I think simon should have not only spoken to her to tell her louis left her hanging but maybe bought her a nice dinner himself. Or better yet gottten her a flight to thier next sight so she could tell him off in person. In any case though we know at the end of the day they could truly care less about anything not having to do with themselves.
@@pollypurree1834 absolute rubbish.There are too many idiots,like you,trying to make people feel bad.Go and take a good look at yourself.A really good look.
@@eh-i1841 If I was obese, I would try and do something about it. Not pretend that it is normal and looks good. I'm certainly not super cruel like you to try and mislead these poor souls into thinking it is "beautiful". Obesity leads to poor health and early death. The majority of Covid deaths were among the obese. Plus, they are highly prone to strokes and heart attacks. It looks terrible too..
It was 2004, people were yet to discover the beauties of thicc culture. Jkjk but fr, you need to remember that this was like 10 years ago, and beauty standards were a lil different in the mid 2000's.
They judged the first girl and almost didn't give her a chance cause she was a little overweight! She was so pretty, personable, and had a beautiful voice! Shame on the judges😔.
I dont think it was right for them to tell that girl she was overweight. Thats why people have eating disorders in the industry. The girl was beautiful.
Exactly. That's why I love The voice instead of the x factor, idols etc. They look at looks SO much. Well sorry but then just say " Okay everyone has to be a model and THEN you can let us hear you sing. Plus they're allowing ALL AGES. Like do you really think that girl or anyone obese, looks worse then grandpas and grannys? And not saying all grandpas and grannys look bad btw. But you know, in general. Or mothers after kids etc. If you're allowing all that then why bother about the overweight. Plus she wasn't even that overweight o.o
***** There maybe but isn't that just rediculous? What are the people supposed to do which don't look perfect? Plus everyone who indeed doesn't look pretty is supposed to look up to them? That's so sad for them when they can't be like that. Amazing for someone's self esteem. Sorry but i'm really honest, i can't stand america at times. i keep thinking; " .... why.... what're you thinking people... "
I Agree Wholeheartedly,If You Dont Have a SOB Story,or Have Fallen On Hard Times,Your Not Going to Be Put Through.I Wasnt Expecting That, Especially From Sharon,This Has Changed My Whole Outlook For Her and .For These 3 ,To Sit There and Say That To Her......Are Ballsy,..Have “0”, Couth, Is Just Plain Ignorant...Somewhere Is a Video Of An Older Lady Telling Simon He Was Ignorant...
The girl with the blind guy I thought had a very good voice, as did he, but I couldn't understand why they said they didn't like her, she sounded better than a lot of them they put through. They have a thing about peoples looks and weight as if it will affect their career, yet they are suppose to be professionals rating someone's voice, I mean, would they have turned someone like Meatloaf down cause he was overweight, idiots at times, too above themselves.
Eh, they’re picking people who will sell and image is part of that. And what ‘04 Meatloaf wasn’t a noteworthy artist so idk why that was your go to example.
Wow, I didn't know that the judges were that savage in the early days, and very tough! I guess you can say that they've matured as judges over the years as they broke a million hearts, heard so many touching stories, and discovered so many different kinds of potential.
Or were told they had to reign it in or they would lose ratings which meant less money for them . I wish it had been a natural thing where they realised that their nastiness was way over the top but I think it was probably more likely to be along the lines of the former
I cannot imagine how much regret that last woman feels everyday when she thinks of how her husband held her back from success. It’s a good thing they divorced
the first audtion all 3 of them were jerks... telling her to loose weight she's awesome person who has a good voice and who's sweet and put her honeymoon off and that's all they can say... well at least they said yes . . I am aware that this clip is old but I just needed to say that
9:28 It's soooo disgusting when judges come between groups by insulting one of the members & pitting them against one another--especially when both are talented & work well together. 👀
@@lifeofxyco7633 because they are always saying it’s a singing competition.They only tell the women that the need to lose weight,even if they’re a perfectly healthy weight.
Disrespectful of Simon to be 2 hours late , if each audition lasts about 5/10 minutes that’s put them way behind . Probably been out the night before but being the boss, had one of the others done it he’d have gone mad !
