How racism makes us sick | David R. Williams

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 1 тра 2017
  • Why does race matter so profoundly for health? David R. Williams developed a scale to measure the impact of discrimination on well-being, going beyond traditional measures like income and education to reveal how factors like implicit bias, residential segregation and negative stereotypes create and sustain inequality. In this eye-opening talk, Williams presents evidence for how racism is producing a rigged system -- and offers hopeful examples of programs across the US that are working to dismantle discrimination.
    The TED Talks channel features the best talks and performances from the TED Conference, where the world's leading thinkers and doers give the talk of their lives in 18 minutes (or less). Look for talks on Technology, Entertainment and Design -- plus science, business, global issues, the arts and more.
    Follow TED on Twitter: / tedtalks
    Like TED on Facebook: / ted
    Subscribe to our channel: / ted

КОМЕНТАРІ • 840

  • @diannerapsey3492
    @diannerapsey3492 4 роки тому +323

    Of all the videos I have watched on discrimination, I have noticed that when minorities speak on the topic they get more 'dislikes' vs. 'likes' averages, than when Caucasians speak on the same topic. Interesting study to conduct and report on (perhaps from a specific group- to make the topic more relevant to some). Speaker was so absolutely great and powerful in highlighting discrimination at its core; that even when he was not saying a single word or trying to.....he made his topic clear.

    • @SuperSparky1957
      @SuperSparky1957 4 роки тому +6

      👌🏿👌🏿👌🏿

    • @ingrid3977
      @ingrid3977 4 роки тому +23

      The dislikes are from those people who believe that the colour of their skin makes them a more exceptional human being. Sad indeed.

    • @kolajames-idowu2552
      @kolajames-idowu2552 4 роки тому +29

      @@ingrid3977 - Not only that, those clicking the dislikes are anti-intellectual. I don't know how a rational being will down-vote such a scholarly presentation.

    • @ooowatshername2946
      @ooowatshername2946 3 роки тому +12

      i also noticed that when an African American speaks on this topic the body language of the people in the audience seems to be a lot more unattentive most people in the audience look uninterested compared to when a caucasian speaks on this topic as well

    • @sgao8115
      @sgao8115 3 роки тому +10

      Psycholinguistic research has shown that people listen with unconscious bias based on gender, ethnicity and race. Social illness such as racism affects our brain cognitively.

  • @esistsciencechannel1061
    @esistsciencechannel1061 7 років тому +357

    After reading the comments on this video, I want to ask. Did some of you actually watch the video? The title alone made some of you angry/upset and disliked the video. In a sense this videos comment and dislikes makes this TED presentation %100 accurate.

    • @isupportthecurrentthing5225
      @isupportthecurrentthing5225 7 років тому +6

      You don't need to watch it. The video title in and of itself is retarded.

    • @tonatid.f.1179
      @tonatid.f.1179 7 років тому +7

      Like you are LOL

    • @torvaderon
      @torvaderon 7 років тому +8

      I watched it and disliked it after I watched it. I don´t get how the way people watch this makes it any more true. His thesis is unfalsifiable. So it is pseudoscience bullshit.

    • @torvaderon
      @torvaderon 7 років тому +5

      Karl Popper was the originator of the distinction between _science_ and what he called _pseudoscience_. I urge you to look him up. It seams the US hasn´t gotten the message that empirisim and inductivism have been dead a century. Sociology is greatly corrupted and laughed at since the days of Freud. Thinking that adding tonnes of factors to your eqation will make it look more sophisticated is just childishly unscientific. You have to establish what you mean by "racism" befor you can quantify it. I mean come on this is school level common sense.
      What matters are the explanitions you develop. How much reach they have quantifies their relevane. A *good* explenation is hard to *vary*, which means that if you switch out any of its componants it doesn´t make sense anymore. If any of it´s parts are disproven the theory is gravely underminded. Theories are only verified by not being disproven and persisting. To achieve progress two factors are importand: *critisim* and *conjecture*. They are the foundation of knowlege, if you dont allow for one or both you´re allready discualified from being scientific and you earn the titel of pseudoscience if you claim otherwise.
      Now that we established what a good explenation is lets get into what sociology often gets wrong. Not all explenations are equal. For instance Freud could make any data point service to explain the problems of any given person, with for example both to much or to little attantion as a child. In good explenations like the current explenation for the seasons, if you only change the degree of the earths axis the hole explenation collapses. This acctually is a good thing. It is called falsifiability and is fundamental for science.
      English isn´t my fist language so I am sorry if some expressions sound a little bit odd. This subject has a lot more implications and is very imported to understand in order to navigate through the wave of bad science we face daily.

