Debunking the TOTAL LIES Norman Finkelstein says about Israel on Russell Brand's podcast
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 вер 2024
- Norman Finkelstein has been all over the media, appearing with Piers Morgan, Candace Owens, Krystal Ball, and others, spreading his lies about Israel and the Palestinians. He's slandered Ben Shapiro, Bill Maher, Destiny, Benjamin Netanyahu, and others. He's been called a "psychopath" by Douglas Murray. In this video we expose 10 lies he told Russell Brand about Israel, Israeli soldiers, the IDF, and Palestinians. This is a lesson in Middle Eastern and Israeli history, as well as Egypt, Jordan, Syria, Lebanon, and the rest of the region.
Wow, I just noticed that my replies were removed. So much for transparency.
Happens to me frequently. They remain in my UA-cam History., but don't appear in the comment section. Very frustrating.
It's shadow deleting. It also occurs for periods, not specifically for one comment.
Let's say you made a "naughty comment". UA-cam then shadow deletes all your future comments for a specific period. No matter whether they are nice or naughty.@@johnpatmos1722
Same here, my comments here were appearing for a while and then deleted after a couple days
I DESPISE THAT CRAP TO UPMOST EXTREME. 😠 No mater who! That options should really be taken off of UA-cam.
🇵🇸
Wow thank you so much for taking on all the lies!!
Someone had to do it! And I'm glad it's you.
He is a double talker, twisting the narrative.
He reminds me of the folk on the channel, Democracy Now!
An eminent professor is being critiqued by a comedian with a credible sexual assault accusation against him, we have surpassed all expectations of actually squeezing our own heads up our own arses.
Yup. I thought that lie that Israel left Gaza was already debunked; hadn't heard it in a while. They left physically but still controlled the air, seas, land, even Gazans' nutritional intake. Wow.
If you watched the video it's not about Russell Brand at all, it's exposing Normans silly lies he tells constantly, including the ones he told on Russels show. Norm is terrible.
@@spacecan1 If you read. Prof. Norman books. You may find out that he is saying the truth.
ua-cam.com/video/iNg93bLJL18/v-deo.htmlsi=_uoFnhWDAiUB6lr7
Eminent professor?
He lives in his father's house, broke, unemployed and the joke of academia
Whatever allegation you heard about -- has NOTHING TO DO WITH whether or not he's correct on this issue. Nice try. Finklestein is evil and wrong. Wake up
You can't debunk anything when you are being dishonest yourself 😂.
Accusations are not facts. The fact is that there was not a Palestinian state prior to 1948. There was British Mandate Palestine which included what is now Jordan. If you are fine with the establishment of Jordan by the United Nations because it is Muslim but object to the UN establishing Israel because it is Jewish then your morality is skewed and you may be r@cist.
@homebg2163 So u think removing someone from their land is OK as long as u Document it first 😂😂😂😂...U must be a American
Ewww, stop misusing that emoji. You're an example of one of the many lazy "thinkers" out there today, using his privilege to spew nonsense on UA-cam. Nice work, dude. The guy who produced this video actually worked hard to debunk one of the most blatantly anti-Semitic "academics" around today, and you have the audacity to claim he's wrong without providing any evidence to the contrary. Great work.
Talking from experience?
Phil you are beyond help if you take anything this activist norm has to say he’s been discredited by any serious person apart from the deranged Muslims and leftists
This is the man (Mr Finkelstein) who wrote in Twitter: ....."it warms every fibres of my soul....." referring the horrendous-monstrosities of the 7 October. And on a Candace Owens programme titled “Israel vs. Palestine with Norman Finkelstein” he said on great length how horrendous and miserable is for a mother who is about to give birth not to have facilities in a hospital because Israel's bombardment. My opinion: It has to be something terrible wrong in Norman’s faculties.
Some people have said that he might suffer from a variety of mental disorders ,Narcissism
47% were miliary. 7 hours later the IDF executed the Hannibal directive. Go and pray.
@@10sodot"some people" and "might". Nah sorry dawg, sounds like twitter people diagnosis
@@BlackWinchester Yeah just because he's a total terrorist sympathizer doesn't mean he's defective in some way.
No context necessary for that quote. We just need soundbites. Don't want to complicate anything. Keep it simple, right?! (Except that your poor spelling and grammar DO complicate things!)
Nachi, thanks for being a voice of truth. Is there a way you can get famous ppl like Ben Shapiro to tweet this video, or at least also debunk Norman's lies, i have no idea why they are ignoring him while he makes so much damage with his sick and stupid lies.
