[POLL] DID WE GET IT RIGHT? What'd you guys think of the music video, as well as Jolin Tsai as an artist? Btw there's some like super hardcore riddle behind this whole video as well! Check the description (There's no english translation right now unfortunately though :( ) LET US KNOW WHAT YOU THOUGHT! AS WELL AS SUGGESTIONS FOR FUTURE VIDEOS!
I’ll say yes , she is my favorite female artist .For Taiwan artists, I’ve only watch her concert before. I think one of the main reason why she is so attractive is her attitude , how she treat her job , the true story about how she learn dance and work so hard until now . Just love her so muchhhh 🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤
"She's someone who challenges the status quo." I like the way you guys see her as an artist. You guys are awesome. Love your reaction 😁❤️ 你們的反應視頻真的很有趣，還有些心得、想法的交換，超讚的👍
Actually there are a puzzle game before the official uploads the music video...So the winners got the chance to go to the premiere day！你們可以去看看那個解密遊戲的介紹。在Jolin Tsai的官方頻道！
Guys plz watch 玫瑰少年Womxnly MV from Jolin!!! It’s the best song from Ugly Beauty this album. It’s a real, sad but extremely touching story from a Taiwanese boy, and they expressed it by dances. Extremely beautiful 😢I’ll be looking forward for you guys new videos 😍
蔡依林是华语乐坛的天后，她独自扛起了华语舞曲大旗！因为有她，华语舞曲才可以达到跟欧美舞曲并齐的位置。最关键的是，她出道二十年一直都如此劳模形象，她出的音乐跟mv还是现场live show每次都是诚意满满，她的作品更堪称华语最优质量的，这也是我们为何如此爱她的原因，说她是21世纪到目前，cpop最长红的女歌手都不为过。个人推荐play我呸（2015Mama颁奖典礼现场)、迷幻、I'm not yours及不一样又怎样mv.感谢up主
That is the magic of Jolin, no mater what, you get interested in her music, and the plot twist is that she will always surprise you. I hope you react to a lot of her old music videos cuz she is amazing!! I love you guys!
I remember in one of the behind the scene video, the mv director explained the use of the colour red and white in the whole mv, it is actually used to portray a wedding that resembles a funeral.
I love when the body is shown the second time it match-cuts to Jolin, because she's "losing her head to violence" and blinded to murder by her jealous rage... 😍 I'm sure there's so much symbolism+double meaning in the lyrics too if I knew what the characters read (red, lol).
The moment I saw her with the blood on her face looking into the mirror I guessed what happened already but I love it when directors gives you clues/foreshadowing before the big reveal. Your banter/reactions are so funny. I feel 10 years younger watching your vids hahaha
guys imagine who didn't been spoiled at the beginning, they can, even more, enjoy the MV as u do too! 【Ugly Beauty】is an album about psychology, she tries to dig deeper of our dark & negativity thoughts,so each song in the album is probing different subjects, like this song is talking about Jealousy, embrace ur darker self , is fine not always be the goodie,the team also plays around with words, and show in the MV, like "green-eyed", why couldn't Red-eyed ,it also means jealousy in mandarin, had A LOT hidden meanings in just 4mins MV! omg...
[POLL] DID WE GET IT RIGHT? What'd you guys think of the music video, as well as Jolin Tsai as an artist? Btw there's some like super hardcore riddle behind this whole video as well! Check the description (There's no english translation right now unfortunately though :( ) LET US KNOW WHAT YOU THOUGHT! AS WELL AS SUGGESTIONS FOR FUTURE VIDEOS!
Ok, I'm sorry for being annoying but how is it possible, that the video was posted 1 hour ago, but this comment was written 7 hours ago?? 😶
這部MV的導演是台灣很有名的恐怖片的導演
所以這MV像電影一樣厲害
I’ll say yes , she is my favorite female artist .For Taiwan artists, I’ve only watch her concert before. I think one of the main reason why she is so attractive is her attitude , how she treat her job , the true story about how she learn dance and work so hard until now . Just love her so muchhhh 🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤
pls react to blackpink kill this love
Jolin說：「我自己非常喜歡紅色
紅色它有一種力量存在
紅色是血液 是熱情 是傷口
是生命的起源 是我們不能缺少的東西
我在跟製作人溝通編曲的時候說：
「我要一個鬼故事的感覺」
因為當你要走進你內心最泥濘的地方
其實是有一點痛苦的
是一種沒有人來救你的 鬼魅的感覺」
左邊那位的講解完全正確~~太棒了!!
