That feel when you have to pause and rewind like 50 times each time he does something, because you have no clue how he did any of it. Trying to comprehend this makes me feel like a dog in a chemistry lab.
YES THERE IS SOME MOMENTS. BUT LOOK AT FORMULA. WRITE IT DOWN. AND KEEP THE LOGIC THREAD ALONG THAT. I HAVE MISTAKEN MYSELF WHEN TRYED TO FIND OUT VECTOR LENGTH GROUP. BUT THIS IS IN 1ST FORMULA AND IT IS RHO. BANZAI. I WISH YOU BEAUTIFUL SPIRIT
Sometimes you find a youtube video that is more useful than the last 100 hundred combined! Like a documentary + a tutorial + a work of art all in one dense but clear form. Amazing overview worthy of sharing many times over.
I know it's a couple years old now, but this is still mind-blowing to me! Fantastic work. My interest is math modeling with Blender and 3dsmax (I'm currently working mostly with Blender 2.8 now), so stuff like this fascinates me.
While this illustrates the strength and potential of eevee, it also shows the node system's weaknesses when it comes to vector maths and arithmetics. Hopefully the everything nodes project will improve the workflow. Thanks for the vid.
vector math has arrived in Blender too if it wasn't already in 2018. I have used it for my own 2D mandelbrot implementation. I'm using vector length, vector multiply. Found all except complex number math.
To go further you can add two vector math nodes in the beginning between texture coordinate: object and Z, c. Make the first vector math node an add and the second a divide. You can now zoom into the mandelbulb by adding values to the divide node. Make sure you have the same value for the x, y and z axis. If you go to deep you will end up in the mandelbulb itself and you have to adjust the position with the add node to find the surface again. Increase the divide amount just in little steps and then adjust the position for easy navigation. You can even make an animated render where it seems you go across the surface of the mandelbulb and zoom in very deep without changing the position of the camera or the object.
@@benjiusofficial no it forces you to rewind and pause the video. Figuring it out on your own wouldn't require a tutorial. The point of a tutorial is to show you how to do it so you can then play with the setup and learn from it.
@@Igor_Zdrowowicz so why didn't he just flash the formula on the screen and call it a day? Its just very hard to follow for no reason. If this was a quick overview video maybe it wouldn't matter so much , but the point of a tutorial is to make it easier to learn.
Really really awesome. I love your learning technic, specially math and mathematics picture visualization. I think nobody used this technic like math node+ math photo
i just subscribed even tho i honestly have no idea what you were doing the whole time with all that math stuff, like i thought it was gonna involve modeling and stuff but this was cool! hopefully you do more tutorials
it would be so nice to have all the mandelbulb3d (mb3d) tools and formulas, also atmospheric and rim lightning that can be modified after render, all integrated in blender ^^
There are times where tutorials are so bad that I could be salty of them. I copied tutorials made in maya, mudbox and unity. But you, mate... are the best of them all, beating them with your teaching skills! I am a somewhat beginner of blender and had a LOT of fun with your great tutorial. My blend file is exactly like yours. Now I am experimenting with it, haha. Thank you very much! I hope to see more tutorials made by you because you´re worth every follower who passes by.
So that's how they filmed the crazy scenes of The Ant-Man and Dr. Strange I feel like saying thanks for this amazing tutorial would be so cheap! Nevertheless I appreciate your incredible work from the depth of my heart!
I have been doing it in basically the same way! So glad to hear Eevee will be able to handle it in real time so I don't have to do any more 12+ hour renders. Great tutorial :) Btw have you tried doing this with osl? If so is it better or worse in Eevee than recreating the math with nodes?
I tried osl in cycles but it only works on cpu so it's basically useless for this level of detail and I don't think Eevee supports osl but I might be wrong. If osl did work it would definitely be much easier than noding though
I'm gonna hafta watch this a couple billion times. Great stuff. How are you getting the morphing tho? Also, have you tried any other formulas, such as Julias?
OK, all this actually works. And of course, the nodes are compatible with cycles, which can give very nice looking things. But please, try to be more didactic, it took me 5 hours to be sure to have the same thing as what you did.
that is one of the best node tutorials i've ever seen, thanks a bunch man, amazing, i have a question though, in the blend file you provided: how did you connect the motion of the empty to the value node !!!!!!!!
up to 6:50 , you can see how the new vector-math node that has a vector-length setting works. it may be faster (less iterations) to just use the new node, instead of this 'hand made' one.
