Battle of the Electric - Mini-E/BMW i3/Vauxhall Corsa-E (Charging/0-62/Interior) FULL REVIEW
Вставка
- Опубліковано 26 лют 2021
- Do you agree with our scores? What electric car would be your winner?
I hope you enjoyed this video, it was a lot of fun to film! What cars would you like to see us put head-to-head next?
Hannah's UA-cam: / @hannahscartorque8763
Tish instagram: / auto_social_uk
Hannah Instagram: / hannahscartorque
Claire Instagram: / clandersonx
Track 2: Ascence - Without You [NCS Release]
Music provided by NoCopyrightSounds.
Watch: • Ascence - Without You ...
Free Download / Stream: ncs.io/WithoutYouA - Авто та транспорт
Well, what did we all think of the results? Do you agree with the winner? ⚡️🔌
BMW have reduced the UK prices of the i3 to under £35,000 so that they qualify for the £2,500 Grant after the changes made by the Government on the 18th March 2021. Just proof that BMW were just chancers with their pricing as are other Manufacturers just because up to £50,000 people could get £3,000 off. Now the cap is at £35,000.
@@georgewalker7061 wow?! That’s an enormous reduction! I didn’t think many of them fit below 40K before? Makes the i3 a lot more worth it now. I guess with the bigger electric BMWs on the way, they needed something to fit under 35K
@@AutoSocialUK the price will go down, classic supply and demand. Its not new tech so probably a convenient time to pass on the savings.
Personally it's just a shame they didn't fit in a bigger battery in the MINI which is what creates a few of its limitations :( a custom MINI battery instead of reworking the packs from an i3 would be better. Personally I do think for everyday the Corsa is best as a way to get normal people into an electric car that isn't too small or "futuristic".
It was such a good experience to film these with you two, thank you girls!!
I still think the mini should have won 😂
You put up a good fight for the little mini 🥰 we still love it!
I agree. It's truly perfect. It's got class, it's chic. The Corsa is very chavvy and it's a damn Vauxhall - isn't that the worst brand ever in the 21st century?
Absolute pleasure to film this with you talented ladies!
What a brilliant video this turned into Tish 🚘⚡️
It was a pleasure having you 🥰 excited to see what this year has to bring!!! 😁😁
Great video Tish. Informative but entertaining at the same time. Congratulations on hitting 4,000 subscribers too!
Thank you! I’m glad you enjoyed it, it was definitely my favourite video to film, even if it was a pain to edit 😂 cheers for watching as always!
wow waiting for this video!! keep up the good work I ve been here since your bmw 2 series review and the quality just keeps getting better!!
Thank you for sticking around! I don’t think you’ll be disappointed with this one!
I’m sooooo excited!!!
Great review. Nice format with the three of you competing. Hopefully more to come!
Thank you so much James. We might have a few ideas up our sleeves 😁
Great review as always...keep up the good work!
Kevin, I don’t know how you saw this 😅 the video was meant to be hidden until tomorrow morning but either way, I’m really glad you like it!
Loved this!! Xxx
Love you for watching 🥰🥰⚡️
What a lovely review. Well done, ladies. Great work.
Thank you very much!
That was fun collaboration and I hope to see more! Great info and the light humor was perfect. There's lots of numbers being conveyed to the audience in terms of range, acceleration, charging times, etc so it might be helpful to have those displayed as they're discussed? Keep it up!
You’re completely correct, I will definitely bare that in mind for next time. I’m glad you enjoyed it! 😁
Excellent review, Well presented and informative.
Thank you for watching, glad you enjoyed it 🔌
This format worked great Tish and you’re all naturals. You should make this trio the norm. A good USP
Ready. 🍿
This one is lots of fun!! ⚡️😁
Talent! Brilliant! Lovely!
Thank you for the high praise Damon :)
Good banter between you all
Good video and comparison. I would go for Corsa E. Seems more practical for the money.
What range did you get from the i3 ?
The i3 doesn’t have a small petrol engine, that was available in the REX version which isn’t available any more and hasn’t been for a while.
