@@ChrisForstnerNo he's confused. He thinks that because tax exists whatsoever, the whole country is 100 percent socialist. That is complete nonsense. There is an element of socialism in there, sure. But Florida is much less socialistic than California. Utah is far less socialistic than New York. There is a spectrum. It was not hard to understand that. And Charlie is saying we need to sway away from it. For whatever reason, the guy wanted a gotcha out of Charlie. Sad.
He's a bad financial investment in the current liberal education system. Get him to quit school, join the army, shut up, do as he's told and learn how the real world works.
@@WhatTheScoots, Charlie made it very clear that there is a spectrum, in his view. However, Charlie didn't make an important distinction. High taxation with lots of government programs is socialistic, but official socialism is an economic system in which the government owns all of the businesses. The claim that government itself is socialism is just ridiculous.
@@LibertyFascism For me it is a difference of degree. Especially because we know that any government grows larger by time. There is no example in history where a government went smaller and more efficient. It will always grow fat and bloated eventually. 10% taxes today will be 11% tomorrow and eventually 50%. There is a huge focus on the impossible task of how to create a government that is somehow fair and restricted. But that is just as impossible to do as to create the "new man" for communism.
@@WhatTheScoots it is impossible to form a new government like you said that is fair and restricted because we as humans are not always fair and good beings we have rules and regulations and things we know we're supposed to do or not do and we still do what pleases us
I guarantee that he owns an iPhone, an apartment/dorm, private ownership of certain non-essential things, if it were socialism, he would not have all of that hahaha
"HA! you gave me a short answer of socialism and made it more specific when pressed! therefore you don't know socialism really is and all your arguments are null and void!!!"
@@FusionnZGamernah, this kid owns nothing and pays zero bills at the moment. When he starts doing that I guarantee you he will stop being a socialist or anarchist.
It's very sad to see what is successfully being done to distort the thinking of young Americans. Thank you for what you so patiently do, Charlie and Team Turning Point.
When you are dead, you do not know you are dead. It is only painful for others. The same applies when you are stupid. That boy does not know he is stupid
This is why when I hire kids out of college I give them the lowest positions possible. Something like customer service. Most of them don't take it. The ones that do usually don't last a month. Meanwhile I hired a kid years ago right out of high school through one of our employees and he's running one of my departments. I watched him for about six months and saw the determination in everything he did. I offered to pay for half of our trade school costs. He took it and he's now a big part of our family. If you don't have to go to college don't. Save your time and money. My folks make more than most college grads and are far happier.
If your job doesnt require high skilled tasks or high skilled workers you should just hire highschool finish people. Costumer service doesnt require even high school education.
@@andrequedanca Being a Certified Financial Planner requires high skills. You don't have to get them from college. It's a myth that non college jobs are only blue collar. There are just as many white collar jobs that don't require a college degree.
@@lgsprings5623Financial planning is a solved science. The people you serve can DIY their own planning if they had the time. College is essential for highly skilled engineering/science/real finance work. Your company/firm just doesn’t need that kind of talent so you can literally pick up some homeless tramp out of the streets and teach him to do it.
Charlie Kirk keeps answering the students question with facts so the student tries restating it in a slightly different way but it is still the same question. The student doesn't want to hear the answer because it isn't the answer he wants but it is still facts. TRUMP/VANCE MAGA 2024
@@transparentglazier The kid is too ignorant to understand the facts CK gives him. Rewatch the video and then reread the comments and if you don't understand you are as ignorant as the kid. The kid is too hard trying to think of something else to ask CK that he doesn't listen to what he is saying. TRUMP/VANCE MAGA 2024
*I'm favoured only God knows how much I praise Him,* $230k every 4weeks! I now have a big mansion and can now afford anything and also support God’s work and the church.
Only God knows how much grateful i am. After so much struggles I now own a new house and my family is happy once again everything is finally falling into place!!
I started pretty low, though, $5000 thereabouts. The return came massive. Joey is in school doing well, telling me of new friends he's meeting in school. Thank you Susan Christy, you're a miracle.
Charlie gave a simple definition to an obviously complex topic for the sake of argument and this kid knew it. Every time he steered back to it, he was being intentionally dishonest.
