Harp comparison : Lewis Creek Nightingale, Marini Bass LAP, Dusty Strings FH26x2
Вставка
- Опубліковано 7 сер 2024
- Here's your chance to see and hear 3 beautiful small haps. Meet the Lewis Creek Nightingale (27 strings), the Marini Made Bass LAP (28 strings) and the Dusty Strings FH26x2 double strung. We'll compare string spacing, harp weight, ways to play, string range and of course the sound of each harp to help you find a perfect fit for your small harp needs.
🔸 CHAPTERS
0:00 Introduction
1:54 String spacing
3:05 Weight of each harp
3:37 How to play: strap or stand
4:35 Hear the Lewis Creek Nightingale (27 strings)
5:50 Hear the Marini Made Bass LAP harp (28 strings)
6:55 Hear the Dusty Strings double strung (26x2 strings)
🔸 MICROPHONES USE
Narration: Shure MV88 on iPhone
Harps: Warm WA-84 and Sennheiser E914
🔸 Lewis Creek Nightingale
www.lewiscreek.net/lc_hg_nigh...
🔸 Marini Made Bass LAP harp
www.marinimadeharps.com/bass-...
🔸 Dusty Strings FH26x2 double strung
manufacturing.dustystrings.co...
🔸 Harp sheet music "A Simple Wish"
musicdiscoveries.shop/product...
Thanks for watching!
♫ Anne
🎶 ABOUT
My name is Anne Crosby Gaudet, I'm a music educator, composer and independent publisher from Nova Scotia, Canada. I am passionate about creative teaching and lifelong learning at the piano and harp.
🎶 MUSIC DISCOVERIES SHOP
www.musicdiscoveries.shop
The Music Discoveries Shop specializes in piano and harp music that is carefully crafted with teachable moments and thoughtful expression. Explore beautiful music that you can instantly download, print and play.
🎶 MUSIC DISCOVERIES COURSES
musicdiscoveries.podia.com/
Enjoy step-by-step courses to help you learn the harp. Courses will guide you through the basics, skills and artistry phases of learning my compositions and arrangements.
🎶 ONLINE HARP LESSONS
musicdiscoveries.podia.com/on...
Interested in private harp lessons? Learn more about personalized online harp lessons where I can provide structure, support and guidance for your unique path at the harp.
🎶 NEWSLETTER
eepurl.com/dmK4hH
Receive weekly emails and be the first to know about new harp sheet music, videos, courses, helpful learning resources and special offers.
FOLLOW
✭ Facebook: / musicdiscoveries
✭ Instagram: / musicdiscoveriesca
✭ UA-cam: / annecrosbygaudetmusicd...
LISTEN
✭ Spotify: open.spotify.com/artist/52wdn...
✭ Apple Music: / anne-crosby-gaudet
✭ iTunes: / anne-crosby-gaudet
✭ Amazon Music: music.amazon.ca/artists/B08DB...
✭ Deezer: www.deezer.com/us/artist/1014...
#harpcomparison #smallharpcomparison #leverharpcomparison
Copyright © 2021 Anne Crosby Gaudet
✅ CHAPTERS
0:00 Introduction
1:54 String spacing
3:05 Weight of each harp
3:37 How to play: strap or stand
4:35 Hear the Lewis Creek Nightingale (27 strings)
5:50 Hear the Marini Made Bass LAP harp (28 strings)
6:55 Hear the Dusty Strings double strung (26x2 strings)
Love the format to your video very easy to follow
Great examples
Thank you for sharing
Glad it was helpful ❤️
Fabulous job as always, Anne! I am harp-lusting for that Marini Bass LAP!
Those low strings on a small harp are awesome aren't they!
Very helpful, Anne! All three are lovely and unique instruments 💕
They are all lovely aren't they? And it's easy to see why we "need" so many harps 🤣
They all sounded really good. I love their tones.
They are all beautiful little harps, but each one has its own unique voice.
I love that your Marini Made goes down to Bass F while still being so light! And when you began to play your Dusty, I just about melted from the sound! All 3 sound really fantastic. :)
Thank you, I appreciate that! I really did my best to get a beautiful but true recording for each instrument.
As usual, very helpful for those of us always shopping!
Happy to help!
I like the Dusty String. I’m partial. Waiting for mine due in December. However, I never thought about spacing and physical abilities. Knowing information like that when I was a new beginner definitely would have made choosing a beginners harp much easier. Thank you!