Perhaps Ben doesn't know he exists idk lmao
The only lie is allowing this Genocide to continue.
Jews will defeat the Zionists and Netanyahu will go to jail for life!
Bad idea ! Ben Shapiro is more famous that Finkelstein ! It will make him publicity !
Thanks for proving that those 40 beheaded babies were true.. 😂😂 When you can't say yourself idiot directly
🎉@@ruspg3d701lucky Ben if he hasn't heard of this despicable Jewish Nnazi 🇮🇱✡️🇮🇱
This is what the world needs to see and listen to. Have more of these podcasts please. Go Israel 👍
Unfortunately, many of American Jews from having a good life in America, forgetting or forgot what happened to the Jews throughout the history .
They learned well from the Germans, they mastered their techniques and applying them on innocent women and children.
oh, shut up with your victim mentality. What about black people, what about Catholic persecution, what about the Australian Aboriginals, what about American Indians etc. etc. etc?
Back to the holocaust tear parade when people mention an ongoing occupation by the very people of that holocaust..
Stfu
Just zionsits. Many Jewish people oppose zionism especially the younger ones. And it's antisemetic to claim all Jews support Israel and their genocide. @@kianleyon6613
And forgot how to treat people who give you shelter with respect... Palestinian mistake is to receive the pity jews to come to their land.
Wow thank you for speaking out and spreading the truth!!! It’s getting tiresome to keep listening to falsehood 😢
It's not because you like his story that it's is truth. If you want the truth you should read the history of the beginning till present! Don't believe this guy or finkelstein, propaganda is a big part of any war. Some claims of octobre 7 are already been debunked the mass rapes and beheaded children never took place,... and more things probebly will come out later in time. Hopefully it will not be to late, no person is perfect but it's possible to live in peace next to each other when we are treated equally and in israel that's unfortunately not the case,
God Bless Israel and ALL its IDF and Reservist troops. 🙏♥️🇦🇺🙏♥️🇦🇺
The only lie is allowing this Genocide to continue.
Jews will defeat the Zionists and Netanyahu will go to jail for life!
Disgusting
@@exiledhebrew1994 כוסאחתה
I said it once and I'll say it again, I would personally love to see any God that will bless the ID F after what they have done ... there is no way in heaven or he'll that they will be blessed and you will see this with your own eyes
@@Arfalun You won’t. You’re kind curse G-d. We all know what happens when you do that.
Everyone knows Norm Fink's livelyhood is heavily depending on his hatred for his fellow J.
I didn’t know that, can you please elaborate on your statement?
And what a luxurious, debauched livelyhood it is. Had the audacity of never bringing kids into this bullshit ideologistic attention span deficited world. Sitting on the apartment he inherited from his parents reading and writing, on his one armchair, talking to people who seek him out. Getting fired for threatening the ego of the potentates ( in the figure of that not-sinister-at-all selfless not-lying-for-a-living-at-all Alan Derschowitz). Ocasional walk on the beach.
What an ambitious, greedy, devious man
@@stephen6851Everytime he comes on one of these talk shows, he makes money.
@@Mfhollander2 BS, you guys have AIPAC to give millions of dollars to found politicons in america
Point of note:
The military operation in 2014 ended with 2 hostages soldiers.
I knew one of them personally.
They are still in captivity to this day.
We have been waiting for 10 years to retrieve their bodies...
Just so everyone around the world would know.
The soldiers were killed also during a cease fire that was broken by Hamas as well.
I am sorry. May their memories be for a blessing.
What the fuck soldiers are doing in occupied Palestinian territories.
@@italia189 they are hostages...
I don't get how you missed that.
@@italia189they were kidnapped
I haven't heard of concentration camps having *cafés, shopping malls, and roads and shops and farms!*
Have you heard of one where people die of hunger? Where people are crushed by tanks? Where you can't find drinkable water? Where surgeries are performed without anesthesia? No? No similarieties? 🤔
@@michelaguazzi5416 Food and medical supplies are being let in by Israel the Arabs are "starving" and "starving" is in quotes because of the *UN CAN'T ISN'T DELIVERING SUPPLIES* and when you massacre Jewish unarmed men, women and children *DO NOT COME AND FUCKING BEG FOR A CEASEFIRE!!!! THE PALESTINIANS MADE THEIR BED AND NOW THEY ARE SLEEPING IN IT!*
@@michelaguazzi5416 yes. They were in Europe on 1940s
@@hpys and now in Gaza. If you are not able to recognise this you are not fit for society to say the least, and dangerous at worst
Gaza concentration camp with international language and culture vacations...