🌈 I was so very confused about the judge's reaction to the couple at 7:01. He's blind and she's a friend. They were GREAT and in my opinion their harmonies were dead on!!! So when they started taking any credit away from her I found myself (weirdly enough) yelling at my phone in protest. I am SO VERY HAPPY that they were let through and I'm looking to seeing what the rest of their X-FACTOR journey is like!! 👍
I thought she was better, but I agree with harmonies. They just sang together not really harmonizing to me. Those three black family members were harmonizing well (families who can sing hit different).
Simon said "who cares whether you stay together or not, you are rubbish". Sometimes the very persons we put down end up doing a lot better than the winners. Can't go around hurting people's feelings like that.
Y'all need to remember that this was in 2004, and that being body positive is a VERY recent thing. This was like 10 years ago or something, and back then, being a singer was just as much about image as it was about voice.
38:48 lol in tune and he sang most of it in tune heavy on his G's though.....if nuthin else he could do standup.... but that was 15yrs ago...they need a show that tracks down some of the stand outs and see if their still making chips or if there still digging ditches
im speechless at this, and shocked there wasnt more of an uproar about this episode. I couldnt believe i was actually hearing them tell her to her face that shes a fucking whale. theres criticism..... and then there's just being plain cruel. her voice might not have been a 10, but her weight shouldve had NOTHING to do with their decision. Bodies can lose weight over time if effort is used. It doesnt require having a gift to accomplish it, so anyone who puts in the work can look fit. ya know, im going to throw out a longshot here but humor me. had they not been so cruel to her, and she started seeing some positive feedback to help undo the previous trauma, it just might help build her confidence..... and (heres a stretch) when she starts feeling confidence coming back to her, she'll want to put more time and energy into bettering her health/fitness, which in turn will strengthen her stage performance, building more confidence..... and the cycle continues. i was just gobsmacked.....
Image is important and they've style referenced it before in relation to everything from weight to teeth, but there was something about this time that made me feel awful watching it. I think Simon was trying to be subtle when he said she looked like a 'shop girl', when she said she knew he meant she was overweight they were a bit too blunt imho.
The judges were a lot more strict back then. I've been watching xfactor stuff on UA-cam and I hadn't watched anything from this season yet. They were brutal.
It is really sad the the friends and family of some of these people aren't more honest. I think it would be better to hear that maybe singing isn't their thing from a loved one rather than getting gutted by the judges (Simon).
These three judges? Telling the new bride who gave up her honeymoon that she's a fat shop girl and too bad cause her voice is good...and then after only one song they tell the duet that she sucks but he's great? The girl sounded like she was trying to sound like Diana Ross in the original version of the song. To me they sounded so much like the original harmonies so that advice might have been premature and unnecessarily cruel. I've always thought American Idol (and its spin offs) introduced pop culture to a "nuevo-rude" thing making it acceptable to trash other people as anyone see's fit. Combined with the trend of recognizing the need for kids to have self esteem made of steel to succeed - combined - it created a generation of horrific brats.
I am disgusted at the fact you told that beautiful girl she was overweight . She was absolutely stunning! On the first or second episode, you told a girl that it's her voice that they are going to here, not what she looks like. This is why young girls have such body issues because of people like you telling them they are not good enough because they don't look like a Barbie doll. I just can't believe you three 😱
Fair enough judge someone on their singing but to judge that girl on her weight is disgusting! Other curvy girls are in the industry have gone onto do amazing things. She is perfect the way she is and she should only go on a diet if she so chooses not because others tell her to. To judge her singing I think she should of sang a bit more, however she wasn't all bad there's potential and when you look at some others who are bad she's hell of a lot better, people like Jedward went onto clowning around yet this girl is willing to try and has something to work on gets spoken to like crap!
She was very fat especially for her age. Someone like that would be massive by the time she's 45, if she lives that long. It's rather cruel to say nothing and to pretend that obesity is sexy🙄.
Y'all notice whenever there's something or someone they don't understand, they always seem to put them down, say nasty rude things about ?! There's no need for that behavior. It's not positive and it certainly doesn't help anyone anywhere anytime.
Wow who is Sharon to tell someone to loose weight. She has been over weight most of her adult years. I’m thoroughly disgusted. Someone can’t be a star because they’re over weight? Are you kidding me?!!!!! That girl should of sued them.
THANK YOU for bringing that up. Look up old pics of her - she had to be over 250 lbs. easy. She also very clearly had gotten plastic surgery on her jaw, nose, and eyes before reality tv.
