Simon Armitage: 'Mother, Any Distance' Mr Bruff Analysis

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 30 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 170

  • @Lurcii
    @Lurcii 4 роки тому +114

    mrbruff was saving my GCSE's until they got cancelled

  • @louiekroberts
    @louiekroberts 7 років тому +82

    This 20 minute video taught me more than my teacher did 2 1-hour lessons... thank you!

  • @vincentcsmith102
    @vincentcsmith102 8 років тому +226

    mr bruff is saving my GCSEs

  • @Ami-wt8fk
    @Ami-wt8fk 7 років тому +92

    I've improved in my English so much thanks to you, I've gone from a C to an A grade in just 3 weeks. My teacher even accused me of cheating because of how much I had improved so I told her how I revise and she's told my whole year about you. Thank you so much!

  • @erinbond9156
    @erinbond9156 7 років тому +86

    Quick tip if you want to watch this quicker, speed it up by 1.25 or 1.5 :)

  • @lilyyoung4360
    @lilyyoung4360 7 років тому +22

    Literally watched this last night and it came up today. Mr Bruff you're a legend.

  • @farzanabegum6800
    @farzanabegum6800 8 років тому +24

    Helped me so much you can't even imagine. It has details that I didn't even learn in class. Thanks so much!!!!

  • @daliagrantham8423
    @daliagrantham8423 4 роки тому +13

    I’m in y10 and having to do all the poems at home, and your videos are really helping me. Thank you

    • @mrbruff
      @mrbruff  4 роки тому +2

      Glad to help!

    • @nz1159
      @nz1159 4 роки тому +1

      Im in y10 too but they didnt make us do any of our anthology poems at home . but i thought i would start doing some . so i did this one today.

    • @nz1159
      @nz1159 4 роки тому +1

      @@mrbruff Love your videos but they are quite long , if you dont mind can you make shorter clips including notes and highlighted important parts that we need for the anthology poems, to make everything easier and simpler . Thank u.

  • @farradehmartin2749
    @farradehmartin2749 7 років тому +168

    who else is procrastinating in the comments section?

  • @Jasmine_111
    @Jasmine_111 7 років тому +6

    This, among other videos meant that my poetry comparison question went SO well! I can't thank you enough. I was so stressed about English Literature and you made it beyond manageable! Thank-you🙏🏼

    • @mrbruff
      @mrbruff  7 років тому +1

      +Jasmine UA-cam good!

  • @indigorosenhunt9789
    @indigorosenhunt9789 7 років тому +6

    Thank you so much, I watched this a couple of nights before the exam and was without a doubt the most helpful video I had watched.

  • @xishaqk
    @xishaqk 7 років тому +18

    This came up in the 2017 paper today! :)

  • @amydunderdale3654
    @amydunderdale3654 7 років тому +1

    mr bruff, you’re a life saviour regarding english gcse’s !!

  • @johnroberts262
    @johnroberts262 2 роки тому +2

    I am an elderly retired man who enjoys these recordings greatly, I watch them and buy some of his e-books.

  • @biancarai2097
    @biancarai2097 5 років тому +8

    Oh my god. This will help me so much I think I am about to cry
    (and fall or fly)

