This is a fictional account of the space race portrayed as if the Russians reached the moon first. The technology is fictional as well. That was not the LEM that lift off the moon. It is a fictional LSAM (Lunar Surface Access Module) that is why the entire thing lifted off and did not detach from the landing legs. Designed to be reusable on the surface of the moon.
Does the fact that there's a Cosmonaut walking around on the Moon give anyone a clue that this is fiction, not history or current reality? Learn about the histories of the actual space programs of the US, USSR, Russia and other countries so you will better understand what differences exist in this fictional storyline.
@Mike DeMarco It sounds like we're close in age. I don't recall the Gemini missions, but I built plastic model kits of the Mercury, Gemini and Apollo spacecraft, along with fictional craft as well. I kind of recall the Apollo 1 fire, but not a lot of details from when it happened. Definitely recall Apollo 7 onwards, and met Jim Lovell at a book signing for "Lost Moon", later renamed "Apollo 13" after the movie came out. My autographed copy of it is one of my proudest possessions. I do get disheartened by the lack of enthusiasm for spaceflights, Flat Earth / Moon Landing Hoax believers, etc. I feel Buzz Aldrin was justified in punching that one Flat Earther (Bart Sibrel?) who called him a liar and a thief after Buzz refused to swear on a Bible that he'd walked on the Moon. Wrong thing to ask someone who took communion right after landing there. There's just too much denial of science and acceptance of false facts these days.
@@jeddyhi I agree, "This is an alternate timeline you idiot." doesn't make it very clear who he is addressing. If he meant me, then I thought I made it clear in my comment, just as you did in yours, that this is not reality and follows a different path through history.
The message is strong in this one:only if we are willing to set aside our differences and work together, are we able to reach the stars, or protect home, whichever direction you choose.
Unless the differences are of belief, and they are too fundamental to reconcile. I mean, if the Third Reich were still around, and was still as genocidal as it was in the 1940s, I think most of us would say it's not morally tenable to set aside those difference to cooperate with it in the exploration and settlement of space (or anything else).
@@richardmalcolm1457 The soviets and America, are still partners in space. When the wall fell, so did the cold war. And relations made a change for the better. :-)
@@mrzorg "Russians," not "Soviets." :) Partners now, albeit rather tense partners. But my only point was that the observation about "setting aside our differences" in cby's comment is pablum if it is not qualified: because we can all come up with scenarios where we would *not* work with another human polity if pressed to it, if they embodied or advocated something we truly considered evil. Putin's Russia may not be in this category, but I tend to think Nazi Germany would be, if it were still around.
Isaac Schrader It’s funny you say that, because the show is all about humanity fighting over stupid things, resulting in competition, furthering space exploration. So they are getting more done because they are fighting over stupid things.
@@justking0600 Yep, which is why capitalism worked so well. It is the epitome of fighting over shit and beating your competitor. If we all sat back and sang songs, nothing would get done.
@@blockobutter Yeah, yet again, SpaceX is doing great and they have no competitors. Not saying you are wrong, capitalism is great, but SpaceX is a huge exception. Musk will be ruling Mars in the next 4 years.
I'm going to have to stop you there. As much as I like cosmonauts, remember that at the beginning of season 2 it was discovered that when Ed left, he implanted a spying device, so, not too innocent
@@IshijimaKairo Are you trying to say that being a human in space is a bad idea (potentially facetiously), or are you saying that it's a bad idea that everyone in space is equal?
And survivors. If things go wrong (your spaceship broke, for example), there's no one else to ask for help but the other guy. The last thing you want to do is to make an enemy out of the only human person in a 384,000 kilometres radius.
@@aconite72 tell that to the writers who decided to portray astronauts as psychos .. renember the american dude decided to arrest and beat the russian cosmonaut thinking they were spying on them... wich was true but no reason to capture and beat another astronaut
@@Nehskov Yeah, I would’ve loved to have seen how his crew reacted when he went back to Zvezda. After all, they did tell his family that he had died...
This scene is way better with the context of what happened before between them. Basically the American was keeping the soviet hostage after he came knocking at their base with not enough oxygen to make it to his own. I love what the Soviet said to the American to help him convince to work together "We are in a dark ocean, together, we have no choice but to trust each other. Let me help you."
Green: Red is sus Red: Nyet Blue: Red was with me, he even helped me with my tasks White: it was Space Stalin Red: nyet, papa stalin is our good boi. Да • ﾟ 。 . . . 。 。 . . 。 ඞ 。 . • White was not the impostor. 2 impostors remains
I kinda like the idea that instead of fighting each other they'd help one another. The moon for them is a new society not bound by any government down on earth, They carry the flags for nationality and propaganda and not for their government to reign over the celestial body.
I like how at the end cosmonaut is just standing there, there's noone to rush him, he has time he can enjoy the view as he sees american for the last time as he leaves the moon
Actually, keeping it the way it is gives them a secondary place they can go to if something happens to their base. Not a good idea to mess up the only other habitable place on the moon.
FWIW, I don't think he knows quite what to do. The whole situation has been so strange and different for him that I suspect he finds himself lost as to how to think about Jamestown.
@@RashaKahn I see it as keeping vacant cabins stocked with firewood and food up in the Northernmost regions of Canada and Alaska. In case somebody gets lost or is in dire need, they turn there - it is a matter of kindness to those in need.
