Their performance of Kashmir is epic during their 2007 Celebration Day. This concert holds the worlds record for the highest demand for tickets for one single concert...there were about 18,000+ tickets but had 20 MILLION requests for tickets.
With 70's music, it's less important to know what the songwriter was writing about than it is to feel where the song is taking you. This song is a journey, and only you can know where you'll end up.
This is Zeppelin’s favorite of their catalogue, according to the three living members. All songs are their children, but this one meant something special, especially to Robert and Jimmy, who were inspired by a journey across the desert in Morocco. Robert was almost in a trance on that long drive and endless horizons, and those mystical thoughts came to him. Read the lyrics…it’s poetry and pretty deep. Nothing to do with Kashmir, which is in the Himalayas, but that name evokes mystery and the exotic, so it’s well used here.
@@CosmicVagabondPixie completely understand. He was dealing with profound subject matter..,,speaking of Time, Fate, life’s journey……creativity and it’s mystery…..is his life preordained, or is he a free agent? Is there a higher power? Plant is a spiritual man, and has deep thoughts….which, as a hugely private person, he keeps hidden away most of the time, I think. Two sets of lyrics from this song I think reveal allot. The first is: Oh, Pilot of the storm who leaves no trace Like thoughts inside a dream He has spoken of his mind as a “ceaseless roar”…(Ifvyou know his album Lullaby and The Ceaseless Roar….it refers to this)…so I’m thinking he might be using a storm as a similar metaphor . He refers to a pilot of the storm….(a higher power? His creative spark?) who leaves no trace…. Where does creativity come from? Thoughts inside a dream? It’s a mystery…..no one really knows. And the other lyric that really gets me is: oh, Father of the Four Winds, fill my sails across the sea of years With no provision but an open face Along the straits of fear This can be interpreted almost like a prayer, although I don’t think he meant it that way. But he is asking for the wind to be at his back as he goes forward. I’ve heard him speak of being very conscious of Time…,and life as a journey that one set out on….unknowingly ..,…trusting in Fate, or luck. He keeps on “open face”….open to new experience, embracing change, always seeking, restless. That has been his gift and his burden. And he speaks of the “Straits of Fear”. He asks for the “Pilot” to be with him across the years, and also with him through times of fear. I almost tear up when I hear these lyrics, because we all know what he would face so soon after he penned those lyrics. So yeah…I can see why this song might scare him : Where did those lyrics come from…..and were they prescient? He is grappling with great mysteries here……as he continues to do……very aware of his mortality….very aware of the richness and beauty of life, and of its losses. perhaps those lyrics are the closest to his heart of any that he has written …..and give us a glimpse of the soul of the man behind the public facade…..especially the facade of the “golden god” that was his public persona at that time.
@@mogheanil actually no. You were probably not alive then, or at least not an adult like myself. “Kashmir” was seen in the late 60’s as a physical representation of the mystical land of Shangri-La ) google if don’t know reference). A legendary land of surreal beauty and enchantment. Many “hippies”, who had the time and money, made pilgrimages to Kashmir to seek spiritual truths. And most of us who listened to this song knew what they were evoking by using that title. And the lyrics that Plant wrote bear that out: Those lyrics speak of a mystical metaphorical journey to “the elders of s gentle race”…where he discovered that “the meaning was quite clear”. Read the lyrics with this in mind, if you care to. And you will see that the song was perfectly named to describe what they were trying to evoke: not the physical country of Kashmir, but the ineffable mystery of Shangri-La ……. And spiritual knowing. And if you really care to understand, read my comment above about the meaning of the song. I’m betting you won’t 😉
@@helenespaulding7562 yeah u r right even beatles came to india in d late 60s. many prominent figures have come here to seek spiritual enlightment. but back then kashmir was safe, ppl from my family (my uncle n his american wife went there to see the beautiful lakes & apple, pomegranate orchids. Sometime in the 80s ussr invaded afghanistan and terrorism in the region started cos america retaliated and armed these jihadis. kashmir isnt just beautiful but has geographically significance which is why its so important india china pak. the reason u gave is d real reason & not the trip to morocco which many have been saying here in the comments
This is the song that introduced me to Led Zeppelin and made me a Led head for years , it was my first step into “ hard rock” and I never looked back ❤❤
I'm 71 and got to see them twice in the early 70's. Phil, you got it 100% right. If you younger people want to know how it hit us at the time, always go with studio versions, with a few exceptions.
