُسے مانا جاتا ہے جو بولنے کے ساتھ ساتھ لکھی بھی جاتی ہو! یعنی جس زبان کا اپنا ذاتی رسم الخط ہو، دراصل وہ ہی زبان زبان کہلانے کا حق رکھتی ہے۔ باقی جن زبانوں کا کوئی رسم الخط نہ ہو وہ وقت کے ساتھ ساتھ آھستہ آھستہ بدل جاتی ہے یعنی وہ زبان اپنی اصل حالت اور افادیت وقت کے ساتھ ساتھ کھو بیٹھتی ہے اور اپنی اصلیت گنوا بیٹھتی ہے!
شکریہ
زبان اور بولی میں یہی فرق ہے کے زبان کا اپنا رسم الخط ہوتا ہے اور بولی کا نہیں اور بولی صرف بولی جاتی ہے لکھی نہیں جاسکتی۔
Sindhi language, script and culture are preserved under Article 28 of the Constitution of Pakistan.
Proud of being Sindhi.
From Sindh
Great tale ever, Love from sindh💐
ﷲ توهان هميشه شاد ۽ آباد رکي سنڌي ٻولي وانگر💐
Proud to be a Pakistani 🇵🇰 Musalman or sindhi soomro
Har bat mai musalman issiliye tumhara culture mar raha hai 😂😂😂 u loose ur punjabi now u all gonna loose ur Sindhi tooo
I am Sindhi & I proud of Sindhi language ❤
I proud is wrong. Say I am proud.
I am a sindhi and very happy to see this video which is very informative,please prepare and share also the videos regarding sindhi language which is spoken india
I'm a proud Sindhi from Hyderabad, Sindh, I personally think that Sindhi language doesn't have any threat of being not spoken by its native speakers, the problem is that I have noticed that alot of native Sindhi words are being replaced by either urdu or English, especially in urban areas, also its very recent thing, as I myself am student of matric and I observed that few words which we used alot 5 or 6 years ago are not used in present, which seems very concerning. Ever since I had this realization, now I always try to use pure Sindhi words.
Who is responsible for loss of Sindhi vocabulary, The non Sindhis or Sindhis?
@@user-ix7zp5gt2y actually no one, but this puts more responsibility on native speakers to try using their native language vocabulary than the dominant language, and this problem is common in every language in the world.
@@ScindianLad You 've hit the bull. Its natives' responsibility to ensure that they get more and more education. Only that is the way to protect local culture and language. No Urdu speaking will ever be able to dominate the natives. See the example of Punjab. Urdu speaking Mohajirs and Urdu is not a threat to Punjabi language and the Punjabi people. Its education and not easy money that gives you awareness and strength
@@user-ix7zp5gt2y right, but in Punjab, KPK, and Balochistan, there are very few urdu speaking population, so they don't need to communicate with them into their language, but in urban Sindh you have to.
@@ScindianLad You know what, Urban Sind (Karachi to be specific) has always been predominantly populated with Parsis and Memons (Gujaratis). They are the ones who actually made Karachi glorious under and even after British rule. Even much before arrival of the Mohajirs in 1947, Karachi was almost alien to local Sindis (other than the native Gabul, Jokio, Palari and Shedi tribes).
It sounds as if the Mohajirs should gracefully and voluntarily move out of the Urban Sind to places elsewhere in Pakistan or back to their ancestral provinces from where they migrated to Pakistan
مٺڙي ادي توهان جا لک ٿورا سنڌين جو ويڊيو ٺاهيون 👋👏👋👏👋
دل خوش ھوگیا آپ نے 80 پرسنٹ بھترین خلاصہ پیش کیا ۔سندھي ٽوپي اجرڪن وارا ماڻھو ۵۰۰۰ سال کان الله پاڪ محفوظ رکيا آھن ء تا قيامت محفوظ رھندا مشڪل ٽائيم وقت سر ايندا آھن سندھي زبان منجھي جان مھرباني
The main reason of Sindhi language survival is its 52 letters alphabet and lots of books, magazine and print media availability. kaawish, koshish and many other small newspapers are being read widely throughout the province on daily basis and there are at least, 7-8 media channels which includes news and entertainment since 24 years. Sindhi's generally are art loving people so there attachment to the culture is very strong too. it is evident that in many areas of Balochistan, Sindhi alphabet is used on sign boards and visiting places.
