The Most Controversial Weapon in Elden Ring History

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 8 чер 2024
  • #eldenring #fromsoftware #videoessay
    When you think of a weapon that has broken a game what comes to your mind? There’s some literal examples then there’s weapons so overpowered that they tip the scale of balance on its head. Then there’s one in elden ring we have already talked about, how it almost ruined the game, the rivers of blood kitana. But.. what if I led you the wrong way, what if there was one weapon that could be any weapon in the game while you used your own? See, this isn’t a video about a weapon, this is a video about a spirit summon that can create any weapon and build, this is what happens when Elden RIng showed players that an easy mode did exist.. This is the story of the Mimic Tear. The Most Controversial Weapon in Elden Ring History
    ------------------------
    Editor: PreppieUniform6
    -------
    Intro - 0:00
    Day One - 1:30
    Cut Quest - 9:57
    Conclusion - 13:24
    -------
    Channels
    @ShisuiSama
    @ModWalker
    @JSwix
    @Nullrinn
    @schlechtelaunetyp9732
    @IronPineapple
    @VideoGameDataBank
    @AshesWolf
    @lastghoul0026
    Music
    Elden Ring - The Final Battle
    Dark Souls 3 - Firelink Shrine
    Elden Ring - Eternal City
    Dark Souls 1 - Firelink Shrine
  • Ігри

КОМЕНТАРІ • 145

  • @LowKeyJaded
    @LowKeyJaded 2 місяці тому +139

    Mimic tear being in the game is a complete non issue. If it was too strong for people’s “super challenging game” fetish then don’t use it. The “controversy” was that it ever existed in the first place. Elden ring isn’t even a PvP focused game, it’s a single player first game with multiple ways to play the game.

    • @kevinguzman9642
      @kevinguzman9642 2 місяці тому +1

      👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽

    • @John_The_Fourth
      @John_The_Fourth 2 місяці тому +1

      🎉🎉🎉

    • @Letwoo67
      @Letwoo67 2 місяці тому +3

      I think they should nerf it just to make people angry, that would be funny.

    • @bimbobomb
      @bimbobomb 2 місяці тому +4

      @@Letwoo67are you okay?

    • @Letwoo67
      @Letwoo67 2 місяці тому +1

      @@bimbobomb I’m good, you?

  • @HarryTestakuls
    @HarryTestakuls 2 місяці тому +43

    Mimic is my brother, hes my soul incarnate. Hes me.

  • @Ozymandias1111
    @Ozymandias1111 2 місяці тому +14

    I agree with the “just don’t use it” camp. We spent money on this game to enjoy ourselves. So I might dabble with it for fun, but when I want a challenge I’ll go solo.

  • @mesadrums375
    @mesadrums375 2 місяці тому +32

    What the mimic tear was for me was a learning tool. This was my first fromsoft game, and once I got the mimic tear, most bosses lost their specialness, but that’s kind of what I needed for my first playthrough. On my second playthrough, I used no spirits or rivers of blood and loved it, and now I’m doing a whole playthrough of all the souls games. The mimic tear was stupid OP, but it was perfect for me to ease into what’s always seemed like a daunting game series.

    • @KokiriCoke
      @KokiriCoke 2 місяці тому

      Respect to you man that’s awesome. I used to hate its inclusion bc I thought it was too broken, but because of people like you and stories like these, in my mind, it keeps the game and its playerbase’s integrity well, relatively stable lol. There are no doubt people who will never play elden ring because it’s just too hard without help. But I respect the ones who use its tools and get better through practice, instead of straight cheese to then claim they “did it”. Anyways yea congrats bro good on you for not clinging to the mimic

    • @mesadrums375
      @mesadrums375 2 місяці тому

      @@KokiriCoke I knew for a fact when I beat Melania first try that it was too much and didn’t really count. It took 86 tries to beat Margit without doing much exploring, pretty much throwing myself at a brick wall till I won, and I fell in love with what everyone did. That’s the games easy mode, and while it was nice to have to help me get my training wheels off, I wanted that same challenge feeling back

    • @EvanExplains
      @EvanExplains  2 місяці тому

      well said

  • @dannysandhu9487
    @dannysandhu9487 2 місяці тому +7

    people dont understand.. the mimic tear is the best attempt of nokron to get their own elden lord.. of course its supposed to be strong... lorewise its half as strong as the tarnished cuz it got half of our life energy or runes or however u want to call the energy that lends all things life in this context

  • @MrPsych77
    @MrPsych77 2 місяці тому +39

    I stand by the fact that in a soulsborne game everything is trying to kill you and it cares nothing about your honor. So in turn it's fair game to do everything you can to win, back stab, use summons or sleep pots if you have to. Whatever it takes to win. The game isn't going to take it easy on you so you shouldn't either

    • @ETBrooD
      @ETBrooD 2 місяці тому +8

      I think this is one of the best ways to describe it. I completely agree.

