Elon Musk on Israel-Hamas war
Вставка
- Опубліковано 8 лис 2023
- Lex Fridman Podcast full episode: • Elon Musk: War, AI, Al...
Please support this podcast by checking out our sponsors:
- LMNT: drinkLMNT.com/lex to get free sample pack
- Eight Sleep: www.eightsleep.com/lex to get special savings
- BetterHelp: betterhelp.com/lex to get 10% off
- SimpliSafe: simplisafe.com/lex to get free security camera plus 20% off
- Shopify: shopify.com/lex to get $1 per month trial
- NetSuite: netsuite.com/lex to get free product tour
GUEST BIO:
Elon Musk is CEO of X, xAI, SpaceX, Tesla, Neuralink, and The Boring Company.
PODCAST INFO:
Podcast website: lexfridman.com/podcast
Apple Podcasts: apple.co/2lwqZIr
Spotify: spoti.fi/2nEwCF8
RSS: lexfridman.com/feed/podcast/
Full episodes playlist: • Lex Fridman Podcast
Clips playlist: • Lex Fridman Podcast Clips
SOCIAL:
- Twitter: / lexfridman
- LinkedIn: / lexfridman
- Facebook: / lexfridman
- Instagram: / lexfridman
- Medium: / lexfridman
- Reddit: / lexfridman
- Support on Patreon: / lexfridman - Наука та технологія
Full podcast episode: ua-cam.com/video/JN3KPFbWCy8/v-deo.html
Lex Fridman podcast channel: ua-cam.com/users/lexfridman
Guest bio: Elon Musk is CEO of X, xAI, SpaceX, Tesla, Neuralink, and The Boring Company.
I love how he is still an engineer while taking on the Israel/Palestine conflict. And he is really right in his conclusion and assesment. The hard part is that there is also a number of other terror organisations which might feel encouraged to attack Israel if they don´t see a really hard response from Israel. That makes this so much more difficult and maybe impossible.
Pragmatism thwarts idealism -- every time.
When Muslims peacefully took control of Jerusalem, they did it without any bloodshed! They did not seek revenge for previous oppressions of their enemies! That’s why the most peaceful time in Palestine has been when Muslims ruled it. Jews trying their best to beat Christians in who can be the most oppressive! What losers!
UN resolutions 242 and 338 call for an immediate end of occupation of lands captured in 1967 and return of expelled refugees to their homeland. Geneva Conventions prohibit the transfer of settlers to occupied land and the expulsion of natives.
Implement UN resolutions 242 and 338 and end the occupation of the state of Palestine. There are 7 million refugees who have been waiting 70 years to return home. END THE OCCUPATION.
they were sppittting danc ing ye llling, now theyre c ryingg
" For every member of Hamas you killed, how many did you create" This stays in my mind . Great interview. Thank you
See? You shouldn't fight terrorism.
Become an activist and join Allah
@@blackdynamite_5470Negga u dont have to follow a particular religion for stopping wars
@@_Lucifer_. Pay no attention to a sarcastic weeb
It is at least worth a thought..
water has memory and blood even more so
The way he strugled to say "if you kill somebody' child" makes you realise how hard it is on any father.
True words though. Smart
No he's just dyslexic 💀🔥
if you were a genius, you'd know speech impediments are not an indication that someone isn't a genius. However, in Musk's case, I seriously doubt he's a genius.@@Terrorist371
@@Terrorist371many of these “ Geniuses” are extremely socially awkward..Elon isn’t as bad with his speech as others I’ve seen
@@Terrorist371Terrorist371 on Lex freidman next?
You can see why he is such a successful man. His assessment is very accurate and his solutions alot more just than present politician's take in Israel or any other western country. Well said Elon.
His opinions are what a stupid person thinks a smart person sounds like.
Oh Elon how I simp for you
this is what he set himself to do in life; solutions to a big global problem.
Oh please. His response was simplistic and vapid. If this is all he has to say, I don't know why anyone should care what he thinks. We should all go watch coverage by NPR, DW, and Al Jazeera instead.
@@SpiceBoy7UK23oh ya like bill gates… idiots
I appreciate his very measured response. It was compassionate yet logical.
Tme/Elonmuskdz9ve
Musk is only talking about white mans suffering and not human suffering
Dont get misled by becoming a blind follower
he is a clown! watch what he did visiting a war criminal in Israel, if you dare visit Gaza and don't belive media propaganda. see the genoicide with you eyes
@@zorro20010 what TF does that even mean???
Spoken like a true engineer. Someone who actually wants to solve a problem.
Only he is not an engineer he spoke more like computer scientist which he is by profession, problem solver and not on-off button switcher. Ahm ahm 😁
@@anismatar If you honestly think engineers are button pushers, you have a lot to learn.
@@MaxSchaphorst From my experience I don't think, I know. It is either red or green for them, system up and running, whatever gibberish it produces 😂
@@anismatar Like I said, you have a lot to learn
@@MaxSchaphorst
software engineer
It will work
For both of you
The trauma the children in war remember later on is what keeps wars going on.
Yuup. Pretty sure Israel created a generation of hate for the kids that survived.
Misconception of the naive west
They fight for islam not for better life, its clear when you look at their history.
Couldn’t have said it better, both for the Palestinians and Jews, and the cycle keeps going, same thing for thousands of years
I also think many Israelis haven't healed from the trauma of the holocaust so they feel they have to wipe out any perceived threat to their nation, livelihood etc (the whole "Never Again" mentality)
@@ahmedalani3513 "The cycle of violence won't end until one party vanishes entirely" - Eren Kruger (Attack on Titan)
I like the way Mr Musk has not distanced himself far from the world around him, and has the dignity to pause before answering questions. Those responses came form the heart, not the head. All we can hope for is someone in Israel is watching and also has the same qualities as Mr Musk, to try and stop this awful war. War has no winners!