سندھی زبان پاکستان میں انگریزی اور اردو کے بعد سب سے زیادہ محفوظ ہے۔ انگریزی اور اردو اخبارات اور کتابوں کے بعد سب سے زیادہ اخبارات اور کتابیں سندھی میں چھپتے ہیں۔
I am a Sindhi speaker. I think we are cousin brother of Punjabi language in terms that both belong to North Western branch of Indo Aryan languages.
I appreciate how you are focusing on one of the most under rated topic of Pakistan i.e. the Negligence of local languages in the mainstream identity.
You have done very nice research but one important point you forget to mention sister is the use of Sindhi language in Sindh Assembly that boosts the pride in native Sindhis unlike the Punjab Assembly which rejects Punjabi & demotivates it's native population to speak Punjabi with pride in Punjab !!
I agree with you my friend there are a lot of very similar words in both languages 👍❤️.
Nice information & good study
Proud to be Sindhi
From Oman/Muscat
Thank you ma'am for this video about Sindhi our mother tongue.
Love and respect from Thaparkar
Proud to be a Sindhi from larkana ❤
🎉 First of all i am very glad to know about your research in sindhi language.Sindhi language is the greatest and ancient language about 5000 years the best civilization of Mohan Jo daro.The nicest poet shah Abdul Latif bhitai is the creator of sindhi language who wrote his collection in the light of the holly quran.besides this sachal sarmast was the poet of seven language.Ubaidullah sindhi, The Quid-e-Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah,two Men that were title the sun ☀️ of knowledge,Mirza qaleech baig and UMER bin daud potta The first wise chànçlor of Sindh university,àllama II KAZI the husband of Elsa KAZI who German lady.
تواڈے رشتیدار دے علاوہ پورے ملک دے لوگ نالے بنگالی تے افغانی وی اتھے رہںدے نے۔
آپ نے بہت ہی خوبصورت انداز میں سندھی زبان کو بیان کیا ہے ؟
I really appreciate that you have researched on different languages and very well studied on Sindhi language. Thank you so much ❤
Thank you 💕
اوهان جي وڏي مھرباني اوهان سنڌي ٻولي تي ويڊيو ٺاھيو آھي ❤
Thanks for video on Sindhi.
We speak Sindhi proudly.
Having learned English.
My previous comment was fact, that we feel proud of Sindhi
This is the need that Sindhi youths Should speaks Sindhi proudly
آپ کی مہربانی آپ نے سندھی زبان پہ بہترین وڈیو بنائی ہے
Mashallah an excellent video my sister. I want to add one thing to it, which is that the graph you showed of high-income families, where a certain percentage of sindhi people shift from the Sindhi language to another language, is due to outcast marriage.
Mostly, high-income Sindhi men marry Urdu, Punjabi, or Pashto speaking women and because of this, their children speak their mother tongue at home instead of Sindhi. Two of my uncles married urdu speaking women, and in their homes their children speak Urdu.
This is the reason that certan percentage of sindhi people speak urdu, other wise we Sindhi People always give first priority to our beloved sindhi langugae ❤
Sindhi Bhasha ko maintain karne ke liye Sindhi log tareef ke hakdaar hain...Pakistan mein Haryanvi zabaan ke baare mein bhi ek video banao please. Manoj Malik, Panipat, India
One detailed video on kutchi language as it is spoken in karachi and other parts of sindh.kindly it’s similar to sindhi and gujrati.
HARYANVI IS VERY SWEET LANGUAGE, I LIKE HARYANVI, DANGAL MOVIE FAMOUS THE HARYANVI LANGUAGE.
I really enjoyed your content and found your research on the Sindhi language to be quite insightful. It's absolutely true that we Sindhis, regardless of our education level, always prefer to speak in Sindhi. I've met many Pakistani Punjabis in Europe, and I've noticed that they often speak Urdu with their children, even during gatherings. It's wonderful to see such a strong cultural connection maintained through language. Keep up the great work!
