What’s Currently Going On In Afghanistan? Ft. Salman Javed | 119 | TBT
Вставка
- Опубліковано 22 тра 2024
- International listeners can support TBT here: buy.stripe.com/14keVU54r5hQ55...
In conversation with Salman Javed, this episode discusses the current situation in Afghanistan is alike. What is the sentiment of an ordinary Afghan regarding the central government and the Taliban? The efforts of Pakistan in the present and past for negotiations of peace? Why Pakistan Holds the Key to Peace in Afghanistan? Why did India open a backchannel to the Taliban? What is the major concern of Pakistan in Afghanistan? Indian Influence in Afghanistan and its Implications for Pakistan? What are the efforts which Pakistan has put up for the betterment of Afghanistan? Russia’s involvement in Afghanistan. Tune in to know more on has the Taliban really controlled 85% of Afghanistan and why Pakistan Refuses to Host Additional Afghan Refugees?
#thoughtbehindthings #muzamilhasan #taliban
00:00 Tonight’s guest: Salman Javed
02:04 What is the current situation in Afghanistan?
06:17 What’s the sentiment of Afghans regarding central government and the Taliban?
09:27 What are the efforts of Pakistan in the Afghan's peace process?
12:39 Why Pakistan holds the key to peace in Afghanistan?
17:34 Why did India open a backchannel to the Taliban?
24:30 What is the major concern of Pakistan in Afghanistan?
30:30 What are the implications of Indian Influence in Afghanistan for Pakistan?
34:00 What are the efforts which Pakistan for the betterment of Afghanistan?
38:27 What is Russia’s involvement in Afghanistan?
44:47 Has the Taliban really controlled 85% of Afghanistan?
54:29 Why Pakistan Refuses to Host Additional Afghan Refugees?
Do not forget to subscribe and press the bell icon to catch on to some amazing conversations coming your way!
Connect with us:
• / thoughtbehindthings
• / muzamilhasan
Salman Javed’s Twitter:
/ m_essjay
Support our podcast:
anchor.fm/syed-muzamil-hasan-...
You can also audio stream our podcast on the following platforms:
• Spotify: spoti.fi/3z1cE7F
• Google Podcast: bit.ly/2S84VEd
• Apple Podcast: apple.co/3cgIkfI
I was literally waiting for sir Salman interview on Afghanistan situation
Who is he btw?!
@@khairulwara1240 He is running a platform Pak Afghan Youth Forum along with another project South Asia Times.
Also he was a co-founder of PKKH. Pakistan's first geo-political digital news outlet, way back in 2008. He also started an e-magazine Stratagem and co-founded first youth oriented security think tank CSCR (Islamabad). He also initiated Voice of Balochistan and ran it for two years before handing it over to Govt of Balochistan and now running those two projects that I mentioned. And he is also a member board of directors in Maritime Study forum.
Do More Podcasts on Geopolitics!!! 🙋♂️
Thanks for inviting him again. And Please invite him again for a detailed discussion on relations with other countries too .
Been waiting for this guy. He is walking encyclopedia.
Does he have a UA-cam channel of his own ?
walking encyclopedia with IQ 70 :P
@@irondome4791 why would you say that? What gave you this impression?
@@uzairawan6418 Loud and Clear is his youtube channel
@@uzairawan6418 ua-cam.com/video/01cZl9v2xdU/v-deo.html
Literally literally......was waiting for Sir Slaman.🙂
thanks, Muzamil Bhai for inviting Sir Salman and educating us to regard Current scenarios ❣❣
Was eagerly waiting for this podcast. Big fan of Salman sb.
A podcast with Masod Lohar, an ex-un executive, NGO activist struggling for urban forestation. He had worked a lot for the nation. You should get him on board.
Most incipated sequel of this wonderfull podcast
Thank you for ur efforts
Much appreciated muzamil bhai. Thank u so much for this splendid discussion
Being a geopolitics nerd, loved ur pure, unbiased podcast. Which we need r8 nw. ❤️
By far my favourite guest on the show!
Thank God for Muzamil Hasan for bringing us this amazing podcast. We really needed this platform in Pakistan.
Please take me as a patreon, don't see the views
Plz continue this kind of podcast
I was actually waiting for someone to cover recent afghan situation... Tysm 🌻
I always wait for Salman's Podcast
Waited for this ❤
17:34 everyone talks about Indian 3 billion dollar investment in Afghanistan but I've never seen someone mentioning that Pakistan has also invested 1 billion dollars in Afghanistan in multiple infrastructure projects.