The Knebworth version is great but to see them own the stage in the Celebration Day version is fantastic! I know it's not John but the other Bonham killed that performance!
This song is one of Led Zeppelin’s favorite Led Zeppelin songs 🔥 The band likes it much better than Stairway To Heaven. I’m glad you did the studio version first 👍
"Mothership" is a greatest hits album for Led Zeppelin. "Immigrant Song" is on "Led Zeppelin 3" "Kashmir" is on the double album entitled "Physical Graffiti".
It couldn’t be produced in 2024 , because there is no one talented enough toddy , to have the ability to go into the studio & come out with something like this
I think that often about most music from that time. No way you’d get anything close to a Zeppelin, Boston, The Who, Styx, Rush, etc. The 70s-80s had the best imo.
I was fortunate to see Robert & Jimmy perform this with the Houston Philharmonic Orchestra, can't recall the year! The members of the Orchestra were very enthusiastic in the performance. With great respect for them both. It was very emotional, hell yeah.
Sam, The cover is the same because it’s a compilation album of their most famous and beloved songs This song is from 1975. Immigrant song was on Zeppelin III, released in 1970
Recorded in 74, released in 75. Jones melatron plus some brass and strings tastefully arranged by Jonesy. Live he replicates most of it with melatron. But all four members shine on it and band has long considered this, not stairway or whole lotta love as their definitive work. Achilles Last Stand is another Zepic you need to check out. Stay with the studio and then live format.
The celebration day version of this is (2007) is the absolute best 👌 definitely DEFINITELY check that out! Also proves how much they still have the talent after so many years. John Bonham's son plays the drums and is phenomenal!
My favorite Zeppelin song - please react to the live version in 2007 - Live at Celebration Day - you get to hear Plant still belt it out and John Bonham's son, Jason kill it on the drums
Great fun guys... I grew up in the 70s and got a little burned out of Zep (especially Stairway) but this i can listen to all the time 😊 The live version with strings is EPIC!! Can you imagine as a violinist getting the call to join LZ on stage? 😮
I will always remember this track and intro being used in RATM - Wake Up (Matrix ending credits) and Puff Daddy - Come With Me (Godzilla movie). My favorites LZ songs are Whole Lotta Love, Immigrant Song (also Kasabian - Days Are Forgotten reminds me that song) and D'yer Mak'er (because of Sheryl Crow's cover). Love your BabyMetal journey so please don't stop and come back for more.🦊🤘🔥
Live version from CELEBRATION DAY Concert is the one to do. Their first concert in almost 30 after Jon passed away. Jon's son is the drummer. Plant's voice is amazing at age 70. He didn't lose a thing. Millions people tried to get tickets for the concert.
Used to hear this on the radio but never knew who sang it. Took me YEARS to find it. Every time it would play, the DJ never said the name. Finally heard it again one day and got wise and called the radio station to ask. He told me the name, I run down to Sam Goody and start looking through all the Zeppelin albums. ...and I can't find it. WTF? The guy said "Cashmere" It's not on any of these!! True story. Anyway, bought Physical Graffiti as he said it was on that album and later figured out my blunder. One of the first CDs I ever bought too.
This kind of thing always happened to me in the 70s. I hardly ever knew what band did what song. It didn't change until I got old enough to afford to buy albums.
Have to see the live version from celebration day. Not often the live is bey than the studio IMO but this is that occasion, I don't think you'll be disappointed.
I read in one of the many books about Zeppelin that yes there was a mellotron used for the strings. But also the Calcutta National Orchestra played on the track as well. They played the string arrangement written by John Paul Jones, and he conducted the orchestra when they recorded their part.
