Cabrini Movie - A Potential Catholic Masterpiece?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 26 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 105

  • @frankpmarsala7682
    @frankpmarsala7682 11 місяців тому +73

    in the early 1900's, my Grandfather was seriously stabbed by his brother-in-law. Mother Cabrini nursed him back to health. This was before my Mother was born, thus I owe her my existence. I invoke her prayers every morning.

  • @m.riveram9217
    @m.riveram9217 Рік тому +31

    I read all her biographies and I think they did a good job portraying her. She was strong lady, that was fearless and had amazing faith!!

  • @vixtex
    @vixtex 9 місяців тому +15

    My mom’s parents remembered Mother Cabrini in NYC. She also attended Mother Cabrini High School. I’ve had a devotion to Mother Cabrini since I was a little girl.✝️

  • @daninspiration4064
    @daninspiration4064 8 місяців тому +12

    It’s a shame they did not portray her holiness as they could have. I think they were scared of the secular world being turned off by it. But it’s a catholic saint so they should have made her true to the saint that she is.

  • @rustiehead
    @rustiehead 8 місяців тому +10

    I just saw Cabrini last night. She is portrayed as a very strong woman who wanted to get things done; she was not portrayed as a feminist. One thing that bothered me was that none of the sisters prayed, that was not shown. Also, crucifixes were blurred or made very small. Good movie that could have been better and Catholic.

  • @christinereich6050
    @christinereich6050 Рік тому +43

    I am nervous about this being anti Catholic or anti hierarchy, but I am from Buffalo and this looks fabulous. People don't understand that Catholic sisters had immense power and owned hospitals and schools. What other religion had this 100 plus years ago?

    • @anonjohn7571
      @anonjohn7571 Рік тому

      That's pretty typical, anti catholics only hate catholicism because they have no clue what the faith is (original Christianity) and that's partly due to the church rejecting mainstream secular materialism which unfortunately is what our culture got sucked into over the last 80 years or so. Once you learn about the faith you won't be anti catholic. You may not become catholic, as beneficial as the lifestyle is, but you will see its beauty and won't be an anti anymore. I think this movie is a great start to delving into the faith and its rich history without the bias of secular corporations just trying to sell you things based on your whims.

    • @wendyannh
      @wendyannh 10 місяців тому +5

      We Jews did.
      My ancestors helped fund (or completely donated) a wide range of such institutions both here in Pittsburgh and elsewhere, and they were far from alone.

    • @christinereich6050
      @christinereich6050 10 місяців тому +8

      Yes, I understand, but were women running the institutions? I totally understand other religions did donate but I was referring to women having a great deal of control back then. @@wendyannh

    • @mallshopper8948
      @mallshopper8948 8 місяців тому +2

      Im buffalo. It was a beautiful film. Thanks be to God it was filmed here.

  • @sailnav
    @sailnav 10 місяців тому +17

    My wife's cousin, Msgr. Paul Bocchicchio, served as a consultant during the filming, and he conducted religious retreats for the cast in Buffalo.

  • @barlow335
    @barlow335 8 місяців тому +2

    Everyone needs to see this movie. As a devout life long catholic and a descendent of Italian grandparents who came to America during the same time as Mother Cabrini, I wept through the entire movie. Tears of sadness and of joy. I definitely left the movie feeling unworthy after see the courage and success of Mother Cabrini. I need to step up my work for the Lord.

  • @gudrun5531
    @gudrun5531 Рік тому +12

    I had never heard about her before but when I watched the trailer I got so excited to watch the movie. the subject matter is something I care a lot about. Also, the actress is extremely striking in the trailer so I became interested in her just from watching that.

  • @prioress
    @prioress 9 місяців тому +4

    I have seen a movie on Cabrini on EWTN and I much prefer the lead actress in that film. There was a sweet tenderness and vulnerability while maintaining the determination of a woman with a mission in that version. I think the reason it is so hard for actors to capture a saint is that saints are not performing for effect. They are motivated from within and don't care how they come across. Their director lives in their hearts. That said, I admire anyone who attempts the task of acting as a saint. God bless them.