Mam love from Sindh to u as sindhi.❤❤❤
Proud to be sindhi love from sukkur sindh Pakistan
I am a Sindhi and I am proud of it.
Jd
Proud to be Sindhi speaking ❤
Sindhi is a main spoken language of Kachhi sibi lasbela region in Balochistan and Kutch jesalmer barmer jodhpur states of India
Also in makran, 30% speak jadgali dialect of Sindhi.
Sindhi is not the main language in Rajasthani regions you mentioned. It's mainly dhatki and marwari both of which are dialects of Rajasthani. Sindhis living in Rajasthan are mainly Hindus who migrated from Sindh during partition and even in kutch only the western part is kutchi while eastern part is Gujarati speaking region
i am from Kutch
@@msr7373 Sindhi is historically one of the main languages in western most Rajasthan I.e Jaisalmer and Barmer. In Jaisalmer the western part of Jaisalmer city, people are majority Muslim Sindhis, they speak Sindhi at their homes, but definitely they can also communicate in Marwari. To the south of Jaisalmer is the dhatki, and no dhatki is not merely the dialect of Rajasthani, dhatki has many of its variations, I personally think Dhatki is more similar to Sindhi than marwari or Rajasthani. In the east side of Jaisalmer people speak Thali which is again mix dialect of Sindhi and Marwari, but it has over time became more Rajasthani, infact very few people today are able to speak Thali dialect. I have read somewhere that Thali is basically one of the variation of dhatki with more inclination to Rajasthani.
In Barmer also the western part speak Sindhi and dhatki and in East its Marwari.
Kutch presently has more Gujarati population but back in time it was majority Kutchi populated region, infact in the western most of Kathiawad for example in Jamnagar and Dwarka kutchi was a significant minority.
Also in Mumbai many kutchi, kutchi kayasthi and memoni were spoken.
@@msr7373 Kutch is historically South Sindh just next to Thatta & Tharparkar. Kutch is made up of 90% Sindhi tribes (Both Hindus & Muslims).
Ofcourse today it's politically a part of Gujarat hence there is more Gujarati Influence but still the fact cannot be distorted that Kutchis are actually Southern Sindhis with little variation from mainland Sindhi Language.The Gujaratis that you mentioned being present in Eastern Kutch are latest immigrants from Kathiawar & Mainland Gujarat. Moreover, the Gujarati medium schools & absence of recognition of Kutchi/ Sindhi as an official language has further pushed the Gujaratification of Kutchis !!!
I am from city of lakes Udaipur !
Your way of talking is very unique. I am
impressed by your style of talking !
There are many Sindhi people in my
city who talk in Sindhi language in their
homes and when they meet each other
they have separate panchayats, I have
read the names of Jacobabad panchayat
and Balochistan panchayat in newspapers
which organize Sindhi cultural programs. !!!
I've seen vlogs about Udaipur and Jaipur. Would love to see the history of that place in person one day ❤️
@@TareekhiTalesUrduWhy not !whenever you come to India, do visit Udaipur. You are heartily welcomed as our guest! !!!