Do you also like how his family got rich off of slaves and apartheid 😐
@@unknownvip00i bet he likes all the ketamine musk does too
@@unknownvip00 to be fair its out of subject how his family did got rich dont involve his own actions , he didn't chose it was given to him
@@mathias9542 same thing a lot of rich whites say oh yeah I’m not racist I just live off the money from racism my grandparents made
@unknownvip00
Nop, he didn't use any of his father money because his father had already lost it when he was quite young, lol
He talks more sense in a topic where he is clearly not an expert but makes more sense than most of the experts combined.
He has read all of the holy books while he was having existential crisis in his adolescence. He does know a lot about this conflict
Tme/Elonmuskdz9ve
You do not kill children no matter who their parents are. Why is this so hard to understand?
Israelis don’t regards non Jews as people
because they're Palestinian children, they don't matter to the west, no benefit.
Children die in every war, sadly. Israel isn’t killing kids for the sake of killing kids - can’t say the same about Hamas.
War is hell
@@AWOL401what are you talking about, they are bombing children hospitals, why do you think they do that? Satanyahu said it when Rabin tried to sign peace agreement: no place for both, we are not dividing Jerusalem
Elon was careful in his answers , but he said it in a nice way.
No, he wasn't careful. That's how he speaks all the time. What did he say?
@@nowinterflight6648he was being careful you dork 😂
he was and i know he is a student of history and probably have more to say about Israel
Yep!
Look at how many Palestinians have been killed or displaced since Israel's colonial and dare I say it, terrorist formation in 1948 and compare it with the number of Israeli civilians killed. There aren't just Muslims in Palestine. You only have to be human to condemn Israel's formation, to condemn Hamas and to condemn Israel's illegal expansion/ethnic cleansing.
There is always a bigger picture than the picture they allow us to see. Things like this don’t happen without many powerful people pulling the strings and make us believe a narrative they keep forcing us to hear but being done for a completely different purpose
Dahiya doctrine is making everywhere around Israel uninhabitable
Bingo! This is why almost EVERYBODY on both sides of the debate, from Chomsky, Finkelstein, and their leftist fans, to Zionists and their shills in media, to alternative news heroes . . . almost EVERYBODY partaking in the debate on this issue simply do not see the principalities in operation at the root of this (and all other) conflicts of this world. It's actually always been this way, one way or other, throughout history and everywhere. This is why the world most CERTAINLY is ending horribly by humanity's own hands. Not to sound like a Bible-thumper or anything, but I'll say it anyway because it is true: JESUS SAVES! The Gospels lay out clearly the Law of Love, the nature of Truth, the actual structure and source of evil in the world and in our hearts, and the way out of it: the path to the Truth, the Way, and the Life.
What do you think that bigger purpose is?
Tme/Elonmuskdz9ve
Money, power, and of course resources!!!
This is exactly what I wanted to hear, Elon said it exactly how it is! Finally a wise celebrity speaks.
I wouldn't class Elon as a 'celeb'... But agree he says it perfectly.
@@kt-11011he goes to met galas he’s a celeb
Dude a whole clown he supports the Jews so I’m not surprised 💩🇮🇱🐷
He is an idiot.
Islamic law requires Muslims to destroy any infidel government which has taken over a land that was once under Islamic rule. That is THE source for the hatred of Israel. It has nothing to do with "An eye for an eye" and all the acts of kindness in the world are meaningless, unfortunately.
It's nice to hear Elon be sensible.
he's sensible when you agree. he's a nazi when you don't. gtfo
Fear of Zionists will do that
Read 👉 Albert Einstein Letter to the New York Times
He has always been sensible, just that now he says something you want to hear
Man always spoke sense, you just agree with him in this instance
Peace is the only weapon that wins a conflict.
I don’t think elon musk have any idea about the situation in palestine how israel commit a massacre towards the palestinian people
A really smart and thoughtful answer to a really difficult question.
Of all the ways the west has tried and failed to eradicate terrorism, kindness may be its most effective weapon of all.
Except the Amerikkk4ns are the biggest t3rror1sts in the world who create t3rror1sts like AlQaeda and ISIS. Just like how Israh3ll created Hamas.
You mean the kindness that they received to build their own water system, instead they used the money & pipes to build 7,000 rockets, to dig tunnels but not for pipes, but to train these terrorist hit squads to use these tunnels to invade, murder & decapitate babies? These people don't want peace, they VOTED for Hamas to run their government.
If only it’s that simple.
Why does everyone say this is a difficult question. It’s not difficult at all. Many things could work. The hard part is getting both parties to agree to ANY solution.
though the kindness they want is to give them their land back
Respect for this man for having an unbiased yet humanitarian opinion on this matter and addressing a genuine hate crises towards the end of the video.
"For every member of Hamas you killed, how many did you create?"
So true. "For every member of the Nazis you killed, how many did you create?"
........
just the truth, perfect.@@Hutchinator8309
@@Hutchinator8309 9 Million exactly. They live in Israel.
so you admit to being a nazi?
@@seer775
bro what?@@seer775
"Conspicuous acts of kindness." Elon put something in words that I've been thinking about for years, essentially asking myself if there is a way to create peace by initiating peace as a response to war, not surrender, but real peace.