Are you getting a Dusty double strung? Yay!
I love your videos and your music 😍 TY
Thank-you!
Thank you for this video, very helpful. I appreciate that they're all the same wood, since that affects the sound. Also, cherry is one of my favorite woods to hear.
Glad it was helpful! I love the sound of cherry too!
How wonderful..., thank you so much for sharing this. These are amazing little ones, a pleasure to babysit.
I just bought the small "Seraphin" harp from the german harpbuilder Pepe Weissgerber. It has 27 strings made of gut and a great sound. I enjoy playing your arrangements and beeing on the move with it.
Oh I just looked up the Seraphin, it looks and sounds lovely!
I was waiting for a video like that! Thank you, that helps a lot.
So glad it was helpful! Do you have questions?
@@annecrosbygaudetmusic No, I had the chance to hear the sound differrences in one video, which was the most important thing for me.
Beautiful
Thank you Ann this was of help to me
Oh good, so glad to hear that Ruth!
Hello Anne this is really a wunderful comparison. All three are really good harps. I like the Dustx most. Greatings Nicole
Thanks for stopping by to listen, Nicole!
Thank you for the comparison! I hope you get to babysit the Marini 24x2 double strung harp one of these days so you can do a comparison of it with the Dusty Strings double strung:) Would love to hear it!
That would be a super fun comparison!
Thanks so much
You're welcome!
Thanks for the demonstration, Anne! I have a Lewis Creek Jessie Nightingale. It weighs 7 pounds - it's made of sassafras wood, which is probably lighter than the wood on the harp you demonstrated. And it has a big sound as well! For me anyway, the Nightingale is the best small harp I've ever had, and it took me about 7 years to find the right harp for my therapeutic music practice.
Yes, it sounds very warm and is one of the best choices for therapeutic music! I played it for a long time and I still love the sound! If you want a bit more bass, the Marini might be the right choice. And the Dusty double ist so different, that you can`t compare it with the others, is my opinion. I`m waiting to play it.
The Jessie Nightingale is such a nice choice for a therapeutic harp! I can see why you are happy with it!
You're right, these three harps serve quite different purposes, but then people choose a small harp for different reasons. I find it fun to compare harps when the opportunity arises.
Ah, that was a wonderful comparison! I would have to say that The Dusty comes in first (in my opinion) in terms of sound (very clear) & resonance. The Marini, second with its sweet & very relaxing tone, & light weight. And, lastly the Lewis Creek Nightingale, which also has a very sweet tone, perfect for bedside playing. Thanks Anne for doing this comparison!🎶🎶👍👍
Gloria, yes I think you narrowed down the most beautiful feature of each harp!
I think they each sound lovely in their own way. If I could babysit sit one of them I would choose the double strung harp. I've never played one but it would be fun to try it out and see what it's like.
Leann, I have a hunch you would create some beautiful music on a double strung!
Thank you!
You’re welcome Irene 😊
Anne, thank you so much for posting this video. It was nice to hear the three harps and your music. I love your arrangements! They all sound gorgeous. I have a Dusty double and Marini bass LAP on order. This is a wonderful opportunity you have provided for all of us who are considering these harps.
Could you please tell me how you would rate them in tension, lightest to heaviest? Please keep your beautiful music coming. I listen to you every night before I go to sleep. Thank you for sharing your talents. 🥰
Oooo, you have some lovely harps on the way! I didn't talk about string tension because really they are so similar, I'd describe them as on the light side of medium tension. They can all be played gently to achieve a sweet, soothing sound (which as you know is my prefered style).
They are all lovely…each one quite distinct.
3 different harp personalities! I love them all for different reasons.
@@annecrosbygaudetmusic yes, I didn’t have a favourite, all so beautiful.
I had so much fun babysitting the Lewis Creek Nightingale this weekend! If you could wave a magic wand, which of these three harps would you choose to babysit for a few days?
I like the tone of the Marini made harp.
I love the sound of the Lewis Creek. I'd want try out the string spacing and tension. Thanks for the video
They are all beautiful, but my favourite definitely is the Dusty Strings. I own a FH36S myself (cherry of course). When ever I have the possibility of trying other harps the result is: "For once in my life I made the right decision."
The extra low notes on the Marini are worthwhile but I like the sound of the Lewis Creek better. Would I miss the extra strings, I wonder. Bottom line is, the sound matters most. I have small hands and arthritis so the small spacing would be a plus.