Thanks for doing the studio version first. That's almost always preferred, but there are some rare exceptions. Do You Feel Like We Do from Frampton Comes Alive comes to mind, as does Bob Seger's Turn The Page . . .
This song is about Plant & Page driving through the Sahara Desert, on their way to Morocco, for a music festival. None of the band members had been to Kashmir, it’s the song the band members are most proud of. Plant fell in love with Morocco, & still visits often to this day. The people there seem like from another time, not modern times. Though they each couldn’t understand the languages, the music was a bond. There is footage of Plant & Page playing music with the elders. The road through the desert seemed endless, & views seem all the same. Page played guitar for P Diddy’s Godzilla, to this music.
@@neilmccomsey9550 that is the story, my guess the name Kashmir just lyrically sounded better. I suggest doing some research if you don’t believe the story, because the story has been told several times.
@@neilmccomsey9550 I believe they used Kashmir as a metaphor for what they felt a hot dry mysterious place seemingly from a time long past and the name just rolled of the tongue in english better than the places in Morocco which inspired them.
I love your approach, "lets listen to the studio version before concert footage, like you would have done it back then" very intelligent , as are your views on the music.
Saw LED Zeppelin in 1975 and 1977. They did this at both concerts and it is such a unique piece of rock. It was spectacular. I liked it on Physical Graffiti but live was far better. Robert's voice hit every nerve he meant to hit.
My absolute fav from them. Celebration Day concert has The son Jason on the drums and he kills it! The modern sound equipment makes this one of the best live performances I've ever seen. Very clean sound.
I saw Zed Zepplin in Tampa Stadium, Tampa Bay, Fla. back in the day and I also saw Pink Floyd, Animals tour there too. Also, Jethro Tull, Robin Trower, and Johnny and Edgar Winter their Back in the day! 😎 I saw so many concerts back in the day I lost count! Our music was so important to us back in the day! A good stereo at home and in our car was a must! You could have a beater car, but if the stereo was good, you were cool! 😎
There are 3 stellar live versions of "Kashmir", and I can't pick a favorite. The first is from 1979 Led Zeppelin at Knebworth, then in 1995 Page and Plant did a special for MTV they called Unledded. The version from that performance is totally different in the best possible way, including a full orchestra. The third is from 2007 Celebration Day which is also incredible featuring Jason Bonham on the drums. Enjoy!
@barsandbarbells2022. Please do "Kashmir" 2007 Celebration Day. Epic performance with John's son Jason on the drums. Great live video all around🎙️🗣️🎸🥁🔥. Love fr Texas 👊
Great Reaction Sam & Phil! Kashmir is actually my ringtone on iPhone! Both Kashmir and Stairway To Heaven are tied as my #1 Songs in general! This reminds me of Fast Times At Ridgemont High! 🎸🤘🙏🏻
Thank God you did the studio version. It is just so much more powerful and mysterious in a way the live recording can't come close to matching. I wish the people who give you the suggestions would specify a little more to orient you guys before listening. One major thing they managed to forget was to bring the lyrics with you because this one matters. Without them you miss the journey they're taking you on. The suggesters never think about little things like that. Anyways, I'm thankful you chose the studio version.
The brilliance of Zeppelin is the journey they take you on with unique arrangements and amazing musicianship that would never happen if you remove and replace any of the four remarkable musicians. They came together and created the greatest band in my 65 year lifetime to this point. Listen to their first song “Good Times Bad Times “ from the 60’s and it still sounds like it could’ve been written yesterday! Truly a beautiful gift for humanity ❤❤❤
@@stevenseul361 Thank you for your comment my friend. I’ve heard their reaction. It was just a general statement of my appreciation for Zeppelin’s contribution to music. I love interacting with music fans 🎶
Phil & Sam thank you for doing the studio version first. Its just like you mentioned , the studio versions are what we first heard when these now classic songs were introduced to the world.