It sounds great, but there's no evidence for it. In fact, it's the opposite. Israel provides Gaza with electricity, water, takes out their garbage. Same in mu country, Georgia. We have regions occupied by Russia. We've provided separatists with free electricity and healthcare but they just don't care. They still commit brutal acts of violence of Georgian residents left in above mentioned regions and they most certainly don't think of putting down their illegitemate power.
Tme/Elonmuskdz9ve
There is a need to be human, period.
Acts of kindness, what a great answer. I'm not even a fan of tesla. Now, this is a man of reason. ❤ An eye for an eye. Leaves everyone blind.
great response.
Meaning Hamas was happy to blind Israel
Sure... acts of kindness... but so much money in military for what? Much more profitable acts of evilness right? extremely right!!
I think the trouble with Musk's answer is that he's talking about Jews and Muslims. Christians are the Abrahamic Faith that believes in turn the cheek, kindness towards enemies. Those were the teachings of Jesus Christ. The Jews and Muslims only go by the Old Testament... which is OBLITERATE YOUR ENEMIES, because they are the enemy of God, and God is therefore with you. Jews and Muslims are two bulls in 1 China shop.
But if someone touch him or his family... no mercy, no free speech, no acts of kindness
Elon Musk tells it like it is and his thoughts are shared by many of us.
Meaning no real solutions. Just everyone's a smart ass telling others what not to do?
Haha.
"Tell it like it is".
Clueless westerners.
@@TheCriticsAreRavingfacts
Everything about this colonial entity is exposed, long ago since Tantura and before. All is available online, Musk's opinion is appreciated but not needed.
@@TheCriticsAreRaving Israel is not apartheid. 20% of the country's citizens are Arab and they have representation in parliament and the Defense Forces
@TheCriticsAreRaving or maybe he ows a social media platform and doesn't get clouded by the bs you've been eating.
Extremely intelligent and informative in many various aspects!
How is that extremely intelligent. He is just spewing out pretty standard opinions that aren't revolutionary in any way.
@@samuelhakansson6680this comment section feels so full of bots. Lol
Only pro musky comments on the top
Yeah not like that Woke Pro palestine shit that support and feed Hamas and all muslim terror around the world !
@@tantoquejodeoiga1197that’s because he is speaking facts and you are the one brainwashed by western media. Search for what’s really going on. Turn your brain on look at what at what an apartheid is and look at Gaza and Palestine. It’s not hard if you use your brain, however it is difficult if you are braindead.
Did you catch Spartacus (Freedom Fighters)? Are they taking on the government’s military in the show?
He is very smart person for a reason. He actually understands the situation better than a lot of politicians we have....
His very very intelligent. How can you wipe out cities clean and expect to think the root problem is gone 🤦
Absolutely. Totally agree.
As a political scientist I can almost guarantee you that most politicians understand it and even understand it very well, only in politics or in geopolitics it is more about interests and alliances.
@@ozzylink Even when Palestinians returned to peaceful demonstrations towards the fences in 2014, they were shot dead by the hundreds.
@@cheguevararevolutionair852 Yes, its True...
I can’t over state how much I enjoy hearing this man’s opinions on things. He understands nuance in a very pleasing way
Dude just makes sense using very simple words.
It's true but this time he is just not familiar with the facts.The leader of Hamas had cancer and he was treated in Israel, Israel is also taking care of Palestinian kids who have Cancer. Palestinians are allowed to work in Israel since all the money Hamas gets, is redirect to Terror. And now we have reports that Palestinians who worked in the Kibuts, helped Hamas murder civilians. I think Israel had been kind enough.
@@commie5211which is more than can be said for most world leaders.
Wish he was more nuanced on Twitter
@@spokentruth5909 cant be nuanced with 150 characters
The amount of breaks and pauses shows how carefully he has to pick his words very carefully.
He’s trying to express 10% of his thoughts on the subject without getting burnt!!!
Exactly especially because his discussion a subject he has limited knowledge about
someone like Elon who never hold his thoughts back is also scared by Israel, wow man. The entire world can't even say something like. Killing kids and innocents is bad without being careful. This is crazy.
@@ojurdenis1190the guy has read every book out there on war. Trust me, he has far more than limited knowledge. He’s just careful with his choice of words so as not to be blasted over social media, etc. which is the norm these days when you’re a figure like him.
He always speaks like that.
not for all the issues, when it comes to israel gov't, the entire world is scared, any other country does the same thing, it will be met with sanctions and end of the world. But Israel, they can do anything and you are labeled as anti-semite( which word I find funny when you critize their war crimes". The entire world is showing prayers but every day killing of 1000's is justified in name of defending israel from what? Oct 7th? What about killing of palestine and treating them like animals for 75 years and ruling over them? Can you imagine if bunch of brown people , took over land and controlled few jewish people. What would that be called? Stop making excuses. @@AR-tl5cd
That was probably the best answer I’ve seen so far.
How a businessmen can take risk to answer question freely? He is genius and good businessman. He answered like chatgpt started from its tough.
"The goal of Hamas was to provoke an overreaction from Israel." Finally someone has said what I figured out on Day 1.
You are genius man
And the goal of israel was to get a excuse to level gaza by giving money to hamas leaders and waiting 6 hours before responding to the hamas attack
@@goodebening6564 source?
i thought this was general consensus among everyone who are practical and not emotionally driven
@@Samoosam25it is common knowledge that Israel has funded Hamas. In fact they have been favouring Hamas over the Palestinian Authority for years
I have a whole new respect for him after his outlook on this issue. His heart is sure in the right place.
“Whoever fights monsters should see to it that in the process he does not become a monster.” - Friedrich Nietzsche
I am old enough and I have seen enough to say that Israel became a monster long time ago.
