How Benjamin Netanyahu Relies on Hamas
Вставка
- Опубліковано 21 лис 2024
- Why Netanyahu wants to Keep Palestinians Divided
Watch my videos ad-free on Nebula (along with tons of other exclusive videos from fascinating creators). Sign up & get a 40% discount HERE: nebula.tv/john...
For the bigger context on this conflict, watch this Modern Conflicts episode exclusively on Nebula: nebula.tv/vide...
Members of the Israeli far right have referred to Hamas as “an asset” and claimed that anyone who wants to stop a two state solution needs to support Hamas. In this video, we go over their strategy to divide and conquer the Palestinian people, keeping them physically and politically divided so their land can be taken.
Special thanks to Max Fisher, Sam Ellis, and Nathan Thrall.
Watch the Search Party video on the conflict between Israel and its Arab neighbors: • The Arab leaders are i...
Check out all my sources for this video here: docs.google.co...
Check out my new channel with Sam Ellis - Search Party: / @search-party
Get access to behind-the-scenes vlogs, my scripts, and extended interviews over at / johnnyharris
Do you have an insider tip or unique information on a story? Do you have a suggestion for a story you want us to cover? Submit to the Tip Line: docs.google.co...
I made a poster about maps - check it out: store.dftba.co...
Custom Presets & LUTs [what we use]: store.dftba.co...
The music for this video, created by our in house composer Tom Fox, is available on our music channel, The Music Room! Follow the link to hear this soundtrack and many more: • Mind Music | Orchestra...
About:
Johnny Harris is an Emmy-winning independent journalist and contributor to the New York Times. Based in Washington, DC, Harris reports on interesting trends and stories domestically and around the globe, publishing to his audience of over 3.5 million on UA-cam. Harris produced and hosted the twice Emmy-nominated series Borders for Vox Media. His visual style blends motion graphics with cinematic videography to create content that explains complex issues in relatable ways.
press -
NYTimes: www.nytimes.co...
NYTimes: www.nytimes.co...
Vox Borders: • Inside Hong Kong’s cag...
NPR Planet Money: www.npr.org/tr...
where to find me -
Instagram: / johnny.harris
Tiktok: / johnny.harris
Facebook: / johnnyharrisvox
Iz's (my wife’s) channel: / iz-harris
how i make my videos -
Tom Fox makes my music, work with him here: tfbeats.com/
I make maps using this AE Plugin: aescripts.com/...
All the gear I use: www.izharris.c...
my courses -
Learn a language: brighttrip.com...
Visual storytelling: www.brighttrip...
"Hamas didn't create the conflict, the conflict created Hamas" ex-IDF soldier
Sums it all up
from the moment there was a declaration of independance of Israel, Arabs attacked Jews. That created it all. The "conflict" comes from constant refusal of all the Arab countries to have ONE small Jewish state in the world, in their indigenous land they never completely left. Hamas is just one more recent occurence of Arab-Muslim Jewish hate, but that started from Mahommet, it's advocated by the Quran, and the pogroms of jews in the Middle East and in particular in the region didn't wait for the state of Israel to be reborn in order to occur.
Die Hamas würde von Netanjahu gegründet.. von Par Jahre
WELL SAID
well said
The moment someone says "turn off the camera" you know something important is about to happen.
And it gets turned ON
Δημήτρη κλείσε την κάμερα
Propoganda
@@Bond786muslim
Explain. Recording what’s actually said behind closed doors is “propaganda?” Riiiiiiiiiight.
@@Bond786muslimok hasbara bot
Let's be honest, there's nothing in this video that people who care about the issue haven't been shouting for years. But it's always great when those messages reach a new audience.
eh I second that some of the points that were made are rarely put up in videos concerning this subject
Isn't that also part of the problem? The perpetual drawing in of audience for their bullshit? Seems People worship their politicians who sell the illusion of safety and security. People are also naive that outside governments (such as Iran) spend endless money using Palestinians ? Free Israel from the US. Free Palestine from Iran. ....and get rid of the United Nations. They have been destroying property rights all over the world since they were first formed. Just a 4th tier government with zero accountability trying to tell others how to live.
JH did a great job at depicting the valid points made by both parties and depicting these situations in all their complexity rather than the black and white many often do.
@@CalicoreGaming how is occupation not black and white? is there even a justification?? ah right my bad, anything for a home for the Jews.
Yeah it’s nothing new here but good sum up of information for more people nevertheless
the worse thing can happen to you is a stranger in your land
Thank you for having the guts to talk about this conflict and not being pressured to make these in haste despite the pressure you received.
Bot comment😂
@@TvGunslingeRvT I’m real bro
@@TvGunslingeRvTBro Your A Bot
@@hadiazam7051that is something a bot would say to someone who is not really a bot
I am an American Palestinian was born and raised in Gaza and what i noticed that this guy tells the real story. The new generation of American become more knowledgeable because they do their own research rather than flow Traditionally TV channels like fox news which funded by bro-Israel groups. Keep it up, you and many of the US young generation will change the world.
Camera man is the main character here. He lied to netanyahu and secretly recorded him. True legend
Cameraman never die
@@arekhandiabruno deep fakes didn't exist 20 years ago
@@arekhandiabruno way too old to be deepfakes lol the earliest deepfake found was the obama thing
Or maybe it he told him to turn it on, so it would look this way?
I'm surprised and kind of disappointed Harris did not show more of that interview where Bibi continues to incriminate himself and even when asked about the Americans potentially opposing his strategy of sabotaging the Oslo accords that they helped establish, he goes on to tell the settlers not to worry because Americans are easily manipulated. I guess he wasn't wrong about that. At least until recently that is.
Divide and Conquer. I am an indian and those words sounds very familiar. The same tactic used by British to separate Hindus and Muslims and weaponizing the minor side to keep the divide going. That's why History is so important.
It's not just British. Even our current politicians do the same.
@@ragul3204 Yup. In North America and Western-Northern Europe. Regarding Globalist, leftist, woke parties seizing power through fear & anxiety tactics, like the global warming hoax, russophobia and neo-nazi slander etc.
Europe too look at Africa and Asia they sat down on a table, made their tactics to conquer to step down fighting with each others In Europe and have some intrest.
As if you needed any help being divided.
Angloids and jews have been using this tactic for years.
The Smile at Netanyahu's face when he announced that his country is in war on October 7th evening proves that the attack was something he wanted
You should have showed the part in Netanyahu speaking to settlers when he said Americans are easy to manipulate and more of put down to USA
That doesn’t make any damn sense.
Also, the true title of this video: “How Johnny Harris spreads lies and hate to earn money”, or “how Johnny Harris relies on left wing extremists”
@@GenericUA-camGuy it actually makes sense
zionists control the US so it's not surprising of him saying that without the fear of it getting published. he said that the US is something that can be moved easily meaning controlled easily
he's gonna fall down
Are u speaking to content of he/she said (that Netanyahu did *not* say such a thing) or the slight jumble use of words they used to say it? Because the quickest of google searches find that Netanyahu did say something to the effect of, so what’s ur contribution to the discussion amount to: trying to defend Netanyahu saying a $hitty thing about a supposed ally or criticizing an absolutely correct ESL speaker?
Netanyahu stated he was going to milk America like a cow!! He certainly kept his word!
if you are homeless you need a home , but that doesn't mean you need to take someone else home .
Well we always had a home and prayed to it, the fact you dont know much about judaism doesn't mean Israel is our homland and always had been
@@galikafry8494 true that is where judaism started and always had a presence there even from the palestinians who were descendents of jews who were forces to convert to islam due to the fact they never received any government help from their muslim governments during famines
@@galikafry8494your land? Your 200 grandma land? Before 3000 years?
I always wanted to understand your opinions but it’s just complete nonsense
😂😂@@galikafry8494
@@potatochip190Palestine doesn’t exist
We would be lost without independent journalism.
Ameen
No you'd be better informed without this propoganda.
It's not journalism, either its regurgitation.
im hungry, man. 1 euro can get me 2 meals!
even better, just think about me once. peace to you
right... he probably gets paid by Katter or someone to spread lies like this
@@dortwito3353 what is a lie? tell me please list all of them Jew
The fact that,10/7 is mentioned 20 mins into the video shows how Jhonny Harris isn't blindsighted to what had happened for 70 years b4 it.
