Y’all do not know Nate at all. In his earlier work he talked about drinking way more to the point he could keep up with Shane, even heard him curse on an earlier release album. Makes no sense to me when people say Nate turns them off, dude is miles ahead of anyone else because he doesn’t need to swear to be funny but you’d never know he was clean unless someone called it out because his comedic ability sacrifices nothing.
All these comments saying “who is this other guy”: Nate has been around a long time. Part of the Joe List, Dan Soder and Mark Normand crew from NYC way before Shane moved to NY from Philly. He is legit, just his humor is more family friendly, no cursing. Still funny but not my preferred style
Nate’s the fuckin man. Shane Gillis is the top dawg rn though. He’s got the commercials and public eye but if you haven’t listened to Nate give him a shot. As far as straight comedy goes id say his sets are better. (I do love me some Shane tho)
I like Shane but it doesnt seem possible he is a bigger money maker or doing bigger shows that Nate is right now. Anyone could decide they like one or the other better but Nate seems more successful by money and buts in seats.
Shane's more popular and more well know at this point... I can ask 10 random people who each are an 1 might know who Nate is while 5 will know who shane is....
Ive watched a fair bit of bargatze and his is more chuckle quietly to yourself comedy. Cant remember any of his stories or bits. Cant forget most of gillis comedy. Dude is the king right now.
Nate’s obviously miles ahead, but is also almost 10 years older. Also, kinda who cares - they’re both unbelievably funny in their own way and will make more money than would kill me dead if I had it.
clearly not....shane is miles more successful mainstream wise. ive never heard of this nate guy...whos has a sponser and several adverts with a company like budweiser.
@@BEEFBRSKT not knocking Shane at all, he’s my favourite comedian right now. The point was Nate has been around longer selling out arenas, something Shane has only really just started to do. Just a longevity thing - Shane will probably earn substantially more long term.
Jo Koy and Bert being successful, even Joe Rogan doing arenas, means I don't understand comedy audiences because I would pay $100 to not see Jo Koy, so what does success mean? I don't see Nate ever coming down because everyone enjoys his comedy. All of Shane's fans like Nate, but not all of Nate's fans want to hear Shane's joke about his ex-girlfriend's Navy Seal boyfriend.
They're both more famous than Ari. Shane is more famous amongst bros. I only recently heard of Nate Bergatze or whatever but dude is probably main stream famous. Kind of how Sebastian Manescalco homie is apparently the highest grossing comedian.
I don’t think Maniscalco is gross? I mean, his jokes have never grossed me out before so to say he is the highest grossing seems off. His jokes are pretty tame. Lots of physical act-outs, but he stays away from gross stuff from what I’ve seen
Well they’re both doing arenas so they’re both “mainstream” lol but Nates been a fan favorite of legit comedy fans for years he was in the NYC crew of List Normand Soder Morrill way before Shane popped.
Lmao what are you even saying. Shane did a Bud Light commercial, did College Game Day multiple times, special on Netflix, appearances on SNL and every pod, Trump on Kill Tony. Nate is like 10 years older and been doing it just as much longer. Shane is on a crazy trajectory. You clearly live in a bubble.
It’s pretty easy to question if even Ari is questioning it. He’s pretty good friends with both of them and knows way more about their success than we do
Bargatze is F’n hilarious. He just had a special in 2024, and another tour with new material this year. Dude is funnier than all of Rogans buddies combined
Nate Bargatze isn't funny to me at all. I base my favorite comedians on pure genuine laughter. Mark Normand and Norm MacDonald are 2 great examples. I mean bert kreischer is in the top 10 and he's not funny to me either. No hatred towards anyone.
Interesting cause I can respect Normand as a great joke writer and objectively good but he never makes me actually laugh while Nate’s delivery and story telling always makes me lol
@@Pacotisdale1268same, norman might get a chuckle out of me now and then watching his stand up but norm was different, he could be reading a newspaper and i’d be howling with laughter
Nate’s style is that he has no style, I guess I can see how other people think he’s funny … I guess … but he has never made me laugh… you know what, I’ll walk the ledge. He’s not funny. Shane‘s specials have me laughing till my face and body are literally in pain. There is no comparison between them too.
They dont have the same audience. Bargatze is the seinfeld romano audience, family style comedy. Gillis is the louie ck artie lange audience, dirty cerebral bro comedy.
Nate's more sucessful right now but ultimately he'll blow past Nate. Really after his comeback, he's just really getting started. And Shane IS NOT a Rogan comic. Even Mr Tough Talk Free Speech Anti Woke Rogan wouldnt touch Shane when he was cancelled. They talked about it when the heat did die down enough for Rogan to bring him on They talked about it when Shane did get invited. Luckily for Rogan Shane wasnt a dick about it.