I am so insulted how dare they say such Comments about her weight wow. look who is in the industry today, Adele, all the big fake butts , how could they say such a thing . shameful
Ugh, shut up. She was overweight and unhealthy and just so happened to find out she was pregnant at boot camp. No one wants to look up to and aspire to be like a fatty. Plus, this was in 2004 and all you SJWs didn't exist back then. Better times really.
Taehyunggie You shouldn't use Taehyungs name as you run your mouth so rudely. So much hate towards fat, big, large, or just not skinny people. You're a toxic person and also you don't know her level of health as overweight doesn't always mean unhealthy just as anorexic skinny doesn't mean healthly either.
Today they would never get away with telling the girl she was overweight and needed to diet! She was beautiful and I feel if the judges looked back they would cringe!..
BTW Mankind needs to look at groups like the 4 Tops and The Temptations who have a lead singer in the group and the other guys make up the fullness of the band.
people need to stopy lying to thier friends and family telling them they can sing, it gives them false hope. Also alot of people are deeply deluded beliving they can sing but can not hear it themselves.
37:27 What happened that smelled so bad when the old guy was in there? Was it the packages he put on their table? Or was it himself that smelled bad? I don't get it.
They ask for the judges opinion and when they give it to them they get pissed and say simon, sharon n louis don't know what they are talking about or tell them off on the camera when they leave
Lots of them go solo from being in rubbish groups but I've never seen someone go solo and then bottle out of that and rejoin the group! Final part of the Mankind saga starts at 22:14
That girl was just as good as Peter. I hate it when people give special attention to blind people. I've talked to blind people before and THEY don't even like that either.
I don't think they could comment on that woman's weight like that now. It's so wrong and now a days people would be rightly outraged by that. She's beautiful inside out and I really hope she didn't end up developing an eating disorder
Is it just me ...I thought the young man that is blind and his lady friend sang perfectly beautiful together.
They did!! I whole heartidly agree😎😎😎😎!
I thought she was iffy at first but got better as it went on
I agree 100%
Remember when X Factor showed more than 4 auditions per episode? Those were the days
"Those were the days".
@@stacynels4 ?
Which series did it start only having 4 auditions per episode?
I think Louis is terrible for standing up that poor woman who thought she had a date with him. Crude and rude.
I think simon should have not only spoken to her to tell her louis left her hanging but maybe bought her a nice dinner himself. Or better yet gottten her a flight to thier next sight so she could tell him off in person. In any case though we know at the end of the day they could truly care less about anything not having to do with themselves.
@@mouse7984 *I'm sure they talked to her, they just didn't show it*
@@MaritsView anything is possible with these shows i suppose, they are primarily fake.
@@mouse7984 The show yeah but they're still real people tho
@@MaritsView real people yes, real compassion and care for strangers obviously not so much.
Holy shit I can't believe they weight shamed that poor girl.....don't think that would fly now a days!! She was beautiful!
They did her a favor. She would be twice as obese at 50 if she lives that long.
@@pollypurree1834 absolute rubbish.There are too many idiots,like you,trying to make people feel bad.Go and take a good look at yourself.A really good look.
@@eh-i1841 If I was obese, I would try and do something about it. Not pretend that it is normal and looks good. I'm certainly not super cruel like you to try and mislead these poor souls into thinking it is "beautiful". Obesity leads to poor health and early death. The majority of Covid deaths were among the obese. Plus, they are highly prone to strokes and heart attacks. It looks terrible too..
@@eh-i1841 You must be morbidly obese yourself. It's time you got out of your dream bubble and faced reality.
@@pollypurree1834 some people do try some don't it's none of your business
"Mould will grow on your lungs after breathing in that shit" ~Sharon Osbourne 2004
Even better, -"My advice to him is,-to put a rocket up your ahss and light it and launch yourself into space"
Peter had an amazing voice. I feel bad that he’s blind 😢 but he really inspires me as a musician!
Another Peters and Lee ??
Bonfire night, bonfire night. A work of true genius
stop teasing us with the chicken factory guy, i want to see him singing barbie girl
her weight was fine they were asses she's beautiful
I agree completely .It would be like me being called fat when I am 119.you can see some ribs I look like a half starved person.
She's got an adorable smile & cute face!! Wtf! What about Adele, gorgeous, talented & a little heavier, like a lot of women!! Uncalled for!!
