Who's Geoffrey part about Thomas' lie being payed off in Lost Treasure was cut from the video, I didn't feel it really added to the overall plot, but I've see quite a few people mention it, so I thought I would just acknowledge that!
You can also possibly throw Thomas and the Babysitter before the events of lost Treasure since you can see Daisy working on Thomas’ branchline prior to working at harwick 🤔
Just goes to show how clever Brenner was with his writing. Even if some of his eps aren't that great imo, it's nice to see him weaving all these different episodes into one cohesive plot
Bro this is the kind of shit I LIVE for, continuity in shows that don’t usually have it that prominently really tickles my brain. I would LOVEEE to see you try and work out S21, JBS and S22, I don’t think it’s actually that hard now I think about it, maybe I’m wrong though idk lmao Such a good video mate!
When it's put in a more subtle way, it was like a giant movie. JBS and S21 though, that continuity is all out of place (and it's mostly due to the show now being a yearly-released property since 2002/03).
@thesudriana016 it's definitely it's best when it's more subtle. That way it feels episodic but still carrys nice continuity Oh titan yeah JBS and S21s continuity was an absolute nightmare
This was such an interesting and mind-blowing timeline! I had no idea these events connected together like this and I find it so intriguing! After seeing this, I feel like it makes A LOT more sense as to why Sir Topham Hatt was so angry at Thomas. For one thing, in 'Who's Geoffrey', Thomas lies and makes a big mess of things, another thing is that Sir Topham Hatt must've been so overwhelmed with all of these engines out of service or away that he had to buy 2 new engines. It just makes more sense now and I really enjoyed watching this! Amazing job!
S19 is honestly a underrated season. Yes, it has flaws like Henry is a scaredy-cat in his S19 episodes and a few bad episodes. But animation is much better as the animation from S13-18 and S22-S24. It has a lot of good or even great episodes. We learn new sides for characters like Edward , Cranky and Salty. Even James has his moments in this season.
Yh I'm so glad someone said it I swear only unlucky tug talked about it and he said it perfectly,the animation was at it's peak and we get to learn so much about the side characters Caitlin is self conscious about her skirt, den and dart have separation anxiety, cranky covers up his mistakes, salty is horrified of the sea Timothy works really well at the docks,victor has a strong hatred for the snow and the episodes just aren't talked about enough I mean look at snow place like home does anyone ever talk about it.
You’re video on the timeline for season 19 is 🤯, fantastic job & I thought all at sea & no help at all are the only two episodes that are connected. But you sure found more of that & I agree with you that sir toppen hat purchase Philip after legends lost of the treasure. Well done 👍🏻👏👏👏
Woah, there is so much I have to say about this video! Firstly, I 100% agree with S19 being one of the best CGI seasons. It makes my top 10 seasons list for sure. Secondly, man this timeline is more complex than I thought. I thought I was a genius for understanding the references in NHAA, but I didn't expect THIS much continuity! This timeline analysis rivals Unlucky Tug's timeline vids on all of the eras, an-maith!
Great video Adam! Even though S19 is my least favorite of the Brenner seasons, there's still some solid gems in it, and I'm glad you made this. Seeing how much forethought went into this season by Brenner & Co. really makes me appreciate how smart things were handled back then in the writers room, and makes me appreciate S19 a lot more.
In the case of this era, least favourite isn’t saying a lot.😛No Help At All is a super fun episode, with great character combos, a fun musical montage and of course this batch of continuity.
The most confusing part of the “Emily is at the Steamworks” part is that she was also at the Steamworks in “Snow Place Like Home”, which is also a series 19 episode. Does Snow Place Like Home happen at the tail end of winter, and Salty all at Sea at the start of spring? That could be the reference as well. Also, Salty was in Lost Treasure which makes this even more confusing…
i swear on EVERYTHING every 45 seconds, a new detail was explained and every single time you BLEW MY MIND. These all seem so obvious in retrospect, but as an average veiwer of these eps, i NEVER picked up on ANY of this/ WELL F'ING DONE!!!
I do like season 19 and I did realize that things like Salty all at sea and no help at all being on the same day in a way. Or how James referenced Arlesburg. And well I technically knew about this in a way I didn't realize how much more there really was to it. Season 20 will always be my favorite of the CGI seasons but I think this comes pretty close. And the fact that all the stuff was able to be woven together like a sweater is impressive. Now all we have to do is wait for someone to put all the episodes and special in chronological order lol. Fantastic job with this video Adam keep up the good work and have a Happy New Year!
Really great video! I always loved and had a soft spot for Season 19, mostly because it was the newest season when I got back into watching Thomas & Friends again after stopping for several years.
