Merrisa Meda you do realize that its not the company's fault tho? Shannon had way better promotions compared to DIA's debut. she always guest on radio shows. something DIA never had. and yet she never became popular. in short, koreans doesnt like her that much.
Yeah it's hard for a Westerner artist to success in Korea. Just like it's hard for an Asian artist to success in US-UK. I think Jeon Somi of JYP was feeling the same before. But JYPE have more experience than many other agencies about how to work with these foreigners and make them become stars, they know how to make Korean audiences accept them so that Somi had the chance to prove it following JYP's formula. I hope Shannon will join JYP and well maybe she will team up with Somi and Lily Morrow lol. That would be the Avengers team!
Aldous Kim Oh yeah of course. It's both parts. Not many people like Shannon because of her attitude and personality, but she has since been more humble. MBK overall is a bad company and I think she could be more popular somewhere else.
someone saw the episode in raw and said that JYP didn't choose her and give her a FAIL and I KNOW it's because JYP hate when singer push too hard when they sing..:/ I LOVE SHANNON VOICE but he prefere when they sing groovy or delicatly, I hope in the next step she will make him change his mind (she should sing a gayo song) sorry for my bad eglish ^^"
jazzy licolia I think better wait for the subbed version and watch again. In the previous seasons of Kpop Star he rejected many ppl too but also give them good advice. Then in the next rounds they use his advice to improve and surprise all the 3 judges.
@@yuchan9755 The entire show he was only impressed when she performed one of his songs. Seems like he was more insecure his artists can’t sing like this.
I can tell she lost her color after being in MBK...and she knows it too. You can see it in her eyes that she doesn't know what to do at this point. It's all or nothing for her. Honestly, I hope she leaves and goes into a smaller, secure and creative company that allows to bring back her inner colors and passion. She has such a gift at only 18 years old.
What is sad is Shannon just does not look fresh faced anymore. When she debuted, you can tell she is enjoying it. But now, not anymore. She is still good though.
really? ok she's not bad but looking to last seasons stars I kind of think her voice whist technically clear has a little bit of narrow range I;m not trying to troll or anything but its well you listen and there is something missing in her voice that doesn't draw you in, and because of this can't actually call her on of this seasons fav's
ram64man lol she sang opera when she was younger and did musicals, she has a really wide range actually 😂 maybe it wasnt clearly shown in this show but you should check her videos out (like star king)
I didn't know her but now I listened to this and I think that she is amazing. Everyone has its own start and I guess hers was this show? Anyways, it was a good place to show her talent although I don't know much about this show... And she looks cute with her outfit and hair, I like it
She knows it that she can't enjoy singing anymore she feels like she's a machine that constantly has to sing perfectly she's hurting and when jyp saw right through her she felt like she found hope. Love you Shannon been with you since your early days before debut and always will !!!!
she was amazing...I loved her ever since I saw her in Star King...her voice in this perf was great, but i think she did lack in conveying the emotions of the song to her audience. There are singers that have a great technique especially in belting out high notes, but lack the capability to allow the audience to feel and understand the song. I think she's still struggling to find out how to do that now unlike when she first performed Daybreak Rain (I love that song ♥) I can relate to her in a way. When I sing I become too conscious of my technique (ie. breathing, pitch, and even facial expression) that I tend to forget what singing is all about. It's about telling a story through your song. She's still young and has great potential. I hope she finds a good coach to help her improve more :)
Ari Ni People have been sleeping on this gem for so long. I'm glad she's given this great opportunity and gets signed in a better company. It's Shannon's time to shine! 😍👏 Tzuyu x Shannon I love them both and I hope they will be in one company.
YES im so happy shannon is becoming a trainee again. Hopefully she picks the label that will promote her for the recognition she needs. Shes so underrated.
Last I checked she's still technically w/ MBK, so she's prob not becoming a trainee again unless she gets another company to void her contract. She's prob auditioning for the chance to get a song from each company since this season allows both trainees and already debuted artists to audition
I REALLY DO FELT SO PROUD AS A LONG TIME FAN OF SHANNON AND TODAY, I JUST REALIZED IVE BEEN USING SHANNON'S PHOTO FOR SO LONG ALREADY AND NEVER BEEN CHANGED IT.
Tess Tran singing like they are telling a story...it touches your soul. you know those singers like lee sun hee, gummy, kim taewong, hwanhee etc baek ji young
She deserves to be in an agency that promotes her the way she deserves because she is really really talented. I've known her for a long time and I've also been waiting for her to finally shine. I hope she gets her place in the kpop industry now! Shannon fighting!!!!!
Shannon is an amazing singer, people might be mad at JYP for critizing her but he is right. And what's funny is that she actually agrees with him. If you want to get better you will have to look at what you're doing wrong. She deserves more recognition!
I just listened to Ariana and after seeing this I clicked on it and wow all I can say is that the girl is amazing! She did so well woah.. I love Jae's reaction. I'll check up her own songs!
I wanna say that even Shannon admitted that she was shocked that he pointed out her flaws that she KNEW. that's why she wanted to come to kpopstar to hear what the judges had to say and now she got it. she obviously wants to improve so the harsh words will be good for her.
This makes me feel so sad. When Shannon just debuted, you can see her enjoying the stage. No matter if it was her own song promotion or on Hidden Singer, you can see it in her eyes. But after all the shit she went through and the negligence faced from MBK, she's like soulless looking. I really hope Shannon gets appreciated more T_T be more happy.
Shannon did a great job of singing this song. Whenever I hear one of the judges's start talking about singing from the heart, I think of the quote from the American Comedian George Burns, who said something to the effect of "The secret of being a successful actor is sincerity. Once you can fake that, you've got it made." I think maybe if at times she had sung the song less strongly and shown more vulnerability at times, her singing would have been viewed as more sincere.
jyp should give more advice's to twice on their singing skills cus Shanon got talent he hopes they could sing like her. she's pretty plus she can sing you can jst know when someone loves music n try their best
Sorry I'm just mad at the fact that he criticizes others harshly while he debuts a group that aren't that strong vocally.talking about how she don't feel the music she singing to, me it seems that she does jst saying doe.