Yeah but this was a different decade. Now it would be different.
@Renee O'Shea What matters the most is what kind of person you are.
It was 2004, people were yet to discover the beauties of thicc culture. Jkjk but fr, you need to remember that this was like 10 years ago, and beauty standards were a lil different in the mid 2000's.
Ugh they had no right to tell her she's over weight and to go on a diet! I've always thought highly of Simon but that crossed a line.
Well it's true and they are just being honest with her and trust she would hear worse than that if she made it to Hollywood
@@sharonfleming810 Well I understand if its Modelling but singing you don't have to be skinny, adele was fat
lol it is 2004. it won't be acceptable to say something like that in 2021
@@amoat7 People in 2021 are too touchy. The world needs to be about telling the truth.
@@lifeofxyco7633 the truth is,that girl doesn’t need to go n a diet.
They judged the first girl and almost didn't give her a chance cause she was a little overweight! She was so pretty, personable, and had a beautiful voice! Shame on the judges😔.
I agree, that part honestly upset me.
She was not that good.
i think they are trying to protect her from a harsh industry
I dont think it was right for them to tell that girl she was overweight. Thats why people have eating disorders in the industry. The girl was beautiful.
Exactly. That's why I love The voice instead of the x factor, idols etc. They look at looks SO much. Well sorry but then just say " Okay everyone has to be a model and THEN you can let us hear you sing. Plus they're allowing ALL AGES. Like do you really think that girl or anyone obese, looks worse then grandpas and grannys? And not saying all grandpas and grannys look bad btw. But you know, in general. Or mothers after kids etc. If you're allowing all that then why bother about the overweight. Plus she wasn't even that overweight o.o
simon can be a COW like when he told one of his girls to get rid of her makeup recently what a prick right?
***** There maybe but isn't that just rediculous? What are the people supposed to do which don't look perfect? Plus everyone who indeed doesn't look pretty is supposed to look up to them? That's so sad for them when they can't be like that. Amazing for someone's self esteem. Sorry but i'm really honest, i can't stand america at times. i keep thinking; " .... why.... what're you thinking people... "
Besides, it's a recording singer. What does her weight have to do with anything? I wished they had gotten more shit over this. So out of place.
I Agree Wholeheartedly,If You Dont Have a SOB Story,or Have Fallen On Hard Times,Your Not Going to Be Put Through.I Wasnt Expecting That, Especially From Sharon,This Has Changed My Whole Outlook For Her and .For These 3 ,To Sit There and Say That To Her......Are Ballsy,..Have “0”, Couth, Is Just Plain Ignorant...Somewhere Is a Video Of An Older Lady Telling Simon He Was Ignorant...
The girl with the blind guy I thought had a very good voice, as did he, but I couldn't understand why they said they didn't like her, she sounded better than a lot of them they put through. They have a thing about peoples looks and weight as if it will affect their career, yet they are suppose to be professionals rating someone's voice, I mean, would they have turned someone like Meatloaf down cause he was overweight, idiots at times, too above themselves.
I was wondering that myself, I think they have to act like that to add drama otherwise it would be so boring
I agree. They were way too picky, harsh, argumentative, and nit picked too much in the first few seasons. Especially the first.
Eh, they’re picking people who will sell and image is part of that. And what ‘04 Meatloaf wasn’t a noteworthy artist so idk why that was your go to example.
I agree completely!
She wasn't that over weight and she was pretty to
Hate to be that guy but its too
Wow, I didn't know that the judges were that savage in the early days, and very tough! I guess you can say that they've matured as judges over the years as they broke a million hearts, heard so many touching stories, and discovered so many different kinds of potential.
Or were told they had to reign it in or they would lose ratings which meant less money for them . I wish it had been a natural thing where they realised that their nastiness was way over the top but I think it was probably more likely to be along the lines of the former
@joannaedssay5988 You know what, you may be right about that one.
I cannot imagine how much regret that last woman feels everyday when she thinks of how her husband held her back from success. It’s a good thing they divorced
Omg. He does resemble Princess Diana 😂
the first audtion all 3 of them were jerks... telling her to loose weight she's awesome person who has a good voice and who's sweet and put her honeymoon off and that's all they can say... well at least they said yes . . I am aware that this clip is old but I just needed to say that
Jessica Woodsum lose not loose. Learn to spell, sweetheart
To cancel a wedding voyage because of THAT needs a deluded mind, don't you think. And it's a sorry excuse....
