ST#65: Problematic Hadiths Case Study - Part 1 | Sh. Anwar Arafat
Вставка
- Опубліковано 13 жов 2024
- Following up from our "How to read the sunnah toolkit" series, Shaykh Anwar Arafat takes us trough an example hadith for a case study and applies the tools we have learned from the previous series.
Help us educate and mentor others to share the faith academically.
Donate now: sapienceinstit...
Free online courses: learn.sapience...
Free books: sapienceinstit...
Have doubts? Book a mentor: sapienceinstit...
Listen (Podcast): sapienceinstit...
Follow:
- Facebook: / sapienceinstitute.org
- Twitter: / sapienceorg
- Instagram: / sapienceinstitute
Articles, speaker requests & more: sapienceinstit...
Worst idea to not give the answer in the same episode. What if people don't follow up or miss the next episode?? Really bad idea...
Do it in one shot
Very bad idea to give shubuhate to people and not give explaination immediately, we are not on Netflix brothers don’t to suspense like this
any one rational enough would wait for the next ep.. this is uncalled for
@@Haze_in-bw7ff No he is right, he should explain immediately, not everyone is as patient and wise especially the Islamophobics who will use this clip as a means to attack the dean
@@xxCrimsonSpiritxx that's their problem
@@Haze_in-bw7ff That's their problem only until is yours as well
You're giving the Islamophobias the wood that they want to burn, and when there will be more people shouting "Islam hates women" you will sit there saying what? "That's your problem" ?!
How are you going to represent your religion if you refuse to accommodate for their ignorance?
That's like you refusing to give someone a job because they don't have a skill when you could train them to obtain
This is very unwise
@@xxCrimsonSpiritxx islamaphobes would pick anything and use it against us.. Our job is to be intellectually prepared not afraid that if somehting isn't explained well they'd use and OH GOSH WHAT A BLOW THAT WOULD BE TO THE RELIGION..
we don't have to carter to their ignorance if its based upon malicious intent..
Anyone with common sense wouldn't wanna conclude without watching the series completely.. And that's all there is to recommend
Watch the second episode where Sh. Anwar Arafat applies the tools we have learned from the previous series: ua-cam.com/video/eHsv5BLwGmI/v-deo.html
جزاک الله خيرا
Where’s the rest of the video 🤦🏻♂️
What do u mean? The video is 7 mins
In the Playlist on channel..
"How to read the sunnah"
ua-cam.com/play/PLE4jCjpXgtqD0HMaSbu1vvP3K6Yn3wdrA.html
Why only the first bit??
PART 1 SUMMARY:
Introduction - this Video has been made to illustrate how to use a toolkit for hadith we find confusing
1:26 This hadith is found in Bukhari, Muslim and others
1:40: In the BAD ENGLISH TRANSLATION, the hadith has been translated as narrated by Abu Saeed Al Khudri
2:20 The Prophet of Allah went to Musallah for Eid Prayer. He passed by the women, and he said "oh women, give in charity, for I have seen that you make up the majority of the hellfire", so they asked why, and he (pubh) said "because u curse frequently and are ungrateful to your husbands, and thirdly because I have not seen anyone more deficient in intelligence an religion that you and a cautious sensible man could be mislead by you". they asked what the deficiency was in their intelligence and religion and he said "is it not true that the testimony of 2 women is equivalent to 1 man?", they said "yes", and they relied in the affirmative, he then said that is from the deficiency in their intelligence, he then asked about women nor praying during menses, and said that is the deficiency in the religion
5:30 This hadith as translated above may confuse women or men reading it.
In the following videos, the toolkit will now be applied
Can anyone explain the contextual meaning of the word ‘problematic’ as used in the title of this video?
The title of this series is problematic :-) Sahih hadith cannot be ‘problematic’, only our knowledge of it… The title could be seen as misleading and not suited to students of knowledge… Perhaps saying “Seemingly problematic” would be better wording?
thats pointless criticism..
anyone reading Bukhari and Muslim would likely translate it into English.. so why should the title be suitable for the scant who know Arabic and can decipher the actual meaning?..bruh
stop idolizing bukhari
Applying the same logic as used by you
It's your interpretation of the hadith. The most acceptable form of interpretation is the one from the earlier gen imams or muhaditheen like imam nawawi . Can anyone plz mention how they have interpreted it.
