TCW: The Continuity Wars - Episode 1

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 18 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 85

  • @darthprime1990
    @darthprime1990 3 дні тому +16

    Thanks for sharing this. It shows how little George was involved with TCW.

    • @Star-Wars-Skran
      @Star-Wars-Skran  3 дні тому +8

      @@darthprime1990 no problem I will be doing one for each season

  • @darthlucasfuu
    @darthlucasfuu 3 дні тому +13

    "The great question is: Why would a great General allow himself to be sabotaged rebuilt as a robot and then just become subservient to someone like Dooku?"
    I don't know, maybe the saboters forgeted to tell him before, you know, that they would sabotage him?!?! The thing is, Grievous didn't knew who had did this to him, and Dooku, who basically saved his life, had told him that all this was the Repubic's and the Jedi's fault. So, he being subservient on Dooku actually makes a lot of sense, I mean, revenge blinded him to the point of he served his own detractor and own assassin, even if he don't know it, making his a very tragic story on how the darkside blinds and twisted everything around, to it's own selfish desire, even with the ones who cannot touch the Force directlly!
    This change shows us how pathetic Star Wars was to become in Filoni's hand...

    • @Star-Wars-Skran
      @Star-Wars-Skran  3 дні тому +7

      @@darthlucasfuu exactly!!! Don’t apply logic to Filoni’s writing you’ll go mad!

  • @MaraJSkywalker
    @MaraJSkywalker 3 дні тому +13

    Excellent video. Well put together and full of undeniable evidence of fioni's deliberate destruction and disregard of lore and George's vision. I hope you do a video focusing specifically on TCW's bastardization of Mandalorians and their world and culture and how it made Karen Traviss quit Star Wars with her last Republic Commando book unfinished. The worst by far of filoni's many offences imo. And since RC is my absolute favorite series I am mad as hell to this day.

    • @Star-Wars-Skran
      @Star-Wars-Skran  3 дні тому +7

      @@MaraJSkywalker thank you I appreciate this! That is something that I am aware of , thanks for mentioning it here!!!

    • @StarWarsMarvelPurist
      @StarWarsMarvelPurist 3 дні тому +6

      Hell yeah! I give Karen Traviss a lot of respect for that! I always try to share this with people because she's one of the few who didn't sell out to the mouse.

  • @ironinquisitor3656
    @ironinquisitor3656 3 дні тому +8

    Can't wait for more episodes!

    • @Star-Wars-Skran
      @Star-Wars-Skran  3 дні тому +3

      @@ironinquisitor3656 yes bud I will be doing it for each season, the footage speaks for itself !

  • @davidb9639
    @davidb9639 3 дні тому +12

    "Just scribbled on a page."
    Wow. I remember getting picked on for preferring reading to sports in high school; I didn't think this kind of bibliophobia would continue into my adulthood.

    • @Star-Wars-Skran
      @Star-Wars-Skran  3 дні тому +4

      @@davidb9639 it’s so disrespectful to what came before

  • @gordonmacdonald6442
    @gordonmacdonald6442 3 дні тому +7

    Filoni can't even remember that Aayla Secura was on screen for 3 separate occasions prior to his trash TCW!! She was first on screen in Ep.2 AOTC during the Petranaki Arena battle on Geonosis, the second time was during the 2003-2005 Clone Wars TV microseries, such as the Battle of Hypori where they barely survived against the newly revealed Grievous, and the third was of course a few scenes in Ep. 3 ROTS such as High Council meetings and the Battle of Felucia!

  • @SolurVoludun
    @SolurVoludun 2 дні тому +5

    6:40
    Somewhere out there, a Starlog quoter is having a meltdown

    • @Star-Wars-Skran
      @Star-Wars-Skran  2 дні тому +4

      @@SolurVoludun haha you bet they are 🤣🔥🍻

  • @theD3CR3P1Tone
    @theD3CR3P1Tone 3 дні тому +8

    Dave Filoni ignored what was established to recreate the StarWars universe in his own image. What we see today are the planted fruition of the seeds he implemented many years ago. Hes a diabolical entity. Resembles Palpatine in many mannerisms. How... ironic....