    • @dsdssdsd283
      @dsdssdsd283 2 місяці тому +6

      That's exactly what I was thinking with my first playthroughs. The boss designs and the ambushes and tricky camera gotchas (to name a few) are BS to begin with. I'm not honor bound to play in a way that tributes any more respect than this game deserves.

    • @user-fq1qv3zk3z
      @user-fq1qv3zk3z 2 місяці тому

      Spoken like a casual

    • @MrPsych77
      @MrPsych77 2 місяці тому

      @@user-fq1qv3zk3z work smarter not harder

    • @thesaltysoup5109
      @thesaltysoup5109 2 місяці тому

      @@user-fq1qv3zk3z Spoken like an elitest that judges people for how they play pve as if it matters. Filthy maidenless who touches no grass and probably ganks lol

  • @metalface_villain
    @metalface_villain 2 місяці тому +13

    i love the mimic tear, it's a whole mini game of its own. you get to make builds and see if it can solo bosses. you can make it a proper tank with shabriri and you can play as a healer for example to have a completely different gaming experience or you can simply make it a strong damage dealer because you simply want to see the story and the world. i honestly despise the fromsoft elitist that want you to only play the game with a big strength bonker and anything else is not allowed. i think other souls games had artificial difficulty and clunkiness but i don't think elden ring does, even without the summons but it's still nice that with the summons it becomes more accessible to more people.

    • @random_something1852
      @random_something1852 2 місяці тому +2

      This actually does sound really fun, maybe I’ll try it on my next NG+!

    • @joshsmith8715
      @joshsmith8715 2 місяці тому

      I’m no elitist of fromsoftware, this was my first ever souls game, I just feel bad for the people that weren’t able to experience the game in a way that didn’t trivialize the game the first time

    • @metalface_villain
      @metalface_villain 2 місяці тому

      @@joshsmith8715 brother the game can be easier with a good build than with summons, especially and no one is forcing you to play with a mimic to begin with xD
      i mean if you go for a double curved sword build with bleed plus mimic then yes the game will be significantly easier but you will have to specifically plan for something like that and hunt all those items. no one will have that as their first experience playing the game naturally. plus much of that isn't accessible for you to get early anyways.
      you say you aren't a fromsoft elitist but what you said here proves the opposite. imagine feeling bad about how someone chooses to have fun in a game. what a pretentious load of crap xD

    • @3XZDgg
      @3XZDgg 2 місяці тому +1

      i been tryna make a mimic tear fighter that i just buff and heal lol.

  • @smokinggnu6584
    @smokinggnu6584 2 місяці тому +6

    The first time i beat Malenia by "myself" wa using a mimic tear, and using a powerstancing magma blade build. My mimic and i would spin-to-win stunlock her into a corner and win the fight like that. I remember it well, i'd gotten to her bossroom intending to skip over the fight and progress on with the story, then decided on a whim to just test it out, see how it would work. Beat her in one go right there. Could never replicate that success again with any other build yet.

  • @RampidWarthogStudios
    @RampidWarthogStudios 2 місяці тому +7

    Imagine one of the DLC bosses flips the scrip and just steals your summon.

    • @PopsiccDesigns
      @PopsiccDesigns 2 місяці тому +1

      That's actually speculated to happen with the DLC. There are datamined things related to miquellas bewitching branch and it could be something a boss does in the future. I think it was in a zulie the witch video.

    • @lordofchaosinc.261
      @lordofchaosinc.261 2 місяці тому

      He does it one time and next time you're wise about it.

    • @RampidWarthogStudios
      @RampidWarthogStudios 2 місяці тому +2

      @@PopsiccDesigns that would be dope. If there is a Miquella boss fight that's who I think would pull that on the player

  • @hightimeswithdan7502
    @hightimeswithdan7502 2 місяці тому +19

    Mimic Tear was the 🐐🐐🐐 😂 At the very least it gave me breathing room with Malenia 😅

    • @TheMineA7
      @TheMineA7 2 місяці тому +6

      My mimic was just feeding her health ngl

    • @metalface_villain
      @metalface_villain 2 місяці тому +1

      @@TheMineA7 yeah i tried to make a tanky build that could solo all bosses but the mimic sadly came to a standstill with malenia because they both would heal themselves xD i tried this before the nerfs and the mimic tank with great stars with prayerful strikes could solo all bosses besides her. i think i managed to beat her with mimic solo when i switched to a bleed build with rivers and mohg's rune

    • @MrPsych77
      @MrPsych77 2 місяці тому

      ​@@TheMineA7with my crucible knight build it helped a lot but in order to keep the minic alive I had to keep attacking relentlessly. She doesn't give you any room for mistakes

    • @whatisreddin7367
      @whatisreddin7367 9 днів тому

      @@TheMineA7 yeah ive beaten her with the mimic, then with a friend and now solo countless times. Its way easier solo without her leeching health off the mimic tear or other players

  • @ninjabackhand1337
    @ninjabackhand1337 2 місяці тому +7

    Me and Dung, always get it done.