Well done ! Fink is really loosing it. You can tell Brand’s body language is just not trusting him based on his presentation … I assume Brand is not invested enough to recognize his BS.
There are no words to describe what Norman Finklestein is doing. Its between him and his Creator.
My question is why does he despise himself so much?????
I don't think Satan (his creator) minds what he's doing.
Money and a sick sense of relevancy even though he knows he’s lying 😢
Youre a sick puppy. Learn history.
You can never comprehend the atrocities of zionism because you have been programmed to swallow their propaganda.
The man did his PhD dissertation and is an internationally recognized Political scientist who has written pages and pages of literature sourcing quotes...
And you believe a youtuber on trial for sexual assault.
Fkin laughable
Norman Finkelstain shouldn't be giving any time on social media he never has told the truth about how Harmas
And how do you know? Are you a scholar or an expert on the topic?
@@kianleyon6613can you name one truth he said in this video
@@togsana Its not that hard unless your abit.. 🐢 slow.🧠 Like the mowing the lawn for example.. its as simple as a quick search and you can see where this "Mowing the lawn" Comes from.. I mean it didn't just pop up from thin air..
@@alitharealist4730 well I can tell you easily that your sources including google are leftist sources so naturally they will say it referenced to the slaughter of innocent civilians
What an odious man. Well done for exposing him ❤
I remember some time ago I was going through the Biblical Archaeological Review Hershel Shanks had written about his find near Gaza showing a garrison outpost that had a door that the hinge on it was for a door in the tones of weight, Norman in usual standings refused to see his proof of it being what was found and he refuted and said as he maintained that David was nothing more than a shepherd and that Solomon was nothing more than a child thrown over the multiples of Davids sons who should have served. Religious interference he called it through Samuel. The issue is that Norman doesn't want to believe in the reality of who we are or in our living in Israel his own narrowminded self hatred is exactly what the Terrorists love him over. But notice he's never gone into Judea or Gaza, he knows what those folks there would do to him even if he is on their side. He remains in Israel. He's a nut job.
He lives in Israel? or Israel let him into their country?
He has been to Gaza 3 times, stop lying.
Thank you for exposing his lies
this dude is the worst. how people are putting this clown in high regared is beyond me
How people are ok with seeing slaughtered children is beyond me.
I agree 💯 what a monster
This man is just unbearable. His voice,oh, man. I seriously have physical reaction to it: nausea.
It puts the lotion on the skin or it gets the hose !
Agree…ugh 🤢
Love listening to Norm. Unlike listening to the lies coming out of Israeli propaganda. Palestinian people will be free whether you like it or not.
Yeah this UA-camr sounds mentally Ill
I thought he was pretty good. He is telling the absolute truth and putting Norman Finkelstein in his place and explaining the lies fully.
10????
when norm talks about israel, everything he says is a lie
Everything Norm says is truth. He stands by it 100%. Unlike the illegal yes ILLEGAL occupation. Who is lying to the while world.
His parents were literal hollacaust survivors, why would he lie?
He wants to defend their memory from psychos like you
Name one lie
@@xerke Oh come on you nuthead.
what lie? be concise.
Someone needs to properly debate Finkelstein. And somebody needs to call him on his off-the-charts animosity towards Jews and self hatred - and calmly.
It is really hard to do in real time. He drives debaters crazy with his demeanor. One has to listen to him on double speed playback to avoid being nauseated.
@@talmudovsky I agree. Shmuley dropped the ball. Needed to be done the way one addresses the wicked son at a Seder,..
@@stevenkarras3490 I happened to talk to him via comments on one of his YT interviews. To be precise I am 99% sure it was him as I did some cross checking. Smart, eloquent, observant. Interested in impressions he makes. Perhaps, narcissistic, egocentric and deeply troubled. A case of Jewish positives morphed into abhorrent negatives.
Douglas Murray made it clear as to why no one wants to debate him. Because he's sick in the head.
Well considering all Norman does is tell FACTS it would be pretty easy to debate anyone
Still trying to figure out where he lied.
Okay if i have to spell it out.
#1 Blockade on borders, yes there is blockades on Gaza from both Israel and Egypt this only happened after Hamas attacked Israel breaking the peace deal after Israel gave Gaza to Palestine in 2005, if Hamas had never attacked Israel both Israel and Edypt would have no reason to blockade borders.
#2 Gaza a concentration camp complete garbage, just nonsense.