    • @Star-Wars-Skran
      @Star-Wars-Skran  3 дні тому +3

      @@theD3CR3P1Tone well said bro, he set it up and now he’s continuing his version of star wars

    • @SithMaster-w8w
      @SithMaster-w8w 3 дні тому +3

      He truly is the sith lord we've been looking for...

  • @scott_johnson_
    @scott_johnson_ 3 дні тому +5

    Great job with this.

    • @Star-Wars-Skran
      @Star-Wars-Skran  3 дні тому +3

      @@scott_johnson_ thank you Scott!!! It’s soul destroying listening to Filoni lie about canon

  • @EzrasJunkyard
    @EzrasJunkyard 3 дні тому +3

    Really good credible hard working content! Excellent video - you’re going straight to the top buddy. I can sense it. You’re a natural at this 🔥

    • @Star-Wars-Skran
      @Star-Wars-Skran  3 дні тому

      @EzrasJunkyard thanks Ezra!!! My goal isn’t to make people hate this show it’s just to point out the misconception that it is more legitimate than the rest of the EU, George Lucas had a hand in all of Star Wars. This show just happened to ignore the rest of the continuity that had been carefully crafted.
      And I think it’s where a lot of the issues began which have spread into the Disney era. You rock man!!

    • @Star-Wars-Skran
      @Star-Wars-Skran  3 дні тому

      Also I said on my live stream last night I will be covering the Ewok movies soon on the channel 🔥

    • @Star-Wars-Skran
      @Star-Wars-Skran  3 дні тому

      Your channel is also preserving Lucas era Star Wars as you covering the old Lucas arts games and you talk extensively about the Ewoks and old action figures, it’s great stuff!!! We all do our part !

  • @gordonmacdonald6442
    @gordonmacdonald6442 3 дні тому +7

    It's kinda funny how the reason why Gendy Tartakovsky was let go from leading TCW is because GL told him he didn't want to make a film at that point in time, only wanting to focus on TV shows, then when Filoni was put in charge, the first thing they made was a movie!!!

  • @gordonmacdonald6442
    @gordonmacdonald6442 3 дні тому +13

    It's baffling just how willfully ignorant Filoni and his team were in regards to the EU and CWMMP!!! They actually said Plo Koon and Luminara Unduli sat around and did nothing and were a clean slate for them to play with, along with getting the EU backstory for Greivous way wrong, then deciding to completely change it!!! It's maddeningly frustrating how people mindlessly gobble his slop up and think it's good!!!!

  • @gordonmacdonald6442
    @gordonmacdonald6442 3 дні тому +4

    Luminara Unduli, along with her padawan Bariss Offee, courageously and successfully defended the sacred Jedi Temple on Illum against the dastardly Separatist plot to completely destroy it using special stealth droids to blow it up, in an attempt to deprive the Jedi of their precious Adegan/Kyber crystals and thus delivering a severe blow to morale! Not to mention other instances of her honorable service prior to and during the Clone War!!!

  • @BrandontheAwesome
    @BrandontheAwesome 3 дні тому +4

    This... is how it happened.
    This is how Star Wars died.

    • @SolurVoludun
      @SolurVoludun 3 дні тому

      I’d say it was the beginning of the end for Star Wars.
      When Star Wars was poisoned and then given the coup de grâce by the Mouse in 2012… only for them to unbury the corpse and begin raping it in 2014

  • @gordonmacdonald6442
    @gordonmacdonald6442 3 дні тому +4

    Thank you, Skran, for making this video to help show other people just how fraudulent Filoni and his team were whilst making the canon/continuity breaking TCW!!! More people need to see it!!

    • @Star-Wars-Skran
      @Star-Wars-Skran  3 дні тому +2

      @@gordonmacdonald6442 thanks for sharing background about the characters Gordon! It’s shameful that they disregarded the EU. Just like Disney they pretended that they were the first to develop these characters while taking from the EU.

    • @gordonmacdonald6442
      @gordonmacdonald6442 3 дні тому +1

      ​@Star-Wars-Skran EXACTLY!! And you're most welcome! I relish every chance I get to discuss GL SW!! Opportunities in my day to day life outside of the internet are very seldom indeed!!