That camera man who turned on the cam again probably recorded the most important thing for this whole conflict
What's the time stamp
@@sponge67111:44
@@sponge671 11:57
Nah, it is very known thing for the locals. But it does has a dramatic effect in a short vid
Netanyahu's anti peace stance should be pretty well known without a video.
As an Israeli Jew that has lived in the country for the vast majority of my life, I 100% agree with you that Netanyahu is just as guilty as anyone else and the blood of Israeli innocent civilians alongside innocent Palestinians, is on his hands. Something that I find could've been added is demonstrating the dissatisfaction of the Israeli people that have been protesting for 10 months straight prior to Oct. 7th in opposition to our corrupt government. We all just want to live in peace, hopefully that can be achieved sooner than later.
What are your feelings on Iran? What do you think the solution is to foreign governments compromising your safety, empowering bad governments and backlash?
I dont understand what Israelis feel so wrong about a two state Solution? It's your promised land? Okay sure, why not let Palestinians have the land according to Oslo accords and just end the conflict? I mean it's pretty clear to both sides and the world that neither of the parties can stop existing or just immigrate. Everyone would stand by a two state solution. As for Jerusalem, everyone can have access as its holy to all three Abrahamic religions.
You don't understand the hurt it causes me as a Muslim to not be able to visit Jerusalem because of the conflict.
I am so glad to read you see the truth. Please more people like you in Israel, speak up! Cheers from a Lebanese guy, praying for peace.
@@hunter62207the is that besides Isreal not wanting a two state solution, hamas is also strictly against it.
@@walperstyleIran should give you a lesson
UP NEXT: Netanyahu is gonna declare Johnny Harris as the Media wing of Hamas
Well, when you expose them they do whatever they possibly could to stop you or you'll be considered anti-Semitic
Lol nobody cares about being called anti-Semitic. Means nothing to me@@Real6002
😅
😂😂😂
Or they write his name on missiles 😢
Ironically, Palestinians played no role in Jewish 1,800 years persecution. Why are they paying the price?
They occupy jew land
They killed Jews on oct 7th
Funny how their old books say "home land for the jews in Palestine" then hear them say "There was never a Palestine."
Palestine is a relatively recent colonial term coined by the Romans.
@@nyc_bkYeah, okkkkay there buddy... How do even you put "Romans" and "Recent" in the same sentence? Go toss your bs on someone less informed.
@@ahdnaji I guess you don’t know what the word relative means 🤷🏽♂️
@@nyc_bk Selective relativity? All remnants of the Roman Empire today are referred to as artifacts, historical sites, and ancient history.
@@nyc_bkbruuuh tf are u even talking about
I know you made This video despite not having a sponsor. This shows great character and integrity. It was very well done and I hope you make more videos on the topic. The entire world needs to see this video! It’s precise and to the point. Thank you!
And I'm subscribing you for your kind gestures 🎉 love for Johnny Haris and you Ms Panama ❤
He is making it sound like Netyanhu's goal since the start was to destroy Palestinians when since the start he wants peace for Isreal which means fighing back anyone who wishes them harm, who are basically 70% of Palestinians.
im not sure who is the evil ones, the ones who used an iron curtain to defend from rockets or the ones shooting them?
2:44 Zionist sponsor him. He omitted in 1492 Ottoman Empire sent ships to rescue jews from the Spanish Inquisition.
2:44 Zionist sponsor him. He omitted in 1492 Ottoman Empire sent ships to rescue jews from the Spanish Inquisition.
2:44 Zionist sponsor him. He omitted in 1492 Ottoman Empire sent ships to rescue jews from the Spanish Inquisition.
As a Muslim who drives Uber in a suburb Jewish neighborhood, (Monroe, NY) I was a bit skeptical about driving after the recent conflict. I let go of my bias and drove for weeks and received nothing but respect. I hope my Jewish and Muslim brothers can live in peace again just like they have been doing for decades. And thanks Johnny once again for the clear and concise video.
I'm Israeli,
That's my dream for my people, but in these time it's hard to imagine...
Every day that the hostages are in its just painful to imagine the things they must be going through. Its unbearable while also half of the world want us destroy
it was never about jews ....
yeah but you should know after watching netanyahus clips here in this video, that peace is almost impossible, zionists dont want peace they showed us that when they killed yitzhak rabin. you saw here in this video netanyahu mentioning that for jews to have peace and security they have to break them (in other words oppressing them) but this is just another zionist lie, its the oposite palestinians just want their land back, if the jews just came to palestine to live there and didnt occupy the land, they would have not had resisting palestinians today and all these enemies. they are more far away from peace and security.
if you ask me jews should have country if they want, but they have no right to occupy palestine and displace palestinians just cuz they want a country. and just cuz their ancestors lived to the holy land doesnt mean they have the right to own it for them selves it is holy for all jews christians and muslims.
before this occupation these 3 religions lived together peacfully in jerusalem.
@@SoMeBoDyThatUKnowUS they dont. brother, no one can or wants to destroy Israel. except hamas, but they were never strong enough to do it. And if your PM keeps slaughtering Gazan children, youre never going to find peace. at first, let go of that indoctrination. No one can destroy Israel. But that hostility is what Bibi exploits, and all the prior PMs. we are all victims of something, but if you being a victim convinces you to victimise others, that's immoral. dont vote for netanyahu. dont live in fear. History will not repeat itself against the jewish people. but it may against the Palestinians. Is killing children really security? then how secure is one? first, get over your fear. then do everything to stop this massacre. or history will not look kindly on the Israelis who watched Palestinians die, just as the Germans did Jews.
They are not your brothers. Allah cursed them in the quran. If you are truly Muslim you would not call the people Allah hates your brothers.
Really good Video that explains the conflict better
Oct 7 was nethanyahu's final piece on the chess board, that man has blood on his hands
Do you think that October 7th was really a surprise?
@rustynails68 not at all, you think one od the best intelligence agencies in the world wasn't aware Hamas was planning a retaliatory attack after Israel upped the killings on Gaza and the west Bank?
stop making it like he is the only reason , his people are like him he is representing them
You think ruining his reputation for ever is his plan? Golda mair fucked up 50 years ago,and every 5 year old kid could tell you what she did, hes over
@@sizebi-hy5gt if you control the media u can control the perception of people.
Content like this is why journalism matters, and I don't think most people understand how much heat and hate JH will get for putting a piece like this out. This is an incredibly complicated issue with a ton of agendas, and it's presented it so well here.
I really regret - as a Palestinian immigrant - to see the Palestinian issue classified as a "conflict", before the seventh of October, the narratives did not take the violent form in their composition, but the truth was on the table (for those who are looking). After the seventh of October, the issue took another turn and considering that the beginning of October 7 and forget that the response from Hamas was not arbitrary, but resistance to the expansion, which Netanyahu himself spoke of Greater Israel and erased any recognition of Palestinian independence, hence the war of narratives arose.
@@Brasle65calling the intentional slaughter, rape kidnappings resistance is disgusting.
You're ill informed..prove otherwise, with evidence..or admit, thats your opinion @wow2031
@@wow2031 the politicized media machine by Israel makes you utter tragedies that have only been proven because of the permanence of repetition, and this is what I talk about "the power of narratives". Absolute loyalty without proof necessarily generates a lack of awareness, and I pray to God to enlighten you to what is right my brother🙏🏼.
But hes just laying and not cover all of the story. Palestine did way more terror attacks then he describe.
Israeli here. Great video. Netanyahu does not represent us. The settlers do not represent us. Everything you said is on point.
are you still alive. genuinly concerned
You and your people will still pay dearly
@@Mebarak.ak4what did he do huh?
I'm an Israeli too and you don't represent us. The masses are with Netanyahu, you guys are a sick elite-class minority with control issues that can't bare the idea that leftists aren't running the country. God bless the settlers 🙌
@@Mebarak.ak4 "anti zionism isn't anti semitism" ahh moment
ok... I downloaded this in case. Good content btw.
i wouldn't expect kisses and flowers from someone i stole land from
Jews where in that land from 1000BC so who stole from who?