而且還很帥XD
陳安 我個人覺得右邊的比較帥～哈哈😄
@@JJ-jm7nu 都不錯😏😏😏
@@麥龍 是的~沒錯
因为他是天蝎座，😂
她是一位創新，改變，努力的天后
恐怖
謝謝你們一次就看懂了
因為其他UA-cam根本有看沒有懂
只是單純覺得恐怖而已
哈哈哈哈真的一堆youtuber 尤其一些女youtuber 只會在那伊伊阿阿 根本只是為了打上蔡依林三個字騙騙點閱率
點進去真的直搖頭
母湯母湯==
+1
@@zyc0618 真的，來騙台灣人點閱率，尤其是某國人(韓國←我小聲說)
贊成，不過也不排除他們聽不懂的原因吧😂😂😂
張凌宇 我記得這次有打各國的語言翻譯上去，結果還是一堆看不懂的（噓🤫其中不乏認識繁體中文的台灣人）不知道是沒有在看恐怖片還是連貫理解的反應差😂
這部MV的導演是台灣很有名的恐怖片的導演
所以這MV像電影一樣厲害
哈哈哈你們三位太可愛了
看完MV後的討論和反應好精彩
我要給你們一個讚，你們一次就看懂了MV
丈夫進來房間時，Jolin已經看到好友跟丈夫kiss了，因為當時她手裡握著好友遺漏的髮飾了。以時間點是好友先來新房看Jolin,後來撞見兩人背叛她,回到房間後,新郎進來,jolin才這麼排斥不想被碰觸。
原来是这样！！！好奇怪
对，是倒叙的。是在你来了，和朋友落下发簪出去密会丈夫被发现后的中间插入了丈夫回来强暴她的片段，也是因为又被背叛又被强暴，才彻底激怒了她
還有 在那年代 新婚前做 女生超級無敵可憐 洞房花燭夜就被那麼草率QAQ
@@hcpan6538
MV開始時的“前一晚”，是指丈夫早晨醒來的前一天晚上。
古字「婚」同「昏」，婚禮大多是傍晚舉行，小S的角色可能是閨蜜、玩伴，但明顯家境不如蔡依林家，甚至可能是從小養在蔡家，如友如僕的貼身女侍(因為她服侍蔡沐浴)，所以表面親和、內心嫉妒。(升米恩、斗米仇)
整個順序應該是
1、拜堂後蔡被送入洞房(新郎在外敬酒)
2、小S到新房探新娘(此時新娘頭紗未掀)並遺落髮釵(也可能是小S故意為之)
3、蔡想歸還髮釵而離開新房，因而撞見小S和新郎有私情(小S故意使其知情)
4、蔡震驚、生氣，新郎酒醉被送回新房(蔡握著髮釵、頭紗已掀開)並暴力行房
5、新郎事後昏睡，小S服侍沐浴，蔡質問小S，小S一副「你的丈夫是我施捨給你的」的態度(我真覺得小S是故意的，因為被質問時，她並不驚慌，回答也有一吐怨氣的感覺)。
6、蔡要求小S穿婚衣，從浴缸中拿出斧頭，行兇後嫁禍給新郎。
最後我認為蔡披斗篷是隱蔽行蹤的意思，歸還髮釵和看丈夫行刑時都是。
以上是我的解讀。
@@mindyc.9945 我知道壓 我的意思是女主很可憐而已
題目"lady in red" red在中國代表喜慶 也有愛情與熱情的意思，但同樣代表著戰爭 危險 慾望 權利 。我在想它說的 lady in red 因該就是說明一個lady 她的“ red ”的變化
達魯啊坦乏伊露蓁 推
在此應該是浴血中的女孩！
"She's someone who challenges the status quo." I like the way you guys see her as an artist. You guys are awesome. Love your reaction 😁❤️
你們的反應視頻真的很有趣，還有些心得、想法的交換，超讚的👍
你們對蔡依林的红衣女孩有甚麼感受? 甚麼反應?
Actually there are a puzzle game before the official uploads the music video...So the winners got the chance to go to the premiere day！你們可以去看看那個解密遊戲的介紹。在Jolin Tsai的官方頻道！
CantoMando 可以看她這張專輯其他首MV！這張專輯目前有5首MV！
這首MV有嚇到😂
Jolin 的團隊 特地找來 擅長 台灣驚悚電影導演 - #程偉豪 來製作這支MV。
利用 倒敘法 並 打破時間軸 的方式拍攝，讓 粉絲們 猜測真正的兇手是誰？
我不得不說，這支MV 的 設計美學很棒、戲劇張力十足、讓人感到後座力很強！！
#自MV播出後我已經看了不下30遍了。
#最愛背景全白的人頭雙眼染血怒吼 及 #蔡依林被血噴到頸部的畫面。
#原本以為 #染紅雙眼吶喊的白人頭 是 #CG動畫，但卻是由 #真人演出。
▲時間順序是這樣：
(影片一開始) 被栽贓殺死老婆的新郎，被眾人抓走，驚恐的他，於是開始回想昨晚所發生的事....
