Ah yes, the Warrior of Light, accomplished doctor and physician. Running around in a bikini, stilettoes and sometimes acts like they didn't make it past fifth grade.
The minute Akasha was talked about in Endwalker I was like, “holy shit, that’s just like Dancer’s job quests” and then Dynamis came into story focus and I spent the whole time shaking my fist at Ishikawa because I can’t not believe the totentanz isn’t directly related to dynamis
Yeah, Dynamis was kinda ham fisted in by Endwalker. They could ruin entire books worth of established lore if they don't handle this new power source correctly.
@@thepurpleshade486 Endwalker did a lot right, I liked it! But the writers also took many more liberties than I thought they should have with what was the "final scene." I enjoyed it, doesn't mean I liked everything about it.
Honestly, it could be easy to have the characters reflect on their jobs and come to realize the deeper reasoning behind certain powers and phenomenon! Why the Abyss manifests personalities based on one’s emotional states and needs. The Tortentanz, etc! We haven’t explored the full depth of how Dynamis truly interacts with Aether, not why prayer is such a powerful tool to mortal races! If the writers take care to explore how the two interact we could see much more depth to the word!
Dark Knight and Reaper cross by each other in the street: "Same ostracization by the very society you protect?" "Same ostracization by the very society you protect!"
I love the Tottentanz and the "dynamis Transformations" are so similar in cause. both root from innate aether disruption, unease, anxieties, and hate. both cause the victims to lash out and attack loved ones, may cause transformations (though Tottentanz transforms the emotions into a physical manifestation more than fully transforming the affecter person) and eventually die
Possible spoiler Actually, the Tottentanz might be better seen as something more similar to the first Final days. In the first Final Days, Dynamis turned an innate capability of man (creation magic) into a destructive force. The Tottentanz also turned an innate capability of man (movement and muscles) into a destructive force. Perhaps a small amount of Meteion's Dyanmis was still leaking through Zodiark's aether layer.
Seriously! It’s such a missed opportunity to foreshadow dynamis… So much so that I made a fix-it fic about it, tying the two together. (Shameless plug: it’s called “Totentanz to the Song of Despair” on AO3)
Random thought: What if the voidsent that Reapers form pacts with are in fact their counterparts from the Thirteenth? It's a possibility and would possibly explain why the voidsent might be cooperative?
and this is the sad result of the writing staff of FF 14 stopping Job specific quest lines. :/ a lack of much needed lore. I mean part of the reason I've played Dark Knight for as long as I have, is the lore behind it. and the promise of potential new lore from new Job Quests, and the short intros we get now, that last a single 10 level stretch aren't doing Reaper or Sage any favors, especially Reaper, who DESPERATELY needs the added depth beyond 'shadow protectors wielding dark powers', cause so far, the Job Quests for it aren't it chief.
I really hope the new void stories help explain how Reapers are able to safely make a pact with and/or control their avatar. As far as I’m aware, they are the ONLY case of making a pact with voidsent NOT going terribly awry
Don’t feed into it more than you’re willing to personally give and you should be safe. Safe being relative because the contract is in place for your “safety” hence the avatar acting as intermediary. Aether is all voidsent care to have from you and don’t give more than you can part with.
@@navyflyboy07 Nope. She's just a former Azem, not the former version of us. There was a different Azem at the time of The Final Days (who was us). Venat was one of the rare Conclave members that didn't return to the life stream (instead, just becoming more or less a "free" Azem).
@@KnTenshi2To be fair, she was our teacher. And we show talent in any fighting style, with any weapon. We being so similar to the unsundered Azem it makes you wonder if he was taught by her to be as diversed in combat, or if she chose him as her apprentice because, like her, he showed proficiency in combat regardless of the weapon.
Thank you so much for your support! I really do hope to share what I find with as many players as possible, whether it be FFXIV lore or any other kind of story telling!
I feel like "The best way to beat (X Job) is always a large efficient military." is just always true for all of the Jobs. No matter how powerful a single individual... they arent invincible.
I hope you cover the origins of the Monk sometime! I'd love to have a collated source of information on their origins and history that isn't a certain insufferably smug professor who shall remain nameless...
Actually Totentanz is translated to "Dance of the Dead"/"Danse Macabre", not "Dance of Death". It's an allegory of that Death influenced the living like we dance in his palms like our dead ancestors did and in death we are all equal (the rich, the poor, the saint, the sinner, the king, the priest). The pictures of Totentanz appeared more often after calamities, plagues, war or after other events of mass death as reminder. This feeling of loss, of fear and lonliness that the survivors felt while mimicking the dance of their loved ones with the Death. This dance is mockery to the living ones, as normally a dance is sign to be alive. So it make sense to challenge a dance with another dance.