    • @torvaderon
      @torvaderon 7 років тому +4

      The youtube comment system makes it hard for me to reread this discussion I can´t see the comment to which I responded in the first place. Never the less I´ll try to answer as best as I can, just keep that in mind.
      Popper took on positivism and the like and earned a lot of respect for defeating them, but he is often misunderstood and the reach of his explenations is greatly underappreciated. His falibilism is not only the bases for good science today, but also of good philosophy. Ever since Popper introduced his crterion of dimarcation people have misunderstood him to say that testable science is the only thing that matters, when infact Popper himself had many philosophical theories which he himself valued very much. The truth is that the empirical and testible side to science is very small and allways theorylayden. What matters are the explenations underneith. Sociology like every other field is able to develop good explenations, but it is often held back by the misguided view that there are fundations to base ones theories (I would prefer to call them cretiques) on.
      This ted talk is a perfect example for this problem, because an explenation for what racism is and how it effacts human lifes is not explained, it is assumed. Since he only discusses corrilation it is clear that he doesn´t understand that they are meaningless without a propper explenation. I can demonstrate this with an example:
      In the seti project centre a champagne bottle is sitting in a shelf. If seti finds extraterrestrial life the bottle will be opend. This means that there is a close to 100% corrilation of the opening of that bottle and the existence of extraterrestrial life. In this situation the normal scientific explenations for opening a champagne bottle (pressure, kork decay) are irrellevent. The most important factor is whether there is life in the univers dicoverd or not. In order to explain why this bottle is being opened you need the right explenation, yet this ted talk doesn´t provide anything close to it.
      Now there are endlessly more things I would like to criticise, but I will leave it with this last one. He tells us and this should be a red flag for everyone, that he started with his conclusion and sought evedince for it (3:49). This will allmost allways lead you to bad science and is to make a far more important distinction unreasonable.

  • @supercasualtarot4861
    @supercasualtarot4861 7 років тому +152

    The comments section truly reflects what Mr. Williams is talking about here.

    • @zain4019
      @zain4019 4 роки тому +5

      Taylor Wilmot
      All comment sections of historically oppressed groups do- blacks, people of colour, women, gays. I hope we can have more empathy for each other with time.

    • @elizabethdorchester5307
      @elizabethdorchester5307 3 роки тому +4

      I agree. i cant stand the hate people are projecting. can we just love each other as people and stop the hate pls im begging everyone pls.pls pls stop the hate . thanks peace

  • @chaton20
    @chaton20 7 років тому +59

    The world needs more people like David R. Williams. What a great talk.

    • @mamaa2430
      @mamaa2430 2 роки тому

      Indeed it does! Fantastic watch.

  • @deborahbowers953
    @deborahbowers953 4 роки тому +21

    David this is what society keeps denying. This is so, so true. As a lawyer of 20 years in Britain am being told that as I did not work for a Legal 500 I do not qualify for a job in the private sector. I worked for government. How many other minorities are facing this invincible wall? This is an institutional form of discrimination. Thank you for sharing.

    • @Krawn_
      @Krawn_ 3 роки тому

      How are you a minority????

    • @cruisyguy
      @cruisyguy 3 роки тому

      @@Krawn_ How are you even asking? In Britain there are many. Good bye.

  • @nickharley2344
    @nickharley2344 7 років тому +48

    Amazing, and so insightful! I understood the psychological, and health effects of racism along time ago.

    • @tommyselbe1999
      @tommyselbe1999 2 роки тому

      >4 ACES. = CPTSD, ODD, BPD. see a pattern? If we are not Part of the solution 🎭 then we are the Problem!
      Anti Racism? Yeah … I stand with the kidnapped against Illegal immigrants from Northern Europe! How dare they steal a whole continent. And steal millions of people to tame it!
      🗽What have I,
      or those I represent,
      to do with your national independence?
      Do ye mock me?
      Are the great principles of political freedom and of natural justice,
      embodied in that Declaration of Independence, extended to us?
      and am I, therefore,
      called upon to bring our humble offering
      to the national altar,
      and to confess the benefits and express devout gratitude for the blessings resulting
      from your independence to us?
      spoken 70 years ago Frederick Douglass so true Today 4th July 2022

  • @sharmaLlama
    @sharmaLlama 7 років тому +15

    thank you... that was so well presented... I'm glad to have stumbled on this video...👍

  • @WalterMwambazi
    @WalterMwambazi 3 роки тому +26

    As one who has given a TEDx Talk before on a subject that touches on racism, this talk is very enlightening and really helps highlight something I as an indigenous African simply had absolutely no clue about. I challenge those who are watching to also research further on what he touched on about inferior medical attention toward minorities. It is a very sad reality especially when one thinks of America as the "land of opportunity".
    May God help more African Americans awaken and actively fight to change this subtle racism.

    • @andrewmohlala3262
      @andrewmohlala3262 Рік тому

      Economically. But socially America is a failure especially on racial divisions

    • @BornIn1500
      @BornIn1500 Рік тому

      But will you fight to end the plague of anti-white racism that has been cheered on by the left? Funny how black people refuse to care when it's their own people discriminating against others.