Supposedly did 80 million last year from arena shows and Netflix special. He is a very funny clean comic. He is in the conversation cause he made all that money, arena shows, and Netflix specials.
That's what someone told me. But if you pay attention (I relistened and heard it), they reference the money in the vid but they say 82 million. So apparently I was wrong...by 2 million. There will be other people in superbowl commercials this year. Are they all up for top comedian too? Shane could be bigger. I'd be surprised by that. I mean he could make more money if Bud Light sinks a mint into him hoping to regain what they lost. But in that case, making the most money from ads wouldn't seem to make you the biggest comedian.
I respect Nate’s space in comedy, but to me it’s watered down. Stand up comedy isn’t meant to be for families… as the great patrice said “Comedy is half the audience disgusted half laughing hysterically”
Stand up comedy is meant to be for anyone that enjoys it. There have always been clean and dirty comedians. Personally I think it's harder to be funny clean so I respect it. But dirty comedians are much funnier.
Nate who? Idk the guy ive never heard of or the guy on TV and UA-cam every 10 minutes even if your actively trying to avoid....hmmmm tough to say whose bigger
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #60 РОЖДЕНИЕ ЛОЛОЛОШКИ [Финал] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YoR0pAV9FVQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Love Shane and Nate. Anyone that gets upset about either comedian is probably a KFC fan.
Their names are the only reason why I clicked on a KFC clip lol
I assumed I didn't like Nate, until SNL... then I was like "oh... he's funny" and caught up on his shit.
wtf does kfc got to do with anything dawg how tf u randomly send hate to them😂😂🤦🏿♂️🤦🏿♂️
Nate’s the best family friendly comic
*Brian Reagan
Y’all do not know Nate at all. In his earlier work he talked about drinking way more to the point he could keep up with Shane, even heard him curse on an earlier release album. Makes no sense to me when people say Nate turns them off, dude is miles ahead of anyone else because he doesn’t need to swear to be funny but you’d never know he was clean unless someone called it out because his comedic ability sacrifices nothing.
Woah, dude sounds very cool!!
Nate is hilarious.
I think Nate is insanely hilarious. I respect a comedian that doesn’t need to be raunchy, not that I don’t like comics that are.
Shane is on an absolute tear right now but Nate is up there with Gaffigan in terms of longevity
All these comments saying “who is this other guy”: Nate has been around a long time. Part of the Joe List, Dan Soder and Mark Normand crew from NYC way before Shane moved to NY from Philly. He is legit, just his humor is more family friendly, no cursing. Still funny but not my preferred style
Clean comics aren't that funny
Nate Bargatzi made the most money. It’s genuinely the most funny thing you can bring your mom l, and or kids.
@@rawpower12xu these people only know kill tony and whoever joe rogan tells them to watch lmao
I know who Nate is, just don’t enjoy it. I like other clean comics (longtime Brian Reagan and others). Not mad about it, I just find his comedy flat.
Nate and Patrice O'Neal used to hang. They have old stories and jokes.
RIP PATREEKY
Ari, OG President of Legion of Skanks + owns free real estate in Bert’s head forever… pretty sick resume to start. (Especially for a 70 year old)
Name one good Ari joke
@@allenangaw4827 the Kobe one
Nate’s the fuckin man. Shane Gillis is the top dawg rn though. He’s got the commercials and public eye but if you haven’t listened to Nate give him a shot. As far as straight comedy goes id say his sets are better. (I do love me some Shane tho)
Is he better than Brian Regan? The best clean comic ever?
Nate is funny too and has more widespread appeal since he’s clean. Both are absolutely hilarious
Lets not compare the 2 both are very successful in their own lane. Shane is for the dawgs and Nate is for clean family comedy.
Dude they are all legends.
Nate made $65 million last year. Shane didn’t make the list. That said I’m a bigger fan of Shane’s.
I like Shane but it doesnt seem possible he is a bigger money maker or doing bigger shows that Nate is right now. Anyone could decide they like one or the other better but Nate seems more successful by money and buts in seats.
Shane's more popular and more well know at this point... I can ask 10 random people who each are an 1 might know who Nate is while 5 will know who shane is....
I like how only some of the swear words are bleeped 😂
Ari actually seems like a decent guy when it comes down to it. Mega level headed
Guy pisses in bottles when he does Protect Our Parks, shit on stage at Skankest and on Kill Tony.