    • @EvanExplains
      @EvanExplains  2 місяці тому

      this is an elden ring book in the making

  • @letsrock12345
    @letsrock12345 2 місяці тому +3

    If it makes anyone feel better, i still get wrecked while using it.

  • @jhonnystar8897
    @jhonnystar8897 2 місяці тому +2

    Seeing someone complaining about the mimic tear it's an excellent way to spot a man baby that thinks playing a difficult game makes him special, the fact that mimic tear is completely optional means that if you don't want to use guess what? You don't use it, so that leaves me to believe those people only complain because others could use it to trivialize the game and I don't get why they care so much about how other people play, when they are 100% not affected by it.

  • @nyhman78
    @nyhman78 2 місяці тому +3

    I love the mimic tear,i used it only on my first playthrough and don't regret it,i worked with the mimic tear not sat around,now i rather use Black knife tiche but will always appreciate the jellyfish and mimic that help me so much on my first playthrough

  • @kevinguzman9642
    @kevinguzman9642 2 місяці тому +4

    To me if it’s available in the game then you can use it. If Miyazaki didn’t want something in HIS game (creation) it wouldn’t be there. Simple as that. IMO u can’t have “I won’t tell u how to play” & then say “but don’t brag about using all the tools provided” in the same sentence. In the end it’s all a CHOICE n some ppl simply want validation for not using all the tools provided. If we keep up with that theory then it’ll end up “well u beat the boss not using any potions but I beat the boss blindfolded, so I’m better” n it’ll end up with a never ending circle jerk of trying to one up eachother instead of simply having fun. This isn’t a pre-k playground.

    • @spicyrock5451
      @spicyrock5451 2 місяці тому

      I mostly agree, but summons went a bit too far imo. A good showing of that is in no hit runs, which are only seen as real runs if they dont use them. But as casual player you should use any tool you want or make the game as difficult without anyone saying or judging you.

    • @zakanyimen
      @zakanyimen 2 місяці тому

      @@spicyrock5451 no hit runners don't use summons because getting them and upgrading them is just more time / more chance to get hit then killing the bosses yourself.

  • @kodemasterx
    @kodemasterx 2 дні тому +1

    My first playthrough of the game was unique, I normally tend to stick with a weapon or building for the entirety of game, and I'd leave experimentation for the 2nd or 3rd playthrough, for that reason, I got the mimic tear but never used until I started to read all the comments online, I had no idea it was that powerful, same goes for the Rivers of Blood katana, I got it on my 3rd playthrough but once I noticed it made the game too easy I stopped using it.
    Also, I beat Radam Hussein on my first try way before he got patched lol

  • @dvillegaspro
    @dvillegaspro 2 місяці тому +1

    I specifically love using mimic tear because it makes me feel like I’m on the journey with a companion. Companion features tend to be some of my favorite parts of any game.

  • @scion6186
    @scion6186 2 місяці тому +1

    your examples for the mimic tear were bosses from limgrave that you could beat easily by the time you get it as well as showing it do one hit at the start of the radagon fight. That's not a good way to show that its op

  • @TrueLawbringer
    @TrueLawbringer 2 місяці тому

    I typically only use summons if they fit thematically with whatever I’m building, for example if I’m doing a little Banished Knoght Oleg cosplay with twin BKGS along with the full armor set, then I may summon Stormhawk Deenh or Banished Knight Engvall, it’s just another part of the theming for me. Sucked that my crucible knight cosplay can only summon winged misbegotten iirc, the only summon who made contact with the crucible and whatnot

  • @ETBrooD
    @ETBrooD 2 місяці тому +2

    The Mimic Tear, RoB, Moonveil, sorceries, all of those things are a necessity to make ER beatable for all players. The game is so difficult that there's a risk that a player hits a roadblock and never returns to experience the rest of the game. That risk is mitigated with stronger builds, summons and co-op.
    Players who want a challenge can have a challenge in various different ways, be that by limiting themselves with certain rules or by playing a thematic build.
    I switch to my most powerful weapons whenever I don't want to bother with an obstacle. Nothing wrong with that. The game has plenty of fun challenges for my normal build. Why would players have to face a big challenge with every single boss? Sometimes you just don't want to go full sweat mode, or you don't enjoy fighting a certain boss, so you pull out the big guns and get it over with.
    It's all about having fun.