  • @dianewiegel7136
    @dianewiegel7136 2 роки тому +7

    I have to shake my head at all the blame and excuses I see all over social media of people who don't want to read and educate themselves so they could learn better and do better instead of sitting there doing not a damn thing because they are too proud or ignorant or stubborn.

  • @fatimaroriz882
    @fatimaroriz882 3 роки тому +9

    Gratidão, por tudo que disse! Me comprometo cada dia mais ser esta onda de Esperança!

  • @cyssyk2472
    @cyssyk2472 7 років тому +68

    He seems like a smart and sensible man, I wasn't expecting him to present such a sympathetic view towards (unintentionally) racist police. He's far kinder than me, or most people

    • @trishm3002
      @trishm3002 3 роки тому +1

      He added the neuroscience behind why humans behave the way we do. Our brains are automatically wired to evaluate threats and rewards. When faced with a threat, we fight, flight, or freeze. Most, if not all police who face Black men, go to fight as their stress response because they believe they’re being threatened (as mentioned in the comparisons between Black and Whites), sadly. And many Black men run and activate a flight response, because they believe they’re being threatened by the police. And because it’s inherent in us to act immediately, arming someone with a gun who knows how to use it, is the most dangerous thing to do under these circumstances. It’s an inherent response that requires an extremely high level of discipline to pause… Most people have not been trained appropriately to pause and evaluate their immediate thoughts, especially if they feel they’re being threatened.
      Until the view of Black people change and is generally more positive than negative, we will continue to see a continuation of deaths, whether consciously intentional or not. It’s a sad and painful reality on what seems like a never ending road.

    • @480JD
      @480JD 2 роки тому +1

      Well stereotypes exist for a reason. If you're a police officer and you deal with the same community day in and day out you're dealing with the worst of those people.

    • @Eternalonly
      @Eternalonly Рік тому

      Coz he wasn't giving opinions
      He's giving facts and truth, which is always not biased

  • @SWEA239
    @SWEA239 7 років тому +34

    One of the best speeches about the black and white race dilemma so far 🙏

    • @SWEA239
      @SWEA239 3 роки тому

      @Groszek Grzesiek hate more between black or white dilemma?

  • @bajinarum
    @bajinarum 7 років тому +23

    Like here in Brazil. the same thing happens.

  • @singlesmeetinternational
    @singlesmeetinternational Рік тому +2

    Wow, this man is awesome in his delivery of this topic. He is so real about it thanks very much, Dr. David. I will share this video. Glad l found it

  • @ingrid3977
    @ingrid3977 4 роки тому +4

    I am indeed proud to listen to David more so as a St Lucian choosing to abandon silence, taking a stand against racism and discrimination which in 2020 continues to impact so many of our brothers and sisters. Our vibrant black colour considered a threat, not climate change, Nuclear war or cyber weapons.

    • @jcornwall6228
      @jcornwall6228 4 роки тому

      I am here because I saw he was St. Lucian. I am Grenadian though but proud as well.

  • @amethyst7084
    @amethyst7084 2 роки тому +4

    Excellent in-depth exposure 👏🏾👏🏾

  • @7sealsr3vs
    @7sealsr3vs 7 років тому +18

    Philosophically, i say, what is 'racism' actually suppressing? ...is it not FEAR of self? Thanks so much David R. Williams for these statistical Evidence/measurement!

  • @goofycawfee
    @goofycawfee 7 років тому +13

    I know i'm probably going to get hate because of this, but every time I think of racism I think of black people because as a hispanic, I've been discriminated more by blacks than whites so its weird to hear a TED talk from a different perspective (In which white people are the racist, but I definitely know that any race can be this way).

    • @cartmanfan4life1
      @cartmanfan4life1 7 років тому +4

      that's the thing about liberalism. They have all their little categories of victims, and then they turn around and scold the white men, but it's actually their groups of victims who are attacking each other. Do you think a gay couple walking through the streets holding hands is going to get harassed or assaulted in the suburbs? it's a lot more likely to happen in the inner city

    • @oluyemiolawaiye125
      @oluyemiolawaiye125 3 місяці тому

      @@cartmanfan4life1 and why is the inner city the way it is ? Why is it mostly poor black people and why are the suburbs wealthy white folks ?

  • @suckmex3899
    @suckmex3899 7 років тому +18

    This video should be an eye opener to some people. But when I see the comments it's only a realization that no matter what I do because of my skin color even being biracial, I'm viewed uneducated and morally compromised.
    Those type of people commenting saying hateful and hurtful things about black people are the reason we are so divided.
    My culture is what ruined me?
    My culture was forced upon me.
    Who would I believe is my lord and savior if my ancestors weren't slaves?
    You see me and all you see is an enemy, even with my arms open and a smile on my face. You sill see me as an enemy.