No land was stolen. Arabs lost land by starting and losing wars against Jews.
You know when the Jews went home to Israel what it was always called. Palestine was the name of the land and Palestinians was the slave name given to the people of the area by the Romans who conquered the area.
you're welcome
@@shaec3405 You know when Romans conquered Israel they declared Herod the Great as "King of the jews". Jews lived in Israel even before 1000 B.C. ,way before Romans.
You're welcome
So are the Palestinians living there Both of them are Canaanites the original owners of the land
@@Lazlum
Its the equivalent for letting a friend stay at your house and they kick out your wife and children and force you to live in the dog kennel and get mad when you object.
and then tell you "you've always lived in the dog kennel"
Yeah but Palestine was offered a state and rejected it?
@@none3157 they werent "offered a state" they were offered a compromise half assed temporary solution. Quoting op "ok, the dog kennel and the bathroom are now your house, and wont get inside of them, but the rest of your house is mine and you cant use it"
@@none3157pretty innocent take they weren’t offered shit bombing continued and was there before there where even hostages
@@none3157 offered a state? I think you meant they offered a shitty dogshit land to Palestinian meanwhile the Israeli got a fertile land and strategic location lol
This is the kind of reporting we need.
why? BBC and CNN dont cut it anymore for you?
@@meddown7035
They did
CNN broadcasted that video about the Arabic calander being called a terrorist list.
BBC mistranslating Arabic interviews and later apologizing for them.
CNN apologized for broadcasting untrue claims of Hamas beheading babies
BBC called pro palistine protesters pro Hamas. There's a lot more but I think you get the point. You can't trust the MSM.
Watch Al Jazeera.@@meddown7035
Best
You can't tell oppressed people how to resist!!!
Free Palestine🇵🇸
In March 2019, Netanyahu told his Likud colleagues: “Anyone who wants to thwart the establishment of a Palestinian state has to support bolstering Hamas and transferring money to Hamas … This is part of our strategy”
- Benjamin Netanyahu told his Likud party’s Knesset members in March 2019
Woow 😮😮
@@rasyaadipratama651 In June 2007, during the Battle of Gaza between Hamas and Fatah, the US Ambassador to Israel quoted Israeli Defense Intelligence Chief, Amos Yadlin, in a memo later published by Wikileaks:
“Although not necessarily reflecting a GOI [government of Israel] consensus view, Yadlin said Israel would be “happy” if Hamas took over Gaza because the IDF could then deal with Gaza as a hostile state.” - Wikileaks (published in 2014)
they (Israel) felt tortured because they were hiding something they did in 7 October , namely the "HANNIBAL PROTOCOL". let's encourage them to talk things through. I think our brothers in Palestine are fed up with this slander, they have suffered too much
"A quote circulating on social media about Netanyahu and Hamas comes from a Haaretz hit piece on Netanyahu.
“’Anyone who wants to thwart the establishment of a Palestinian state has to support bolstering Hamas and transferring money to Hamas,’ he told a meeting of his Likud party’s Knesset members in March 2019. ‘This is part of our strategy-to isolate the Palestinians in Gaza from the Palestinians in the West Bank.’”
The actual source is supposedly the biography of Haim Ramon, who had not served in the government since 2009, and certainly not in the Likud.
Ramon, a leftist politician, had been convicted of sexual harassment, partially ending his political career. He certainly had not been a Likud member and was not attending any such meetings, raising serious credibility issues regarding the quote."
so basically The Jewish people moved to escape what has been happening to them for thousands of years to just go and do it to other people?
The Jewish diaspora wasnt a single entity that was from one geographic location nor did all of them have the same experiences.
There is documented evidence from aa far as the late 1800s where a Russian Jew had decried how his Middle Eastern Jewish counterparts were misstreating their Arab neighbours the same way the rest of Europe was treating its Jewish citizens.
One has to note the middle eastern Jews had not experienced the pogroms nor the later genocide like the European Jews had.
Nope
Yep
@@ahmedshawqi2090 nope habibi, we came back to our land.
@@Annabella_159by kicking everyone else out?
I'd suggest that Oct 7 was part of the plan too. Don't forget that Israel had multiple sources warning them the attack was on the way, and they did nothing to prevent it. Not only that, but the Gaza Border is supposed to be one of the most secure, most heavily surveilled in the world, the IDF is supposed to have the best counter terrorism training in the world, and the Iron Dome is supposed to be one of best missile defense systems in the world. They all failed on the same day.
Much like how Roosevelt failed to warn Hawaii that the attack on Pearl Harbor was coming, because it gave him a convenient excuse to join the war.
My thoughts exactly, only those with a brain who aren’t brainwashed know this!
Or just as likely they dismissed the attack. For every threat to national security theres 100 false flags
Particularly true seeing the reports coming out about how israel was aware of this attack well in advance, and in fact even FORCED the music festival to go on despite knowing the threat
@@CL-fg5ne Yeah, nothing suspicious there...
'Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity' - Hanlon's Razor
Also this is pure speculation, of which there is no evidence. On the contrary, the failure of Israel's multiple warning systems and the political laziness and incompetence that caused those failure have already been documented and investigated, and will be studied much more in the future. Suggesting that Netanyahu just allowed 7 October to happen because it provided him with a handy casus belli, massively underestimates the brutality of the 7 October attacks, and Hamas violence in general. Also it It lacks any understanding of Israeli history, or the generally unpleasant character and politics of Netanyahu. He didn't need those attacks for any further repression, he's been playing the long game. And if he wanted to bomb the shit out of Gaza he would have anyway., as he's done before...
I am new here. Y T thought I might like to see what you do. I have just spent much of the weekend watching your channel. Thank you, thank you for your very well researched and presented episodes. What a pleasure to watch. I am hooked! 💚☘️🇮🇪
This is what we meant that history didn't start on "October 7th".. thank you Johnny
Actually within that year itself a month before the Oct 7th attacks the 'Save the Children' foundation published a report stating 2023 was the deadliest year for Palestinian kids, with 2022 being the 2nd deadliest. The article is still online and is dated on 18th Sept 2023. But every1 is gonna turn a blind eye to that 🙄
I agree with you, history does not start on October 7th. Now, just for the sake of argument, when would you say the history of that land started?
@@83samueleit started when Jews started to occupy Palestine instead of going back to Europe
@@83samuelewe could go thousands of year back, many occupied the land, and many wars and brutalities occurred..but once the video recording times came, times with laws set in place to safeguard human rights and humanity (allegedly) we should ask, why are some countries paying for their occupation, and mistreatment of their counterparts and some not? Is it only when people of color are in question, we drag our feet to decide right from wrong?
@Kewlstorybro101 Thousands years back.... many occupied the land. Such a general answer you gave me, we both know that before that land was even called Palestine by the Romans in the first century or so, it was called Judea and for over 1000 years was the home of the Jews. Then, it was occupied by the Romans, and from there by other powers. It's no surprise that wherever you excavate in Israel, you find archaeological rests of the ancient Jewish nation and history. This is common knowledge. The only way for peace is to have a two states solution like it was proposed a number of times in the past and refused by the Arabs. But before any of this can happen, the Arabs need to stop hating the Jews and stop pretending that the Jewish people don't belong to that land.
Nice story but the end was not balanced. The Plalestinians deserve to have a State and feel safe too!
No
there are a lot of Arab and Palestinian countrys and there is only one Jewish country in the world!
@@carlosbenavides8786why no?
Palestinians are like the Zionists. Neither had a state.
Hundred percent
Netanyahu fun fact, was raised in Philadelphia and the former Prime Minister was raised in Wisconsin. I believe she was born there as well. My family is from the West Bank and a traces back to my great great grandfather and I was supposed to go visit right before the attacks with my mom a week prior Visa did not come in on time and now everything and Gazza, including my grandfathers homeland and my mom‘s neighborhood is ruined and I will never see it with her. I’ve never been there and she hasn’t been back since she was 16 when she had me,
Yasser Arafat was born in Egypt and died in France. Hamas leaders live in Qatar. So I don’t get your point.