I wish that instead of competing US and Soviet astronauts were to meet on the moon and congratulate each other and make a cooperation. We aren’t Americans or Russians we are humans
Different Era of human history. It was a battle of systems so there would be no cooperation Both countries tried to make huge fools out of eachother and every moment was just another instance to one up the other. Those who forget history are *doomed* to repeat it
The image interpretation algorithm probably is confusing it with the SFX shots in the Christopher Nolan film. It might get misidentified as Gravity too!
In space, there's no Russian or American. Russia was the first to put a man in space. America was the first to put a man on the moon. Imagine how much we could have thrived together. I believe that nations should come together in terms of Technology for a safe and secure future. We don't have time for boundaries and political differences. We are losing out of time.
Actually it was all only because the competition between USA and USSR. And the fundaments of space explorations lie in nazi Germany.. so I think imma stop you right there and tell you that the only reason Yuri Gagarin was the 1st man in space and Neill Armstrong with Buzz Aldrin were the first men to stand on the Moon, was the space race partly based on knowledge from nazis. You can't really apply your theory here.
@@David-du4xs He really isn't applying "theory" here, what he said is basic knowledge that you're told or heard or what people think about when they're talking about The space race. But again a nazi scientice did play a big role in the moon landing, but Op comment wasn't about who won and why/how they won, he's simply saying that we shouldn't really hold each other back for our difference, but rather work together. Competition plays a role in it too, but imagine if they had work together, imagine if they had share the knowledge they had, now its common to assume one side won because of competition but both side could've won if they just had put their difference aside and worked together. That was what OP meant.
@@howtonotbasic1383 I wasn't talking about anyone winning the space race. I simply stated that the space race was basically bragging between USA and USSR. By working together, this would have never been achieved. Or at least not at the time it was. Competition is what makes people generally work harder and here we have two superpowers trying to be the best in every aspect including space exploration. Even the basics of internet were developed in order to catch up to the Eastern bloc's technologies after Soviet achievments in space and science generally. It is sad but having a competition makes us do better than cooperating with someone.
We only put a man on the Moon to beat the Russians to it. Our competition against them is what was the driving force. Once that goal was reached, we did six more missions then cut funding and did something else. Now we have to rely on private companies to keep pushing us forward. It was our competition to do better than each other that enabled us to accomplish what we did in the Space Race.
It's sad how we, the human kind, needed a competition and a lot of political tensions to achieve this. Because if that didn't happen, nobody would have achieved any of that
Everyone before release of Season 2: It's so cute and glorious, cosmonaut is helping astronaut, we're just humans after all! Everyone after release of Season 2: Red was an Impostor
That was Misha Popov! This must have been one of his earlier missions before he joined Em, and Ram, and Kwesi, and Lu to Mars! Its true: he IS the most experienced person in space. I hope his eyesight comes back...
US astronauts and Soviet cosmonaut was been studying more foreign language, so can you see US astronauts can speaking Russian language, and Soviet cosmonaut can speaking English. The radios on the American and Soviet spacecraft could be interconnected, not through encryption systems, except for internal encryption systems.
TO ANYONE COMMENTING ON THIS CLIP THAT HAS NOT WATCHED THE EPISODE.... You should go watch it then come back before making comments about love and peace and flowers and how we are all just humans together in space and such..... without watching the show you have NO clue just how much context there is before this scene and just what the motives actually are of the two men in this scene. Bellow is a comment I made about another clip from this episode.... LOTS of comments here on this scene. For anyone who for some crazy reason hasn't watched this show..... Go watch it. For All Mankind is on Apple Tv. Season one is 10 episodes and is a really good binge watch. Season two coming soon so get busy before it gets here. lol Now, some context..... SPOILER ALERT The Soviet (cold war adversary) cosmonaut does NOT die for anyone wanting the spoiler. The American has been on the station WAY longer then planned because of technical problems and his two previous companions left without him because one was already mentally cracking up from the long extended stay with little to do mentally. The Bob Newhart show video tape with six episodes had even died from repeated use. He has been staying alone specifically to protect the station from the Soviets instead of going home when the others did. His son has died and now all he has is this job that kept him away from his son in the first place. His son specifically asked why he couldn't just come home even though his replacement was late in arriving. Soviets have been spying on them and even used a message about his brain dead son to cause him further stress and anxiety.... which worked. lol Soviet used their American mine lift to spy in their American mine then escaped (he thought) by using implied threat of force with the mini moon pix axe. Cosmonaut did, in the end, help the American but it was in his self interest to convince the American to let him live and hopefully get access to the American station finally if things went wrong with the crazy rendezvous plan. It was NOT all happy international love and flowers on the Soviets part toward the American. This is a VERY good show and this a VERY good, climatic episode of the show. LOTS and LOTS of context this little clip cant come close to capturing.
It is a damn shame tho, I understand it’s a drama but it could have been really cool to see a show tackle the divide between the west and east in a more nuanced way. Realistically if someone is stuck on the moon you are not just going to let them die “because they believe a different ideology than you” you are going to try and help them get home.