  • @tragedy393
    @tragedy393 6 років тому +4

    深く考えさせらる内容でした。希望のさざ波になれるよう努力したい。

  • @crissim9844
    @crissim9844 3 роки тому +13

    I am in a country where I rarely see black people but we do have our own minorities. From cultural minorities to the impoverished.
    This video truly is an eye opener for me as it should be to a lot of people. I might not be in America or any other country where it is as easy to see racial differences but what he says makes perfect sense to me. People who does not accept this truth is pretending to be blind.

  • @johnfortner357
    @johnfortner357 7 років тому +7

    This talk speaks volumes. My hope is that someday there can be true, fair, equality between groups of people. This is still an issue, and it's important to remember that

  • @dphd5164
    @dphd5164 Рік тому +2

    I love listening to Dr. Williams.

  • @SoniaSephia
    @SoniaSephia 7 років тому +13

    I don't like the VictimHood of Possessive Liberals.
    However this talk was NOT one of those things. This guy made a legitimate case that in Social stituations as a black individual you are always looked at with suspicion which does raise more of your stress/negativity. A lifetime of stress the comes from being perceived as a threat, are you less desirable human do leave to negative health consequences.
    In a way compared to a high school Outcast that for years of high school he is completely alone made fun of by everybody. Now well I disagree in this man stance on affirmative race hiring quotas I think the rest of what he said was fair.

  • @TheBeautyofRealTV
    @TheBeautyofRealTV 7 років тому +3

    Interesting Perspective!

  • @Kongolox
    @Kongolox 7 років тому +19

    so basically.. Stress kills.

    • @seagatie
      @seagatie 3 роки тому +1

      But also, the cyclical nature of racism ensures that things won't get better unless we dismantle the root cause.

  • @mervekevser1256
    @mervekevser1256 3 роки тому +9

    It’s just a small detail, but did some of you notice how the sponge of his microphone around his head has the same colour like his skin? It’s like the new bandaids for darker skin tones or the new ballerina shoes for black dancers. It’s quite sad that it actually took so long that the Color of a darker skin tone is finally getting recognition in everyday supplies. Like scissors for lefties (a really BAD comparison but the only one i could think of rn)

    • @KiaTheDMVBison
      @KiaTheDMVBison 3 роки тому +5

      The company is named Countryman. They have three or four different tones to try to match skin color: peachish beige (for whites), light brown and dark brown. It’s so there are no distractions when someone is speaking. It blends in with their skin tone.

    • @KiaTheDMVBison
      @KiaTheDMVBison 3 роки тому +2

      I just saw your name. Yes, BTS also uses them during performances.

  • @JeremySPeterson
    @JeremySPeterson 7 років тому +14

    This that Grey Poupon, that Evian, that TED talk. :) People want to pretend like their racism doesn't affect people's health. Yes, stress makes you sick, but what causes stress? Imagine a mother or father being racist against their own child. All of a sudden it's not hard to see how racism might affect health. Our community is just a larger scale of the family. Institutions that have the power over all aspects of life and death are structurally racist and staffed by people with implicit bias. Classism is the partner in crime with racism.

  • @everafter2611
    @everafter2611 5 років тому +2

    What would you do if your son came home with a broken hand saying that the police were rough with him and he's in so much pain?

  • @ashknoecklein
    @ashknoecklein 7 років тому +7

    Great talk about some uncomfortable truths. We can and must do better than we currently are.

  • @lisagorman216
    @lisagorman216 10 місяців тому +1

    David's presentation should be part of EVERY healthcare curriculum for every professional, of every gender, race, age, ethnicity, region, etc.... He so brilliantly described the full and sad nature of U.S. White Supremacy in every institution, and how each of us is unwittingly a part of, by the very nature of programming. To share this with such clarity, (which often involves an entire book) means he is so brilliant! What a testament to the coming together of mind and heart. ❤ I'm in awe of you, David.

  • @sunriselotus
    @sunriselotus 4 місяці тому

    Best amazing video I watched on TED. So true, when will people wake up and understand.

  • @SupermaninJapan
    @SupermaninJapan 7 років тому +2

    Good talk.

  • @Fnidner
    @Fnidner 7 років тому +7

    This brings new meaning to when Dave Chappelle said in a sketch: "This racism is killing me inside!"

  • @ej7431
    @ej7431 3 роки тому +5

    Really good insighful presentation. I would love to see him have a group meeting with Thomas Sowell, Bob Woodson, and Ben Carson. Bob Woodson a civil right leader has been really working hard to raise the standards of the black community, Thomas Sowell a black economist has done many studies on history etc regarding slavery etc. The sad thing that I see that has hurt the Black Community more than anything is the Democratic Party. Like Joe Biden said...you ant black if you don't vote for me. That should say it all. Yes this country can do better especially if they repent and turn back torwards God.

  • @minkailulamin1304
    @minkailulamin1304 7 років тому +145

    All this salt in the comment section though. It's like people get triggered anytime someone mentions race. Sad.