@@DemocRATsTouchKids you do realize the kid is not a leftist, though, right? He was absolutely correct in what he was saying, Charlie wasn't able to provide a good definition and was not able to stay on topic.
Oh my god..... Let's go in circles endlessly for a thousand years because you must define everything a certain black and white way instead of actually taking in reality just a little bit.
People like this guy truly think they are intelligent simply for questioning while not understanding some things don’t need to be questioned. Taxes don’t immediately mean socialism
Watching this mesmerizing video dredges up painful memories of the recent dissolution of my 4-year relationship. The departure of my beloved, the one I adore deeply, has left me in a perpetual state of longing. Despite my tireless attempts at reconciliation , I find myself mired in frustration, unable to shake the persistent thoughts of her. Despite my efforts to move forward, I'm compelled to share my inner turmoil and the overwhelming sense of missing her here .
Letting go of someone you love deeply presents a formidable challenge. I faced a comparable ordeal when my 6-year relationship ended. Refusing to succumb to despair, I relentlessly pursued avenues to reconcile with him. Ultimately, I sought solace and guidance from a spiritual counselor, whose intervention proved instrumental in restoring our connection.
I am deeply concerned about my 2-year-old child. I fled my country to escape the influence of communist ideology, and now I feel hesitant to send my daughter to school. I fear that she might be exposed to values that go against what I believe in, and that she could be influenced by those ideologies.
10 % was not by force. If I become poor and hungry and can’t pay my property tax on my own primary residence the Gov takes it from me … they put an old lady on the street just doing that over few thousand dollars she couldn’t afford - sickening / I admire your patience Charlie. These kind of idiots boil my blood ..
This guy has no clue what extremist is does he? Have to ask why he is in school at all since he clearly thinks he already has all the answers. I wonder, how many taxes paid for the schools he went to in order to learn how to be so ignorant?
Rude kid does not allow any conversation and thinks he knows it all. He asked the same question fifty times and didn't wait for or listen to the reply by Charlie.
@@jackm3040 Of course... Mr. Kirk so evil... allow people to speak with him and give their points of view... such facist isn't it?? I also like to give people the opportunity to explain their points of view before I can claim my thoghts on them... but as much as their opnion is s***, it's their freedon the belive... I really don't respect people, do I??? I'm so triggered, I'm almost losing it... you have no idea...🤧🤧 Would you tell me why Kirk is evil? Or will you just call your self winner and leave?
To cut the long explanation, Charlie should just suggest for him to read more books so he can exercise comprehension skills, that way you won't have to dumb it down
Yep and the kid is not a liberal as the title says. He is an anarchist which means he wants no government at all. He's even further freedom than Charlie is.
The kid doesn't know the difference between taxes in California and Florida... having one state tax you 30% per say And another tax you nothing on what you make.. one definatly is more socialist than the other. Not sure how you see the kid winning this argument when he doesn't understand simple things. It's exact the same as pointing out socialist facts to him and him saying "that's not socialism" he clearly doesn't have an understanding.
@@danobraColleges and universities are funded by the Government bro. So the kid is literally a hypocrite for saying he’s an anarchist but go to college who funded by the government.
Charlie I disagree with you on a flat 10% income tax. An income tax is slavery. Property tax is too. The only fair tax is tariffs. When your society prospers the government will get more money, when it suffers the government gets less money, which encourages people in government to pass policies based on the state of the nation.
I actually don't support personal taxation. Let people choose to voluntarily pay for police or fire protection or healthcare or education. Tax corporations, not people, for defense and the military.
The dude's just saying the same f****** thing over and over and over and over again, you expect Charlie to sit there and everybody else is sit there and listen to midwit ignorant horseshit like that? Without calling out the idiocy?
It’s wild turning point posted this voluntarily. I’m not sure who made the worse argument here. Socialism is defined as the collectivism of private goods. It is not socialism for a community to work together for common goods. If a community builds a road through town, that’s not a violation of free market principle. If a community demands we pool money together to help pay for Jack down the road to have free housing, now it’s socialism. This isn’t that hard for people who actually understand economics but sadly, it seems to fly over the heads of even the people claiming to be the most versed on the topic.