Im sorry for your situation… i truly am. But if it wasn’t for the continual terror attacks against Israel, none of this would happen. Wish you guys could just learn to live in peace with Jews/Israel instead of putting Israel in the hyper-sensitive position of protecting its citizens vs. caring for the plight of non-citizens. Wish the whole world would appreciate that delicate balance. Wish the whole world would understand that Israel hates being in this position. That’s why it gave back Gaza to the Palestinians in 2005.
@@EiJaBlu239you might wish all that but your leaders don’t as laid out in this video. The citizens who have been stoking the fire by even building settlements on the land they “gave back” and in other areas today don’t wish that. If what’s happening now is justified by the “t… attacks” then those same actions are justified by the actions carried out by your state.
@@EiJaBlu239let’s not pretend they left the strip for peace. Your leaders have admitted that the other side had too many people. It would have been impossible to assimilate them into the state because then those who are now the vast majority would lose that advantage and you can’t have a democracy in an ethno state where the ethnicity could become a minority. Otherwise it’s no longer an ethno state.
@@EiJaBlu239take your hasbara elsewhere. The world no longer believes it.
You mean Benjamin Mileikowsky …
Impressive to see the straight face applied to the narration of one side. Well done mate.
As an African, I understand the pain that Jews around the world feel. Black people have been persecuted for centuries and continue to face persecution in their own continent by foreign corporations. However, establishing an exclusively Black state would be a grave mistake. On whose land would it be built? At whose expense? Such an action would likely ignite endless conflict. The United Nations made a significant error in supporting the creation of a state based on a single ethnicity, religion or language. That is not going to work under this sun.
The United Nations did not create this barbaric entity. Britain created it in 1948, when Syria and Palestine were under its authority during the British colonization of the Middle East. Then, after that, the United States assumed the responsibility of protecting this fragile entity untill this days.
The truth that the world do not wants to hear it " No force, whatever it may be, will be able to support this entity that will disappear one day".
free Palestine .. and viva Palestina from Algeria
@@Tanneche_Saidwell said sir
Really Isreal is a multi cultural democracy
Do you understand the pain of the Palestinians?
@@Wise__guy check the history..
as a Palestinian living in the West Bank, you did an amazing job explaining. Well done sir!!!
I'm surprised by how detailed and correct this video is.
please continue with your work. 👏👏👏
Bot
@@DaveIsALegendPeriod so anyone who disagree with you is a bot? how old are you ? 13?
@@DaveIsALegendPeriodare you confused son?
Stay safe…
@@kguehini it’s a bot
I gotta be honest and say that your historical stance on Palestine-Israel even when it wasn't mainstream was enough for me to really trust your coverage on other topics that I wasn't as informed on as this one. You've always passed the moral litmus test with this one and this video is no exception. Thank you, Johnny. Keep up the great work. And deep respects for taking these risks for the sake of objectivity and proper journalism. 🤜🤛
🙌🙌🙌
@@johnnyharris Hey Johnny why is that when you mention the initial war between Israel and those Arab states you don’t mention that this was after Israel’s right to exist as a nation was codified by the UN or that every single nation that bordered Israel declared war on them the very minute the British left?
Furthermore it’s also weird that you describe the six-day war as “Israel goes to war with their Arab neighbours”… Except that ignores that Egypt blatantly disregarded international law by preventing free passage to only Israeli maritime vessels, lining up their troops on the border with Israel (Ala Russia’s invasion of Ukraine), removing all of the UN elements from Egypt and doing all of this after Israel has made it clear that an attempt at preventing Israeli maritime vessels from their right to free passage under international law, will be seen as a casus belli.
It’s akin to you describing the Russia/Ukraine situation as “Ukraine went to war with Russia” as if they were somehow an eager participant in the conflict to begin with and not the victims of a planned act of violence in the form of a coordinated invasion attempt.
I’ll also go ahead and ask why you entirely gloss over the fact that Israel defeats Egypt by force, controls the Sinai Peninsula, and then just hands it right back to them? Is it possible that one of those countries at the time didn’t recognize the others right to basic existence (Egypt), and as such had no interest in recognizing the right of Israel and Israelis to the same international protections provided to every other nation on Earth?
It’s incredibly weird that when every state that surrounds Israel in 1948 declares war on them, and then the breaking of international law again by Egypt/Syria/Jordan/Lebanon in 1967 wasn’t “immoral” like you so emphatically state the Israeli settlers in Palestine are.
Would you also be willing to answer why you don’t ever acknowledge that the very first Arab country to recognize the BASE rights of Israel to exist would be Egypt themselves over 30 years after Israel was solidified as existing to the majority of the rest of the non-muslim world?
The international community has deemed invading your neighbours and refusing to accept their right to exist based upon your desire to religiously persecute and murder them all to be “immoral and illegal”.
Maybe your video should have touched on some of those things - had I known nothing or very little about the history of the conflicts there I would have come away from your video earnestly believing that Israel attacked their neighbours in 1948 and that once again in 1967 they just decided to “go to war with their Arab neighbours again”.
I enjoy your content typically, but when you try to address some of these capital M, Massive and capital V, Vast issues, such as in this one or your “How Europe stole the World” video (I know you and your team have seen the @ThePresentPast_ video discussing that videos issues therein), I think you and your team don’t properly engage with these sorts of grandiose subjects in the way that I believe you think that you are (earnest, academic, unbiased and entertaining).
Even as a brief example that applies to both videos: You demonstrate a clear and repetitive bias for both geographic tools like maps and numerical tools that allow you to ‘short-form’ not only the history of an event but moreover the morality of the event itself. It’s useful because it allows you to keep the content in digestible pieces that run from 20-40 minutes per subject and keep it entertaining. However the manner it which you elect to craft this ‘short-form’ is persistently biased and un-academic - I do believe you’re earnestly trying to balance these things, the directed bias feigned as neutrality, only makes it feel slightly less so.
@@SmallAndDisfiguredWhy don't you mention that the same UN resolutions calling for the establishment of Israel also call for the establishment of Palestine? Why don't you mention that the 1947 War was immediately preceded by the civil war between the people who would become Israelis and the Palestinians? Why do you act as if Israel stating under what conditions they'll go to war justifies a war? Why does Egypt massing troops at their own border after Israel says they want war make Egypt the aggressor?
It seems you're upset this video doesn't lead people to the conclusion you want. I actually thought it was slanted in Israel's favor for most of the video, so maybe it's fairly balanced after all.
@@SmallAndDisfigured No one blames you for winning the war, but massacring the aborigines is a crime against humanity.
@@SmallAndDisfigureddo you write this much for school or what? Get a life.
Very enlightening, thank you.
This was well done. When can we expect your full video on the ICJ? I feel this topic deserves greater attention. I hope you have the courage to venture further into it boldly.
Yes please. Let me know if you need help researching. I have some great sources on this and would be willing to go deep if it helps you make this sooner
Knowing Johnny, he's probably taking his time to get all the sources correct before he posts that
If you had a Christian faith, you would know that there is no “secular court” to hear this matter.
I always remember this story that my Father told me when he was Hiking in Northern India with my Aunty and 2 Israeli counterparts they had met, they somehow found out the news Rabin had been assassinated, and began screaming and crying in disbelief before saying “Any hope at Peace is Dead”.
And who knows, maybe BiBi was behind it.
@@trishalamb138 Of course he was. The last thing he wants is peace in the middle east.
@@alexandrasymeon5893 No, he doesn't want peace, He wants to bring Middle East to it's knees by ending the need of a Palestinian State and Normalizing relations with Saudi and UAE, so, that people forget about the Palestinian Suffering, and just Blindly support Izevil, and after sometime He, wants total Superiority and Control of Izevil over Middle East, that's why He encouraged Hamas, and even after Mossad had Intel that Hamas is going to launch a massive attack, on Izevil but Bibi
Allowed Hamas to launch it's attack So, that In the name of declaring war on Hamas, he could destroy the Entire Gaza Strip and resettle it through Illegal Israeli settlements, and removing 2.5 million Palestinians from their land, It was a well-made plan, but it backfires because Izevils couldn't bear 1,400 deaths under Bibi's regime, and Global Support for the state of Palestine increased, even in America, support for Palestinian State increased by 120% and the indiscriminate bombing on Gaza
And Killing of more than 27,000+ Palestinians 70% of them being women and Children encouraged more and more Americans to support a Ceasefire and an Independent Palestinian State, That's why I always Karma always pays off, Free Palestine! 🇵🇸
@@alexandrasymeon5893do destabilize and fragment his enemies?