Shannon cried because she knows that she lacks emotion in her singing which was what JYP basically meant. How can you be a singer when all you do is sing what's on the paper? she a great singer but didn't you see that she was just trying to hit all the notes that she needed without the feelings in it? Beside you didn't watch SIXTEEN which TWICE was in because if you did watch it you can see that JYP also critised the member's abilities too. I'm sorry that he is honest and wants your unnie to become a better artist.
ABBY: Hm. It's interesting to think that JYP said any of this because he wants Shannon to be successful. I think that listening to the audio independently of the video and without all these comments about "singing like a machine" nobody would have even mentioned it. I'm not a fan of Shannon, but I don't think that her singing is mechanical. I also don't think that SIXTEEN is a reliable reference for how accurate or founded JYP's criticism is. He's not a vocal coach, he's a producer and a CEO. He has a public image that he's been trying to cultivate for a long time. One where he is seen as exacting, even harsh at times, but ultimately knows what's best and can always fix a person's flaws with a few 'deep' sentences. I think that he doesn't care about Shannon at all. He simply wants to further this image, so he picks apart a performance which otherwise would have been pretty quality. What do you think about this line of analysis?
I'm in tears, seeing Shannon here, I hope the best for her, I want her to be more famous before, not because she's from one of the big three companies, but because she's really talented.
i pretty much just came for jason's song because it's such a beautiful and dAMN IT'S A HARD SONG TO SING AND SHE MAKES IT SEEM EFFORTLESS YOU GO GIRL YOU HAVE SO MUCH TALENT
Kailee Broadway she and lee hi can be a duo like davichi. I think both she and lee hi are opposite in vocal aspects but if yg can make it happen, its a new for kpop. I'm really disappointed in mbk for not appreciating her talent and the wasted time she was in there.
Doesn't anyone else find it odd that when she sang I Dreamed a Dream in Hidden Singer, Shannon practically moved people to tears and here, the main criticism was that she sang it so professionally that it didn't seem like she had emotions? I think the long years she spent with MBK really affected her.
Ariana wrote this song explaining her relationship with Scooter Braun, and to me I feel like this song fits Shannon so well. Shannon expressed her talent and feelings through the song very well.
lol everyone is telling she fits jyp and here i am saying YG papa u need her after losing bom ! lee hi and her would make the earth shatter with their voices combined so def want her in YG !
Isn't she good in Jyp too? I think she'd be good in JYP or in YG, how much does it matter? I'm just asking (I don't know much about the way how the both Entertainments work tbh) But Lee Hi and her would be really great if I think about it
I love Shannon!! I hope she goes far!! She did seem really nervous as her voice shook a bit at the end but I know she can be flawless when needed!! 😍 Been a fan since her first single! Go Shannon!
cantwaitforthis meh so why do this then she should of quote her contract seriously MBK isn't good if she's with a bigger better company then she'll be able to shine more plus more pay check to be honest
+Shaz Green kpop star let already debuted singers and trainee of other company to be able to apply this time because this is going to be last season of kpop star and also called "kpop star the last chance". purpose is thay because many idol group or singers debut but not get best attention. also, many trainees work hard waiting their chance to debut.. (if they get positive reaction from this, they will get debuted faster). Plus, the tv program called 'produce101' with tons of trainees was hit. so it is good chance for the kpop star itself to gain more attention from viewer as last season had lower view. It is win win reasons.
+Shaz Green Not all the cases but usually it is not easy for trainees to move their company because the companies put their money to train them. so because of that groups debuted from not top 3 company get their money much later than their debut in order to pay back the cost for train. there is a case that they need to 'pay' to move as there is contract for trainees too. but especially I dont think company that has shannon (?) or other applicants(havent watched this yet) will let her or he go easily if they get attention by this program. they will try to not let them go. so maybe you should pray yg or jyp to find them very attractive but they fail the show. ;p Additionally, cost for moving their company for 'already debuted aritist' with contract is much expensive. for example, Jay park had to pay 2 hundred bilion to get loco out of previous company and before his first single at aomg, he was not even famous or had any hitted song...
MidnightAshess Maybe you should actually listen to her lol. Her voice is consistently well placed and often resonant. The only problem here is the repeated belting on the "aye" vowel, but other than that she did fine. In her Breath performance(on Kpopstar) she was able to maintain resonance while phrasing D5s and Eb5s without any trouble. Shannon's biggest issue is that she doesn't pick the best songs for her, but I guess her choice is getting better.
It's not like JYP is better (look in 15&, Park Jimin, Bernard Park, G.Soul, Day6, Miss A...). Anyway, she's still from MBK. This season they will only be promoted for 1 year by the three agencies and back to original after this :)
dousuga but if she wants recognition then she should stick with YG. JYP needs a lot of media plays for his groups to get some boosts like sixteen etc. YG only posts who's next teasers and everyone is legit crazy
Aldous Kim well actually YG also does that kind of thing like when they did win and also mix&match. They also needed a media boost, sixteen also was because they already had their group but it disbanned bcs 2 of them left. But we need to admit that the two companies are guaranteed to start with a big fanbase if they debut a new group.
I feel like people are taking what Jyp said the wrong way. Some people may find it harsh but he wasn't completely lying. Hopefully this show helps her.
If she gets booted from the show in the second round I'm going to be pissed. She's the best singer this show has EVER had. I don't care what kind of excuse JYP comes up with. If you're that good JYP, help the girl break out of the funk she's in!
I'm not saying this to diss shannon but, I don't think she'll get far in kpop star. She's a great singer and that's it. There's nothing unique about her except her appearance which is probably why her solo career didn't last. Although, if she trained under JYP with Somi, she might have a chance at debuting in a group as the main vocal.