  • @Incognito_ST
    @Incognito_ST 2 роки тому +9

    GRADE 9 20 MARKER EXAMPLE FREE TO USE , WROTE IN EXAM CONDTIONS APOLOGIES FOR ANY GRAMMACTICAL ERRORS.
    In the poem, the writer has presented the relationship with the mother as two opposites that attract. They have very contrasting personalities that are bonded together like a "spool of tape". The mother is presented as a formal character that keeps her son grounded and gives a sense of structure in his life. We can see this as the poem is put in a AABB rhyme scheme throughout the play. This set structured rhyme scheme symbolizes how his mother keeps him structures throughout his life. She is the very thing keeping his safe and protected. This set of arrangement gives us a sense that she has set foundations in her sons life. The speaker clearly has a formal relationship with his mother as it isn't free verse or flowing. This sense of formality is even more emphasized as the write gives a direct address to his mother about how he is going to leave the "hatch" and go into the wide world. He used colloquial formal language of "mother" instead of a more loving connotating word of mummy or mum. This shows they have a very traditional relationship. We see her personality and the relationship being presented thorough the word "anchor" , the mother has been presented through the noun as someone who is grounded and firm. A anchor connotates to someone that protects her son and keeps him at bay. Like the anchor that protects the boat from getting lost in the waves and wind his mother is keeping him safe and protecting him from the world and society. A anchor is a important component in a boat signifying how important his mother is to him. This tells us that the mother is a figure in his life that is dear to him someone that has protected him and gave him a sense of structure in his life. This tells us that the speaker and his relationship of him and his mother is a figure of formality , structure, importance and is someone who has protected him and cared for him. She has kept him grounded in the relationship which contrasts with his idea of breaking free into the world.
    The writer shows the clashing of personality's in the relationship. The speaker is someone who is a "kite" and is opening a "hatch " into the "endless sky". The noun kite is a direct juxtaposition to anchor. The word endless signifies the boundlessness of the world he will enter into , its hyperbolic language is emphasizing what he is entering into to. He will either "fly or fall" the speaker is telling his mother that he understands what he is going to face and is reassuring her. The speaker is trying to fly high in the wind and sky but is being holded down by a string (his mother). He is being compared to like a kite a strong metaphor showing his personality trait as someone who is about to be free. The speaker wants to be released into the world, the very thing his mother is protecting him from. In doing so he is going to break the hatch and open the doors. This is a metaphorical representation of what he will do (leave his mother and go be by himself in the endless world). This tells us that the speaker is someone who is going to leave his mother and go break free into the world but he is reassuring the mother that he will be safe on the other end of the tape. This tells us that his relationship with his mother is tight knit together and close. He reassures her that even though they will be separated and he will be gone with the wind and float away he cares- even though he's moving on.

  • @mialewis8474
    @mialewis8474 6 років тому +7

    you’re saving my life

  • @emmac8495
    @emmac8495 8 років тому +4

    Thank you so much, your videos have helped me incredibly with my GCSE revision!

    • @mrbruff
      @mrbruff  8 років тому +1

      no problem

  • @g123-i5o
    @g123-i5o 7 років тому +3

    mr bruff is the reason i'm passing English thanks !!

    • @mrbruff
      @mrbruff  7 років тому +3

      +MYxLIFExASxAxTEEN happy to help

  • @MrBobbycat123
    @MrBobbycat123 7 років тому +2

    These are going to help with my mocks tomorrow, luckily my teacher suggested them!

  • @justshen2879
    @justshen2879 4 роки тому +5

    13:00 wouldn't the shortest line be "has to give"?

  • @jonathanmelia
    @jonathanmelia 6 років тому +12

    “Acres” and “prairies” could be interpreted as the promise of a “new world”. Much early American literature is all about the promise and romanticism of “wide open spaces” and striking out on your own, in the American Wilderness. Perhaps Armitage is presenting himself as a similar type of pioneer, which ties in with the image of the “space-walk”.

  • @Akhan._.1512
    @Akhan._.1512 Рік тому +1

    감사합니다 😊, 역시, bruff 님 너는 최고야!

  • @raytrevor-p4j
    @raytrevor-p4j Рік тому +1

    i really enjoyed this video great help and really gave me a good understanding of the poem thank you so very much mr Bruff

  • @riyaperuvelil221
    @riyaperuvelil221 8 років тому +21

    Do you have any tips on how to actually revise for poetry? Could you do a video on it?

    • @mrbruff
      @mrbruff  8 років тому +13

      yes of course

  • @rosie8642
    @rosie8642 6 років тому +2

    Thankyou!!! you have no idea how much this helped

  • @pixelbro3327
    @pixelbro3327 7 років тому +1

    thank you for the help.
    this will defiantly help me prepare for my exam.

