Is it anything to do with sky though. I know it's sponsored by skybet but Sky sold that to paddy power years back. Think it's a independent neville thing tbh
Maybe without fan channel representatives though, love all of their channels but would love to get fans who aren’t making coin out of it. Not saying those that do aren’t real fans but just saying it would be awesome to reach out to other people and not the same ones every time. Not me though because I’m stuck in the States and can’t wait to get back to my home.
@@user-by7cc2wn2v and it's hard to find some1 who's rational and well educated about their own club and the rest of the league and football generally or let me say how would they know they've found the one
@@jeffd3473 you swear wes hoolahan was fucking zidane. Im irish and with or without wes hoolahan we wouldnt have done any better than we did. Ive heard enough of wes fucking hoolahan
Rafa (on paper) is the perfect fit for Everton right now as well. His track record is minimal spend, club looking to push on toward the top places but are underdogs, wheeling and dealing- that's where he has always shown his best management (if not where he would prefer to be). I remember that 2004 Liverpool team he took over, we were tragic, so many of the players from the Houllier era were on terminal decline, and he just had 3-4 years where he knocked it out the park and continually improved us. That was honestly a period that without Rafa we could have ended up sliding into midtable under an inferior manager. Similar at Valencia, although he actually managed to win the league because Real/Barca were in a shitstorm at the time. The only question is how the fans back him obviously.
@@bootroom9802 lol it’s a debate you’re allowed to jump in literally every person there was allowed to speak if it was about their club. Also Evertonians know very well how much we’ve spent on crap, however people can’t act like FFP is fair for all clubs evenly across the board. It’s not and hampers teams from trying to bridge the gap between the “big 6”
Thank you for this, honestly. Throughout this whole Americanisation and financial disaster going on in football, this engagement between fans and three legends is a serious breath of fresh air. Honestly, the 2 hours flew by, I was that engaged. Massive thanks!
@@FaustoTheBoozehound Are you playing stupid or are you actually stupid?..My team Villa even have cash these days and that's before the 100m. And it was a 100m because anything less we wouldn't have accepted. Iq tests should be implemented before being able to comment kid.
Congrats to Josh Denzel. I think he hosted this superbly well. Didn't interject, continued the conversations and brought in fans well. Can't wait to see more from him.
@@ChargedWords I don’t think they are full of shit, I think they are deluded by the fact that because they played professionally at the highest levels, that this translates to their opinions post career, in a different era with a different generation, being as notable as their playing careers were. At the end of the day once they’ve hung up their boots, they’re just fans like the rest of us.
@@ChargedWords Oh god, Jenas, what a mug. Generally, being a part of something will give people better insight, obviously, but as the commenter below you said, that isnt always the case. Its the same way just because you are a good footballer, in no way will it make u a great manager. I dont have to be a chef to tell you if the steak is good or not. Pele for example almost all his footy opinions were absolute fucking bollocks.
This is brilliant!! A throwback to the early days of Sky when they had The Footballer's Football Show going around the grounds having debates with the fans. More of this please!
Him and a bunch of other lads have a cool UA-cam account I can't remember the name but they all seem like good guys. The Liverpool fan after him is one of em
I'm a Liverpool fan but I actually have a lot of time and respect for both Baz and Ped from Toffee TV, and you're right, they always argue their points beautifully
Everyone: *talks about a topic for more than like three seconds in total-* Josh Denzel: *´-UHHHMM, hahah listen we could talk about this stuff all day long´* 😭😭
I have nothing against the guy, but he must have one hell of an agent. Was a generic, unremarkable Love Island contestant, now he’s got the dream job of talking football, interviewing and hanging out with footballers and presumably getting paid lots to do so. Fair play to his agent 👏🏻
Keane only says that because he hates him. Schmeichel is deffo the best all time in the Prem. And he was the most important player for Denmark at the Euros 1992 when they won.
@@JacobTaaning I reckon Kasper is better, a lot of football is luck and circumstance, Peter found himself in a United team that mostly dominated with little competition compared to now, put Kasper in that team and he'd do just as well if not better, certainly not as many mistakes as Peter
30:16 Roy making an EXCELLENT point about survival reminds me of how right Arsène was to be happy about keeping Arsenal in Europe. Only now do the fans realise
The average fan doesn’t realize the amount of money their club misses out on when they don’t qualify for a European cup. Obviously you’d rather be fighting for a CL spot, but getting into the EL is a huge boost to maintain relevance and avoid digging a deeper hole.