This dude said he was an anarchist 🤦♂️🙄 Anarchy is usually considered to be the chaos that erupts at the lack of governmental authority in a society. However, anarchism-the theory that society is improved when people freely rule themselves apart from all laws-is touted as a worthy ideal by those who reject the necessity of governing authorities. When prevailing authorities have been overruled or removed, usually by force, anarchy results as every person becomes his or her own authority. We see examples of anarchy during riots, when police have been fought back and the crowd becomes a looting, destroying entity. While it may seem ideal for a society to operate without oversight, the reality is not so pretty because the heart of man is “evil continually” (Genesis 6:5; cf. Romans 3:10; Jeremiah 17:9). Since the Garden of Eden, mankind has loved the idea of self-rule (Genesis 3:1-7). In fact, the motivation behind most sin is the insistence upon being one’s own god. We don’t want anyone else, including our Creator, to tell us what to do. We imagine that the throwing off of all restraints equals freedom and that, if left alone, we and our neighbors could peacefully coexist without enforcement of laws and standards. But this utopian dream has never proved true. Every society that has tried anarchism has ended in anarchy and disorder. Sinful man has come to believe that our need for governing authority is a flaw that needs correcting. Yet the Bible presents a different story. God instituted law from the beginning of history (Genesis 2:16-17). Laws are merely boundaries that keep us safe and ensure human interactions are fair and honest. But boundaries must have consequences for violating them, or they are merely suggestions. Without consequences, opinions become the basis for rules, and we know that everyone has a different opinion. It is difficult enough for a group of friends to decide where to eat dinner. Far more difficult is the building of a civilization based upon varied opinions. From one person’s viewpoint, it is right to love our neighbors; from another’s, it is right to eat them. So whose viewpoint wins? The battle between opposing views can lead to anarchy. Romans 13:1-7 tells us that God designed government, and one of its primary functions is to avoid anarchy. Along with that divine authority comes the power to enforce the decided boundaries. There were a few times in biblical history when anarchy was the order of the day, and “everyone did what was right in his own eyes” (Judges 17:6, ESV; cf. Deuteronomy 12:8). It never ended well. First came blatant idolatry, followed quickly by further lawlessness and the demolition of society. God had to rescue Israel from itself by sending a series of judges to keep the peace; later, He sent a succession of kings. When anarchy rules in a culture, that culture is easy prey for a more organized enemy to overthrow it. God’s plan is not for us to live in anarchy or pursue anarchism. Though we may chafe at unjust laws and unwise lawmakers, we can still thank God for whatever system of government protects our freedoms and our lives. We are to do our best to live peacefully under that system (1 Timothy 2:2), pay our taxes (Matthew 22:21), get as involved in our local governments as we feel led to do, and pray for those in authority over us (1 Timothy 2:1-3). We should obey our authorities in all things, unless they require us to directly disobey God (Acts 5:29). Only then is civil disobedience in line with God’s Word.
Hope you don't mind-I copy/pasted your comment and shall read it back to myself in an effort to better come to understand the demise and downfall of anyone who thinks Marxism, communism, or socialism would ever work if put into widescale practice. Thank you for clearing up a few of my questions.
As Charlie said there’s a spectrum of socialism, some social services are needed. Exorbitant taxes, make the gluttonous government of a state or country wasteful.
@@WhatTheScoots In Europe Liberal parties are Pro free marker, 0 or less state intervention in economy and 0 tax or a low flat tax. Usually Center Right or Right wing party. I dont know why USA people keep calling liberals the Woke left people.
never can understand the mindset of people who are "anarchist" or "rebels" but also want government control.
All this kid wants to do is smoke weed and hear himself talk
100%! Most of these "thinkers" are dopers.
He was definitely not there to learn anything.
Nailed it
I need to smoke weed to listen to these kids
@@roxmattern60 facts
This kid definitely does not know what socialism is, wasted money on education
He's literally using the definition Kirk gave.
@@ChrisForstner "literally" shows the kid has no common sense of how human societies are different from chicken farm or sim city.
@@ChrisForstnerhe wasnt at all but intellectually dishonest people will always stick together lmao.
