she has such a driving force in the final movement... it's *SO* energetic! (Eg go to 5:42, I've never heard it played with such crispness) I really really hope this will be officially recorded one day!!
Hilary wore that dress when I saw her play the Tchaikovsky in D with the San Francisco Symphony! It's beautiful, just like her playing. :) I play cello, and am learning the transcription of the piece right now. Bravo!
Brilliant playing from this duo as always. I LOVE the way she ends the last note with a dramatic down stroke. It's like the large sweeping motion of a sword.
Cadencia y limpieza sonora impecable,un duo perfecto en esta interpretación. El lujo inolvidable de asistir a este momento por su paso por Buenos Aires.Hilary Hahn transmite musicalidad genuina.
Joya ver a dos genias una en el violín como Hilary y otra en el piano como Valentina , tiene un toque místico pero jamás pensé que se podrían acompañar , ambas tienes una idea muy diferente ya que al ser 2 solistas sus ideas no se comparten , más que ver una interpretación veo como una rencilla en quien se lleva las miradas es interesante.
Très belle interprétation de ces danses roumaines par la toute jeune violoniste américaine Hilary Hahn déjà coquette et par son accompagnatrice,malgré la prise de son !
people say u should be motionless & expressionless when playing the fiddle....well H.H. is a top player & her movements are a bonus as i see it...completely endearing...wouldn't be the same if she played standing there like a statue!!...as does heifetz etc!
True, I am Romanian, and claim to feel these songs a bit closer to my soul, as I grew up with these songs and her moves are quite the way these songs make me move when hearing them. It shows me she's got the gist of them, in and out! Great interpretation!
ameblo.jp/galwayera/entry-12178794174.html I am admitting there are several excellent solo piano performances of this Bartok's Rumanian folk dances like Elena or Kaori. But regarding this tune, I love the performance by violin and piano than piano solo. Hilary and Valentina even have expressed very joyful and festive scenery at the last quick dance. Although some people may think that their playing is pretty wild and rough, that is just their aim. This tune was composed by Bartok for the brave and decent farmers in East Europe. I think so.
Not to criticize all the Hungarians in here throwing a fit but how do you appropriately EVER capture the emotion in the voice of 70 year old men and women in the world left, who actually can recite like tunes? The emotion is there -- and you are missing it. Commemorating and memorializing the rich tradition of folk music from one of the most underrepresented areas with the powerful and technical brilliance of a violinist like HH. Emotion is truly subjective until you listen to HH -- then emotion is objective in the most convincing way. This is the true power of music - to win over the fresh-eared listener to look at the music they are listening to for the first time in a whole different way.
I'm Romanian from Voivodina. There are hardly any tonal characteristics in the violin here at all the resemble Romanian folk violin playing. The notes may be from Bartok but that's about it.
Bartók: Kakaska (Hahn) és Rókácska (Liszica). Tényleg kicsit lapos előadás, pedig mindkét hölgyet annyira imádom, de a hírnév sajnos nem minden. Az elsőbe annyi rubatót belenyomtak, hogy táncparódia lett belőle. Amíg Ojsztrach koloratúráiban ott van a pánsíp, itt csak üveghangokat hallok, ráadásul egy mélyebb húr is belekontárkodik egyszer (baki?). Az elégikus táncban (negyedik?) inkább andalúziai itt a feeling. A gyors zárótáncokban pedig a kíséret ringlispílre vagy diesel-hajómotorra hajaz, semmint egy ütőgardonos kontrajátékra. Kedveseim, vissza Ojsztrach-hoz és Kollegorszkajához, vagy ott van a Menuhin/Gazelle verzió, nekik még megadatott a lehetőség Bartókkal konzultálni a táncokat. (Hogy a magyar előadókat ne is említsem, mert az már maga a nirvána lenne.)
Mais quel dommage l'acoustique de la salle transforme le violon en crin crin ,quand au piano......Mais très belle interprétation de ces deux artistes!!
Hi SugarPlum Fairy! You sound fine! Valentina is fine ,but it sounds lake the piano ic coming out of a well. Recordings fine except for the piano sound-weird.How is Europe? I think thats Where You are?Hope You fiddle & fiddle around, and have lots of fun.I wonder if You read these comments?Sparkel! LvU lots & Prayer Dano (Dream A Little Of Me,song btdotknow singsit.)(I dream of a SugarPlumFairy dancing in My head)"Sh-Boom"Crew Cuts."Quiet Nights"Diana Krall.KYAO when You let Me.XOXO
Hahn is tasteful as ever, but why the cheat notes on the A string in IIIrd mvt. And what is the pianist doing? The music can well do without her drawing attention to herself, yuk!
I dont know what you meant by “cheat notes” but I doubt hilary has to cheat anything in any music. have you considered that maybe she used a different arranger than you have? and have considered that the violin isnt the only voice in this. Piano isnt just there for support its a partnership
It's so thoughtless to make a video with your phone at a concert like this. It's really an unacceptable distraction when you're sitting behind the person holding up the bright screen.