@@aidensindia8914 I can't emphasize enough that you should watch the show if you haven't yet. I don't want to spoil anything for you if you haven't but the Soviets were an equal player in what got things to this point in the story and in helping shape what the astronauts frame of mind was in this scene. If you want the full spoiler read my first comment in full but I recommend watching the season yourself for the full buildup experience. It's hard not to sympathize with and understand an astronaut that went through all he did for all the reasons that he did. As for the show. Shows in general now are just not long enough for anything really anymore. In this case with only 10 episodes a season the focus is on what if Women were more involved in a space race that didn't stop when the key adversary failed. Season 2 picks it up and really makes you think a lot about how different that future we are now living in might have look with just a couple key things going differently in the past. For what it has time to tell, this show does it VERY well. If you haven't watched I recommend at least just a one month subscription to binge watch it all. This show alone is worth a one month subscription price. Personally, I dropped my subscription between seasons one and two. lol
@@chilemeatballs7370 I don’t mind among us memes but seeing people insert them everywhere is disappointing. Imagine someone died and they were wearing a red shirt. “blue sus I saw them kill red” anything space related “red sus” I used to not care but now they’re getting repetitive.
I just realised with the reflection of the Jamestown in Mikhail's helmet, This was the moment he placed the listening device that they found 9 years later.
It would've been cool as heck if this show and Apollo 18 (a movie about another spacecraft going 2 moon and alien spiders are there) were connected like the Cosmonaut looks over and we see the reflection of his visor reveals moving rocks.
It is important to remember just how much work their was done to try and make space "For All Mankind". And it is important to remember how much more was wanted to be done but the USA, USSR, and private business stopped them because all saw it as a threat to their personal interests.
When i saw the listening device in season 2 i got generally just saddened, I thought they actually reached this friendship type status, But no he uses this opportunity to listen on the Americans for like a decade
Anything short of complete cooperation between the two would be met with extreme criticism. This hypothetical between a US astronaut and a USSR cosmonaut is very different as the two people's home countries are extremely hostile towards each other; they are technically enemies. Blue Origin and SpaceX astronauts would cooperate because they are both from the United States and therefore have absolutely no reason to be hostile.
I doubt Musk will ever send a manned rocket to land on another solar system object on his own, and Blue Origin looks even weaker. SpaceX's Starship is a dangerous design that should never get human rating and Musk likes to spend public money (the Falcon 9 is cheap for private customers because the government contracts are overpriced). I even have doubts whether the Starship lunar landing ships SpaceX got a NASA contract for will ever work as intended. We should return to space exploration with proper public funding and real oversight, instead of letting it be the plaything of whimsical billionaires drunk on the feedback of yes-men employees and cult-like social media followers while riding roughshod over labour and the environment.
As a comrade my self I want to say we didn’t screw with the James town base, we only had a massive super Soviet party inside of it. Why? Cause it’s not ours so we didn’t have to clean up once the party was over.
Some times, even for a second, I think, hey, maybe we arent so stupid, maybe we can just get along. We can all join together as humanity And then I see this comment section and I realize that's a pipe dream Edit: This comment was made before the massive influx of people these past few weeks, the video used to only have a couple thousand views and the comment section used to be like filled with like 30 people, made up of crackpot conspiracy theorists and arm chair rocket scientists
Anyone else thinking about how the regolith kicked up would've absolutely torn the cosmonaut to shreds. Like you saw it flying towards him but then it just stopped lmao. The engine firing would've shot those small particles faster than a bullet at him.
Like a sand blaster....except that regolith is so fine that can't see it blasting any holes in the suit though, because the damage would be uniform across the entire surface of the suit. So the damage would likely be comprehensive, but only superficial, like using some 1000 grit sandpaper over the entire front of the suit.(For how long, I'm not sure) ...but if there isn't enough energy in those particles to completely scrub away or "dissolve" the entire front of the suit (which seems very unlikely), then again, I personally doubt it wouldn't put any holes in it either due to the uniformity of the damage).. You may not be able to see through your helmet's glass anymore though .....well, unless that regolith is 5000grit or more. Then it would probably make it even clearer lol.
I thought about that too. Then I noticed he doesn’t see the flame from the engines as they ignite and blast the dust. The dust shoots from under the horizon of the hill, each bit of grit in a straight line, above him. And it thins out a lot with distance. I’d say it was well done.
No it wouldn't have. Think of the engine like a grenade. After a certain distance, there would only be a minute chance of being hit by shrapnel, and even if you were it would only be one or two pieces. Now, replace that shrapnel with sand and after a certain distance you would only be hit by a very small amount of sand.
@@richardmillhousenixon There's no air resistance. The plume from the engines propel rocks and gravel-sized particles up to 10 to 100 meters per second. The finer sand like particles shooting out upwards of 1000 meters per second. even though a very "small amount of sand" would hit his body, it'd be traveling at speeds close to the speed of many bullets.
@@ChadDidNothingWrong My idea is based on the absolute speed that he'd be hit with from those particles. It makes sense that they may get reflected or absorbed but traveling at 100-1000 meters per second, I'd assume it wouldn't turn out too well for him.
does anybody know what music/ song is used at the end of this clip, just listened to the entire soundtrack album on spotify and this is NOT on the album
The last thing you want to do is to rewrite history to suit narratives that you think are more convenient. Those who do not learn from history are doomed to repeat it.
This is the fictional LSAM, used to ferry astronauts from the CSM, to Jamestown. It’s designed to be a reusable upgrade from the previous LEM iteration.
Even if I didn't know this was an alternative-history work of fiction, I would have figured it out by the use of a slightly modified NASA Worm logo and the fact that the LSAM looks only superficially like the LEM. Or if I read the other comments that already spelled it out.
There is the saying: separate and win, but this is a proof that separating is not the right choice, together we are stronger that the one that separates two sides together we are the strongest version of mankind, together we will reach any goal, together we win
This is a fictional account of the space race portrayed as if the Russians reached the moon first. The technology is fictional as well. That was not the LEM that lift off the moon. It is a fictional LSAM (Lunar Surface Access Module) that is why the entire thing lifted off and did not detach from the landing legs. Designed to be reusable on the surface of the moon.