#3 Mowing the lawn, basically when Israel retaliates to rocket fore attacks from gaza
#4 taking IDF quotes from soldiers out of context.
#5 Some nonsense about claiming Hamas dont use civilians as human shields or that IDF soldiers have also not recorded this complete BS.
#6 Some silly suggestion Israel targets killing of children in Gaza
#7 suggestion's it's Israel thats attacks Gaza without reason, total nonsense...they only attack after an incident.
#8 Suggestion Hanmas doesn't break ceasefire's
#9 Purposely misquoting Bibi on some religious war story
#10 Suggesting Hamas have offered long term peace deals, which they have, but he fails to mention only for ridiculous unrealistic conditions
@Indonesiansurftravel hasbara ≠ the truth
watch the video
@@ligntush Hamas ≠ the truth
@@spacecan1 where is the KHAMASS'??
"The Neighborhood Bully." Yeah ,right!
How dare he call Gaza a concentration camp.
In the same way the world dared to behead 40 babies. 😂
Lets call Armenia the same now
@@md.arifurrahman3830the world said nothing
Media of some agencies is not the world
Most people don’t watch news.
Media wants Muslims and Christians fighting each other because the elites created some real problems AI Wokeism inflation Terrorism
He is an idiot!
I find myself repeating myself that I did not know that concentration caps had schools, swimming polls, amusement park, water park, restaurants, bakeries, markets, supermarkets, hotels, motels, etc. to idiots who think he is correct
We all what he means when he says that- concentrations camps during the holocaust - slavery, underweight people, some people look like skeleton, people getting killed by overwork and due to a really poor condition, people forced to see other people getting killed during punishments etc...
@@LambSauce-ey6jx
I have never seen an interview with Russel Brand but he looks very uninterested in this interview. Thank you for these amazing true facts.
I hate him so much and how do people have him on cause it’s lies not an opinion
Yes it is an opinion, and it's also called freedom of speech
Takkiyah means you can never trust them in business because it says in the Quran they can be deceitful as long as you are not one of them
Which verse of Quran. What a liar!
And which verse would that be?
@@ibnsaid9247 It's Quran Sura 3:28. Look up "taqiyyah" on Wikipedia, it's a real thing. Ex-Muslims will tell you all about it.
Finelstein has to live with himself 24/7 which must be so unbearably painful.
He is insane
he is a sociopath he has no problem with what he says
@@elizabethkelly8552 totally
name one lie
@@imhere8380 1-10 on the video
Eyes are the window of the soul. Just look at his eyes
There is no light in his eyes. His eyes remind of dead fish eyes.
True, he looks evil.
First of all, the Universal soul is emptiness but you're not ready for that blessing
Please do not identify your empty soul to the Universe . The Universe is run by G-D
@@barbaraschwimmer1338So G-d doesn't want any business with you for now, ok. Good luck
Also you need to educate yourself on what is defined as a concentration camp because that has clear historical terminology. The Japanese internment camps, and even Gaza, are considered concentration camps. These aren't my words, these are words by international agencies, and the words of Israel's cabinet. Again, nearly every point you are making is so far off that not even Israeli Historians would agree with you. Simply the worst breakdown I have ever seen.
Thank you for debunking Finklestein
I cannot stand Finkelstein thank you for making this video! 👍
Concentration camps existed before, during, and after the Holocaust. You may be confusing them for death camps, which would certainly lend more credence to lie #2.
Norman didn't begin using the term to describe Gaza. It was first credited to Baruch Kimmerling, a Romanian born Israeli scholar.
Either way, it's a completely inappropriate and deliberately emotional and provocative way to describe Gaza.
Gaza was labeled a concentration camp by a former Israeli official. Regarding the term "concentration camp", it refers to a very densely populated enclosure or prison where the inhabitants do not have free control of their activities. The United States forced Japanese Americans into concentration camps during World War II. Israel did not allow the inhabitants of Gaza to enter or leave without strict control. Israel controlled the food that entered Gaza and kept the inhabitants on a per person ration just above malnutrition. Many international human rights organizations had expressed concern for Israel's human rights abuses regarding the "blockade".
@@worsethanjoerogan8061Giora Eiland the former Israeli National Security calls Gaza a huge concentration camp in 2004, that's before when Israel imposed the brutal blockade
@@worsethanjoerogan8061 "completely inappropriate"
says you.
It's been referred as such by plenty of international monitors, human rights organizations, scholars specializing in the conflict and former IDF officials.
Just because it ruffles your feathers doesn't make it false.