I followed your tutorial and made the Mandelbulb! It is beautiful! Thanks a lot!!! And it made me reading a lot of crazy math as well!! Just one question, why wouldn’t it work on Cycle???
@@JonasDichelle It's strange, up to the 2nd iteration, switching to cycle looks like the same shape, but from the 3rd iteration, it starts to give me some unexpected wavy form warping around the sphere.
Loved the vid. Math hurt my head a bit on the first watch through ;) Only criticism is that at 0:27 when the 5.25" floppy goes into the drive *backwards*. You have no idea how many times I had to fix friends/family/school machines where someone did that, or tell someone they ruined the floppy (and data) by touching the actual disk inside...
First of all, this is one of the coolest things Ive EVER seen done w blender and I want to thankyou for this! secondly, I have a couple of questions for you if you have a minute or two: First of all a specific question of methodology/math: when there are coordinates in an equasion which are separated by a comma, such as in the theta function for z.... well, what does that mean, is it getting multiplied by something? I understand the coordinate system in euclidian space to locate a point but of c here youre using spherical coordinates ... and I guess Im trying to figure out how the z here gets operated on, youve plugged it into the divide by sqrt of x*x + y*y so Im not sure why that is working that way... The other question is much more general: Im totally inspired by this and would love to develope further and want to try to put some of these equasions into shaders bugman123.com/Hypercomplex/ but I see that there are some operations/symbols that dont look to be inside of the math node that are essentially programming operations like iterators presented here in c++ code snippets.... so, might these (for example the first one at the top of the page) be doable in blender? I am struggling with this as Im pretty much NOT a math or coding person but still want to dive in and try nonetheless and would love your thoughts! thanks in advance and keep up the kickass work!
I don't know if anyone wrote this but the vector math node now has length as an option. Maybe it had that before too, I don't know.. but it's quite useful.
Very cool and thanks for the history lesson. I can't believe this has not came across my suggestions until now. Could I trouble you for title of the music that starts at 3:13? Edit: Just found it in the description, nice work man! CheerZ!
I thought this would be one of those tutorials where the guy just drones on and on about useless stuff, due to its 20 minutes length. But nope, I couldn’t keep up with this lmao, good work on not wasting our time
cool? no! extraordinary :D haha but it will pretty hard since it is programmed using the pascal object dialect "Delphi" In Mandelulb many formulas are described in the info button or you can find some on the web. Someone with good math skills could create some group nodes like you did and pack it into an addon? But if someone is interested to port it (formulas only would be awesome already) here is the source code ! github.com/thargor6/mb3d
This video is awesome! Thanks! Tho I’m having trouble rendering/ animating it. I’m pretty new to blender and I know this isn’t the best project for a beginner but I just love it
For some reason mine looks like a log. Could you help me with this? I downloaded the original blend file and cross checked it with mine, everything looks right. But instead of looking spherical it has become cylindrical.
I’m finally understanding how to read and comprehend the formula, but I’m wondering how to get the parent node groups visible while working on an inner group? Love this video, been trying every day for the past 5 days and think I might actually get it right this time!
"Keep the cube" ... History was made.
my dream came true.
Gleb Alexandrov this is pure magic to me
Gleb Alexandrov Ditto
creative shrimp is here
Gleb Alexandrov is one of my favorite ppl on this planet. To see you comment on this tutorial means a lot.
Seriously - Blender Eevee would be MUCH faster than any of the popular Mandelbulb renderers!
That feel when you have to pause and rewind like 50 times each time he does something, because you have no clue how he did any of it. Trying to comprehend this makes me feel like a dog in a chemistry lab.
Us dogs want a downloadable plugin!
change the playback speed :) I do it alot it helps.
This was Greek to me! Makes me feel like I have to be a rocket scientist to be able to do it 🤣 🤣🤣🤣🤣
YES THERE IS SOME MOMENTS. BUT LOOK AT FORMULA. WRITE IT DOWN. AND KEEP THE LOGIC THREAD ALONG THAT. I HAVE MISTAKEN MYSELF WHEN TRYED TO FIND OUT VECTOR LENGTH GROUP. BUT THIS IS IN 1ST FORMULA AND IT IS RHO. BANZAI. I WISH YOU BEAUTIFUL SPIRIT
@@Lubawaandme the highest level of math I understand is long division. the formula is useless to me
Sometimes you find a youtube video that is more useful than the last 100 hundred combined! Like a documentary + a tutorial + a work of art all in one dense but clear form. Amazing overview worthy of sharing many times over.