Does the fact that there's a Cosmonaut walking around on the Moon give anyone a clue that this is fiction, not history or current reality? Learn about the histories of the actual space programs of the US, USSR, Russia and other countries so you will better understand what differences exist in this fictional storyline.
@Mike DeMarco It sounds like we're close in age. I don't recall the Gemini missions, but I built plastic model kits of the Mercury, Gemini and Apollo spacecraft, along with fictional craft as well. I kind of recall the Apollo 1 fire, but not a lot of details from when it happened. Definitely recall Apollo 7 onwards, and met Jim Lovell at a book signing for "Lost Moon", later renamed "Apollo 13" after the movie came out. My autographed copy of it is one of my proudest possessions. I do get disheartened by the lack of enthusiasm for spaceflights, Flat Earth / Moon Landing Hoax believers, etc. I feel Buzz Aldrin was justified in punching that one Flat Earther (Bart Sibrel?) who called him a liar and a thief after Buzz refused to swear on a Bible that he'd walked on the Moon. Wrong thing to ask someone who took communion right after landing there.
There's just too much denial of science and acceptance of false facts these days.
@@jeddyhi I agree, "This is an alternate timeline you idiot." doesn't make it very clear who he is addressing. If he meant me, then I thought I made it clear in my comment, just as you did in yours, that this is not reality and follows a different path through history.
@Spacefarer Who are you talking to?
Anonymous - Creations Yes, we were aware of that.
The idea of Soviets and Americans helping each other on the moon kind of reminds me of the christmas truce for some reason
Yes. Hell my favorite ever song is "belleu wood" (I think that's spell) you should listen
“enemies” realizing both are human and come to peace
Agnus Dei...
Take the politicians out of things, and there's very little actual animosity there.
We are officially doing on the Space Station what the people in this show are doing unofficially.
“I was with red the entire time he can’t be the imposter”
idk red is sus
@@rosegear4583 Red is not imposter he did his task he even help blue get his task done
@@giannmikhael5939 pink was not the imposter
1 imposter remain
American was ejected.
I saw green doing weapons he is safe
The Cosmonaut after watching the American blast off gets inside his own lunar module and sits backhand watches "Interstellar" while drinking smirnoff.
Smirnoff is made in America and is an American company
@@starkrasher4978 Smirnoff was originally Russian in the 1860's, but it is now owned by Diageo, which is based in the UK.
I love your name
Vodka is better
Russian vodka
Cosmonaut: Goodluck Baldwin....
*Looks at the jamestown*
Cosmonaut: ...Goodluck......
Please explain to us. WHAT DOES THAT MEAN IM SCARED
@@tsrmmercy836 Nothing He just looked at it
@@shataph19 I think it implies he went into Jamestown to investigate
goodluck i guess
@@shataph19 no its not nothing, he placed a device inside of it. you can find it later in the series.
The message is strong in this one:only if we are willing to set aside our differences and work together, are we able to reach the stars, or protect home, whichever direction you choose.
Unless the differences are of belief, and they are too fundamental to reconcile. I mean, if the Third Reich were still around, and was still as genocidal as it was in the 1940s, I think most of us would say it's not morally tenable to set aside those difference to cooperate with it in the exploration and settlement of space (or anything else).
@@richardmalcolm1457 If a frog had a glass ass...
@@richardmalcolm1457 The soviets and America, are still partners in space. When the wall fell, so did the cold war. And relations made a change for the better. :-)
@@mrzorg "Russians," not "Soviets." :) Partners now, albeit rather tense partners. But my only point was that the observation about "setting aside our differences" in cby's comment is pablum if it is not qualified: because we can all come up with scenarios where we would *not* work with another human polity if pressed to it, if they embodied or advocated something we truly considered evil. Putin's Russia may not be in this category, but I tend to think Nazi Germany would be, if it were still around.
@@richardmalcolm1457 Even the Soviets/Now Russians, worked together somewhat to advance space tech. Consider the skylab missions.
Just imagine how far humanity would be if humanity didn’t fight about stupid crap all the time.
Oh americans and russians where about to do that.. but JFK got killed.. and the USSR fell..
Maybe another time.
Isaac Schrader It’s funny you say that, because the show is all about humanity fighting over stupid things, resulting in competition, furthering space exploration. So they are getting more done because they are fighting over stupid things.
Mars would be populated by now...
@@justking0600 Yep, which is why capitalism worked so well. It is the epitome of fighting over shit and beating your competitor. If we all sat back and sang songs, nothing would get done.
@@blockobutter Yeah, yet again, SpaceX is doing great and they have no competitors. Not saying you are wrong, capitalism is great, but SpaceX is a huge exception. Musk will be ruling Mars in the next 4 years.
There's a reason to why the space station is named "the International Space Station" and not "the American Space Station"
Also is a better acronym than ASS
@@whaleforanothertime1847 Lol
@@whaleforanothertime1847 "The ASS orbits earth incredibly fast."
@@Nicolas-km8wr “You know, the ASS is great for scientific experiments!”
"The ASS is also great if you want to help the science team make science stuff!"
That cosmonaut goes forward in time and joins the mars crew!
Is that Misha?
@@trumfit yep!!
@@trumfit Yep! Its Misha!
Im dumb what are you reffering to?