@@sford557 what? You serious? Take your own advice...
The truth must be made clear to people and that is what you have done so I jest want to say thank you.
Yes they were but it was much different back then. This would not fly today at all.
These judges are blind sometimes to very good sounding voices! Unbelievable!
… do you mean deaf?
You didn't know that no one wanted to be in a boy ban until you were told you had the best voice.
I was thinking the exact same thing
9:28 It's soooo disgusting when judges come between groups by insulting one of the members & pitting them against one another--especially when both are talented & work well together. 👀
You’re the type of person who wouldn’t take honesty
I agree! I didn’t hear anything wrong with her voice. It just didn't match Peter's voice. But I honestly liked the group!
Did they seriously need to blur out Simon’s cigarette?🙄
Jen Vincur it’s as if we’ve never seen one before
Its from 2004 remember
@@hannahgoodchild5255 now he wouldn't be allowed to smoke onscreen or anywhere inside.
"I'd love to see you do it in Full Drag" Love Louis
when simon said “youre really overweight, you really are” it rubbed me all the wrong ways
Why?
@@lifeofxyco7633 because they are always saying it’s a singing competition.They only tell the women that the need to lose weight,even if they’re a perfectly healthy weight.
@@eh-i1841 But reality is different. The world accepts hotties over fatties. That's just reality. Not my idea.
them coming at her like that for being overweight made me really uncomfortable like.. tf does that have to do with her singing
I would laugh if that guy actually did get a number 1...I would buy it just so Simon would have to pay him.
Disrespectful of Simon to be 2 hours late , if each audition lasts about 5/10 minutes that’s put them way behind . Probably been out the night before but being the boss, had one of the others done it he’d have gone mad !
FABULOUS fAbUloUs *fabulous* fabulous *FABULOUS* *FauLouS*
HELPPPP
Darren at 144 actually comes off like a nice guy
🌈 I was so very confused about the judge's reaction to the couple at 7:01. He's blind and she's a friend. They were GREAT and in my opinion their harmonies were dead on!!! So when they started taking any credit away from her I found myself (weirdly enough) yelling at my phone in protest. I am SO VERY HAPPY that they were let through and I'm looking to seeing what the rest of their X-FACTOR journey is like!! 👍
Actually, I thought she was better than he was
They were horrible to her.Allowing for slight nerves,which they should,their harmonies were very good.
I thought she was better, but I agree with harmonies. They just sang together not really harmonizing to me. Those three black family members were harmonizing well (families who can sing hit different).
At 14:46, it looks like he's staring off into space imagining a future as a successful solo artist..
The Bonfire night song lives rent free in my head everyday 😂
Does his smell ? 👃🏻💦
do not make fun of someones weight!! and that grl with the blind kid sang grreat!
Exactly
They didn't make fun of her weight they said the truth, she's obese.
I love X Factor
Which era do you prefer:- Kate & 3 judges (my favourite) or Dermot (and/or Caroline & Olly) & 4 judges?
VWS sounded amazing!!!
Simon said "who cares whether you stay together or not, you are rubbish". Sometimes the very persons we put down end up doing a lot better than the winners. Can't go around hurting people's feelings like that.
Y'all need to remember that this was in 2004, and that being body positive is a VERY recent thing. This was like 10 years ago or something, and back then, being a singer was just as much about image as it was about voice.
I realize this is14 years ago but a lot of good singers were not getting through. This was definitely a bad year.
first time ive seen this.im disgusted with what they said to the girl.
Awh I miss these 1 s back when it was fun and life wasn’t so serious!! ❤️❤️❤️
I think that they are both strong singers xx
Some of these people are not that bad and the judges act like they sound way worse then they actually do! 😦😦😦
Yep.
Melissa Ludovico 90% will be sent home during Hollywood week anyway. Only one person can win.
I like this Episode 3 X Factor 2004
38:48 lol in tune and he sang most of it in tune heavy on his G's though.....if nuthin else he could do standup.... but that was 15yrs ago...they need a show that tracks down some of the stand outs and see if their still making chips or if there still digging ditches
my endless love wooooooooooooooooooooooooooooow loved it
binge watchin since last week lol
I like Simon, because he says what I'm thinking!🤣
(Before) your a star⭐️
im speechless at this, and shocked there wasnt more of an uproar about this episode. I couldnt believe i was actually hearing them tell her to her face that shes a fucking whale. theres criticism..... and then there's just being plain cruel. her voice might not have been a 10, but her weight shouldve had NOTHING to do with their decision.