So organic and powerful. Their studio sound especially on vinyl every remembers when first hearing. Then there is the musicianship and the voice of Robert Plant.
Their performance of Kashmir is epic during their 2007 Celebration Day. This concert holds the worlds record for the highest demand for tickets for one single concert...there were about 18,000+ tickets but had 20 MILLION requests for tickets.
And I didn't get one 😢😢😢
Kashmir is not just a song, it's a journey.
I thought it was a kind of exquisite sweater.
Bah-dum-bomp.
It's also top notch hashish.
Brilliant description
You sound very American on your "journey"?
@@PUNKinDRUBLIC72 nah you sound very American.
Best rock band of all Time Led Zeppelin
A legendary rock song. It's a masterpiece. Nothing sounds like it.
Stargazer by Rainbow. R J Dio and Cozy Powell. A fantastic song.
The guys in the band consider this their masterpiece
Yes Robert wants to be remembered for Kashmir and not Stairway, Jimmies favorite 3 are Whole Lotta Love. Kashmir and Since I've Been Loving You.
@@stevenseul361 SIBLY is my personal fave
With 70's music, it's less important to know what the songwriter was writing about than it is to feel where the song is taking you. This song is a journey, and only you can know where you'll end up.
GOATS = every single one of them. So beloved, so missed.
thanks
Especially since, in this song, Bonham and page are playing in different time signatures.
Studio first is a GOOD call. This song IS,,,,Led Zeppelin. 💥💥💥💥💥👍😎
Kashmir is a region on the India Pakistan border. Beautiful, mountainous and been fought over for years by the 2 countries
Disputed territory today at that
One of the greatest songs every recorded. Period.
Question mark!!!!
100%, it's my ringtone, every time I hear it I reach for my phone!
THE best ever recorded.
Bonham!!
@@mikehoo66can't listen to music on a phone
Record or the cd is the way to go
This is Zeppelin’s favorite of their catalogue, according to the three living members. All songs are their children, but this one meant something special, especially to Robert and Jimmy, who were inspired by a journey across the desert in Morocco. Robert was almost in a trance on that long drive and endless horizons, and those mystical thoughts came to him. Read the lyrics…it’s poetry and pretty deep.
Nothing to do with Kashmir, which is in the Himalayas, but that name evokes mystery and the exotic, so it’s well used here.
Robert Plant also said the song Frightened him as well LOTS of different Emotions & Feelings attached with this Masterpiece
@@CosmicVagabondPixie completely understand. He was dealing with profound subject matter..,,speaking of Time, Fate, life’s journey……creativity and it’s mystery…..is his life preordained, or is he a free agent? Is there a higher power? Plant is a spiritual man, and has deep thoughts….which, as a hugely private person, he keeps hidden away most of the time, I think. Two sets of lyrics from this song I think reveal allot. The first is:
Oh, Pilot of the storm who leaves no trace
Like thoughts inside a dream
He has spoken of his mind as a “ceaseless roar”…(Ifvyou know his album Lullaby and The Ceaseless Roar….it refers to this)…so I’m thinking he might be using a storm as a similar metaphor . He refers to a pilot of the storm….(a higher power? His creative spark?) who leaves no trace…. Where does creativity come from? Thoughts inside a dream? It’s a mystery…..no one really knows.
And the other lyric that really gets me is:
oh, Father of the Four Winds, fill my sails
across the sea of years
With no provision but an open face
Along the straits of fear
This can be interpreted almost like a prayer, although I don’t think he meant it that way. But he is asking for the wind to be at his back as he goes forward. I’ve heard him speak of being very conscious of Time…,and life as a journey that one set out on….unknowingly ..,…trusting in Fate, or luck.
He keeps on “open face”….open to new experience, embracing change, always seeking, restless. That has been his gift and his burden. And he speaks of the “Straits of Fear”. He asks for the “Pilot” to be with him across the years, and also with him through times of fear.
I almost tear up when I hear these lyrics, because we all know what he would face so soon after he penned those lyrics.