  • @saimauddin5093
    @saimauddin5093 8 років тому +3

    Your videos are so helpfull, you wouldn't understand! I've been listening to each of your poetry videos this holiday and I'm thinking more into depth when reading poems, sometimes my predictions of what you say in the videos are true. Thank you so so much:)

    • @mrbruff
      @mrbruff  8 років тому +1

      +Saima Uddin fantastic

  • @sweetprincess2990
    @sweetprincess2990 8 років тому +22

    this helped me soooo much. thank you.

    • @mrbruff
      @mrbruff  8 років тому

      +SweetpRincess great!

  • @elisegreen1227
    @elisegreen1227 7 років тому +4

    Ur saving my gcse's right now. I want to do my best but I just don't know how to analyse this poem. it's quite complex I feel

  • @h4lplays932
    @h4lplays932 6 років тому +2

    I’m in year 9 and this analysis has certainly helped me during the exam period. Will certainly recommend to my fellow students :) also there are so many points in this that I am not sure where I can include in my KECAL paragraphs anyone got any ideas

    • @samagate4459
      @samagate4459 Рік тому

      im in year 11 and i agree wholeheartedly

  • @henrybryant1075
    @henrybryant1075 6 років тому +9

    Good sir I would like to shake your hand, thank you!

  • @theSafetyCar
    @theSafetyCar 8 років тому +4

    Another great video. Thank you so so much!

  • @cheeseworld6057
    @cheeseworld6057 Рік тому

    The poem starts using the ground floor to represent the start of the child's life. Falling out the hatch on the roof (failing at something in life) would bring the speaker back to the first floor again. This perhaps symbolises how the mother will look after the speaker after he fails and being a "mother" at "any distance".

  • @Oli_Pequeno
    @Oli_Pequeno 7 років тому +4

    I’ve been saved for my GCSE

  • @gracedoyle4924
    @gracedoyle4924 6 років тому +2

    Mr Bruff is a godsend

  • @polyquadratus5304
    @polyquadratus5304 Рік тому +1

    1:14 I spent so long trying to read this poem aloud in under 20 seconds that I've pretty much memorised it by accident...

  • @Dallimoo
    @Dallimoo 7 років тому

    Sososososo glad my teacher was right in predicting it would be this poem and so glad I watched this last minute last night!!!

    • @nazish5065
      @nazish5065 7 років тому

      how did she make the prediction when this was the first exam in the new spec lol?

  • @AroojFatima-vu7hy
    @AroojFatima-vu7hy 5 років тому

    Thank you so much you really are saving my GCSE’s

  • @annieen3884
    @annieen3884 8 років тому +1

    This video was so helpful! Thank you!!

  • @ahmedbenhariz8694
    @ahmedbenhariz8694 7 років тому +4

    whats the difference between structure and form?

    • @mrbruff
      @mrbruff  7 років тому +2

      Covered in my Literature playlist

    • @outofthegoldfishbowletcete762
      @outofthegoldfishbowletcete762 7 років тому +4

      Ahmed Benhariz form us what it looks like. Structure is where do different things happen. (Exposition - rising action - climax- falling action - denoument) or beginning/middle/end

    • @elliottclark6547
      @elliottclark6547 3 роки тому

      @@outofthegoldfishbowletcete762 thanks

  • @leilamalik2412
    @leilamalik2412 6 років тому +2

    Another great video, thank you 👍🏼📝

    • @mrbruff
      @mrbruff  6 років тому +1

      Thanks

    • @Akhan._.1512
      @Akhan._.1512 Рік тому

      I love how he replies to yours but ignores the others

  • @ellieisabella5067
    @ellieisabella5067 3 роки тому +1

    saving gcse since 2016

  • @Santiago-ct2rv
    @Santiago-ct2rv 4 роки тому +1

    Thanks for the help

  • @nazrinrahman6781
    @nazrinrahman6781 7 років тому +1

    YOU ARE SIMPLY AMAZING, can you give me some advice when writing essays, as I find it so hard to do