Bodies can lose weight over time if effort is used. It doesnt require having a gift to accomplish it, so anyone who puts in the work can look fit. ya know, im going to throw out a longshot here but humor me. had they not been so cruel to her, and she started seeing some positive feedback to help undo the previous trauma, it just might help build her confidence..... and (heres a stretch) when she starts feeling confidence coming back to her, she'll want to put more time and energy into bettering her health/fitness, which in turn will strengthen her stage performance, building more confidence..... and the cycle continues.
i was just gobsmacked.....
Image is important and they've style referenced it before in relation to everything from weight to teeth, but there was something about this time that made me feel awful watching it. I think Simon was trying to be subtle when he said she looked like a 'shop girl', when she said she knew he meant she was overweight they were a bit too blunt imho.
Why'd they blur out Simon's cigarette?
I was wondering the same thing 😂
For marketing reasons. They don’t want to show what he smokes lol. Not that it matters 15 years later
15:55 who wants boy bands? One Direction showed you 4 years later: millions of girls and boys want them.
Where are you now?
TUMNIAISETU i was reading this comment just when the guy said that and i think, well...onde direction...lol
bts too, they're like soooo famous noow
Ngl one direction only exists cuz of him so...
The judges were a lot more strict back then. I've been watching xfactor stuff on UA-cam and I hadn't watched anything from this season yet. They were brutal.
It is really sad the the friends and family of some of these people aren't more honest. I think it would be better to hear that maybe singing isn't their thing from a loved one rather than getting gutted by the judges (Simon).
Even the ones that go thru are awful.
They put through people who are average and let go people who should've gone through. These older episodes are odd
"oh you've got wicked B.O. I'm going to be sick, please go away. You stink!" 🤣🤣🤣
Sharon!!!! Love you crazy lady 😂🥰☮️
Oh fabulous
These three judges? Telling the new bride who gave up her honeymoon that she's a fat shop girl and too bad cause her voice is good...and then after only one song they tell the duet that she sucks but he's great? The girl sounded like she was trying to sound like Diana Ross in the original version of the song. To me they sounded so much like the original harmonies so that advice might have been premature and unnecessarily cruel. I've always thought American Idol (and its spin offs) introduced pop culture to a "nuevo-rude" thing making it acceptable to trash other people as anyone see's fit. Combined with the trend of recognizing the need for kids to have self esteem made of steel to succeed - combined - it created a generation of horrific brats.
The " Jim Morrison" lookalike actually had a bit of a young John Travolta about him.
And he sounded a bit like Robert plant
I thought the same
Oh hell NO they did not just tell that girl to go on a fooking diet 😯😲
So being fat and unhealthy while facing a young death is fabulous?
She needs to she's obese
I am disgusted at the fact you told that beautiful girl she was overweight . She was absolutely stunning! On the first or second episode, you told a girl that it's her voice that they are going to here, not what she looks like. This is why young girls have such body issues because of people like you telling them they are not good enough because they don't look like a Barbie doll. I just can't believe you three 😱
If the judges only like one singer in the band that's ok because if that individual makes it famous he can always recall the others.
gwanni Actually the Manager has to accept the other artists to jump in on the track.
Thanks for the information. Never looked at it like that.
gwanni truth is most managers don't give a shit anyways lol.
Just care about the money. Are you an artist?
gwanni i'm an aspiring artist and Link up have noticed me a couple of times. But nothing came from it.
I love Simon......😁
We're gonna give you one more chance is the nicest thing simons said
Fair enough judge someone on their singing but to judge that girl on her weight is disgusting! Other curvy girls are in the industry have gone onto do amazing things. She is perfect the way she is and she should only go on a diet if she so chooses not because others tell her to. To judge her singing I think she should of sang a bit more, however she wasn't all bad there's potential and when you look at some others who are bad she's hell of a lot better, people like Jedward went onto clowning around yet this girl is willing to try and has something to work on gets spoken to like crap!
Whats that song at 35:49-36:06?
Surprised this hasn't been removed on the grounds of hate speech lol
so what if she is overweight.. its not like louis walsh is exactly in shape.