The monster on this guys is isarel not Hamas
and who you think are monsters here ?
lmaooooooooooooooooo@@Bell_plejdo568p
@@Bell_plejdo568p Monsters are the ones who attack a country formed yesterday, 5 against one, lose the war and then claim victimhood.
E.g. Germans and Japanese are not monsters, they started WW2, lost and took their defeat with dignity.
“An eye for an eye, makes everyone blind” powerful
This must be the most monotone yet brilliant 5 minutes on the internet.
Tme/Elonmuskdz9ve
Pearls of wisdom. Thanks Elon. Hopefully your message of compassion spreads like ripples on a pond
“When the power of love overcomes the love of power, the world will know peace.” - Jimi Hendrix
Elon for King
he says russia hasnt taken that much land but that land theyve taken is as large as denmark lol
The exact opposite is happening - ua-cam.com/video/CoYny0N1lR0/v-deo.html
No wisdom ... there is also no need for a genocide... you can drive them out to the Arab countries. This eliminates this source of conflict and after a few generations the Palestinians merge into the Arab countries. There is no other solution ... that would be realistic ... the differences between these ethnic groups are too great for a one-state solution and a two-state solution is geographically not realistically feasible
I have to say I have hardly ever liked anything coming out of that man. But this was genuinely very well put.
You don't like cars that do 0 to 60 in seconds or rockets blasting in to space?
this showed he had no clue on the conflicts history.he did not even mention zionists
The land was never Palestine’s, that’s a myth.
When Muslims peacefully took control of Jerusalem, they did it without any bloodshed! They did not seek revenge for previous oppressions of their enemies! That’s why the most peaceful time in Palestine has been when Muslims ruled it. Jews trying their best to beat Christians in who can be the most oppressive! What losers!
😂 It was literally called PALESTINE before israelis stole it and continue to steal it till now!
There once was a man who claimed:
HIS way was the only,
HIS culture was the only,
HIS religion was the only
HIS love was the only, until, he was only lonely.
Thanks
trying to digest these ideas.
the most sensible plan I have heard thus far
Contentious is definitely the correct word to use. It's also difficult to label someone as a terrorist, even if they create acts of so called 'terrorism.' If you burn down my house, and I tell you that I love you even though you destroyed part of my life, then you burn down my kids house, and I still forgive you, but then you steal my land and tell me that it's gods will, and I fight back, is that terrorism?
No. Terrorism is the use of violence to achieve a political goal. What you stated isn't even close, which was your point, i'm sure.
@@ermesborgnino4704 The violence is more specifically against civilians. If it's not against civilians then that's just war in general.
Well questioned. The convenient forgetting of the Nakba is just pure hubris from Musk. He is not the answer to all peoplekinds problems. I also believe he is one of the problems of this world.
Is raping children "fighting back"?
@@ucmanhle9601 Oh you don't have to tell me! But, i don't think it's war in general. i think it's a civil war. Internal within Israel's borders.
eye for an eye law was initially set as a limit in response, meaning you could not retaliate in a disproportionate way. It was an attempt at justice while preventing all out war amongst tribe members. Now the phrase is interpreted as a call for vengeance
It is both a call for vengeance as well as equal response. An equal response tend to escalate because both side underestimate the badness of their response and overestimate the badness of their opponent's response. Furthermore, for a century back and forth conflict like Israel-Palestine. It would go on forever even if both side would keep doing fair eye-for-an-eye response.
People seem to forget that terrorist organization Hamas can end the war immediately by surrendering themselves and by releasing the hostages, but instead they want to happen what is happening know, they want it to go on and they want things to escalate even further, they are willing to sacrifice and keep sacrificing the Palestinians for their wish for an infernal war.
an eye for an eye leaves the whole world blind unfortunately, but governments and military in their nature are supposed to act as a defender and enforcer for their people so intrinsically a government cant transcend this dilemma if it wishes to still be a government
Israel believes in the Old Testament/Hebrew Bible which calls for an eye for an eye. They have the bible to back them up and divine calling to back them up. Who cares what the world thinks when your actions are backed up in a divine way LOL. I am kidding of course. There needs to be peace.
"Now" in that sense began a long time ago ;)
We need engineers, physician and doctor's in Power not power hungry narcissistic psychopaths.
We can see and hear his sadness at not having a solution. He realizes it is hopeless.
He just gave the solution lol. It's not a complex situation as we are told.
@@samikhalloufi1530 …overt acts of kindness…” That’s not a long term solution. He knows it. You know it. Everyone with an understanding of the source of hatred, knows it. Is it a potential solution to near term pain and suffering? maybe.
“Lol” …naive fool or gaslighter? Which choice characterizes you best? A, B, or A+B
@@callmesceptical9114 well Israel should leave the occupied territories according to international law, support and treat Palestinians like actual people. And there you have it... treat the people with kindness and radical groups will lose support of the people. And don't let Israel create and fund groups such as Hamas to split the Palestinians would also help.
Wow, it’s amazing to see the difference between how politicians approach this issue versus a person who specializes in actually solving some of the biggest problems in human history. What a completely different and affective approach he has.
Because acts of kindness are free or cheap and don't result in any profit being made. Politicians are always looking to keep their backers in the defense industry well paid.
Whenever Israel has made concessions, those concessions have backfired. The reality of the situation is that Israel is too small in terms of both land area and population to be able to play nice. The U.S. and Europe can afford to make feel-good decisions because they're large, powerful and surrounded by allies; but for Israel to do the same would be unwise at best, suicidal at worst.