  • @shampabanerjee4715
    @shampabanerjee4715 7 років тому

    Excellent analysis

  • @sergeantweasel
    @sergeantweasel Рік тому

    Could the "acres" and "prairies" also represent aspiration to travel greater distances away from his mother/show that his decisions are now more impactful and matter on scales more significant than just a "single span"?
    Very helpful video, got my mock tomorrow

    • @mrbruff
      @mrbruff  Рік тому +1

      Yes that's a good idea.

  • @hasanlort1820
    @hasanlort1820 Рік тому

    Mr Bruff would it be possible if you could do a video on farmers bride?

  • @minazalam6964
    @minazalam6964 7 років тому +1

    Your videos help a lot, thanks, honestly. :)

  • @بنتأنصار-ح4ذ
    @بنتأنصار-ح4ذ 5 років тому +1

    Its says his poems are usually influenced by music - does this have any link to Mother Any Distance????

  • @afelbino5929
    @afelbino5929 8 років тому

    how is the 2nd stanza (which includes anchor) an ejambment. Isn't enjambent when a sentence flows from one stanza to another

    • @maddieh1878
      @maddieh1878 8 років тому

      Naod Sahle it can be from one sentence to another as well. In fact this is the more common use

  • @ewandeeley4019
    @ewandeeley4019 7 років тому +2

    what poem would you compare this too/

  • @elliotchilton3431
    @elliotchilton3431 7 років тому

    thank you so much your videos are so helpful! have you got any tips on how best to remember quotes? i am studying Merchant of Venice, LOTF and Jekyll and Hyde for aqa. Thanks!

  • @simranjeetsingh6879
    @simranjeetsingh6879 4 роки тому

    One thing I don't get with poetry is that what do you even write when the mark scheme says talk about context. I bought a revision guide and it just talks about the background of the writer's which doesn't fit in any points you make in the essay. Can you please help Mr Bruff?

  • @skylaliberty267
    @skylaliberty267 7 років тому

    Do you have a book with annotations on all the love and relationship poems???

  • @temimahrees4248
    @temimahrees4248 3 роки тому

    Splace? What is splace? 17:26

  • @parneets5207
    @parneets5207 7 років тому

    such a good video!!

  • @deoxysgeneration2126
    @deoxysgeneration2126 8 років тому

    Is it good to refer to similar texts from Simon Armitage to compare and contrast in the exam?

    • @Akhan._.1512
      @Akhan._.1512 Рік тому

      Yes ones I can recommend are before you were mine by carol Anne Duffy and walking away.

  • @kieragibson8999
    @kieragibson8999 5 років тому

    so helpful!

  • @lukef1131
    @lukef1131 6 років тому

    Do you have anything on the context of the poem? Or is it not really as relevant to this poem as say follower?

  • @alexyankson4759
    @alexyankson4759 7 років тому

    can this poem also be compared to Walking away

    • @hasanal-ansari7118
      @hasanal-ansari7118 7 років тому

      Both show the changing relationship between parents-children so as the themes are similar the answer would be yes

    • @Akhan._.1512
      @Akhan._.1512 Рік тому

      Yes , they both use the imagery of space and changing relationships between parent and child

  • @leec4185
    @leec4185 8 років тому

    Excellent.

  • @VJ-fr2zd
    @VJ-fr2zd 4 роки тому +1

    I appreciate these poems more now that I’m not in school

  • @BreadButter00
    @BreadButter00 3 роки тому

    Can't believe this is my HOMEWORK

  • @zainabmussa4515
    @zainabmussa4515 7 років тому +1

    youre the best!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @tyrellwellick5968
    @tyrellwellick5968 8 років тому +5

    Plz can you do tissue by imtiaz dharker

  • @maisiedavis3750
    @maisiedavis3750 8 років тому +2

    OMG THANK YOU SO MUCH

  • @jessica_little_star757
    @jessica_little_star757 8 років тому

    this helped me so much with my GCSES! thank you

    • @mrbruff
      @mrbruff  8 років тому +1

      +jessica_little_star good

  • @eleanor6271
    @eleanor6271 5 років тому

    Is this written from the perspective of Simon Armitage do you think?