But when and where
@@musabbinumair8763 hospitals,roads, scholarship
Do you know the meaning of investment??... that's a AID ,we are not getting a single penny from those 3 billion dollars.,not a single revenue..modi only invested 700 millions till now...all r done by previous govt.
@@parthachoudhury4332 My son I'm also taking about 1 billion dollar aid.
If you're feeling so charitable than try hosting 3 million refugees too
@@arminius6506 bete..tum palo...afterall assi vi musalman tussi vi musalman...😂bad joke..i knw...bhai 50k to 100k Afghanistani rehte h yaha...apne business bhi set-up kr liya h unhone...some afghani brilliant youth have built startup here also and giving employments to fellow afghani and indians too...,if i recollect the names ,i will mention here..
Shukar hai itnay arsay se ma comment pe likh raha tha ke inko bulao. Aur finally aj Salman is here
Thank you Muzamil for this podcast
Really interesting episode!
Great Salman Bhai
Sir Salaman You did great Job (Y)
One of the problems that I see with your podcast is that you often try to steer a conversation towards certain points which gives it a scripted touch when in fact the interesting thing about podcasts is and why people including myself watch it is because it's free flow of ideas and it flows naturally in different directions like natural conversation. If you guys fall upon an interesting topic, please don't put it off for later episodes, discuss it now so we're not irritated. That's what's awesome about Joe Rogan and Junaid Akram, natural conversation. Just some constructive criticism. Hope this'll be helpful.
Umair Muzammil Bhayi has to keep it within an acceptable time frame. Because often individuals are put off by “ 3hr “ mark on any video. The podcast does need an audience to ACTUALLY deliver the message that it wants to deliver to a more diverse audience. Often people dont even know the def of “ podcasts “
Change is always gradual.
And another point, about Joe Rogan and Junaid Akram (?) is you are mixing up different types of podcasts. Some are individual based podcasts. Like the ones Joe Rogan does. And then there are narrative based podcasts like this one. The latter are usually confined to a specific topic and the host obviously has to steer the conversation back to the topic at hand. To address as many issues and subpoints as possible. While the individual based podcasts are free for all. The individuals can take it to wherever they want. Thats why some of Joe’s podcasts go over 4 hrs. And some dont even go over 90 minutes.
Muzammil Bhayi is an AMAZING host. And the way he articulates the narrative while (trying) keeping the balance between the expert’s explaination of each subpoint. And touching upon as many points as possible within an easily digestible time frame is MashAllah TabarakAllah, fascinating.
Cheers
Someone has put Joe Rogan and rondu wannabe aunty Junaid Akram in one sentence 🤦🤦🤦
@@arminius6506
I was thinking the EXACT same thing 😂
Joe Roagan to theek hai but Junaid Akram ??? Junaid to question based posdcasts hi krta hai. Mooroo ki although unscripted podcasts hoti hain.
Excellent podcast. Thank you all for such a informative conversation.
very insightul discussion
it was a great session
could you do a podcast on pk banks like giving awaam an idea how behind they are
Absolutely loved this episode 😍
Muzamil you are doing great job❤
most awaited guest
Waiting for so long for this man.
Bring someone to talk over the matter of Balochistan. Our people need to know what future demands, and how we as youth can participate in building it.
SCENCE/TECHNOLOGY AND TRADE..TRIBALISM WILL LEAD TO NOWHERE..
Usually watch your podcast for not more than half hour but today episode was very good , informative and in one hour what happening in Afghanistan from past 20 years is explained with excellence and honesty ! Thank You ❤️
Finally he's back
So informative.
Please do another podcast with him about the post 9/11 era.
I like your discussions on political factors
Aslam O Alikum Muazamil bhai,
I am following your podcasts for a longtime, these geo politic padcasts are amazing giving us a bunch of information that unfortunately we should have get from our media but thats busy in political cases only,
My humble request is please do a podcast on current situation of pakistan in term of terrorism, recently attacks are increasing after long time of peace, i believe here we as pakistani living abroad can get much knowledge as compared to following news. Please do a podcast about that.
Love your podcast.