    • @JosephGamacheKD0AHS
      @JosephGamacheKD0AHS 7 років тому +26

      It's more to do with the level of race-baiting this talk contains. If the speaker hadn't defaulted to the position 'blacks are helpless victims of society' within the first three minutes, people would probably have been more civil. We're sick of tired, inaccurate narratives.

    • @AndrewGunner
      @AndrewGunner 7 років тому +3

      SAD!*

    • @DigitalWraith
      @DigitalWraith 7 років тому +1

      Joseph Gamache
      Well Blacks are helpless victims of society generally speaking.
      watch?v=FuN_2ik02jQ

    • @minkailulamin1304
      @minkailulamin1304 7 років тому +3

      Joseph Gamache you have a point but when this video was first uploaded it had more likes than dislikes in less than 2 minutes of going live lol

    • @DigitalWraith
      @DigitalWraith 5 років тому

      @duo maxwell You're an idiot.

  • @misssue14u
    @misssue14u Рік тому

    Great presentation

  • @Boddhisattva007
    @Boddhisattva007 7 років тому +3

    This man is saying that he want's the lives of black americans to improve... what could possibly be wrong with that?? I am shocked that as of this writing there are 876 down votes. Where is the humanity? How amazing would this world be if we were all united and worked towards common goals and the betterment of all humanity? Our ability to work together is precisely why humanity is were it is today, and why we have such great accomplishments. I don't know if his facts are wrong or right or somewhere in between and in all honesty it doesn't matter. The reality is that black America is telling us they feel mistreated and unequal so let's fix it... THAT is win win for everyone involved. If you use logic, I don't see how anyone could come to a different conclusion.

  • @willierowsey3660
    @willierowsey3660 5 років тому +5

    Great speech... only people that refuse to educate themselves can disagree

  • @kamilah2651
    @kamilah2651 5 місяців тому

    If the system have been designed to benefit some over others then that is what we see in society.

  • @madvillain3811
    @madvillain3811 7 років тому +17

    Boy the comment section sure is explaining exactly what he's talking about.

  • @shannonmcintyre9117
    @shannonmcintyre9117 3 роки тому +2

    It's very sad. Because it's not only black. It happens to anyone not white. Or if their nationality differs. I.E. Chinese, Vietnamese, Russian, German, Irainian, Mexican. It really sucks. Not everyone feels that way.

  • @wilbertwalcott2255
    @wilbertwalcott2255 4 роки тому +4

    Time was when Dr Frances Cress Welsing was the only one who did research, documented and spoke much about this issue. She was the only voice in the world. She stood alone with practically no support.

  • @lauraorestano3923
    @lauraorestano3923 7 років тому +11

    So...are all the negative comments/dislikes here from anyone who ISN'T black just generalizing this guy's talk down to "no data and/or stop whining about racism."? Did you even watch the video?
    For the love of God, what happened to just...listening? Just listening to his research and own life experiences and the life experiences of others? If you aren't black, you can't speak to their experiences, you literally can't put yourself in their shoes. Plain and simple. So why can't you just at LEAST shut your damn mouths and respectfully listen?
    Damn. People are assholes.

  • @almahiali4551
    @almahiali4551 3 роки тому +1

    Excellent

  • @andrea8173
    @andrea8173 4 роки тому

    What is the book name?

  • @tiavor
    @tiavor 7 років тому +173

    please do this study again in majority black countries! I just want to see a counter study. No study is complete without a control group.

    • @TROONTRON
      @TROONTRON 7 років тому +13

      Someone give this person a cookie.

    • @DigitalWraith
      @DigitalWraith 7 років тому +1

      *Good point, Tomyo95.*

    • @nattygirldred
      @nattygirldred 7 років тому +3

      Tiavor Kuroma You don't understand the meaning of the word racism if you say that.

    • @liamwinter4512
      @liamwinter4512 7 років тому +2

      Tiavor Kuroma any county, do this study in Brazil, china, Japan , Greece.

    • @Amoncaco
      @Amoncaco 7 років тому +12

      Haha but how would people be able to support their narrative if they use a control group? I mean who needs the scientific method when you can simply convince people with terrible studies!

  • @---re9jc
    @---re9jc 3 роки тому

    We need Dr D Williams to come to the UK. A survey claims racism does not exist April 2021.

  • @timmysinvestments3110
    @timmysinvestments3110 7 років тому +109

    The comment section and like/dislike ratio of youtube is a good indicaton of the society and how sick it really is.
    We humans will never change

    • @irek1394
      @irek1394 7 років тому +2

      Because not agreeing with someone who talks about racism means that you are a racist too...

    • @dwp1slyfox
      @dwp1slyfox 7 років тому

      There is no such thing as never. Anything and everything that can happen will happen in the fullness of time. It may have already happened, and we just haven't caught up to it yet.

    • @irek1394
      @irek1394 7 років тому

      That response... did you write it under a wrong comment?