新郎或許是因為門當戶對的關係吧，所以，仍假意示愛的選擇跟Jolin 結婚，但其實，
早就跟 新娘 - Jolin 的 閨蜜 - 小S 有染....於是，他一直喝著悶酒、想讓自己喝醉(失去理智)。
(另外一幕) Jolin 在結婚當天，小S 來新娘房找JOLIN談心，後來小S 被叫出去，
Jolin 發現以前送給 小S 的 髮髻，小S 竟忘了、落放在她床上，於是披著紅袍拿著髮簪要還給小S
(但其實是 小S 故意放的，才會有後面 浴缸那場戲中的那句：這次"#換我施捨給你" 的對白)。
然後，Jolin 出去庭院時，剛好看見 小S 跟 新郎 接吻這一幕....Jolin回到了新娘房間，
感到悲傷和背叛、並驚魂未定的模樣，此時，醉酒的新郎進來，想要洞房 Jolin 卻拒絕，
所以，就粗暴地強奸了他的新娘 - Jolin。喝醉酒的新郎 在這之後，就睡得不省人事，
當 小S 幫助 Jolin 清理時，Jolin 在浴室跟 小S 攤牌。這時，小S 的回答 讓 Jolin 決定殺死他們。
Jolin 騙 小S 去試穿新娘的衣服，把斧頭藏在浴缸裡，切掉 小S 的頭，然後把斧頭放在新郎手上，
嫁禍並誣陷他，讓他去斷頭台。
這樣，Jolin 就可以讓每個人都認為，她的新郎殺死了Jolin。
然而，事實是，Jolin 還活著，背叛她的兩個人已經死了。
#我必須稱讚你們很聰明立刻就猜到了兇手. (*￣▽￣)/‧☆*"`'*-.,_,.-'`"-.,_☆
Guys plz watch 玫瑰少年Womxnly MV from Jolin!!! It’s the best song from Ugly Beauty this album. It’s a real, sad but extremely touching story from a Taiwanese boy, and they expressed it by dances. Extremely beautiful 😢I’ll be looking forward for you guys new videos 😍
Please do a reaction to jolin's "Womxnly", it's a touching song!
Mizmu 好可愛！ 謝謝妳們喜歡蔡依林！ 她與其他歌手不同的地方是再歌曲的表達不再是襯托自己美或者一些華服與厲害的東西來襯托自己，他要告訴各位她想表達每首歌的含義例如怪美的（不要在意別人眼光與自己和解放過自己）紅衣女孩（待妳的好不求感謝，但妳卻反咬一口只好對你反擊）把社會會遇到的真實事件做成歌曲表達出來，她不是單純的一位歌手，而且一個藝術家把歌曲，故事，MV提高到一個境界！ 感謝亞洲市場還有Jolin！ My Queen!
請一定要看看蔡依林的新歌mv
玫瑰少年 womxnly ！
這是一個真實故事來自一位叫 葉永誌 的小男孩
歡迎google他的故事，或直接找蔡依林為了他做的影片
這是一首很有意義的歌
ua-cam.com/video/V_M9ZId2QAY/v-deo.html
影片在這~~~
100% agree😭🧡
是 葉永"鋕"喔~
Jin Min Tsai 在搭之前 《不一樣又怎樣》MV一起看
kao雪珠 沒錯沒錯！是一起的
蔡依林是华语乐坛的天后，她独自扛起了华语舞曲大旗！因为有她，华语舞曲才可以达到跟欧美舞曲并齐的位置。最关键的是，她出道二十年一直都如此劳模形象，她出的音乐跟mv还是现场live show每次都是诚意满满，她的作品更堪称华语最优质量的，这也是我们为何如此爱她的原因，说她是21世纪到目前，cpop最长红的女歌手都不为过。个人推荐play我呸（2015Mama颁奖典礼现场)、迷幻、I'm not yours及不一样又怎样mv.感谢up主
這是我看過最棒的Reaction 沒有之一👍👍👍
That is the magic of Jolin, no mater what, you get interested in her music, and the plot twist is that she will always surprise you. I hope you react to a lot of her old music videos cuz she is amazing!! I love you guys!