I'm going to give a few Gunbreaker questions as speculation and I stress that, and this is a lore channel so I assume people know what their getting into, this may be spoiler-ish about a certain aspect of the Garleans themselves. But through the Stormblood expansion it's revealed that they as a people generally lack the physical capabilities to manipulate aether, hence why their civilizations power has come mainly through the development of technology like magitek. At some point in time they integrated the combat school the Gunbreakers developed, but even then certain characters have pointed out that it's a hollow imitation. You'd think they would have altered the core aspects of it's design because the gun is supposed to be charged by ones own aether, which is something the Garleans aren't easily disposed to. And that brings up the better question of why did this style catch on with many of the higher ranked soldiers (at least from what I can discern is the case)?
The reason Gunbreaker(or the imitation of Gunbreaker) caught on so easily was because the barrier to entry was low when compared to most jobs. Of course, Garleans can't fill the rounds with aether as expected because of their disability. However, nothing was stopping magitek from creating these enchanted rounds for them. So by stealing some of the Gunbreakers style they were able to create a faux form of magic by releasing aether from their weapons mid combat. A Gunbreaker is trying to be an explosive siege weapon, a Garlean soldier is trying to mimic magic.
I will honestly be dissapointed if the third lorebook will go for the "all gunbreakers load manually" instead of drawing aether during combat into their gunblade like in the gameplay mechanics to keep their fight going. Because it will bring the jobs prestige down by lowering it down to Thancreds level of unable to manipulate aether. Such an ancient job and weapon system from the Allagan times relying on a manual reload during combat would be clunky and inefficient. And just by having them "Be able to infuse their own bullets kek" would be such a heartbreaking thing.
I find it funny how slapstick incompetent gunbreakers are in lore... created to defeat the allagans... were beaten, became bozja's royal guard... the queen was assassinated, became protectors of the kingdom... the kingdom fell, and then they end up as common bodyguards begging for work on the streets
To be fair! They were constantly put up against the worlds greatest superpowers, and the queen went insane. They are just unlucky but are still very dangerous I mean I didn’t hear the monks going up against the empire. Hell they were almost wiped out by the mad king. Plus most jobs have a less than favorable past, the white and black mages caused a calamity. Warriors are super dangerous in that they can cause you to go berserk and kill your friends. dragoons were only created because of a tragedy from years ago where thordan betrayed the dragons then the churches lied about it for years.
@restlessundead9366 Lorewise, they feel like a jack of all trades, master of none. They have good survivability and a few shields, but can't block, heal, or empower from damage as well as other tanks can. In return, they deal more damage, and have more intricate attack patterns than the other jobs. But they don't perform as well as other jobs meant for offense.
Well if RP in FF14 has thought me anything its that everything in this video is false :D according to your average RP-er; RPR- Edgy Vampire GNB- swearing 9 year old mercenary Sage - It's just one of my 20 jobs Dancer- Sex craving crazed monogamous coomer
@@SynodicScribe It didnt used to be like this, in 2.0-3.0 RPers actually put in the research to make a character that fit into the world. Now its nightclub RP, Leather jackets, and baseball caps. Literally made me quit rping and start PvPing. So I can crush these normies in honorable combat.
@@Zoeila but there are surviving WoL from the 13th. Unukalhai and Cyella. and they didnt cause the Flood of Darkness. they failed to stop it because of a very overeager Ascian
@@Zoeila There's a difference between the title of "Warrior of Light" and actually BEING the same person as the WoL we play as. "Warrior of Light" is simply given to heroes of great import throughout history, and not all of them had the Blessing of Light or the Echo. This is explained in Shadowbringers, when you speak with the librarian to ask after the First's Warriors of Light (there were several, all considered Warriors of Light).
@@Zoeila but they literally are the 13th's Warriors of Light? they only failed because their modus operandi as WoL were to operate independently. and they started to heed their calling at different ages. That's why Unukalhai (iirc, he was the Earth Crystal holder of their reflection, and this is another can of worms) is so young compared to Cyella.
Now that I know more about dancer: SPOILER!!! When Endwalker starts endwalking in Thavnair, if you're playing a Dancer, does your WOL dance during any of the cut scenes? It seems like Dancers are trained to deal with a very similar scenario. It's a shame and an oversight if you don't.