    • @Shangori
      @Shangori 7 років тому +5

      It is sick. Absolutely sick. Everyone feels like they are victims.
      What needs to happen is that EVERYONE takes a course in math and statistics. Oh, and everyone needs to throw out antipositivism. Its ruining science

    • @rogervansteenkerke2504
      @rogervansteenkerke2504 7 років тому

      It is indeed saddening how many likes this video has. So many stupid people upvoting this...

  • @Izak0world
    @Izak0world 6 років тому +1

    that's very true

  • @glebkhachatryan242
    @glebkhachatryan242 7 років тому +6

    Speech was great! Just one thing. Why is the speaker talks only about the US? There is the problem of racism around the world, not only in the USA.

  • @ReassuringSmile
    @ReassuringSmile 4 місяці тому

    I want to add something after watching the video that's worth bringing up. around 7:30 it's mentioned that if we see a bias in a different group, we automatically treat them with suspicion. Doesn't this stem from pattern recognition? If one group behaves poorly towards others at a higher frequency,. then it's natural that we treat them with suspicion. It is a survival instinct that is automatically do to protects ourselves. It's natural.

  • @mmendi1114
    @mmendi1114 2 роки тому +1

    I will trigger a ripple of hope also...

  • @kght222
    @kght222 7 років тому +5

    there is more appeal to authority in this talk than there is a talk.

  • @storyaid8605
    @storyaid8605 4 роки тому +1

    Greetings Hanaan.
    I believe (with the deepest respect), that it is impossible to apply a reductionist or a strictly empiricist view, as you have. The impact of racism, can't be isolated as a discreet socioeconomic, psycho-social or even longitudinal trauma that can be understood via epigenetic exploration. Pharmacological, penal, family support, healthy nutrition, housing fit for life, an intelligent and appropriate educational interventions. This will enable human beings to think and imagine a life of beauty, recognise the ecology that binds them, the geography that ensures life. I trust that this has been a positive contribution to this discussion.
    Stay blessed.
    OL. Eli

  • @georginafrancis4123
    @georginafrancis4123 4 роки тому +3

    great speech. very informative

  • @overzealouseuthanasiast9731
    @overzealouseuthanasiast9731 7 років тому +143

    Don't even bother with this comment section. Take a deep breath and walk away. Do something constructive, creative. Leave your comfort zone. Expand your experiences. But don't look down this toilet, whatever you decide to do.

    • @elias1706
      @elias1706 7 років тому +14

      How about debating the people that have different opinions then you?
      Maybe you'd realize that not every comment is racist.

    • @LuxiBelle
      @LuxiBelle 7 років тому +5

      You can take the comments out of the cancer but you can't take the cancer out of the comments.

    • @remyllebeau77
      @remyllebeau77 7 років тому +2

      Pathetic safe space liberals. You disgust me.

    • @bryanmulligan4665
      @bryanmulligan4665 7 років тому

      Adding a comparison of African American with Africans in Africa would be a more balanced discussion. Ethiopia was never colonized how do they compare when there are no others to blame?

    • @Bloodxyco
      @Bloodxyco 7 років тому

      too late :/

  • @sheppazii
    @sheppazii 4 роки тому +1

    *breaths in mixed*

  • @Keanangela
    @Keanangela 4 роки тому +2

    Excellent!!!👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾

  • @lucaquinn7707
    @lucaquinn7707 7 років тому +4

    Why is even discussing racism so toxic to some people? A discussion is the most important thing in the world.

    • @oaxacachaka
      @oaxacachaka 7 років тому +3

      I think people are sick of the pone sided presentation.

    • @lucaquinn7707
      @lucaquinn7707 7 років тому

      What is one-sided about this?

  • @needforsleep28
    @needforsleep28 2 роки тому +1

    rascism is an experience you gain but that you immediately show that it happens at a similar level for every level of education. Like you just refuted ur own point. How isn't there a single comment about this.

  • @VincoMalus
    @VincoMalus 7 років тому +1

    Facts!!

  • @darsoulr
    @darsoulr 7 років тому

    it's situation and where we put blame it's heriadtary it's learned behavior...

  • @horsegirlb7120
    @horsegirlb7120 7 років тому +2

    Yes, there's a lot of racism which is unconscious and yes, there's a lot of racism embedded in every system contributing to the running of America - but *_what is wrong with people_* who are STILL committing individual acts of harassment?

  • @hermajestynefertiti
    @hermajestynefertiti 4 роки тому

    Rayyyyyyyyyy St. Lucia in the house!! Rayyyyyy!

  • @jarfuloflove7320
    @jarfuloflove7320 7 років тому +10

    Wow, the guy who sees racism everywhere, did a study and saw racism everywhere. What are the chances?!

  • @shannonmcintyre9117
    @shannonmcintyre9117 3 роки тому +1

    It would be a true shame if just because I was white, I was presumed to be racist for calling attention to a contradiction in speech. Which, there are some who know, that I would do it to anyone. No matter their color, as it has been done to me as well. No disrespect intended.

