“Voting For Labour Is Voting For Erasure Of Word ‘Woman'!” JK Rowling BLASTS Women’s Minister
Вставка
- Опубліковано 26 сер 2024
- Kevin O’Sullivan and NHS GP Dr Renée Hoenderkamp discuss JK Rowling hitting out at past comments made by Anneliese Dodds on gender as the Labour MP was announced as women and equalities minister.
The Harry Potter author has previously accused Labour of having “abandoned” her and others campaigning for women’s rights.
Shortly after Monday’s announcement, Ms Rowling tweeted part of a transcript from an interview Ms Dodds had done on BBC Radio 4’s Woman’s Hour in 2022.
According to the posted transcript, when asked for Labour’s definition of a woman, Ms Dodds said there are “different definitions legally around what a woman actually is” and, when pressed again, said: “I think it does depend what the context is.”
Click here for more from Talk talk.tv
If you need any help visit: talk.tv/helplines
#gender #jkrowling #labour
Well done to the Labour voters that have done this to themselves (women)
are you under the impression that no men voted for Labour?
@@AeronwenTrewent are you under the impression you are making sense
Not every woman voted Labour so don’t put us all under the same umbrella and from your post we are all to presume that no men voted Labour oh well what a miracle they got in then!
Scrap labour now....
Too late
Placing Men’s feelings before Women’s safety! Outrageous!
Round of applause to the 10 million airheads who votes Labour in. They were so hell bent on bashing the Tories they seemed to have forgotten how bad Labour will be.
The ones who voted for labour are the die-hard brain-dead labour supporters. They got fewer votes than they did when they lost the last two times, so there hasn't been a shift over to them in any way - that was also clear at the last few by-elections which they won with fewer votes.
FFS ! Our politicians are pathetic !
Labour = race DEI , gender , climate aganda 2030 . People were warned about labour .
Sick of telling everyone. But they just blindly voted Marxists in to government.
why is that a problem?...the last 14 years of hell might be a bigger issue to address.
@@Lloyd.Browne The Conservatives turned Left for the last 14 years. So I’am glad you recognise why everything was going to HELL. It’s going to drop a lot quicker to HELL now Sir Smear I Don’t Know What A Woman Is Starmer is in😂😂😂
@@magfan77 change the record...which is more urgent, food banks, starving children, or the small minority of individuals with gender dysphoria? Get your moral compass to point in the right direction.
Absolutely disgusting. It’s two fingers up to women by Labour!
1 finger from America!
If I've understood this correctly, Labour's definition on what a woman is depends on the context.
I'm not sure the UK could withstand 5 years of this nonsense.
Hopefully they won't last 5 years
You have to ask why ,as a woman you would have voted Labour when there policies are anti women.Oh and Lisa Namdy as Culture secretary!!¡!? The very definition of an oxymoron
unbelievable, if a medical professional doesnt know what a woman is or asking a male are you pregnant, surely their medical certification should be cancelled
Good comment, totally agree. I never was just a procreating uterus. More than any man induced trans is.
I couldn't bring myself to vote for them mainly for this reason.
It was the Islamist idea that made me change my vote.
Seriously,it was only THIS?
@@davidbarlow350 It was the main reason, not the only reason.
Males do not have the same chromosomes as females.
@user-kb2fh7ox5e yes...intersex - did you fail at school?
@@Lloyd.BrowneNo, apparently you did. 1 in 2,000 human births gender non-specific & used to be randomly surgically assigned. Now that that barbarism is over & individuals choose, we have trans. 1 reason, people have lived as opposite sex always, often only outed posthumously. Along with intersex we have hermaphroditism (also in other species of living things), heterosexual cross-dressers who are often family men, drag queens & more than 31derful other variations🌈. Just as race is more complex & varied than black & white, so is human sexuality.
@@unowen-nh9ov the topic of intersex individuals and their experiences touches on both physical and mental elements, with various factors influencing their identity and well-being. You have outlined the physical representations, do you not think there will be impacts on the mental and psychological aspects related to intersex individuals?
So, yes, I did not fail at school. You have more to learn.
@@Lloyd.Browne no such thing and certainly not an amount to make it a big issue
@user-kb2fh7ox5e there is only identity policitics. as a species, most of us are emotional stunted. Only the fullnes of time will address these behavioural issues.
Labour should be called The Unicorn Party !
The Barbie land Party!
Dodds, Mrs Balls, Lammy, Ed Militant, Diane Abbott MotH and two pads Raynor.
Labour's Core of Intellectual integrity? Brit voters for this shower of .... have condemned 70 per cent of the population to the new 'Dark Ages'.
Labour Equals Erasure.
Vote of no confidence for Labour Party
Said this on numerous videos - who the feck voted Labour and is happy with this crap. It's some kind of sick joke.
It's interesting that what I learned in school about male vs. female decades ago is now considered a form of witchcraft.