@@lyndavonkanel8603 Sounds like a Stoney End Lorraine might be a good choice for you.
Thank you, Anne! This is a well done harp comparison! I always wanted a Nightingale and I still love its sound. However, I now have a new respect for the Dusty Strings. About 8 years ago when I was first shopping for a harp I tried a Dusty Strings full size harp and didn't like the sound of it in the mid range. I don't remember what model it was but it left a lasting impression toward all Dusty Strings harps. I just love the sound of your double strung harp and might just end up owning one. I live in the Pacific NW and Dusty Strings is in my backyard, so to speak. Time for a road trip!!
Thanks Cheryl! There are a lot of Dusty Strings owners in my area so I've heard quite a few different models and each one sounds unique. A road trip to the Dusty showroom sounds like fun!
I remember not liking dusty strings, the name seemed apt like the strings were old and dampened, but then I heard a SUPER LOUD resonant one, not sure which model, wow that impressed me.
@@StaringCompetition Ray Mooers, founder of Dusty Strings, started building dulcimers in 1977. By this time the interest in dulcimers and other folk instruments was growing and people started playing on old instruments that had been stored in attics for some time, therefore "Dusty Strings". The harps came later (early eighties).
Definitely visit Dusty Strings if you’re in the Pacific Northwest! I have a Dusty FS36 in Bubinga! Nothing beats its tone and resonance!
If I had a magic wand, I'd wave it to find a Marini Bass lap harp to tinker with for a few days. My favorite was the Dusty Strings double strung, but I don't know how to play a double strung! (But maybe I could use the magic wand to magically know how to play it...) I'm overthinking this! Lol! Then, I'd wave the again to put a spell on Dusty Strings, and they'd send me a Ravenna 34 free of charge! ;) Thank you for the video, Anne!
You make me laugh, Rebecca 🤣 Hope you have a magical day!
Great comparison! I love these videos!
Thanks Amelia! They are fun to do!
Anne, this was SO informative! Thank you for doing this - such a difference in sound. Quick question for you - does it mess with your brain and fingers when the string spacing is different from the harp you usually play?
Great, I'm glad the video was helpful! It messed with my brain to quickly move between these three harps, but it really doesn't take long to adapt. That being said, I personally prefer a wider string spacing for my long fingers!
It's awesome playing and do we have to change the lever or bridge pin or tuning pins if it's broken
Can you make a video on comparing the harpcicle to other small harps? Especially the string spacing since that seems to be the topic on everybody’s mind when they think of the harpcicle.
I've had quite a few Harpsicles over the years, but I don't own one currently.
Wow - all are lovely. I was prepared to like one in particular - but they all have a beautiful tone. BTW the Lewis Creek also has a stand available to match the wood choice. It's sturdy and yet folds mostly flat for transport. I'm assuming they all have wound lower strings?
Thanks Jill! Glad you mentioned the Lewis Creek stand, I looked on the website, but didn't see that option. Good to know!
Thank you for the wonderful comparison and the great playing! While watching, I was wondering: What's the material of the levers of your Nightingale and are you still playing the Christina? I missed it in the video!
I could be wrong on this, but I believe the Nightingale had gold plated Camac levers. They are VERY nice! I actually sold my Christina a few months ago, which is why it wasn't in this comparison video.
This was fun, They are all so lovely, but the figured cherry wood... it has become stunning in my opinion. i like the tone the best also from the DStrings. I believe they have a single 26 string harp,
It was fun to make this video (but you should have seen the chaos in my studio on Friday and Saturday!) I agree, the figured cherry is amazing... I'm dreaming of an FH36S in cherry someday. Yes, they do have an FH26 single row, which is the same body as my double strung.
@@annecrosbygaudetmusic by the way because you've measured the string spacing on those lap harps I went and measured mine and my lap harp is 7 in and a quarter Maybe. Mine is the sonnet music-makers lap harp. I am convinced now, I like dusty's now even more, seriously thinking about selling mine and finding a 26 string cherry DString lap harp
@@debw2635 Yes, that measurement makes sense. I thought the Sonnet string spacing was on the narrow end of the spectrum. Interesting isn't it?