    • @mrbruff
      @mrbruff  5 років тому +1

      Not that I know of.

  • @mariaosu
    @mariaosu 7 років тому +1

    Mr Bruff, I have subscribed - what does this give me? Not that I'm expecting anything, just curious. Your explanations are great, very helpful. Thanks!

  • @joycelynallotey4170
    @joycelynallotey4170 8 років тому

    A-MAZING!

  • @hillarytrimarchi4944
    @hillarytrimarchi4944 6 років тому +1

    What is splace. Splace? What IS splace? ahaha that made my day

  • @kittyjohnson2875
    @kittyjohnson2875 8 років тому +2

    helpful

  • @morganrhea9412
    @morganrhea9412 4 роки тому

    Can some1 pls make a summary of this pls 🥺🥺

  • @nads5267
    @nads5267 5 років тому

    thank you oh my

  • @anisafarah78
    @anisafarah78 7 років тому

    Where is the context for this poem?

    • @mrbruff
      @mrbruff  7 років тому

      the book it comes from is context

    • @anisafarah78
      @anisafarah78 7 років тому

      mrbruff I wrote that in my essay and my teacher commented that it's not relevant context

    • @mrbruff
      @mrbruff  7 років тому +3

      It depends on the question.

  • @ruxi5503
    @ruxi5503 7 років тому +2

    exam today :(

  • @rosey2743
    @rosey2743 8 років тому

    Hi please can you finish the power and conflict cluster In the time space of 6 weeks please thank you so much

    • @mrbruff
      @mrbruff  8 років тому

      new poem every Saturday

  • @samuelthomas4175
    @samuelthomas4175 8 років тому

    Could you say that as you can't have a single-word sentence that is grammatically correct (you need a verb). It reflects how there are no bounds to the mother and speakers relationship.

  • @yoosufnasleem8810
    @yoosufnasleem8810 7 років тому +15

    his voice makes me go to sleep...

  • @joebastianich3410
    @joebastianich3410 4 роки тому +2

    simone artwedge looks clapped

  • @ninomiletic7860
    @ninomiletic7860 5 років тому

    you legend

  • @claudiamoreno7382
    @claudiamoreno7382 8 років тому

    can you do Eden Rock?

    • @mrbruff
      @mrbruff  8 років тому

      +Claudia Moreno this week

  • @ea1766
    @ea1766 5 років тому

    7:31

  • @leochampion6491
    @leochampion6491 4 роки тому +1

    Mr Kelly is the true boomer

  • @xxcrazygamerxx4315
    @xxcrazygamerxx4315 6 років тому

    south africa

  • @lvrnknnlvr
    @lvrnknnlvr 4 роки тому +1

    Ah

  • @shaznaks7568
    @shaznaks7568 7 років тому +1

    woo

  • @SunshineSML
    @SunshineSML 8 років тому +1

    sup 11X

  • @fredcalledbygod
    @fredcalledbygod 5 років тому +1

    This is the most boring poem in the anthology

    • @fredcalledbygod
      @fredcalledbygod 5 років тому +5

      Krrish Mehrotra It’s my opinion though? It’s not even a negative comment and yes I do understand the poem but I PERSONALLY find it boring.

  • @theanti-christ2842
    @theanti-christ2842 8 років тому +2

    If this gets pinned I'll pass my GCSE's

  • @johnholme138
    @johnholme138 7 років тому

    Splace

  • @Sarong86
    @Sarong86 4 місяці тому

    5:39