Exactly. That’s the biggest mistake Arsenal fans have made. Not wanting Arsene because he finished 4th “too much”. I mean… are you really complaining ending top 4? Look at Arsenal now… there my point
Well done to Pippa for controlling herself and not clipping Ty round the back of the head 😂🤣😂 His passion overshadows his logic and it’s a brilliant watch for us non Arsenal fans
Anyone who loves football could listen to these 3 guys all day, what a fantastic show and the fan interaction made it even better. Would love to see this throughout the season.
I would classify myself as a casual football fan and this was so well done that I was riveted for the entire two hours (which definitely did not feel like two hours)! I would absolutely watch if Sky ever did this again!
We need this every month or every two months this season, where fans can discuss likely issues in their team, win/draw/loss/before/after the game, and possible solutions expected to see in the next game.
Not every week plz.... every week talk with fan can be sound more naive and bit illogical...becz if u see last season tot and Everton were top of the league and will be praised bt u see end of season they were down...i feel like 3 time is good.. before start of the season , during Christmas, after season...just enough..
Tai made some half decent points in the first video, Cara clearly knew he could clown him and get a laugh but when you actually listen to it he isn't being a usual level of Tai delusion
This is a brilliant idea. I wish it was done more often. fascinating to see ex pros, now pundits discuss these issues with regular fans. A great watch.
this content is class. absolute top class. please do more because i feel like this is a good way for fans to have their concerns heard whether they are there in person or watching at home.
A few years ago I could never imagine us fans having such a direct relationship with these professionals. It just felt like they lived in a separate bubble. Thank you so much Garry for this initiative. Chelsea fan 💙
Best thing sky have done in a long time. This should be a regular series throughout the season. Great interaction between the panel and the fan base 👍🇮🇪
Great interaction with Baz! What a legend. Edit: Roy really wanted to say Denis Irwin, he contained himself at last but he said his name two times when he reasoned his way to Scholes lol.
I suspect it was only because Luke Shaw is playing really well and it was about what the team need rather then the player he respects the most. In the Keane v Viera show years ago you could see how highly he rated Irwin (and rightly so). For me it's got to be Ronaldo, Cantona or Keane himself.
I’m so glad you are doing this Gary! Bringing the players we grew up watching and hearing their point of view and being able to ask them questions from a fan point of view. Unscripted, no frills.
You know Roy sees Gary like a little brother, because he laughs the hardest when they are roasting him. But when Vieira was playing the tough guy in the tunnel with him, Roy was immediately there.
This is why we all love football. Having great talks, laughs & interesting conversations about our clubs & what happens behind the scenes at our club. We all want another one of these!!
You should do this again. As long as you got Keano in it. Gary is knowledgeable but can be boring also, as he doesnt like to challenge the status quo much, while Keano is the spice to any talk.
Wouldn’t change a thing it was balance and fantastic…so glad we didn’t have a host pretending he knew more than the panel, he came in at the right time cut off the annoying ones at the right time but he let the show flow!
@@blacksling9 Host did what any good host should do. He simply enabled the ppl to talk, and as you say allowed a good flow . And with the exception of a couple "fans" ,that we could do without, this also shows that proper fans have a solid football foundation and understand the game way more than ppl have given us credit all this time. Yeah I agree, no need to change one thing. Keep it as it is' its brilliant.
Absolutely loved this. This needs to be a monthly thing. Great interaction with the fans from the ex pro’s, great banter as well and also insightful talk from everyone. The pro’s were excellent at speaking with the fans and not belittling their comments and thought. Only negative was that Arsenal fan…. What a helmet.
Heard him say this a few times in the past. I’m a Leeds fan but for me Schmeical is one of the best keepers I’ve ever seen. Roy seems to have a bee in his bonnet about keepers in general, never really rates them and seems to have maybe a personal issue with Schmeical
This is brilliant! Engaging with fans is the best way to discuss what's going on with clubs. Make this a weekly show & change the fan representatives every episode so a lot of fanzines get their chance to speak for their clubs.
Keane's a very decent man, as if often the case with more cold, serious people. It's the charmers who want to be your best friend 24/7 that you have to look out for
Rafas a legend in Newcastle we love him and we're gutted he left. Everton fans should be happy if there not we will swap rafa for Steve Bruce all day long
No one: Josh: "we could sit here all day and talk about..." Just kidding, very good presenting from Josh, and great to see fans debating with the pundits. For so long pundits and fans have been so far removed, so it's interesting to see excellent fan pundits like Rory express their opinions to the pundits, even if they disagree.