Doesn't mean all small companies are bad. She unfortunately got into a company that didn't not how to promote her or help her. Antenna is a small company and maybe not as popular but they have really good artists that let them do their own stuff. Rainbowbridge has Mamamoo & BigHit. I think it really depends on the company and how they look out for their artists. Don't like how MBK is hardly doing anything for her.
Shannon just wasn't doing well as a solo artist. I saw her on many variety shows. She had her chance to make an appeal for herself, but just didn't get popular. That's another thing. You'll get your opportunities in the beginning but if you don't become popular, the broadcasting companies won't invite you back to their shows. The companies you mentioned have groups, and as i've said in my original post, if she joins a group she may have a better chance, but not as a solo artists.
I think it's best that she join antenna because at least there they won't lock her up in the dungeon. They would really nurture her talent and let her be exposed to the world.
I think she fit in jyp. I think jyp could help her improve. I'm looking forward to jyps new group trainee line up in a few more years! jyp has so many half Korean trainees tho 😁
hahahahahahahaha so JYP said all that things about Shannon and her voice, but it's okay because it's no the first time he wrong about an artist. She has so much talent, personality and charisma. Maybe she will become the next CL, Hyorin, IU... Good luck
Meli RV also his new girl group has way less vocal talent then Shannon in my opinion. I think his version of talent is very different from my point of view.
Meli RV non jypnation stans truly will never understand j.y. park he got his reasons and he said them so many times if yall dont like him nor his choices then ok but dont go around saying he doesn't know what talent is when there's so many jyp artists w talent (if yall didn't know rapping and dancing r talents then now u know) and he got amazing vocalist too. park jimin, baek yerin, baek ayeon, minjun, yeeun, all of day6, nayeon and the list just go on.
***** I am sorry, I believe I may have phrased my statement in a way that is way to open to interpretation. I am a fan of Twice by all means and I made no statement to even remotely state that his other artists are "untalented." I must admit that my use of the term, the " rest of the world" is a generalization (I apologize) but you need to admit that in terms of sheer vocal ability Shannon is gifted. Now, I understand the importance of uniqueness, and musicality along with the ability to compose music and I understand that Mr. Park has the right his opinions and so do you, but please don't speak to me that way. It's my prerogative to state my opinion in a respectful way (no antagonizing undertones). Emphasis on the word respectful. Also, just as you said (I'm interpreting this as I couldn't quite understand what you wrote), but you said that criticism is good and I totally agree. We don't grow without criticism so I think Shannon has even more opportunity to grow, but my criticism of Mr. Park is also valid -at least that is what you seem to have expressed in your final statement- so I would appreciate if you wouldn't speak to me with such an accusatory tone.
Linh KelfPi he didn't say anything bad tho, she admitted it, she can't sing with emotions anymore. And JYPE have incredible vocalists, from Jokwon to Jihyo, all the generations have beautiful and unique voices (:
After 3 years, i come back again for this and i always stan for shannon, u deserves better. For me u deserves more than just an idol. International class
lmao i don't understand why everyone is hating on jyp and saying he knows nothing. face it- he knows more about singing and producing stars than all of us combined.
+Jay Pascua hosting an english show and going on 1 singing show for 2 years isnt promo its stupid. the public barely knows her bcuz he doesnt put her on shows
Shannon really should have been put in a group. It's sad that things ended up this way for her. That said JYP is not gonna take her so I don't know why people keep thinking that's gonna happen.
Subarashi Cat he said she sings like a machine. I agree, she is a good singer but I'm not getting the same feeling from her as I did when that little girl who sang Adele's song. She's missing the artistry part in her singing which is different from being able to do vocal flairs. A good example of this is Janis Ian's "at seventeen", she doesn't use a bunch of techniques but you can feel the pain in every word she sings.
Katherine Darnell this song isnt one to be sung with pain though..... its a song thats to be sung in a "i can do better" way lol. theres no pain to be heard here
***** I wasn't saying she needed to sing it painfully I was saying she needed to sing it with better emotion and tact. If she was in a group she would be covered by other members helping to disguise the shortcoming and it would give her time to improve.
Jyp is debuting a new gg soon. It would be beneficial if she goes to JYP. Furthermore why should Shannon risk her own career and chance at going to YG. When she'll just end up in the dungeon for yrs on yrs. Remember Katie Kim that girl still hasn't debuted and it's been 2yrs. Feel so bad for her that is going to happen to Shannon if she goes to YG.
I agree with the comments about the YG dungeon, because I truly think that she fits JYP the best. I can 100% see her own personal style shining a lot more brightly through JYP than under YG. Plus why not add some more vocal talent to JYP?
Everyone all upset at JYP don't even realize that Shannon herself said that was her problem before and was happy afterwards that the judges agreed with her. It was her whole motivation behind coming onto the show, to confirm her own doubts which they did. Nobody said she was a bad singer lol go actually watch the episode for yourself.
This girl is extremely talented, I also have the feeling that she lost a lot of confidence and her unique color. For the company I don't really know, imo I think YG suits her really well, imagine a trio SHannon (young and powerful voice), Katie (unique and soulful voice) and Hanna (deep, feminine and soft voice)
i don't know how i stumbled up on this video.. but its 1:35 am in the morning and its cold enough as it is in my living room.. she ain't have to give me goosebumps like that lol
real_bbh 23 Girl groups are quite different from being a solo singer. Especially as a girl. It's a lot more difficult to be successful which is why I think he was so harsh. And it's true too.. she's not that successful and Twice is super successful so. He does know what he's doing in some regard.
real_bbh 23 Girl groups are quite different from being a solo singer. It's a lot more difficult to be successful which is why I think he was so harsh. Also, he did say that she's a good singer.
Did you not even watch the episode? He said she was a great singer. Shannon actually cried because she was relieved that they agreed with her on her own faults, that singing has become a technical exercise for her without her own emotions.
I agree to what JYP told Shanon because in the first place the reason she applied was to get criticized(you'll know if you watch the whole episode). If JYP didn't told her anything then I think that she will regret going to kpop star. That's why she cried when JYP mentioned her problem because it is exactly her concerns. -P.S. I don't understand why mention Twice. Shanon is a solo artist. Why not mention JYP's solo artist like Baek A-Yeon. Idol groups and solo artists are different anyway.