@@ChrisForstnerNo he's confused. He thinks that because tax exists whatsoever, the whole country is 100 percent socialist. That is complete nonsense. There is an element of socialism in there, sure. But Florida is much less socialistic than California. Utah is far less socialistic than New York. There is a spectrum. It was not hard to understand that. And Charlie is saying we need to sway away from it. For whatever reason, the guy wanted a gotcha out of Charlie. Sad.
He's a bad financial investment in the current liberal education system. Get him to quit school, join the army, shut up, do as he's told and learn how the real world works.
The questioner is just being a contrarian, arguing like a child.
The best part of Free Speech is that ignorant people can makes fools of themselves all they want
Like Charlie in this video? Cause the kid was intellectually honest.
Charlie was the one throwing out arbitrary bullshit.
@@danobra the kid goes to school that was paid for by taxes then says he is an anarchist . lol
@@danobraare you actually that dumb????
@@danobra You’re right
The kid’s a complete muppet.
The fact that he won't let Charlie explain proves everything. Looking for the "gotcha" moment that never came. 😊
The gotcha moment is charlie saying 10% taxes are fine. Which IS confiscation of private property. Which is a building block of socialism.
@@WhatTheScoots, Charlie made it very clear that there is a spectrum, in his view. However, Charlie didn't make an important distinction. High taxation with lots of government programs is socialistic, but official socialism is an economic system in which the government owns all of the businesses. The claim that government itself is socialism is just ridiculous.
@@LibertyFascism For me it is a difference of degree. Especially because we know that any government grows larger by time. There is no example in history where a government went smaller and more efficient. It will always grow fat and bloated eventually. 10% taxes today will be 11% tomorrow and eventually 50%.
There is a huge focus on the impossible task of how to create a government that is somehow fair and restricted. But that is just as impossible to do as to create the "new man" for communism.
@@WhatTheScoots it is impossible to form a new government like you said that is fair and restricted because we as humans are not always fair and good beings we have rules and regulations and things we know we're supposed to do or not do and we still do what pleases us
@@WhatTheScoots LOL what are you babbling about. taxes is not confiscation of PROPERTY. why do you people that are so stupid it hurts even comment
Unless he was born in a barn, the day he was born and all the doctor visits were using the health system, or parts of it
Most tax’s are paying for a service…police, firefighters, roads etc
This kid is so annoying, he was playing gotcha. if we pay one dime in taxes we are living in a socialist country how stupid...
I guarantee that he owns an iPhone, an apartment/dorm, private ownership of certain non-essential things, if it were socialism, he would not have all of that hahaha
"HA! you gave me a short answer of socialism and made it more specific when pressed! therefore you don't know socialism really is and all your arguments are null and void!!!"
@@FusionnZGamernah, this kid owns nothing and pays zero bills at the moment. When he starts doing that I guarantee you he will stop being a socialist or anarchist.
@@FusionnZGamer He's on board till it's time for him to be apart of what he "believes" in
He did “get him,” initially. Charlie’s definition was sloppy. I think he will refine his answer.
It's very sad to see what is successfully being done to distort the thinking of young Americans. Thank you for what you so patiently do, Charlie and Team Turning Point.
When you are dead, you do not know you are dead. It is only painful for others.
The same applies when you are stupid. That boy does not know he is stupid
Oh, I think he does cause he was staring at it.
@@danobra You are the illustration that proves my point
@@danobra every comment you get cooked😂
This is why when I hire kids out of college I give them the lowest positions possible. Something like customer service. Most of them don't take it. The ones that do usually don't last a month. Meanwhile I hired a kid years ago right out of high school through one of our employees and he's running one of my departments. I watched him for about six months and saw the determination in everything he did. I offered to pay for half of our trade school costs. He took it and he's now a big part of our family. If you don't have to go to college don't. Save your time and money. My folks make more than most college grads and are far happier.
Agree totally!
If your job doesnt require high skilled tasks or high skilled workers you should just hire highschool finish people. Costumer service doesnt require even high school education.
@@andrequedanca Being a Certified Financial Planner requires high skills. You don't have to get them from college. It's a myth that non college jobs are only blue collar. There are just as many white collar jobs that don't require a college degree.
@@lgsprings5623 But for you to be a certified finance planer you have to study. You cant get a certification on UA-cam.