Odd. As far as I understand "Krieg" and "Toten" are German words. But Radz-at-Han is highly Indian inspired. So why is there German sounding words in a job from a land inspired by India?
I live how you dislike the idea of Dynamis so much you refuse to even entertain the idea in any of the theories presented here even when it comes to the dancer.
Dynamis is something they hinted towards, but honestly it's a massive plot device we have zero idea how it works other that it works off intense emotions.
![[FFXIV] Five Mistakes Tanks Make!](/img/n.gif)
Ah yes, the Warrior of Light, accomplished doctor and physician. Running around in a bikini, stilettoes and sometimes acts like they didn't make it past fifth grade.
I doubt anyone would say the WoL was a good source for lore. lol
But he’s/she’s definitely a source of interesting tales
Look they're currently putting all their brain power into getting their bunny hood and law degree. Not necessarily in that order.
The minute Akasha was talked about in Endwalker I was like, “holy shit, that’s just like Dancer’s job quests” and then Dynamis came into story focus and I spent the whole time shaking my fist at Ishikawa because I can’t not believe the totentanz isn’t directly related to dynamis
Yeah, Dynamis was kinda ham fisted in by Endwalker. They could ruin entire books worth of established lore if they don't handle this new power source correctly.
@@SynodicScribe do you like end walker? this is the second of your posts saying it could ruin lore
@@thepurpleshade486 Endwalker did a lot right, I liked it! But the writers also took many more liberties than I thought they should have with what was the "final scene." I enjoyed it, doesn't mean I liked everything about it.
Honestly, it could be easy to have the characters reflect on their jobs and come to realize the deeper reasoning behind certain powers and phenomenon!
Why the Abyss manifests personalities based on one’s emotional states and needs. The Tortentanz, etc!
We haven’t explored the full depth of how Dynamis truly interacts with Aether, not why prayer is such a powerful tool to mortal races! If the writers take care to explore how the two interact we could see much more depth to the word!
Dark Knight and Reaper cross by each other in the street:
"Same ostracization by the very society you protect?" "Same ostracization by the very society you protect!"
DRK and RPR truly are like lost brothers. Both even have a headmate !
To be fair Reaper was never Ostracized, they stuck to the shadows by choice
@@dakotadoyle7573 They kind of are a mix of DRK and Ninja
MOOD KINDRED!
@@et3inuyasha MOOD KINDRED?!
To be fair for the gunbreakers, most other classes were not straight up trying to ward off the world's greatest superpowers.
Seeing your character dance is quite hilarious scholar by day Dancer by night
How else are they going to pay off their student loans? 😅
I love the Tottentanz and the "dynamis Transformations" are so similar in cause. both root from innate aether disruption, unease, anxieties, and hate. both cause the victims to lash out and attack loved ones, may cause transformations (though Tottentanz transforms the emotions into a physical manifestation more than fully transforming the affecter person) and eventually die
Possible spoiler
I spent a lot of mid endwalker screaming at my monitor as a dancer main. I’ve seen this before someone listen to me lol!
Possible spoiler
Actually, the Tottentanz might be better seen as something more similar to the first Final days.
In the first Final Days, Dynamis turned an innate capability of man (creation magic) into a destructive force. The Tottentanz also turned an innate capability of man (movement and muscles) into a destructive force. Perhaps a small amount of Meteion's Dyanmis was still leaking through Zodiark's aether layer.
Seriously! It’s such a missed opportunity to foreshadow dynamis… So much so that I made a fix-it fic about it, tying the two together.
(Shameless plug: it’s called “Totentanz to the Song of Despair” on AO3)
I for one would love the Idea of a Sage using their weapons to write on massive chalkboards
It's possible.
Just duct tape chalk to the ends of their Nouliths lol
I'm still waiting for deeper lore about my fav class Gunbreaker :3
Random thought: What if the voidsent that Reapers form pacts with are in fact their counterparts from the Thirteenth?
It's a possibility and would possibly explain why the voidsent might be cooperative?
That theory has been floating around for sure, but there's nothing solid to work with yet.
and this is the sad result of the writing staff of FF 14 stopping Job specific quest lines. :/ a lack of much needed lore. I mean part of the reason I've played Dark Knight for as long as I have, is the lore behind it. and the promise of potential new lore from new Job Quests, and the short intros we get now, that last a single 10 level stretch aren't doing Reaper or Sage any favors, especially Reaper, who DESPERATELY needs the added depth beyond 'shadow protectors wielding dark powers', cause so far, the Job Quests for it aren't it chief.