All the respect for Hahn, but this is the worse performance of Bartok ever played by professional musicians. Also very bad match between Valentina and Hahn.
I really like the two performers individually, but there was a lot of wrestling between the two regarding tempo. I think that undercut the interpretation.
@@jayspenceranderson yes that's what i meant as well. I respect both of them but this is lacking a lot of the energy that Bartok conveys. I would take Schwarzberg Gililov interpretation any day even with the shitty audio quality
she has such a driving force in the final movement... it's *SO* energetic!
(Eg go to 5:42, I've never heard it played with such crispness)
I really really hope this will be officially recorded one day!!
Hilary wore that dress when I saw her play the Tchaikovsky in D with the San Francisco Symphony! It's beautiful, just like her playing. :) I play cello, and am learning the transcription of the piece right now. Bravo!
Die beiden größten aktuellen Stars ,...in der Welt.🥰😍🤩
Two of classical music's greatest musicians performing together...brilliant!
My favorite pianist & my favorite violinist playing one of my favorite repertoire!
This is just GOLD!
This is simply incredible!! What a perfect match!
My favorite violonist and my favorite classical pianist playing my favorite piece ... where the hell was I 13 years ago !?
Brilliant playing from this duo as always.
I LOVE the way she ends the last note with a dramatic down stroke. It's like the large sweeping motion of a sword.
I wish there was a high quality version of this! It's beautiful :D
Watch David Ostrakh
Ça groove de fou dans le final !
Love these two working together! Charles Ives Sonatas are my favorite! This is a close second!....Terrific stuff!
One knock on my heart while the other talking to my soul. Fantastic!
DEVINE!
I love Bartók so much
Wow, just stunning.
I didn't know this so dramatic Bartok's piece! It's so beautiful too!
Hilary Hahn performs her magic for our immense pleasure.
Wonderfull traditional Romanian music! thank you!
Cadencia y limpieza sonora impecable,un duo perfecto en esta interpretación. El lujo inolvidable de asistir a este momento por su paso por Buenos Aires.Hilary Hahn transmite musicalidad genuina.
great playing! and i love her dress too :)
Hope this goes on their next CD!
Great! Didn't expect to see Lisitsa accompanying for Romanian songs. Both are great! And the moves of violonist, very into the songs!
Behind that beautiful dress Hilary is Dancing with passion and grace. She has said that she uses her legs to better feel music.
Joya ver a dos genias una en el violín como Hilary y otra en el piano como Valentina , tiene un toque místico pero jamás pensé que se podrían acompañar , ambas tienes una idea muy diferente ya que al ser 2 solistas sus ideas no se comparten , más que ver una interpretación veo como una rencilla en quien se lleva las miradas es interesante.
Great dress!
Très belle interprétation de ces danses roumaines par la toute jeune violoniste américaine Hilary Hahn déjà coquette et par son accompagnatrice,malgré la prise de son !
thanks for recording this!!!
Dos prodigios de la música me imagino a Paganini tocando con Franz Liszt jejejej que placer escucharlas hermoso sonido me encanta 😍
Wonderful. Great performance.
I really enjoyed this performance!
the gorgeous flowing glittering dress is beautiful
❤️💕💕
people say u should be motionless & expressionless when playing the fiddle....well H.H. is a top player & her movements are a bonus as i see it...completely endearing...wouldn't be the same if she played standing there like a statue!!...as does heifetz etc!
True, I am Romanian, and claim to feel these songs a bit closer to my soul, as I grew up with these songs and her moves are quite the way these songs make me move when hearing them. It shows me she's got the gist of them, in and out! Great interpretation!
Que Dios bendiga a estos genios de la interpretacion` musical, amen.
incredible
Divine
Briliant
o yes o yes o yes super
wow!
This is truly beautiful!
So far, noone has played this better than Scheryng.
rrjjyy, thanks for pointing that out. When Hilary Hahn invites you to accompany her in Berlin, we'll all be sure to listen to you play the right one!
Wow Valentina plays Accompaniment
Agreed... the drama just isn't there.... still beautiful in every respect though....
what a nice sounding violin, geeez
NightShadeslayer it’s not the violin, it’s her talent
ameblo.jp/galwayera/entry-12178794174.html
I am admitting there are several excellent solo piano performances of this Bartok's Rumanian folk dances like Elena or Kaori. But regarding this tune, I love the performance by violin and piano than piano solo. Hilary and Valentina even have expressed very joyful and festive scenery at the last quick dance. Although some people may think that their playing is pretty wild and rough, that is just their aim. This tune was composed by Bartok for the brave and decent farmers in East Europe. I think so.
