If you are having an issue with the Farmer(s) taking one of the beds at night, check out my solution shown here: ua-cam.com/video/XSi8dmO7nxA/v-deo.html
ok so i timed time it took me to get the villagers into the thing and it took about 2 hours (well i did take breaks and stuff so yea this is inaccurate )
A villager I was transporting fell out of the mine cart and took on the profession of a librarian, and then he sold me mending for 14 emeralds. I do not have a villager breeder but I now have a mending book
You have unlimited mending books haha! You can probably make the villager discount it if you use a zombie purifier thingy. I got Sharpness V for 1 emerald that way (sadly it was in creative mode)
one of my breeders ended up cheating with the farmer causing the other breeder to commit suicide by getting out of bed on the wrong side and falling to their death
1.16 fix: - Open the trapdoors (so that they are horizontal) - Add trapdoors on top of the existing trapdoors (again horizontal) This way the villagers can breed, and the babys don't escape. Edit 1: I didn't directly connect it to the carrot farm, but you can probably make that work too. Edit 2: 1.16.2 fix: Put trapdoors on the corners as well, so that the Beds all have two trapdoors above them.
I did figure out if you're using boats and nether portals place a boat outside the nether portal you're shoving the villagers into that way once they show up in the nether they'll be in boat takes a little headache out of dealing with villagers
I had the problem with my farmer using one of the beds. Solution: When building the farm make sure the two breeder villagers occupy the two beds closest to the farm, that way the farmer has no access to a bed. This can be done by only placing the two closest beds, waiting a night and then placing the other two.
You have just saved me a lot of time. I was trying to see if I did something wrong with the tutorial but now I have 3 villagers stuck in the breeder... one of them is a nitwit too... but through the power of minecarts I will succeed lol
@@ultikillerrrr yeah I tried that it's not super precise plus breaking the minecraft sends them outside of the trapdoors, so you need them to walk into it
For all those who it isn’t working for in 1.15.2, remove the beds and place them as they were after you’ve finished the farm. I’ve seen this advice posted as replies to comments but wanted to make this a main comment so it can clear up the issue for most who aren’t willing to scroll forever as I did. Like so others can see and comment any other tips if you have them! :D edit: some other advice is to make sure there are no blocks near the villagers they could spawn on to get out of bed. this includes slabs and trapdoors. also make sure the only villagers near the beds are the two breeding villagers and the farmer. if there are any others they may claim a bed and cause the two villagers not to breed as there are no extra beds edit 2: just a tip for transporting villagers, if you are constantly editing your setup as i did to make it work efficiently, a good strategy is to have rails and dirt to transport, and instead of using powered rails use a furnace minecart to push a villager in a minecart.
@@JamesFreedmanIsVeryCool sometimes the villager won't breed even after they already slept in the bed or have foods in their inventory. Removing the beds then placing it again kinda solve this problem.
When I first started this design, my villagers were going at it. My villager trading hall wasn't complete yet so I had to keep them in a holding room. Once I finished it I had so much overflow that I built a second trading hall. Then an iron farm. Then ANOTHER one of these farms hooked up to the same breeder. They still went at it. I've got way too many villagers and my last resort was a water stream that leads to lava. My villagers have been going at it like rabbits and I've had to kill the kids because of it. At least I got a lot of carrots and potatoes to show for it 10/10 would recommend.
@@JamesMiguelMusic more like involuntary government execution edit: also my villagers used to work fine and all of a sudden they both died. After replacing them, they decided to retire breeding for the rest of their lives. i think its because they cantfind a way into their beds, but i still dont understand how u have such a surplus of them its almost like diorite. u throw it instantly when u see its in ur inventory.
iqman1000 iskall fan I see :) ran into the same problem a few days ago but I got plenty of villagers left over that I don't need to worry too much abt it. not too sure why it breaks though.
Recently an MC update broke this farm because the villagers won't wake up inside the trapdoors, the solution is very simple. Instead of keeping trapdoors keeping them in, put carpet on top of the beds but leave the space you want them to wake up in uncovered. They refuse to wake up on carpet so they'll automatically wake up in the hole they're supposed to wake up in. You also have to put a trapdoor/block above the villagers or else they'll just walk off the edge. This works for me as of 1.16.3.
Just made it myself and noticed that problem. Thanks your tip fixed it. But also, ull have to place trap doors on top of the carpet to prevent the villagers from just stepping out onto beds again during the day.
Finished it, got all the villagers in, then afked for like 10 minutes, came back and realized I left a block on the side and a zombie came in and killed all 3... my fury cannot be contained
To solve the farmer sleeping on bed situation u can just place another bed in the farm land for the farmer to sleep on. Yes it would destroy 2 crop space, but it is way better than spending hours relocating the villagers
Notrikus break all four of the bed first and place one in the carrot/potatoe farm. Then wait for night time and wait for the farmer to claim the bed in the farm. Finally place the four beds back.
thank you so much for showing the amount of items I need for this farm, it makes it so much easier than having to listen to someone list them out and me rush to write them down
EDIT: Do NOT place the four trapdoors like in the video. Instead, place carpets on top of all the beds (8 carpet) and then glass on top of that. This fixes the farm for 1.16.4+ . To anyone who is having problems with the farmer sleeping in the bed: - Make sure to have a trap door on the crop level of the farmer's feet (the bottom half of the the block below the trapdoor in the video) To anyone who is having problems with the villagers not staying on the fence/escaping out of the area: - Surround the beds with fences, 2 high To anyone having issues with frustration particles after hearts of villagers not breeding: - Make sure the beds have the "pillows" in the corners of the farm - Make sure that there are NO blocks (includes everything even glass, slabs, trapdoors and other transparent blocks) over the the pillows/corners of the breeding area EDIT: this just means RIGHT on top, so there just needs to be a one block air gap between pillow/corner and the glass wall Had a couple problems while building this a couple times but these are all the solutions I've found. Thanks for the awesome farm impulse!
Thx dude! You're my Hero! THAT was my problem with farm! "To anyone having issues with frustration particles after hearts of villagers not breeding: - Make sure the beds have the "pillows" in the corners of the farm"
What I did was take them in a boat to a cobble staircase to the top, one block above the trapdoors, and closed off the other paths, and they just walked right in on their own!
Brilliant video, I can see how the concept works. Building it today right after my coffee. Also love how you reference the other youtubers that inspired this build. Earnt yourself a subscriber Impluse. good work :D
I think it has something to do with the bed orientation I always put the pillows in the corners, and place the beds counter clockwise I think the pillow corner is what's really causing the farmer to jump in, but I still do the counter-clockwise anyway. My farmer invasion problems stopped when I put the pillow in the corner, not in the edges as he does here.
Thank you. I've been wanting a new design for breeder/carrot farm. This is perfect. So glad you're doing tutorials again. I like you still have an actual intro and you keep it fresh.
fix for villagers waking up on top of the bed instead of on the fence post (1.18.2): put carpets on the four corners of the bed and then open the four trap doors so that they cover the other part of the bed, make sure the trap doors open downwards and not upwards so they are right above the bed
This worked absolutely perfectly. Thank you for the amazing and detailed video on how to build, and transport villagers. This was easy to build and it started working before I was even done building. Thank you.
Tip: To prevent villagers from getting out of the chamber after they sleep, you should put another 4 trapdoors on top of the other ones. But these should be open (horizontally).
Tried this and a few other ways and none seem to work. They always will get up not on the fence post. They will even get up and stand with their head fully in blocks just to not stand on the fence.
I have a lot of damn tasks... breed some villagers, make a village raid farm, find a jungle biome for bamboo, then find some cactus in a desert, then make a xp farm from that, then fight the ender dragon, then make a nether farm for all the mobs there, then fight the wither... I don't think I'm gonna live long enough to do all that stuff, even if I don't get bored lol... Anyways thanx for the guide man!
For 1.14.4 Full release you need to give the farmer a bed in the farm, there's almost no other way to keep him from claiming one of the 4 in my experience. put it on the opposite side and put glass above it so he doesn't break the crops.