@@annecrosbygaudetmusic it is interesting, and an important factor since everyone's hands are different, would be nice if the manufacturer would advertise the spacing length, save us all from regrets possibly 😊
Hi Anne, If I could wave a magic wand I would have all three! I love love love the tone of the Nightengale. I am terribly curious about the Marini and hope to put my hands on one very soon. Thank you so much for this videos! I am a much better aspiring harpist because of your compositions and videos. Always looking forward to more of your videos!
Yes, all 3 please! LOL The Nightingale is so lovely to play! I'm looking forward to doing a few more recordings before it needs to go home.
@@annecrosbygaudetmusic Tell them it ran away from home smile :)
Can u do a video on juno 27 salvi and Marini 22 strings '
:) thank you so much for sharing! This was so informative!
Would you say it was more comfortable wearing the Marini Lap Harp or the Nightingale harp? I see the Marini has a curve and the other doesnt. Did it make a difference?
You're welcome, glad it was helpful. I could easily wear either harp, they are roughly the same weight. The Marini is large or course, but I think weight is the bigger factor if wearing it for a few hours at a time.
Thank you,! I especially appreciate the string spacing comparison. What about string tension? Were they all about the same?
The string tension is similar on all three, though I feel I play each one with a slightly different touch to get the sound I want.
I’m curious, how is it transitioning from a single row to the double strung? How was it to learn double strung? I have a Dusty FH36S in Bubinga, an Allegro 26, and just ordered an FH26 double strung in Bubinga. I’ve never played a double strung.
Do these harps play a chromatic scale? Do they play in all keys? thank you
Hi Anne! I have the Marini Bass on order in figured Cherry with walnut Burl soundboard.❤️🎵. I’m curious - which of these do you like best for sound?
I like them all, but for different reasons!
what kind of microphone did you use for this recording? it sounds beautiful!
Thanks! I used the Warm WA-84 on the harps.
Interesting. You mentioned the wood of the Dusty but not of the other two harps. Can you do that? Also are the soundboards of different material? Thanks
I think I mentioned early in the video that all three are made from cherry. I believe the soundboard of the Marini is aircraft birch.
Oh gosh I missed that somehow. Thanks!!
Hi Anne, Thanks for this comparison video. I want to order a harp this week. My question is to help me decide which harp. I have opportunity to get a figured cherry DS fh26, used, pristine, with financing and $500 under list price for a new one. single strung. my other choice is fullsicle se, walnut with extras in the pkg. I like the richer sounds, but also like the portability of the fullsicle. the DS fh26 is heavier and not as easily portable. but, probably a good deal. I am a chaplain and would like to off r harp at weddings, and do harp therapy. what are your 1st thoughts? the DS would look better at weddings. is the sound of the DS way nicer and warm than the fullsicle?
Did you make a decision? Both lovely harps!
@@annecrosbygaudetmusic The DS was sold in a heartbeat. That's okay. It currently takes 6-7 months to get a Lewis Creek harp. So, I went with the Fullsicle. They can be purchased in packages and I ordered the therapy pkg. 8 weeks awaiting, now! I think in a couple of years, I likely will want a 2nd harp. I will mknow more about what I would want for a 2nd harp, then.
I noticed my Stoney End lap harp got better tone after a year! You can’t compare your new Marini with a harp that’s a year older or more. Like us, we get better with age!! 😆
Your Marini just needs time and it will sound as rich as the Lewis Creek. Which sounds the richest. I remember when you received your double string, it sounds beautiful and will be even more beautiful with time.
Quite true, that's why I mentioned the age of each harp.
@@annecrosbygaudetmusic and just downloaded your beautiful arrangement! A Simple Wish 💕
@@annmaes7550 Wonderful, thank-you!
So I see three harps Lewis Creek ale Nightingale the Marini made base lap heart and the dusty strings double straw harp. It’s a lot of instruments but just three harps one of those I really would love to get a bigger heart to find a bigger heart would be expensive I know it is expensive, I would see that I would like a harp with 34 strings that is also made by Dusty strings like a Ravenna 34 sure one of those how many strings no matter how many strings are has most harps have 47 strings but I want my heart to have 3634 or 38 strings I probably could contact Dusty strings and see if they’ll send me a 34 string harp which would be really incredible. I have never had a bigger heart and seem to appreciate your taste in music. I wonder what streams I wonder what Dusty strings has in store for me down the road, lucky get a harp with 3438 string. I would like to get any harp. Probably anyone my heart desires I know and.