That one is completely my fault, Hannah works for BMW and hadn’t mentioned it once, for some reason I added it into the voiceover. The only time I have driven an i3 was a long time ago and it was the REX 🤦🏼♀️ sorry about this. Definitely doesn’t change the ratings though.
Not in the UK. I can still spec it in South Africa, even with the 120 aH i3.
exiting
Loved this ladies 😍👌💗 mini all the way for me 😂😂😂
of course!! Mini girl through and through! Thanks for watching, glad you liked it!
Great review ladies and fab team work. You three should do more together.
Thank you Keith, hopefully we can. Just logistically atm it could prove tricky with getting 3 cars but who knows.... watch this space!!!
Great video, and your ratings are spot on. My choice would be the Corsa, or its Peugeot cousins, the e208 or the e2008
Tough to choose between them, but I prefer the Mini -- seems more fun to drive daily.
I think you missed the most common chargers. 7kw home wall boxes.
Came here to see how long the Corsa took to charge but just got a reading out of some figures!
Why did the i3 get the points on the charging score? I assume because it gets faster to 80% but it's a smaller battery than the Corsa, so not a fair test.
What a great presentation....be interesting if you all ran the cars for a month....then compared your experiences of the charging networks ?
Little difficult for the girls (Claire & Hannah) as they work at the dealerships and therefore charge points at the dealership which will be their main way for ‘free’ (to them) charging. HOWEVER, perhaps not a month but I have 2 electric cars coming up (back-to-back) for 2 weeks, so I will be documenting how I get on 😁 I’m going to try charging a few ways
I thought all 3 ladies were fantastic with the reviews, Claire was so funny at the end which made me howl with laughter. And it is a nice change to have car reviews from pretty ladies and not just males
Well numbers would show that batterytech wise Corsa is the newest and the most capable one. Interiors are nicer on two others though.
Not sure I agree about rapid chargers. Look at zap map they are everywhere. In Braintree you have one in town car park, gridserve and instavolt at banmatyne . Loads of chargers out there
The 100kw ones? Wow that’s really good to know!
Think you find the road tax on the i3 is nil where did 4 hundred and something come from? The 40k luxury car tax does not apply the EV's
Just trying to completely clear this up Michael, everything online reads that you are correct but the girls (both work at BMW) have sold i3’s (even non i3 REX) have had £465 tax but we’re going to investigate even further on this to clear it up completely.
It does seemed to me that it was scrapped from April 1st 2020
@@AutoSocialUK luxury tax is only the i3 rex is payable if it was first registered between April 17 and April 2020 and had a retail price of over £40,000(road tax fees still payable at £135 per year because it's classed as a hybrid) as we are talking new cars any EV that has less than £60,000 does not pay luxury car tax.
@@MILKYBAR1969 apologies, it does seem a bit of a mind field.
@@AutoSocialUK so much miss info out there much of which is spread by the writers of FUD. fear uncertainty doubt. Working for big oil, the truth is a mine field.
Hi auto social uk great review I hope you get the vw I'd range on your channel at some stage 👍
Hi Wayne, I’ve been desperately trying to get my hands on some VW and ID, fingers crossed if I bug them enough they will eventually cave! 😁
@@AutoSocialUK fingers crossed I would love to see the vw id4 💯
The corsa is the same as the e 208 if I'm not mistaken? Loved the video . Like classic Top gear
You are correct!! :) Glad you liked the video - thanks for watching!
The e-Corsa can be the same as the e-208 but then there are the specs and the cheapest of the range are lighter and go further, then you need to look at the actual kerb weights and the e-Corsa on 16" wheels and 295 tyres or 17" & 205's. Same with the e-208. Bother are the lightest of the PSA EV cars, DS, 2008, C4 etc. The WLTP is kidology with pinches of salt needed.
I'm not convinced yet on EV cars. Yes they drive well but the charging times are too long still and range anxiety is a real thing! At present there aren't many on the roads but imagine when they are there just isn't enough chargers or infrastructure, yet! I'll stick to my petrol and try be green in other areas such as food, energy and recycling.. Great video though. Very informative and full of useful info. Personally I'd go for the Vaxhall
Thank you for commenting Nic, I have a video coming soon where I spend a week with the Nissan Leaf and directly compare it to a week with my Petrol VW up. I think you’ll find it echos exactly what you’ve just said!