Masha allah bhen ji zaberdast respect you from hyderabad
hum sindh m rehny waly mehman Nawaz h sary love Sindh m a panhwar Tando Allah Yar Sindh
کاش پنجابی کے ساتھ بھی ایسا ہوتا۔ اس کو بھی محفوظ رکھنے کی شدید ضرورت ہۓ۔ پنجابی کا استعمال اسیمبلی میں اور تجارت میں ہو۔
😂
سنڌ اسان جو ساھ آ
اور آپکا بہت بہت شکریہ میدم❤❤
Best Representation of Sindhi language
ماشاءاللہ بہت عمدہ ❤🎉
Thank you
آ پ کا انداز گفتگو کمال باتیں بے مثال اللہ تعالیٰ سلامت رکھے
سندھی زبان اپنی جگہ، مگر آپ اردو بولتی ہوئی بہت خوبصورت لگ رہی ہیں۔ اردو زندہ آباد
I studied in urdu medium school where we only spoke urdu and english. In the school most of the students were urdu speaking and teachers as well so, i remeber we made habit to speak in urdu me and my sister at our homes as well. So my father started teaching us sindhi, bought us sindhi books and made us able to read and write in sindhi. Which he felt is important for us and i am proud that my father felt responsible to preserve sindhi language in next generation with his little efforts. No doubt sindhi is a beautiful language like others. Proud sindhi! ❤
My wife and I were born in Kandiaro Sindh, after partition moved to India. Visited Karachi and Sindh in February 24. Karachi proper few Sindhi speaking , but few miles outside to Thatto, Bhumbhore all spoke Sindhi. Further north, Hyderabad, to nawabshah, Sukkur everyone spoke Sindhi, very exciting. Loved the visit…
As a Sindhi, I always speak Sindhi, even at university and while shopping. I also message my contacts in Sindhi. I always try to speak Sindhi.
اللہ تعالیٰ آپ کو سلامت رکھے آمین ثم آمین آپ نے ہم سندھ کی زبان کو پرموٹ کی آپ کا شکریہ
Boht khushi hui kay kisi ne hum sindhis ko yaad rakha or video banai ♥️🫶🏻
سندھی زبان کا پنجابی سے زیادہ کثرت سے استعمال ہی شائید اسکی وجہ ہیکہ سندھی بولنے والے صرف سندھ میں ہی رہنا پسند کرتے ہیں یہ لوگ بقریہ پاکستان میں کہیں نظر نہیں آتے جبکہ پنجابی کثرت سے اردو بولنے کے سبب ساری پاکستان کی قوموں کیساتھ کاروبار اور سوشلائیز کرنیکے قابل ہی نہیں بلکہ سارے پاکستان میں کہیں بھی جاکر رہ سکتے ہیں اور نوکری کاروبار بھی کرسکتے ہیں۔ اس سے ثابت ہوتا ہیکہ پنجابیونجو اردو میں مہارت کے سبب پاکستان کے کونے کونے میں کسی قسم کا روزگار تلاش کرنے میں کوئ مشکل نہیں۔
I am Urdu speaker from Karachi and I am thankful for my Sindhi brothers for keeping their language alive and teaching us. It is a very beautiful language. There is a saying in Farsi that says: "farsi shakr ast" which means Farsi is sugar. I can definitely say that's true for Sindhi too. I am also sad at the state of other regional languages. I think, the most hurt is Punjabi and I strongly believe that we should preserve these extremely beautiful languages for coming generations.
اوهان جي محنت کي سلام💕💕💕
I m proud to be Sindhi from India
PROUD TO BE A GOJAR AND MY LANGUAGE GOJRI❤
I’m fortunate to be born in Sindh, the cradle of Indus Valley civilization. Being Hindu family moved to India but have kept close touch with Sindh, besides I speak Hindi, Urdu, Punjabi, Some Bangla, good Russians and of course English. But still in my eighties, my thought process is in Sindhi, which consider as sweetest, peaceful and humble language..so proud to be Sindhi
مھرباني توھان سنڌي ٻولي۽سنڌين ڪلچر کي سمجھڻجي ڪوشس ڪءي۔ آھي❤❤
میڈم اپ کا پروگرام دیکھا بڑا پسند ایا بہت اچھا تھا خاص کر سندھی لینگویج کے اوپر اپ نے جو بات کی ہے ہر وہ زبان زندہ رہتی ہے جو اینوویشن کرتی دیتی ہے نئی نئی الفاظ کی اگر کسی زبان کو اپ اس طرح چھوڑ دیں گے اور نئے نئے الفاظ اس میں داخل نہیں کریں گے جس طرح انگریزی اپنے الفاظ داخل کرتی جاتی ہے یعنی کہ وہ لینگویج بڑھتی جائے گی اگر اسی طرح سندھی ہو پختون ہو پنجابی ہو کوئی بھی لینگویج ہو اس میں اگر وہ الفاظ جو ترقی دلارہے ہیں کوئی نہیں کریں گے نہیں نوشن نہیں ائے گی الفاظ کی تو وہ لینگویج اہستہ اہستہ ختم ہو جائے گی سندھی بھی اب چل رہی ہے بہت اچھی لینگویج ہے مگر وہ اینوویشن نہیں کر رہے جو ریسرچ ہونی چاہیے یہ فقدان ہمیں اردو میں بھی نظر ارہا ہے سندھی میں بھی نظر ارہا ہے پختون میں بھی نظر ارہا ہے سب میں اور رہی بات اب ہم جو بھی زبان استعمال کر رہے ہیں زیادہ تر اسی کے اندر انگریزی کے الفاظ زیادہ استعمال ہو رہے ہیں اور یہ قسم کا غلط کام ہو رہا ہے کسی بھی زبان کو ختم ہونے کے لئے
Lets promote her channel, she's our sister. The way she contributed in our language its amazing 🤩 . This video has been viral on Facebook.