@@lgsprings5623Financial planning is a solved science. The people you serve can DIY their own planning if they had the time.
College is essential for highly skilled engineering/science/real finance work. Your company/firm just doesn’t need that kind of talent so you can literally pick up some homeless tramp out of the streets and teach him to do it.
Thank you Charlie!
I think this kid simply wants to argue.. about anything..
Reminds me of myself, at age 9.
Wish he would’ve asked this kid who pays his bills? Who pays his tuition? Whose house does he go home to on break? What a dbag….
Charlie Kirk keeps answering the students question with facts so the student tries restating it in a slightly different way but it is still the same question. The student doesn't want to hear the answer because it isn't the answer he wants but it is still facts. TRUMP/VANCE MAGA 2024
The kid is a paid troll to keep trolling on Kirk, it's plain and simple
CK called him out on that, but the kid wouldn't give up
@@transparentglazier this kid is not dumb he is obviously a paid actor pretending to be dumb
@@transparentglazier The kid is too ignorant to understand the facts CK gives him. Rewatch the video and then reread the comments and if you don't understand you are as ignorant as the kid. The kid is too hard trying to think of something else to ask CK that he doesn't listen to what he is saying. TRUMP/VANCE MAGA 2024
TRUMP/KAMALA 2024
You just know this kid has wealthy parents and grew up with a silver spoon.
*I'm favoured only God knows how much I praise Him,* $230k every 4weeks! I now have a big mansion and can now afford anything and also support God’s work and the church.
Only God knows how much grateful i am. After so much struggles I now own a new house and my family is happy once again everything is finally falling into place!!
Wow that's huge, how do you make that much monthly?
I'm 37 and have been looking for ways to be successful, please how??
It's Ms. Susan Jane Christy doing, she's changed my life.
I started pretty low, though, $5000 thereabouts. The return came massive. Joey is in school doing well, telling me of new friends he's meeting in school. Thank you Susan Christy, you're a miracle.
If America is socialist, why are these kids trying to change it.
B/c they are told to, and they fall-n-line as they're told.
@@bennypit4411 Bingo
@@bennypit4411so sorry but it’s fall in line
Because they haven't been lived under that system besides brainwashed.
My reply was censored.
It's only happened in communist or dictorship countries.
No country can survive without some kind of taxation. The problem is when the government reaches too deep and controls too much.
Just the one that aspires to "anarchy" wouldn't survive it!
He wasn't born in a hospital? He doesn't commute on public roads or use electricity and water via public utilities?
What does it have to do with anything?
@@danobra he said he never used a hospital. keep up
@@danobra go ask an adult
@@danobra go ask your parents, your obviously like 12
My God what has happened to the youth of this country??
Department of Education
They went to college. This is what the "professors" are teaching.
Charlie gave a simple definition to an obviously complex topic for the sake of argument and this kid knew it. Every time he steered back to it, he was being intentionally dishonest.
This kid thinks these concepts are as defined as math. So annoying
The Left thinks "math is racist" 😂
That's exactly the problem today. People sees no distinction between a real world human society and a "society" of NPCs in a game.
@@DemocRATsTouchKids you do realize the kid is not a leftist, though, right?
He was absolutely correct in what he was saying, Charlie wasn't able to provide a good definition and was not able to stay on topic.
@@danobra 👈found another leftist
@@danobrafound another moron😂
Should've asked who's paying for his schooling...
Kid needs to stop with the drugs...
Nope. Charlie needs to read some books.
@@danobraThen certainly you can explain where Kirk was in error.
He is an anarchist but goes to school. Oh, what a rebel.
I bet you 20 bucks he listens to Rage against the machine religiously
It's okay, it's not his money.
and obeys traffic laws prolly has a driver ID etc!!
@@3DNETWORK hey, I like Rage lol Killing in the name is a badass song.
So wonder if he uses city water, public roads, public parks...
Oh my god..... Let's go in circles endlessly for a thousand years because you must define everything a certain black and white way instead of actually taking in reality just a little bit.
There, I've given the 100 thumbs up for Charlie Kirk.
He has one point that he thinks is brilliant
That's his whole existence
These kids just repeat things they have heard but dont really understand.
He's more interested in talking, and not listening....