@@AutoSocialUK I have access to the UP GTI as my brother has one. It's a peach! And the range is incredible for the performance from the lovely 3 cylinder engine. Theres alot to consider with EV cars I mean imagine you have no driveway or live in flats.. now where's that UP GTi...😉
Love the I3
I can highly recommend the i3 and i3s. No more noisy stinking poisonous fossil burners for me. :-)
Do you know what Ladies... that was AWESOME Entertainment. I know you all have your own things, but if that's the last we see of you 3 together, that's UA-cams loss. As for the cars... Cos I'm weird and lairy, I'd probs actually go the BMW. But it'll never beat the VW California! Same time next month on Hannah's Channel??! Whats funny though... that flippin' Car Park. When I used to go there, it'd take bloody hours to find an empty Spot.....😂
Thank you Steve for your kind words, I’m glad you enjoyed it! We may just have to sort something out again soon..... what next? Is the question
Nuts. The i3 looks so much better… apart from the rear end maybe.
I prefer the look of the Corsa.
It’s slightly more subtle but that isn’t always a bad thing!
I'd take the Corsa-E as it looks better to me!
Good cars. But sure about the awful plastic looking trousers
while I am waiting for the next model Mini Cooper SE, and waiting... and waiting... it got me curious about the now out-of-production i3s. I like it more and more. It's not pretty, but it' so smartly designed it does win my sympathy... What about you, you still dislike the look of it?
Omg what a wonder the biggest battery needs the longest time at normal charging. Why the i3 wins against the corsa-e? 50kwh again 100 kwh peak at the hpc. Who drives faster a range of 400 Miles? No question the corsa-e. More range and faster charging.
One thing of note with the i3 is that it charges at 50kW across its full capacity. The peak charge rate can be a bit misleading if you're trying to charge to 100% since most EVs slow right down as they get past 85% full. So a car with 100kW can be slower to charge fully, than an i3.
I really had no idea that there were still new BMW i3 Range Extenders available in 2021.
I’m not sure if that is sarcasm but you’re correct. No range extenders available anymore and they’re also tax exempt. Sorry fell into the trap of miss information online.
@@AutoSocialUK I thought so after check the DVLA info on the car. So how much was the cost of the BMW i3 on the review, and how far did it go on a charge?
@@georgewalker7061 I’ll get Hannah to comment on that information as her family own the car. However, the i3’s claimed range of 190 did turn out to be more achievable than the Corsa.
@@AutoSocialUK good from a smaller capacity battery. It would be good to know if that was with both starting with 100% charge. And good if you called Rapid chargers just that if they are 50 or 100kW ones. Level 1,2 or 3 and fast charge rather odd terms.
@@georgewalker7061 of course; I was trying to keep it consistent across the three of us without getting too technical. If you watch any of my other electric car reviews I will always go into KW terms ☺️
Nice video, the i3 is now outdated, it should be replaced by now, the Vauxhall is just a 208 and the mini is a rip off with low range, but I enjoyed watching 😆
I believe the i3 has been updated for 2021 but I don’t think the shape has changed. @hannahscartorque is this true?
I think the the BMW i3 is the probably the most advanced car under £200,000 so light quick for its size. Just try and beat one off the traffic lights.
Not sure how the i3 is outdated. An older design yes. However, a newer design does not guarantee that it is better.
I think most would consider the tech (i.e. screens) dated in the i3, but as for the engineering, the i3 is still ahead of the other contenders in many respects. E.g. carbon tub, double wishbone suspension, dedicated EV platform.
It is a shame that BMW haven't pursued the CFRP route and so no 'update' to the i3 design philosophy is going to happen.