Im from a rugby league town, so rugby is my sport to watch. But I have to say, these Overlap programmes are very very good and a very interesting insight into football. Hats off to Gary and the other pundits involved, keep up the great work and well done.
Brilliant engagement with the fans. Looking forward to further events. As a Forest fan, I love how Keane reveals his affection for the club. Carragher was on fire.
Loved this, feel like there needs to be more to talk about the clubs they missed. Would love to hear from the fans of the newly promoted clubs, and about the pundits' thoughts on what Leicester could aim for in the next few seasons.
I dont follow a team but I love the game. I absolutely loved the whole concept of this show. Feet on the ground chatting with the people that are borrowing money to get to matches, buying the jerseys and making sure they get home in time for the game etc. Brilliant
This is amazing. Very rare you get three absolute legends talking so candidly about things that actually concern fans. I swear half of twitter could do with listening to this. That Everton fan did really well holding his ground, by the way. Cheeky poke at Keano too 😂
As an LFC supporter who studied in the North East and now lives in London I found the first half of this show really engaging and certainly stirred some opinions with me. But I really appreciate the editing that allowed for the sudden swing to Racism in football. It felt jarring, but that's what's needed. You could see that some people were uncomfortable that it had gone from good natured banter about footie to serious social topics, but unless we confront the issues it won't change.
Please make this a series. Perfect mix of banter/insight. Keep the presenter/moderator guy too. He always knew when to keep the guys going on deep analysis or move things on.
@@lomzaunfiltered9151 not now mate, players wouldn't react well to his man management style these days, it's sadly a snowflake generation compared to the team he had when he was at Sunderland previously
@@PazzV27 I’m a Irish Liverpool fan I went to old Trafford to see Sunderland play United they were class under him took a last minute Vidic goal to beat the blackcats that day. Honestly think he’d still make a good manager now he’s older and a little calmer than before.
@@lomzaunfiltered9151 think he’s matured he was a great coach and he had awful players to work with in the prem like Chopra Nosworthy McShane etc. But he’s definitely changed and calmed down as he’s gotten older so I think he would be a great coach but why would you go back into coaching when you’re getting paid that much to sit on the telly
Shall we do another Overlap Live Fan Debate? 👀
Yeah
Yes
hell yeah
Yeah but get Mark Goldbridge next time and Robbie
Yes, this as a series during the season would be very interesting
This should be a series all the way through the season, would love to see more fan interactions back at sky, like they used to with fan cams and such
They don’t care about fans enough for that
They should do cos it gives fans a chance to show on how they feel about their club more publicly
As if sky would do what the public wanted.
Yes it’s great
Mabye once a month when they present the player of the month and the manager
Roy’s passion & him constantly looking to see if the fans were enjoying the show was absolute class 👏🏾👏🏾
I watch his reactions, they are priceless
He's quality and I used to hate him as an arsenal fan
Roy Keane is a nice person and he’s really good with the supporters as well
Definitely a lot more layers to Roy than people realise.
He plays up to it a bit I think in order to be entertaining but he’s a decent guy
You should read The Athletic's piece they put out for his 50th birthday a few days back!
Why what did u expect ?
Roy Kent is better tv!
This fan debate with this panel has been arguably one of the best things that sky has produced in recent years! Loved it!
Is it anything to do with sky though. I know it's sponsored by skybet but Sky sold that to paddy power years back. Think it's a independent neville thing tbh
Maybe without fan channel representatives though, love all of their channels but would love to get fans who aren’t making coin out of it. Not saying those that do aren’t real fans but just saying it would be awesome to reach out to other people and not the same ones every time. Not me though because I’m stuck in the States and can’t wait to get back to my home.
Minus the City fan who was an absolute prick
@@TTWGD3 most regular fans are too passionate and clueless to have an objective and constructive discussion about football..
@@user-by7cc2wn2v and it's hard to find some1 who's rational and well educated about their own club and the rest of the league and football generally or let me say how would they know they've found the one
"Courage isn't about nailing someone in a football match. Courage is about wanting the ball when you don't want it." Keano
Yet he was part of a regime for ireland who wouldnt play wes hoolahan in big games, the only player that got on the ball and made things happen.
@@jeffd3473 😂
brilliant still
that is a great statement
@@jeffd3473 you swear wes hoolahan was fucking zidane. Im irish and with or without wes hoolahan we wouldnt have done any better than we did. Ive heard enough of wes fucking hoolahan
That Everton fan was class, very reasonable and took the pushback well whilst not melting away from his point.
Rafa (on paper) is the perfect fit for Everton right now as well. His track record is minimal spend, club looking to push on toward the top places but are underdogs, wheeling and dealing- that's where he has always shown his best management (if not where he would prefer to be).