Wow.. You made the tutorial. And you sir are the kind of guy who makes maths look so cool. Thank you. Learnt a lot.
Even if I'll never replicate what you did here I learned sooo much by watching this. Thank you!
just download the .blend and render the heck out of it! :)
David Kozma Way too much mathematics
Wow, this tutorial is truly top-notch. Very nice 👍
I know it's a couple years old now, but this is still mind-blowing to me! Fantastic work. My interest is math modeling with Blender and 3dsmax (I'm currently working mostly with Blender 2.8 now), so stuff like this fascinates me.
Love that quick rainbow pallet in the colorramp in only four clicks or so.
This tutorial stands our amongst most other blender tutorials on youtube! Kudos!
unbeliavable quality - both content and presentation!
One of the first Blender 2.80 tutorials and then already this,amazing.
While this illustrates the strength and potential of eevee, it also shows the node system's weaknesses when it comes to vector maths and arithmetics. Hopefully the everything nodes project will improve the workflow. Thanks for the vid.
I would have loved to code it instead of noding it but unfortunately Eevee doesn't support osl.
GSOC 19 might change some things: devtalk.blender.org/t/cycles-eevee-improvements-weekly-reports/7697/2
vector math has arrived in Blender too if it wasn't already in 2018. I have used it for my own 2D mandelbrot implementation. I'm using vector length, vector multiply. Found all except complex number math.
i like to see more tutorial like this in the future, luv it
To go further you can add two vector math nodes in the beginning between texture coordinate: object and Z, c. Make the first vector math node an add and the second a divide. You can now zoom into the mandelbulb by adding values to the divide node. Make sure you have the same value for the x, y and z axis. If you go to deep you will end up in the mandelbulb itself and you have to adjust the position with the add node to find the surface again. Increase the divide amount just in little steps and then adjust the position for easy navigation. You can even make an animated render where it seems you go across the surface of the mandelbulb and zoom in very deep without changing the position of the camera or the object.
one of the most interesting videos Ive seen lately, I have to try it someday.
Going to give this a try, looks so fun! And thanks for including the blend file!
Very nice video and effects. I like how you made this. Must of been a lot of work :)
thanks, it was more work than i expected :)
Its really helpful when you minimize the nodes immediately while filming at high speed.
fr. who collapses nodes anyways, node hoarder gang💯
It actually is tho
cause it forces you to figure it out
@@benjiusofficial no it forces you to rewind and pause the video.
Figuring it out on your own wouldn't require a tutorial. The point of a tutorial is to show you how to do it so you can then play with the setup and learn from it.
Well he has shown the formula and order of operations. Figuring out what to substract from what is not a big deal. All sockets are named.
@@Igor_Zdrowowicz so why didn't he just flash the formula on the screen and call it a day?
Its just very hard to follow for no reason. If this was a quick overview video maybe it wouldn't matter so much , but the point of a tutorial is to make it easier to learn.
I'm a nerd and a blender addict, so this couldn't have been any better
Blender Anonymous called, they want you to try again.
Thank you so much. I'll use this for some visuals in a concert, I've always wanted to make a mandelbulb and you're the man.
I took notes on this. Thank you for sharing.
The moment when you plug the colorramp 😍 Thank you for sharing this masterpiece! 👏
i replicated in blender 2.93.1 and it worked! i really liked playing with the variables, thanks a lot for this tutorial
Really really awesome.
I love your learning technic, specially math and mathematics picture visualization.
I think nobody used this technic like math node+ math photo
This is the kick in the butt I needed to finally start learning Blender.
Great tutorial, easy to follow, fun to build.
Thank you.
i just subscribed even tho i honestly have no idea what you were doing the whole time with all that math stuff, like i thought it was gonna involve modeling and stuff but this was cool! hopefully you do more tutorials
it would be so nice to have all the mandelbulb3d (mb3d) tools and formulas, also atmospheric and rim lightning that can be modified after render, all integrated in blender ^^
Yeah, that would be a great addon
Can we get togheter and do It?
You read my mind... MB3d is my FAVORITE abstract art creation environment, but Blender has MUCH better rendering capabilities...
I'm trying to create the [spoiler creature] from the movie Annihilation. This is the perfect tutorial. Thanks!
this was so good. I followed your instructions directly and was left with a glitchy cube, so sad to come so close and fail
I’ve been waiting for someone to do this in Blender for a looooooong time
One of the biggest and outstanding experiment in blender so far! Lets play with this magic, guys)
nice musics in background, great choice!!