So yeah…I can see why this song might scare him : Where did those lyrics come from…..and were they prescient? He is grappling with great mysteries here……as he continues to do……very aware of his mortality….very aware of the richness and beauty of life, and of its losses.
perhaps those lyrics are the closest to his heart of any that he has written …..and give us a glimpse of the soul of the man behind the public facade…..especially the facade of the “golden god” that was his public persona at that time.
very idiotic of them to name it kashmir then isn't it. its like me writing a book about my trip to france n naming it london
@@mogheanil actually no. You were probably not alive then, or at least not an adult like myself. “Kashmir” was seen in the late 60’s as a physical representation of the mystical land of Shangri-La ) google if don’t know reference). A legendary land of surreal beauty and enchantment.
Many “hippies”, who had the time and money, made pilgrimages to Kashmir to seek spiritual truths. And most of us who listened to this song knew what they were evoking by using that title. And the lyrics that Plant wrote bear that out: Those lyrics speak of a mystical metaphorical journey to “the elders of s gentle race”…where he discovered that “the meaning was quite clear”.
Read the lyrics with this in mind, if you care to. And you will see that the song was perfectly named to describe what they were trying to evoke: not the physical country of Kashmir, but the ineffable mystery of Shangri-La ……. And spiritual knowing.
And if you really care to understand, read my comment above about the meaning of the song. I’m betting you won’t 😉
@@helenespaulding7562 yeah u r right even beatles came to india in d late 60s. many prominent figures have come here to seek spiritual enlightment. but back then kashmir was safe, ppl from my family (my uncle n his american wife went there to see the beautiful lakes & apple, pomegranate orchids. Sometime in the 80s ussr invaded afghanistan and terrorism in the region started cos america retaliated and armed these jihadis. kashmir isnt just beautiful but has geographically significance which is why its so important india china pak. the reason u gave is d real reason & not the trip to morocco which many have been saying here in the comments
Appreciate you listening to studio first. Especially with Zep. Page is a wizard producer.
Watch live at Knebworth (1979) & live Celebration Day (2007), when they are in their 60’s & Bonham’s son Jason plays drums.
This is the song that introduced me to Led Zeppelin and made me a Led head for years , it was my first step into “ hard rock” and I never looked back ❤❤
A true masterpiece
Don't forget about the drums, John Bonham displayed his mastery in this one.
I'm 71 and got to see them twice in the early 70's. Phil, you got it 100% right. If you younger people want to know how it hit us at the time, always go with studio versions, with a few exceptions.
Bravo! Bravo for your decision to go with the studio version for your first listen.
When you think about the diversity of their catalog remember they were only together for 12 years!! That is still hard to wrap my head around!
I'm so glad you listen to the original recording first. I think it's so important to hear all the nuances.❤
My favorite live version of Kashmir is the one in 2007 celebration day concert with John Bonham Son Jason on Drums it’s Epic! A must see
Watch them do this live in 2007 Celebration Day Concert
It is EPIC!
Or Kashmir live at Knebworth
Unbelieveable versions!!!
Yes! The Celebration Day version IMO is the best version ever. Goes to show age is no barrier when it comes to music.
Knebworth is great…Bonzo is ridiculous
The Knebworth version is great but to see them own the stage in the Celebration Day version is fantastic! I know it's not John but the other Bonham killed that performance!
This song is one of Led Zeppelin’s favorite Led Zeppelin songs 🔥 The band likes it much better than Stairway To Heaven. I’m glad you did the studio version first 👍
The studio version is better in both Kashmir and Stairway to Heaven!
That live version is going to blow your minds. Celebration Day!
My favorite zep song... also Robert plants fav
Kashmir and In My Time of Dying are my favorite Zep songs, but 99% of them are great also.
You made the correct choice about going studio with one as the "effects" are much more pronounced and mystical.
"Mothership" is a greatest hits album for Led Zeppelin.
"Immigrant Song" is on "Led Zeppelin 3"
"Kashmir" is on the double album entitled "Physical Graffiti".