蔡依林Jolin❤的音樂是如此多元，自由，台灣的音樂很多元🎉
左边小哥最先反应过来的 哈哈
感覺他最聰明 哈哈
LOL "is that liquid nitrogen?" *ignored*
Lmaooo
that’s dry ice lol. Liquid nitrogen is like -78 Celsius degree...
Yubo Xu dry ice is as freezing as liquid nitrogen too lol
太喜歡你們三個的反應了
These 3 guys are just so cute. The one on the left is the brain guy, and the other two are cute, cooking up the atmosphere.
Everyone: waowww that’s spooky
Mike: *is that liquid nitrogen?*
這是我看過最棒的reaction video了！！！（非常真實的反應 一點都不做作👍👍👍👍）
你們可以觀看Jolin的最新MV《愛的羅曼死Romance》，也是同一個導演唷
jolin is the queen! you are so cute! thank you for your reaction!
比任何时候都更认真的3位小盆友在讨论剧情😂😂😂莫名觉得可爱
蔡依林一直都是我們亞洲的驕傲
謝謝你們3人喜歡這個MV ！
I remember in one of the behind the scene video, the mv director explained the use of the colour red and white in the whole mv, it is actually used to portray a wedding that resembles a funeral.
紅色通常表示喜慶/婚禮/戰爭/血腥，白色通常表示葬禮/純潔，還有一種白底紅喜字傳統上用於冥婚，這邊用於暗喻婚事的不祥。另外在台灣的民間故事裡，穿紅衣服的女孩死亡後會從冥界回來向她的仇人復仇，所以在歌名裡就已經提示了女性的復仇
Eleungg is a clever boy hahaha and plz react to more Jolin like womaxly, play, I’m not yours, fantasy, the great artist...
Jolin! 😍 终于等到你还好我没放弃
I love when the body is shown the second time it match-cuts to Jolin, because she's "losing her head to violence" and blinded to murder by her jealous rage... 😍
I'm sure there's so much symbolism+double meaning in the lyrics too if I knew what the characters read (red, lol).
蔡依林真的太屌了
看完馬上訂閱，你們的反應真的太可愛了❤而且你們超認真的在解讀歌跟mv想表達的內容，一次就看懂也很厲害😂
這才是我想看到的影片阿，那些看完mv後只會說歌好聽mv好看的youtuber根本無法跟你們比
Watched this and Jolin Tsai's Lady in red as soon as it posted
真的很像看了一部電影👍
Edward is like not saying anything or reacting, and then it was his favorite reaction..,DOPE
Jolin Tsai is one of my favourite C-Pop singers :3 I love her new song so much. I loved playing her all songs when I lived in Taiwan ^O^
左邊的超聰明哈哈哈哈
其實顏色的部分有點反了😂
傳統上紅色除了是血的顏色之外，在中華地區是婚禮的顏色
白色是喪禮的顏色
跟歐美是反得
這個好像是外國人在看這個MV 的時候，一開始不會感覺到違和感的原因😂（所以後面也會嚇得比較慘
你說錯了一點，西方喪禮的代表顏色是黑色、婚禮是白色（包含日本），並沒有跟華人的紅白兩色相反。
反倒是我看了一部戲，你們的反應實在是太可愛，又太真實了
Jolin's Mv show us a full story within 4 minutes consists of horror/suspense/esthetic/poetic, I must give Jolin a big thumb up, well done !
三位男孩很聰明的把MV的劇情解說出來 我的感覺是:人一出生就要面臨種種競爭. 小時候搶你玩具的隔壁男孩. 上學後同班或某班課業上的競爭同學. 出社會後在工作上或事業上競爭的同僚或業者. 愛情裡出現競爭者或第三者等等...這些人在當下或許會對你造成一些傷害 但真正會傷到你痛不欲生的人 反而是你最愛的人或是親人.....(個人體悟 切勿筆戰)
JOLIN TSAI IS ALWAYS MY QUEEENNNNN!!!
很喜歡妳們把蔡女神的MV講解的這麽好！
你们好棒👍🏻第一次就看懂了视频内容！
Does anyone like the way Sheldon explains everything with so much passion ?😆♥
TOP REACTION! Jolin Tsai is my fave Chinese artist!
i find it so adorable when they get excited/hyper about any vids they react to😊😊!