Typical of the cultist Left
How dare he talking when there is a big sign that says "prove me wrong"....
@@WhatTheScoots someone poked that soft spot on your skull when you were a baby. Didn't they?
@@WhatTheScoots Someone poked that soft spot on your skull when you were a baby.... didn't they?
@@WhatTheScoots Someone poked that soft spot on your head when you were a baby.... didn't they?
People like this guy truly think they are intelligent simply for questioning while not understanding some things don’t need to be questioned. Taxes don’t immediately mean socialism
And yet this is the smartest student that’s debated Charlie the last few weeks.
If only they tried this hard to counter their professor's take
Oh dear. 'Mr' hoddie is in for such a surprise when he enters the real world ! Haha
Watching this mesmerizing video dredges up painful memories of the recent dissolution of my 4-year relationship. The departure of my beloved, the one I adore deeply, has left me in a perpetual state of longing. Despite my tireless attempts at reconciliation , I find myself mired in frustration, unable to shake the persistent thoughts of her. Despite my efforts to move forward, I'm compelled to share my inner turmoil and the overwhelming sense of missing her here .
Letting go of someone you love deeply presents a formidable challenge. I faced a comparable ordeal when my 6-year relationship ended. Refusing to succumb to despair, I relentlessly pursued avenues to reconcile with him. Ultimately, I sought solace and guidance from a spiritual counselor, whose intervention proved instrumental in restoring our connection.
Remarkable! How did you discover a spiritual counselor, and what's the procedure for me to get in contact with her?
Meet Suzanne Ann Walters, a renowned spiritual counselor acclaimed for her talent in bringing back ex-partners.
Many thanks for providing this valuable information; I've just conducted an online search for her.
What in the bot account conversation did I walk into?
The devil lives in the detail which is where this boy argues from.
The fellow has a stellar career in academia ahead of him.
I am deeply concerned about my 2-year-old child. I fled my country to escape the influence of communist ideology, and now I feel hesitant to send my daughter to school. I fear that she might be exposed to values that go against what I believe in, and that she could be influenced by those ideologies.
Wow that collage student is paying for that level of mind blowing idiotic thought
I think you're the idiotic one.
Ten bucks says he comes from a VERY wealthy family.
I hope this guy will never need to call the police ambulance in the future. He’ll be eating his own words.
Unfortunately for him if there was anarchy he wouldn't stand a chance and would probably learn a painful valuable lesson.
The kid is all mouth and no ears. Sad!
10 % was not by force. If I become poor and hungry and can’t pay my property tax on my own primary residence the Gov takes it from me … they put an old lady on the street just doing that over few thousand dollars she couldn’t afford - sickening
/ I admire your patience Charlie. These kind of idiots boil my blood ..
Only difference between Socialism and Communism is the Spelling.😂😮😂😮😂😮
This guy has no clue what extremist is does he? Have to ask why he is in school at all since he clearly thinks he already has all the answers. I wonder, how many taxes paid for the schools he went to in order to learn how to be so ignorant?
He's an "anarchist".
Gimme a break.
"I'll just try and make this one point over and over and over and over again. I got him."
Rude kid does not allow any conversation and thinks he knows it all. He asked the same question fifty times and didn't wait for or listen to the reply by Charlie.
Kirk lost this argument. He wins 99 percent but on syllogistic terms he lost this one. Need to read Hoppe
A friend had a parrot like that once. No matter what you said, it only had one answer. ... I can't print that answer here, this is a family show.
Socialist CallMeKevin sounding like a broken record
Lol
Like talking to a rock.
Romans 1:22 “Although they claimed to be wise, they became fools.”
absolutely nobody likes that kid
I do.
@@danobra No, you're just a troll.
@@jackm3040 Of course... Mr. Kirk so evil... allow people to speak with him and give their points of view... such facist isn't it??
I also like to give people the opportunity to explain their points of view before I can claim my thoghts on them... but as much as their opnion is s***, it's their freedon the belive... I really don't respect people, do I???
I'm so triggered, I'm almost losing it... you have no idea...🤧🤧
Would you tell me why Kirk is evil? Or will you just call your self winner and leave?
That guy only wamna hear his voice
He doesn't want to debate.