I remember that 2004 Liverpool team he took over, we were tragic, so many of the players from the Houllier era were on terminal decline, and he just had 3-4 years where he knocked it out the park and continually improved us. That was honestly a period that without Rafa we could have ended up sliding into midtable under an inferior manager. Similar at Valencia, although he actually managed to win the league because Real/Barca were in a shitstorm at the time.
The only question is how the fans back him obviously.
class as in interrupting his crap about everton not allowed to spend money when they have done more than other clubs?
By interrupting and being rude
Baz is class
@@bootroom9802 lol it’s a debate you’re allowed to jump in literally every person there was allowed to speak if it was about their club. Also Evertonians know very well how much we’ve spent on crap, however people can’t act like FFP is fair for all clubs evenly across the board. It’s not and hampers teams from trying to bridge the gap between the “big 6”
Straight up brilliant couple of programmes. Doesn’t feel like I’ve just watched 2 hours worth, it flew by.
I watch it at 2x speed fits into schedule. Ears adjust within a minute.
@@ghostofguy Nev must be pretty squeaky at double speed!
Thank you for this, honestly. Throughout this whole Americanisation and financial disaster going on in football, this engagement between fans and three legends is a serious breath of fresh air. Honestly, the 2 hours flew by, I was that engaged. Massive thanks!
Americanisation LOL youre tripping my guy
@@Jhoto How? The capitalist oligarchs and owners are ruining the sport with their desire for pure financial gain.
@@ahx.21 Na it's fairer now ...United can't just bully everyone anymore. Hence why they've not won the league in a decade
@@bigdaddy3700 right, because it's Man City and Chelsea with their piles of ill-gotten money that bully everyone
@@FaustoTheBoozehound Are you playing stupid or are you actually stupid?..My team Villa even have cash these days and that's before the 100m. And it was a 100m because anything less we wouldn't have accepted. Iq tests should be implemented before being able to comment kid.
Congrats to Josh Denzel. I think he hosted this superbly well. Didn't interject, continued the conversations and brought in fans well. Can't wait to see more from him.
Also told Ty to wind it in
He has obviously had good media training proven his worth with other journalists
wE cAn gO oN aLl dAy aBoUt tHiS
Preferred him on Lions Den to be honest. This felt too formal for him, he’s better in a one on one chat.
@@ninadpatil7995 I was looking for this comment
Roy’s showed more passion interacting with these fans than he ever had speaking to other pundits.
Love it.
Because he knows what we know, most pundits are full of shit. One thing Roy will respond to is passion for your club.
@@ChargedWords I don’t think they are full of shit, I think they are deluded by the fact that because they played professionally at the highest levels, that this translates to their opinions post career, in a different era with a different generation, being as notable as their playing careers were.
At the end of the day once they’ve hung up their boots, they’re just fans like the rest of us.
@@ChargedWords Trevor Sinclair is the best example of that. What a fuckin mug he is.
@@Irfan87 agree mate, can't stand Jermaine Jenas either. Talks absolute nonsense.
@@ChargedWords Oh god, Jenas, what a mug. Generally, being a part of something will give people better insight, obviously, but as the commenter below you said, that isnt always the case. Its the same way just because you are a good footballer, in no way will it make u a great manager. I dont have to be a chef to tell you if the steak is good or not. Pele for example almost all his footy opinions were absolute fucking bollocks.
"Courage is not about nailing somebody in the football match. It's about wanting the ball when you don't want to have it."
Keane's a legend.
Yeah sage words there now you put them inside quotation marks 😆🙄
@@DeeTeaDee 🤣
Josh is a great presenter. Just let’s the guests get on with expressing their views, very relaxed and just lets the show flow
He’s a good link between the fans and the pros.
Man survived love island I bet his chat game is impeccable
We could talk about him all day
Yeah he did a good job. He knows when to come in and he does it politely
That's his job.
This is brilliant!! A throwback to the early days of Sky when they had The Footballer's Football Show going around the grounds having debates with the fans. More of this please!
Exactly. Fans are now getting to say what they feel in private to legends of the game
Perfect 👍
"I'd bring back Ian rush"
Roy "what a player, bloody hell" 👏🏻
Respect 🙏
I was surprised as well :D
I thought I heard that right. Respect.
Everton fan conducted himself rather well and was eloquent in what he wanted to say. Well done 👏🏽
Him and a bunch of other lads have a cool UA-cam account I can't remember the name but they all seem like good guys. The Liverpool fan after him is one of em
Toffeetv.