I think STH's office was blown up before SLOTLT as all of his equipment including his phone seem to be unharmed and not even damaged (9:21) I have a hard time believing dynamite would go off in a small office like that and not damaging anything
Grasshopper Baked Alaska Ingredients: 1/2 cup butter, cubed 2 ounces unsweetened chocolate 1 cup sugar 1 teaspoon vanilla extract 2 large eggs, room temperature 3/4 cup all-purpose flour 1/2 teaspoon baking powder 1/2 teaspoon salt 2 quarts vanilla ice cream, softened 1 package (4.67 ounces) mint Andes candies, chopped 2 tablespoons creme de menthe 1 tablespoon creme de cacao Green food coloring, optional MERINGUE: 8 large egg whites 1 cup sugar 1 teaspoon cream of tartar Directions: 1. In a microwave-safe bowl, melt butter and chocolate; stir until smooth. Stir in sugar. Beat in vanilla and eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition. Combine flour, baking powder and salt; stir into chocolate mixture. 2. Transfer to a greased 8-in. round baking pan. Bake at 350° for 30-35 minutes or until a toothpick inserted in the center comes out with moist crumbs (do not overbake). Cool for 10 minutes before removing from pan to a wire rack to cool completely. 3. Meanwhile, in a large bowl, combine the ice cream, Andes candies, liqueurs and, if desired, food coloring. Transfer to an 8-in. round bowl (1-1/2 qt.) lined with plastic wrap; freeze until set. 4. In a large heavy saucepan, combine the egg whites, sugar and cream of tartar. With a hand mixer, beat on low speed for 1 minute. Continue beating over low heat until egg mixture reaches 160°, about 8 minutes. Transfer to a bowl; beat until stiff glossy peaks form and sugar is dissolved. 5. Place brownie on an ungreased foil-lined baking sheet; top with inverted ice cream mold. Remove plastic wrap. Immediately spread meringue over ice cream, sealing to edge of brownie. Freeze until ready to serve, up to 24 hours. 6. Bake at 400° for 2-5 minutes or until meringue is lightly browned, or use a kitchen torch to carefully toast the meringue. Transfer to a serving plate; serve immediately. Also, to stay on topic, I like the part where the time was lined.
Loved the video Adam! There was something i think you missed, I'm pretty sure in no help at all there is a "We make a team together" motif when salty and porter arrive at the clay pits to help. i feel like that would have also been some foreshadowing to SLOTLT! all in all I loved the video. you did an awesome job on piecing it together!
I remember when these episodes came out and I tried to piece the events together myself. But I never factored in SLOTLT. Now that you've pointed all this out, I don't think any of us can't see them now. 'And then Philip arrives on Sodor' Unfortunately...
I'm generally skeptical about claims of TVS continuity and such, but you convinced me about the James/Arlesburgh and the construction materials/Brendam connections
People actually forgot about this? How many people actually remembered from the start? Wow, some are more ignorant of the Brenner era than I thought. Series 19 is so good and I easily forgave and got over some of the flaws. Justice for worried Henry.
And I thought David Mitton's map of Sodor in the Classic Series was complicated but interesting to understand, but even that was amazing yet confusing to learn about S19 and Lost Treasure. The part where you mentioned Sam Wilkinson's statement about the production team being sick and frustrated how each season keeps spoiling the movies before and after their initial releases does explain these weird/set up and payoff continuity stuff regards to the animation or events. Truth be told I can understand where he was coming from given how each new season was aired first before the events of each new movie released in the same year occurred which often gives confusion and spoilers to younger viewers about the new locations and characters (then again, Shining Time Station also had the same problem when airing the Thomas episodes such as Two Old Hands for example, am I right?). At the same time, all of these things up until JBS kinda throws every event off when the latter and S21 had a massive continuity problem until BWBA somehow fixes all that (minus the Thomas traveling around the world and back on Sodor issue). Then again, even the Railway Series is not strictly perfect within its continuity like Stanley (No. 2) being turned into a pumping engine in 1928 even when Duke mentioned the events that happened PRIOR to Stuart and Falcon a few years later after they arrived on the railway (even that illustration error in Bulldog's second page shows that). I guess you can say writing a series of talking trains is not all easy when continuity is the most top priority to keep consistent with, but can also cause such a headache to try and piece together.
Well, I must say, that is a fascinating video of the Season 19 timeline with the episodes and Sodor's Legend of the Lost Treasure. A bit puzzling but very great. Also, I think Philip would be at the other shunting yards during the crash scene off screen since his episodes are before the special, I'm sure of it. Overall, you're very impressive at these kind of stuff. Keep up the good work for the new year.
Thanks for explaining some of Series 19's confusing mess. I'm in the midst of working on a proper CGI timeline that includes every single episode from this era, so having at least some things cleared up can definitely help fix some things up. And hey, maybe I could help with the possibility of fixing up the Series 21 timeline. It's been a mind boggle for me, which is why I started working on the timeline in the first place. That, and how Henry is the main protagonist for the CGI era, but that's a different can of worms.
You forgot something unless I missed it. Who's Geoffrey has Thomas lie. In SLOTLT Thomas lies again and Sir Topham Hatt is really mad. That episode could explain it and give reason to any fans who argue he is out of character by being too angry.
That is interesting and I think Season 19 is a good series and hearing you say that these episodes take place during the same time, you can say like these episodes take place in Real Time. Andrew Brenner is one of the best Thomas writers that the show had and I can see what he was doing.