  • @rachelkulakowski9843
    @rachelkulakowski9843 10 місяців тому +8

    I went to a school in New orleans named after her one of our buildings we used for classes was the orphanage we could kneel in front of her bed, now there's a time line in the hall on the second story of her story and the students have to memorize her story for her feast day. The class symbols are after her angels, violets, the star, and the heart

  • @maryallen8051
    @maryallen8051 10 місяців тому +6

    St Ambrose Catholic Church (built 1963) in Cheverly, MD had a huge stained glass window devoted to Mother Frances Cabrini! So happy that they tell her story.

  • @maryharrington8983
    @maryharrington8983 8 місяців тому +3

    Wow, how delightful that St. Anthony of Padua Catholic Church has daily Latin Mass. Deo gratias!

  • @LateNiteBreaks
    @LateNiteBreaks Рік тому +9

    I was emotional when I saw this trailer before the Sound of Freedom, I trust the director(Alejandro Monteverde) of Sound of Freedom and Bella, I hope many people give it a chance. I don't think that those lines everyone's talking about are that controversial because the main parts of the movie will be greater than these sound bites.

  • @americapatton9266
    @americapatton9266 10 місяців тому +8

    I can't wait to see it with my family and friends. 🎺🆓📚😃✏️

  • @brendazolli3059
    @brendazolli3059 8 місяців тому +4

    I agree with the comments concerning the lack of Mother Cabrini seen praying with her nuns etc The movie was wonderful, but I found the watered down Catholic practices detracted from the story. I wonder if this was intentional? The film got very good reviews from several MSM publications. I think they would have been less complimentary if there had been more overt scenes of her spiritual life. I think it must have given many non believers pause for thought about the love for God that permeates our Church and creates saints like Mother Cabrini and St Mother Theresa, both of whom dedicated their lives to service to the poor and marginalized. So maybe a few seeds got planted. 🙏🙏🙏

  • @TracyW-me8br
    @TracyW-me8br 10 місяців тому +4

    I think it looks well made. I’m looking forward to it.

  • @MichelePlunkett
    @MichelePlunkett 10 місяців тому +5

    I use to live in Saint Cabrini group home between 16 and 20 years old.

  • @joelemerson2732
    @joelemerson2732 Рік тому +9

    I worked on this film, in the prop department providing a tiny portion of historicity to the hospital scenes, as the Period Hospital Consultant. And I am grateful for Ms. Kraft's notice of the props and sets in the film. As far as people being critical of the character of Mother Cabrini, I think there's a little too much pearl clutching over how a saint should behave. After all, before they became saints, how many individuals would have been rejected by traditional Catholics because of their lives before being elevated to sainthood?

    • @amysill3815
      @amysill3815 9 місяців тому +6

      Very few? Traditional Catholics who live according to Christ don’t reject people , they reject their sins.

    • @melindaharrington900
      @melindaharrington900 8 місяців тому +2

      I've never known of a Catholic Saint who didn't pray.

  • @polarisjustdothework2258
    @polarisjustdothework2258 Рік тому +16

    I do kind of feel like way too much glory is been given to Cabrini herself... She would not agree. All of her strength, all of her passion, and all of her accomplishments, came directly from the Lord.
    She herself, says this many times...

    • @WhatsThatNoiize
      @WhatsThatNoiize 9 місяців тому +1

      Don't you feel it's up to each of us to accept that love and strength to give it to others? That power isn't metered out and given to people like Mother Cabrini and not to others - she simply chose to let it flow like a river to the world around her rather than closing it off for herself.
      God doesn't choose to work through specific individuals - God chooses to love all and our will to act as free beings in that power is on us. That is why we are children of God, not pawns.

    • @polarisjustdothework2258
      @polarisjustdothework2258 9 місяців тому +1

      @@WhatsThatNoiize I haven't seen the movie yet, but I know Cabrini's character. Her greatest strength was obedience and a heart on fire with love for God and His Creations (us), especially His wee ones. I hope the movie depicts that and gives God all the Glory

    • @melindaharrington900
      @melindaharrington900 8 місяців тому +2

      @@polarisjustdothework2258 It doesn't give any glory to God. Very disappointing.

    • @WhatsThatNoiize
      @WhatsThatNoiize 7 місяців тому +1

      ​@@polarisjustdothework2258this fundamentally undercuts the faith in God as Father.