MashaALLAH Pakistan🇵🇰 zindabad soomro
Sindhi language is peace of language ❤
Sindhi might be a beautiful language, but 99% of Urdu-speaking Karachiites HATE it due to the PPP's discriminatory policies, especially the unfair quota system targeting them. Forcing Sindhi into the academic syllabus only intensifies this resentment, leading them to vent their frustration on the language.
I know it's not right, but it's similar to how, at one point, everyone in Pakistan assumed Urdu speakers were terrorists due to ISI-sponsored MQM policies. Similarly, in Balochistan, people hate Punjabi Language due to oppressive policies. Get your facts straight.
Thanks.
You didn't choose me from Thatta/Karachi hence reject your research 😂.
BTW; In Pakistan; Sindhi are much sensitive when it comes to language, culture, topi ajrak, Karachi, heritage and anything else breathing for centuries like I have been living in Karachi for decades but I always prefer speaking Sindhi here I have applied a rule in my life I always initiate conversation in Sindhi either it's office, court, market or anywhere else but my first words are always in Sindhi and in case listener is unable to understand afterwards I continue it in Urdu/English but priority is always Sindhi and this doesn't mean we are some superman or prioritizing our nation over others but this only meant to protect our language as much as possible.
Moreover; I have visited almost all areas of Punjab, KP , Balochistan etc I observed people from KP & Balochistan who are from villagers hardly knows Urdu and very few speak Urdu but here in Sindh despite we prefer Sindhi but our people from villages speaks Urdu perfectly.
At last; I love speaking Urdu and always curious to learn Punjabi, Pashto, Balochi.
We are one❤
Thank you for this video!
Sindhi language is very rich in literature. It is a living and thriving,l.
ادي توهان کي جس هجي، توهان روشن خيال سوچ جي ملڪ آھيو، 🌹♥️
In the linguistic landscape of Pakistan, the Sindhi language stands as a proud emblem of cultural defiance and resilience. While many other linguistic communities in Pakistan have gradually adopted Urdu, the national language, often at the price of their native tongues, the Sindhi people have remained steadfast in preserving their linguistic heritage. This resistance to linguistic assimilation has, however, subjected them to systemic biases and ongoing challenges, particularly from the Urdu-dominated media.
Since the inception of Pakistan, powerful circles have sought to make Urdu the sole national language, associating it with the Islamic identity of the country. This decision was made despite the linguistic similarities between Urdu and Hindi, both of which are essentially the same language differentiated mainly by their scripts-Urdu using the Persian script and Hindi using Devanagari. In contrast, Sindhi, a language deeply rooted in the region's history and culture, has its own unique connection to Islam. It was the first language in which the Holy Quran was translated, and it holds the distinction of using the Arabic script rather than the Persian script.
The Sindhi language, with its rich literary tradition, has been a fundamental part of the region's history for centuries. It predates the establishment of Pakistan and has a profound cultural and religious significance. Sindhi is not just a means of communication; it embodies the identity, heritage, and spiritual life of the Sindhi people.