I'm a Liverpool fan but I actually have a lot of time and respect for both Baz and Ped from Toffee TV, and you're right, they always argue their points beautifully
I loved how he started off by just joking about Everton's title charge 😂. Not an Everton fan but big up to them boys.
@@ReanimatorsMutilations was Ball street kinda died out a few years ago 2 of the hosts are trying to revive it
The odd banter was great. This must be a series. Reasonable arguments and constant back-and-forth was great to watch.
Except Ty, he can do one
Literally don’t bring anyone from AFTV unless it’s Robbie. even him is a maybe
No one:
Josh Denzel: “We could talk about this all day but…”
Hahaha came to say that
So true lol
Everyone: *talks about a topic for more than like three seconds in total-*
Josh Denzel: *´-UHHHMM, hahah listen we could talk about this stuff all day long´*
😭😭
I have nothing against the guy, but he must have one hell of an agent. Was a generic, unremarkable Love Island contestant, now he’s got the dream job of talking football, interviewing and hanging out with footballers and presumably getting paid lots to do so. Fair play to his agent 👏🏻
The Everton fan’s subtle Salford dig to Gary was top drawer
As was Keane’s reaction to it 😂
What was the time stamp for that?
@@williammoulton9958 24:39
It was subtle?
Hardly subtle
"No, Schmeichel was overrated" bloody love Keano
He was though. Van Der Sar was far far better
Keane only says that because he hates him. Schmeichel is deffo the best all time in the Prem. And he was the most important player for Denmark at the Euros 1992 when they won.
@@WakaWaka2468 that's your opinion fam for me schimichel is greatest keeper in pl ever but I like van der sar to
@@JacobTaaning I reckon Kasper is better, a lot of football is luck and circumstance, Peter found himself in a United team that mostly dominated with little competition compared to now, put Kasper in that team and he'd do just as well if not better, certainly not as many mistakes as Peter
I think roy says that because he is still pissed about peter's performance in the 99 ucl final
30:16 Roy making an EXCELLENT point about survival reminds me of how right Arsène was to be happy about keeping Arsenal in Europe. Only now do the fans realise
The average fan doesn’t realize the amount of money their club misses out on when they don’t qualify for a European cup. Obviously you’d rather be fighting for a CL spot, but getting into the EL is a huge boost to maintain relevance and avoid digging a deeper hole.
Exactly
Exactly. That’s the biggest mistake Arsenal fans have made. Not wanting Arsene because he finished 4th “too much”. I mean… are you really complaining ending top 4? Look at Arsenal now… there my point
@@eldiego68 As DT would say: It's not my money i don't care! Also: why can't we afford players...
The Everton fan was funny and logical. Good lad.
Yeah he was good. Wonder does he have a UA-cam channel.
@@fractaled3129 Toffee TV
@@delacote60 Cheers.
@@fractaled3129 even as a LFC fan I have to give credit to Toffee. They will not disappoint. Really good lads and knowledgeable!!
Nah he was annoying
This has to be a constant series throughout the season! Top notch content
Roy you excited to meet the fans?
"No but I'll engage with them"
Fs we're only 30secs in, Roy haha
Can’t wait to see what goodness Ty has for us
I'm here for the cringe
No more arsenal talk in this part
@@brianmcsherry1338 thank fuck
@@brianmcsherry1338 Thank goodness for that haha!
@@brianmcsherry1338 you legend i was hoping i wouldnt see Ty again. i had to turn the last one off.
Again, amazing time representing Newcastle at the Fan Debate. True honour 🙏🏼
Your team needs some investment into it.
Either way am there Sunday and I’ll sing my lungs out in the gallowgate
I thought you spoke really well about your club as did the others about theirs..
Big up!
Followed you since Take me out for the chebs
Well done to Pippa for controlling herself and not clipping Ty round the back of the head 😂🤣😂
His passion overshadows his logic and it’s a brilliant watch for us non Arsenal fans
👍🏻
Josh "we could sit here and talk about this all day" Denzel
hahahahh facts! I picked up on it too
Geezer is so annoying, God knows how he's landed on his feet like this considering love island but fair play
Was just about to comment it lol
Not a bad host, just odd because he done nothing with football previously
😂😂😂
Literally finished watching the first part, this was perfect timing😂😂😂
Mate that's hilarious
Same
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
What about the '"just" though?
Fantastic this show, format was perfect. I would love this weekly, but at the very least monthly. Brilliant, brillant stuff! Well done Sky.
These fan debates are brilliant. Great to hear the insights from the fans. Hope Gary keeps doing them.