@@worsethanjoerogan8061
Unpopular view: Israel 🇮🇱 is a hero and is freeing Palestine 🇵🇸 from Hamas by doing the exact opposite of the g word everyone accused Israel of - Israel is actually the saviour of the Palestinians. Game of Thrones analogy: Daenerys 'Mhysa' (up to S7 only lol) is Israel, and Yunkai is Palestine. See Matthew 5:10-11,44 & 18:6.
QUESTION:
I don't really care if you agree or disagree. Where else can I find someone else who's actually said this view before?
- Many pro-Israel extremely agree with me, but they haven't seen anyone before me. I've never seen any pro-Israel argue that Israel is doing the exact OPPOSITE of genocide. So, well, I could be wrong, even in their POV.
- Many pro-Palestine find such ridiculous, which I guess is really just a polar opposite position of essentially the same answer as the pro-Israel side which is 'I haven't seen any.'
So I'm either extremely insightful or articulate (pro-Israel) or I'm extremely ridiculous (pro-Palestine). Again either way extreme which in this case means NEW. Unbelievable.
---
Elaboration:
(Begin)
Part1
IDF soldiers have DIED saving Palestinians.
Israel won the 3rd arab war in 6 days, yet Hamas hasn't been beaten after months. I read if Israel didn't care about civilian casualties, even if they didn't nuke, then this war would've been over in weeks with hundreds of thousands in casualties.
Part2
Most Palestinians HATE Hamas. (There are videos!)
In the 1st Arab war, the Arabs were supposed to be the saviour of the (Arab) Palestinians from the evil UN partition plan. Now Israel is saving the Palestinians from the evil UN that votes for a ceasefire. Looks like Israel has done a better job of saving Palestinians in the last few months than the Arabs did in the last 75 years. Quote from Israeli declaration of independence:
‘WE APPEAL - in the very midst of the onslaught launched against us now for months - to the Arab inhabitants of the State of Israel to preserve peace and participate in the upbuilding of the State on the basis of full and equal citizenship and due representation in all its provisional and permanent institutions.’
Israel saves the Palestinians
- politically from a dictatorial regime that steals from them and
- morally by dropping leaflets & providing aid & corridors which the ww2 allies never did in Dresden.
Part3
Despite all the baseless accusations, the deaths incurred that they see on a daily basis and the ceasefire calls, Israel still perseveres in the prosecution of this war to defend not just Jews but Arabs (Hamas hates Arab Israelis more than Jewish anti-Zionists?) and still provides aid, instead of being spiteful like 'Oh you think we're evil after all the aid we've provided? Ok let's see how you like it when we turn off the aid.'
Note:
- Israel is condemned despite giving aid to the FOREIGN Palestinians.
- No one cares when Hamas steals aid from its OWN people!
Part4
Hamas violates the principle of honour - ‘They must refrain from taking advantage of the adversary's adherence to the law by falsely claiming the law's protection’. Hamas commits war crimes such as employing human shields, wearing civilian clothing & indoctrinating children (Matthew 18:6) and then commits another war crime of dishonourable lawfare!
Part5
Israel goes BEYOND honour. I wonder if this magnanimity goes beyond Judaism. I don't recall anything as explicit as this in the old testament. Like Jesus takes a step further to say 'love your enemies.' Israel has no obligation to save the Palestinians who voted Hamas into power. Yet Israel saves despite being reviled - This is exactly what Jesus did. Jews are more Christian than Christians! Like in the 10 commandments movie, Moses doesn't know God, but God knows Moses. Here, Jews don't know Jesus, but Jesus knows Jews.
I mean look what Pope Francis has said and even HASN'T said about this situation. Disappointing. You'd think Pope Francis, who's read the Brit Had Asha aka New Testament a million times while the Jews haven't, would bring this up but nada. Tsk tsk.
Part6
I think this view might be unpopular because unfortunately Israel doesn't have that many vocal defenders who are gentile non-Israeli. so Israel is just humbly saying as a matter of fact that they're not committing war crimes. They can't say further because if an Israeli or a Jew says so then it sounds arrogant (maybe like Numbers 12:3 if Numbers was written by Moses) - Israel is actually a SAVIOUR/HERO of the Palestinians - the exact OPPOSITE of a war criminal.
Again, if anyone's already seen a view like this then please tell me where I can read about it.
(End)
Let Israel 🇮🇱 free Palestine 🇵🇸.
More info:
- pspcYv
- yirg14TiLt8
Just at #2 and you've already fully discrediting yourself. "to compare Gaza to a concentration camp is a form of Holocaust denial".
lmao...