    • @polarisjustdothework2258
      @polarisjustdothework2258 7 місяців тому

      @@WhatsThatNoiize ??

  • @michaela.abbott222
    @michaela.abbott222 8 місяців тому

    I saw the movie yesterday (3/12/24).
    I'm not Catholic.
    I saw it as a Cabrini masterpiece. A very inspiring human story.

  • @mollya.7206
    @mollya.7206 7 місяців тому

    May Jesus be glorified! Excited to see this evening!

  • @edwardonsax9919
    @edwardonsax9919 8 місяців тому

    Just saw this movie and I was blown away.

  • @jencincy1363
    @jencincy1363 8 місяців тому +3

    They could've said the name of Jesus or God ONCE. After all, Mother Cabrini was/is Catholic. She did what she did for love of Jesus.

  • @betterd9160
    @betterd9160 Рік тому +7

    Could you imagine Katharine Hepburn pontificating about woman empowerment in The African Queen. Will the lectures never end?

  • @samdelgado8511
    @samdelgado8511 7 місяців тому

    Such a good movie! I’ve seen it twice and preordered.

  • @richardbenitez1282
    @richardbenitez1282 9 місяців тому +2

    In my mind Angel Studios has lots of credibility from work on sound of freedom. When I heard about this film , Cabrini, I just automatically assumed good work. I hope I’m correct.

  • @stephaniehatfield5831
    @stephaniehatfield5831 8 місяців тому

    OUTSTANDING FILM! Cabrini did not accept the answer NO! She knew God’s plan and carried it out! This film show the strength a woman has, if they can get over themselves and help others🙏🏻

  • @williamsmith-bf2vv
    @williamsmith-bf2vv Рік тому +5

    awesome movie...

  • @mraemartinez
    @mraemartinez Рік тому +14

    I am a supporter of the Team behind this film…but I agree with Tim Gordon about the feminista bent of it. I noticed it in the trailer (I was so impressed with everything else…Very much so!) & then Tim Gordon said out loud what I was thinking. Women power is everywhere & that’s not a good thing. 😒😞

    • @yoname1887
      @yoname1887 Рік тому +3

      "Agreed."
      - A woman

    • @mraemartinez
      @mraemartinez 10 місяців тому +1

      @@brianmurphy9570 It’s thru the whole movie…sadly. That being said, I do think it is worth watching. I saw a sneak peek last week & the film is so impressive. And I don’t say that easily…I am a real film snob. Monteverde did something special here. Pity about the feminista bent.

    • @melindaharrington900
      @melindaharrington900 8 місяців тому +1

      I have to say, I thought Cabrini's last words of the film, "There are some things only a woman can do', was more of a swipe at the Trans movement than anti -male.

  • @EGR370
    @EGR370 Рік тому +21

    I’m Catholic and I don’t like how the trailer portrayed a Catholic saint as a feminist. St. Mother Cabrini was virtuous. This almost makes a mockery of saints and it’s insulting that they would use a saint to push their narrative. Imagine if they did that with a Muslim or Jewish person? But they do it with our Catholic saints and it’s disrespectful.

    • @Geronimo_Jehoshaphat
      @Geronimo_Jehoshaphat Рік тому +8

      I don't think you know what feminism is if you think a woman not sitting on her hands to be railroaded is a feminist.

    • @wendyannh
      @wendyannh 10 місяців тому +1

      We Jews have *many* such strong women who would not back down from power, speak truth to it, and who get things done - and we’re very proud of them! A movie like this about a number of them would be very welcomed.

    • @EGR370
      @EGR370 10 місяців тому +2

      @@wendyannhif a movie was made that portrayed a Jewish woman advertising things that are against Jewish beliefs, I’m sure it would be disappointing.

    • @wendyannh
      @wendyannh 10 місяців тому

      ⁠@@EGR370 Possibly…
      But what do you see is against Catholic beliefs in this movie?

    • @streamscreen
      @streamscreen 10 місяців тому +3

      She wasn’t a feminist but she was tough she lived in a man’s world,and her assertiveness was thought of feminism.She was just a very determined woman to do Gods will and she wasn’t submissive to any man.She was a powerhouse saint and wouldn’t let anything get in her ways despite her health problems.All for the glory of God.