  • @m.e.3251
    @m.e.3251 День тому

    I love that you compiled all this! And I look forward to seeing more of these.
    I would really appreciate if you shared your sources for everything. (Please and Thank You!)

    • @Star-Wars-Skran
      @Star-Wars-Skran  День тому +1

      @@m.e.3251 thank you so much I appreciate that!!!
      I plan on doing it for each season.
      I’ve never thought of listing all of the sources, a lot of this stuff is hard to find these days.
      My channel is a way for me to preserve the original continuity of Star Wars 😊

    • @Star-Wars-Skran
      @Star-Wars-Skran  День тому +1

      @@m.e.3251 in this particular video the audio from George comes from his appearance at Star Wars celebration 3 in 2005.
      The audio with Filoni is from an interview with rebel force radio.
      The quotes I highlighted from George are actually easy to find if you type it into google.
      The footage is compiled from the TCW season one dvd
      The stuff from the original 2003 micro series is from that dvd as well 👍

    • @m.e.3251
      @m.e.3251 День тому

      @@Star-Wars-Skran Oh yeah, I know first hand how hard it is to find this stuff, since I look for it too. Which is why I appreciate so much when sources are shared! Makes it easier to research the topic further myself.🙂
      Thank you!

    • @Star-Wars-Skran
      @Star-Wars-Skran  День тому

      @@m.e.3251 no problem !! And if you want to use anything from my videos feel free! I recognise your pfp from imyouralibi, I love that channel and how you both analyse ahsoka in TCW and how she’s not a well written character!!

    • @m.e.3251
      @m.e.3251 День тому

      @@Star-Wars-Skran Glad to hear you enjoy our channel! Thanks!☺

  • @Captain-Thievius
    @Captain-Thievius 3 дні тому +5

    I have no idea what Lucas was thinking by having TCW become a thing and be given special treatment. The Clone Wars Micro Series needed to play by the same rules as everyone else, but TCW was allowed to bulldoze anything and everything.

    • @Star-Wars-Skran
      @Star-Wars-Skran  3 дні тому +5

      @@Captain-Thievius I personally think Filoni took something George said out of context and George was already distancing himself at this point. I’d take most of what Filoni says with a pinch of salt as he likes to appeal to authority by using George’s name to justify things

    • @Captain-Thievius
      @Captain-Thievius 3 дні тому +4

      @@Star-Wars-Skran No doubts there on Filoni. He’ll say anything to excuse his bad writing and lack of respect for continuity.

  • @gordonmacdonald6442
    @gordonmacdonald6442 3 дні тому +5

    Filoni not only completely disregarded (and continuously ripped off of) the EU, but also ignored well established lore facts set forth in the 6 movies!! Case in point, the stupid inhibitor chips and his "Jedi influence" over the clones directly contradicts what was stated in Ep. 2 AOTC!!! He couldn't even remember that Padme and Shmi had not only met each other but spent about 3 days together in Ep. 1 TPM!!!

  • @gordonmacdonald6442
    @gordonmacdonald6442 3 дні тому +4

    12 years prior to TPM, Plo Koon served admirably on the battlefields of the Stark Hyperspace Conflict, grabbing up the fallen Republic banner and gallantly waving it to rally the scattered troops! Not to mention his service during the bloody Yinchorri Uprising and the Eriadu Summit about a year prior to the events of TPM! He even created his own Force ability called "Electric Judgment" (yellow Force Lightning), and was one of the very few highly skilled pilots within the Jedi Order, who gave Anakin his famous Azure Angel! Plo Koons' niece was also a very skilled Jedi within the order at that time!!!

  • @stigkenobi7525
    @stigkenobi7525 3 дні тому +5

    Filoni destroyed SW before Kennedy was even involved. Sadly: idiots cheered it on.

    • @Star-Wars-Skran
      @Star-Wars-Skran  3 дні тому

      @stigkenobi7525 for many it only counts if it’s on screen

  • @gordonmacdonald6442
    @gordonmacdonald6442 3 дні тому +4

    I'm pretty sure it was George who first said that the Jedi aren't supposed to be "super heroes with unlimited powers," and they're trying to paint it like Dave was the one who said that!!