There are times where tutorials are so bad that I could be salty of them. I copied tutorials made in maya, mudbox and unity. But you, mate... are the best of them all, beating them with your teaching skills! I am a somewhat beginner of blender and had a LOT of fun with your great tutorial.
My blend file is exactly like yours. Now I am experimenting with it, haha. Thank you very much! I hope to see more tutorials made by you because you´re worth every follower who passes by.
That was an absolutely great tutorial. How you were able to break down the math of that...wow
Amazing... thank you also for the finished blend... hoping to see more!
looks amazing in blender EEVEE. This is incredible stuff.
So that's how they filmed the crazy scenes of The Ant-Man and Dr. Strange
I feel like saying thanks for this amazing tutorial would be so cheap!
Nevertheless I appreciate your incredible work from the depth of my heart!
I'd bet they used Cinema4D fractal generating plugins or some other professional-grade fractal generating software...
@@Eradifyerao Oh yea DEFINITELY Cinema4D, the most limited program to ever exist. They do stuff like this with houdini obviously.
I have been doing it in basically the same way! So glad to hear Eevee will be able to handle it in real time so I don't have to do any more 12+ hour renders. Great tutorial :)
Btw have you tried doing this with osl? If so is it better or worse in Eevee than recreating the math with nodes?
I tried osl in cycles but it only works on cpu so it's basically useless for this level of detail and I don't think Eevee supports osl but I might be wrong. If osl did work it would definitely be much easier than noding though
eevee is the new real time render engine included in blender 2.8:
code.blender.org/2017/03/eevee-roadmap/
its really cool
This looks amazing, I'm definitly going to get right on this next time I'm on blender
Can't wait for the full release of 2.8
Amazing final product!
thank you now i can look at this when i am tripping at home this will be awesome!!!
Funny how it takes in a vector and gives out a vector. The setup also makes it look like a neural network. That's kinda cool.
I'm gonna hafta watch this a couple billion times. Great stuff.
How are you getting the morphing tho?
Also, have you tried any other formulas, such as Julias?
The most wonderful material! Thank you so much for your lesson! The magic begins))
Math is "boring" ... says noone after watching this video !
cant wait to see more mathematical object tutorial like this in the future
woops sorry i though my last comment didnt sent
this really is amazing. a bit too complex for me right now as I just started learning 3d two weeks ago, will get there soon ;)
Thanks so much for this tutorial! Well explained and easily recreatable in Blender 4.0!
Thank you for your time, brutha...your flow is just right and I grasp every step!
If Gleb asked, this must be *g00d* :D
GREAT tutorial! thanks for sharing!
OK, all this actually works. And of course, the nodes are compatible with cycles, which can give very nice looking things.
But please, try to be more didactic, it took me 5 hours to be sure to have the same thing as what you did.
This was excellent, thank you!
This is gold. Thank you for sharing.
I love that you modeled the retro computer but I remember those floppies from back in the day, and you made it go in backwards. :)
that is one of the best node tutorials i've ever seen, thanks a bunch man, amazing, i have a question though, in the blend file you provided: how did you connect the motion of the empty to the value node !!!!!!!!
anyone able to tell me how to do 13:40 on the newer versions of blender? i cant find anything online
Click the plus to the right of the inputs box in the N side menu
Just brilliant all the way around! Great tutorial, and putting all this together via math nodes is genius. Thank you!
man U have great teaching skills 😍
Thank you 🙏
4:03 your welcome fellow math nerds and blender people
excited to do this thanks for posting!!
up to 6:50 , you can see how the new vector-math node that has a vector-length setting works.
it may be faster (less iterations) to just use the new node, instead of this 'hand made' one.
phi is the rotation around the z-axis while theta is the angle of the vector, of length r, from the xy-plane.
You are my hero. Wow!
I followed your tutorial and made the Mandelbulb! It is beautiful! Thanks a lot!!! And it made me reading a lot of crazy math as well!! Just one question, why wouldn’t it work on Cycle???
Thanks, I'm happy you were able to follow :)
It works in cycles too, it would just be excruciatingly slow to render
@@JonasDichelle It's strange, up to the 2nd iteration, switching to cycle looks like the same shape, but from the 3rd iteration, it starts to give me some unexpected wavy form warping around the sphere.
Learned so much! thanks for the video!! Make more videos. Don't stop making!