  • @elizabethhonaker4855
    @elizabethhonaker4855 8 місяців тому +5

    Where was Jesus Christ in the movie? I only heard the word "God" ONCE! The script managed to sidestep Mother Cabrini's faith in GOD -- they only highlighted HER faith in HERSELF!

  • @adfly7
    @adfly7 8 місяців тому +4

    The film is beautiful but very sanitized of any real faith elements. Make is look like Mother Cabrini did it all herself without any help form God. You never see her praying and you never see one scene with the mass. I was very disappointed. I give the film 5 out 5 stars for artistry and 2 out of 5 stars for showing spirituality. What a missed opportunity.

  • @sac1303
    @sac1303 8 місяців тому +1

    Would like to see it.

  • @TheGringoSalado
    @TheGringoSalado 8 місяців тому

    They feature the priest as a wimpy man. Historically accurate? Believable as we’ve seen today in the church, absolutely. Also, don’t show Mother Cabrini in prayer. Other than that The movie is absolutely amazing!

  • @Rosie-q4f
    @Rosie-q4f 8 місяців тому +4

    I saw the movie and they toned down the Catholic part. The real Mother Cabrini was devoted to the sacred heart and this made it into a feminist movie. I’m sure the real mother Cabrini didn’t go around yelling at men. I guess they were trying to sell this to a secular wile secular crowd. I think it does disservice to the first American saint .

    • @melindaharrington900
      @melindaharrington900 8 місяців тому +1

      i wasn't so much worried about the feisty nature of Mother Cabrini. (My mother was part Italian and she was always yelling at men). What concerns and disappoints me is the absence of God and prayer in the film. By film's end there has been no mention of God's hand in the whole turn of events.

    • @maryharrington8983
      @maryharrington8983 8 місяців тому +1

      In parts of Italy, that's the way they talk. They're not yelling.

    • @mollya.7206
      @mollya.7206 7 місяців тому

      Jesus yelled. Sometimes it's needed!

  • @bradleylove8606
    @bradleylove8606 4 місяці тому

    Cabrini kept with orders of her superiors most of the time but we see sometimes she moves out of that and operates on her own. She did have respect and beg the Pope at times and he listened a few times, however, he thought was against his better judgement. She had many set backs due to not listening to others at times but at all times satan always has his people in place if you are a true believer and trying to do His will.

  • @deborahcox-mp5ul
    @deborahcox-mp5ul 9 місяців тому

    I will be watching this movie but since it could be considered "tans" I will wait until it comes out on UA-cam!

  • @Liberal_From_Prairies689
    @Liberal_From_Prairies689 Рік тому +1

    Mea Maxima Culpa: Silence in the House of God

  • @seanohare5488
    @seanohare5488 8 місяців тому +1

    Why can't there be movies about saints Hollywood for far too long has made enough films of sordid people and subject matter lets balance it out

  • @jaimefernandez4899
    @jaimefernandez4899 8 місяців тому +1

    CABRINI is certainly a powerful movie, however it was centered on the idea of Feminism, I do not remember any prayer or thanking GOD in this movie, everything was accomplished through cleverness, hard work, and persevering through all obstacles, God was left out!!!

    • @mollya.7206
      @mollya.7206 7 місяців тому

      IT is the overflow and outpouring of God's love that come good works. Jesus talked with God in private. I think it's understood.

  • @frospina1
    @frospina1 8 місяців тому +4

    Liked the movie but did not appreciate the lack of respect for the clergy!! As a staunch Traditional Catholic man I love, respect and REVERE my holy priests!!! This movie made sure to portray our priests as irrelevant and not necessary!! Unfortunate to see mother Cabrini without a confessor!! Also did not appreciate her giving the gun back to the kid instead of bringing him to a priest!!! Movie did not exalt the Catholic Church!

    • @CarmenTorres-sx2bk
      @CarmenTorres-sx2bk 8 місяців тому +3

      Thank you! You said exactly the truth! I feel they portrayed our priests negatively, and it made me very sad..
      I feel the main character was demonstrated as being a bit too prideful, not sure if her character was very accurate..