@@javilo2797 Israel's goal is to exterminate the indigenous population of Palestine as the Final Solution. Does that remind you of anything?
This is an incredibly difficult subject that is either not reported on or is when it is, is very one-sided. I feel you gave a balanced and unbiased summary of the atrocities in Israel and Palestine.
This was very pro-israeli compared to truth, it's pretty much the same as what the Zionist history revision is taught in Israeli schools, except its toned down
it is not a difficult subject, its a subject that need to be spoken with courage. its an occupation that had british and UN support
@@dunaaratam Thank you. To call it "difficult, complex, or hard" is cope. 😢 shits sad.
@@dunaaratam occupation from whom? What sovereign county was there before Israel?
@@joshuamusch6485 the sovereignty of Palestinians people. and the sovereignty of Palestine state which israel violated. both nations have sovereignty based on UN law. if anyone palestine is not a state, then israel never a state. both of them are using UN recommendation.
if the law of the right to determine people sovereignty is used, then israel also never have any legal basis. palestenians are way more indigenous than any of those european refugee
Amazing video. One of my fav on this topic. Will support.
I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again, Netanyahu is the root of the whole conflict right now. He is quite literally doing what Emperor Palpatine did in the prequel movies.
I agree lol
This comment wins the thread
The Ideas of bebe, he is just a face of it!
He can be the fall guy, exonerate the rest of the Israelis but all Israelis will enjoy the fruits of his doing.
He rose to power because his lover assassinated Yitzhak Rabin
Thank you Johnny, it’s also important to bear in mind the corruption cases of Netanyahu, the business associated with colonial settlers developments, the nefarious judicial reform and the role of weapons industry and how it secures flows of cash moving into this conflict
as much as johnny harris tries to make it seem so, this is not about netanyahu. if there was not an israel the united states would create one. this is still palestinian land that must be returned to them. from the river to the sea.
@atoagej The Jewish people deserve to live you will not silence them. YOU WILL NOT WIN!. 😊
@@Peter-ge4ov any jew with a heart is anti-zionist. same goes for any other people. i know humans are unlikely to win and the genocide will likely be a “success”, but it is the moral duty of everyone to fight for the freedom of the palestinian people.
The Quran and The Bible it's clear that Jesus is in heaven. But when it comes to Mohammed it's unknown what happened to him after death. So if he is in hell whoever believes him and his religion are going to hell...right. Think Muslims...
@@Peter-ge4ovJews lived in peace in Palestine before the Zionist colonial project. When PAlestine is free, the true jewish locals will be free as well. Not the violent settlers from Europe, though, who need to be brought to justice and to lose their power.
Thank you Johnny Harris for having the courage to be unbiased and provide historical context
The issue is that the first few minutes of the video where he goes over the historical context actually is an extremely biased view of the history.
Unbiased 😂😂😂😂 Google "jaffa riots 1921" if you think the Palestinians are the victims who were thrown off their land for no reason. They have been trying to throw the jews out since the fall of the ottoman empire.
Yup I love Johnny but this has quite a lot of bias in this
And yes even though I'm an Israeli I'm also a pro peace activist in the region with probably better connections with Palestinians then most of the people commenting here
And this was very hard anti Israel telling of the regional history
@@תוםפיזז Oh I thought the opposite. I thought it went way too easy on Israel
@user-fs9xe9ls2o as it should be. From Bibi's (🤮) own lips, Israel has ALWAYS been the initiating aggressor in this conflict. It was intentional. Right from the start.
Your depth and detailing are very thought provoking and clear. Narrative neutral but open. Definitly raising certain eyebrows. Hoping you continue to track the story and dive deeper. Excited!
Thank you, Johnny. Almost no one has the courage to make a video like this.
what are you on abuot?
there are littalliy hundreads of psudo-history vidoes like this one online XD
@@meddown7035I think OP was meaning that not many people are willing to represent both sides of the conflict as it is pretty common nowadays to spew one sided information without taking into account the valid arguments of the other side.
This was a real, informative and honest report on the situation in the conflict. Great work Mr. Harris. Appreciate the work you do.
The moment you say it's a conflict, it's not honest. I am not blaming you. But whoever says it's a conflict, are wrong.
@@toufikhereandthereI assume you mean it's a genocide
@@hipgnosis533 Genocide, Occupation, Conquest.
Johnny has one of the best independent journalism - it's refreshing to see someone who hasn't been bought out yet.
@@SSGoatanksif you truly believe he’s independent you’re hilarious
My suspicion is confirmed. Next question is could Netanyahoo have fascilitated the Hamas attacks? I mean he has clearly been waiting for an opportunity to go all in.
At the minimum, he turned a blind eye to the 7 oct attacks - all with the goal of mobilizing the country into war.
Everything leading up to 7th October is very suspicious. The festival changed locations three times (and was placed closer to Gaza), it took Israel 6 hours to repell Hamas after the attack, and the hostage rescue missions with Apache helicopters and tanks that killed Hamas and hostages alike.
i saw in Telegram Channel in Israel of IDF soldiers saying they were forced to shot to everyone.
Look at the houses and cars, Hamas didn't have te weapons to do that.
It's called Hannibal Directive
Can’t have Jews without
Someone claiming a Jew conspiracy.
@@gogotrapx9339dude even made up fan fiction to create a name for the conspiracy
Automatically Guilty: When asking someone to turn off the camera.
It's unreal how after a week of the attack in Israel, documents came out exposing how Netanyahu and his intelligent fully knew about an incoming attack, a report from Egypt and the US intelligence. Yet, the guy chose to ignore it, hoping a conflict would arise to save his reputation and potential to be jailed for corruption....
Read that spotters along the border to Gaza spotted the attack coming but as they were women and their superiors took them more lightly they were not so prepared
Right - and the CIA knew the planes were going to hit the towers and rigged the explosives themselves all to engineer 9/11 so they could gain the money needed to invade the Middle East. Why else would thousands of Jews not show up for work that day - they had been warned.
The lunatic fringe conspiracy theories like those around 9/11 are exactly the same as the ones around October 7. Terrorists are evil, and pretending their violence was really somebody else just does their work for them.
"a matter of internal security - the age-old cry of the oppressor" ~Captain Jean-Luc Picard
this quote always finds a way to remain relevant
In its current situation Israel only produces "security" as long as it can excersise overwhelming military force.
It is folly to think that a state can continue such a status quo indefinetly.
"From 2008 until 6 October 2023, 1,434 Palestinian children were reportedly killed, with an additional 32,175 sustaining injuries, primarily at the hands of Israeli occupation forces. Of these, 1,025 children were killed in Gaza alone, since the unlawful blockade began in 2007." - UN Human Rights, ‘Unchilded’ from birth: UN expert calls for decisive protection of Palestinian children under Israeli rule, 24 October 2023
That is why it is an illegitimate entity. Its “security” is contingent on the genocide of others.
Sadly true. But Israel has made long-standing peace with Egypt, Jordan. And more recently in the Abraham Accords normalised relations with UAE, Bahrain, Morroco, and Sudan.
And there would have been a peace deal with Saudi Arabia already if it was for the October 7th Hamas attack derailing those talks which were happening a few months ago.
Indeed it seems that Netanyahu and his government are (perhaps slowly, but faster than ever before in my adult life) losing support internationally. Videos like this, and the availability of information at our fingertips in general today make it easier to understand his warmongering intent and actions. It's become an endless stream of heart-rending news for both the Israeli people and Palestinians.
some people never really learn anything from history.
Love your quality work. So balanced and informative. Thank you
As an outsider who has been watching conflicts in Israel since I was a little kid in the 1960's I have to applaud you for shedding light on an old problem. I'm not sure if peace will ever happen in that region because every time a decision is made there are some who are opposed and willing to use violence to reach their objectives. It only gets worse.
I learned a long time ago. The best solution to conflict resolution is one where all parties are not happy with. Sadly both parties are unwilling to reach a compromise which is why I agree with you that there may never be peace in the region
Do you call it a "conflict between naz-s and jews"?