  • @bispeskov1123
    @bispeskov1123 2 місяці тому

    You earned yourself a sub. This type of content is exactly what i needed. Everyone else is talking about cryptic lore thats up for interpretation so this type of content is really refreshing. Love this game and i look forward to more from you!

  • @madengineerkyouma
    @madengineerkyouma 2 місяці тому +1

    I exclusively play thematic builds, so I never used the mimic tear because it would never fit the theme of my build.
    Tiche, on the other hand, carried me through the endgame of my first playthrough.

  • @gogitoDBZ963
    @gogitoDBZ963 12 днів тому

    As someone who’s experiencing Elden Ring as their first proper Soulsborne game, my take on the Mimic Tear is simple; It’s fine and sometimes even a fully upgraded Mimic won’t really help. It’s not that you should let it fight battles for you. It’s that you should let it fight WITH you. Just do what I do. For the first few attempts, fight the boss on your own. If it’s too difficult, then call it in and see how it contributes to the fight.

  • @ags8507
    @ags8507 2 місяці тому +1

    mimic tear was heavily nerfed from released, and it isnt as op as it once was, greatshield skeletons are still one of the top tier ashes along dungeater

  • @WarrenBerzerkerLee
    @WarrenBerzerkerLee 2 місяці тому +2

    As much as I enjoy mimic tear, I feel like other than tiche I didn't wanna try any other spirit ash after getting it. Great video 👍🏻

  • @Tritamus
    @Tritamus 19 днів тому

    There should be items that a player needs to collect in order to summon any spirit ash in the game in accordance with how many of those items the player manage to collect.

  • @ameshizen381
    @ameshizen381 2 місяці тому +1

    Bosses in this game can one shot you to high hell in anything but the poise bois armors but a summon is too much for the community lmao

  • @dsdssdsd283
    @dsdssdsd283 2 місяці тому

    On a laggy console and in many cases broken in-game camera locking this was the only access I had to beat the game and not lose my progress by dying because of lost frame rate and inconsistent input delay when the boss does anything that takes extra effort for my console to render.
    Playing the NG+ I feel the need to solo the bosses in order to test out different weapons or weapon skills. The lag is still there except I don't have the mentality of just "getting it over with". It took me a while to understand that one boss killed by mimic tear is one boss lost to test my weapons on. I still pretty much take all the hits from the boss so memorizing the boss's move pattern is never going to be a thing for me.
    And no I don't think mimic tear is broken or OP. I like it being an option for me to whip out when I don't want to spend time studying the game.

  • @herohunter81
    @herohunter81 2 місяці тому

    The mimic tear has all my equipment, but it doesn’t mimic my aggression. That’s why I like black knife Tiche.

  • @fadeddragon123
    @fadeddragon123 2 місяці тому

    I have a build where I’m just a tank and heal myself. And I feel like that’s ultimately where the mimic belongs. If you are a support build. It’s rather fun to support yourself and to be supported by yourself lol

  • @calyx_datura
    @calyx_datura 2 місяці тому

    Why use the mimic tear ash when there will be new ashes in the DLC (I assume)?

  • @Revealingstorm.
    @Revealingstorm. 2 місяці тому +1

    Play how you wanna play. You wouldnt say its unfair when summoning someone like let me solo her.

  • @arran4285
    @arran4285 2 місяці тому

    I really wished you continued the COD Zombies Easter Egg Playlist

  • @soccerandtrack10
    @soccerandtrack10 2 місяці тому

    4:08 i did that in let it die and dark souls 2=i kept dieing to the max guy by him shooting,
    so i explored and got more heath,then i survived,
    i did that with dark souls 2,i couldnt fight the skelitons,
    i beat the horse boss and then found the summoners in the cave ressurecting them.
    And they stayed dead after i did stuff.

  • @tickledpickle5671
    @tickledpickle5671 14 днів тому

    I hung up my mimic tear before Radagon/Elden Beast. I wanted to earn my ending as god intended. one on one.

  • @Nostalgia_NH
    @Nostalgia_NH 2 місяці тому +2

    Hey guys, tired of using mimic tear? I recommend using Black Knife Tiche, Latenna The Albinauric or Dung Eater Puppet.

    • @madengineerkyouma
      @madengineerkyouma 2 місяці тому +2

      I would also recommend the Greatshield Soldier Ashes. They tank a LOT and keep the aggro from the boss wonderfully.