    • @melindaharrington900
      @melindaharrington900 8 місяців тому +3

      Yes, i noticed the first time we see the inside of a church in the film is when the Archbishop is standing in front of the crucifix and tabernacle shouting at Cabrini for being disobedient. That was no accident, it was very carefully crafted to portray the Catholic clergy in authority as judgmental, angry, ineffectual and pretty much corrupt. I was grateful that they had the grace to portray the Pope as a more reasonable and kindly man.

    • @mollya.7206
      @mollya.7206 7 місяців тому

      Only Jesus be exalted. I am reminded of his turning the tables having a fit about what folks turned the temple into. Jesus is the only "priest".

  • @Geronimo_Jehoshaphat
    @Geronimo_Jehoshaphat Рік тому +7

    A devout Italian nun ardentilly serving God by pilgriming to New York and refusing to sit quietly by and let her anointing and vocation be dismissed and obstructed by foolish men has no relation to the feminist movement or women's liberation.

    • @wendyannh
      @wendyannh 10 місяців тому

      What are you smoking if that’s what you think?

    • @Geronimo_Jehoshaphat
      @Geronimo_Jehoshaphat 10 місяців тому +1

      @@wendyannh
      I'm smoking out people who don't know the history and origin of feminism yet ardently subscribe to its detriments.

    • @emiliarutigliano7991
      @emiliarutigliano7991 9 місяців тому +3

      Totally agree!!! We Catholics, Christians were born to fight, born to stand out; wishy -washy need not apply. Not 100 yrs ago, certainly not now…

    • @melindaharrington900
      @melindaharrington900 8 місяців тому +2

      I love your passionate comment! I don't think we can sidestep the power imbalance between Cabrini and the men in authority in this era, as depicted in the film. That power imbalance is at the heart of feminist theory. It's not necessarily anti Catholic.

  • @Cristero4718
    @Cristero4718 Рік тому +21

    Unfortunately I think this movie is insulting to us traditional Catholics. It has a woman feminist propaganda twist instead of focusing on her catholic life. If your going to make a movie about a saint then it has to be catholic , you cant be afraid of alienating others when it’s about a catholic saint.

    • @mraemartinez
      @mraemartinez Рік тому +3

      Yep. Totally agree!

    • @wendyannh
      @wendyannh 10 місяців тому +3

      Serving the poor and helping people was her religious vocation, though. That’s what a lot of orders do. They just aren’t generally as widely prolific or as well-known.
      Someone should make a movie instead about nuns who never leave their cloisters, or live in silence instead? About their daily prayer cycle? How is that any more “Catholic” than what Cabrini did? How would *portraying* that be any more “Catholic” than portraying what Cabrini accomplished and what she had to contend with in order to do so? This was clearly a religious calling for her, so how much more “Catholic” can you get? I think the fact that she was canonized says quite clearly that the Pope obviously agreed.
      And how would that make a more interesting movie that a lot of people would want to see? The reality is it’s freaking expensive to make a film, and there needs to be a reasonable expectation that enough people will want to pay to see it in order for it to make any sense to make it in the first place.
      Having just heard of this remarkable woman for the first time, I’m absolutely blown away with what I have learned about her with a quick Google search. What an incredible person, and all the more so precisely *because* she was both female and a nun in very difficult times! I *really* look forward to this movie.

    • @hiuszenoom809
      @hiuszenoom809 10 місяців тому

      I don’t understand serving others is something about “liberals and feminism”! I am a traditional catholic and also a special educator! Am I a liberal feminist?

    • @mpetershat
      @mpetershat 10 місяців тому

      Has she been declared a Saint?

    • @Aurora-tp3dy
      @Aurora-tp3dy 9 місяців тому +2

      ​@@mpetershat She was canonized in 1946.

  • @frospina1
    @frospina1 8 місяців тому

    Great cinematography no doubts!! But we Catholics missed an opportunity to see priests confess!! Mother Cabrini must and had to have a confessor!! The movie made the priest like a good for nothing idiot!! Even from the initial appearance of the priest the movie made sure we sideline the priest!! As a traditional Catholic I understand the importance of the priesthood in our religion!!