@@vojtechjancura682 the actor plays a cosmonaut on a brand new netflix tv series 'away', where a multinational crew goes on a 3 year mission to mars
Soviet cosmonaut: Helps American astronaut
Americans in S2: So anyways, I started blasting
I'm going to have to stop you there. As much as I like cosmonauts, remember that at the beginning of season 2 it was discovered that when Ed left, he implanted a spying device, so, not too innocent
@@marcoantoniopadillaorozco3591 I haven't watched the series. I made a joke without context.
@@johnlime1469 Oh shit sorry for the spoiler
@@marcoantoniopadillaorozco3591 It's fine, my watchlist query is just too long at this point. I'm probably not going to be able to get to this one.
@@johnlime1469 Sad
"In Space, we are not one of race...not one of color...not of language....we are one of the same...we are...human..."
That's the point, that's the bad thing.
@@IshijimaKairo What?
@@erictheepic5019 the bad this is that they're all human in space.
@@IshijimaKairo Are you trying to say that being a human in space is a bad idea (potentially facetiously), or are you saying that it's a bad idea that everyone in space is equal?
@@erictheepic5019 No I am saying that Humans are bad, I'm a misanthropist
This is realistically what would happen. Up on the moon, you aren't rivals from different nations. You're both scientists/explorers
the problem is what happens before this scene....
And survivors. If things go wrong (your spaceship broke, for example), there's no one else to ask for help but the other guy. The last thing you want to do is to make an enemy out of the only human person in a 384,000 kilometres radius.
@@aconite72 tell that to the writers who decided to portray astronauts as psychos .. renember the american dude decided to arrest and beat the russian cosmonaut thinking they were spying on them... wich was true but no reason to capture and beat another astronaut
@@sparrowlt It's called being human
@@sparrowlt How did you know about the spying ? They didn't know that in season 1
Is it weird that even though he had very little screen time, compared to the other characters, Mikhail is one of my favourites of the entire series?
Not weird at all. Hes pretty epic for the time we get to see him on Screen.
@@Nehskov Yeah, I would’ve loved to have seen how his crew reacted when he went back to Zvezda. After all, they did tell his family that he had died...
This scene is way better with the context of what happened before between them. Basically the American was keeping the soviet hostage after he came knocking at their base with not enough oxygen to make it to his own. I love what the Soviet said to the American to help him convince to work together "We are in a dark ocean, together, we have no choice but to trust each other. Let me help you."
only to then spy on him.
This Russian lives forever. Now he is on Mars thanks to Netflix. (Away)
hell yea
Wait, what? Is that REALLY the same guy in the “Away” sci-fi series on Netflix?!! The mind boggles! 😳
We're forgetting the real mars tv show: Mars (2016)
@@datathunderstorm Yes haha! I also was confused.
*Red and white doing tasks together*
Purple: EMERGENCY MEETING 🚨
Moments later
*Yellow was an imposter**
*victory*
*Purple has an emergency meeting.*
*Yellow still on Impostor and win for about ten times.*
*Green.. who's Green?*
Sora Pantsu
Red said green was acted sus so yellow killed him
Red and White.... looks like the flag of my Country
@@lifesoframadhangaming7364 oh hello pola- wait no guessing? Og ok
When it boils down to it, Humans should not be rivals, but brothers and sisters for a common goal:
Exploring Our Universe
Thank you general Pinochet, very cool!
"We are on the Dark Ocean together. We have to trust each other."
Green: Red is sus
Red: Nyet
Blue: Red was with me, he even helped me with my tasks
White: it was Space Stalin
Red: nyet, papa stalin is our good boi. Да
• ﾟ 。
. . . 。 。 .
. 。 ඞ 。 . •
White was not the impostor.
2 impostors remains
good copy pasta
Blue and Red were the impostors all along!
@@Gremlinke96 nyet!
Нет комарада
I kinda like the idea that instead of fighting each other they'd help one another. The moon for them is a new society not bound by any government down on earth, They carry the flags for nationality and propaganda and not for their government to reign over the celestial body.
they look adorable in those suits
:3
- You won't be exploring my base, are you?
- Hell no, comrade!
...
2:38
- I will only explore OUR base...
Watching Season One: He's one of the good ones.
After Season 2: That Red Bastard.
Was he Ivan?
I like how at the end cosmonaut is just standing there, there's noone to rush him, he has time he can enjoy the view as he sees american for the last time as he leaves the moon
Looks like the cosmosnaut is about to do something bad to the American base
Or thinking about asking for political asylum
Serge Abtan or taking all their rations
Actually, keeping it the way it is gives them a secondary place they can go to if something happens to their base. Not a good idea to mess up the only other habitable place on the moon.
FWIW, I don't think he knows quite what to do. The whole situation has been so strange and different for him that I suspect he finds himself lost as to how to think about Jamestown.
@@RashaKahn I see it as keeping vacant cabins stocked with firewood and food up in the Northernmost regions of Canada and Alaska. In case somebody gets lost or is in dire need, they turn there - it is a matter of kindness to those in need.
I wish that instead of competing US and Soviet astronauts were to meet on the moon and congratulate each other and make a cooperation. We aren’t Americans or Russians we are humans
Different Era of human history. It was a battle of systems so there would be no cooperation
Both countries tried to make huge fools out of eachother and every moment was just another instance to one up the other.
Those who forget history are *doomed* to repeat it
Cool this was one of the best parts of the series
WHY DOES UA-cam SEE THIS AS INTERSTELLAR?
The image interpretation algorithm probably is confusing it with the SFX shots in the Christopher Nolan film. It might get misidentified as Gravity too!