    • @ETBrooD
      @ETBrooD 2 місяці тому

      Therolina all the way. Coming in clutch with the heals and holy pots! Also, I feel lonely after Melina gets to the Erdtree :(

  • @TheJML1975
    @TheJML1975 2 місяці тому

    I’ve unlocked the Dung Eater summon, on my latest run… and he’s outstripped the Mimic Tear summon.. imho..

  • @DD-to5ig
    @DD-to5ig 2 місяці тому

    Pre-patch mimic tear was goofy. Me and mimic spammed hoarfrost stomp with a +0 icerind hatchet and completely shut down Malenia in both phases.

  • @LR11Gaming
    @LR11Gaming 2 місяці тому

    This is my first souls game. I was stuck on Margit for a year. I hated the game so much. I'm still not to the mimic tear but I use the rot dog from caelid and it's helping me not quit in a day.

  • @WarshipMolester
    @WarshipMolester 2 місяці тому

    I pray to the greater will that I can summon the mimic tear in the dlc.

  • @the_ilumiel
    @the_ilumiel 2 місяці тому

    I do think Mimic Tear made the late game a bit too easy and after a certain point I stopped fearing bosses at all and was glad to see a boss fog after a difficult dungeon because I knew here's something I can defeat with the help of my trusty Mimic Tear. In fact, I barely remember my fights against Mohg or Maliketh because it was all over so fast and I never felt the need to learn their moves. Still, I intend to use Mimic Tear in the DLC. I will be using mostly the same build as my first playthrough for the DLC and it just wouldn't be the same without Mimic Tear. And I also want to try out any new summons they might add in the game, so I don't want to lock myself into a no-Summon run at least on my first time playing the DLC.

  • @victorprati7908
    @victorprati7908 2 місяці тому

    The Mimic tear is the go to for people who find the game extremely hard/"unfair"/unbeatable... to make it less hard for them.

  • @vexmyth0clast
    @vexmyth0clast 2 місяці тому +1

    Sure Mimic tear and Rivers of blood was strong af but no one mentions the Ice Rind hatchet pre nerf when the game first released. If you even had a few points in Dex and got this thing upgraded you could literally stomped your way through the entire game. I would know it was my cheese weapon when I got tired of getting my cheeks clapped lmao 😂

  • @lostechoes5917
    @lostechoes5917 2 місяці тому

    Here’s the thing. The mimic is here to stay. However we can all agree that the mimic is still very strong. It’s the benefit of having another good player build with you without buffing the boss like summoning another. So while I understand why people do it I will continue to not because I want the challenge.

  • @TheDanishMuggle
    @TheDanishMuggle 2 місяці тому +2

    man the fact that i still live with the knowledge that there is a spirit summon nearly on par with pre nerf mimic tear that no one is noticing is insane honestly.

  • @saxongamer2323
    @saxongamer2323 2 місяці тому

    My first couple of playthroughs the mimic 2 really wasn't that powerful, but I didn't use a meta build or anything like that.

  • @Personage9487
    @Personage9487 2 місяці тому

    I don't understand why people complain about mimic tears, like there are some better summons depending on your play style. Like the black knife tiche who does a lot of DOT and there's this other summon(that I forgot the name of, it was something like astfollo rolo) who literally could stun Melenia out of her waterfowl dance thingy. And when I fought Melenia with my mimic tear, he was kinda crap cuz whenever Melenia used waterfowl she gained a lot of health back cuz the mimic couldn't do anything about it.

    • @spicyrock5451
      @spicyrock5451 2 місяці тому

      I'll explain it for you, if you have a mid maxed build for level 125-150 you can easily beat the whole game. With the mimics tankiness you don't even have to think or engage with any mechanic of any boss. Malenia may heal up 3-5k hp with 1 waterfowl, but she only uses the move 3 times in the fight if you dont stagger her out of it. So it means only 1-2 attack and you get that health easily back, lets not forget you can always cast your buffs because you don't have her aggro.

    • @Letwoo67
      @Letwoo67 2 місяці тому

      Because mimic tier is the best with every play style.

    • @Personage9487
      @Personage9487 2 місяці тому

      @@spicyrock5451 Lowkey a valid point💀. And ngl, I didn't even know Malenia used waterfowl only 3 times💀.