Great input from the Everton fan. Brilliant job from him! Very knowledgeable.
Anyone who loves football could listen to these 3 guys all day, what a fantastic show and the fan interaction made it even better. Would love to see this throughout the season.
I would classify myself as a casual football fan and this was so well done that I was riveted for the entire two hours (which definitely did not feel like two hours)! I would absolutely watch if Sky ever did this again!
We need this every month or every two months this season, where fans can discuss likely issues in their team, win/draw/loss/before/after the game, and possible solutions expected to see in the next game.
It's gonna get boring
Not every week plz.... every week talk with fan can be sound more naive and bit illogical...becz if u see last season tot and Everton were top of the league and will be praised bt u see end of season they were down...i feel like 3 time is good.. before start of the season , during Christmas, after season...just enough..
You do another one at the midpoint of the season. Better than doing it too often
That would be great
This is honestly absolutely brilliant. I can’t remember watching something just debating/talking about football that had my complete attention.
19:23 your wish for cristiano has come true gary
lmao was just going to comment this!
Same
35-40 goals tho 🤣
Hahaha record breaking loss vs Liverpool Haha funny people nowadays
This needs to be weekly. Even if it’s just the Everton fan talking. Keane’s reaction after the Salford comment at 24:39 was priceless too.
Carraghers face aswell 😂
ive never heard keane laugh but imagine telling people u made keane burst out laughing
Is Ty still there? He could take a page from this Everton guy's book
Man has a grip on reality.
Where in the video is ty talking?? I need a laugh
@@sa5986 it's in part 1 mate. But I think the clip should be on youtube
He got his own right to feel however he feel.Why bother about another man view.
@@ljunyreona9882 Come on he speaks utter shite.
Tai made some half decent points in the first video, Cara clearly knew he could clown him and get a laugh but when you actually listen to it he isn't being a usual level of Tai delusion
This is a brilliant idea. I wish it was done more often. fascinating to see ex pros, now pundits discuss these issues with regular fans. A great watch.
lot of vids there
Big up all youtubers, without you we wouldn’t get these mainstream crossovers so thanks this was ace
Well done Baz good to see someone being able to speak up for Everton some good points made .
Thanks mate :)
this content is class. absolute top class. please do more because i feel like this is a good way for fans to have their concerns heard whether they are there in person or watching at home.
Thank you Jared
Roy keane is so honest love him
It’s an act
@@rmanS2C rubbish. He's been b the same for the last 30 years
One of the few genuine people in football
@@rmanS2C hi patrick 👋
@@gailemory3625 bonjour
We don’t deserve to see ty arguing with these legends😭😂
It’s hilarious tho 🤣
He complains how people aren't treating Arsenal seriously but people like him are the reason we're all clowning Arsenal lmao
Legends and Jamie Carragher
Ty is a complete embarrassment to this platform
Ty is hilarious ,and doesn't even know that people are laughing at him not with him
Roy Keane is a breath of fresh air ...brilliant work guys.
legends
Sky gets it, good mix of old and new media. Quality show, hope it continues throughout the season.
A few years ago I could never imagine us fans having such a direct relationship with these professionals. It just felt like they lived in a separate bubble. Thank you so much Garry for this initiative.
Chelsea fan 💙
These fans are often the unofficial club fan organisations like Redmen TV for LFC. That’s why they are full of knowledge.
@@fayesouthall6604 And most of full of shit too.
@@danniwilder2198 who. I think they all did well
Best thing sky have done in a long time. This should be a regular series throughout the season. Great interaction between the panel and the fan base 👍🇮🇪
true btw read book SATYARTH PRAKASH mate
Please don’t stop this series it’s amazing
Great interaction with Baz! What a legend.
Edit: Roy really wanted to say Denis Irwin, he contained himself at last but he said his name two times when he reasoned his way to Scholes lol.
I suspect it was only because Luke Shaw is playing really well and it was about what the team need rather then the player he respects the most. In the Keane v Viera show years ago you could see how highly he rated Irwin (and rightly so). For me it's got to be Ronaldo, Cantona or Keane himself.
I’m so glad you are doing this Gary! Bringing the players we grew up watching and hearing their point of view and being able to ask them questions from a fan point of view. Unscripted, no frills.
👍🏻
This was absolutly brilliant. A monthly show would be great.
They should have a 2 hour fan session after every matchweek discussing every match in the weekend, loved this
Great show - enjoyed every minute. Do more of these...lads
Love the Newcastle fan, she knows her staff and speaking brilliantly. Great show Overlap.
What's her name?