@@VVayVVard That's why Israel needs to leave. They are forcing themselves in an area that is predominantly Islam. It's just so stupid.
@@VVayVVard Israel small? Tell that to the palestines. They live in a tiny prison.
Look how it backfired to allow the jewish people to settle there as their own?
They even helped fund Hamas of all things.
@@bretoncristobal The Arabic world consists of 22 massive countries, 1000x the size of Israel in total, with 50x the population, formed via endless conquest and suppression of minorities (which is why most minority languages became extinct wherever Arabic people settled; contrast to Europe, where there's 100~200 different languages within a smaller area). The 'Palestinians' are just a group of Arabic people; they don't have a unique language, culture or history. Yes, Palestine is a tiny colony within the Arabic world, which is why I'd suggest they give it to the indigenous people of the land, who lived there for 1700+ years before the Arabic people left the Arabic Peninsula.
Right. Not a word of the 10,000 dead. And yes, this did not start on October 7.
For all who are gushing over Gandhi’s fatuous ‘eye for an eye…’ quote. He also had this to say about the Jews after the Holocaust: “It is the greatest crime of our time. But the Jews should have offered themselves to the butcher’s knife. They should have thrown themselves into the sea from cliffs.....It would have aroused the world and the people of Germany.... As it is they succumbed anyway in their millions.” - Thanks Mahatma Musk but the world has enough martyrs willing to pluck out their own eyes if it means ushering our world into darkness.
The 10k dead is a number provided by the Hamas ministry of truth. I mean “health”. The same people that accused Israel of bombing a hospital when they didn’t, and killing 500 people. In a parking lot as it turned out. But keep believing the Hamas lies.
Exactly, elon is not who we think he is
I'd stop the interview for a sec "wait what are you writing down?"
Spot on - thank you for sharing
Why is everyone talking about this issue avoiding to address the real reasons of the conflict?
75 year illegal occupation?
@@branka570No thats just for the shallow and uninformed. The situation is complex. The early years saw the occupation by Egypt and Jordan and you have to study this to engage in proper discussion.
@@jazura2 Is your argument really that since it has been occupied before by Egypt and Jordan it’s okay for it to remain occupied by Israel? Really? And the way Israel has behaved from the beginning they had no intention for the two state solution. I’m not gonna get into the specifics of the terror Israel inflicted on the Palestinian people-anyone who gives 2 cents about it has seen it. Israel has long planned on taking over the land in Gaza. West Bank will be next, followed by Damascus if nobody intervenes. The fact that Netanyahu showed up in October in front of the UN with a map of the Middle East without showing Gaza tells you all there is to know. I used to believe in the two state solution and now I don’t. Thanks to Netanyahu’s own words, those from his cabinet and his generals the world has seen the true face of Israel.
Because they know that Zionism is an ideology that founded on apartheid and racist and xenophobic and hatred of people of Palestine
@@branka570it’s also a lie it’s never been occupied by eygpt or Palestine
That's what natanuahu Said on his dinner table along with his family. He said ' Israel Will push Palestine to such a point where' they Will have no choice And Loose their mind and gather what Palestinians can' and stop defending them selves from Israel and finally try to Go on the offense. And That's when Israel will go in to completely wipe them out . Anyone else seen/Heard this plan by him?
@@donfarlan214 people of greed vs people of GOD .
Do not forget the fact that Israel funded hamas in the early years.
@@rokasdobrovolskissame old story’s it’s alqaeda and isis , same bs
Thanks for your courage in speaking the truth as it is difficult in this time
Tme/Elonmuskdz9ve
Damn didn't expect such nuance from Elon but he's got the overarching issues in the current situation spot on...obv there's a lot more history n context there
Tme/Elonmuskdz9ve
I have to say this is one of the most logical and coherent explanation and interview I have seen about the Israel and Hamas conflict.
Piers Morgan vs Bassem Youssef Round 2! Please watch it. You will see some critical answers to understand the conflict.
@@T_Henryplease not. Bassem is very giftet speaker but he is lying about many many "facts" also he is taking true events but frames them in the opposite direction. He is a master of deseption
@@ArielBrener deny them and provide evidence then? no one can deny his words because it's THE truth, there is no opinion in stating facts, these are events that happened as it is described, there is history who support the so called "deception" as you say.
Fed up of Morgan's interview bashing...other guy frames answers....
I think most people thought like that. Not sure what is logical? It is basic history. Iraq created more terrorists. Would you have now supported bombing Afganistan and Iraq for 20 years? No. Times changed people do not like to see genocide and they know we breed terrorism.
This reminds me of a story I heard some time ago.
A father was taking his young daughter for a walk in the woods and she asked:
"Are there monsters in the woods?"
"What would you do if there were?", he responded.
"Feed them", she said.
If there are any monsters, it's the zionisits not Hamas, but you seem to be, unfortunately, misled enough to not realize that.
I think the father should explain to his daughter who the woods belong to...nice story though!!!!
Early beginning... The jews
Feeding the monster is exactly what the useful idiots of the West are doing.
He chooses his words as if he is walking in a land full of bombs, everyone fears Israel, no one dares to say stop the massacres in Palestine ... Otherwise he becomes a terrorist and antisémite! Free Palestine
“An eye for an eye makes everyone blind” - brilliant quote
Lol that one has been existing for hundreds of years now
the person who wrote that quote got killed by voilence
We the people don't want war! Life is precious for the innocent. Elon is correct with this heart breaking topic. Praying for a solution to end this madness amen 🙏
but a certain religion do not think life is precious. and hopefully Israel can help with the numbers. they getting out of hand everywhere.