Trampled Under Foot!! Love the jam!! Always great!!❤
LIVE
My favorite rock tune of all time.
It's second to none, for me.
It couldn’t be produced in 2024 , because there is no one talented enough toddy , to have the ability to go into the studio & come out with something like this
I think that often about most music from that time. No way you’d get anything close to a Zeppelin, Boston, The Who, Styx, Rush, etc. The 70s-80s had the best imo.
I was fortunate to see Robert & Jimmy perform this with the Houston Philharmonic Orchestra, can't recall the year!
The members of the Orchestra were very enthusiastic in the performance. With great respect for them both.
It was very emotional, hell yeah.
1995-1997 sometime..,
I was sooo high the first time I heard this! Magical!😎👍
No other song reminds you of this song or vice versa. Awesome.
The studio version is impeccable ✌️
Bless you for doing the studio version first!
It is so much fun seeing young people enjoy themselves with the music i grew up with 50 years ago......
This has been my ringtone for years!
Sam, The cover is the same because it’s a compilation album of their most famous and beloved songs
This song is from 1975. Immigrant song was on Zeppelin III, released in 1970
This always takes me on a magic carpet ride
My Uncle saw them in 68 as an opening act for the Who God I am so jealous
Wow, can you imagine?!
Recorded in 74, released in 75. Jones melatron plus some brass and strings tastefully arranged by Jonesy. Live he replicates most of it with melatron. But all four members shine on it and band has long considered this, not stairway or whole lotta love as their definitive work. Achilles Last Stand is another Zepic you need to check out. Stay with the studio and then live format.
Zepic "nice one Cyril" a Tottenham supporter will know.
The celebration day version of this is (2007) is the absolute best 👌 definitely DEFINITELY check that out! Also proves how much they still have the talent after so many years. John Bonham's son plays the drums and is phenomenal!
The 2007 version is so good with technology allowing John Paul Jones to play the strings etc on keys
Bonham's drum outro is unreal.
I agree. Also if you crank up the volume at the last fill of Misty Mountain Hop 👍
My Absolutely Favorite Led Zeppelin Song Great Song
Legendary Song
Legendary Album
Legendary Band
Echoing others, the 2007 performance of Kashmir live on Celebration Day is a must watch and listen. Absolutely incredible how they perform and sound.
My favorite Zeppelin song - please react to the live version in 2007 - Live at Celebration Day - you get to hear Plant still belt it out and John Bonham's son, Jason kill it on the drums
Don’t think I’ve ever seen Phil soooooooo delighted with a song . Awesome! 🤩
Battle of evermore one of lead zeppelins best a Beautiful story, a must rear.!!🥰
The 2007 is the live from Celebration Day. They were in their 60’s. It’s amazing!
Great fun guys... I grew up in the 70s and got a little burned out of Zep (especially Stairway) but this i can listen to all the time 😊 The live version with strings is EPIC!! Can you imagine as a violinist getting the call to join LZ on stage? 😮
Physical Graffiti was 1975 The Presence Album was 76’
Presence sucked
@@earlfox6030 "Tea For One" Did Not Suck!
@@earlfox6030 Achilles doesn’t suck
Immigrant song was Led Zeppelin 3.
Now immediately do this song again from Celebration Day. It's amazing 40 years later. Might be the best live rock performance of all time.
every time I hear a Zeppelin song it's my favorite
🤪🤪🤪👍
I completely understand 😂
@CardiacCat
0 seconds ago
SO, now that you say it, YOU just suggested your next Led Zeppelin song. "Ramble On"
I will always remember this track and intro being used in RATM - Wake Up (Matrix ending credits) and Puff Daddy - Come With Me (Godzilla movie).
My favorites LZ songs are Whole Lotta Love, Immigrant Song (also Kasabian - Days Are Forgotten reminds me that song) and D'yer Mak'er (because of Sheryl Crow's cover).
Love your BabyMetal journey so please don't stop and come back for more.🦊🤘🔥
The studio version is king. Well done!