@@auquitaine9201 if the farmer can actually get to the beds you've done something wrong in following the tutorial.......... do you have the trap door at the top of the opening? and are the beds and post at the right height? Also, Id recommend removing all the beds except the Farmer's for a night so that the farmer assigns himself to it then put the other 4 in even during the night once you see the farmer sleeping.
place a lower trap door on the block space above the farmland in between the farmland and beds he shows the solution while building this farm on the hermitcraft server
for ppl using this in 1.16.4+, I found if you place double carpet on the beds they won't escape the trapdoors (which they will if you dont with this design because of the 1.16.2 update)
Here's a video showcasing the fix for the farm for 1.16+. Here's the link:ua-cam.com/video/SWcw9nFgt2I/v-deo.html. Your support really matters to me I am a small UA-cam please check the video out and give your opinions in the comments
This design does work on PS4 with a few easy/minor modifications. 1) Water logging does not keep crops hydrated. To fix this simply come in one block from each of the cardinal points as well as the center, break it, fill with water, and cover (Everything I've tried works). This will keep all but two blocks on each diagonal hydrated. 2) The farmer can escape. Just replace the trap door with an upper slab. He will still be able to see and throw food to the other two villagers. 3) The villagers can occupy a bed and not return to the fence post position. For this one I moved the beds 2 blocks away from the holding cell; on PS4 they do not appear to need to sleep in order to restart the breeding cycle. I have confirmed this over several Minecraft days (about an hour; maybe hour and a half play time) 4) Villagers are easily distracted (This is true on my java version on my laptop as well). Easiest fix of them all, just don't stand so close to them. Sometimes they will try and track you instead of wanting to go into "love mode" or throw food to their buddies. Try and watch the farm from a dozen or so blocks away to make sure it work. 5) Not sure if this is necessary, but I replaced the trapdoors with solid blocks, seemed to make it harder for escapes and easier for the babies to fall through. One thing that I cant seem to get to work; is that my farmer will only throw food down when they need it and not a carrot, potato, or wheat more. This means I am not receiving the extra produce like ImpulseSV does. If anyone can shoot me a solution to this (For PS4, again my java version runs this breeder smooth as silk) I would be very appreciative.
@@brandonlaurie7042 They may have full inventories. Things like wheat or potatoes (they may have received before transporting to your system) can gum them up. This did happen to me, so I just went to a new village and kidnapped a fresh guy. Another trick I saw in a different video is to replace the trapdoor holding section with full blocks (I.e. glass), then place a trap door on the upper half of one of these blocks and close it, it will not suffocate the villagers but will prevent food from falling through. This does have the obvious negative that you will no longer receive excess produce. Have you previously traded with the villager in the farm cell? If so you'll just have to acquire a new one, as that villager will be locked into which ever profession you traded with him as. If not try removing every "work station" type block around the base. Even if they aren't visible to him he can still sometimes become linked. Also make sure once he is a farmer trade with him at least once to ensure he remains a farmer; even if the composter is accidentally destroyed.
Pretty sure my farmer keeps trying to breed with one of the two in the trapdoors, and it's stopping them from breeding since they can't get to eachother and they just keep trying, even after separating them
I am having a similar problem - the result is the farmer is always breeding and then spawning the child villager. My fix so far is the one impulseSV has made in his pinned comment
Villagers are so easy to breed now. I just built a few new houses in the Village I'm living in, put a bed in it, and throw a couple of villagers some food.
Okay, so I think i found the fix for 1.16.2. So do everything he said. BUT. Face the beds away from the corners. And make the trap doors horizontal, not vertical. I've tried putting trap doors on top of the trap doors, but It wasn't letting the villagers breed. The only problem, is the there's no stopping the farmer villager from breeding with the other villagers. So, sometimes the baby villager will spawn on the farm. I took the information from @Hakuna Matata, and just added on to it. Thank you. It should work.
1.16.4 Fix: - Remove all the trapdoors, and put carpet about the beds so all the beds are completely covered with carpet - Put a block above the villagers head so they cannot escape (as shown in this image imgur.com/a/CqqSc05). The glass beside the carpet is just so carrots don't get thrown where the villager cannot pick it up. Shift click the carpets with a block (as shown in this image imgur.com/a/l6D8DHE), so the baby villagers cannot escape and the villagers are protected from outside threats. Last, place a trapdoor (as shown in this image imgur.com/a/8ncrXul) this ensures that the baby villagers cannot escape, and the carrots can still be thrown to the villagers (a solid block would make this difficult). This fixed all the issues I was having with the farm in 1.16.4
For anyone who's farmer is not working (harvesting or planting) make sure you have Mob Griefing turned on. If it is off the farmer will not be able to break any crops or pick any up. You can toggle this gamerule with the command "/gamerule mobGriefing true" to turn it on and "/gamerule mobGriefing false" to turn it off.
I've built this farm a few times now and I've always had issues with it. Regardless of what fix I tried, the farmer villager always ended up getting into one of the breeding beds and breaking the self-sufficiency of the farm. Recently, however, I think I found a permanent solution. Having the three blocks at the edge of the farm be complete blocks (i.e. not tilled dirt, basically any other full block) and then adding a solid trap door (none of the ones with gaps in them) to the bottom of the gap as Impulse suggests makes it so that the farming villager cannot see beds at all, but I found that it also caused the food the Farmer throws to land on the trap door instead of the beds for the breeders to pick up. I fixed this by having a redstone pulse running into the block that the bottom trap door was attached to, linked up to a daylight sensor 8 blocks away, outside the farm. This allows the trap door to be open during the day so that the food can be thrown correctly, but the daylight sensor will close the trap door at about 6:00pm, just before the villagers start to hop into beds. That way, there's never a point where the Farmer both has access to the beds and also wants to get into them, so he'll never take them. Hopefully this can help others, it seems to have permanently solved the issue for me.
Another issue with mine is that my "Breeding" villagers end up using the beds and they don't get back into the single block that they're supposed to be trapped in
@@mashmash4597 That's a problem when there are other blocks nearby that the villagers can "wake up" onto. The best way to fix this is to simply remove all nearby blocks. I have my breeders in a large 5x5 cut out in the ground with 3 or 4 blocks of open space beneath them to force them to wake onto the fence post
SMALL CHANGE FOR 1.16: add a second trap door to the area where the farmer and villagers interact below the original one, and left click it so it is on the side. This prevents the farmer from hopping in with the breeder villagers in 1.16.
Somehow my farm broke after I put a block below the trapdoor that kept the farmer from escaping, he just started to sleep then, and he didn't do that before. :/
TOO ANYONE HAVING PROBLEMS: I have made this design before and it has worked great! It produces WAY more than advertised, but thing can sometimes go wrong. When I build it, I always bring two villagers over, breed them, and put the third as the farmer. This time, I had thrown stacks of beetroot at them (that was the only crop I could get) and they were not breeding. I broke the beds, gave them more food, tried to give them jobs, and nothing worked. Then, while I was looking at a different window, I got a third villager! It had been around 10-15 Minecraft days, and without me doing anything, they just breed! After I put him as the farmer, the breeder is working perfectly! So if you are having problems, just wait!
I highly recommend a lever you can flick to switch from **burn them in hell, throw them into a pit full of evokers, kill them in a redstone game of connect the dots, or whatever the hell you fancy** to **send them to a local storage.**
If anyone’s having trouble moving the villagers, try these. 1. During night time place beds near them and they will try to sleep on it. Once they get there, break the bed and place it in the next location. 2. Drop food near then and they will go to it and pick it up. Continue dropping the food near then until they are in the proper location.
If ur doing this on 1.14.4 Its a bit tedious because of the farmer acting strange. The way i fixed this was by putting a bed inside the farm therefore he can sleep and work. Also I made sure that the breeding villagers claimed the correct beds because i had a problem where one wouldnt claim a bed,
I’m on ps4 Bedrock Edition and if I spent all day working on this and it doesn’t work I’ll be mad, i don’t remember him saying anything about it only working on certain editions tho
For everyone having issues with them NOT making babies, all you have to do is add 4 more beds UNDER the beds you put down, that'll create the needed space they want, it worked great for me an I tried EVERYTHING, gl guys hf!