What movie is it as it looks very interesting
@@infamoustimes2927 for all mankind
@@infamoustimes2927 A TV series - "For All Mankind". I believe it's available on Apple's subscription-only streaming network.
Technically speaking, your going through space
Man. This made me tear up a little.
I just wish the US and China and Russia could all get together and work together for the common good.
In the storyline the Cosmonaut
we back to Jamestown Base and planted a listening device.
In space, there's no Russian or American. Russia was the first to put a man in space. America was the first to put a man on the moon. Imagine how much we could have thrived together. I believe that nations should come together in terms of Technology for a safe and secure future. We don't have time for boundaries and political differences. We are losing out of time.
Actually it was all only because the competition between USA and USSR. And the fundaments of space explorations lie in nazi Germany.. so I think imma stop you right there and tell you that the only reason Yuri Gagarin was the 1st man in space and Neill Armstrong with Buzz Aldrin were the first men to stand on the Moon, was the space race partly based on knowledge from nazis.
You can't really apply your theory here.
@@David-du4xs He really isn't applying "theory" here, what he said is basic knowledge that you're told or heard or what people think about when they're talking about The space race.
But again a nazi scientice did play a big role in the moon landing, but Op comment wasn't about who won and why/how they won, he's simply saying that we shouldn't really hold each other back for our difference, but rather work together.
Competition plays a role in it too, but imagine if they had work together, imagine if they had share the knowledge they had, now its common to assume one side won because of competition but both side could've won if they just had put their difference aside and worked together. That was what OP meant.
@@howtonotbasic1383 I wasn't talking about anyone winning the space race. I simply stated that the space race was basically bragging between USA and USSR.
By working together, this would have never been achieved. Or at least not at the time it was. Competition is what makes people generally work harder and here we have two superpowers trying to be the best in every aspect including space exploration.
Even the basics of internet were developed in order to catch up to the Eastern bloc's technologies after Soviet achievments in space and science generally.
It is sad but having a competition makes us do better than cooperating with someone.
We only put a man on the Moon to beat the Russians to it. Our competition against them is what was the driving force. Once that goal was reached, we did six more missions then cut funding and did something else. Now we have to rely on private companies to keep pushing us forward. It was our competition to do better than each other that enabled us to accomplish what we did in the Space Race.
It's sad how we, the human kind, needed a competition and a lot of political tensions to achieve this. Because if that didn't happen, nobody would have achieved any of that
When Mikhail turned send you saw Jamestown reflected in his visor…
I think he truly did want Ed to get home safe, but he still had his orders.
The cosmonaut was standing far too close to the takeoff. His visor would have been sandblasted by the dust.
I'm guessing you have a degree in low-gravity projectile propulsion?
@@jjclark1035 Reasonable inferences do not require a college education.
he helps him then bugs the Jamestown base lol
Everyone before release of Season 2: It's so cute and glorious, cosmonaut is helping astronaut, we're just humans after all!
Everyone after release of Season 2: Red was an Impostor
this show is perfect at showing even during the hardest moments in human history, humanity wins.
That was Misha Popov! This must have been one of his earlier missions before he joined Em, and Ram, and Kwesi, and Lu to Mars! Its true: he IS the most experienced person in space. I hope his eyesight comes back...
I finished Away a few days ago and instantly recognized him. He (Mark Ivanir) is a good actor
Sometimes, Foes can work together, and in this case, to explore our universe and what it lies within it
US astronauts and Soviet cosmonaut was been studying more foreign language, so can you see US astronauts can speaking Russian language, and Soviet cosmonaut can speaking English. The radios on the American and Soviet spacecraft could be interconnected, not through encryption systems, except for internal encryption systems.
2:31 Good bye..old friend
Idk why but them riding along makes me laugh, like an awkward car ride 🤣
i cant wait for season two to come out, this show is a masterpiece
with context behind this and the post events on season 2... the cosmonaut has finally completed his mission with the astronaut paving the way for it.
Truly, for *all* mankind
US:"Thank you..."
USSR:"You killed my friend, asshole."
TO ANYONE COMMENTING ON THIS CLIP THAT HAS NOT WATCHED THE EPISODE.... You should go watch it then come back before making comments about love and peace and flowers and how we are all just humans together in space and such..... without watching the show you have NO clue just how much context there is before this scene and just what the motives actually are of the two men in this scene. Bellow is a comment I made about another clip from this episode....
LOTS of comments here on this scene. For anyone who for some crazy reason hasn't watched this show..... Go watch it. For All Mankind is on Apple Tv. Season one is 10 episodes and is a really good binge watch. Season two coming soon so get busy before it gets here. lol Now, some context..... SPOILER ALERT
The Soviet (cold war adversary) cosmonaut does NOT die for anyone wanting the spoiler.
The American has been on the station WAY longer then planned because of technical problems and his two previous companions left without him because one was already mentally cracking up from the long extended stay with little to do mentally. The Bob Newhart show video tape with six episodes had even died from repeated use. He has been staying alone specifically to protect the station from the Soviets instead of going home when the others did.
His son has died and now all he has is this job that kept him away from his son in the first place. His son specifically asked why he couldn't just come home even though his replacement was late in arriving.
Soviets have been spying on them and even used a message about his brain dead son to cause him further stress and anxiety.... which worked. lol
Soviet used their American mine lift to spy in their American mine then escaped (he thought) by using implied threat of force with the mini moon pix axe.