I don't care what JYP says, I know it was probably constructive criticism and probably needed, but I like the song and I like Shannon and I think she did an amazing job
Shannon is a golden gem that MBK should be ashamed to say they have. She's way too talented to be so underrated.
Merrisa Meda you do realize that its not the company's fault tho? Shannon had way better promotions compared to DIA's debut. she always guest on radio shows. something DIA never had. and yet she never became popular. in short, koreans doesnt like her that much.
Yeah it's hard for a Westerner artist to success in Korea. Just like it's hard for an Asian artist to success in US-UK. I think Jeon Somi of JYP was feeling the same before. But JYPE have more experience than many other agencies about how to work with these foreigners and make them become stars, they know how to make Korean audiences accept them so that Somi had the chance to prove it following JYP's formula.
I hope Shannon will join JYP and well maybe she will team up with Somi and Lily Morrow lol. That would be the Avengers team!
Aldous Kim Oh yeah of course. It's both parts. Not many people like Shannon because of her attitude and personality, but she has since been more humble. MBK overall is a bad company and I think she could be more popular somewhere else.
someone saw the episode in raw and said that JYP didn't choose her and give her a FAIL
and I KNOW it's because JYP hate when singer push too hard when they sing..:/ I LOVE SHANNON VOICE but he prefere when they sing groovy or delicatly, I hope in the next step she will make him change his mind (she should sing a gayo song) sorry for my bad eglish ^^"
jazzy licolia
I think better wait for the subbed version and watch again. In the previous seasons of Kpop Star he rejected many ppl too but also give them good advice. Then in the next rounds they use his advice to improve and surprise all the 3 judges.
7년뒤에도 들으러오는사람..
원곡도 좋지만 샤넌 음색 너무 좋아..
가수 꿈 관둬서 아쉬워..
한국이 품기에는 장벽이 컸다
This is probably one of Ariana's hardest songs and she did great.
Yeah. Yet JYP is not happy for her performance lol
@@yuchan9755 The entire show he was only impressed when she performed one of his songs. Seems like he was more insecure his artists can’t sing like this.
the whole ass industry LITERALLY wasted Shannon, she has the most strongest vocals yet they let it all go to waste. My baby deserved so much more
I can tell she lost her color after being in MBK...and she knows it too. You can see it in her eyes that she doesn't know what to do at this point. It's all or nothing for her. Honestly, I hope she leaves and goes into a smaller, secure and creative company that allows to bring back her inner colors and passion. She has such a gift at only 18 years old.
I hope she goes into Source Music
What is sad is Shannon just does not look fresh faced anymore. When she debuted, you can tell she is enjoying it. But now, not anymore. She is still good though.
Gracie C. i agree... seems like right now there's too much pressure on her shoulder... this is why talented people also need good agency...
She should go in the same company as Ailee or MAMAMOO, they are pretty good at keeping their artist's colors :)
True
Shannon has already released TWO very good singles. It is weird seeing her here...
Reginald Greene I KNOWWW THATS WHY I WAS SO SHOCKED TO SEE THIS!! AND SHE LOOKS A LITTLE FATTER AND HER HAIR IS SHORTER
really? ok she's not bad but looking to last seasons stars I kind of think her voice whist technically clear has a little bit of narrow range I;m not trying to troll or anything but its well you listen and there is something missing in her voice that doesn't draw you in, and because of this can't actually call her on of this seasons fav's
ram64man lol she sang opera when she was younger and did musicals, she has a really wide range actually 😂 maybe it wasnt clearly shown in this show but you should check her videos out (like star king)
IK is she still in mbk
I didn't know her but now I listened to this and I think that she is amazing. Everyone has its own start and I guess hers was this show? Anyways, it was a good place to show her talent although I don't know much about this show... And she looks cute with her outfit and hair, I like it
She knows it that she can't enjoy singing anymore she feels like she's a machine that constantly has to sing perfectly she's hurting and when jyp saw right through her she felt like she found hope.
Love you Shannon been with you since your early days before debut and always will !!!!
How is that she doesn´t have emotion!!????? SHE DID IT AMAZING and I can see she feels the music... wtf with JYP?
EmyAchOl that's what i'm wondering about
but she actually agreed with him and moreover YG said the same thing(you have a great voice but you didnt reach out to me)
she was amazing...I loved her ever since I saw her in Star King...her voice in this perf was great, but i think she did lack in conveying the emotions of the song to her audience. There are singers that have a great technique especially in belting out high notes, but lack the capability to allow the audience to feel and understand the song. I think she's still struggling to find out how to do that now unlike when she first performed Daybreak Rain (I love that song ♥) I can relate to her in a way. When I sing I become too conscious of my technique (ie. breathing, pitch, and even facial expression) that I tend to forget what singing is all about. It's about telling a story through your song. She's still young and has great potential. I hope she finds a good coach to help her improve more :)
realtaek yes i agree with you her vocal is good only lack of emotion
제대로 보여줄려고 아리아나 노래
준비했는데 현재까지 활동하고 있기에 심사위원셋이 수준을 갑자기 높여서
평가한 듯... 샤넌이 우승했어야 했는데...
slayyy shannon!! I was waiting for her appearance on kpopstar 💕 so glad that she joined this show 😁 hope she gets really far
Ari Ni People have been sleeping on this gem for so long. I'm glad she's given this great opportunity and gets signed in a better company. It's Shannon's time to shine! 😍👏 Tzuyu x Shannon I love them both and I hope they will be in one company.
at 2:11 YG be like "OH i think i found my next artist to keep in my famous dungeon ofc" CLOSE UR MOUTH YG
im done hahahahhahahaha
YES im so happy shannon is becoming a trainee again. Hopefully she picks the label that will promote her for the recognition she needs. Shes so underrated.