I'm on a 1.14 server and I cannot thank you enough, my villagers have been stubbornly not breeding for ages and I couldn't find a fix. This has done it, thanks!
Astral Projection don’t remember but I built one today on 1.16 and all you need to do is put more trapdoors around the villagers, what yo do is you flip the existing trapdoors horizontally making shure they are on the bottom of the block and you just put another trapdoor on top of it
This is happening to me as well. He walks around the farm for a bit and then looks at them and repeats the process again without throwing them any food.
Works really great on 1.15.2! I had a few problems with baby villagers spawning outside of the machine so I built a lava pool to kill any who spawned elsewhere. I just hate it when they steal my bed in my house lol also sometimes the farmer would get stuck in the trapdoor square so I removed the bed that is adjacent to the farm and put one on the farm.
One of my villagers keeps escaping. He sleeps in his bed, then wakes up outside the cell and is free to galavant around. I have the beds in the correct orientation with the pillows in the corners. I am going insane.
Dave Wynkoop I actually fought with it for an hour again and got it to work. What SEEMED to fix it was to surround the beds with a block (I used dirt. I’d had the beds just in the air unsuspended before.
I fixed this by moving the fence and trapdoors one block lower Edit: this is tentative and I don’t know if it breaks the farm, also try moving the beds one block higher etc. Edit 2: yep, moved the beds up and it worked. I just built it wrong the first time haha
@@ghostreaperlord5944 isnt it 6? also thats a lot more then what most people need with 1.14. its not like before where you had to find one with good trades you just need to give one good trades from rerolling
@@jonathanclark7444 idk i remember hearing 4 but still its way faster to give many villagers jobs at a time , which increase chances for a perfect villager
I made the farm and slept through a night and nothing spawned, so I flew through the comments looking for a reason for why it might have been broken and I came back and there was one there! thanks a ton
I’ve had so many problems doing this, 10 villagers died, the farmer keeps sleeping with them, it’s taken me hours and it keeps breaking and it’s so stressful
The way this comment read :) To fix the farmer issue just add a trapdoor between the carrot/potato farm and the breeding cell. Impulse also posted a link in a pinned comment.
@@thepizzaman9159 leave an open block so that he can see the villagers, if thats doesnt work, scratch that and just place another trapdoor on the bottom like you did on the top
Make sure your beds are positioned the right way. I think where the villager spawns depends on how your beds are laid out. If the pillows of the bed are facing the corners, then the villager will spawn in a space occupied by the trapdoors, forcing it to go back on the fence post.
Try digging the blocks around the bed out. Like in the video when he digs down to destroy the blocks under the bed. Don’t fill back in what you destroyed to be able to get to a position to destroy the blocks under the bed. I really hope that makes sense. Cause if you do, when the villagers sleep and have babies it risk them spawning on the blocks out from the bed.
Is the situation resolved? Have you given up? If not, Java? bedrock? Have you tried the "fix" ? What are you feeding them? (Carrots is the safest card, the others have issues due to villager inventory settings and how they work) Have you double checked your build to the design?
@@hache4938 You probably could, but it would require you to place torches on top of the actual farmland, which would limit space and over-complicate the simplicity of the design. It would probably just be best to find some pumpkins and farm them to make Jack-O-Lanterns.
I need help, my villagers are throwing food at each other, but every time the farmer comes by, they breed with the farmer. So they baby get's spawned in the farm, not the cell
@@hogo21 i got ya i just fixed this problem trying to sort if for hoursss, dont have the trap door facing from the outside into the villager, put the trapdoors from the villagers outwards and flip them down so there all facing down, then they should be stuck in there and only be able to see there heads
Bed Placement and Orientation seems to be incredibly important in preventing the farmer from getting into it. The orientations shown at 1:09 seem to work consistently, other placements and orientations may allow the farmer to get into the bed
I found out that u need ALOT of food to start breeding... Mine keep throwing the food to each other but when they get enough they breed... (For some reason my villagers get broken hearts and don't breed successfully and ivdo t know why).
@@lilEpicNam3 Its working now but.. i have a new issue.. the farmer keep falling down the hole. its fine tho cuz i just need to put some blocks at the side of the beds and when they sleep theyll wake up on them, and i just need to open the sides so he can pathway back to the farm. its just annoying how you need to do that over and over.
Place some rails and move your villagers with minecarts. Place a rail on an open trapdoor. This way they should fall into the hole. If they are out of it after they sleep, you should place another 4 trapdoors on top of the 4 you already have.
@@WatercraftGames I have the problem where they 'escape' after sleeping. You say to put trap doors on top of the original ones, but won't that block the food coming in?
Works fine on 1.16 with that extra trapdoor. If you get broken hearts it's because you put the villagers in badly. It's because the beds have bugged out and they can't find one for the child. I think possibly the farmer can take one, hence putting them in badly as he shouldn't be able to. To fix this mine and re-place the beds. Took me a while to puzzle this one out -_-
Hello, I have been replied to as many comments as possible however I think it would be easier if I were just to put a comment that people can look at Ok, So if your villagers are disappearing make sure that there is no blocks near the breeder as when the villagers get out of bed they might go to those block Will wheat work: Yes wheat will work but It is bad because the farmer has to craft bread and slowly his inventory will fill up with seeds and he will not be able to harvest any wheat beetroot also works but the best is potatoes or carrot in my opinion If the villagers aren't synced, sleeping at the same time then try replacing all of the beds if this doesn't work then kill the villager who wasn't sleeping before doing this ensure that there is a spare villager then replace the villager. If this still doesn't work then kill the farmer as well. If the villagers are not breeding (in order to get the farmer villager) then because each villager needs 12 of the item to breeder and there is two villagers (2x12=24) try dropping 24 of the item (wheat won't work because they would need bread) then they should breed alternatively if the food keeps dropping down then give the food to them on the beds so they can pick it up easily The villagers are escaping: make sure that the pillows of the beds are in the corners of the square. How many villagers does this make: 12 per hour provided you sleep through the night and the farmer villager has max crops on the dirt. Also last thing (this is copied from impulses's comment)If you are having an issue with the Farmer(s) taking one of the beds at night, check out my solution shown here: ua-cam.com/video/XSi8dmO7nxA/v-deo.html Edit: Some tips for moving the villagers when they escape from beds use a boat to trap them and wait until night and ensure that they can pathfind to a bed at the breeder, then simply break the boat and he should go to bed. Then break all of the blocks around the breeder
Whenever I throw them carrots (I usually throw them on the bed) they pick them up, and then just throw them down the hole. I don't know if they're trying to share and just unable to in the position they're in, which causes them to drop down, or if they're just dropping them while picking them up. I did get them to breed successfully one time, but ever since it hasn't worked. This villager breeder has taken hours and hours of my time, and its hurting my brain
hey, I have been trying to fix my problem for hours my farmer villager keeps trying to breed with my other villager in the trap doors and results in no villagers spawning and the storm particles appearing do you have a fix?
@@noursnice1254 if so i'm not sure if this will work but try killing the villager in the trapdoor that keeps trying to breed with the farmer also try placing a trapdoor at the bottom of where the other trapdoor is: impluse's fix so that the villager cannot pATHFIND to the other villager
![[UA] NAVI проти G2 Esports | Blast Premier Fall Final](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/QWlIm4FGESQ/mqdefault.jpg)
If you are having an issue with the Farmer(s) taking one of the beds at night, check out my solution shown here: ua-cam.com/video/XSi8dmO7nxA/v-deo.html
My farmer doesnt want to plant stuff
bray
I copied what you did exactly but the villager still manages to get in the bed!!
AronLoL 11 same I’m not too sure what it is though
@@jaggtowngaming3485 Yea
8:23 It took me 5 hours to move 3 villagers over. You have a sick and twisted definition of "fun".
yep
I used Nether portal linking and boat travel. My carrot farm was a bit easier because it was underground.
ok so i timed time it took me to get the villagers into the thing and it took about 2 hours (well i did take breaks and stuff so yea this is inaccurate )
Maybe u r just ''noob''
._.