We might get more information with the upcoming relic quests in the future.
I really hope the new void stories help explain how Reapers are able to safely make a pact with and/or control their avatar. As far as I’m aware, they are the ONLY case of making a pact with voidsent NOT going terribly awry
Don’t feed into it more than you’re willing to personally give and you should be safe. Safe being relative because the contract is in place for your “safety” hence the avatar acting as intermediary. Aether is all voidsent care to have from you and don’t give more than you can part with.
Given that venat uses dancer skills and azeyma uses war fans and Thavnair's religious belief about enduring suffering i wonder....
Venat uses everything. She IS us
@@navyflyboy07 Nope. She's just a former Azem, not the former version of us. There was a different Azem at the time of The Final Days (who was us). Venat was one of the rare Conclave members that didn't return to the life stream (instead, just becoming more or less a "free" Azem).
@@KnTenshi2To be fair, she was our teacher. And we show talent in any fighting style, with any weapon. We being so similar to the unsundered Azem it makes you wonder if he was taught by her to be as diversed in combat, or if she chose him as her apprentice because, like her, he showed proficiency in combat regardless of the weapon.
Some of the best Lore vids out there, thanks for doing what you do, my dude. You've earned a sub.
Thank you so much for your support! I really do hope to share what I find with as many players as possible, whether it be FFXIV lore or any other kind of story telling!
I feel like "The best way to beat (X Job) is always a large efficient military." is just always true for all of the Jobs. No matter how powerful a single individual... they arent invincible.
Regarding about Sage, I'm not sure if this is relevant but Grandpa is a sage, thus I always think Sage is a job from Sharlyan.
When your done with the jobs, I would love to see some lore video’s on the different beast tribes.
Yeah I haven't touched any of them after the Sahagin video. Which ARR Beast tribe would you like to see next?
@@SynodicScribe probably the Amalj'aa.
I hope you cover the origins of the Monk sometime! I'd love to have a collated source of information on their origins and history that isn't a certain insufferably smug professor who shall remain nameless...
Actually that's happening later this week
@@SynodicScribe Oooh, excellent! I'll look forward to that then :)
Actually Totentanz is translated to "Dance of the Dead"/"Danse Macabre", not "Dance of Death". It's an allegory of that Death influenced the living like we dance in his palms like our dead ancestors did and in death we are all equal (the rich, the poor, the saint, the sinner, the king, the priest). The pictures of Totentanz appeared more often after calamities, plagues, war or after other events of mass death as reminder. This feeling of loss, of fear and lonliness that the survivors felt while mimicking the dance of their loved ones with the Death. This dance is mockery to the living ones, as normally a dance is sign to be alive. So it make sense to challenge a dance with another dance.
Can we have a video on ivalice lore in ffxiv and in depth looked into gunhilder’s blades
I'm going to give a few Gunbreaker questions as speculation and I stress that, and this is a lore channel so I assume people know what their getting into, this may be spoiler-ish about a certain aspect of the Garleans themselves. But through the Stormblood expansion it's revealed that they as a people generally lack the physical capabilities to manipulate aether, hence why their civilizations power has come mainly through the development of technology like magitek. At some point in time they integrated the combat school the Gunbreakers developed, but even then certain characters have pointed out that it's a hollow imitation. You'd think they would have altered the core aspects of it's design because the gun is supposed to be charged by ones own aether, which is something the Garleans aren't easily disposed to. And that brings up the better question of why did this style catch on with many of the higher ranked soldiers (at least from what I can discern is the case)?
The reason Gunbreaker(or the imitation of Gunbreaker) caught on so easily was because the barrier to entry was low when compared to most jobs. Of course, Garleans can't fill the rounds with aether as expected because of their disability. However, nothing was stopping magitek from creating these enchanted rounds for them. So by stealing some of the Gunbreakers style they were able to create a faux form of magic by releasing aether from their weapons mid combat. A Gunbreaker is trying to be an explosive siege weapon, a Garlean soldier is trying to mimic magic.
@@SynodicScribe That makes sense and thanks for the anwers!
I will honestly be dissapointed if the third lorebook will go for the "all gunbreakers load manually" instead of drawing aether during combat into their gunblade like in the gameplay mechanics to keep their fight going. Because it will bring the jobs prestige down by lowering it down to Thancreds level of unable to manipulate aether. Such an ancient job and weapon system from the Allagan times relying on a manual reload during combat would be clunky and inefficient. And just by having them "Be able to infuse their own bullets kek" would be such a heartbreaking thing.