The Sindhi language’s association with Islam is profound. It was the first language in the Indian subcontinent to have a complete translation of the Holy Quran. This translation dates back to the early Islamic period in the region, underscoring the deep roots of Islam in Sindh. Unlike Urdu, which uses the Persian script, Sindhi uses the Arabic script, making it unique among the languages of the region. This script not only aligns Sindhi more closely with the script of the Holy Quran but also emphasizes its historical connection to the broader Islamic world.
The promotion of Urdu as the sole national language has had significant implications for linguistic diversity in Pakistan. The Sindhi community, in particular, has faced numerous challenges as a result of these policies
Following the creation of Pakistan in 1947, Urdu was promoted as the national language, ostensibly to foster national unity. However, this policy often overlooked the linguistic diversity and the strong regional identities within the country. While many provinces began to shift towards Urdu, the Sindhi community maintained a strong attachment to their native language, ensuring its continued use in education, administration, and daily life.
The Sindhi community's refusal to abandon their linguistic heritage in favor of Urdu has not been without significant repercussions. The most glaring manifestation of the challenges they face is the biased behavior of the Urdu media. The Urdu press and electronic media have often targeted the Sindhi community, perpetuating negative stereotypes and marginalizing their legitimate concerns.
The Urdu media frequently portrays Sindhi issues in a negative light, focusing disproportionately on problems such as political corruption and lawlessness. Positive contributions and the cultural richness of the Sindhi community are often ignored, leading to a skewed and unfair representation.
There is a noticeable absence of Sindhi intellectuals, writers, and activists in mainstream Urdu media. This exclusion limits the visibility of Sindhi perspectives and deprives the national discourse of a more balanced and inclusive narrative.
The dominance of Urdu in media and education has contributed to the erosion of Sindhi culture, particularly among younger generations. The pervasive influence of Urdu-language television, films, and literature has led to a gradual decline in the use of Sindhi, threatening the preservation of its cultural heritage.
The Sindhi language is a vital component of the cultural identity and historical legacy of the Sindhi people. Despite facing systemic biases and challenges, the Sindhi community’s dedication to their language remains unyielding. Promoting linguistic diversity and cultural respect is essential for fostering an inclusive society in Pakistan. It requires concerted efforts from policymakers, media, and civil society to acknowledge and address the injustices faced by linguistic minorities like the Sindhi community. Only through such efforts can Pakistan achieve a truly unified and diverse national identity where all languages and cultures are valued and celebrated.
وہ کیا بات ہے ❤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤
We love our language and culture. Being Sindhi, I would love to share that I myself emphasize my siblings to speak Sindhi in schools and with friends.
❤🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹ہیلو ہم سندھی عبدالمجید سندھی جی لاڑکانہ
I am sindhi Alhamdulillah❤❤❤
Well explained .... as a sindhi i saw that many other people like pinjabis are hassitated talk in punjabi with their punjabi colleague but we sindhi proudly talk to another non sindhi person with sindhi . And they like it which shows we are proud of our langauge .
All punjabis speak Punjabi and are proud of it but they learn urdu as a second language which is the lingua franca in all provinces. That is why punjabis are functional and prospering in all provinces.
ماشاء منھنجی ڀيڻ توهان ڏاڍا سٺا آهيو
جئ واعلیکم السلام موسٹ ویلکم۔ الحمدللہ میں سندھی ہو سندھی زبان پوری سندھ میں بولی جاتی ہے ❤
Hey Misha, I appreciate your Research content and enthusiasm for the Sindhi Language, especially by a lady who comes from a Punjabi-ethnic community. You know, our language is as beautiful as your eyes. :))
❤👏🏻👏🏻🎉
A very well analysed and presented... a comprehensive study. An urgent need for the same study on Sindhi Language /Cultural behaviour of Sindhi people in India.
اردو پاکستان کی قومی زبان ہے لیکن اسے وہ مقام نہیں دیا گیا جس کی وہ حقدار ھے ۔
I always talk My Language Sindhi with Children and Elders friends. I Love my Language
Allhamdulla I'm muslim from Pakistan I'm proud to sindhi my city is Karachi❤❤
Proud to be a human
Am belong from karachi Sindh . Pakistan zindabad ❤
ڀيڻ تمام بهرين ريسرچ وهان ڪئي آهي,اوهان جي محنت کي سلام,جو اوهان اسان جي سنڌي ٻولي تي ريسرچ ڪر ي ڄاڻ ڏني❤آباد هجو
❤ I Love Sindhi.