A villager I was transporting fell out of the mine cart and took on the profession of a librarian, and then he sold me mending for 14 emeralds. I do not have a villager breeder but I now have a mending book
u can still make a breeder if you using the librarian
lol good luck
lock him, zombifie him(only if ur on hard mode) and cure him. Your books will then cost one emerald
You have unlimited mending books haha! You can probably make the villager discount it if you use a zombie purifier thingy. I got Sharpness V for 1 emerald that way (sadly it was in creative mode)
@@matthieuchalouhi7273 Do that ONLY if you play on hard difficulty, otherwise you have a chance to lose him
one of my breeders ended up cheating with the farmer causing the other breeder to commit suicide by getting out of bed on the wrong side and falling to their death
wth lol
me too how did you fix
I feel sorry for you because I understand ur pain with villagers but that is quite funny lol
Yea put blocks underneath and around bed, they might fall
all bitches expect mama
1.16 fix:
- Open the trapdoors (so that they are horizontal)
- Add trapdoors on top of the existing trapdoors (again horizontal)
This way the villagers can breed, and the babys don't escape.
Edit 1: I didn't directly connect it to the carrot farm, but you can probably make that work too.
Edit 2: 1.16.2 fix: Put trapdoors on the corners as well, so that the Beds all have two trapdoors above them.
THANK YOU
Did you place the trapdoors on the bottom of the blolcks? Because my babys are escaping... :/
Yes, for both trapdoor layers on the bottom of the blocks
@@kelle500Okay, thank you
Was the additional one on top of the opened trapdoor so they are horizontal and parallel next to the stair?
Perfect. now I can recreate the Anakin younglings scene.
Alex Coomer oh-
This is where the fun begins...
66 likes to go along with the comment. "the time has come, execute order 66".
Alex Coomer dew it
Uh ahaha
Love how Impulse calls transporting Villagers "fun"
We all know that It's a disaster that causes a lot of casualties
It causes casualties amongst my brain cells
Yeah, it took me 3 hours and 4 stacks of iron to escort 2 villagers
The Corona virus is more fun than moving villagers
Normie Slayer yeah I literally just finished getting them from a faraway village
I did figure out if you're using boats and nether portals place a boat outside the nether portal you're shoving the villagers into that way once they show up in the nether they'll be in boat takes a little headache out of dealing with villagers
9:07 Eating 512 potatoes really gets me in the mood too.
@@obodoyo Can't say I counted how many he threw so nice correction :)
Unlike Jon, where a single raw potato is enough to get him out of the mood
www.larknews.com/archives/217
Yeah, especially when they're raw.
thfreakinacage 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
well my villager comitted suicide while going through the nether, he literally did parkour to go to a cliff and threw himself right into a lavapool.
Welcome to the world of Minecraft villagers, doing literally the exact opposite of what you want and/or would expect them to do. Every. Single. Time.
does the farm work on 1.16
@@TheClapGodSr. it should
I was literally trying to fix my villager breeder (in the air) and then it decided to rain and one of my stupid villagers ran of the edge and died.
F
Hey Dipple Dop, thanks for the shoutout! Really happy you found the design useful, lovin' the tutorials, keep 'em coming!
yeet
Hope you get invited in hermitcraft Vll
Should have known you would be here too! 😄
LogicalGeekBoy hey
Why are you familiar to me
I had the problem with my farmer using one of the beds. Solution: When building the farm make sure the two breeder villagers occupy the two beds closest to the farm, that way the farmer has no access to a bed. This can be done by only placing the two closest beds, waiting a night and then placing the other two.
Nice solution!
thanks for the awesome solution
Would there be any issue with just giving the farmer his own and sacrificing 2 of the crop spots?
You have just saved me a lot of time. I was trying to see if I did something wrong with the tutorial but now I have 3 villagers stuck in the breeder... one of them is a nitwit too... but through the power of minecarts I will succeed lol
Since you know more about this than me will it matter if you use beet root instead of carrots or potatoes
I'm actually losing brain cells trying to get these villagers in the right places
LMAO SAME
Use a minecart
@@ultikillerrrr yeah I tried that it's not super precise plus breaking the minecraft sends them outside of the trapdoors, so you need them to walk into it
@@apersonwhomayormaynotexist9868 use walls to block the path
@@ultikillerrrr I found that using a water bucket and a boat is the most helpful for me.
It's been a while since I've looked into your tutorials... i hope your enjoying your 'temporary' full-time minecrafting, you've earned it ^ _ ^
For all those who it isn’t working for in 1.15.2, remove the beds and place them as they were after you’ve finished the farm. I’ve seen this advice posted as replies to comments but wanted to make this a main comment so it can clear up the issue for most who aren’t willing to scroll forever as I did. Like so others can see and comment any other tips if you have them! :D
edit: some other advice is to make sure there are no blocks near the villagers they could spawn on to get out of bed. this includes slabs and trapdoors. also make sure the only villagers near the beds are the two breeding villagers and the farmer. if there are any others they may claim a bed and cause the two villagers not to breed as there are no extra beds
edit 2: just a tip for transporting villagers, if you are constantly editing your setup as i did to make it work efficiently, a good strategy is to have rails and dirt to transport, and instead of using powered rails use a furnace minecart to push a villager in a minecart.
Can you elaborate a little I don't understand
@@JamesFreedmanIsVeryCool sometimes the villager won't breed even after they already slept in the bed or have foods in their inventory. Removing the beds then placing it again kinda solve this problem.
Thank you so much for this comment!
nuke211 just remove them and place them again or should it be in a different placement?
The villagers keep sleeping and not going back onto the fence and it’s been troubling. Is there a fix? Or am I doing something wrong
When I first started this design, my villagers were going at it. My villager trading hall wasn't complete yet so I had to keep them in a holding room. Once I finished it I had so much overflow that I built a second trading hall. Then an iron farm. Then ANOTHER one of these farms hooked up to the same breeder. They still went at it. I've got way too many villagers and my last resort was a water stream that leads to lava. My villagers have been going at it like rabbits and I've had to kill the kids because of it. At least I got a lot of carrots and potatoes to show for it 10/10 would recommend.
Jiggs You don’t need to keep them breeding dude
poor kids immediately born then slaughtered
Exotic Biking it's like an abortion except after they're born
@@JamesMiguelMusic more like involuntary government execution
edit: also my villagers used to work fine and all of a sudden they both died. After replacing them, they decided to retire breeding for the rest of their lives. i think its because they cantfind a way into their beds, but i still dont understand how u have such a surplus of them its almost like diorite. u throw it instantly when u see its in ur inventory.
iqman1000 iskall fan I see :) ran into the same problem a few days ago but I got plenty of villagers left over that I don't need to worry too much abt it. not too sure why it breaks though.
"There are many ways to move villagers around, they're always fun..."
"nO tHeY'rE nOt"
FuriousTree lol, I just tried and lost 1 to a zombie and another to a strange vanishing
@@mightbeahuman3442 ugh i hate villagers.every single farm involving them turns into a 2 day ordeal.
Nomad Hakuna Matata yes
I never had a problem with moving villagers. Are you trying to make them do stuff they don't want to? lol
@@nomadhakunamatata5793 ya my farmer wont do anything with my carrots he just pulls wheat out of his butt
Recently an MC update broke this farm because the villagers won't wake up inside the trapdoors, the solution is very simple. Instead of keeping trapdoors keeping them in, put carpet on top of the beds but leave the space you want them to wake up in uncovered. They refuse to wake up on carpet so they'll automatically wake up in the hole they're supposed to wake up in. You also have to put a trapdoor/block above the villagers or else they'll just walk off the edge. This works for me as of 1.16.3.
Just made it myself and noticed that problem. Thanks your tip fixed it. But also, ull have to place trap doors on top of the carpet to prevent the villagers from just stepping out onto beds again during the day.