“You can fool some of the people all of the time, and all of the people some of the time, but you can not fool all of the people all of the time.”
― Abraham Lincoln
Elon's speaking wisdom here. Although it's very hard to act wise when your family or friends have been killed brutally. So I'm not sure how many of us would act sane in that situation. Wishing peace for everyone. 🕊️
"If Isreal kills someone's child..u creat Hamas members "
But are these new Hamas members terrorists? Like Elon says.
No!! Not at all.
They need to fight the a
terror State of I$real
You just answered the question of why would Hamas do such a thing.
He was saying exactly what are you trying to say too. To stop the war, give what people need, not put more gas on the fire because if you do, more people will die, and because of that, those dead people's relatives seek revenge desperately, and again, because of that more people will die and the loops continue until the fire is big enough to destroy a whole country.
"An eye for an eye will make people blind" - Elon
@@TheMrBrouneactually that's not how it started, they first attacked cause they didn't like the immigration of jews, tried to get rid of em like the Germans that's why the US supported isreal...and that's why isreal has always been harsh to em i mean at some point, everyone in dat region attacked isreal at once
@@FOH45 you should read the history. The Palestineans were the ones who accepted them as refugees. There are pictures from the time when a ship of Polish jews came in with sign saying something like "we have been displaced, dont leave us hopeless". And the Palestineans accepted them. Some even gave them homes. But the jews started saying, well ACTUALLY... This is our land, we are going to make a jewish state here. That was the point when arab nations started attacking them. Even the famous star Bella Hadid's father's family shared their home with these jewish refugees. But his family was thrown out of their own homes by those they sheltered when Israel was founded. As for two nation theory. Israel technically agrees with it but on the ground level its far from the truth. That's why Palestineans have a problem with two nation theory.
Okay but what about the hostages?
Surprisingly good analysis
Fully agree with the wise man Elon. Only kindness and love can help us further. That would have showed great strenght and wisdom. I wish peace for everyone.
Don't think that he would be so kind and full of love if his kids were in that music festival.
@@Reptiloid5g Very difficult proposition. Who would know what one would do in that situation. But now, at the present, we should create peace. We should stop war. We can do that.
Great interview. “Conspicuous acts of kindness.” “Eye for eye makes everyone blind” Ghandi.”Every Gazan child killed creates another Hamas.” He truly is the world’s ambassador.
What's so great? Why is it so difficult to understand that Palestinians need to have their independent country? Jews are not the only humans there. Israel must share the land with Palestinians. If they think that they will take over whole of Palestine then they will have to face the wrath of the entire world.
I think Elon is missing the point here because the hatred is based in Islam, it is part of the religion to wipe out Jews. There are even verses from the Quran that the Muslims quote all the time.
This hatred stemming from religious beliefs of Islam is the root cause of the hatred. Unless you change the Quran You cannot remove the hatred that is why this problem continues over millennia.
@@phillipanon7139 Jihadists do not want a two state plan, that is their fault not Israel's. From the river to the sea remember.
@phillipanon7139
You seem to love terrorists a lot.
Why not bring them to your home and give them your country?
@@raclark2730 Jihadists? Palestinians are prisoners in their own land. Jihad means to struggle. They very much want a two state solution. The only criteria is that they want East Jerusalem as their capital. Israel has been stealing their land even during peace talks. Israel propped up Hamas so that Palestinians will be split up and weakened. From the river to the sea, is just a slogan, meaning Palestinians all over Israel should be free. The Israeli PM who was about to sign the deal was assassinated by a Bibi supporter.
Interesting... so behind every military convoy follows a humanitarian convoy with massive amounts of help.
Ghandi said "an eye for an eye made the whole world blind." ?
I’m back to liking Elon with this amazing answer.
Now take his neurolink.
I’m not quite there yet but keep this up and one day I may be. Great answer Elon. Smart.
Tbh as a very fair answer
No its not at all. He has no clue what hes talking about and is answering like its a video game that allows for israel to maintain the gaza strip while presenting the media with a perception of peaceful behaviour. He drew this conclusion of "hamas did x to in order to produce Y" but he totally made that up, he just "thinks" thats why hamas attacked and is using the result of the attack to explain the cause which is redundant, its like knowing the final answer and saying "nah they did this because they wanted that exact consequence to occur". So he bullshitted that axiom and his logic is all designed with israel in mind to create a false perception to the media of being peaceful so they can retain the gaza strip vs actually obtain a fair and just answer. He basically advocated for israel to just be more sneaky about how they will dominante the reigon.
you guys are blinded by his persona
@@amirhussain3028 utter nonsense. He did his best to contribute some positive ideas. Your negative mindset is part of the problem.
That was a really good and unique take on the situation, I actually entirely agree with what he said.
Didn't america did that for some communist countries. Air dropping chocolates and whatnot.
@@Unkown242 that's a darn interesting idea
I think Elon is missing the point here because the hatred is based in Islam, it is part of the religion to wipe out Jews. There are even verses from the Quran that the Muslims quote all the time.
This hatred stemming from religious beliefs of Islam is the root cause of the hatred. Unless you change the Quran You cannot remove the hatred that is why this problem continues over millennia.
Look at how many Palestinians have been killed or displaced since Israel's colonial and dare I say it, terrorist formation in 1948 and compare it with the number of Israeli civilians killed. There aren't just Muslims in Palestine. You only have to be human to condemn Israel's formation, to condemn Hamas and to condemn Israel's illegal expansion/ethnic cleansing.
It's an interesting take, but it's also a misinformed one.