That was quick.
How can support of Palestines in gaza becomes untisemitism.... Do you realise the Palestinian are suffering now the most and the world is praying for them. So now what school will Palestinians kids go now. Is there even a university anymore. Infact hospitals are reduced to kiosks. I think Norman is right. Even UN is telling you this forget Norman
Suffering, yes. The Most? Debatable
I love how the most unqualified people who have never heard of the conflict until Oct 7th are now lecturing the rest of us on who we should or should not listen to. If someone is telling you who you should or should not listen don't trust that person. Watch, read listen for yourself then come to your own conclusions not clowns like these
Gaza is accupation by hammas
No
Check your mental state. I think you’re seeing things inside out.
Gaza and Israel was occupied by arabs
So you are saying Hamas controls food, water, and electricity and has build a wall around it and bombs people in Gaza and is starving them by no allowing any humanitarian aid to enter the territory??? And by the way it is spelled Hamas,
Check your spelling if you want to be taken seriously.
Lol gotta keep that propaganda machine rolling.
I cannot listen to Dr. Frankenstein for more than 2 minutes. I cringe
He's so slow I gotta watch his videos at 2x speed
@@ruspg3d701yeah that fixes that but not the nonsense that is coming out of his mouth.
@@LomuHabana fr bro. He legit wants to give the Houthis a Nobel peace prize 😭
@@ruspg3d701 😂😂😂👌
Antisemites and self-hating Jews in the modern times realize they can't destroy Israel by warfare. The only thing they have in their favor is deception
I heard about Finkelstein very unflattering things, but I decided to watch your video. After second lie I couldn’t continue and I thought how can earth bear such a monster?
It makes my skin crawl 0:29 Oct 7 attack. 'it wasn't the beginning, it was the climax'
Nothing on this planet justifies raep, end of final. NOTHING!
Nor any of the other sadistic acts they carried out.
Thank you for speaking truth and calling out the hypocrisy. Blessings to you and your family ❤ Love from Israel 🇮🇱❤️🇮🇱❤️🇮🇱❤️
So you are o.k with IDF killing innocent children and women?
🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
אתה כלב גדול . אל תדאג בקרוב מאוד אתה תצטרף לחברים שלך הנצים וגם אתה תפגוש 72 בתולות
🍉 🍉
"He's slandered Ben Shapiro, Bill Maher, Destiny, Benjamin Netanyahu, and others."
This is a good thing.
Why? Did you not hear anything in this video
Doesnt anyone rhink about rhe children of gaza who have lost everything no food water shelter why do they have to pay the price 300000 lost lol ves 100000 children
30k dead - half were Hamas. Most of the “children” are teenage soldiers. For only half of the deaths to be civilians means this is an unusually careful war - usually 90% of deaths are civilians.
Your Freudian slip is showing. West Bank, Jerusalem and Gaza are not Israel's to "give" or "not give" to Palestinians. West Bank and Gaza are internationally recognized as belonging to the state of Palestine and Jerusalem is international territory. The core of this whole conflict at this point is Israeli irredentism and expansionism and your wording just served as evidence for it.
There is no state of Palestine and there never has been
@@soltantio there is an internationally-recognized State of Palestine and no amount of revisionism or genocidal policy will change that.
Palestinians mean invaders, Palestinians are homeless
@@pilisopa lol tik tok history
@@soltantio You are saying the opposite of the Truth , and repeating propaganda.
There was no state of Isreal and there never has been, on any map.
Palestine has existed on maps for over 2000 years.
There is no mention of Isreal, outside of the bible and Torah.
This is why Zionists made up that lie, which you parrot.
The famous : " accuse the other side of what you are guilty of" , technique !
This should be shared widely! Thank you
dont be so dumb and brainwashed.
How ignorant you are...
Kudos, great vid. Finkelstein is a complete disgrace.
Great video calling out the truth! Love this!
Thank you for putting this info out there
name just one lie he said...one.
@@imhere8380well Norman did a lot of lying
Finklestein’s voice is unbearable. I have to mute it. If that place is an opened air prison, check the videos circulating of the open air luxury. Russel Brand is disgusting too. What he’s done to women is despicable.
what do you use?😂😂😂
Please send this to Russell, he is an honest person who should take it seriously
Nope.