Everything is wrong in this video.
The cable he refers to in the beginning makes clear that Mr Yadlin regarded Hamas in power in Gaza as an outcome as preferable to a situation in which Israel had "to deal with Hamas as a non-state actor".
Hamas has been clandestine before being in power in Gaza, they were hidden amongst civilians. So for them to be a mini-state was easier to deal with for Israel, than a group mingling amongst Palestinian and Israeli civilians!
This video them wants to make the viewer think Palestine was a real country during its British rule. It wasnt an independent Arab state from 1917 - 1947, it was British and Arabs never called themselves Palestinian until the 1960s when terrorist Arafat started to use it.
The (British) Palestine Philharmonic Orchestra of the 1940s was all Jews! The Arab farmers had no idea what a violin or trombone was ! Let alone play them in an orchestra.
At 5:11 he says "Arabs would have to move to their side of the line".
No, the 1947 UN Partition plan did not require any moving. But the Arabs rejected the plan because they wanted to stop Israel forming since it was a state to take care of Jews! They declared war on the newly formed Israel in 1948 with the stated goal of "throwing Jews into the sea". They lost, many Arabs fled! Some forced out. Tens of thousands of Jews were also forced out of Jerusalem by the Jordanian army.
mark my words..there will be peace there and the muslims will control it..
This video is terribly misleading at the time the jews moved to this claimed land it wasn't even called Palestine, and there have always been Jewish settlers there before the jews thought of creating a state of theirs
Great video bro. Not only did you present it in a great way, but also anyone who tries to deny this video is gonna make a fool out of themselves 😂
Exactly. I was hoping he’d address issues like the oct 7 attack and how the breach even happened but it wouldn’t have been productive at all. That being said, netenyahu wanted it to happen.
@@HamBone123456789ten I suspect that Netanyahu's close supporters were also behind the assassination of Yitzhak Rabin. The Russian government murders its enemies, and history is full of similar examples,so that sort of thing is not unprecedented
Cool story bro but... If Hamas wins: "United Middle East", no democracy in the region, & Islamic extremists emboldened to take over the world and force Sharia law onto it as their "religious destiny" - SO I MUST SIDE WITH ISRAEL.
Israel is in the right. God gave them that land. Get over your terrorist sympathies.
@@godwarrior3403 'God gave them that land', you claim? Thanks, it's nice to know that in 1917 us British people were declared to be God.
As someone who just spent a month in Gaza as part of the limited humanitarian response there, I want to thank you for the work you have done here. The individual responsibilities of the October 7th atrocities do indeed primarily lie with those who have committed them and with those who have planned them. But as it seemingly always is the case, it is now being used to legitimize war crimes committed against 2 million people, including children who, by definition are not Hamas. And taking more land in the West Bank, as always.
So thanks again for calmly bringing up all this.
Hamas is the government of Gaza. 3000 gazans participated in the massacre. The idf does more to prevent civilian casualties than any other military. Israel builds bomb shelters for its civilians. Hamas created a network of tunnels to ensure an Iranian lead invasion of Israel, those same tunnels could have been used to shelter every civilian instead they used them to torture grape and mu rder hostages. There is no moral comparison here. Like Golda said, we can forgive you for killing our children we will never forgive you for forcing us to kill yours. We will have peace when you value the lives of your children more than you hate ours.
@@nicci337 What tunnels? Where are they? I saw the NY ones, still waiting to see the Palestinian ones. The one that the IDF did "discover" was actually made by Israelis before they got their troops out of Gaza, as admitted by an Israeli official on live CNN.
@@nicci337The IDF implemented the Hannibal directive on Oct 7th.
@nicci337 If Israel really cares about civilian lives, why do they bomb residential buildings, hospitals, mosques, and churches. We know hamas liberation fighters are not there, they are underground in the tunnels as you have mentioned.
@nicci337 You say that yet there's no war in modern history that has killed 23k civilians in 3 months.
Wonderfully put. Thank you Johnny.
I’m so glad people like you are around to speak the truth. God bless you Johnny.
What truth?
Half of the history he presented was false.
Harris gets basic facts wrong, in about every video he makes.
Thank you for reporting on this - I definitely have my own thoughts and opinions on the matter as an outsider, but uncovering and reporting on the leaked documents and videos gives us all insights and perspectives that aren't often considered.
Just thinking now based on land geography How is it isreal is europe and PALESTINE Asia doesn’t make any sense
Just thinking now based on land geography How is it isreal is europe and PALESTINE Asia doesn’t make any sense
As an Israeli, who has been servicing in reserve since the start of this war, I have to approve the overall message of this video.
I also appreciate the separation between Bibi and the Israeli people, and would also like to see a deeper dive into the staunch opposition of a lot of the Israelis against him, if you ever cover Netanyahu in the future.
His controversial strategy proved to be a failure and so is the right winged government he formed, unfortunately, many of us knew this. Hopefully, we'll be able to throw him out soon and figure out a way towards a new future.
Israel wouldn't exist today without Bibi.
It seems like it has been a trend that anytime Bibi loses favor or becoming unpopular, then suddenly Israel tends to have conflicts other nations or is attacked... It really beats my mind
Do you honestly believe as an Israeli that what is happening currently now is "self defense" ?
If I had to pick the one person most responsible for an increase in global anti-semitism Netanyahu is surely head & shoulders above anyone else, or even any group of people.
But it's never one just one person... the real power/blame is with those who keep voting for that one person. Same with Trump.
Your people elected the monster. You only have yourself to blame for the failure of the Israeli state. Insha Allah.
Excellently delivered, clarity and accuracy are your strong points.
As Middle Eastern And Egyptian I 've always been frustrated about how people don't see this truth or just choose to ignore it. Both Hamas an Israel rely on each other to exist and to get funds. Shout out to you for covering such sensitive topic. My respect 👏👏👏
Al-Sissi is a puppet of Israel.
as an Egyptian you should tell them about the Treaty of al-Hudaybiya. tell them how all those firearms got into gaza. tell them what Islam is truly about.
@DanielinAction Your comment is confusing in English. otherwise, you made it confusing to share a double message . Can you explain what the treaty is all about?
@@DanielinAction
I am not muslim so I don’t know what are you talking about. However I don’t support Hamas actions nor IDF actions. Innocent civilians on both sides pay the price of actions made by corrupted politicians to gain wealth and power. Also, you should know that Hamas is not Gaza and doesn’t represent all Gazans. What the IDF is doing right now is a mass punishment.
it seems more like you have no idea what islam "is truly about" maybe share some of the verses fox news shoved into your head so I can debunk the bs in 20 seconds lmfao@@DanielinAction
From, "Please, Palestinian. Give us lands." to "Palestinian can't have this land, not even a portion."
you dont know what you are talking about - educate yourself.
they are forever victims and predators.
@@JfK--OBJECTivE Conquering/genocidal actions against the Palestinian people are clearly visible. wdym?
Jews bought land from the British.
Where the f did you learn this self-serving history
Palestinians never owned this land, that region was constantly conquered till the British Empire decided to leave and give it back to Jews and Arabs that lived there already
I am by far no expert on this all I can say is I was in Israel and in Palestine and seeing with my own eyes what the Israeli government does to the people there really made my stomach drop. I met the most impressive, honest and resilient people I have ever seen there.
You need to ask yourself why Israel treats the way it does, before 2003 the borders were open, no major checkpoints no walls, than the arabs took advantage of it and made terror attacks, suicide bombing, stabbing victims, shootings
Did you get to visit Hebron? If so, did you see that giant metal fence ceiling built by Palestinians above their streets and stores because the Israel settlers living above them kept throwing trash and bottles of piss on them?
'most impressive, honest' , not sure I agree with that. 'Resilient' sure. They don't know when to give up. Israel is the only country in the middle east with a functioning government and diversified economy. Without oil, all the other countries there would be a wasteland. Give some credit to Israelis.
@@alanjacob1488you’re embarrassing yourself
@@alanjacob1488algeria was conquered by france 150 years algeria fight to kicked out france and they succed
Thank you for providing a bit of clarity in all the noise.