Loved the vid. Math hurt my head a bit on the first watch through ;)
Only criticism is that at 0:27 when the 5.25" floppy goes into the drive *backwards*. You have no idea how many times I had to fix friends/family/school machines where someone did that, or tell someone they ruined the floppy (and data) by touching the actual disk inside...
;)
You, sir, are totally awesome!
key for reroute is right clicking :) amazing tutorial btw !!!thank u!
This is terror inducing
I like that in the file you had some Easter eggs like the output location!
Lol, I just forgot to change them :D
Finally, I can now create cool looking fractals.
Woah you're a genius! Thanks for this video :D
excited to dive into the tutorial. What skin are you using for blender? Looks nice and clean
It's actually the new default theme for blender 2.8, it's much better than the old one
Idk why but i love you ❤️
First of all, this is one of the coolest things Ive EVER seen done w blender and I want to thankyou for this! secondly, I have a couple of questions for you if you have a minute or two: First of all a specific question of methodology/math: when there are coordinates in an equasion which are separated by a comma, such as in the theta function for z.... well, what does that mean, is it getting multiplied by something? I understand the coordinate system in euclidian space to locate a point but of c here youre using spherical coordinates ... and I guess Im trying to figure out how the z here gets operated on, youve plugged it into the divide by sqrt of x*x + y*y so Im not sure why that is working that way... The other question is much more general: Im totally inspired by this and would love to develope further and want to try to put some of these equasions into shaders bugman123.com/Hypercomplex/ but I see that there are some operations/symbols that dont look to be inside of the math node that are essentially programming operations like iterators presented here in c++ code snippets.... so, might these (for example the first one at the top of the page) be doable in blender? I am struggling with this as Im pretty much NOT a math or coding person but still want to dive in and try nonetheless and would love your thoughts! thanks in advance and keep up the kickass work!
I don't know if anyone wrote this but the vector math node now has length as an option. Maybe it had that before too, I don't know.. but it's quite useful.
you should use a multiply node with both inputs being the same for the squaring operation
, the power node uses more computational power
This great!! Thanks for the history lesson as well, I had no idea ;-)
Can you replicate in blender 3.0 I followed the steps and also tried downloading the file, both came out wrong thanks
*genius spotted. loved it ❤
Very cool and thanks for the history lesson. I can't believe this has not came across my suggestions until now.
Could I trouble you for title of the music that starts at 3:13? Edit: Just found it in the description, nice work man!
CheerZ!
Very clever, looksawesome...
I thought this would be one of those tutorials where the guy just drones on and on about useless stuff, due to its 20 minutes length. But nope, I couldn’t keep up with this lmao, good work on not wasting our time
wow great node
Thank you so much, the coloring part is very interesting! :) now i need to dig a bit to implement the mandelbox formula !! :D
ooh, itd be cool to have a Mandelbulb 3d Addon in blender
www.mandelbulb.com/2014/mandelbulb-3d-mb3d-fractal-rendering-software/
cool? no! extraordinary :D haha but it will pretty hard since it is programmed using the pascal object dialect "Delphi"
In Mandelulb many formulas are described in the info button or you can find some on the web.
Someone with good math skills could create some group nodes like you did and pack it into an addon?
But if someone is interested to port it (formulas only would be awesome already) here is the source code ! github.com/thargor6/mb3d
hmmmmm.....
Thank you bro this was awesome
Extreme noding.... cool!
"The real part can be anything number you think of (...). Anything REALY".
Welcome to Tautology Club!
This video is awesome! Thanks!
Tho I’m having trouble rendering/ animating it. I’m pretty new to blender and I know this isn’t the best project for a beginner but I just love it
For some reason mine looks like a log. Could you help me with this? I downloaded the original blend file and cross checked it with mine, everything looks right. But instead of looking spherical it has become cylindrical.
Wow… amazing video. When u said “oh I’ll just use power for sqrt Bc 0.5 power is the same” my mind was like wait, no way that’s amazing 😂🤯
I have decided, I will do this. I may have to watch it at 0.25 speed and rewind it 50 times but I will create this legitimately.
Get this an a medal
I’m finally understanding how to read and comprehend the formula, but I’m wondering how to get the parent node groups visible while working on an inner group? Love this video, been trying every day for the past 5 days and think I might actually get it right this time!
Keep watching the video over and over until you thoroughly understand what he's doing
"If you named it like I had" 🤣🤣🤣