For example, he said he "thinks" Hamas' only objective was to commit as many atrocities as possible and produce a huge response. This is just nonsense. Their goal was to get hostages and exchange them for Palestinian hostages with Israel. Atrocities were an unintended consequence and weren't as common as propagandistic media is claiming.
He is right about turning the other cheek. But they already done it for more than 10 years and 35k missles. They just can't let it slide now.
Do you think occupying other people land, demolishing their houses, kidnapping and imprisoning them on false pretext is 'turning other cheek'?
We as humans should know what people are capable of when they have nothing left to live for
People who have never lived under terror are way too naive
Absolutely agree. Philosopher Karl Popper talks about the paradox of tolerance. Defending tolerance requires not tolerating the intolerant. Anyone who has lived in a truly violent country knows the lesson well: you eliminate threats. We used to know this about bullies too. You hit back. Now we tolerate all forms of bullying.
Especially since Elon and his family in South Africa, another Apartheid State, benefitted from the system of oppression.
Israeli terror on people they colonised
Like the Iraqis who had to deal with US terror?
@@motoquipe Elon grew up in South Africa Apartheid in South Africa they shot terrorised blacks daily there while he lived the good life sheltered from it
Probably the best answer I’ve heard so far
For all who are gushing over Gandhi’s fatuous ‘eye for an eye…’ quote. He also had this to say about the Jews after the Holocaust: “It is the greatest crime of our time. But the Jews should have offered themselves to the butcher’s knife. They should have thrown themselves into the sea from cliffs.....It would have aroused the world and the people of Germany.... As it is they succumbed anyway in their millions.” - Thanks Mahatma Musk but the world has enough martyrs willing to pluck out their own eyes if it means ushering our world into darkness.
Love the quote "if you do eye for eye u both become blind" love you Elon❤
Original and wise
Totally agree is to increase acts of kindness!
He speaks well and carefully. Well thought out words leave his mouth. More people should really think before they speak.
As an engineer he is using 5Y analysis and using 8D to root cause .. he is very visionary
He didn't identify a root cause.
Root cause American war funds and Zinonsm illegal settlement
Engineers suck
considering 5y analysis and 8D as visionary is the definition of an oxymoron
@@ab452 : that’s two statements.. as engineer and he is visionary as a person that’s well proven. You are just joining two different sentences
That's what I was saying during the whole Middle East conflict when America was busy occupying and destabilizing. Americans wanted blood after 911, but we kept creating a huge refugee and collateral damage crisis that hasn't helped alleviate the current situation over there.
Laden was saying the 9 11 was doe to the US policy in region and supporting isreil killings and land theft
Do you realise Saddam wasn't a saint either? He had it coming either way.
@@i.c.wiener2750Don't be fool we all know why America invade Iraq it is not about Saddam Hussein or terrorist or for peace or Democracy. It is about black gold. It is about greed. They said there is WMD lol.but America always have WMD, nuke but no one said anything about them (there are peoples said about them but they got shut up) Why? Because America had the power and media.
@@i.c.wiener2750 America is the terrorist country. That country is not even their country. They are invaders. They kill the actual people who live in that country. Do they still think they are heroes?
Americans don't ever learn from history. The comment above me is a good example of being clueless
There should be more natural scientists/philosophers who govern the US than we have. I personally feel like physics and math make one think in a more creative way. I hope everything turns out well in the end. I hope peace happens somehow in Palestine/Israel. Peace.
He is really smart and has wide angle glasses.
ELON THANK YOU FOR BEING A HUMAN!!!! RESPECT
So obvious yet very few people are saying this. Fair play to him!
so many driven by hate and fear nowadays
What did he actually say though?
What's the way for the IDF, for the Israeli government to go by?
He didn't say s**t.
Just said what's the popular "progressive" thing to say.
When it's not you who are actually making the decision, it's easy to give these Disney advices.
It is obvious for everyone except the Palestinians and the Israelis. They are the real people in this, not the idea or something on a paper.
Crazy Ive had the same thoughts on the issue. Break the cycle. Love that brain of yours, Elon.
Very civil conversation
Basically he is saying not to have any casualties if you can avoid it but otherwise setup an unparalleled humanitarian mission
Everyone has an opinion on this war but nobody actually do something to stop it, humanity is hopeless
Because there is no easy solution
Then you got protestors condoning attacks and destroying public property.
well because it's not so simple 😢
Jesus Christ is our only hope.
Lets see you try stopping it first
Very well analysis done by Mr Musk! At least attempted to identify the root cause of the problem!
Tme/Elonmuskdz9ve
looks like that 6 hours of sleep a night is catching up with Musk
When addressing the Palestinian/Isreal conflict it needs to be considered in the context of the history of this conflict.
Now that’s just sheer common sense being stated with absolute clarity !
Kindness needed ❤
tell this to the aggressive Arabs
I agree with @captainchaoscow, Whos common sense are we talking about. There's so many differing versions in the world.
if i don't steal it, someone else will, sure peace can happen.@@captainchaoscow
last time I read a book, the brits kicked out Palestinians of their homes to create Israel... so the ones that started this conflict where not the arabas@@captainchaoscow
@@captainchaoscowtell that to KIKS
People just need to grow up and give peace a chance
telling even simple things at his level is courageous and need lot of careful with words.. well done Boss.. atleast you are dare to keep things as it is.
The reason why Elon can speak the truth without fear of repercussions is because he is one of the most wealthiest men on the planet. The others, politicians, pundits, influencers all have to think about their pay-masters before the truth. And we all know where the money comes from.
Money before Morals.