  • @KnoakLIfe
    @KnoakLIfe 2 місяці тому

    Al take the second best summon black knife tiche 🤣🤣🤣

  • @TheJclone
    @TheJclone 2 місяці тому

    only way a solo can co op

  • @grimreefer213
    @grimreefer213 2 місяці тому

    Personally I don’t really care that it’s in the game as I just don’t use it and you can safely ignore it if it’s not something you like but i’d like to not have the option to trivialize the game if it were up to me but if it helps new people get through the game then i’m not mad about it

  • @crazymage5316
    @crazymage5316 10 днів тому

    Idk my mimic has been pretty pointless and just gets bodied

  • @Agent-mb1xx
    @Agent-mb1xx 2 місяці тому

    Mimic using 2 RoB +10 or just miracles to heal you the entire fight it makes it the MVP

  • @buckiemohawk3643
    @buckiemohawk3643 2 місяці тому

    hoarfrost day one was so stupidly strong against malenia and paired with rivers wiped her out

  • @EngineersToGoMT
    @EngineersToGoMT 2 місяці тому

    the t1000

  • @milivoje1111
    @milivoje1111 2 місяці тому

    I usually play black knife tiche ashes.

  • @virtually_1
    @virtually_1 2 місяці тому

    I used mimic tear in my first playthrough as Elden ring was my first souls title and after my first run I didn't I went to 100% the game and am now waiting for dlc and cant wait to try knew things. Elden ring is not a game of Impossibility and should not be a game of controversy it is shaped by it player base and the many people who make the challenges for them selves.

  • @soccerandtrack10
    @soccerandtrack10 2 місяці тому

    "That the only thing left of him they could find WAS HIS FINGAH!!!!"
    if you dont have the fanticy stuff=
    she likes dogwisles...

  • @jesserenobato7613
    @jesserenobato7613 2 місяці тому

    I'm a souls-borne vet who has beat every game in the series including sekiro and bloodborne, I've defeated Midir, sister friede, The nameless King, the fuckin orphan of Kos, artorias, Kalameet, every Sekiro Boss... SOLO, and I believe that using mimic tear is totally valid, I believe it's intended to be a sort of cathartic reminder that you don't have to face the tremendous amount of bastard bosses that are in elden ring alone, and don't forget there are many bosses in elder ring that you HAVE TO face without the use of the mimic tier as well...

  • @tylermatthew378
    @tylermatthew378 2 місяці тому

    mimic tear is so nerfed now its totally fine to exist. its not like the sword of knight and flame when the game launched. that think was mega busted.
    also, the rivers of blood is so late game and isnt that good anymore, so its totally fine.

  • @drabberjoins327
    @drabberjoins327 2 місяці тому +2

    They nerfed the mimic tear a long time ago. It's nowhere near as good as it used to be. Though I still prefer Tiche for the most part, the mimic is still arguably the best summon in the game, in most cases (unless your loadout is spell heavy). Pre-nerf, it was OP, because it could solo most bosses with ease (depending on your loadout). It was especially nutty with with Shabriri's Woe swapping (even to this day). Post nerf, I don't see an issue, though. It's much weaker than it used to be. If people want to use it, use it. If they don't, then don't. I know your video didn't really do this, but I just don't care for the constant gatekeeping with how people choose to play/enjoy the game.

  • @LewdGyrations
    @LewdGyrations 2 місяці тому

    I wouldnt say its too powerful, it was at one point though. I think they needa buff every other spirit though.

  • @hunterprice321
    @hunterprice321 2 місяці тому

    But also the mimic tear has stage 17 autism and has constant strokes

  • @reasonmattersmost
    @reasonmattersmost 2 місяці тому

    I did not realize just how easy I had made the game until I devoured Melania with the mimic and blasphemous blade. Then I saw online how hard she was supposed to be! I have since beaten her solo and it was much more fun!

  • @ron2291
    @ron2291 2 місяці тому

    There’s nothing wrong with options to use certain play styles and if you don’t like a play style don’t use it but trying to force everyone into playing a game only the way you permit it it’ll reduce the audience which will reduce the budget for the next game it even get the next one canceled. I don’t like Magic builds but I would never want from to remove it because I don’t want to turn those players off a game I love.

  • @tommynson440
    @tommynson440 2 місяці тому

    My honest opinion: Malenia is free game for whatever devious thing you decide to cook, it's okey.
    No seriously, unlike all other bosses, there was no real catharsis on killing Malenia beside "Yey... it's finally over..." rather than "Let's go!"

  • @Davidheat1088
    @Davidheat1088 Місяць тому

    For me, if its in the game it useable, and really a non issue, and the ppl who say its "Op" just wants to ruin the fun for others as there is nothing stopping them form not using it, sell it or put it in your chest when at grace and never use it, its really the simple

  • @spicyrock5451
    @spicyrock5451 2 місяці тому

    I personally hate summons, they take the game formular I love and destroy it. The "dance" you and the boss have gets thrown out for another aggro taking summon and the price you pay or setup is literally nothing. Why not just keep the old system if you can't beat a boss or don't want to engage with it?
    At least you can fully ignore the feature and only need to use it for one ruin side quest, so I can't hate on it too much.