I'm 48. I don't remember much about what was taught in PHSE. But thinking about it, it was rather quaint and missed out a hell of a lot. Much like History classes. It didn't really include the finer realities. Very simplistic. Maybe that was enough. I've learnt a great deal since. I have my own opinions about the bits that were missed. Much different than your own. I suspect. If I went through my life without further learning that would be a travesty.
I learnt the difference in biology not phse.
@@clovermark39Recently: " Under the plans, secondary-school pupils will learn about protected characteristics, such as sexual orientation and gender reassignment.
But the updated guidance makes clear schools "should not teach about the concept of gender identity", the government says."
A lot is about the politics of the time. PHSE is now broader and more intimate.
When you have governments talking about 'contested views' etc It becomes very muddy indeed.
Gender identity was never mentioned when I was at school. Probably not when you was at school. But it is within the curriculum now.
You may say that it shouldn't be within the curriculum.
I'm sure the same was thought decades ago.
Scrap the gender equality act
How can anyone can be that thick
priDE MONth
the truth is right in front of your eyes.
Omg the world has gone mad
What do you mean gone always has been just worse with the social media chit
The constant fairytale politics whilst Rome burns. We’re doomed..
These labour MPs are totally un hinged ,they are women ,i think they are i could be wrong,a massive own goal by them ,those who voted labour will regret what they voted for .
Srap the act now
Protected space is not just to protect women's safety, it's surely to protect their privacy and dignity.
Would an uhinged man that is a danger to women go through the whole charade of being trans ? You're damn right he would.
What charade? All they have to do is, say I am a woman
They have done.
It’s not even that, how easy would it be for young people with low self esteem and other issues think they must be born in the wrong body. It’s very loose logic
I’ve had 5 children im wasn’t a pregnant person ffs
Labour isn't inpower Davos is
Transwomen are not women!
did women kill other women and children? is there a history before now that you know of?
Pretend women would be mor accurate
Or delusional men
@@amandahudson2038 you are simple minded to understand the complexities of the situation.
And this is what you have voted into government.
Orwellian lunacy!
Absolute muppet
This is all ridiculous, it's not even funny.
BRAVO, especially to you, Dr.Renee for telling the truth and fighting for women & children!-Jesus' blessings to & prayers for you and all truth tellers!
Absolutely Kevin
Keep fighting for women, Kevin and Renee!!
God that labour women looks like Beaker from the muppets
I was thinking "Sideshow Bob" from the Simpson's
And you are an oil painting in comparison? 😂 Stop being a bully 😇
I think more like a Ken Dodd tribute act.
Silly cow
All men born in the fifties should change their name to Agnes or Betty so if the WASPI women win they can claim back several years pension.
PAUL🇬🇧 I was a member of the Labour Party and left, their not Christian or working class anymore. If people disagree with this read about James Kier Hardie, Ramsay Mcdonald, Clemente Atlee, great men, especially Atlee wounded In Galibalie, If I have spelt It propperly. The Cooperative part of the Labour Party have got to stand up to this madness.Also great Labour men like Andy Burnham, and Steve Rotherham. Would they want their Children being taught Immoral subjects In school. I would advise these two great men read the book the Pink Swaztika on the real history of the Nazi Party, because I'm seeing similar behavioural patterns.
Adult, female, there is no context. Labour are looking stupid on loads of subjects.
Yes and it didn't take long!
Tranada erased adult human females in 2017. Please don't be like Tranada.
The GRA was brought under the claim that it would allow gay marriage, which is now legal anyway so there is no reason for it to remain.
Tebbit was extremely foresighted and asked about the consequences we see now and over and ove rthe answers were that women's single sex spaces were safe. We see now that it is not true and men who seek to harm women (and children) are flocking to call themselves 'trans'. we need to return to no lies on official documents.
Also join Party of Women
Calling all females - keep standing up for our female rights …
Protect our women! Their rights, safety, value and identity is under threat!
Annaliese "SideShow Bob" Dodds
Freedom of Information Act:
How much is this costing, incl training etc: Government Departments ?
NHS, Schools, Councils, Police etc.
These people need to get some help
Ohh my god
Let's stop calling this corruption and calling it donations 😡
Sadly ms Dodds is my mp
Maybe you and other women can let her know why you didn't vote for her?
It's M P's that are the problem, not any other gripe of people.
OMG !! WHAT the hell have we got in Government ??
My 7 yrs old grandson can identify what a woman is ??😊
Spot on Renee, keep spreading the sanity.
Government for them will be a shock. Everyone will be going at them on everything.
JK Rowling is spot on 👍
Thought it was bad before???? Think it's going to be any better???? Reap what you sow. It's just a shame it's going to be inflicted on everyone.
Coincidentally, I took six kittens to be vaccinated recently.