@@ltbeefy9054 Shoot! I forgot to mention that!! Thank you for telling me
This worked for me!
@@judedettorre9484 I simply put 1 more later of carpet on top works the same way. 👍Amade a mistake has to be trapdoors
thank you good sir
I've been playing on a server for 3 months now.
I have 9 days playtime and just now thought
*Yeah villagers might be a good idea*
what server ? Is it a survival server ? If so what version and ip bc I’m looking for a new server to play on lol
Finished it, got all the villagers in, then afked for like 10 minutes, came back and realized I left a block on the side and a zombie came in and killed all 3... my fury cannot be contained
that must be so annyoying!!
you can turn them back to villagers if they are zombie villagers and not despawned
This is why my farm is in the air
Just turn em back aaand they should spawn an iron golem
F
Thank you for the massive shout out!
That design setup looks really useful
Instructions unclear, summoned ender dragon.
how?
@@catalyst217 /summon ender_dragon
No, I m good at commands but how did he summon it when trying to make a breeder
@@catalyst217 it is a joke
Oh ok
Literally everything went wrong. This was the most stressful experience of my life
You have an easy life
Dumbass
Villagers are always a pain in the ass to work with
@@daanstrik4293 they all got out. Then they all just despawned nothing worked the right way
@Esteban Christoffersen that's what's weird about it
I had tons of problems, so I resorted to using pistons to smash the villagers into each other, effectively forcing them to smooch up a baby.
Well that's one way to do it
I like this method
@@BredNuts It sounds like the best way to do it
thats so wrong, forcing villagers to reproduce lmao
Damn
To solve the farmer sleeping on bed situation u can just place another bed in the farm land for the farmer to sleep on. Yes it would destroy 2 crop space, but it is way better than spending hours relocating the villagers
You just fixed my problem too, thank you for that little tip
I did it and hes still taking the bed
I can only put one villager in the breeding chamber and when he goes to sleep he wakes up out of the chamber, please help
@Caiden 25 I just killed him, brought a new one and placed 2 beds next to him, and now they are doing so muchhhh babys
Notrikus break all four of the bed first and place one in the carrot/potatoe farm. Then wait for night time and wait for the farmer to claim the bed in the farm. Finally place the four beds back.
he sounds like he's smiling through out the video
Gigglyman does have that smile plastered to his face.
It's called "uptalk"
Yeah sounds so nice
And you sound stupid
Ikr
thank you so much for showing the amount of items I need for this farm, it makes it so much easier than having to listen to someone list them out and me rush to write them down
EDIT: Do NOT place the four trapdoors like in the video. Instead, place carpets on top of all the beds (8 carpet) and then glass on top of that. This fixes the farm for 1.16.4+ .
To anyone who is having problems with the farmer sleeping in the bed:
- Make sure to have a trap door on the crop level of the farmer's feet (the bottom half of the the block below the trapdoor in the video)
To anyone who is having problems with the villagers not staying on the fence/escaping out of the area:
- Surround the beds with fences, 2 high
To anyone having issues with frustration particles after hearts of villagers not breeding:
- Make sure the beds have the "pillows" in the corners of the farm
- Make sure that there are NO blocks (includes everything even glass, slabs, trapdoors and other transparent blocks) over the the pillows/corners of the breeding area EDIT: this just means RIGHT on top, so there just needs to be a one block air gap between pillow/corner and the glass wall
Had a couple problems while building this a couple times but these are all the solutions I've found. Thanks for the awesome farm impulse!
Thx dude! You're my Hero!
THAT was my problem with farm!
"To anyone having issues with frustration particles after hearts of villagers not breeding:
- Make sure the beds have the "pillows" in the corners of the farm"
Do you have a solution to the villagers after sleeping, getting up and standing on top of their beds, instead of spawning on the fence?
I have 2 questions:
1, does this work in 1.16
2, are the villagers supposed to sleep in the beds?
@@plat6152 1. Probably it work in 1.16, you can try it
2. Yes, villager can go to sleep. They shouldn't get out of the trapdoors! That is important
What does that mean make sure to have a trap door on the crop level of the farmers feet
breeding cell? you mean
FRICK CHAMBER
EXACTLY!!!! :DDDDDDDD
FRICKINATOR
N O W F R I C K
GET IN THE BOAT
frickitator
Tip: Use work stations to lure the villagers into the breeding chamber, very effective
And bed at night. I managed to do it in 3-5 min
What I did was take them in a boat to a cobble staircase to the top, one block above the trapdoors, and closed off the other paths, and they just walked right in on their own!
Agreed
I have a problem,at night villagers escape with sleeping in bed,how I can fix it thx
@@talkingben9874 How do they escape? Do they wake up in the beds and escape like that?
Brilliant video, I can see how the concept works. Building it today right after my coffee. Also love how you reference the other youtubers that inspired this build.
Earnt yourself a subscriber Impluse. good work :D
Thank you for listing the needed materials, that was super handy!
I spent 4 hours on getting the villagers in there, but I'm so glad it's done, I'm done with villagers for a long time lmaooo
I spent 15 minutes
Lol
@@FxbyyMC same
@Spencer Lu when a villager is in the middle of a desert without close access to water it's not that simple
@Spencer Lu yeah and if a boat is too complicated when going up blocks u just use minecarts
The farmer villager somehow slept on the bed and is now in the breeding pit
I think it has something to do with the bed orientation
I always put the pillows in the corners, and place the beds counter clockwise
I think the pillow corner is what's really causing the farmer to jump in, but I still do the counter-clockwise anyway.
My farmer invasion problems stopped when I put the pillow in the corner, not in the edges as he does here.
@@anshaljain8552 i put the beds counter clockwise with the pillows in the corners but one villager still doesn twake up in the breeding "pen"
@@Emma-ed3jk I am having the same problem
I defently need to try this! And I love the fact that you showed how to escort them to! It will make everything a bit easier ☺️
Thank you. I've been wanting a new design for breeder/carrot farm. This is perfect. So glad you're doing tutorials again. I like you still have an actual intro and you keep it fresh.
"There are many ways to move villagers around, they're always fun..."
Poor choice of words.....
Very poor choice xD
it is fun tho
Yes
why is it a poor choice of words? I didn't understand. Is this supposed to be a joke or something?
It was in fact meant to be a joke lol
fix for villagers waking up on top of the bed instead of on the fence post (1.18.2):
put carpets on the four corners of the bed and then open the four trap doors so that they cover the other part of the bed, make sure the trap doors open downwards and not upwards so they are right above the bed
Thanks, that helps a lot.
Should the trapdoor or the carpet be over the pillow side of the bed?
This worked absolutely perfectly. Thank you for the amazing and detailed video on how to build, and transport villagers. This was easy to build and it started working before I was even done building. Thank you.
TIP: GET THE VILLAGERS TO FALL INTO THE TRAPDOORS, DONT TRY TO SLIDE THEM IN
Edit: Use minecarts and position it above the trapdoor
Tip: To prevent villagers from getting out of the chamber after they sleep, you should put another 4 trapdoors on top of the other ones. But these should be open (horizontally).
Tried this and a few other ways and none seem to work. They always will get up not on the fence post. They will even get up and stand with their head fully in blocks just to not stand on the fence.
This is my issue as well.
@@rdjd91 did you manage to fix this? I still have that problem and i can't figure it out.
thank you!
thanks! this helped out a lot
I have a lot of damn tasks... breed some villagers, make a village raid farm, find a jungle biome for bamboo, then find some cactus in a desert, then make a xp farm from that, then fight the ender dragon, then make a nether farm for all the mobs there, then fight the wither... I don't think I'm gonna live long enough to do all that stuff, even if I don't get bored lol... Anyways thanx for the guide man!
For 1.14.4 Full release you need to give the farmer a bed in the farm, there's almost no other way to keep him from claiming one of the 4 in my experience. put it on the opposite side and put glass above it so he doesn't break the crops.
@@auquitaine9201 if the farmer can actually get to the beds you've done something wrong in following the tutorial.......... do you have the trap door at the top of the opening? and are the beds and post at the right height?