Hayakum Allah. Bism Allah blessed series ameen
Great initiative by sapience institute.
Keep the good work up.
I think you shouldn't use such phrase like "problematic hadiths". Because it sounds absurd. 🤔
All scholars use this word, you would know if you hav patience.
Even the scholars used “problematic” to describe Hadiths. Relax.
Subhannallah your miskeen. Scholars from the past the term "problematic" yhh you definitely don't know Arabic or have even studies this
Okay let’s apply the toolkit… End of video 🤷♂️
What do u mean? The video is 7 mins
ua-cam.com/play/PLE4jCjpXgtqApnwOKLyS4MQ0peIpA0f8Q.html
1OO% Pure contradiction in the Bible
For God So loved the Criminals that he gave his only son, that whoever believes in him should not perish but have eternal life ( John 3 : 1 6 )
For he who Does wrong will receive the consequences of the wrong which he has done
(Colossians 3 : 25)
Can a book from God have any contradictions in it 🤦♀❓
Every thing that is mentioned in the Quran & Hadiths are in literary terms...like Riba, Jina, Idol worship, jihad etc etc.
Riba is allowed by Allah SWT..except interest rate higher than 500% per day.
Jina is allowed by Allah SWT ...except Jina with Prophet's Wife & daughter.
Idol worship is allowed by Allah SWT .... except worship of Iblis.
Jihad is not made mandatory by Allah SWT.... except in self defence.
Where is explanation
ua-cam.com/play/PLE4jCjpXgtqApnwOKLyS4MQ0peIpA0f8Q.html
ua-cam.com/play/PLE4jCjpXgtqD0HMaSbu1vvP3K6Yn3wdrA.html
Where is the explanation?
What's up with the brother's constant chuckling? Is the misunderstanding of the Hadith really that funny compared to the actual translation?
barakaAllahu feekum
Game of Thrones Sapience Version… *wait* till next episode to find out the rationalization of a seemingly repugnant report about women. Are you mates even serious or is this a soap opera 🤔
❤️❤️❤️🌹
i like the 7min videos concept
It's a shame how pathetic this institute has become, now erasing the rightful meaning of the hadith (there are many commentaries written on bukhari, none mention it as wrong or problematic), but here we see these slaves bowing down their religion in front of political correctness and using liberal left terms like probelmatic, seriously? Calling a saheeh hadith problematic?
Brother if you listen closely, he didn’t say that the hadith was problematic or wrong. What he said was that this particular ‘translation’ is wrong because of which people misunderstand the hadith.
Problematic hadiths? Perhaps your religion is false. That's the simplest and most plausible explanation.
Thats a very big jump 😂
@@WaqasAli-ct7ly when there are many such hadiths it's a much more likely conclusion than thousands of ad hoc rationalisations
It is termed as such to attract audience's attention. Hadiths aren't problematic 🤦♀️
The only thing problematic is your comprehension skills.
There are so many other variables at play here. Rejecting Islam wouldn’t be the most rational conclusion.
The Bible/Torah/Koran was not handed to mankind by a god,...
nor was it dictated to human stenographers by any gods;
all written by men!
The Olden Testes Bible/Torah were just fables from the stone ages by oral tradition...
the Bible, a books of fables, was VOTED on by a group of men after the 4th century;
the Koran was just the copied and demented dogma of a selfish and petty despot....
There are no gods...
[btw - any objections to these historical facts must be accompanied with evidence
to prove the existence of any gods/allahahas claimed]
You should first actually prove that about the Quran bc quite frankly its wrong
And where is your evidence chile
@@mehmet20003 Quite frankly ... you all canNOT prove any gods exist ... Hahaha
@@user-jw9jt5jg5u Haha... and where is your evidence to prove a god ... do not use man-written rubbish books...
@@briendoyle4680 quite frankly you cant prove God doesnt exist.... hahahah