2:22 ....4:51 ... favorite
Not to criticize all the Hungarians in here throwing a fit but how do you appropriately EVER capture the emotion in the voice of 70 year old men and women in the world left, who actually can recite like tunes? The emotion is there -- and you are missing it. Commemorating and memorializing the rich tradition of folk music from one of the most underrepresented areas with the powerful and technical brilliance of a violinist like HH. Emotion is truly subjective until you listen to HH -- then emotion is objective in the most convincing way. This is the true power of music - to win over the fresh-eared listener to look at the music they are listening to for the first time in a whole different way.
I'm Romanian from Voivodina. There are hardly any tonal characteristics in the violin here at all the resemble Romanian folk violin playing. The notes may be from Bartok but that's about it.
gott damn. nice ending
Yes i know....
Beautiful performance. Sometimes the piano is too loud.
'de-se-personaliser' - á votre profit , c'est 'signum du génie d'elle
The twosetters wont find us here
Bartók: Kakaska (Hahn) és Rókácska (Liszica). Tényleg kicsit lapos előadás, pedig mindkét hölgyet annyira imádom, de a hírnév sajnos nem minden. Az elsőbe annyi rubatót belenyomtak, hogy táncparódia lett belőle. Amíg Ojsztrach koloratúráiban ott van a pánsíp, itt csak üveghangokat hallok, ráadásul egy mélyebb húr is belekontárkodik egyszer (baki?). Az elégikus táncban (negyedik?) inkább andalúziai itt a feeling. A gyors zárótáncokban pedig a kíséret ringlispílre vagy diesel-hajómotorra hajaz, semmint egy ütőgardonos kontrajátékra. Kedveseim, vissza Ojsztrach-hoz és Kollegorszkajához, vagy ott van a Menuhin/Gazelle verzió, nekik még megadatott a lehetőség Bartókkal konzultálni a táncokat. (Hogy a magyar előadókat ne is említsem, mert az már maga a nirvána lenne.)
Igaz.
Someone has the score of this, or knows where to find it?? I would love to play it!
Thanks a lot! Adios
Try imslp
Its in the sixth book of "solos for young artists". I played it a while back
Its the last piece in the book... Lol im the same person as ^^^^ just switched accounts... This is my violin acc. Lol :-))
Try musescore
Mais quel dommage l'acoustique de la salle transforme le violon en crin crin ,quand au piano......Mais très belle interprétation de ces deux artistes!!
good but I recommend a listen to Kocsis and Barnabás's rendition, that's truly moving
watch?v=XX-XJdnu1I4
SOUNDS LIKE = EXODUS
@rrrjjjyyy She definitely did not hit a wrong note.
Hi SugarPlum Fairy! You sound fine! Valentina is fine ,but it sounds lake the piano ic coming out of a well. Recordings fine except for the piano sound-weird.How is Europe? I think thats Where You are?Hope You fiddle & fiddle around, and have lots of fun.I wonder if You read these comments?Sparkel! LvU lots & Prayer Dano (Dream A Little Of Me,song btdotknow singsit.)(I dream of a SugarPlumFairy dancing in My head)"Sh-Boom"Crew Cuts."Quiet Nights"Diana Krall.KYAO when You let Me.XOXO
Live recordings are often fraught
Hahn is tasteful as ever, but why the cheat notes on the A string in IIIrd mvt. And what is the pianist doing? The music can well do without her drawing attention to herself, yuk!
I dont know what you meant by “cheat notes” but I doubt hilary has to cheat anything in any music. have you considered that maybe she used a different arranger than you have? and have considered that the violin isnt the only voice in this. Piano isnt just there for support its a partnership
maybe people dont know him well....
Not quite the best rendition of the Romanian Dances. I'm not a specialist but Oistrakh's version is way better in my opinion.
So ?
who the fuck takes a phone video on a classical music concert?
me :)
And that’s always better than nothing...
not enough aggression
lose
50000 views for Ms Hahn, 35 views for Mr Szeryng. Shows all the things wrong with this world.
Tymur Melnyk and 1'000'000'000 for justin bieber...
and 5 000 000 000 for despacito.
Now (1019/07/04) it is 152,000 for Hahn and 254,000 for Szering. Has the world changed?
Nonsense
@@eduardobarbabosa4846 now 7 million smh
It's so thoughtless to make a video with your phone at a concert like this. It's really an unacceptable distraction when you're sitting behind the person holding up the bright screen.
All the respect for Hahn, but this is the worse performance of Bartok ever played by professional musicians. Also very bad match between Valentina and Hahn.
Jean Valjean that’s your opinion... and the sound is a disaster
You judge on the basis of a live recording!
I really like the two performers individually, but there was a lot of wrestling between the two regarding tempo. I think that undercut the interpretation.
@@jayspenceranderson yes that's what i meant as well. I respect both of them but this is lacking a lot of the energy that Bartok conveys. I would take Schwarzberg Gililov interpretation any day even with the shitty audio quality