TRÉS MIGNON yeah tru i mean she has a lot of experience so i think with more training she'll be eveb famous. :)
Last I checked she's still technically w/ MBK, so she's prob not becoming a trainee again unless she gets another company to void her contract. She's prob auditioning for the chance to get a song from each company since this season allows both trainees and already debuted artists to audition
her worst mistake is joining MBK...
Its the mistakes of all mbk's idols not just her
There are many talented idols like her in the company
Given the fact that she’s a foreigner, the best choice would have been to join JYP or YG.
I REALLY DO FELT SO PROUD AS A LONG TIME FAN OF SHANNON AND TODAY, I JUST REALIZED IVE BEEN USING SHANNON'S PHOTO FOR SO LONG ALREADY AND NEVER BEEN CHANGED IT.
아무리 내려도 한글 댓글이 없다....한국인 계십니까....아엠 뤀잉폴 코리안ㅅ.....? ㅠ
아임 프롬 코레아!
샤넌이가 한국에서 왜 유명하지 않은지 정말 이해가 안되요. 지금 현재의 걸그룹 매인 보컬 멤버들보다 보컬이 더 좋은데요 ...
@@larasahin5962 비교 안될정도잌데...
이 노래 라이브가 이정도라니
I really have respect for Shannon's talent. She deserves more recognition. 💖 Check out her songs: Why why, Daybreak Rain :)
Yanagi YES! and check out her cover "you the one who loved me" omfg.
I did , I love it!!!
이게 어떻게 로보트야?... 존나 잘하는데...
Shannon 's voice isn't soulful but she taught herself techniques to sound soulful. many singers do it like Ailee.
Riri Suleiman the other man from sm so yg, jyp and sm?
Sarah Anton No. The other man is from Antenna Music (Owner of Yoo Hyeol Sketchbook).
Riri Suleiman what is a soulful voice in your opinion?
Tess Tran singing like they are telling a story...it touches your soul. you know those singers like lee sun hee, gummy, kim taewong, hwanhee etc baek ji young
John Eres yea I know his sketchbook show but who are the artist from his company?
She deserves to be in an agency that promotes her the way she deserves because she is really really talented. I've known her for a long time and I've also been waiting for her to finally shine. I hope she gets her place in the kpop industry now! Shannon fighting!!!!!
Shannon is an amazing singer, people might be mad at JYP for critizing her but he is right. And what's funny is that she actually agrees with him. If you want to get better you will have to look at what you're doing wrong. She deserves more recognition!
I just listened to Ariana and after seeing this I clicked on it and wow all I can say is that the girl is amazing! She did so well woah.. I love Jae's reaction. I'll check up her own songs!
I wanna say that even Shannon admitted that she was shocked that he pointed out her flaws that she KNEW. that's why she wanted to come to kpopstar to hear what the judges had to say and now she got it. she obviously wants to improve so the harsh words will be good for her.
she should audition for SM, shes already a top visual and shes super talented, she deserves to be in a big company
she's still trying to make her dreams true. she deserves this so much. hope she can make it. I mean. She Will make it
N년 째 계속 듣고 있고, 아직도 심사평을 이해 못함. 원곡 뿐만 아니라, 살면서 들어본 jasons song 중 단연 최고임. 그루브, 딕션 등 뭐하나 빠지는 게 없다. 그저 탑
This makes me feel so sad. When Shannon just debuted, you can see her enjoying the stage. No matter if it was her own song promotion or on Hidden Singer, you can see it in her eyes. But after all the shit she went through and the negligence faced from MBK, she's like soulless looking. I really hope Shannon gets appreciated more T_T be more happy.
her control is out of this worldddddd this song is so freaking hard to sing!
Arianator here👋🏻
She did justice to this song.
Shannon did a great job of singing this song. Whenever I hear one of the judges's start talking about singing from the heart, I think of the quote from the American Comedian George Burns, who said something to the effect of "The secret of being a successful actor is sincerity. Once you can fake that, you've got it made."
I think maybe if at times she had sung the song less strongly and shown more vulnerability at times, her singing would have been viewed as more sincere.
jyp should give more advice's to twice on their singing skills cus Shanon got talent he hopes they could sing like her. she's pretty plus she can sing you can jst know when someone loves music n try their best
Stephanie f u dont have to bring other groups into this though
Sorry I'm just mad at the fact that he criticizes others harshly while he debuts a group that aren't that strong vocally.talking about how she don't feel the music she singing to, me it seems that she does jst saying doe.
Shannon cried because she knows that she lacks emotion in her singing which was what JYP basically meant. How can you be a singer when all you do is sing what's on the paper? she a great singer but didn't you see that she was just trying to hit all the notes that she needed without the feelings in it? Beside you didn't watch SIXTEEN which TWICE was in because if you did watch it you can see that JYP also critised the member's abilities too. I'm sorry that he is honest and wants your unnie to become a better artist.
lmao dude did u even see the full ep. i actually hate it when people make assumptions like this when they didnt even watch the full thing
ABBY:
Hm. It's interesting to think that JYP said any of this because he wants Shannon to be successful.
I think that listening to the audio independently of the video and without all these comments about "singing like a machine" nobody would have even mentioned it. I'm not a fan of Shannon, but I don't think that her singing is mechanical.
I also don't think that SIXTEEN is a reliable reference for how accurate or founded JYP's criticism is. He's not a vocal coach, he's a producer and a CEO. He has a public image that he's been trying to cultivate for a long time. One where he is seen as exacting, even harsh at times, but ultimately knows what's best and can always fix a person's flaws with a few 'deep' sentences.
I think that he doesn't care about Shannon at all. He simply wants to further this image, so he picks apart a performance which otherwise would have been pretty quality.
What do you think about this line of analysis?
This girl deserves so much better. I hope she receives success or at least something a little more through this show.