Also, Id recommend removing all the beds except the Farmer's for a night so that the farmer assigns himself to it then put the other 4 in even during the night once you see the farmer sleeping.
place a lower trap door on the block space above the farmland in between the farmland and beds he shows the solution while building this farm on the hermitcraft server
@Snoi Med yes
@Snoi Med They'll end up breeding, leading to excess villagers in the farm.
Been looking for a new infinite breeder. Thanks man
for ppl using this in 1.16.4+, I found if you place double carpet on the beds they won't escape the trapdoors (which they will if you dont with this design because of the 1.16.2 update)
Thank you so much! I was wondering why this didn't work anymore :)
thank that really help
Here's a video showcasing the fix for the farm for 1.16+. Here's the link:ua-cam.com/video/SWcw9nFgt2I/v-deo.html.
Your support really matters to me I am a small UA-cam please check the video out and give your opinions in the comments
This design does work on PS4 with a few easy/minor modifications.
1) Water logging does not keep crops hydrated. To fix this simply come in one block from each of the cardinal points as well as the center, break it, fill with water, and cover (Everything I've tried works). This will keep all but two blocks on each diagonal hydrated.
2) The farmer can escape. Just replace the trap door with an upper slab. He will still be able to see and throw food to the other two villagers.
3) The villagers can occupy a bed and not return to the fence post position. For this one I moved the beds 2 blocks away from the holding cell; on PS4 they do not appear to need to sleep in order to restart the breeding cycle. I have confirmed this over several Minecraft days (about an hour; maybe hour and a half play time)
4) Villagers are easily distracted (This is true on my java version on my laptop as well). Easiest fix of them all, just don't stand so close to them. Sometimes they will try and track you instead of wanting to go into "love mode" or throw food to their buddies. Try and watch the farm from a dozen or so blocks away to make sure it work.
5) Not sure if this is necessary, but I replaced the trapdoors with solid blocks, seemed to make it harder for escapes and easier for the babies to fall through.
One thing that I cant seem to get to work; is that my farmer will only throw food down when they need it and not a carrot, potato, or wheat more. This means I am not receiving the extra produce like ImpulseSV does. If anyone can shoot me a solution to this (For PS4, again my java version runs this breeder smooth as silk) I would be very appreciative.
i’m on ps4 and every time i try to give them food to breed it falls into my hopper how do i stop this and also my villager won’t become a farmer
@@brandonlaurie7042 They may have full inventories. Things like wheat or potatoes (they may have received before transporting to your system) can gum them up. This did happen to me, so I just went to a new village and kidnapped a fresh guy.
Another trick I saw in a different video is to replace the trapdoor holding section with full blocks (I.e. glass), then place a trap door on the upper half of one of these blocks and close it, it will not suffocate the villagers but will prevent food from falling through. This does have the obvious negative that you will no longer receive excess produce.
Have you previously traded with the villager in the farm cell? If so you'll just have to acquire a new one, as that villager will be locked into which ever profession you traded with him as. If not try removing every "work station" type block around the base. Even if they aren't visible to him he can still sometimes become linked. Also make sure once he is a farmer trade with him at least once to ensure he remains a farmer; even if the composter is accidentally destroyed.
Pretty sure my farmer keeps trying to breed with one of the two in the trapdoors, and it's stopping them from breeding since they can't get to eachother and they just keep trying, even after separating them
I am having a similar problem - the result is the farmer is always breeding and then spawning the child villager. My fix so far is the one impulseSV has made in his pinned comment
yeah, i had the same issue i do still have it
@@azeravOS so the raised trapdores fixed it?
Found a fix?
Trying to create my first iron and creeper farm and need some villager.
@@azeravOS Raising the trap door dowsnt work for me :/ Do u have any solutions?
Villagers are so easy to breed now. I just built a few new houses in the Village I'm living in, put a bed in it, and throw a couple of villagers some food.
Awesome tutorial, I always love it when people show the materials beforehand.
Okay, so I think i found the fix for 1.16.2. So do everything he said. BUT. Face the beds away from the corners. And make the trap doors horizontal, not vertical. I've tried putting trap doors on top of the trap doors, but It wasn't letting the villagers breed. The only problem, is the there's no stopping the farmer villager from breeding with the other villagers. So, sometimes the baby villager will spawn on the farm. I took the information from @Hakuna Matata, and just added on to it. Thank you. It should work.
thank you
@exoticasfxck What did you do when your villagers spawned on the beds?
Thanks for the tutorial, Impulse. :)
1.16.4 Fix:
- Remove all the trapdoors, and put carpet about the beds so all the beds are completely covered with carpet
- Put a block above the villagers head so they cannot escape (as shown in this image imgur.com/a/CqqSc05). The glass beside the carpet is just so carrots don't get thrown where the villager cannot pick it up. Shift click the carpets with a block (as shown in this image imgur.com/a/l6D8DHE), so the baby villagers cannot escape and the villagers are protected from outside threats. Last, place a trapdoor (as shown in this image imgur.com/a/8ncrXul) this ensures that the baby villagers cannot escape, and the carrots can still be thrown to the villagers (a solid block would make this difficult).
This fixed all the issues I was having with the farm in 1.16.4
@SkIchT I edited my comment so it's more clear what to do.
@SkIchT No problem at all!
The second link is not working, at least for me, please fix it
@SkIchT oh...
I had't noticed :v
thank you so much
Thank you!
For anyone who's farmer is not working (harvesting or planting) make sure you have Mob Griefing turned on. If it is off the farmer will not be able to break any crops or pick any up. You can toggle this gamerule with the command "/gamerule mobGriefing true" to turn it on and "/gamerule mobGriefing false" to turn it off.
I've built this farm a few times now and I've always had issues with it. Regardless of what fix I tried, the farmer villager always ended up getting into one of the breeding beds and breaking the self-sufficiency of the farm. Recently, however, I think I found a permanent solution. Having the three blocks at the edge of the farm be complete blocks (i.e. not tilled dirt, basically any other full block) and then adding a solid trap door (none of the ones with gaps in them) to the bottom of the gap as Impulse suggests makes it so that the farming villager cannot see beds at all, but I found that it also caused the food the Farmer throws to land on the trap door instead of the beds for the breeders to pick up. I fixed this by having a redstone pulse running into the block that the bottom trap door was attached to, linked up to a daylight sensor 8 blocks away, outside the farm. This allows the trap door to be open during the day so that the food can be thrown correctly, but the daylight sensor will close the trap door at about 6:00pm, just before the villagers start to hop into beds. That way, there's never a point where the Farmer both has access to the beds and also wants to get into them, so he'll never take them. Hopefully this can help others, it seems to have permanently solved the issue for me.
Just for curiosity, are you playing in a snapshot?
@@hellstormbishop2165 No, current release, 1.15.2
Another issue with mine is that my "Breeding" villagers end up using the beds and they don't get back into the single block that they're supposed to be trapped in
@@mashmash4597 That's a problem when there are other blocks nearby that the villagers can "wake up" onto. The best way to fix this is to simply remove all nearby blocks. I have my breeders in a large 5x5 cut out in the ground with 3 or 4 blocks of open space beneath them to force them to wake onto the fence post
It was easy to set up...moving villagers wasn't an issue. But they're not making love or eating.
Yeah it won’t work for me either
d4nk.mp4 I think I built mine too close to a village. Haven’t moved it yet though.
Joshua Hatfield Same
Feed them breed
Bread
SMALL CHANGE FOR 1.16: add a second trap door to the area where the farmer and villagers interact below the original one, and left click it so it is on the side. This prevents the farmer from hopping in with the breeder villagers in 1.16.
This didnt happened to me tho
Somehow my farm broke after I put a block below the trapdoor that kept the farmer from escaping, he just started to sleep then, and he didn't do that before. :/
My farmer isnt giving potatoes, and my villagers arent breeding, they just keep throwing the potatoes
Yes this is broken
Game rule mob grefing set to truw?