  • @idrial12345Flash
    @idrial12345Flash 7 років тому +4

    How exactly does discrimination effect wellbeing in such a profound way tho

  • @robbanrobbson2401
    @robbanrobbson2401 7 років тому +1

    I can`t believe how hard it`s to take some fucking personal responsibility these days.

  • @carmenvera
    @carmenvera 10 місяців тому

    Bravo!

  • @RosarioMarieSalvador
    @RosarioMarieSalvador 9 місяців тому

    As a paid advocate for human rights, BLM supporter, and someone who literally named their 1 year old bisexual child "George Floyd", I wanted to to take this opportunity to make a public service announcement:
    Black folx, and folx im general are welcome for the incredible work us advocates do. We are literally changing the world for y'all, and you are welcome for our saving you. 😇

  • @brandonwilliams4429
    @brandonwilliams4429 2 роки тому

    We as African Americans need unity and that will allow us to fight together and we know once you racist you forever racist.

  • @MissMawu
    @MissMawu 7 років тому +1

    TED Why didn't you turn off the comments section and likes and dislikes. You did it when Monica Lewinsky decided to make a statement about her "bad" choices.

  • @seekdatruth2022cedricksgoldman

    I'd like to Here by use this symbol to stand for Black wisdom 👌🏾BW

  • @weltfenos1021
    @weltfenos1021 7 років тому

    why are there so many dislikes?!

  • @fravelmchaney9642
    @fravelmchaney9642 5 років тому +11

    Everything he talks about has way more to do with culture and less to do with racism. He should debate Thomas Sowell.

    • @Dirtysweatsuit
      @Dirtysweatsuit 5 років тому +12

      racism is apart of our culture

    • @rosita101arden
      @rosita101arden 3 роки тому +1

      Ay?🤔🤷‍♀️

    • @merrytunes8697
      @merrytunes8697 Рік тому

      Oh, you're one of those that preach Uncle Tom's message? Stop, this is pathetic.

  • @joeyjacob8088
    @joeyjacob8088 7 років тому +134

    A 17 minute video that was posted less than 10 minutes ago and already has a majority of dislikes. Something seems odd about that.

    • @anvelopes
      @anvelopes 7 років тому +51

      Andrew Shedlock people get really uncomfortable when they're reminded that racism exists and affects people in subliminal ways. watch, right now somebody who benefits from racism is going to respond to my comment super triggered by my even suggesting it.

    • @joeyjacob8088
      @joeyjacob8088 7 років тому +6

      I am not saying that I disagree, I was just pointing out that people seem very capable to see a title and immediately dislike it without even watching all of it. These people also seem to be able to reply to the video as soon as it is released.

    • @abhishekkumar3679
      @abhishekkumar3679 7 років тому +4

      Aracely Ramos Or maybe people are just getting tired of the bullshit?
      You mention the dislikes but what about those who liked the video before even watching it?
      If America was racist, explain to me how you had a black president? How you had a black television personality who's worth a billion dollars?
      I do agree that blacks are socially backward but pinning everything to racism to just childish.

    • @abhishekkumar3679
      @abhishekkumar3679 7 років тому +1

      Andrew Shedlock It's because this is not the first video of its kind is it?
      People are just getting tired of this repeated bullshit and the agenda of the modern day liberals.
      They watch for a few seconds and realize what this video is going to be about. Hence the dislikes.

    • @joeyjacob8088
      @joeyjacob8088 7 років тому +2

      Clicking away from a video because you presume what the content is going to be is very different from clicking on a video, disliking it and not watching it because you disagree with an ideology that agrees with the video.

  • @ricktap3247
    @ricktap3247 7 років тому

    Can't you use those same scales for all races? So that dosn't prove annyting? Could someone explain that to me?

  • @epic6434
    @epic6434 Рік тому

    Caribbean Islands? I left some things there and it was mine.

  • @Donilzz
    @Donilzz 7 місяців тому +1

    im sick

  • @Zoutsteen
    @Zoutsteen 7 років тому

    America has a tough job dealing with the post-slavery age. But David R. Williams proves that Racism is a silly word. The 5% rule has not been broken.

  • @wb3381
    @wb3381 Рік тому

    I love real talk

  • @beliasphyre3497
    @beliasphyre3497 7 років тому +2

    If this is true, shouldn't women be dropping like flies from discrimination?

    • @seagatie
      @seagatie 3 роки тому +3

      Women don't have the same institutionalized barriers that black people have. They aren't limited by their zip code and years of de jure segregation. You're right in the sense that women, of all races, have worse health outcomes to men in some respects, but women are also more likely to visit a doctor over men. These things are inherently different. You're comparing apples to oranges.

  • @fairlylasseiz8662
    @fairlylasseiz8662 7 років тому +9

    Man how about those Native Americans though? A human race almost extinct because the White man. Some things you just cannot deny.