You’re right, super level-headed 😂
@@robbaholicon stage.. yeah. He’s also extremely intelligent and funny.
@@robbaholic thats what im saying, i bought too much into his act
Shane is the chosen one
Ive watched a fair bit of bargatze and his is more chuckle quietly to yourself comedy. Cant remember any of his stories or bits. Cant forget most of gillis comedy. Dude is the king right now.
Nate’s obviously miles ahead, but is also almost 10 years older. Also, kinda who cares - they’re both unbelievably funny in their own way and will make more money than would kill me dead if I had it.
clearly not....shane is miles more successful mainstream wise. ive never heard of this nate guy...whos has a sponser and several adverts with a company like budweiser.
@@BEEFBRSKT not knocking Shane at all, he’s my favourite comedian right now. The point was Nate has been around longer selling out arenas, something Shane has only really just started to do. Just a longevity thing - Shane will probably earn substantially more long term.
Jo Koy and Bert being successful, even Joe Rogan doing arenas, means I don't understand comedy audiences because I would pay $100 to not see Jo Koy, so what does success mean? I don't see Nate ever coming down because everyone enjoys his comedy. All of Shane's fans like Nate, but not all of Nate's fans want to hear Shane's joke about his ex-girlfriend's Navy Seal boyfriend.
Nate made. like 87 mill most this year by a comic
Is this TJ Dillashaw's brother or something
I love Ari. He is so real.
I came in to laugh and was just reminded how poor I am repeatedly
Not even a question, Nate
Both are great but they do different kinds of comedy.
Nate’s latest special was a hard watch tbh
Aris too lol I loved Jew but that last one uffff
I mean this is a KFC type question where it doesn’t fucking matter 😂
Ari went in there to be the most Jewish man on the show and by God he did it.
Both are amazing, we need all kinda folks in this wacky worlds. But SODTAOE❤🎉 also 🌈 💵
They're both more famous than Ari. Shane is more famous amongst bros. I only recently heard of Nate Bergatze or whatever but dude is probably main stream famous. Kind of how Sebastian Manescalco homie is apparently the highest grossing comedian.
Good insight, bro
I don’t think Maniscalco is gross? I mean, his jokes have never grossed me out before so to say he is the highest grossing seems off. His jokes are pretty tame. Lots of physical act-outs, but he stays away from gross stuff from what I’ve seen
Nate is not more main stream famous than Shane lol. Shane’s got a bud light commercial campaign and about to be on their Super Bowl commercial lol.
Well they’re both doing arenas so they’re both “mainstream” lol but Nates been a fan favorite of legit comedy fans for years he was in the NYC crew of List Normand Soder Morrill way before Shane popped.
@@STSGuitar16grossing means selling tickets lol
Nate bargatze definitely bigger. See him doing shows everywhere. Shane seems to only be in UA-cam shorts.
Lmao what are you even saying.
Shane did a Bud Light commercial, did College Game Day multiple times, special on Netflix, appearances on SNL and every pod, Trump on Kill Tony. Nate is like 10 years older and been doing it just as much longer. Shane is on a crazy trajectory.
You clearly live in a bubble.
The longest face in the comedy history….
Nate. No question. Shane is fine.
Sadly, I think a lot of people will say Shane for culture wars reasons.
I don’t think so. Real comedian fans know Nate is funny af but Shane is on another level.
It’s pretty easy to question if even Ari is questioning it. He’s pretty good friends with both of them and knows way more about their success than we do
I’ll have to check out Nate’s stuff; I just learned who he is. Just based on quick clips tho he seems like another Tom segura
It's super clean. It would be better to compare clean comics with other clean comics.
Nah he’s way funnier and smarter than Segura
Nates bigger sad to say he is the highest paid comedians atm
People can take their kids to Nate’s show. It’s a huge advantage.
Sad? 😢 😂
Comedy sucks
one of the them is funny and the other is nate
Nate is a far better comedian
Fr, Shane is just milking the frat guy joke that’s big right now. Nate is a true writer
Nate is currently bigger, Shane ends his career miles ahead of Nate both legends of the game.
First time I heard of Nate but I watch comedy stuff on UA-cam
Bargatze is F’n hilarious. He just had a special in 2024, and another tour with new material this year. Dude is funnier than all of Rogans buddies combined
More successful? Nate
More famous/bigger? Shane
Nate Bargatze isn't funny to me at all. I base my favorite comedians on pure genuine laughter. Mark Normand and Norm MacDonald are 2 great examples. I mean bert kreischer is in the top 10 and he's not funny to me either. No hatred towards anyone.