I’m 64. I grew up with this music. I grew up when John bottoms, Jason‘s dad played.. rest his soul, but Jasonplays his just like his dad
One of my favorites!
Live version from CELEBRATION DAY Concert is the one to do. Their first concert in almost 30 after Jon passed away. Jon's son is the drummer. Plant's voice is amazing at age 70. He didn't lose a thing. Millions people tried to get tickets for the concert.
Absolutely epic
Used to hear this on the radio but never knew who sang it. Took me YEARS to find it. Every time it would play, the DJ never said the name. Finally heard it again one day and got wise and called the radio station to ask. He told me the name, I run down to Sam Goody and start looking through all the Zeppelin albums. ...and I can't find it. WTF? The guy said "Cashmere" It's not on any of these!! True story. Anyway, bought Physical Graffiti as he said it was on that album and later figured out my blunder. One of the first CDs I ever bought too.
This kind of thing always happened to me in the 70s. I hardly ever knew what band did what song. It didn't change until I got old enough to afford to buy albums.
The masters of music. Now and forever more.
Have to see the live version from celebration day. Not often the live is bey than the studio IMO but this is that occasion, I don't think you'll be disappointed.
JP Jones is fantastic playing this keyboard section with oriental vibe........!
He makes it as far as I'm concerned 🤘
I read in one of the many books about Zeppelin that yes there was a mellotron used for the strings. But also the Calcutta National Orchestra played on the track as well. They played the string arrangement written by John Paul Jones, and he conducted the orchestra when they recorded their part.
The gods that are Led Zeppelin, with me for over 50 yrs. 🥰
Another Masterpiece. Zeppelin never disappoints. Saw this live they were mind blowing Lucky me❤
One of the first albums I ever purchased just after release. I was 13.
This Mothership album is a greatest hits album.
You need to listen to ten years gone Led Zeppelin
Talk in song from tongues of lilting grace
Sounds caress my ear
And not a word I heard could I relate
The story was quite clear
This is originally off of Physical Graffiti.
Heart does a good live performance of Kashmir and Immigrant Song
And Battle of Evermore ❤
Thanks for doing the studio version first. That's almost always preferred, but there are some rare exceptions. Do You Feel Like We Do from Frampton Comes Alive comes to mind, as does Bob Seger's Turn The Page . . .
This song is about Plant & Page driving through the Sahara Desert, on their way to Morocco, for a music festival. None of the band members had been to Kashmir, it’s the song the band members are most proud of. Plant fell in love with Morocco, & still visits often to this day. The people there seem like from another time, not modern times. Though they each couldn’t understand the languages, the music was a bond. There is footage of Plant & Page playing music with the elders. The road through the desert seemed endless, & views seem all the same. Page played guitar for P Diddy’s Godzilla, to this music.
Well....Kashmir is no where close so...the story makes no sense
@@neilmccomsey9550 that is the story, my guess the name Kashmir just lyrically sounded better. I suggest doing some research if you don’t believe the story, because the story has been told several times.
And they were pretty high at the time.
Kashmir is a city in southern Pakistan. Is that Arabian enough?
@@neilmccomsey9550 I believe they used Kashmir as a metaphor for what they felt a hot dry mysterious place seemingly from a time long past and the name just rolled of the tongue in english better than the places in Morocco which inspired them.
Best Led Zeppelin song.
Fight me😌🙏
I love your approach, "lets listen to the studio version before concert footage, like you would have done it back then" very intelligent , as are your views on the music.
It's one of my favorite Led Zeppelin songs.
Saw LED Zeppelin in 1975 and 1977. They did this at both concerts and it is such a unique piece of rock. It was spectacular. I liked it on Physical Graffiti but live was far better. Robert's voice hit every nerve he meant to hit.
Thanks for more Led Zeppelin ❤
My absolute fav from them. Celebration Day concert has The son Jason on the drums and he kills it! The modern sound equipment makes this one of the best live performances I've ever seen. Very clean sound.
If the live version is the O2 concert you will be stunned by how good it is.