  • @craignaylor2648
    @craignaylor2648 2 місяці тому

    Yeah but in my opinion summoning another person is the same thing basically

  • @tomer078
    @tomer078 2 місяці тому

    The footage is wierd - my mimic was good mostly for getting attention, the damage it did, let alone the AI, was very lacking. And I was good with that. That said, there were times it land the final blow in a fight and that pissed me off.
    Overall, if it in the game it is fair play.
    You can also say they went too far with magic, akin to having a cheat code. But, in the end, each one chooses the level of difficulty, and they did a great job providing a variety of tools to do just that.

    • @ETBrooD
      @ETBrooD 2 місяці тому

      Sorcerers may be a little too powerful in open fields and large arenas, but they get absolutely stomped in cramped spaces. I think slightly reducing the range and/or tracking of some spells would've been a good idea.

  • @Ultima1134
    @Ultima1134 2 місяці тому

    I never used Mimic, I prefer Tiche

  • @DanYami
    @DanYami 2 місяці тому

    Schlechtelaunentyp means bad mood guy lmao

    • @drowsydan7691
      @drowsydan7691 2 місяці тому

      lol the auto translation even changes it to “bad mood type”

    • @shnobrin7928
      @shnobrin7928 23 дні тому +1

      @@drowsydan7691 Because in german "Typ" means both Type and Guy. Translators tend to have difficulty sometimes with german words that have multiple meanings.

  • @majorasmask5523
    @majorasmask5523 2 місяці тому

    Even prenerf, this would be useless on NG7.

    • @spicyrock5451
      @spicyrock5451 2 місяці тому

      Not rly, I play on NG+7 with a 150 character because Im stubborn. My time would be so much easier if I used any summon, so I dont get 1 shot. Not to mention if you have a good build you can easily fck any boss up even at higher NG runs.

  • @Angelos_Choudeloudis
    @Angelos_Choudeloudis 8 днів тому

    im all about those who use spirit ashes to beat the game, its their journey and i am fine either way, BUT dont be one of those who beat the game with summons and then say that the game was easy, because then ppl are gonna mock you and you will call them bullies and gatekeepers. We have already seen the play.

  • @daveidhentie8760
    @daveidhentie8760 2 місяці тому

    Just play without the mimic. Pretty simple

  • @fobbitoperator3620
    @fobbitoperator3620 2 місяці тому

    Applesauce is fruit gravy!

  • @kgldude
    @kgldude 12 днів тому

    I don't understand the people who complain about the Mimic Tear being OP. They know that they can just *not* use the Mimic Tear if they don't want to, right? It's not mandatory.

  • @vivi44
    @vivi44 2 місяці тому

    Why bother with a mimic tear when you can just summon 2 maxed out players to gank a boss with you?

  • @YooSouth
    @YooSouth 2 місяці тому

    What Did You Use On Guts’ Greatsword To Make It All White?

  • @unholymethod
    @unholymethod 2 місяці тому

    Black knife tiche was better… guess my build sucked

  • @izzymosley1970
    @izzymosley1970 2 місяці тому

    My biggest complaint about the mimic tear is how anticlimactic it is to get it even though it's so powerful. makes me wish there was a super mimic tear that would take a quarter of your health but do something crazy like summon a mimic with double your stats but you also have to do a quest to get it.

  • @daudland1194
    @daudland1194 2 місяці тому

    I feel like people glorify these games as something much harder than they are to feel like they've accomplish something and hold it over other people's head.
    idunno, go get diamond in a pvp game instead or something if that's what you want.
    even without mimic tear, the list can go on for ever, first it was moon veil, then rivers of blood, and so on. we can talk about ancient dragon lightning, anything with endure, prayful strike, night comet, blasphemous blade, and so on. I think people latch onto mimic tear because its a summon and "you have to do it solo, but you can't use spells, also you can't use a shield, also.."

  • @Azur_Vita
    @Azur_Vita 2 місяці тому

    do not agree
    not regarding RoB (yes o.p. but not most o.p. in ER) and regarding the mimic - it was o.p. in the first month only, YES, but it was not horrible, and did get nerfed.
    there is far worse,
    and even the worse stuff aint gamebreaking !!
    The base game (day 1) was already pretty good
    btw.
    i'm a REAL veteran here,
    played og Demons Soul and Dark Souls on ps3 before western release, played old Armored Core games on ps2 and psp, platinumed all souls Games and AC6, and there is a flood of fans, who pretend to be the hardest and seem to misunderstand what the games are about.
    Miyazaki even stated in an interview that it is specifically not about difficulty but a fairness and a sense of accomplishment, he wants to give players multiple ways to tackle a challenge but still push players into adapting different tactics.
    Almost EVERY boss in a Souls game had a 'weakness' or exploit.
    EVERY BOSS