I'm in tears, seeing Shannon here, I hope the best for her, I want her to be more famous before, not because she's from one of the big three companies, but because she's really talented.
shannon always suprises me with her unique voice
Her voice isnt unique tbh but she has a lot of vocals skills
js if jyp took her in and she made it all the way to the finals, what if she joined his label? maybe somi would have a chance to debut with her 👀👀👀
JYP have like 10 ready to debut trainees
I don't know how he even gonna chose between
Them
Somi lily M chae sisters eun Soo
Natty
And a lot
i heard shannon left mbk? i also heard she just went back to being a trainee under mbk. idk what's true but maybe it'll be revealed soon
it would be cool if shannon, somi, lily, and natty debuted together omg
yungtaro she didn't left MBK
Pink Moon48 okay then that's that lol thanks
Really love her debut song, hope more people know her talent😉
Woaaa. She slayed!! Her voice so good and she pretty💕 perfect!!💋
It’s honestly such a shame how MBK did Shannon. She’s has such a gem of a voice. I really wish she would have been successful on Korea 😭
I wouldn't mind seeing her in a girl group; She can always get a solo further into her career
Myyyyy girl finally, she deserves so much more than this, she is so talented, hope to see her go far inthis competition!
i pretty much just came for jason's song because it's such a beautiful and dAMN IT'S A HARD SONG TO SING AND SHE MAKES IT SEEM EFFORTLESS YOU GO GIRL YOU HAVE SO MUCH TALENT
i love YG face expression he like " i want her" lol :)
Namkong Kirat LOOL
Kailee Broadway she and lee hi can be a duo like davichi. I think both she and lee hi are opposite in vocal aspects but if yg can make it happen, its a new for kpop. I'm really disappointed in mbk for not appreciating her talent and the wasted time she was in there.
To be honest, if she joins YG she will be busy with promotions back to back
@@krystalpark8269 Like Blackpink, Winner, iKon, CL, or Lee Hi?
Doesn't anyone else find it odd that when she sang I Dreamed a Dream in Hidden Singer, Shannon practically moved people to tears and here, the main criticism was that she sang it so professionally that it didn't seem like she had emotions? I think the long years she spent with MBK really affected her.
Honestly what kind of emotion was expected from this song?
Shannon fightingg .. i love voice of you 😘😙
NOT SHANNON BLOWING UP THE STAGE THEN SAYING THANK YOU SO NICE AND GENTLE
I’m here in 2019. don’t know this girl, but really liked her performance. Hope she’s doing well
beautiful rendition. i love how her tone is kinda similar to ailee's. this is such a hard song also. she did it well!
Ariana wrote this song explaining her relationship with Scooter Braun, and to me I feel like this song fits Shannon so well. Shannon expressed her talent and feelings through the song very well.
so who's Jason?
@@Azarath_Metrion_Zinthos the guy who play piano on this song and songwriter this song
lol everyone is telling she fits jyp and here i am saying YG papa u need her after losing bom ! lee hi and her would make the earth shatter with their voices combined so def want her in YG !
If she joins YG she get a comeback after 3 years and loose hype at least with JYP their is some stability
YG have so many trainees that really deseprate to debut.. if she join YG, we dont know when she will debut..
^^every company has a lot of trainee lol
it's also yg's fault for losing bom and lee hi tbh. he hid them well people don't recognize them anymore
Isn't she good in Jyp too? I think she'd be good in JYP or in YG, how much does it matter? I'm just asking (I don't know much about the way how the both Entertainments work tbh)
But Lee Hi and her would be really great if I think about it
This girl is one of the TOP technical singer in Kpop next to Ailee!👍good luck shannon!
SHE DEF DID ARI JUSTICE 💙💙💙 SOUNDS SO GOOD!!!
I love Shannon!! I hope she goes far!! She did seem really nervous as her voice shook a bit at the end but I know she can be flawless when needed!! 😍 Been a fan since her first single! Go Shannon!
she's been one of my fav solo singers and she still i love u wish all the best for you 💕💖
shannon!!! omg her hair, I was waiting for herr
C'mon YG, let's give this girl a chance to shine and sign her!
no way. yg artists dont even come out that much.
james wee Katie Kim says hello, I miss seeing her :(
Im so surprised that shanon came!! But im excited!! GO SHANON
Areen Qambari
Damn she added her own lyircs. RESPECT
Shannon Shannon Shannon go get a good agency girl hope you go for Sm or YG
she cant there is a contract with mbk(?)
cantwaitforthis meh so why do this then she should of quote her contract seriously MBK isn't good if she's with a bigger better company then she'll be able to shine more plus more pay check to be honest
+Shaz Green kpop star let already debuted singers and trainee of other company to be able to apply this time because this is going to be last season of kpop star and also called "kpop star the last chance". purpose is thay because many idol group or singers debut but not get best attention. also, many trainees work hard waiting their chance to debut.. (if they get positive reaction from this, they will get debuted faster). Plus, the tv program called 'produce101' with tons of trainees was hit. so it is good chance for the kpop star itself to gain more attention from viewer as last season had lower view. It is win win reasons.
+Shaz Green Not all the cases but usually it is not easy for trainees to move their company because the companies put their money to train them. so because of that groups debuted from not top 3 company get their money much later than their debut in order to pay back the cost for train. there is a case that they need to 'pay' to move as there is contract for trainees too. but especially I dont think company that has shannon (?) or other applicants(havent watched this yet) will let her or he go easily if they get attention by this program. they will try to not let them go. so maybe you should pray yg or jyp to find them very attractive but they fail the show. ;p Additionally, cost for moving their company for 'already debuted aritist' with contract is much expensive. for example, Jay park had to pay 2 hundred bilion to get loco out of previous company and before his first single at aomg, he was not even famous or had any hitted song...