You know what 5/15Jolin's Ugly Beauty is nominated for seven Golden Melody Awards this year.
You guys are pure cuteness
YESSSS I LOVE THESE REACTIONS
超級愛你們講評的，很自然
Like this reaction video soooooo much. I realized I didn't get what the story until now.
These three boys made me watch her videos ... 💕💕💕
The thing is....why didn’t u guys recognize Elephant Dee 小S😂😂😂😂
I recognized her
他們也太可愛
Edward is getting everything so quickly!! Haha~
Nice reaction video! dude~
The moment I saw her with the blood on her face looking into the mirror I guessed what happened already but I love it when directors gives you clues/foreshadowing before the big reveal. Your banter/reactions are so funny. I feel 10 years younger watching your vids hahaha
Good analysis Edward!
I have seen the mv beforehand but didnt bother to solve the mystery behind it
Mike and Sheldon saying "HOLY SHIIIT!!!" in sync is literally me after watching this MV🙈
MOOD👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
Yesh!!! More reaction!!!! Yay!!!
you should react to 蔡依林Jolin Tsai - I'm Not Yours Feat. 安室奈美惠NAMIE AMURO as well!
我！的！天！我真的超级喜欢你们三个哈哈哈哈哈哈
" Is that liquid nitrogen? " .... Who would bathe in liquid nitrogen ... I like how you discuss the plot carefully, you are great
yo thats why they say dont mess with scorpio ... look at how edward is a genius who figured out it so quick DARK my brader dark
Love Jolin ^^
超愛看你們reaction 的影片！有顏值口才也很好😂
喜欢你们三个哈哈哈哈
我愛蔡依林
Queen jolin, only she dares to make mv like this, stan!!
Lol I know you guys will have those reactions HAHA. I love this mv so much! I appreciate it. : )
Edward's eyes...though . 💗💗💗💗💗💗
Honestly, I am feeling lucky to watch this mv in your video, known as "together" with you guys... otherwise, I guess I should have nightmare... lol
你們三個的反應好可愛！
Omg this is by far my favorite reaction video of all time!!! I’m hoping that you guys can react on sweet guilty pleasure from Jolin too!!
You three are so cute!
guys imagine who didn't been spoiled at the beginning, they can, even more, enjoy the MV as u do too!
【Ugly Beauty】is an album about psychology, she tries to dig deeper of our dark & negativity thoughts,so each song in the album is probing different subjects, like this song is talking about Jealousy, embrace ur darker self , is fine not always be the goodie,the team also plays around with words, and show in the MV, like "green-eyed", why couldn't Red-eyed ,it also means jealousy in mandarin, had A LOT hidden meanings in just 4mins MV! omg...
你們的反應很真誠也有趣哈哈哈
I love her.
因為解說了這個影片，我訂閱了，真的是看得非常認真👍
Found you guys from this video and now I’ve spent the last 3 days watching all of your videos lmao
哈哈哈，你们太可爱了吧！
dannng that's such a good mv
Your profile pic 😑
Kinda says it different
jessica ArmyBlink 😅 I swear I’m not being sarcastic haha
I have watched this my so many times and I love it. The plot is amazing 😍
Jolinnnnnn Tsaiiiiii~~~❤️❤️
I knew Jolin Tsai always have a created ways of music ! We watch this together
最左邊的最帥了😏反應也很好，最後我笑了，這意味著我吻著他....不，老兄，你不要吻我😆😂🤣
i was so confused when i saw her mv lmao thanks for clearing it up
and im usually good with video theories :""") i was lost af
中間一度三隻都好安靜🤣好認真🤣
很棒的視頻 比起其他根本沒有想理解 只想騙點閱率的影片…
我很期待你們下次的觀看💓💓
超級推薦 蔡依琳的 不一樣又怎樣 ~ ！！！！
哈哈哈 你們超可愛的！
希望你们也可以去看蔡依林的之前专辑的MV play我呸 和 I'm not your 还有蔡依林在HONG KONG MAMA的表演
That's actually a good music video and you guys did a really good reaction as well. I also wow when you realize what's going on in the story!!!
Such a great review great job guys
I LOVE JOLIN TSAI
Very enjoy your post. Thanks
我第一次看是張著嘴巴看完的，看了第二次才看懂女二說把丈夫還給女主是什麼意思，左邊那位居然一次就看懂了，厲害！！
miz真的推理太强了！
完完全全跟我第一次看推理的一模一样
整個反映下來我對"holy sh*t"印象最深XDDDD 但很喜歡妳們的反應哈哈哈哈!!!