Suggestion - slow down in the begininning to welcome everyone and slow down at the end to encourage everyone to subscribe to your channel.
👊 Enjoyed.........
Invite Syed Muzammil. He is one of the very few rising intellectuals of Pakistan.
Mr liberal aur koi nai mila ap ko
@@usamahkhalid6333 he is not liberal. He just views every thing with different perspectives.
Finally....
We should hope for the best and ready for the worst. Situationa now is very Appalling.
One more podcast with him on current situation plzzzzzzz
Imf loan podcast lol
I love such fact-based geopolitical analysis.
I love this interaction
Great job. More podcast on geopolitics please.
Finally
Waiting for next episode with him.
yar post 9-11 session karain! Thankyou so much for these though!
Need more podcasts like this ❤️
bro you are the best... elite class
please call him more, complete the last podcast timeline and start new timeline
Very knowledgeable podcast thanks
He cleared my many concepts.overall thori bht baten e nae thi r jo nae thi wo tu kisi kitab me nh thi and that is what this guy is brilliant!!
This guy is walking encyclopedia...i literally watched all of the podcasts with him in it
Please make your videos more in Urdu. This is a quality channel and using Urdu will make it one more bit better
پلیز اپنی ویڈیوز اُردو میں کیا کریں۔ یہ پاکستان کا بہترین چینل ہے اور اُردو کا استعمال مزید بھتر بنا دیگا۔
Lagta hai aaj islamabad mein b bijli chali gai thi 🙂🙂🙂🙂
Can you please share Bruce riddles video Salman saab is talking about thank you in the first part?
ua-cam.com/video/EwBaZFQnr7Y/v-deo.html
Here it is
@@salmanjaved1712 thank you Salman Bhai
Salman Javed has articulated a logical inconsistency in his argument. He wants India to be part of stable South Asian ecosphere, to join Pakistan Afghanistan and Bangladesh into making peaceful South Asian century.
Is Pakistan able to a accept stability in India?
Are China and its client Pakistan able to give up their animosity to coerce India? When PLA confrontated the Indian Army in 2020 in East Ladakh, the biggest cheer was found amongst Pakistani commentators. When in 2021, disengagement was agreed between the two militaries, the biggest disappointments were heard in Pakistan.
Intellectuals have to base their conclusions not only on evidence and facts, but offer honesty, even if it goes against the grain of their country's popular narrative.
please invite him again as there is a 360 paradigm shift after the Taliban take over
it was a very informative podcast and waiting for post 9/11 era podcast
👍👍👍
Brother, plz put more lighting in the studio 👍
I didn't know how 1 Hour passed.
Where is the new podcast Muzamil
Hi muzzamil! Please invite ammar ali jan to your podcast
Tell us about Afghanistan between 2001 and till now.
76.7K
Sir , Muzamil Hassan, How can one contact you ?
muzamil@outlook.com
@@TBTGO Okay, I'll be sending you a mail very shortly.
@@TBTGO Have Sent
This one was amazing . But I will request if there was a video on Israelis and how we prevent doing such things that they are doing right now in Palestine
Is podcast me shirt achi nhi pehni to lights off krk hi recording krli 😜😜🤪
Invite manzoor pashteen, would like to hear his perspective on the current situation
Agree 👍
Hum us taraf ya is taraf nahi jaate hum country ke national interest ke taraf jaate hain. Jaha jaane se country ka national interest serve hoga waha jayenge
Please call Ramish Safa.
Please invite Ahmed Bilal Mehboob from pildat
Osama bin Laden was caught...😂😂😂
kitna time hogaya
Main Quran e Pak pay videos banatee hoon, Allah nay taufeeq dee tau aa kay sawab kamayie ga ☪️🕋
fall of kabul k bd bulayie
Invite Imran Yousufzai
from where did you find pablo Escobar for this podcast
somewhere in islamabad
@@salmanjaved1712 🤣🤣🤣🤣...