TrainMasters Uk yes
@@Kathen there is another comment on this section that answers the question have a look
the same for me
tip: if you build it in a really high place you can make moving the villager a lot easier
What is the most effective way to transport villagers? Also how?
TOO ANYONE HAVING PROBLEMS:
I have made this design before and it has worked great! It produces WAY more than advertised, but thing can sometimes go wrong. When I build it, I always bring two villagers over, breed them, and put the third as the farmer. This time, I had thrown stacks of beetroot at them (that was the only crop I could get) and they were not breeding. I broke the beds, gave them more food, tried to give them jobs, and nothing worked. Then, while I was looking at a different window, I got a third villager! It had been around 10-15 Minecraft days, and without me doing anything, they just breed! After I put him as the farmer, the breeder is working perfectly! So if you are having problems, just wait!
I think you have to be quick to build a trading hall
I have watched this video so many times...
The fence, it gets me every time!
Anyone else, or is it just me?
10/10 I am literally drowning in villagers I cant breathe help there are so many
Doesnt work for me at alll
thats crazy bc im drowning in stress from the villagers... :) help me
I highly recommend a lever you can flick to switch from **burn them in hell, throw them into a pit full of evokers, kill them in a redstone game of connect the dots, or whatever the hell you fancy** to **send them to a local storage.**
If anyone’s having trouble moving the villagers, try these.
1. During night time place beds near them and they will try to sleep on it. Once they get there, break the bed and place it in the next location.
2. Drop food near then and they will go to it and pick it up. Continue dropping the food near then until they are in the proper location.
My villagers are refusing to sleep in beds (?) so this somehow broke the breeder.
those are such convoluted ways of moving villagers but ok lol
orr you could just use minecarts
On consoles, you need to have a block of water instead of a waterlogged block for the land to be saturated properly
Edit: This is only the case on PS4
No, only on ps4.
Okay thanks
Literally one of the most important minecraft buidls in history. Impulse being a champ
If ur doing this on 1.14.4 Its a bit tedious because of the farmer acting strange. The way i fixed this was by putting a bed inside the farm therefore he can sleep and work. Also I made sure that the breeding villagers claimed the correct beds because i had a problem where one wouldnt claim a bed,
Thomas Whitford I’m having the same problem, one of the breading villagers never sleeps....
@@Buik- I had this same issue, what fixed it for me was placing the beds the way he does in the video, with the pillows in the middle.
Every time my villagers went to sleep they
wouldn’t go back to standing on the fence they would stand on the bed
Did you arrange the beds with the pillows in the corners?
Same. Please someone help us
I’m having the same problem, plz help!!!!!
Andrew Ross i have that to, see them just walking trough the little doors. They wont stay in the middle. Is it because of bedrock?
I’m on ps4 Bedrock Edition and if I spent all day working on this and it doesn’t work I’ll be mad, i don’t remember him saying anything about it only working on certain editions tho
For everyone having issues with them NOT making babies, all you have to do is add 4 more beds UNDER the beds you put down, that'll create the needed space they want, it worked great for me an I tried EVERYTHING, gl guys hf!
Does this still work in 1.16.1?
I'm on a 1.14 server and I cannot thank you enough, my villagers have been stubbornly not breeding for ages and I couldn't find a fix. This has done it, thanks!
Astral Projection yes it does but you need some quick fixes he shows them in a recent hermitcraft video
ElTrouble Gamer Oh. Thanks. Do you know what episode?
Astral Projection don’t remember but I built one today on 1.16 and all you need to do is put more trapdoors around the villagers, what yo do is you flip the existing trapdoors horizontally making shure they are on the bottom of the block and you just put another trapdoor on top of it
You are the only that I see who talk about beds orientations, thanks ;)
he said "build 21*21" but built 19*19 big brain time
so i'm not the only one who noticed XD
@@SetoWolf bruh he added two more blocks on either side afterwards
OMG THATS WHY my build was off!!! LMAO and the whole time I kept thinking to myself "dangit why do I keep thinking it's 19??"
yeah, doesn't work for me. My farmer wont leave the breeders alone. He just stands next to them up against the trap door.
or
ua-cam.com/video/_vzs-3ZrERM/v-deo.html
He walks to them because it’s not work time. He’ll work when it’s time.
@@yashjethwani1025 That video is wrong, they claim doors matter in 1.14 which is wrong. Also their method to pull out villagers is very very tedious.
This is happening to me as well. He walks around the farm for a bit and then looks at them and repeats the process again without throwing them any food.
@@cristianstoica2927 did you give the farmer enough time to collect enough food to share? once he has extra, he should start sharing with the others
my villagers are waking up outside the trapdoors
same
Make sure you put the trapdoors right
@@franromero151 Same problem and I mounted the trap doors exactly as shown in the video.
@@franromero151 what do you mean place them right why would we place them wrong
OliverOrnmarker youre fucking braindead
It really works guys thank u so muchhh bro
Keep it up
This is the most frustrating thing on the planet to try and set up
For those having issues with villagers staying in, I put carpets on the ends on each bed and it seems to have worked
Thx a lot!
dankjewel
If the Farmer villagers keep sleeping with the enslaved ones, place a bed in the corner of their farm. That's the easiest fix I can find.
I did that and he sometimes changes his bed :(
Works really great on 1.15.2! I had a few problems with baby villagers spawning outside of the machine so I built a lava pool to kill any who spawned elsewhere. I just hate it when they steal my bed in my house lol also sometimes the farmer would get stuck in the trapdoor square so I removed the bed that is adjacent to the farm and put one on the farm.
Having the same issue. Nice solution. Might try that
One of my villagers keeps escaping. He sleeps in his bed, then wakes up outside the cell and is free to galavant around. I have the beds in the correct orientation with the pillows in the corners. I am going insane.
I have the same problem! Can anyone help?
Dave Wynkoop I actually fought with it for an hour again and got it to work. What SEEMED to fix it was to surround the beds with a block (I used dirt. I’d had the beds just in the air unsuspended before.
make sure the area near the beds is slabbed off
Make sure there are no blocks to villagers can move to around the beds. They will teleport out the beds if there are any
Also make sure the pillow of each bed is in a corner
When my villagers sleep they don't go back to the breeding cell...
Underface Kelly is the pillow of the bed in the corners of the chamber?
I fixed this by moving the fence and trapdoors one block lower
Edit: this is tentative and I don’t know if it breaks the farm, also try moving the beds one block higher etc.
Edit 2: yep, moved the beds up and it worked. I just built it wrong the first time haha
Me too and my bed are as same as in the vid I've been trying for 4 hours
@@DJSpoona21 they aren't supposed to be like on the vid. The pillows are supposed to be on the corners.
@@nakog8686 I've done that but I'm on bedrock so that might have something to do with it?
>Me looking for villager breeding guides
"Heyyy isn't that by Grians hippie buddy? Sure I'll use this one then"
Issue resolved.
just wanna say btw this works really really well
peachy its only 4 villagers an hr LOL
@@ghostreaperlord5944 isnt it 6? also thats a lot more then what most people need with 1.14. its not like before where you had to find one with good trades you just need to give one good trades from rerolling
@@jonathanclark7444 idk i remember hearing 4 but still its way faster to give many villagers jobs at a time , which increase chances for a perfect villager
Ghostreaperlord once this thing gets going it’s basically a constant supply
I made the farm and slept through a night and nothing spawned, so I flew through the comments looking for a reason for why it might have been broken and I came back and there was one there! thanks a ton
I’ve had so many problems doing this, 10 villagers died, the farmer keeps sleeping with them, it’s taken me hours and it keeps breaking and it’s so stressful
How did you fix the farmer's problem?
The way this comment read :)
To fix the farmer issue just add a trapdoor between the carrot/potato farm and the breeding cell. Impulse also posted a link in a pinned comment.
Gregory Norris even if i place the trapdoor the villager keeps getting into the bed.
@@orotsz i made a room connected to the farm with farmers own bed, if he sleeps in that 1 time he will do it for ever
but my farm is still very slow i got like 2 babies after like 4 hours dunno why
even with the fix from your hermitcraft world, the farmer manages to sleep in a bed
Just place blocks around the villager pen, then the farmer wont be able to see the villager
@@astron0mix484 wouldn't that stop him from throwing the carrots?