He just wants to take over the replies to his questions. 🙄
To cut the long explanation, Charlie should just suggest for him to read more books so he can exercise comprehension skills, that way you won't have to dumb it down
Dude got Charley. We are a socialist nation. Florida is a policed state.
Yep and the kid is not a liberal as the title says. He is an anarchist which means he wants no government at all. He's even further freedom than Charlie is.
He should have asked the kid if he walks in the street or walks in the park or drives on the roads.
Kirk lost that one and the student isn't "liberal".
YES
The kid doesn't know the difference between taxes in California and Florida... having one state tax you 30% per say
And another tax you nothing on what you make.. one definatly is more socialist than the other.
Not sure how you see the kid winning this argument when he doesn't understand simple things. It's exact the same as pointing out socialist facts to him and him saying "that's not socialism" he clearly doesn't have an understanding.
Love those College is a Scam Shirts
All woke rhetoric, no knowledge or common sense. Hasn't read up on subject.....
An anarchist going to college 😂😂😂
I don't think you know what Anarchy means.
@@danobraColleges and universities are funded by the Government bro. So the kid is literally a hypocrite for saying he’s an anarchist but go to college who funded by the government.
ProAmerican = Freedom
Just bought one of the _American Farmer_ tees that the attentive girl behind this sleepy guy is wearing! 🇺🇸🚜 _Feeding the Red, White & Blue_ 😊
Sad that Police have to be there.
Sounds more like this kid has a sounder argument than Charlie 😮
Anarchist! He'll finally grow up one day.
I lost brain cells listening to both of them. Lord help us.
It's amazing how effective Charlie is in attracting the biggest tossers modern universities have to offer !!!!!!!!!!!!!!
the kid is a whack job but definitely kept charlie on his toes. I am sure he was stimulated by this. the other kids have been a layup for him
Another 'gotcha' merchant.
So sad, how brainwashed young people ( so many of them)are. Thank you, Charlie, for trying to explain them....
I'd like Captain Know-It-All to explain when day ends and night begins.
Have you ever been to the hospital have you ever called the cops he just said no he know he was lying😂
What ever happened to government bonds to fund the government? That way people can decide each project they want to fund.
Charlie I disagree with you on a flat 10% income tax. An income tax is slavery. Property tax is too. The only fair tax is tariffs. When your society prospers the government will get more money, when it suffers the government gets less money, which encourages people in government to pass policies based on the state of the nation.
That's why Jefferson in the end refused to engage in debate. Some like it...Some think it nonsense.
Good dialogue and respectful
10% across the board would be more than fair. Everyone should pay; it gives an incentive to work harder and not suck off the system.
I actually don't support personal taxation. Let people choose to voluntarily pay for police or fire protection or healthcare or education. Tax corporations, not people, for defense and the military.
The first sane comment after scrolling for about a minute. Thank you!
He's a child arguing 'fingers & thumbs'.
The " who will build the roads " justification coming from " the right " . Overton window has moved way f- ing left
That kid should have stayed home...
Charlie shouldn't interrupt so much. Just letting these people speak shows the flaws in their arguments better than constantly overtalking them.
That guy was constantly interrupting charlie lol! Did we watch the same video??
The dude's just saying the same f****** thing over and over and over and over again, you expect Charlie to sit there and everybody else is sit there and listen to midwit ignorant horseshit like that? Without calling out the idiocy?
@@Whiskey0880 yes, but Charlie is supposed to be the sane, rational one.
Ever notice why Charlie seems to win debates? He constantly talks over the person trying to make a statement.. Very smart Charlie
Right? He did terrible. The kid is clearly a hardcore libertarian and he was using Charlie's own definitions.
@@danobra cant be an anarchist and libertarian. why are you so stupid?
That kid is actually intelligent, but misguided in his anarchist beliefs.
You'd have to prove that he is misguided. Charlie fumbled hard here
Without forced taxation, who will pay the police to force close your business during muh pandemic??
It’s wild turning point posted this voluntarily. I’m not sure who made the worse argument here.
Socialism is defined as the collectivism of private goods. It is not socialism for a community to work together for common goods. If a community builds a road through town, that’s not a violation of free market principle. If a community demands we pool money together to help pay for Jack down the road to have free housing, now it’s socialism. This isn’t that hard for people who actually understand economics but sadly, it seems to fly over the heads of even the people claiming to be the most versed on the topic.