@@Yogendramal Kendall rowan
Not concise at all tho is she
@@TheMiist She had a lot to get of her chest.
Loved the pies
You know Roy sees Gary like a little brother, because he laughs the hardest when they are roasting him. But when Vieira was playing the tough guy in the tunnel with him, Roy was immediately there.
Vieira didn’t play the tough guy, he was the guy tough 😂😂!
@@kailanphillips7305 yeah and can only stand up to people smaller than him
@@jackdelacey7392 Vieira would destroy you. Now pipe down.
@@gegenpress1695 I know he would but I'd like him to be a man for once and take on someone his own size
@@jackdelacey7392 Like who another giant. Roy was all mouth
This is why we all love football.
Having great talks, laughs & interesting conversations about our clubs & what happens behind the scenes at our club.
We all want another one of these!!
Thank you for having us! was a pleasure to get the opportunity to ask a question.
You should do this again. As long as you got Keano in it. Gary is knowledgeable but can be boring also, as he doesnt like to challenge the status quo much, while Keano is the spice to any talk.
Wow, nailed it. Totally agree
Wouldn’t change a thing it was balance and fantastic…so glad we didn’t have a host pretending he knew more than the panel, he came in at the right time cut off the annoying ones at the right time but he let the show flow!
@@blacksling9 Host did what any good host should do. He simply enabled the ppl to talk, and as you say allowed a good flow . And with the exception of a couple "fans" ,that we could do without, this also shows that proper fans have a solid football foundation and understand the game way more than ppl have given us credit all this time.
Yeah I agree, no need to change one thing. Keep it as it is' its brilliant.
Neville, Keane and Carragher is the perfect trio for this. The 3 best football pundits on TV.
@@adeternitamn2859 agreed
Absolutely loved this. This needs to be a monthly thing. Great interaction with the fans from the ex pro’s, great banter as well and also insightful talk from everyone.
The pro’s were excellent at speaking with the fans and not belittling their comments and thought. Only negative was that Arsenal fan…. What a helmet.
The Everton fan is absolutely brilliant
He’s baz From toffee tv
Nah he was wafflin the whole way
@@maxloraine1605 na he wasn’t he was talking facts but you probs clueless football knowledge mate
@@maxloraine1605 or you just don’t resonate with what he’s saying
Baz is sound tbf
This was fantastic, should definitely do more episodes, in a way I feel like it gives the fans a voice in a broader sense
Keane is such a legend. He is always himself and that already makes me laugh
“No, Schmeichel is overrated”
Heard him say this a few times in the past. I’m a Leeds fan but for me Schmeical is one of the best keepers I’ve ever seen. Roy seems to have a bee in his bonnet about keepers in general, never really rates them and seems to have maybe a personal issue with Schmeical
@@ronoccc Schmeichel was the first to criticise roy as being too harsh in his game review he had to do which led to him being he forced out.
@@Newelly_Newells there you go then. Tbf two big egos right there, two big characters.
@@Newelly_Newells How does that work? Schmeichel wasn't at United when that happened and the segment never aired.
@@Aardvarked88 Schmeichel had just joined hence why roy said to him he's had his foot in the door for 5 mins
"You should know. You're still an Evertonian last time we won". Lmao Carra in shambles.
I thought it was more of a roasting than what Carragher did to Ty and that’s saying something 😂
That's what I don't understand about him. Like he played for Liverpool but he's been an Everton fan his whole life surely he should support them
I really hope this is a regular thing 😊 fantastic to see this kind of discussion
Just been introduced to these Overlap vid’s, absolutely hooked = brilliant..!😎👍🏻
Baz representing us Everton fans well there, well said throughout Baz 👏🏻
The Newcastle fan spoke extremely well. Credit to her!
Thankyou 🙏🏼
Beautiful too
This is brilliant! Engaging with fans is the best way to discuss what's going on with clubs. Make this a weekly show & change the fan representatives every episode so a lot of fanzines get their chance to speak for their clubs.
Keane's a very decent man, as if often the case with more cold, serious people. It's the charmers who want to be your best friend 24/7 that you have to look out for
That Everton fan speaks a lot of sense.
Yeah! He was also funny!
he is a clown
@@bootroom9802 can tell what team you support
@@bootroom9802 your the clown 🤡
@@bootroom9802 lmao he's absolutely rattled you
Rafas a legend in Newcastle we love him and we're gutted he left. Everton fans should be happy if there not we will swap rafa for Steve Bruce all day long
I think Steve Bruce has done a good job at Newcastle tbh.