@@thepizzaman9159 leave an open block so that he can see the villagers, if thats doesnt work, scratch that and just place another trapdoor on the bottom like you did on the top
Man, what would I do without Impulse, all the love and support man
im so lucky that i live from a village thats about 1000 blocks away but right next to a sea =)
nice
Just had to deal with this but I got two villagers to my home through the nether
Wow now that's awsome
The villagers just aren't breeding but there are no visible problems
Same
yeah me to
William Cartner same
Ok I got it to work remove all blocks around the pillow of the head and give them like 10 stacks of food that seemed to work for me
It’s patched
Now I can beat a baby villager like my father beat me! Thanks Darl!
thanks for breeder tutorial it is very useful thank you Impulse!!
My villagers don’t spawn in the trapdoors and just spawn on the bed when they wake up, then they just walk away
Can anyone help me?
Unknown Mission64 maybe place a slab 1.5 blocks above the bed so the only block they can wake up on is the fence?
Make sure your beds are positioned the right way. I think where the villager spawns depends on how your beds are laid out. If the pillows of the bed are facing the corners, then the villager will spawn in a space occupied by the trapdoors, forcing it to go back on the fence post.
Try digging the blocks around the bed out. Like in the video when he digs down to destroy the blocks under the bed. Don’t fill back in what you destroyed to be able to get to a position to destroy the blocks under the bed. I really hope that makes sense. Cause if you do, when the villagers sleep and have babies it risk them spawning on the blocks out from the bed.
I have the same problem and these suggestions don’t work
I’m having the exact same problem, no way of stopping it
My villagers just throw food at each other without breeding
me to
pingüino crack same
Fe051206 Luz literally nothing will work. They just keep throwing food
That happened to me too, I brought in a new villager and it was fixed
Arjun Anand yeah I have a village right next to my base but there’s no villagers and those were the last three I had
Also, villagers are not breeding no matter what. Everything build perfectly; hundreds of food being given to them
same idk what i did wrong
same
Same
Theey became sterile
Same
Thanks for the video impulse ♥
I'm a new subscriber and thank you
I’m playing in the most recent snapshot and it will not work consistently. It has been up for around 2 hours and has only produced one villager
Is the situation resolved?
Have you given up?
If not, Java? bedrock?
Have you tried the "fix" ?
What are you feeding them? (Carrots is the safest card, the others have issues due to villager inventory settings and how they work)
Have you double checked your build to the design?
You can use Jack-o-Lanterns instead of Glowstone or Sea Lanterns, just FYI.
Or build on a mooshroom biome.
Can you do it with torches?
@@hache4938 You probably could, but it would require you to place torches on top of the actual farmland, which would limit space and over-complicate the simplicity of the design. It would probably just be best to find some pumpkins and farm them to make Jack-O-Lanterns.
In 1.16 you can also use shroomlight
I need help, my villagers are throwing food at each other, but every time the farmer comes by, they breed with the farmer. So they baby get's spawned in the farm, not the cell
same thing
memoli4321 I’ve destroyed all the beds multiple times though
@@hogo21 i got ya i just fixed this problem trying to sort if for hoursss, dont have the trap door facing from the outside into the villager, put the trapdoors from the villagers outwards and flip them down so there all facing down, then they should be stuck in there and only be able to see there heads
I switched the beds around gave them a lot of carrots and it worked
@@sd_marra920 wich trapdoors do you mean ?
Bed Placement and Orientation seems to be incredibly important in preventing the farmer from getting into it. The orientations shown at 1:09 seem to work consistently, other placements and orientations may allow the farmer to get into the bed
My farmer is just staring at then not throwing food
villagers wont breed now... they just throw the carrots right back at each other.. help :(
Same, got it fixed? :)
I found out that u need ALOT of food to start breeding... Mine keep throwing the food to each other but when they get enough they breed... (For some reason my villagers get broken hearts and don't breed successfully and ivdo t know why).
Update (it's apparently because I was looking at them.... So give them alot of food and just wait). See if that works
@@lilEpicNam3 Its working now but.. i have a new issue.. the farmer keep falling down the hole. its fine tho cuz i just need to put some blocks at the side of the beds and when they sleep theyll wake up on them, and i just need to open the sides so he can pathway back to the farm. its just annoying how you need to do that over and over.
I'm also having this issue, no fix for me so far, I'm currently trying the "not looking at them" strategy from the other reply
My problem is they won’t go into the trap door part
Place some rails and move your villagers with minecarts. Place a rail on an open trapdoor. This way they should fall into the hole. If they are out of it after they sleep, you should place another 4 trapdoors on top of the 4 you already have.
@@WatercraftGames I have the problem where they 'escape' after sleeping. You say to put trap doors on top of the original ones, but won't that block the food coming in?
Watercraft thanks man
Smiley Cyrus that’s another problem I have aswel they go to sleep and wake up on the outside of the trap doors
@@joris1899 have you got the pillows of the beds on the outside like the text he put on screen at: 7:13?
Works fine on 1.16 with that extra trapdoor.
If you get broken hearts it's because you put the villagers in badly. It's because the beds have bugged out and they can't find one for the child. I think possibly the farmer can take one, hence putting them in badly as he shouldn't be able to.
To fix this mine and re-place the beds.
Took me a while to puzzle this one out -_-
thx
@@steinar.offroad Check out Impulse's comment/link, don't forget carpets for the corners as of 1.16.2
“Thanks for the F shack” -Dirty Mike and the boys
The other guys ??
Hello, I have been replied to as many comments as possible however I think it would be easier if I were just to put a comment that people can look at
Ok,
So if your villagers are disappearing make sure that there is no blocks near the breeder as when the villagers get out of bed they might go to those block
Will wheat work: Yes wheat will work but It is bad because the farmer has to craft bread and slowly his inventory will fill up with seeds and he will not be able to harvest any wheat beetroot also works but the best is potatoes or carrot in my opinion
If the villagers aren't synced, sleeping at the same time then try replacing all of the beds if this doesn't work then kill the villager who wasn't sleeping before doing this ensure that there is a spare villager then replace the villager. If this still doesn't work then kill the farmer as well.
If the villagers are not breeding (in order to get the farmer villager) then because each villager needs 12 of the item to breeder and there is two villagers (2x12=24) try dropping 24 of the item (wheat won't work because they would need bread) then they should breed alternatively if the food keeps dropping down then give the food to them on the beds so they can pick it up easily
The villagers are escaping: make sure that the pillows of the beds are in the corners of the square.
How many villagers does this make: 12 per hour provided you sleep through the night and the farmer villager has max crops on the dirt.
Also last thing (this is copied from impulses's comment)If you are having an issue with the Farmer(s) taking one of the beds at night, check out my solution shown here: ua-cam.com/video/XSi8dmO7nxA/v-deo.html
Edit: Some tips for moving the villagers when they escape from beds use a boat to trap them and wait until night and ensure that they can pathfind to a bed at the breeder, then simply break the boat and he should go to bed. Then break all of the blocks around the breeder
Whenever I throw them carrots (I usually throw them on the bed) they pick them up, and then just throw them down the hole. I don't know if they're trying to share and just unable to in the position they're in, which causes them to drop down, or if they're just dropping them while picking them up. I did get them to breed successfully one time, but ever since it hasn't worked.
This villager breeder has taken hours and hours of my time, and its hurting my brain
hey, I have been trying to fix my problem for hours my farmer villager keeps trying to breed with my other villager in the trap doors and results in no villagers spawning and the storm particles appearing do you have a fix?
@@noursnice1254 do you have any other villagers
@@noursnice1254 if so i'm not sure if this will work but try killing the villager in the trapdoor that keeps trying to breed with the farmer also try placing a trapdoor at the bottom of where the other trapdoor is: impluse's fix so that the villager cannot pATHFIND to the other villager
@@christianpihlhansen4820 try placing a temp block below the fence and retry