She was very fat especially for her age. Someone like that would be massive by the time she's 45, if she lives that long. It's rather cruel to say nothing and to pretend that obesity is sexy🙄.
10:45 never knew thunderfoot tried out for the xfactor, must have been before he started the youtube channel.
That isn’t thunderfoot.
144 years old imagine if he wasn't lying
All people care about is looks, weight, and age. Why did they act like 49 is so old? That lady said wow, 49, you look good. Since when did 49 come 89?
People don't live to be 89 × 2
This was recorded on Saturday 18th September 2004
Ok
Y'all notice whenever there's something or someone they don't understand, they always seem to put them down, say nasty rude things about ?!
There's no need for that behavior. It's not positive and it certainly doesn't help anyone anywhere anytime.
Mankind has a lot of people for a boy band🤭😆
20:19 what song is that in the background?!
Colleen Kyle Oasis - stop crying your heart out
Darude sandstorm
Whats the name of the last contestant?
Wow who is Sharon to tell someone to loose weight. She has been over weight most of her adult years. I’m thoroughly disgusted. Someone can’t be a star because they’re over weight? Are you kidding me?!!!!! That girl should of sued them.
THANK YOU for bringing that up. Look up old pics of her - she had to be over 250 lbs. easy. She also very clearly had gotten plastic surgery on her jaw, nose, and eyes before reality tv.
Her kids were overweight
@@JokersSerious Exactly. So who is she to tell that to someone
Sharon isn't overweight.
Remember Adele? She was a big girl
"When I get the record deal I deserve" 😹
27:35 WARREN!
I noticed that too!
I actually screamed when I saw him on the screen
I cant believe they r blurring Simon's cigarette. Pfffgf
X factor was ruthless that stuff wouldn't stand now in this fragile world😂
Was it bum fire 🔥 or bonfire I'm confused
I am so insulted how dare they say such Comments about her weight wow.
look who is in the industry today, Adele,
all the big fake butts , how could they say such a thing . shameful
Ugh, shut up. She was overweight and unhealthy and just so happened to find out she was pregnant at boot camp. No one wants to look up to and aspire to be like a fatty. Plus, this was in 2004 and all you SJWs didn't exist back then. Better times really.
Taehyunggie wow what a terrible person you are
In your dreams, Amy Whale.
Taehyunggie wow, so much for being an army "taehyungie" 😒
Taehyunggie You shouldn't use Taehyungs name as you run your mouth so rudely. So much hate towards fat, big, large, or just not skinny people. You're a toxic person and also you don't know her level of health as overweight doesn't always mean unhealthy just as anorexic skinny doesn't mean healthly either.
emma has a good voice
ilove watching these auditions, adore Simon!! but hahaaaa when he criticize their look, hahaaa i get so sad for the people :$
Today they would never get away with telling the girl she was overweight and needed to diet! She was beautiful and I feel if the judges looked back they would cringe!..
What plant do they come from the moon shilly lot
well the moon isnt a planet its a MOON!
Just shows how much we have declined even in the last 15 years
Absolutely!
BTW Mankind needs to look at groups like the 4 Tops and The Temptations who have a lead singer in the group and the other guys make up the fullness of the band.
people need to stopy lying to thier friends and family telling them they can sing, it gives them false hope. Also alot of people are deeply deluded beliving they can sing but can not hear it themselves.
It's not the weight, it's the clothes
37:27 What happened that smelled so bad when the old guy was in there? Was it the packages he put on their table? Or was it himself that smelled bad? I don't get it.
They ask for the judges opinion and when they give it to them they get pissed and say simon, sharon n louis don't know what they are talking about or tell them off on the camera when they leave
Lol did anyone notice thru blurred out Simons cigarette
The bloke in the booth looks like Burt Reynolds! Should sign him just for that!
Lots of them go solo from being in rubbish groups but I've never seen someone go solo and then bottle out of that and rejoin the group! Final part of the Mankind saga starts at 22:14
He knows more thwn you lot 😮
That girl was just as good as Peter. I hate it when people give special attention to blind people. I've talked to blind people before and THEY don't even like that either.
11:45 best Pauly shore act
I don't think they could comment on that woman's weight like that now. It's so wrong and now a days people would be rightly outraged by that. She's beautiful inside out and I really hope she didn't end up developing an eating disorder