  • @dZ0647
    @dZ0647 2 місяці тому

    Naw. 2 years it’s been now….summoning is a must. Idc if you beat it without it, so did I but it’s foolish and lame to pretend most of the game esp the 2nd half isn’t made with summons in mind. It was already bad when they made everything tyreek hill fast in ds3 but it still worked there….Elden ring just ramped it up by 50…10 hit combos where you gta dodge perfect or parry perfect etc which is great that it’s an option. Fck man, playin through Bloodborne again and I feel like I’m being ganked the entire time….bc of shit like this. Instead of making challenges they mask a lot of it with bullshit ganks, it used to be oh here’s a elite with regular mobs let’s see what you can do to Elden ring where it’s here’s a fckin mini boss with 4 elites and 5 archers that will keep you in stunlock if you get hit once…like why. I also need the mimic tear that can solo shit bc ng+4 and Maliketh (not to mention his lil bitch mini boss before his room) are so fckin annoying. Maliketh isn’t even that hard but he’s a sponge at this point and these mfkers are just to fast…I feel like they can and have made actual challenges, but they’ve gotten away from it to play fan service…bc even 2 years later people are still claiming the end of the game is fine, and those bosses are lame annoying bullshit. It’s fun on the first play through, but I feel like that’s the reason we don’t get the same feeling on play through in ER as we did in the others.

  • @Gaellirian1808
    @Gaellirian1808 2 місяці тому

    Playing Elden ring is about choices, they are as many op weapons than shitty ones. You choose how you want to play the game. Theres nothing wrong about using amything.
    I never used Mimic Tear because i knew i was an advanced player and didnt have to rely on it, so i let it disappear in my inventory.
    But new players will be happy to get the help they need with no matter what it is. So i dont agree about bashing on it

  • @joshsmith8715
    @joshsmith8715 2 місяці тому +1

    I can proudly say I never used mimic tear for any of my playthroughs, and this was my first ever souls game. And I was able to beat malenia and all the other bosses through pure melee. Wish others could’ve experienced that on their first playthrough ever of a souls game but hey no shade to you if you did use mimic tear

  • @kiraigami8002
    @kiraigami8002 2 місяці тому +2

    well, because the game doesn't have a "difficulties" option, they added this to help newbie players and for the ones who always cry and complain about how hard the game is

  • @James-os2rg
    @James-os2rg 2 місяці тому

    anyone who seriously complains about a way to play a single player video game is kind of weird.

  • @zelatoth
    @zelatoth 2 місяці тому

    I've always said that if someone wants to play the game with a base stats club with no armor and no flasks and never leveling. And the proceeds to spend 3 to 5 hours trying to beat a boss with chip damage while being one shot then I'm not gonna try to stop you in fact more power to you. I'm still gonna call you mentally stunted but don't let my opinion of your playstyle of a single player game get to you.

  • @lordofchaosinc.261
    @lordofchaosinc.261 2 місяці тому

    Yeah who cares about validation from a game. Am I twelve? I see folks overlevelling then running to Margit shouting first-try. Big deal. There are easy ways to deal with the difficulty in most cases.
    Also a second player might be more powerful than the mimic tear. Then there are buffed magic oneshots and the like, cheese galore.
    The only con I can see is that it devalues the rest of the summons.

  • @thesaltysoup5109
    @thesaltysoup5109 2 місяці тому

    He showed some of the weakest bosses in the game being beaten most likely by a +10 mimic tear and shows the final boss radagahn(don't forget there is still the Elden Beast to come) getting its butt handed to it. Lol definately a shite post

  • @Jai_dinn
    @Jai_dinn 2 місяці тому

    w

  • @BDeerhead
    @BDeerhead 2 місяці тому

    "We don't set out to create a difficult game, we set out to create a challenging game."
    - Miyazaki
    Your success in this aspiration is highly inconsistent.

  • @josephmcauley3305
    @josephmcauley3305 2 місяці тому

    Lmao a couple seconds in an rivers of blood is laughably bad even just a normal katana with double slash is better

    • @spicyrock5451
      @spicyrock5451 2 місяці тому

      On release it was pretty strong tho

  • @FortniteBallz-qt1jj
    @FortniteBallz-qt1jj Місяць тому

    I honestly don’t mind summons. I hate overpowered weapons because having them makes weaker weapons feel useless but summons are fine. They feel separate enough from the main game that it doesn’t feel bad if you don’t use them and I love using mimic tear against Godskin Duo because that fight is bs.

  • @bobbythebrainii2118
    @bobbythebrainii2118 2 місяці тому

    If it is available it is meant to be used. If you disagree you’re a dork.