And I Love Sindhies. Or wo Jo Sindhies se muhabbat krte hen❤
We are salute you. Really great work.
سنڌي ٻولي هڪ قديمي ٻولي آهي، اوهان جو انداز ڳالهائڻ جو تمام سهڻو آهي اوهان جي چهري جو تاثر خوبصورت آهي
The biggest appreciation for this ❤❤❤❤❤
Thank you, glad gou enjoyed it. 💕
Love you I mسندهي 🌺👍🏻🤲🏻
Nice information on how sindhi language develop and use in daily life of sindhies in pakistan when government or rulers use specific language for their administration communication then automatically this language flourish develop and becomes everyone's government of sindh pakistan support sindhi is best thanks
میرے بچپن میں ہمارے گھروں میں خالص سندھی زبان بولی جاتی تھی۔آج کل حیدرآباد اور کراچی میں سندھی اردو مکس زبان بولی جاتی ہے ۔
Good job dear sister zindabad sada salamat raho sindh ki tarhs
سندھی بہت ہی خوبصورت میٹھی زبان ہے ہندوستان کی بہت ہی قدیم ہزاروں سال پہلے سے سندھی قوم سندھی زبان موجود ہے سندھ ہی سے ہند بنا ۔حلانکہ میں سندھی نہیں ہوں میں گرجر ہوں مجھے سندھی زبان بہت پسند ہے
proud to be part of sindhi culture💖🙏
Sindhu Sabhita is my civilization😊
I am Sindhi from khairpur mirs❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Sindhi is well preserved in Sindh province despite the fact that most Urdu-speaking Muhajirs call Karachi and Hyderabad their home.
What do you mean despite the fact Urdu speakers call Karachi and Hyderbad their home? They too have a right to call it their home and they are not conspiring against Sindhi language. You appear to be some random Indian dude who wants to create rifts between ethnicities in Pakistan. Apnay desh mein Muslims aur Urdu Kay khilaf zehar ugalna kaafi Nahin that you have to bring your toxic behaviour here as well?
@@msr7373 do you understand English less or are you high on being a keyboard warrior? When did I say that who has the right or no right to call Karachi their home? The Urdu speaking Muhajirs call Karachi their home is a fact because most Muhajirs from India settled in Karachi. Isn’t it a good thing that both Urdu and Sindhi are thriving in your province? I consider it a good thing, that’s what being cosmopolitan is.
@@msr7373 “despite the fact” specifically means the tolerance of Urdu speaking Muhajirs of Karachi who are the majority in the city, and yet didn’t suppress the Sindhi language, and in fact helped it flourish. nobody has got time for conspiring against Pakistan on UA-cam comments. come out of India America Israel ki saazish mentality and start seeing things with a positive light, it will help reduce the toxic load of your brain.
Proud to be Sindhi from Khairpur Mir's Sindh Pakistan
محترمه تمام شاندار video تمام گھڻيون محبتون سنڌ کان ❤😊
میں سندھی ہوں مجھے اپنی زبان اور کلچر سے پیار ہے😊
I am proud to be sindhi and i am from London ♥️
Thank you, Ma'am, for the well-researched work. I appreciate that most of the parameters are agreeable. The only thing I want to mention is the state of academics in the Sindhi language, which is declining as we advance towards modern and higher education. Unfortunately, after secondary education, our textbooks are mainly not in Sindhi. As a Sindhi person, I wish that we had college-level education as well as official office work in the Sindhi language too.
Very true, but still its commendable how hard the Sindhi community is working to promote their language, but of course there is always room for doing better 💕
Excellent observations please keep up. All languages of our soil are our national languages
Proud to be Sindhi. I love Sindhi language
Thanks for researching on Sindhi language....from a common Sindhi