EVERYONE IS SURPRISED YESSSS GO ROCK THEM SHANNONNNNNNN
I am so happy that she took this opportunity and hope she make something out of it. Because she has so much potential for someone who sings so well.
she sings from the back of her throat, she needs to sing further forward, other than that
HER VOICE IS AMAZING AND WHY IS SHE HERE OMG IM CRYING
MidnightAshess MBK ent. ignores her 😢💔 .... that's why she's working for her own good .... i missed her and i didnt know about this audition of her 😢
MidnightAshess Maybe you should actually listen to her lol. Her voice is consistently well placed and often resonant. The only problem here is the repeated belting on the "aye" vowel, but other than that she did fine. In her Breath performance(on Kpopstar) she was able to maintain resonance while phrasing D5s and Eb5s without any trouble. Shannon's biggest issue is that she doesn't pick the best songs for her, but I guess her choice is getting better.
Shannon.....fighting!!! So amazing!!!
please don't join yg she'll go into yg's dungeon where artist disappear and won't be seen again
It's not like JYP is better (look in 15&, Park Jimin, Bernard Park, G.Soul, Day6, Miss A...). Anyway, she's still from MBK. This season they will only be promoted for 1 year by the three agencies and back to original after this :)
Melissa K. yeah jyp does the same too but I feel like yg is worse
dousuga but if she wants recognition then she should stick with YG. JYP needs a lot of media plays for his groups to get some boosts like sixteen etc. YG only posts who's next teasers and everyone is legit crazy
So you saying she will be back at MBK after promoted by the three agencies just for a year if does win?
Aldous Kim well actually YG also does that kind of thing like when they did win and also mix&match. They also needed a media boost, sixteen also was because they already had their group but it disbanned bcs 2 of them left. But we need to admit that the two companies are guaranteed to start with a big fanbase if they debut a new group.
Wow, young lady just blew my mind. Arianna Grande brought me here and I am glad I came...
Shannon is an amazing singer and she was feeling the song so much... JYP you better start to care of TWICE´s singing lessons
I feel like people are taking what Jyp said the wrong way. Some people may find it harsh but he wasn't completely lying. Hopefully this show helps her.
If she gets booted from the show in the second round I'm going to be pissed. She's the best singer this show has EVER had. I don't care what kind of excuse JYP comes up with. If you're that good JYP, help the girl break out of the funk she's in!
shannon just keeps slaying
jimin is ma man, u aint gon touch him Oh my...
jimin is ma man, u aint gon touch him hello Jimin.
I don't want her in a group. If she's going to win this show and be in one of these companies, I want her to continue being a solo artist.
I wish..
I wouldn't like to see that. She is the type who does well being solo. ; - ;
I'm not saying this to diss shannon but, I don't think she'll get far in kpop star. She's a great singer and that's it. There's nothing unique about her except her appearance which is probably why her solo career didn't last. Although, if she trained under JYP with Somi, she might have a chance at debuting in a group as the main vocal.
Not all contestants get that far or win but they can still get signed if the company wants them.
Moglomlov that's exactly how shannon got signed. She was contestant on superstarK. She got signed by a small company, and now look where she's at.
Doesn't mean all small companies are bad. She unfortunately got into a company that didn't not how to promote her or help her. Antenna is a small company and maybe not as popular but they have really good artists that let them do their own stuff. Rainbowbridge has Mamamoo & BigHit. I think it really depends on the company and how they look out for their artists. Don't like how MBK is hardly doing anything for her.
Shannon just wasn't doing well as a solo artist. I saw her on many variety shows. She had her chance to make an appeal for herself, but just didn't get popular. That's another thing. You'll get your opportunities in the beginning but if you don't become popular, the broadcasting companies won't invite you back to their shows. The companies you mentioned have groups, and as i've said in my original post, if she joins a group she may have a better chance, but not as a solo artists.
She was also a contestant on superstarK?
hmm.. i teared up watching her sing...you can feel her pain and her wanting to be come something more. she must be really sad inside.
OMG SHE RAISED THE KEY!!!!
I think it's best that she join antenna because at least there they won't lock her up in the dungeon. They would really nurture her talent and let her be exposed to the world.
fejiro okumo ikr there are already too much people in the dungeon
I think she fit in jyp. I think jyp could help her improve. I'm looking forward to jyps new group trainee line up in a few more years! jyp has so many half Korean trainees tho 😁
hahahahahahahaha so JYP said all that things about Shannon and her voice, but it's okay because it's no the first time he wrong about an artist. She has so much talent, personality and charisma. Maybe she will become the next CL, Hyorin, IU... Good luck
Meli RV also his new girl group has way less vocal talent then Shannon in my opinion. I think his version of talent is very different from my point of view.
Meli RV non jypnation stans truly will never understand j.y. park he got his reasons and he said them so many times if yall dont like him nor his choices then ok but dont go around saying he doesn't know what talent is when there's so many jyp artists w talent (if yall didn't know rapping and dancing r talents then now u know) and he got amazing vocalist too. park jimin, baek yerin, baek ayeon, minjun, yeeun, all of day6, nayeon and the list just go on.
***** I am sorry, I believe I may have phrased my statement in a way that is way to open to interpretation. I am a fan of Twice by all means and I made no statement to even remotely state that his other artists are "untalented." I must admit that my use of the term, the " rest of the world" is a generalization (I apologize) but you need to admit that in terms of sheer vocal ability Shannon is gifted. Now, I understand the importance of uniqueness, and musicality along with the ability to compose music and I understand that Mr. Park has the right his opinions and so do you, but please don't speak to me that way. It's my prerogative to state my opinion in a respectful way (no antagonizing undertones). Emphasis on the word respectful. Also, just as you said (I'm interpreting this as I couldn't quite understand what you wrote), but you said that criticism is good and I totally agree. We don't grow without criticism so I think Shannon has even more opportunity to grow, but my criticism of Mr. Park is also valid -at least that is what you seem to have expressed in your final statement- so I would appreciate if you wouldn't speak to me with such an accusatory tone.
***** oh and I have subsequently changed my comment. Thank you for giving your criticism
Meli RV what did he say?
I have a feeling Antenna is going to take her.
***** Yeah JYP was harsh but his words can only make her stronger. 😂😂
I hope this is the new beginning for her... wish her the best!!! Really love her ❤️ fighting!