    • @rosita101arden
      @rosita101arden 3 роки тому +1

      SOOOOOO TRUE. THEY SEEM A FORGOTTEN PEOPLE GIVEN THE WORST AND CRUMMIEST PIECES OF LANDS TO EXIST ON. SOOOOOO VERY SAD!!!😔

  • @mathiaslaurence1006
    @mathiaslaurence1006 7 років тому +1

    As a black immigrant I always got confuse with whites hating black in the U.S.
    Because in Haiti,we have a lot of Caucasian(I mean a lot of them,they are mosly coming from the U.S) and I don't think they are racist.
    There is even some of them living in front and 2 blocks away from my house,they are zaine people.
    They even got their kids in the same schools as us.
    Well...Can someone tell me actually what's wrong over there?
    P.S:Sorry for the way I write.English is noy my first language nor my second ;)

  • @eigelgregossweisse9563
    @eigelgregossweisse9563 26 днів тому

    The aggressor paint the victim as the aggressors, and they themselves paint themselves as the victims.

  • @karenbrown7232
    @karenbrown7232 3 роки тому

    I see and or experience what is talking about.

  • @laurieberry162
    @laurieberry162 2 роки тому

    Cause I take care of myself and exercise regularly. That it’s sickening after being scandalized and I am white and I am not a politician.

    • @Ehsidorah
      @Ehsidorah 2 роки тому

      Good to know for nothing

  • @nokoolaid
    @nokoolaid 7 років тому +1

    I would substitute discrimination and expand the circle. People outside the bell curve of inclusion seem to suffer from more health problems.

  • @LynSpooner
    @LynSpooner 4 роки тому +4

    I just don’t understand how residential segregation is to blame for single motherhood. This man is such an eloquent speaker! I enjoyed this video immensely. So, if anyone can answer my probably idiotic question, please do and thank you in advance 💜

    • @MizzGidget
      @MizzGidget 3 роки тому +8

      More opportunity means more.jobs and more people.working, means less crime to support families, means more fathers at home and.more two parent families.

    • @merrytunes8697
      @merrytunes8697 Рік тому

      @@MizzGidget Thank you for your comprehensive, succinct response.

  • @C00chieZ
    @C00chieZ 6 років тому +2

    READ: Whistling Vivaldi: How Stereotype Threat Affect Us And What We Can Do by Claude M. Steele.

  • @charlesgoodman2514
    @charlesgoodman2514 Рік тому

    We need to have more conversations about racism,we need our white brothers and sisters who can't stand racism, wants to end it, much like they helped us end slavery, Jim Crow.if only white people could live with black skin for 1 year and see what it's like. This country is not a Christian nation as some say it is, they get upset when you say it's a racist Nation.

  • @BrantWeckstein
    @BrantWeckstein 7 років тому +3

    Wow what is wrong with this comment section

  • @tommyselbe1999
    @tommyselbe1999 2 роки тому

    What have I,
    or those I represent,
    to do with your national independence?
    Do ye mock me?
    Are the great principles of political freedom and of natural justice,
    embodied in that Declaration of Independence, extended to us?
    and am I, therefore,
    called upon to bring our humble offering
    to the national altar,
    and to confess the benefits and express devout gratitude for the blessings resulting
    from your independence to us?
    spoken 70 years ago Frederick Douglass

  • @VCGConstruction
    @VCGConstruction 7 років тому +50

    We are all human, we all experience emotions and struggles, we are all created equal

    • @matusjansta
      @matusjansta 7 років тому +9

      VCG Construction except we aren't created and we are only equal before the law, not nature. just being a smartass as allways i guess.

    • @AndrewGunner
      @AndrewGunner 7 років тому +16

      Not true. Everyone is different. But, that's OK.

    • @seekingsomething9026
      @seekingsomething9026 7 років тому +9

      But some are more equal than others.

    • @Tych0naut
      @Tych0naut 7 років тому +4

      Exactly, I don't understand why people don't get this concept. What's wrong with being different? Some are smarter, more attractive, stronger, etc. Life isn't fair, get over it.

    • @yeahheyyayya4745
      @yeahheyyayya4745 7 років тому +4

      TyLinkster race isn't a reason to be treated differently tho

  • @allysanchez5630
    @allysanchez5630 19 днів тому

    It’s not the skin that counts. It’s the person you are.

  • @jamesskiles9694
    @jamesskiles9694 7 років тому +9

    13:05 did he seriously just quote Plato in a statement that completely dismisses his entire argument? My tax dollars paid for his education through affirmative action for this!?!?

  • @greenranger9428
    @greenranger9428 7 років тому

    This is TED

  • @epic6434
    @epic6434 Рік тому

    Age 25 ? You got that on 75, this must be the social security thing

  • @jamesskiles9694
    @jamesskiles9694 7 років тому +1

    @ 12 minutes he gives us all a good reason to realize the folly in affirmative action.