Cosmonaut did, in the end, help the American but it was in his self interest to convince the American to let him live and hopefully get access to the American station finally if things went wrong with the crazy rendezvous plan. It was NOT all happy international love and flowers on the Soviets part toward the American.
This is a VERY good show and this a VERY good, climatic episode of the show. LOTS and LOTS of context this little clip cant come close to capturing.
It is a damn shame tho, I understand it’s a drama but it could have been really cool to see a show tackle the divide between the west and east in a more nuanced way. Realistically if someone is stuck on the moon you are not just going to let them die “because they believe a different ideology than you” you are going to try and help them get home.
@@aidensindia8914 I can't emphasize enough that you should watch the show if you haven't yet. I don't want to spoil anything for you if you haven't but the Soviets were an equal player in what got things to this point in the story and in helping shape what the astronauts frame of mind was in this scene. If you want the full spoiler read my first comment in full but I recommend watching the season yourself for the full buildup experience. It's hard not to sympathize with and understand an astronaut that went through all he did for all the reasons that he did.
As for the show. Shows in general now are just not long enough for anything really anymore. In this case with only 10 episodes a season the focus is on what if Women were more involved in a space race that didn't stop when the key adversary failed. Season 2 picks it up and really makes you think a lot about how different that future we are now living in might have look with just a couple key things going differently in the past. For what it has time to tell, this show does it VERY well.
If you haven't watched I recommend at least just a one month subscription to binge watch it all. This show alone is worth a one month subscription price. Personally, I dropped my subscription between seasons one and two. lol
OMG! You tell a fictional story as though it were real, as if all these motivations were real and typical.
Now they should make a movie where Apollo 11 lands to find a Swastika already planted on the moon.
Iron sky is kinda the movie you're talking about
Freakin' Hindus, taking over the moon!!
This would have been a better future. Mankind united.
Cant wait for season 2
Any idea of when it might be out?
@@cafarellano9340 hopefully right around the same time as last year, november.
@@Spartan2035 Some others say that it should be out on January.. I hope it comes in November
@@cafarellano9340 Thankfully, it's releasing already! (albeit weekly)
@@matheuss886 For real? I didn’t know, that’s great! Thanks :)
Damn this is heartwarming
Glad to see both helping one another. Let's make this world a better place.
Well the Cosmonaut then later bugs Jamestown so, not as benevolent as once thought
@@odinharou7112 well I didn't watch the series so I didn't know
Hes like 'Oh so you do talk?'
Helped himself to all the technology in Jamestown, is what.
Можем же дружить 🇧🇾🇺🇸🇷🇺 даже в космосе))
…no
The fact that now almost every comment is from Among us
It bothers me a lot to be honest. But that's in my opinion.
@@chilemeatballs7370 I don’t mind among us memes but seeing people insert them everywhere is disappointing. Imagine someone died and they were wearing a red shirt.
“blue sus I saw them kill red”
anything space related
“red sus” I used to not care but now they’re getting repetitive.
@@HogBurger Yeah I also think the same thing. It's such an over used joke and it isnt funny.
@@chilemeatballs7370 Yes, I cannot watch anything remotely space related involving astronauts without seeing those stupid memes
@@HogBurger Then fuck off
How two enemies in a relationship so bad that a war could’ve happened became friends:
He's gonna have a fun time flying that module while blind.
I just realised with the reflection of the Jamestown in Mikhail's helmet, This was the moment he placed the listening device that they found 9 years later.
It would've been cool as heck if this show and Apollo 18 (a movie about another spacecraft going 2 moon and alien spiders are there) were connected like the Cosmonaut looks over and we see the reflection of his visor reveals moving rocks.
Вот это настоящая дружба советским союзом и США 👍👍👍👍
Up there all the hate and racism is gone, we are not divided by the countries we're from, we are united as one race
It is important to remember just how much work their was done to try and make space "For All Mankind". And it is important to remember how much more was wanted to be done but the USA, USSR, and private business stopped them because all saw it as a threat to their personal interests.
This is what I want to see, FOR ALL MANKIND.
This has to be the best scene in this show
This is more of what we need in this world
You should upload Apollo 11’s lunar liftoff
When i saw the listening device in season 2 i got generally just saddened, I thought they actually reached this friendship type status, But no he uses this opportunity to listen on the Americans for like a decade
I love your channel keep up the great stuff
Camera people are the ones we should be afraid of they are literally immune the the vacuum of space
"Interstella" What The fu-
I can’t wait for season 2
That cosmonaut suit is adorable
Comrade helps comrade.
I still strongly suspect Mikhail was just a figment of his imagination. An imaginary companion to stave off loneliness on a desolate world.
Lol it’s Poppov from Netflix “Away”
This puts a smile in my face
It would be amazing if this show was how life actually played out
Can you imagine how historic this interaction would be?
This doesn't really happen in Kerbal Space Program, maybe because I send them to the Mun at the speed of Mach Jesus
SEASON 2 SPOILERS!!!
And to think “Ivan” put a hidden microphone in the base, how sad.
I knew something was up when you could see Jamestown's reflection in his visor
It’s not personal. Ivan helping Ed was personal but him planting the bug was a political reason.
@@hazardous458 Agreed, I think Ivan was sincere when helping Baldwin, but he still had a mission no matter what he felt about the Astronaut.
The Soviet Orlan EVA suit looks very good 👍
Wow I enjoyed the mini clips it's hard to get such movies
What is the name of the series & what platform is it upon?
What is the name pls
For All Mankind.