노래도 잘하고 얼굴도 예쁜데 왜 안떴을까 ㅜㅜ
"shannon sings like a machine" , wtf is your idolss singing skills, Park Jin Young ?
Linh KelfPi he didn't say anything bad tho, she admitted it, she can't sing with emotions anymore. And JYPE have incredible vocalists, from Jokwon to Jihyo, all the generations have beautiful and unique voices (:
sofía dolores jihyo? :))) twice is nothing
hoangngoc trịnh their sales says otherwise, if u dont like them there you go honey😊
even so Jihyo is nothing compared to shannon in terms of vocal
Victor Yao I never compared Jihyo and Shannon (:
After 3 years, i come back again for this and i always stan for shannon, u deserves better. For me u deserves more than just an idol. International class
lmao i don't understand why everyone is hating on jyp and saying he knows nothing. face it- he knows more about singing and producing stars than all of us combined.
Yoona Yoon then how come he doesnt seem to know how to promote one of the best singers in the industry, Jimin park?
+Jay Pascua hosting an english show and going on 1 singing show for 2 years isnt promo its stupid. the public barely knows her bcuz he doesnt put her on shows
Shannon really should have been put in a group. It's sad that things ended up this way for her. That said JYP is not gonna take her so I don't know why people keep thinking that's gonna happen.
Katherine Darnell you know what did he say for her in the last video?
+Subarashi Cat he criticized how she sung with "no emotion" yet tbh from watching this it just seems he doesnt know what his talking about
Subarashi Cat he said she sings like a machine. I agree, she is a good singer but I'm not getting the same feeling from her as I did when that little girl who sang Adele's song. She's missing the artistry part in her singing which is different from being able to do vocal flairs. A good example of this is Janis Ian's "at seventeen", she doesn't use a bunch of techniques but you can feel the pain in every word she sings.
Katherine Darnell this song isnt one to be sung with pain though..... its a song thats to be sung in a "i can do better" way lol. theres no pain to be heard here
***** I wasn't saying she needed to sing it painfully I was saying she needed to sing it with better emotion and tact. If she was in a group she would be covered by other members helping to disguise the shortcoming and it would give her time to improve.
let her be the champion 💪💪
Honestly she's better for yg in my opinion, she's too talented for jyp
En JYP hay mucho talento.
Yes better for YG basement
Jyp is debuting a new gg soon. It would be beneficial if she goes to JYP. Furthermore why should Shannon risk her own career and chance at going to YG. When she'll just end up in the dungeon for yrs on yrs. Remember Katie Kim that girl still hasn't debuted and it's been 2yrs. Feel so bad for her that is going to happen to Shannon if she goes to YG.
It's okay. This year is special. They don't take the winner in an agency. They'll promote the winner with the help of each agency.
I agree with the comments about the YG dungeon, because I truly think that she fits JYP the best. I can 100% see her own personal style shining a lot more brightly through JYP than under YG. Plus why not add some more vocal talent to JYP?
Everyone all upset at JYP don't even realize that Shannon herself said that was her problem before and was happy afterwards that the judges agreed with her. It was her whole motivation behind coming onto the show, to confirm her own doubts which they did. Nobody said she was a bad singer lol go actually watch the episode for yourself.
she better win this
so talented
Asmaa Asmaa this show proved that talent isnt the one that will take you to the finals. its the public's decisions.
I think she could shine as soloist
She is a soloist right now
KPop CurlyTop I know I just answered the people saying that she and somi must be put on the same group
This girl is extremely talented, I also have the feeling that she lost a lot of confidence and her unique color.
For the company I don't really know, imo I think YG suits her really well, imagine a trio SHannon (young and powerful voice), Katie (unique and soulful voice) and Hanna (deep, feminine and soft voice)
now she’s Jett VA in valorant i used to fanboy over her before😀😀😀😀😀😀😀
i don't know how i stumbled up on this video.. but its 1:35 am in the morning and its cold enough as it is in my living room.. she ain't have to give me goosebumps like that lol
Jett is so talented
It's so obvious she's a high key Ariana Grande fan I love ittttt. Her covers of Ari's songs etc 💕
finally she's getting heard 😊😊😊
Finally Shannon is out of MBK's practice room!! She totally needs to find a better entertainment agency that will fit her style maybe JYP?
Nothing Much jyp turned her down tho
Aldous Kim yeah i heard :( maybe SM? Not YG definitely cause she'll be stuck in a dungeon for a really long time...
She is still in mbk.
Nothing Much JYP FTW
Im happy to see Shannon again.. hopefully she goes far :x talent like hers shouldn't be wasted.
she has good face and amazing voice wtf jyp i wonder if you think shyshyshy is good more than her singing -_-!
real_bbh 23 lmaoo
real_bbh 23 Girl groups are quite different from being a solo singer. Especially as a girl. It's a lot more difficult to be successful which is why I think he was so harsh. And it's true too.. she's not that successful and Twice is super successful so. He does know what he's doing in some regard.
real_bbh 23 Girl groups are quite different from being a solo singer. It's a lot more difficult to be successful which is why I think he was so harsh. Also, he did say that she's a good singer.
Did you not even watch the episode? He said she was a great singer. Shannon actually cried because she was relieved that they agreed with her on her own faults, that singing has become a technical exercise for her without her own emotions.
I agree to what JYP told Shanon because in the first place the reason she applied was to get criticized(you'll know if you watch the whole episode). If JYP didn't told her anything then I think that she will regret going to kpop star. That's why she cried when JYP mentioned her problem because it is exactly her concerns. -P.S. I don't understand why mention Twice. Shanon is a solo artist. Why not mention JYP's solo artist like Baek A-Yeon. Idol groups and solo artists are different anyway.
이건지금도 한번씩 생각날때 찾아들음
her mic so far and her voice so powerful wow
She chose a really good song for her voice ! go Shannon !
omg it's so surreal to see her now knowing that she's jett from valorant.
I don't care what JYP says, I know it was probably constructive criticism and probably needed, but I like the song and I like Shannon and I think she did an amazing job