No one:
Josh: "we could sit here all day and talk about..."
Just kidding, very good presenting from Josh, and great to see fans debating with the pundits. For so long pundits and fans have been so far removed, so it's interesting to see excellent fan pundits like Rory express their opinions to the pundits, even if they disagree.
Josh smashed it. Hate it when presenters lose control or talk to much. He was a super healthy balance.
There should be another one mid season to analyze how each team has been playing and discuss potential January signings.
This was fantastic, I hope there will be more of these kind of shows. Especially when we hear from the fans.
Would love to see this around Nov 1st, Feb 1st and end of the season aswell.
That Everton fan is sound 🙌🏽
Im from a rugby league town, so rugby is my sport to watch. But I have to say, these Overlap programmes are very very good and a very interesting insight into football. Hats off to Gary and the other pundits involved, keep up the great work and well done.
Brilliant engagement with the fans. Looking forward to further events. As a Forest fan, I love how Keane reveals his affection for the club. Carragher was on fire.
Brilliant. Love to see more of this. Be good to see a debate for each of the leagues.
Absolutely brilliant this. Thoroughly enjoyed it from start to finish.
😁👊🏼That's my next hour sorted! Keep em coming lads. Top quality content🔥
Loved this, feel like there needs to be more to talk about the clubs they missed. Would love to hear from the fans of the newly promoted clubs, and about the pundits' thoughts on what Leicester could aim for in the next few seasons.
This was great, really hope you do more of them!
Absolute brilliant channel ❤️ GREAT CONTENT ! Keano is a Legend
This is the best thing I ve seen in such a long time. This is what we need. Every week I would watch this without a shadow of a doubt!
I dont follow a team but I love the game. I absolutely loved the whole concept of this show. Feet on the ground chatting with the people that are borrowing money to get to matches, buying the jerseys and making sure they get home in time for the game etc. Brilliant
That Everton fan smashed it
Was thinking the same thing. Proper composed.
@@blackkrayfanclubindiana7035 this same clown was on skysports news about how they won transfer window. loves the sound of his voice
@@bootroom9802 Hmmm wonder what team you support 🤔😂
@@bootroom9802 no that was his mate who is a blert alot like urself
@@Djst-zv1sv both clowns of toffeetv
This is amazing. Very rare you get three absolute legends talking so candidly about things that actually concern fans. I swear half of twitter could do with listening to this.
That Everton fan did really well holding his ground, by the way. Cheeky poke at Keano too 😂
As an LFC supporter who studied in the North East and now lives in London I found the first half of this show really engaging and certainly stirred some opinions with me. But I really appreciate the editing that allowed for the sudden swing to Racism in football. It felt jarring, but that's what's needed. You could see that some people were uncomfortable that it had gone from good natured banter about footie to serious social topics, but unless we confront the issues it won't change.
Should be a weekly show this was brilliant to watch, make sure to keep bringing back Ty :D
Carra putting the debate on his back. Very smart logical dude
Please make this a series. Perfect mix of banter/insight. Keep the presenter/moderator guy too. He always knew when to keep the guys going on deep analysis or move things on.
As a Sunderland fan - I applaud what Roy is saying. He looks way more at home amongst the real world of fans then the fabricated punditry world 😂
All three of them looked more comfortable in this setting, impressed by their listening skills and lack of egos.
Would you take him back as manager? Just interested I think he would get Sunderland up to championship personally
@@lomzaunfiltered9151 not now mate, players wouldn't react well to his man management style these days, it's sadly a snowflake generation compared to the team he had when he was at Sunderland previously
@@PazzV27 I’m a Irish Liverpool fan I went to old Trafford to see Sunderland play United they were class under him took a last minute Vidic goal to beat the blackcats that day. Honestly think he’d still make a good manager now he’s older and a little calmer than before.
@@lomzaunfiltered9151 think he’s matured he was a great coach and he had awful players to work with in the prem like Chopra Nosworthy McShane etc. But he’s definitely changed and calmed down as he’s gotten older so I think he would be a great coach but why would you go back into coaching when you’re getting paid that much to sit on the telly
This series is actually class, amazing that it is free wo watch aswell🌟
Brilliant show! Love to see it in May back with the same trio!
“Get the defenders defending properly” that was literally our only positive Ancelotti
The girl from Newcastle knows her stuff 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
This is the sort of show that I've been waiting for 👏👏👏
Loved everything about this, presented well, knowledgeable fans, and pundits were great! Praying this is a new thing this season 🙏🙏
knowledgeable fans...and Ty
@@RafaelSantos-di5yw FACTS 😂😂