I find it funny how slapstick incompetent gunbreakers are in lore... created to defeat the allagans... were beaten, became bozja's royal guard... the queen was assassinated, became protectors of the kingdom... the kingdom fell, and then they end up as common bodyguards begging for work on the streets
To be fair! They were constantly put up against the worlds greatest superpowers, and the queen went insane. They are just unlucky but are still very dangerous I mean I didn’t hear the monks going up against the empire. Hell they were almost wiped out by the mad king. Plus most jobs have a less than favorable past, the white and black mages caused a calamity. Warriors are super dangerous in that they can cause you to go berserk and kill your friends. dragoons were only created because of a tragedy from years ago where thordan betrayed the dragons then the churches lied about it for years.
@restlessundead9366 Lorewise, they feel like a jack of all trades, master of none. They have good survivability and a few shields, but can't block, heal, or empower from damage as well as other tanks can.
In return, they deal more damage, and have more intricate attack patterns than the other jobs. But they don't perform as well as other jobs meant for offense.
Your videos on lore are the best I've seen please keep up the good work!
Perhaps on the next relic quest. we may get more information on some of these jobs.
Notes on Sage:
_"It's not Nocturnal Astrologian"_
Sigh
Well if RP in FF14 has thought me anything its that everything in this video is false :D according to your average RP-er;
RPR- Edgy Vampire
GNB- swearing 9 year old mercenary
Sage - It's just one of my 20 jobs
Dancer- Sex craving crazed monogamous coomer
Yeesh. I try not to judge but stuff like that makes it hard not to. O.o
@@SynodicScribe It didnt used to be like this, in 2.0-3.0 RPers actually put in the research to make a character that fit into the world.
Now its nightclub RP, Leather jackets, and baseball caps. Literally made me quit rping and start PvPing. So I can crush these normies in honorable combat.
@@BongSwansong We've prolly fought side by side in PvP then! Or against one another. lol
@@SynodicScribe Depending on the data center we might have been allies and never known! Ha! Crystal-Balmung btw.
Like, subscribed, and commented. Your videos are insightful and amazing. Keep it up!!
Omg a week ago I asked on the comments for reaper >.< thank you so much! Monk next? *coughs coughs*
what if avatars are reapers' reflections from the 13 shard?
Impossible the wol of the 13th caused the flood of darkness and likely became some sort of dark eden
@@Zoeila but there are surviving WoL from the 13th. Unukalhai and Cyella. and they didnt cause the Flood of Darkness. they failed to stop it because of a very overeager Ascian
@@youiri65 calling them wol is like calling the scions warriors of light
@@Zoeila There's a difference between the title of "Warrior of Light" and actually BEING the same person as the WoL we play as. "Warrior of Light" is simply given to heroes of great import throughout history, and not all of them had the Blessing of Light or the Echo. This is explained in Shadowbringers, when you speak with the librarian to ask after the First's Warriors of Light (there were several, all considered Warriors of Light).
@@Zoeila but they literally are the 13th's Warriors of Light? they only failed because their modus operandi as WoL were to operate independently. and they started to heed their calling at different ages. That's why Unukalhai (iirc, he was the Earth Crystal holder of their reflection, and this is another can of worms) is so young compared to Cyella.
Love the video keep em coming bro
I'll do my best! Thanks for watching!
Amazing video great job!! Edit: I love lore
Damn where do i get that cool mask you have on. Remonds me of zodiark
Sunken Temple of Qarn
Now that I know more about dancer:
SPOILER!!!
When Endwalker starts endwalking in Thavnair, if you're playing a Dancer, does your WOL dance during any of the cut scenes? It seems like Dancers are trained to deal with a very similar scenario. It's a shame and an oversight if you don't.
11:00 fabulous
Odd. As far as I understand "Krieg" and "Toten" are German words. But Radz-at-Han is highly Indian inspired. So why is there German sounding words in a job from a land inspired by India?
FFXIV uses all our worlds languages all over their world. It's crazy. lol
Thank you
What is this "doctor" profession? Do you mean chirurgeon?
When's What It Means To Be a Blue Mage?
Why aren't you doing monk yet?
Cause that's next weeks video. Patience my friend.
I live how you dislike the idea of Dynamis so much you refuse to even entertain the idea in any of the theories presented here even when it comes to the dancer.
Because Dynamis is still untested. We simply know it exists, no freaking clue how it interacts with us yet.
Dynamis is something they hinted towards, but honestly it's a massive plot device we have zero idea how it works other that it works off intense emotions.