    • @Star-Wars-Skran
      @Star-Wars-Skran  3 дні тому +3

      @@gordonmacdonald6442 exactly, they talk like Filoni is so wise when he’s just repeating things that george said

  • @BrandontheAwesome
    @BrandontheAwesome 3 дні тому +12

    Couple this with the fact Filoni is a liar who went behind George's back and kept his Mary Sue alive!

    • @countcampula
      @countcampula 2 дні тому +3

      It's not really a Mary Sue if they show their progress (and their consistent flaws)
      Then it's just a character

    • @FMK03
      @FMK03 День тому

      @@countcampula BS, the character in and of herself isn't all that good. I highly recommend @carolusmagnus1871 "How Ahsoka's Overrated" video along with @imyouralibi6208 "Anti-Ahsoka" and "Fixing Ahsoka" series or playlists and @imyouralibi6208 "A Writer's Response to Lore Star" video.
      All 4 of those show why and how Ahsoka's a Mary Sue, the first shows her Mary Sueness and the last recommendation shows how she wasn't developed in the least.

  • @chewy99.
    @chewy99. 2 дні тому +1

    The old EU was always tiered, things could be changed and there were always plenty of contradictions. What makes me mad about Filoni is how he’s treated and talks about the new canon that was announced as, is said to be, and is supposed to be one canon where it’s all equally “real” and no media can just overwrite another.

    • @Star-Wars-Skran
      @Star-Wars-Skran  2 дні тому

      @@chewy99. I have a video that explains how the eu you worked in coordination with George.
      The new continuity was said to be all coherent but was immediately contradicted.
      He doesn’t adhere to pre established continuity or even the Disney continuity.
      Here you go bud
      ua-cam.com/video/boqEI-zb76g/v-deo.htmlsi=e2K5pO_JddRgIUfR

  • @gordonmacdonald6442
    @gordonmacdonald6442 3 дні тому +2

    Where was Leeland Chee during all of this mess??? His job description was quite literally to make sure everything maintained a singular continuity!!! What a mess!!! Why even keep him on at that point, if "SW is like a campfire story that you can change with each telling," according to Filoni, who was apparently left alone and in charge!!!

  • @BrandontheAwesome
    @BrandontheAwesome 3 дні тому +2

    Huh, funny how Official Rave Blitz seems to never comment on these videos, despite him being the biggest Filoni glazer on the Internet.
    Guess he knows whens he's beat.

  • @StarWarsMarvelPurist
    @StarWarsMarvelPurist 3 дні тому +4

    Great video dude!! Anyone reading this comment Subscribe and SHARE this video and channel out. Very thoughtful and well edited. 🍻

    • @Star-Wars-Skran
      @Star-Wars-Skran  3 дні тому +3

      @@StarWarsMarvelPurist thanks dude I knew you would appreciate it!
      Plenty more to come 🔥

    • @BrandontheAwesome
      @BrandontheAwesome 3 дні тому +2

      Already did so!

  • @matthewgaudet4064
    @matthewgaudet4064 3 дні тому +5

    Filoni destroyed Star Wars canon.

    • @Star-Wars-Skran
      @Star-Wars-Skran  3 дні тому +4

      @@matthewgaudet4064 I completely agree

    • @matthewgaudet4064
      @matthewgaudet4064 3 дні тому +2

      @@Star-Wars-Skran , scribbles in a comic. I bet you he never even read Star Wars Outlander with Aurra Sing.

  • @DarthPawz
    @DarthPawz 3 дні тому +24

    TCW was the start of the downfall of Star Wars

    • @Star-Wars-Skran
      @Star-Wars-Skran  3 дні тому +9

      @@DarthPawz correct, it helped destroy continuity before Disney got their hands on it

    • @DarthPawz
      @DarthPawz 3 дні тому +9

      @@Star-Wars-Skran This might be a “Star Wars Theory” but I think Dave was destroying the lore on purpose so he can introduce his own characters. Maybe Dave knew that George was selling soon, so Dave wanted to continue his “story”.