Wexare living in a mad and sick world. People jus lie to get their way through whateuù
0:38, that skips the Israeli disengagement from Gaza and Hamas attacking Israel and thus starting a war
are you kidding me? right away you're totally wrong, gave gaza full independence. except that they can't leave and Israel controls food water and electricity
Great video bro 👏
I can only imagine that as stressful and frightening as it is for most Jews now, for those who hate themselves for being Jewish like Finkelstein this must be a time of utter self-abnegation.
Finklestien is not a self hating Jew, he is a mentally stable Jewish man who sees what he’s looking at and speaks truth to power.
@@Rememberwhatyouknow I see you are driven by real faith. the absurdity of your statements is not a barrier to you. be healthy.
That is just stupid.
I like how this guy ignores how Lehi and Sterner gang (self proclaimed terrorists that eventually became the IDF) were committing acts of terrorisms against Palestinians and English army officials long before Israel was a country. Now imagine you live in this region being terrorized by a self proclaimed terrorist group but now a country not even on the same continent says they have a right to your home and you have to live under their rule. Generally when to groups of people go to war they study each other and learn their tactics (know your enemy) what is inevitably going to happen is the two sides start to resemble each other. Hanna’s is a terrorist group and it was inevitable that they where to form because they themselves where victims of terrorism. There are no clean hands here.
Those terror acts were because the people in charge at that time weren’t allowing boats filled with refugees to land in Israel. They sent the boats back to Germany. Read the history.
Take a look at John Spencer’s Jan. 31 Newsweek article on the war. He’s a West Point specialist in urban conflict.
Most people in the west don't seem to think that deep nor show any interest in cause and effect
They have recruited a lot of western money minded persons and gullible persons
EXCELLENT!!!
BUT.... you missed my favorite!
Has Norman Finkelstein ever BEEN to Gaza?? 🤔
Because to be the foremost expert on a place, you should have been there before, right?? Everyone just assumes that he knows Gaza like the back of his hand, so no one even ever asks him! 🙄
Candace Owens asked him last interview (I think around time stamp 30 mins?). He pretends not to hear her.... So she asks again.... shifting in his seat, he nods yes and says "Yeah, yes" and then adds", "Many years ago. Twice...hmmm, let me think... yes, twice! Briefly. Before the disengagement. But I spent summers in the West Bank" and then jumps into an explanation of that. IF he WERE the pre-eminent voice on Gaza, he would have visited! To add some color to his books... of course he would have to fly through Cairo like Abby Martin does....😢
In any event, he is not only a blowhard, he is a fake! And just as he monetized his parents Warsaw Ghetto experience and makes money off of being the son of survivors (and unfortunately, that doesn't make him special either!), which I find repugnant, he makes money off of a place he talks about daily yet can't seem to recall if he has been there even twice or not! 🤔
Briefly, mind!
It's not easy to enter Gaza, mind you not because of Hamas but because of the colonial settlers state. Finkelstein was banned from entering the colonial settlers state and thus have no access to the Palestinian territories. He had met with Hezbollah leaderships in Lebanon, so Hamas would have zero issue with him to be in Gaza. I think one of the few people who managed to enter Gaza was Miko Peled and he was smuggled through a tunnel.
Just came across your channel for the first time. Thank you for showing the truth
what a silly video with nothing but half truths that misses all context. Also, learn what a concentration camp is.
you can't handle the truth!!!!!
In most opinions, this Finkelstein is a pathological twister of fact
Interesting, and how did you come up with this assessment? Do you have examples to share
you need to normailise the volume. Your volume is much softer then finkelsteins
It's sad that this young man has no intellect but has to make propoganda in UA-cam.
LOL in 2006 Israel withdrew from their illegal occupation of Gaza, but maintained an illegal air, sea, and land blockade on Gaza. Even Israeli politician call it the largest open air prison. Stop making up lies!
Im a hindu from India 🇮🇳🇮🇳 and i support Israel and jews.. stay strong brothers and sisters
To bad they dont give two F about you
2:15 drop the volume of the background video 🙏
everytime he speaks i lower the volume i cant bare to listen
@@ajl8198 You can't spell, either.
I absolutely detest this fo.ol
Ignorance is a blessing for some…
What you are saying, just simply isn't true. Not even Israeli historian Benny Morris would have your take. Your take is so propaganda that it's embarrassing. This is worse than your Bousef breakdown where you tried to explain how Palestines population increase is due to birthrate when over 70% of them are refugees. Bottomline, you need an education and one that isn't from propaganda.
Gaza has very high fertility rate. There population after refuges came was 200k after now in its 2.3 population the UA-camr stated correct info your wrong
@@warrenw5270 73% of the Palestinian population are refugees. Having a high fertility rate is only one component in population dynamics. I would know because I study it. Unfortunately you are wrong.