Ask Netanyahu about delivering bags of cash to Hamas Hq in the back of his bulletproof Audi on Sunday mornings.
I asked him.... The truth is that according to the Oslo agreement, Israel collects the Palestinian tax on imported products at the Israeli port and every month it transfers the amount to Ramallah.
In 2006, Hamas was elected to power in Gaza (and no elections have been held since then, nor in the PA). Then the PA transferred half of the tax collection to Gaza.
Because of internal conflicts, the Palestinian Authority stopped transferring half of the collection to Hamas. To prevent an economic collapse at the expense of the citizens of Gaza, Israel agreed that Qatar would transfer an average of the tax value each month - which is around 30 million dollars per month. This is neither Israeli nor Palestinian money, only Qatari money that replaces the PA money. Israel made sure to keep the Oslo agreement, even though both the Hamas and the PA repeatedly violated it.
But beyond the Qatari money, the European Union, and some European states, America and Iran transferred hundreds of millions of dollars a month to Hamas. The Qatari money was negligible. And it is these "humanitarian" donations that allowed Hamas to purchase weapons through Egypt and receive weapons that Iran sent from its own money. That's why whoever got hung up on the Qatari money will see that his claim will not last long and it will fall quickly.
@@Salamwamat🔥🔥🔥
@@Salamwamatsorry to sound stupid but what is the PA
@@zorrow_Palestinians
@@wevibin6504 ty
Thanks for making this informative video! I appreciate you being, nuanced, thoughtful, and minimally biased.
Not so minimally , actually
This is a nasty and dishonest way of depicting this conflict. His painting Hamas as an ally of the Zionists
Actually he is pretty biased. Netanyahu wasnt president in the 2nd Intafada
@@stardekk1461 Not president Netanyahu to like Mafia Terrorism israel
Hedidnt say that he was, he said that it paved path for him didnt he?
Minutes into it and i´m surprise by the guts and factual research you were able to share it with the public. Carry on
Carry on revising history. Let’s just ignore the centuries of ottoman rule, and the centuries under Moore imperialists that wanted to conquer France. Let’s ignore millions massacred by the Palestinians, in favor of 20,000. Let’s ignore countless peace offers with accurate land appraisals.
@@zachdave2994Arabs have been living there for centuries older than jews
@@zachdave2994Which millions?Israel had always been responsible for more deaths...
Due to YT censorship,I'll put it here...it's the Turks that were responsible for the Armenian genocide...you are actually misquoting facts
Also,let's ignore that many groups have been moved way after jews were exiled from the middle east and they will never go back...let's ignore that if you buy land and someone says...it was mine 300 years ago,you wouldn't give it back...forget a 1000 years....let's ignore that with ancient Kingdoms,their rules were different from ours....let's ignore that there are more than 300M bantu Africans living in east and south africa but 3000-6000 years ago,their ancestors were in West and Central Africa but west and Central Africa isn't their home...instead,east and south africa is...by rules of their time,they made where they live their home and it would take a literal war to move them today
@@faithkerubo8357 Not if you count the millions that died by the hands of Palestinians in the very same region no later than 29 years before Israel existed. The IDF has been far less brutal to civilians, yet here we are with most people still supporting the other side. Yet here we are with many comparing the IDF conduct to the worst humanity has ever done. Your side is infected with ahistorical falsehoods and moral obfuscations.
Thanks to tell us about NEBULA ! 👍👏👏
This is an angle to the conflict that is not talked about enough. Thank you for this well-researched video!
This was always very clear to me because I’ve read on the topic. I suggest everyone else treats every mainstream headline and news story with utter contempt because they are lying to you
As an Israeli, The video is full of half-truths and twisting the truth to fit the narrative he wants to present. For him, harming the right-wing government currently in Israel is great, and this is exactly what he is doing...
@@natalie_milo Lot of people like you in the comments. Instead of gesturing to some bias or half truth, demonstrate it. Other people here have tried and ended up being the ones spreading misinformation
@@natalie_milo Sorry what are the so called "Half Truths" Lets play this out
Thank you for your continued efforts to bring context to global conflicts! I am surprised and happy to see that all comments agree with your summary and perspectives. Well done, sir! Please keep up the good work 🫶
21:19 "there is no excuse or justification for their actions" man the whole video is full of excuses and justifications, armed struggle is supported by international law against occupation.
@@abdoudrk8528 except for the fact that Hamas just committed some war crimes by deliberately bombing civilians and their homes. so yes there is no justification for the bombings on civilians
@@fractational the reason discourse on this conflict is so annoying and polarising is because both sides have for decades done horrific, illegal, immoral things to the other side and sometimes their own (often constituting literal genocide), citing the last time they got it done to them as justification. it's a never ending circle of stupidity and the real victims are the average people caught in the middle of it, and both sides leadership seem more than willing to use those civilians as pawns.
P.S for the guy you were replying to, an explanation is not inherently an excuse.
@@abdoudrk8528I don’t believe his video is a justification for what’s happening, instead it’s background knowledge to help you understand what’s lead to this
@@danielmacpherson8487 a conclusion can be dirived from an explanation , in this case the conclusion is simple : invaders from europe came as refugees to palestine because hitler drove them out, then they turned against the people that welcomed them, and genocided them and keep doing so just to do a land grab, with the help and blessing of the "democratic" west from the begining of the conflict to this day, it's genocide it's not complicated.
The way you worded it so perfectly: The objective of Israel was to live in a safe space, and Netanyahu's conquest of land has done the exact opposite.
Not really. Israel was created from a zi0nsit project/movement with the objective of creating a jewish ethno state. In order to fulfill this agenda, conquest of land and removal or non-jews was needed. And it didnt start with just Netanyahu, but from Israels earlier leaders in the late 1940s.
As long as Netanyahu plays his mind games on Gaza & Hamas like Chess Board there's no peace or safety.
It’s quite ironic to realize they only created a huge prison for themselves. Israel is surrounded by walls and enemies everywhere. The number is only increasing.
@@anDar8708bs misinformation, they never once said “remove non Jews from the country”
@@jordanwilliams2557they quite literally undermined non jewish folk since day one. the original settlers tried to maintain no reliance on arab labor in favor of being only dependent on jewish labor
The proposal for Jews to feel safe somewhere is good however it does not have to come at the expense of other people. In a modern world the need for a separate state for Jews to feel safe is no longer necessary anyway
It's definitely necessary, seeing as the jews have always been persecuted wherever they have been scattered. The Arabs have many nations to call home, the jews only have one.
this conflict is quite literally living proof that they do need a separate state, most of the arab world hates the idea of a jewish state and have attempted multiple times to destroy israel.
Exactly especially when they own america and co, they already have an safe haven..
The last part is exactly what we thought in the 30's in europe.
I'm constantly amazed at the short sightedness
@@Orion216not at all stop your drop that pompous know it all attitude especially when what u makes no sense
Thanks for the video. Really brave of you to tackle this topic knowing how many creators got cancelled and silenced trying to do the same
Silenced for being pro Palestine? Yea right
@@dtoad5576yeah. He IS right. It IS happening.
Interesting. I've heard many different takes on this conflict, but it never crossed my mind that Hamas could actually be beneficial for Netanyahu, as it lowers the probability of stable united Palestinian government.
as if the probabilityof a stable united palestinian government wasn't low enough
This was literally the most obvious thing ever
Doubt he could make them any more unstable even if he tried
Unfortunately for people most don't understand this
@@houseplant1016 exactly! As much as the far right denies it, they are in bed with the terrorists because each other justifies one another's existence
Thank you for your transparent and independent journalism!!!!
free palestine
MASSIVE well done Johnny. I studied journalism and the Middle Eastern Studies and this piece is spot on, in terms of accuracy, balance, tone, videography and most important of all, insight, and by that I mean the ability to delve into the nitty gritty details but still able to look at the developments over the past decades from a high-level perspective. This is an extremely complicated subject and you've absolutely nailed it. I sincerely hope this video gets the clicks it deserves.
I don't believe he nailed it, you're more than welcome to read my comments to him below
Buddy you should keep studding, when you call hams a militant group...
@@EyalBenZeev Netanyahu is indeed the mastermind behind this conflict. because the Palestinian and Israeli people both want peace.