Yeah crazy comedys objective
Interesting cause I can respect Normand as a great joke writer and objectively good but he never makes me actually laugh while Nate’s delivery and story telling always makes me lol
@@Pacotisdale1268same, norman might get a chuckle out of me now and then watching his stand up but norm was different, he could be reading a newspaper and i’d be howling with laughter
@@isaiah988 no one asked
@GearsJosh56 Who cares comment section is free to everyone. If I'm not allowed to be honest why comment.
Legit never heard of this nate guy before
I been following him since like 2018. Didn’t even realize he was a clean comic for like a year - he’s actually funny.
He's legitimately funny. Pretty anomalous among clean comics.
He is good
You must not follow comedy much then.
Check out his SNL appearance
Nate is one of the biggest comedians in the world get out and actually learn some shit 💩. Not just from Rogan. Bro is hilarious. Shane also
I think Shane is much funnier, but Nate is unquestionably more famous and successful.
I do not know who Nate Bragatze is so he hasn't been inducted into the UA-cam shorts community yet
Bruh what? His shorts are FIRE
Nate’s style is that he has no style, I guess I can see how other people think he’s funny … I guess … but he has never made me laugh… you know what, I’ll walk the ledge. He’s not funny. Shane‘s specials have me laughing till my face and body are literally in pain. There is no comparison between them too.
Agreed
lol if you have never laughed at Nate, I don’t trust your opinion on comedy. Shane is great, Nate is great.
They dont have the same audience. Bargatze is the seinfeld romano audience, family style comedy. Gillis is the louie ck artie lange audience, dirty cerebral bro comedy.
Nate's more sucessful right now but ultimately he'll blow past Nate.
Really after his comeback, he's just really getting started.
And Shane IS NOT a Rogan comic.
Even Mr Tough Talk Free Speech Anti Woke Rogan wouldnt touch Shane when he was cancelled.
They talked about it when the heat did die down enough for Rogan to bring him on
They talked about it when Shane did get invited.
Luckily for Rogan Shane wasnt a dick about it.
I know Gillis who is the other guy??
Supposedly did 80 million last year from arena shows and Netflix special. He is a very funny clean comic. He is in the conversation cause he made all that money, arena shows, and Netflix specials.
Ari shafer is only famous cus of Joe .
They have 2 different styles and both are funny. But I gotta go with Shane because him and Matt’s podcast is hilarious.
Nate isn't bigger than Shane. Neither is Dave Attell. They're more established but shane is way more popular
Nate is far more popular. I love both comics, but Nate reaches a much larger audience.
Supposedly Nate did 80 million last year from arena shows and specials. He may not be the biggest but he sure is up there.
@hankhooper1637 Shane's about to be in a superbowl commercial. We're not talking about money. Also that's complete bullshit lol. 80 million?
That's what someone told me. But if you pay attention (I relistened and heard it), they reference the money in the vid but they say 82 million. So apparently I was wrong...by 2 million.
There will be other people in superbowl commercials this year. Are they all up for top comedian too?
Shane could be bigger. I'd be surprised by that. I mean he could make more money if Bud Light sinks a mint into him hoping to regain what they lost. But in that case, making the most money from ads wouldn't seem to make you the biggest comedian.
Well, Nate is actually funny and talented so there is that.
Shane is more popular. Both are funny.
Nates a clean comic. So Shane's bigger.
I respect Nate’s space in comedy, but to me it’s watered down. Stand up comedy isn’t meant to be for families… as the great patrice said “Comedy is half the audience disgusted half laughing hysterically”
Stand up comedy is meant to be for anyone that enjoys it. There have always been clean and dirty comedians. Personally I think it's harder to be funny clean so I respect it. But dirty comedians are much funnier.
God forbid there be one clean comic that is relatable to masses
I can’t imagine sitting around talking about other people’s money how tacky
Nate is the white gabriel Iglesias. That's not a compliment if you have the GPA to break it down
Never heard of this Nate guy till now 😂 definitely Shane is bigger
If women could vote…it’d be Matt Rife. But women aren’t funny so it’s either Shane or Nate
Nate who?
I have no idea who Nate is….it’s Shane by a mile
You have no idea who Nate is but Shane wins by a mile? 😂😂😂 That's like saying I have no idea what math is but the answer is definitely 4 lmao
Shane fans ruined comedy
Nate who? Idk the guy ive never heard of or the guy on TV and UA-cam every 10 minutes even if your actively trying to avoid....hmmmm tough to say whose bigger
I know who Shane Gillis is. I do not know who Nate Bargatze is.