Kirk should have shut him down on the "any tax makes a government socialist". End of any possible argument.
This dude said he was an anarchist 🤦♂️🙄
Anarchy is usually considered to be the chaos that erupts at the lack of governmental authority in a society. However, anarchism-the theory that society is improved when people freely rule themselves apart from all laws-is touted as a worthy ideal by those who reject the necessity of governing authorities. When prevailing authorities have been overruled or removed, usually by force, anarchy results as every person becomes his or her own authority. We see examples of anarchy during riots, when police have been fought back and the crowd becomes a looting, destroying entity. While it may seem ideal for a society to operate without oversight, the reality is not so pretty because the heart of man is “evil continually” (Genesis 6:5; cf. Romans 3:10; Jeremiah 17:9).
Since the Garden of Eden, mankind has loved the idea of self-rule (Genesis 3:1-7). In fact, the motivation behind most sin is the insistence upon being one’s own god. We don’t want anyone else, including our Creator, to tell us what to do. We imagine that the throwing off of all restraints equals freedom and that, if left alone, we and our neighbors could peacefully coexist without enforcement of laws and standards. But this utopian dream has never proved true. Every society that has tried anarchism has ended in anarchy and disorder. Sinful man has come to believe that our need for governing authority is a flaw that needs correcting. Yet the Bible presents a different story.
God instituted law from the beginning of history (Genesis 2:16-17). Laws are merely boundaries that keep us safe and ensure human interactions are fair and honest. But boundaries must have consequences for violating them, or they are merely suggestions. Without consequences, opinions become the basis for rules, and we know that everyone has a different opinion. It is difficult enough for a group of friends to decide where to eat dinner. Far more difficult is the building of a civilization based upon varied opinions. From one person’s viewpoint, it is right to love our neighbors; from another’s, it is right to eat them. So whose viewpoint wins? The battle between opposing views can lead to anarchy.
Romans 13:1-7 tells us that God designed government, and one of its primary functions is to avoid anarchy. Along with that divine authority comes the power to enforce the decided boundaries. There were a few times in biblical history when anarchy was the order of the day, and “everyone did what was right in his own eyes” (Judges 17:6, ESV; cf. Deuteronomy 12:8). It never ended well. First came blatant idolatry, followed quickly by further lawlessness and the demolition of society. God had to rescue Israel from itself by sending a series of judges to keep the peace; later, He sent a succession of kings. When anarchy rules in a culture, that culture is easy prey for a more organized enemy to overthrow it.
God’s plan is not for us to live in anarchy or pursue anarchism. Though we may chafe at unjust laws and unwise lawmakers, we can still thank God for whatever system of government protects our freedoms and our lives. We are to do our best to live peacefully under that system (1 Timothy 2:2), pay our taxes (Matthew 22:21), get as involved in our local governments as we feel led to do, and pray for those in authority over us (1 Timothy 2:1-3). We should obey our authorities in all things, unless they require us to directly disobey God (Acts 5:29). Only then is civil disobedience in line with God’s Word.
Hope you don't mind-I copy/pasted your comment and shall read it back to myself in an effort to better come to understand the demise and downfall of anyone who thinks Marxism, communism, or socialism would ever work if put into widescale practice. Thank you for clearing up a few of my questions.
As Charlie said there’s a spectrum of socialism, some social services are needed. Exorbitant taxes, make the gluttonous government of a state or country wasteful.
This is what you come up with when you have only one bullet in your magazine.
Charlie didn't do well lol
Exactly! This comment section is full of people that cannot tell the difference between a libertarian and anarchist and a socialist and liberal
@@WhatTheScoots In Europe Liberal parties are Pro free marker, 0 or less state intervention in economy and 0 tax or a low flat tax. Usually Center Right or Right wing party. I dont know why USA people keep calling liberals the Woke left people.
Thank god someone noticed it.
@@WhatTheScoots Right? This is the level of right wingers we have in the US?! I guess things are gonna get worse from now on
@@danobra I am not even from the US, friend. 😭I am from germany. Good luck on the elections though.
Kid won that debate.