This is from the Physical Graffiti album. Not the same album as Immigrant Song but the same as In My Time Of Dying.
I saw Zed Zepplin in Tampa Stadium, Tampa Bay, Fla. back in the day and I also saw Pink Floyd, Animals tour there too. Also, Jethro Tull, Robin Trower, and Johnny and Edgar Winter their Back in the day! 😎 I saw so many concerts back in the day I lost count! Our music was so important to us back in the day! A good stereo at home and in our car was a must! You could have a beater car, but if the stereo was good, you were cool! 😎
There are 3 stellar live versions of "Kashmir", and I can't pick a favorite. The first is from 1979 Led Zeppelin at Knebworth, then in 1995 Page and Plant did a special for MTV they called Unledded. The version from that performance is totally different in the best possible way, including a full orchestra. The third is from 2007 Celebration Day which is also incredible featuring Jason Bonham on the drums. Enjoy!
Kashmir, is it a place? Love honesty! Simply say I don't know and ask. Thanks for being authentic.❤
@barsandbarbells2022. Please do "Kashmir" 2007 Celebration Day. Epic performance with John's son Jason on the drums. Great live video all around🎙️🗣️🎸🥁🔥. Love fr Texas 👊
Great Reaction Sam & Phil!
Kashmir is actually my ringtone on iPhone! Both Kashmir and Stairway To Heaven are tied as my #1 Songs in general! This reminds me of Fast Times At Ridgemont High! 🎸🤘🙏🏻
Kashmir is one of those great songs that have been in a few movies; I even remember it being a mix in the 98 Godzilla.
2007 Celebration Day Concert is 10X better. Hard to imagine, but it is truly is a ride!
❤ the reaction ! Zeppelin was way before their time
Thank God you did the studio version. It is just so much more powerful and mysterious in a way the live recording can't come close to matching. I wish the people who give you the suggestions would specify a little more to orient you guys before listening. One major thing they managed to forget was to bring the lyrics with you because this one matters. Without them you miss the journey they're taking you on. The suggesters never think about little things like that. Anyways, I'm thankful you chose the studio version.
The brilliance of Zeppelin is the journey they take you on with unique arrangements and amazing musicianship that would never happen if you remove and replace any of the four remarkable musicians. They came together and created the greatest band in my 65 year lifetime to this point. Listen to their first song “Good Times Bad Times “ from the 60’s and it still sounds like it could’ve been written yesterday! Truly a beautiful gift for humanity ❤❤❤
They reacted to it already
@@stevenseul361 Thank you for your comment my friend. I’ve heard their reaction. It was just a general statement of my appreciation for Zeppelin’s contribution to music. I love interacting with music fans 🎶
The greatest band is the beatles and then the rolling stones. Zeppelin is number 3
@@shoeplayisbad1 we have the exact same top 3. I would probably rank all three #1 if possible. Thanks for the reply
@@DougCaffey all number one works
Phil & Sam thank you for doing the studio version first. Its just like you mentioned , the studio versions are what we first heard when these now classic songs were introduced to the world.
Amazing song. This was played at my step sons funeral it was one of his favorite songs. Great reaction ❤❤❤
Some of your comments in this video reminded me that you should listen to Ramble On from Led Zeppelin II. A favorite of many.
Yus indeed
Good.....studio. Live never meets the same level for this.
John Bonham's drumming was better live. He was a monster.
The version from Knebworth in 79 pretty epic though.
Yes. Was about to leave the video when I thought they were reacting to the live version.
Studio versions rule !! 😊
@@lyndoncmp5751 I think that's fair. But the rest of the music for this song just doesn't work as well, when played live.
ah, say what now..go watch Knebworth and/or Celebration Day...amazing. Would always prefer watcing them live...the joy in watching page play - GOAT
So organic and powerful. Their studio sound especially on vinyl every remembers when first hearing. Then there is the musicianship and the voice of Robert Plant.
I agree with y'all's decision about hearing the studio version when listening to a song for the first time 👍
Endless stream of music, great.