How could Hamas' movement on October 7 escape Israeli intelligence monitoring?
even though Israel has the best military strength and spy intelligence in the world. this is the fact
Surely Netanyahu already knows that Hamas will attack on October 7. He didn't stop it because he would use it as an excuse to expel and eliminate the people of Gaza.
How is it possible that Israeli intelligence cannot know about Hamas movements in Gaza which is only tens of kilometers from the Israeli border???
Can anyone answer 😆😆
I think he actually shows bias in this piece. A line that really stuck out to me was something like, “and every few years you fire a couple rockets at us”. That really downplayed the number of rocket and mortar attacks.
Why would anyone want to waste time on hasbara propaganda...@@EyalBenZeev
This is why I fell in love with your journalism, reporting on the truth with guts. Thank you for educating us all on this situation.
This is not journalism it’s investigative opinion.
If your leaning on this piece to illuminate what's going on, may I please advise you to seek out many more sources, from both sides,,read the history, understand the faiths and practices that drive the attitudes and direct the actions and policy in this conflict that has endured many many hundreds of years. Jonny does not sum it all up, and it's so millenail to thing he can wrap a tidy little bow on this 20 minute opinion piece and call it fact.
@@ThemanofkickbuttJust because you don't like the facts presented to you, doesn't mean it's not journalism my friend.
It's biased left-wing journalism. You can look through a story through one lens thinking its facts and still don't understand the full picture. @@Ty-dk2sj
@@colinl1980@colinl1980 He has already done the research into the sources and this video is a good evidence of that. And I agree although it is not possible to cover the entire history in 20 mins, it was a great attempt. Great work by Jhonny 👏
Wow Johnny! This is real good research and in-depth. Bravo on tackling one of the most mischaracterized conflicts in the recent times. I really can't stress how you get right. You even portray the most subtle but important details like what compelled Rabin to agree to the OSLO accord. Rabin, as with most rational people, understood that the continuation of the occupation of Palestinians would never lead to the long promised security and safety for the Jewish people. It was a conclusion that was absolutely obvious to him. Thus, he did not agree to the OSLO accords due to benevolence towards the Palestinians as many have erroneously suggest.
It is also great that you show that Benjamin Netanyahu has been actively supporting Hamas because it created a pretext to continue to occupy Gaza and the West-Bank. We so often hear that the Palestinians are to blame for their plight, that they refused to agree to a peaceful resolution to the conflict when the facts show that it is the leaders of Israel (i.e. Netanyahu and his cabinet over the years) that actively tried to sabotage any attempt at peace at every step of the way. This is backed up by the video evidence you present and by Neo-historical works done by Norm Finklestein and Ilan Pape and countless other works. I can't stress how frustrating it is to hear the same lies be repeated that only Palestinians are to blame for the genocidal violence that is currently going on today and has been going on a yearly basis whenever Israel decided to "Mow the lawn."
In short, this video is so good that I will be using it in an ethics course I teach in College. It is fair, unbiased, historically accurate and humanizes the oppressed while not resorting to villainizing the many Israeli citizens that are simply not aware of the true historical facts. If you are interested in maps, I strongly suggest you try and get a copy of the current and previous text books used in Israeli primary and secondary schools. It is outstanding how inaccurate they are only to reinforce a narrative that justify the colonization of a land that started in 1948.
GREAT JOB!!!
Thank you for reporting this!
As a gazan i could confirm the accuracy of this video we just want peace but i guess that's a big price to ask for
stay strong brother ! You are always in our prayers 😢❤❤
@@abdullahjalal27 thanks, all love
Stay strong brother 💪 🙏
@@verros03 thanks
I can't do much from where I am, but I'll keep trying to spread the word about what's going on and I'll pray for an end to all of this.
This is an incredible video. Thank you for your work and sharing this history. I hope it reaches the people who need it.
We either learn to share this land, or share the land beneath it.
Damn. Put that on a T-shirt. Brilliant
well Palestinian bodies are being dug out and organs stolen
That's a really good quote. Did you make it or did you hear it somewhere? Very powerful
Israel wants to share, but Palestinians want all hence - From The River To The Sea.
@@rees5714then why does israel continue to vote no on a two state solution proposed by the UN for decades now?
All your videos are awesome keep it up
Thank you, Johnny. I wish more people think this way.
There is no doubt, Netanyahu is one of the biggest obstacle to peace between Israel and Palestine
Only slightly overshadowed by the mass Palestinian support for turning humanitarian aid into rockets and like, the complete refusal to negotiate at all despite having no position to make demands.
@@vyvianalcott1681something a zionist would say
@@vyvianalcott1681 Hasbara Talking points.
joking 😂
@@nagalon7255 it's difficult to justify stealing, lying and bullying the weak, n think of it as their right, but these guys do it openly, it's impressive really
I do not know much about the terrain there in Israel/Palestine but dividing the Palestine fraction into three separate enclaves look like a formula for failure from the start.
💯💯💯
That probably because the separation is from de facto occupation post-war, which making eclaves is ensuring strategic locations for defending.
I do think israeli is unfair for double-dipping in both old land ownership claims (which some are questionable) from purchase and de facto war occupations. Also by building housing immediately and offer it for free to immgrant jews.
For jokes, look up Trumps 2-state proposal. The UN plan will instantly appear to be totally rational compared to his.
@@fltfathin Either way, we've been migrating legally to Palestine since 1840. Our state was created democratically, and we're not going to give it up. Should the Arab colonizers be unhappy, they can return to Arabia.
almost like it was the zionist plan from the start.
Amazing reporting! Thank you!
Netanyahu's brother was killed in the Entebbe mission in 1976 and that's when he entered political activism. I was there as a Christian pilgrim in 1976 and in Jerusalem Arabs took me in and were good to me. This Gaza war is breaking my heart and I hope that the many friends I made over there, both Jew and Arab, are safe and well. Personally, Zionism makes me sick, totally racist.
Thank you for saying how present day Zionism is sickening and people who don't support it are NOT anti- semitic
Excellent essay on a difficult topic. It was neutral and as unbiased as humanly possible. It included hugely important factual events and development often ignored. A+
Wanting peace during conquest doesn't add up
So ... why did the "palestinians" offer their FEALTY to HITLER during WWII ..?
Channeling animus they'd eventually find a reason to justify hating ze Jews?
Why is their animus with Jews then, and not just Israelis ..? No? No ideas..?
Why'd they reject two-states on _no less than 5 occasions_ ..? LOOK. IT. UP.
Correction : Its not conflict, its 75 years of illegal occupation and genocide* - Free Palestine
It is 75 years of two groups of people fighting for the same land so they can have their right to be safe.
To me learn about one history you understand their truth and are on there said but learn about the other side and the same happens. 😢
So, occupation is when a country invades another country and occupies it. What country did Jews come from with the army ?
Exactly ! UN decided to give Jews the land. If you don’t like it, sue the United Nations
The Jews have been there for 3000 years while muslims only 1400. So who are the colonisers
@@bob1234881you are literally spreading misinformation and criticizing the very same thing
@@deepaksayee3414”the Muslims”?? I’m sorry I did not realize all Palestinians are Muslims
I love how the word "terrorist" is strictly exclusive to Arabs lol
It’s not though is it mate, the IRA were a prescribed terrorist organisation for years. The reason why you hear so much about Islamic terror because there are countless Islamic terror grouos across the globe who commit atrocities on a regular basis then play victim.
We call it the “double standard” Welcome to the world. The world is a double standard.
Its not and a 30 sec google search proves it. But its true that in the last decades the most violent terrorist acts where done by muslim extremist groups.
the "war on terror" was always a dogwhistle for anti Islamic genocide.
Nope Israel is full of em
Free Palestine from Israeli occupation
💜
Who don’t know this fakelstine thing this never was a thing and never will be why those the Arab countries that control Israel before British didn’t give the land to the fake people yes because never was a thing called like that
Think that this is my first comment on your channel, by the way, I've been watching your videos for about 4 yrs now. I sometimes disagree with your take on some issues, but as an African, I must thank you for making this video. The presentation, the courage, and details- SUPERB.
Thank you for posting/making this video.