Why won't you go debate Dr Finkeilstein.
You should debate Frankenstein.
He looks like he had a stroke and doesn’t know what’s going on.
This man would get demolished.
Really. Nah. Even Shapiro won't face Finkelstein. He isn't about to be humiliated by Norm. All will make a fool of themselves when it comes to the professor. Just look at those who were brave enough, or stupid enough or egomaniac enough.
Noway they will debate this guy would lose badly. This video is made for people who hate Frankenstein.
Good one😢😢.
Thank you! I have been commenting and sending emails to Russel Brand asking him to talk about Palestinian corruption and how they could be in a total different situation if they use the money to serve the people, not building tunnels and rocket launchers. I feel very frustrated that he chose to amplify the voice of this opportunist,
Listening to this guy criticize Finkelstein is like listening to a dog bark at the moon.
I totally agree with your analysis. I am so sick of that man's falsehoods, and I'm not even Jewish or Isreali.
Thank you for this video! I have been wanting to make content exposing Norm Finkelstein. The man lives on another planet. Very sad.
There can never be enough videos exposing that guy. Do it!
How come Gaza is is, free when Israel decides to cut down food... Dikhd correct ua Slater lie
I admit I didn't watch your entire video. I stopped watching after you asserted that Israel took a great deal of caution during Protective Edge.
I'm certainly open to critique of Norman, but you aren't really providing any counter to the vast evidence and historical accounts he has presented in his books and talks. Perhaps your book has more elaboration.
You clearly disagree with what he's said, but spend more time belittling him than you do providing information that adequately refutes his claims. These days, most people won't take IDF quotes seriously--of which you supply a few--given how widely and brazenly they have fabricated information. The rest of your information (granted, I didn't watch your whole video) is either not sourced or seems more your opinion than objective information.
Finally, you haven't acknowledged any truth in any of what Norm has said. In most earnest debate, each party usually grants at least a few points to the other. I think you're more interested in silencing people like Norm than you are in sincere discourse, and cannot take your position seriously.
I hope the right people see this video. Thank you 🙏🇮🇱❤️
His high pitch pothetic voice brings out his disingenuous plight to earn the world to sympathy
That's because he has his voice raised. Because he's speaking so slowly, it's easy not to realize that he's shouting.
I like his voice somehow
His voice grates on me. Weird.
"Gaza is a comcentration camp" - that isnt Finkelstein quote, its Israeli scholar Baruch Kimmerling , Norman is simply repeating it. This post is nothing but generic Hasbara talking points. No nuance or understanding if the history of the conflict.
Wow, what a grat video, thank you for putting this Finkelstein guy on it's place. I hope he sees your video
So basically you're not denying the facts on the ground, e.g. Hamas's actions, the blockade, Israel's policy of mowing the lawn, etc.
You're simply giving a different interpretation of what happened than Finklestein.
Now, which interpretation is closer to the truth? You're interpretation seems to place Israel as a state coming out of a fairytale which is in a bad position but only does good. Idk if Finklestein's interpretation is truer but yours is just not realistic.
*DISTORTED* , Cherry picked facts become something else.
lol stop israeling the truth.
a bunch of bots giving generic praise to his propaganda
@@caiocarugati7432 correct. What are the chances that a nobody with 2 thousand bot subs could debate the history of Palestine with a scholar who's written books on it? About zero.
@@farqueuemanjust because you are a scholar dosent mean you can’t lie to make a truth that benefits your morals (in this case Normans want to kill all Jews)
Nothing Norman Finklestein (an accomplished Historian and field-expert) says should be taken seriously 🤡
There is something about Finkelstein I find quite repugnant as soon as he starts speaking and it's not even his opinions at this point. I really get the impression is has some kind of mental condition. I don't know that Finkelstein is capable of interpreting the information he sees.
Finklestein sounds credible to me.
I find it weird that he’s calls Gaza a holocaust situation yet he avoids the pain his parents gone through in the holocaust
He's a disappointment to his parents for sure
@@Thenoobestgirl they'd probably disown him!
Thank you for that
Am Yisrael Chai
Yeah, I'd rather listen to a professor who's spent years on the subject than some random UA-camr. Anyway #FreePalestine.
So when does the “debunking” happen? Watched the video and not a single point was actually debunked
I like norman Finkelstein to put the logic when talking about North Korea blockage and starving innocent children and civilians . Same situation no hate for it
Great work,thanks