Money before morals for some.* Definitely not all
🤣 the US sending hundreds of billions to israel only to have them spending it on US politicians is glorious. Muricans owned by the jews.
There are others alot richer than him that are not listed! Im talking about trillionaires and wealthy arab families combined wealth!
Elon Musk is bigger than what you think, and it's not about money
@@itrig7679 he doesnt control the world banks or oil. He is not rich enough to be mentioned along the unknown elites.
That's an interesting take. He makes some sound strategic observations you'd have to concede to or at least give strong consideration to.
Create a mobile hospital... for 2 million people............ 😂
@@user-wx9bc7il5vYou could do Hospital ships. Those are mobile.
i bet you think that's a smart comment
@@user-wx9bc7il5v
Correcting errors or misinformations in Elon Musk’s "opinion":
🔻 "ISRAELI OCCUPATION GOAL" is to provoke a "certain reaction" from Arabs and Muslims.
"Israrli occupation" obviously expect to have "the military superiority",
"Israeli occupation" realy want to commit the worst "crimes and atrocities" that they could, in order to provoke the "less possible response" from arabs and muslims, and than laverage that response to rally fascists worldwide for the cause of jewish-zionism and israel,
which they "have not" completely succeeded in doing, "so far, this time".
🔻 The most conspicuous acts of kindness, that israeli "criminal psychopath occupation", could engage in (mobile hospital, food, water, medical necessities) , will be automatically exposed as being a "trick".
🔻 israeli occupation is "ultimately" the broader force of hatred in the region.
🔻 Israel is a "terrorist occupation" that was "created", in Palestine,
out of a combination of several factors:
{ jewish diaspora + antisemetisme in europe (expulsion, oppression, massacres, holocaust) + zionisme }
via imposing a set of inacceptable measures:
{ balfour/Rothschild declaration 1917 + illegal jewish immigration to Palestine + imposing law of the jungle on humanity by psychopath criminal forces }
🔻 Elon Musk’s opinion about Hamas's "goals" and "means", does not express in any way the truth of Hamas:
Hamas (in arabic, abbreviation for, Islamic Resistance Movement),
Arabic and Islamic, because Palestine is part of arabic and islamic nations.
Resistance, because palestinians are oppressed, and Palestine was brutally occupied, by multinational invaders.
Hamas is an independent Palestinian political and military organization, established in 1987, Under the oppression of the Israeli occupation,
It is one of the national liberation movements.
It limits its struggle and work to Palestine, and does not interfere in the affairs of others,
it limits its resistance to the Israeli occupation only, and does not have any battle with any party in the world.
it only resists those who fight the Palestinian people and occupy their land.
The teachings of the Islamic religion forbid the Intentional murder of innocent people, women, children, the elderly, clergy, and employees.
It forbid to intentionally cause damage to homes, temples, shops, trees, or animals.
With the legitimacy of application of the principle of retribution (an eye for an eye).
For Hamas, resistance is a mean not an aim.
It works to confront the Zionist project supported by modern colonial powers,
to provid the appropriate conditions to achieve the liberation of the Palestinian people and their land from the Israeli occupation, the liberation of Jerusalem and the Islamic holy sites, the return of refugees and displaced persons,
to achieve the Palestinian national project and establishing an independent Palestinian state with true sovereignty.
And work to serve the Palestinian people everywhere by all means and in all fields, so that they can withstand and be steadfast, and bear the consequences of the confrontation with the Israeli occupation.
This is not interesting in the slightest. This is the most obvious thing anybody can possibly state. Half the world is brain dead and that’s sad to see everyone is blind and can’t see that what Israel is doing is only worsening the situation long term
O bu kadar mevki sahibi mi insancıl insan üç tane daha dünyada olsa haksızlıklar da yer kalmaz çok teşekkür ediyorum seni büyüten annenin ellerinden öperim
sounds like he learned a few tricks after the ol Emerald mine days
elon musk is a great person, one of the few who deserves to be a billionaire .
Why? Because of this clip from a podcast he was on
Every billionaire deserves their money
😂
Not if they are war mongers !
Nobody deserves to be that rich
"The meek shall inherit the earth."
A reasonably accurate translation of the word "meek" is something like "One who has a sword and knows how to use it, but keeps it sheathed."
You may have the power to destroy your enemy in totality, but your ability to exercise restraint in this displays a much deeper power: compassion.
excellent comments...!
Thank you.
God I love seeing intellectuals trying to make sense out of senselessness
yes however intellectualism and philosophies are often not as realistic in this world.
all bc of the dumbies @@dennis3351
It is not hard to make sense out of it.
Musk isn't an intellectual lol
@@Norcha8 lol. He owns three huge corporations. And has overcome NASA lol. Lol. Joke is on you Curly. Lol
Thank you lex for this interview.
100%. Manage to get the outcome that you want.
This is such a surprisingly beautiful answer...and also very Christian sounding too
Well said. But while it’s pretty Simple…it’s definitely not easy.
Bro was criticizing Isreal in the smartest & most careful way.
00:04 Elon Musk emphasizes the need for peace in the Israel-Hamas war.
00:35 Hamas provoked Israel to elicit a strong response
01:19 Israel should engage in conspicuous acts of kindness to thwart the goal of Hamas.
01:56 Israel needs to take action against Hamas
02:32 Recommend providing food, water, and medical necessities to hospitals with transparency to avoid trickery claims.
03:12 Countering hatred in the region
03:44 The success of the Israel-Hamas war lies in the ratio of Hamas members killed to new members created.
04:18 Examining the creation of terrorists over time as a factor in achieving long-term peace.