Mini would definitely win the drag race if it ever happened xD
Your all fabulous ladies ☺ but I'm surprised you didn't pick an SUV as I'm a horsey boy 😉🐾🐴🤩😍🇬🇧💓🤗
No SUV’s this time but would be fun to get hold of a few SUVs for next time! 😁
‘Not losing to a Vauxhall’ looooooool
Good channel, good videos, more and more professional each time. That said I will never buy an electric vehicle - they are soulless. Is it just me?
Mercedes EQC has soul and plush leather bound seats 💺🙌😎😍
Thank you Leon, glad the hard work is showing ☺️ I do feel a little like we’re being forced towards the decision of electric rather than choosing to go that way, yes the new Porsche Taycan for example is incredible but I certainly do not have £140,000 lying around!!!!
@@shanjanusman9974 don’t hate me for this...... I like the interior but I really do not like the look of the EQC!
That leads me to the conclusion that the "soul" of a car actually comes from inhaling the fumes of its fuel... LOL
Like the video, but confused with the term 'level'. You guys used this to compare both car trims and also charging types. 🤔
Yes apologies, someone else mentioned that figures on the screen would have helped. The mini trim types are levels 1,2 & 3. The chargers also come in 1,2,3 1=3 prong, 2=fast charger, 3=super charger.... even I don’t know the KW linked to all those. 1=bloody ages, 2= a few hours, 3=pretty damn fast
I can’t see how the Mini stacks up expensive and small range - certainly wouldn’t get my money for an “eco” car
I agree, if it has the latest i3 technology and did closer to 200/200+ it would have been absolutely spot on!
The question is who would won't to do 200 miles regularly in any kind mini anyway?
None of them are really a traveling reps car.
The thing is though if you have a long commute it is saving you hundreds of pounds a mouth.
Eg a 10k car on hp equals about 250 in repayments plus fuel now you might be looking at 500 a month if you do 100 mile a day to work and maybe more for your monthly cost of motoring. Now go check PCP deal on an electric car. What would you rather have a £10,000 fiesta at 3-year old or BMW i3 / mini E/ Vauxhall Corsa E
@@AutoSocialUK
But the Mini has the exact same drivetrain and battery as the i3S.
The Mini in the USA is only $19k after tax incentives.. I am not sure what i3 technologies the Mini lacks? The i3 has no major tech no other EV is lacking.. These car city cars meant to be driven in an urban environment where there are numerous charging options, these are not long distances EVs and those complaining about the range should know these cars are purposely built with smaller batteries..
Not enough room in the trunks
Would you need +300?
Three girls from Essex showing us how little they know about, well, anything really.
Thank you for watching Simon!
Great vid as always Tish. I did like the BMW, shame the mini was not top notch. Oh, any of your mates single BTW? 😊
Ahhhh so you’re a lover of Marmite then?! 😜 They are both snapped up unfortunately!! Thank you for watching!
@@AutoSocialUK lol, yeah. Keep the videos coming 👍
The i3 wins it for me, I wonder why 😂
May you be slightly biased Terry?
It must look familiar 🤔
I3 as my vote too.
@@MILKYBAR1969 Once we hear the cost of the i3 tested then it will be helpful.
@@georgewalker7061 cost or price? It's the true cost of a car including running costs. I mean who buys a new car nowadays?
I own a bmw i3 and road tax is free.
i own a 2018 i3 Rex .....road tax £140 yearly
If I was forced to (and I mean forced to) take one of these EVs, I’d take the Mini. I can’t stand looking at that i3.
Well not a bad video but no way is that bmw base car near £40.000 and more a lot more for the i3s and you are unlikely to get much of a discount. Looks are very subjective so I will leave that one me I would of the three go for the corsa. More space welll specked and better range. And you can get one hell of a discount on it. The mini has nowhere near the range as a main car it’s only useful as a second car and as such is expensive. But I can see looking through a woman’s eyes why you would choose the the way you did.
Hope u don't mind me asking are u on Snapchat so can add u as friend tish ? X
I don’t have Snapchat unfortunately Chris! ☺️
Ok no problem I like ya a lot to chat with where u from am from blackpool in Lancashire if u know it lol x
who can stand to listen to two of these girls voices? irritating