    • @Star-Wars-Skran
      @Star-Wars-Skran  3 дні тому +4

      @ well it was supposed to be a continuation from 2003 microseries. George distanced himself and Dave was basically in control, hopefully this video shows to what extent Filoni had power over the development. He claims to have presented George with EU but that is weird concerning things like grievious background where George was already heavily involved

    • @MaraJSkywalker
      @MaraJSkywalker 3 дні тому +3

      The first death blow to SW, the first reboot years before diznee's. I wouldn't be surprised if filoni destroyed the lore not just due to his own laziness and narcissism, but deliberately to pave the way for diznee's reboot, which gave filoni himself far more power to shape the new lore as he pleased, more shows and more attention. And the new story group not only knows nothing about Star Wars they don't even care about the lore and continuity of their own reboot, giving filoni free reign to contradict it all as he pleases because "sTar wArS iS jUsT a bUnCh 0F cAmpFiRe StOriES" is the prevailing view now.

    • @SolurVoludun
      @SolurVoludun 3 дні тому

      TCW was Star Wars getting poisoned after being in its prime three years prior.
      After 4 years of endless agony, the Mouse killed Star Wars. And then in 2014, the Mouse and the Cowboy unburied the corpse and have been raping it ever since

  • @jakefoley9539
    @jakefoley9539 14 годин тому

    Filoni has easily done as much damage to the franchise as Kennedy and Johnson. It's nice to see people finally talking about it.
    I won't watch the video because it will make me depressed, but I leave this comment in support of what you're doing.

    • @Star-Wars-Skran
      @Star-Wars-Skran  14 годин тому

      @@jakefoley9539 thank you so much sir, I have other videos that cover true George Lucas era Star Wars, my channels intention is to preserve the integrity of real star wars lore canon and continuity 🔥🔥🔥

    • @jakefoley9539
      @jakefoley9539 13 годин тому

      @@Star-Wars-Skran I will check out your other videos

    • @Star-Wars-Skran
      @Star-Wars-Skran  12 годин тому

      @ thank you my friend!!! And thanks for taking the time to comment I appreciate you 🍻

  • @gordonmacdonald6442
    @gordonmacdonald6442 3 дні тому +3

    "Aurra Sings' first appearance since TPM" COMPLETLY disregarding a whole bunch of Aurra stories from the novels and comic books that were well established in the lore of the SW timeline from 1999 to 2007!!! Filoni COMPLETLY and DIRECTLY RIPPED OFF her stories almost VERBATIM from the Boba Fett Clone Wars YA novel series by Scholastic from the early-to-mid 2000s!!! He hasn't an original thought in his head!!

    • @darthlucasfuu
      @darthlucasfuu 3 дні тому +1

      He's a liar! And he completely destroyed Aurra Sing's character! She was so badass and sadistic on the Republic's and on Clone Wars Adventures' comics, she could handled and even killed Jedi, fighting with them as equals! A cold and lunatic villain, who scared the poodoo of a young Padawan, making her had nightmares for years! Filoni ignored all that and transformed her into a generic weird bounty hunter, who loses even to Ahsoka, unbelievable!

    • @gordonmacdonald6442
      @gordonmacdonald6442 3 дні тому +1

      @@darthlucasfuu Quite right!! 🍻

  • @gordonmacdonald6442
    @gordonmacdonald6442 3 дні тому +1

    Filoni saying that he likes "Using stories from the EU" is a nice way of saying completely ripping off and retconning long-established lore and continuity, and plagerising other creator's works because he's a lazy, fradulent hack who managed to fail upwards into a place of some "authority!"

  • @Starwarsfearsome
    @Starwarsfearsome 2 дні тому

    I had a problem at first with the continuity issue but now I’m fine with it because I see it as two perspectives

    • @Star-Wars-Skran
      @Star-Wars-Skran  2 дні тому +2

      @@Starwarsfearsome I think lore is very important in Star Wars, in George’s words everyone expanding his universe works for him but it is too big for him to personally control everything. Filoni is the only one to not want to adhere to continuity

  • @macattackk
    @macattackk День тому

    Filoni only seems to care about his own vision, and gladly overwrites other creators works in order to realise it. He is a very selfish creator in my opinion, he tells some good stories but doesn’t work well within a larger franchise.

    • @Star-Wars-Skran
      @Star-Wars-Skran  День тому

      @@macattackk I agree with that, for 30 years everyone working for Star Wars did so under George’s direction and maintained great continuity. He doesn’t adhere to continuity and likes to use George’s name as an appeal to authority