I asked the vet how many were females? and she said, "Well... It depends on the context really!"
Simples = xx = woman XY = not woman - anything other is a spelling mistake.
This looks like five years of Labor hell for Britain!
Nandy is the worst of all. Completely bonkers.
Dodds...The most unappetising- looking excuse for a woman Ive ever seen ( Dragged through a hedge backwards comes to mind )is the last person to lecture us on what a woman is....
She must be a left over from the SNP, following their ideology.
I just had to check my trousers to make sure... This is
will somebody buy that Dodds woman A COMB ......PLEASE !!!!
Jk....bravo ! Keep up the pressure on this ridiculous government ( not elected by the majority). Hold them to account because Labour are going to destroy what's left of this country!
Looking at the first picture,i can only say how much Ken Dodd has let himself go.
WTF!!!...???
Tell me folks why did you vote for Labour? This is the crap that we have to deal with for at least 5 years
They haven’t even started!
These people that want these men that our pretending to women let them live in your house before u put them near us
same with these illegal invaders they can house them first
That woman is Medusa reincarnate. There used to be cartoon jokes of people wandering about dressed as Napoleon and thinking there were. We all knew they belonged in an asylum for their own good.
If it has an orange beak, webbed feet and goes 'quack' then it's not a chicken.
so what...dying children take a higher priority than definitions...humanity is more important
It's like the foreign secretary not knowing what foreign means, yeah a great person for the job ffs.
a woman does not have a Adams Apple, or a Prostate
Pregnant people 😅🤪 crazy times and certain crazy people
Hello,My names Wullie! And this is my wife, her names Fanny🎉 🤦😷👀
Im so sick of the definishion of a woman 👩 its bloody obvious.. infact if you get a honda & a garage puts a body kit on it that looks like a porche IS IT A PORCHE OFCOURDE NOT
As a Biologist: Gender and sex are synonymous. Only 2 Sexes (Male and Female) therefore only 2 Genders Man and Woman (adult form).
You can't change your Sex therefore you can't change your gender ergo no such thing as "Transgender".
Gender Identity is the social construct! You have Trans-Identifying Men (a man living as / pretending to be a woman) and Trans-Indentifying Women (a woman living as / pretnding to be a man)
All should have respect an live their lives just don't attack women's or men's rights.
its a form you fill in at the nhs which has a box saying tick this if you are pregnant.
If trans women insist in using Female spaces : Quextion, what is the issue with Trans-Men?
What cubicle do they use.
There are 3 loos in most places Men,woman and the lesser used disabled. Just make the disabled also a trans loo and problem solved
You should really ask the question "As a bioloicial woman, describe yourself as a woman?" not what is a woman.
The Screwtape Letters how to ruin everything.
Why women voted labour i ant imagine. Rishi didnt deserve this rout. At least he knew what woman was.
This stupid row is getting boring ...😂😂😂😂😂😂
Oh people think they have made a brillisnt start. Are they crazy. All the peoole fighting the pylon scheme in east anglia will get nowhere with the destroyer in charge. Hes all for the pylons. Lets get started he said
"Breasts? Well that kind of surgery can be done over the weekend, but that's not enough time to get rid of old Mr K'Nish!! - Ace Ventura
That is not right Kevin. In Australia all people are asked are you pregnant prior to X-rays because it is a proforma document, same for for all people.
It would probably be best to define men, 'people with prostates' as I understand that is one part of the anatomy which cannot be or isn't removed in so-called bottom surgery. Trans-women still get the morning reaction..........
I don't have a cervix any more following surgery, no one has offered me hormones to regrow one............
priDE MONth
the truth is right in front of your eyes.
Wombman woman
What is wrong with you people in the UK? The beautiful language of yours has been hijacked by lunatics.
Sub-titles ... Who needs this rubbish?
David said you have surgery and drugs (to prevent rejection). He was a littlle vague, tbf. But he did not say you can grow a cervix. Cervix transfer is a thing.
Tommy Robinson.
In general I agree with the notion that woman's toilets, changing areas and such other spaces should be restricted to women. But I am undecided about fully transitioned trans women who are female presenting and have had bottom surgery.
For me if a trans has had the full surgery I got no problem with them using female changing spaces,it is the men saying they are women to come into women's spaces
I will never be voting reform again … sacking Habib is the last straw for me and many others..
This is worse than when girls aloud split up….
He was not sacked. In politics a Party has a Deputy who must be an MP when the Leader is not there!
I am so glad I didn’t vote for Labour.
Dodds clearly transitioned
These crazy people, really want sectioning END OF...
Labour won
Just admit it losers 😂😂😂
Labour did not win the head count, more people voted for other party's and it was the Torys that throw it away, Labour will mess it up sooner rather later.
Like Brexit.
Only gullible fools and liars say humans can change sex. That’s labour for you. Liars living in cuckoo land.
Labour were the protest vote.