Apple T.V. it seems
So is that when the Russians planted the bug?
This is a very creative series. They think deep into the consequences of what would happen politically if the Russians landed first. A must watch!
What people forget is that we are all human in the end and always will be.
Hopefully this is how SpaceX and Blue Origin will treat each other when they meet at the Moon.
Anything short of complete cooperation between the two would be met with extreme criticism. This hypothetical between a US astronaut and a USSR cosmonaut is very different as the two people's home countries are extremely hostile towards each other; they are technically enemies. Blue Origin and SpaceX astronauts would cooperate because they are both from the United States and therefore have absolutely no reason to be hostile.
I doubt Musk will ever send a manned rocket to land on another solar system object on his own, and Blue Origin looks even weaker. SpaceX's Starship is a dangerous design that should never get human rating and Musk likes to spend public money (the Falcon 9 is cheap for private customers because the government contracts are overpriced). I even have doubts whether the Starship lunar landing ships SpaceX got a NASA contract for will ever work as intended.
We should return to space exploration with proper public funding and real oversight, instead of letting it be the plaything of whimsical billionaires drunk on the feedback of yes-men employees and cult-like social media followers while riding roughshod over labour and the environment.
This triggered me when I actually just witnessed the entire LEM module lift off from the surface and if you know anything about Apollo you’d know why.
Triggered me aswell
Could you explain why?
@@everybodysclown3413 believe the legs of the landing module stayed on the surface.
That doesn't look like ordinary Apollo LEM. For starter, it has at least 2 engines.
Good thing i'm not the only one
Instances of peace and cooperation...no matter how corny....are more than welcome in today's divided society.
Hell yeah, space is cool, America is cool, Russia is cool, friendship is cool, this show is cool
As a comrade my self I want to say we didn’t screw with the James town base, we only had a massive super Soviet party inside of it. Why? Cause it’s not ours so we didn’t have to clean up once the party was over.
I wish the space race continued, if only so we could have space travel by now.
We have space travel.
And now we found out he planted a mic in Jamestown. Makes this interaction a little less nice 😂
National bonds!! I love this.
Some times, even for a second, I think, hey, maybe we arent so stupid, maybe we can just get along. We can all join together as humanity
And then I see this comment section and I realize that's a pipe dream
Edit: This comment was made before the massive influx of people these past few weeks, the video used to only have a couple thousand views and the comment section used to be like filled with like 30 people, made up of crackpot conspiracy theorists and arm chair rocket scientists
Fuck conspiracy theories
Anyone else thinking about how the regolith kicked up would've absolutely torn the cosmonaut to shreds. Like you saw it flying towards him but then it just stopped lmao. The engine firing would've shot those small particles faster than a bullet at him.
Like a sand blaster....except that regolith is so fine that can't see it blasting any holes in the suit though, because the damage would be uniform across the entire surface of the suit.
So the damage would likely be comprehensive, but only superficial, like using some 1000 grit sandpaper over the entire front of the suit.(For how long, I'm not sure)
...but if there isn't enough energy in those particles to completely scrub away or "dissolve" the entire front of the suit (which seems very unlikely), then again, I personally doubt it wouldn't put any holes in it either due to the uniformity of the damage)..
You may not be able to see through your helmet's glass anymore though .....well, unless that regolith is 5000grit or more. Then it would probably make it even clearer lol.
I thought about that too. Then I noticed he doesn’t see the flame from the engines as they ignite and blast the dust. The dust shoots from under the horizon of the hill, each bit of grit in a straight line, above him. And it thins out a lot with distance. I’d say it was well done.
No it wouldn't have. Think of the engine like a grenade. After a certain distance, there would only be a minute chance of being hit by shrapnel, and even if you were it would only be one or two pieces. Now, replace that shrapnel with sand and after a certain distance you would only be hit by a very small amount of sand.
@@richardmillhousenixon There's no air resistance. The plume from the engines propel rocks and gravel-sized particles up to 10 to 100 meters per second. The finer sand like particles shooting out upwards of 1000 meters per second. even though a
very "small amount of sand" would hit his body, it'd be traveling at speeds close to the speed of many bullets.
@@ChadDidNothingWrong My idea is based on the absolute speed that he'd be hit with from those particles. It makes sense that they may get reflected or absorbed but traveling at 100-1000 meters per second, I'd assume it wouldn't turn out too well for him.
Me and the boys rolling up to Mac Donald’s to get the Travis Scott meal
does anybody know what music/ song is used at the end of this clip, just listened to the entire soundtrack album on spotify and this is NOT on the album
If you don't like history, change it.
That's always been done
The last thing you want to do is to rewrite history to suit narratives that you think are more convenient. Those who do not learn from history are doomed to repeat it.
That's not how the LEM works. The landing legs stayed on the moon.
That's not the LM you're familliar with though.
This is the fictional LSAM, used to ferry astronauts from the CSM, to Jamestown. It’s designed to be a reusable upgrade from the previous LEM iteration.
Its not the LEM. Its a advanced version. you can see that if you watch the show. It has 4 engines on it.
Even if I didn't know this was an alternative-history work of fiction, I would have figured it out by the use of a slightly modified NASA Worm logo and the fact that the LSAM looks only superficially like the LEM. Or if I read the other comments that already spelled it out.
U.S and USSR best team ever since WW2
There is the saying: separate and win, but this is a proof that separating is not the right choice, together we are stronger that the one that separates two sides together we are the strongest version of mankind, together we will reach any goal, together we win