Please invite SAHIL ADEEM
time when pakistanis were very happy
Alhamdullilah Allah ne islam ko phir se Ghalib kiya
#WeSupportTaliban
Muzammil bhai amazing Podcast
You don't have knowledge about them so don't speak about it
@@togrulbeg764 I have more knowledge more than you You really dont wanna mess with me i have read almost all the books from the creation of Taliban to this day
@@lsheikh7473 hahaha... try bringing taliban rule in your house... you won't last one day
@@lsheikh7473 if you like them so much then why do you dislike ttp? Pakistani taliban? Oh because they kill innocent pakistanis? Guess what, afg Taliban also kill innocent people too! Just cause if isn't your family isn't affected doesn't mean they are good people... look at it from a different perspective
@@togrulbeg764 @Togrul Beg O bhai mujhe maro mujhe maro BHAI MERE AP KO JAB KUCH NHI PATA AP NA BOLE
TTP is another thing which is clearly made by INDIA just like Afghan Democracy
And one more thing Taliban ko bana ne wale america hi thai Soviet ko khatam karne ke liye baad me jab unhon ne Allah swt ka nizam nafiz kiya to America ne unhi ko Disown kar diya kar kisi ko is baat ka pata hai
Syed muzammil ko be bula lay yar. Why is he not invited?
Please invite SAQIB AZHAR (Enabler's Owner) to your podcast, he worth it.
TTP and TTA maybe separate entities but they have same ideological underpinning. The ideological fall out of a radical regime is every moderate rational pakistani's worst nightmare. There was no mention of it this conversation. I hope and pray things will go as smoothly and nicely between a taliban regime and pakistan.
Still better than the puppet indian american baked anti pakistan regime
Get some musicians on your show, dude!
Guys do you know where Osama Bin Laden was caught 😂
Bhai this gentleman who is running ths podcast is a PTI youthia..he invites those who supports PTI.
@@parthachoudhury4332 haan Bhai...mast saare positive news bata ke ..mast views leta hai...😂😂...aur log bhi chutiya hai .jinko lag raha aab pak superpower banega...
In the sea 🌊
@@shanu3588 they are living parallel world with identity crisis.
Hum Pakistani fazool chezen hi dekhe nhe aisi quality content ni dekhte hum , ye views dekh lo is podcast pr 🥺🥺
Recently Chaman Border has also been captured by the Taliban and they hosted their flag there.
pakistan shouldn't expect amrullah saleh and others to use words sensibly.. after Pakistan's prime minister used words like , pogrom, ethnic cleansing, nuclear war, false flag operation, RSS , hindutva etc etc etc...
@Sick Beats why would we take them... you created the problem .. you face the burden... we gave aid to Afghanistan.. we supported democracy, you supported anarchy and sharia,. so you face the burden.. without Pakistans help taliban is nothing
@Sick Beats okay.. World created them in past... but now its pakistan thats in control... and bring it on send them to kahsmir.. we'll kill every trespasser... and don't worry they will create ruccus in Pakistan also.. remember APC... av to chini mar diye...
@@rishabhpatel2051so you are saying that america aur NATO jaisay powerful country pakistani backed taliban se haar gaye?? Bro baat karte hue 10 baar socha karo kya bol rahe ho copy paste nahi kiya karo plzz
@@rishabhpatel2051 agar Pakistan jo aik ghareeb aur 3rd world country hai aur wo taliban ko support kar raha hai to kya america afg army aur nds ko support nahi kar raha?? How can pakistan support can be enough against whole nato+usa+afg army???
@@naajfanaajfa5415 nato har nhi gya bhai .. aaj k World me haar jeet nhi hoti bhai . battle of perception hai bs... agar us chahta to pura mitti me mila deta Afghanistan aur pakistan ko.. per wo time gya bhai ab...
Why not tell Pakistani government to stop supporting und exporting terrorists to Afghanistan ?
Please bring Raja Zia ul Haq
Geopolitics
sir ye bias hone ka jo reason ap de rahe ke pro afghans ko pakistan ki achi side nhi dekhti bs taliban wali baat par baat karte tu ye same chiz tu america bhi karta ha tu kya america thik ha ? kya america ne mulko me civil war or illegal attack nhi kiye jisko compensate karne ke lie wo waha education centers khulwate or aids provide karte
chako marke toffe dena kesa compensation ha or agr sahi bhi man le isko tu kis se puch ke ye compensation deal hui ?
Purvaj hindu the inke aur baadshahoo ki aulaad 😂😂
Pakistan was in a Good Ship America.. What is ur condition right now
politics ke baare me aam awam se puchna or kuch acha logical jawab ki umeed hona kisi mazak se kam nhi or ye baaat apko bhi pata ha tu unse puch karke ap khud ko dhoka de rahe ya lsiteners ko