  • @frospina1
    @frospina1 8 місяців тому +1

    The movie did not exalt the Catholic faith nor the priesthood!! They made father morrell look like a complete idiot. Good movie though. Not too catholic

  • @seanohare5488
    @seanohare5488 8 місяців тому

    Well said big bad joe mclane

  • @ognqski
    @ognqski 8 місяців тому

    I am sure Mother Cabrini was a saint, but....this is the second Angel studios movie that really is borderline Hollyweird. Cabrini comes across as a zero spriritual, zero catholic, 100% feminist social justice warrior. Sad to see that Angel has gone the way of hollyweird, never again to pay for a movie ticket for them. Compromise and go the way of hollyweird. Long, and really devoid of giving God and His church their due.

  • @monicag7330
    @monicag7330 10 місяців тому +1

    I dont mean to be disrespectful but someone please answer this question to help me UNDERSTAND? When I google Cabrini it shows how even though there was community in this socialism "helping the poor" building complex, there was high crime, murder and rape which is typical when a handout or helping the poor becomes permanent, instead of structured in a way to be just a platform to stand on your own. Hence, it seems Cabrini was not a hero but tried to play GOD in making permanent homes for people but it created a MESS. Why is she glorified when the properties have since been demolished and many deaths, rapes, people-remaining-oppressed by her getting INVOLVED and it should have been structured differently as a temporary place or just not get involved at all. Help me understand why she is a hero? As I read, it was bulldozed and a failure??
    I also came across this article online: I do not know if the story is apocryphal, but it is said that, whenever a company who had done work on one of Mother Cabrini’s many institutions sent her a bill for their services, she would send the bill back, unpaid, with the hand-written note, “Thank you for your generous contribution to God’s work!” She was never called on it!
    This is NOT God's way. God's way is to be righteous in all things, including finances. God will provide if an endeavor or mission is truly anointed by God in the name/Spirit of Jesus. If donations dont come through, then NOT anointed by the Lord God. We need to be careful to not bulldoze through missions in the name of God. God through Jesus Christ our Lord, must be Glorified at all times- even if our flesh desires something to happen, we cannot decide to default on a financial obligation.

    • @wendyannh
      @wendyannh 10 місяців тому +3

      It was certainly not her fault that neighborhoods and developments like Cabrini-Green went downhill and became overridden by crime. That unfortunately often happens in poor communities, and projects like that have failed all over the country.
      At the time they were built, they were widely thought to be the epitome of the best way to serve a downtrodden population, to permanently house as many people as possible. These places were shining beacons of hope and goodwill.
      It was not known at the time the influence that building style has on people, however. We now know, in no small part thanks to what happened at Cabrini-Green, that such highrises with double-loaded corridors and long stairways actually foster drug use and crime, and do not engender any sense of pride in their home in the residents. Low income housing is now built in very different styles that are much safer, and create far more vibrant communities.
      The details of this are beyond the scope of this post, but suffice it to say that each generation learns from the ones before - and *many* very important lessons were learned precisely from the spectacular failure of Cabrini-Green in particular.
      She didn’t even have anything to do with those infamous projects; they were just named after her and the developments that had been on the site before.
      Why would you say that temporary housing rather than permanent would have been a better goal, though? That makes no sense.

  • @paulmartinez2480
    @paulmartinez2480 8 місяців тому

    Sorry but this movie left out the Catholic spiritual of her faith. Lack of faith and prayer in this movie.

  • @paulyosef7550
    @paulyosef7550 8 місяців тому

    Election year! What incidious timing. This is a great example of a false equivalence though. Sinister like the movie "Cider House Rules".

  • @Frankiefirenze
    @Frankiefirenze 10 місяців тому

    Looking forward to this movie. It's too bad that a right-wing group had to make it

    • @amysill3815
      @amysill3815 9 місяців тому +1

      😂😂😂

    • @rastaisfuture8630
      @rastaisfuture8630 8 місяців тому

      Feminist right wing group😂

    • @Frankiefirenze
      @Frankiefirenze 8 місяців тому

      @@rastaisfuture8630 are you saying that you don't feel this group that produce this is far right?

  • @poppiethestable1090
    @poppiethestable1090 8 місяців тому

    Pure Propaganda Rubbish

  • @seanohare5488
    @seanohare5488 8 місяців тому +1

    Well said big bad joe mclane