I think that goodbye fat controller takes place before lost treasure because the tnt would have most likely damaged most if not all the stuff in sir Topham's office and also because it's ironic/funny but hey that's just a theory a Film Theory thanks for reading
I noticed how some episodes had been taking place over each other more specifically Salty all at see and No help at all but I'm now kicking myself for not realizing more of this
Can i have a list of all the episodes (and special) in order?? im looking to watch all of the seasons in order and ive come up to s19 so i would like to know :) (time order like this vid)
I think you should do a video about what type of real life steam locomotives does each character look like the most. I know that the Sodor Island Book explains what class of engine each character is and most of the illustrations of the characters in The Railway Series look like their actual basis but characters like Thomas, Edward, James, and Percy don’t really look like their actual basis. This is just a suggestion but I would really like it if you could make a video about it.
Awesome video! Adam this is why Emily at the steamworks which was a reference to best engine ever and Mavis at the dieselworks which was a reference to Den and Dart and Salty being sent to the mainland which was a reference to Salty all at sea 🌊 and also In no help at all sir topham hatt mentioned about getting a new engine I honestly don't know if this engine sir topham hatt's mentioned is Ryan or Philip because Philip is a new character for season 19 but in sodors legend of the lost treasure thomas was the station 🚉 pilot after the accident sir topham hatt had brought Philip and also in best engine ever James said that he was going down the harwich branch line and also Marion was going down the coast to the new branch line
But how could the crash with the coaches happen after “lost treasure”? Because that crash directly led to Thomas working on the construction of the new branch line, which led into the whole story
What was meant by “a few days later” in Best Engine Ever? I’d also say that that episode’s intro might have been from earlier when the Vicarstown Bridge was functional
If I am being honest I think it goes like this Toad and the Whale, Phillip Arrives, The next day Phillip to the rescue Sir Topham Hatt's office gets redesigned and the strike happens (Conicendially it got blown up 3 days later) Salty All at Sea, Best Engine Ever (beginning) Den & Dart (Beginning), No Help at All (Beginning) Sodor's Legend of The Lost Treasure (Day 1)/Best Engine Ever rest of the episode) Then the docks get busy again and Timothy comers to help out.Thomas goes to the Harwick Branchline, Mavis comes back, Salty Come Back (This explains how he is there the next morning in lost treasure, Thomas meets Sailor John, Then he finds the treasure then later the chase then the end of SLOTLT. However that is just me and it is completly fine to have a different interpatation on it.
This might not be too in depth, but I heard Series 12 had a rather consistent timeline. For example, ‘Arry and Bert being at the works after being crashed in Don’t Go Back. This probably isn’t in depth enough to warrant a video, but maybe a quick short. What do you think?
But in Snow Place like Home Emily is still at the steam works and it's winter so how many accidents/troubles did she have? I mean its says in Snow place like home shes waiting for new Pistons which looked like what her reasoning for her being took to the steamworks as the crew are scene working on her while she waited for Caitlin
Can you do the timeline of seasons 1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16,17,18,20,21,22,23,24 and your cgi season 25 like in your video on what happened next please
Goodbye, Sir Topham Hatt being after Lost Treasure because Sir Tophatt's office was blown up is not 100% working for me. When I think of the aftermath of STH's office being blown up, I think of his office being decimated and not really fit for work, but in Goodbye Sir Topham Hatt, Topham is seen working in his office and during the Sir Topham Hatt Song montage we see Topham looking out his office window at James, showing that the wall Sailor John blew up is fine. Perhaps workmen rebuilt Sir Topham Hatt's office after the explosion from Sailor John, but it was a bit of a rushed job and wasn't 100% to Topham's liking, so he decided to have the office properly redecorated during the events of Goodbye Sir Topham. Or the episode takes place before Sodor's Legend of the Lost Treasure, idk. Besides that, most other things presented in this video work for me. Good job piecing this all together.
honestly why was Thomas even shunting gordon’s train in the first place he’s no longer station pilot for knapford ever since thomas and the breakdown train.
I think his sir Toppom hats 🎩 office was redecorated before SLOTLT because all his stuff is in tact. If it was blow up wouldn’t it all be destroyed? And wouldn’t the engines know that?
Who's Geoffrey part about Thomas' lie being payed off in Lost Treasure was cut from the video, I didn't feel it really added to the overall plot, but I've see quite a few people mention it, so I thought I would just acknowledge that!
Seen nearly all the episodes including the movie and I never realized that
What was the part about Who's Geoffrey that was paid off??
Nice job and I'm a huge fan
@@exeggutivejudge3747 thomas lying
Thomas making silly excuses to escape being blamed @@exeggutivejudge3747
Great video! Some of these setups I never caught before. Nice editing, too!
Oh hello there
100% Agreed
You're vids are great
Yup
Season 19 must've been one hell of a week for topham
No wonder he was so mad at Thomas in SLOTLT...
You can also possibly throw Thomas and the Babysitter before the events of lost Treasure since you can see Daisy working on Thomas’ branchline prior to working at harwick 🤔
Someone screwed up there XD
Just goes to show how clever Brenner was with his writing. Even if some of his eps aren't that great imo, it's nice to see him weaving all these different episodes into one cohesive plot
You know how slotlt and tgr were about thomas regaining sth trust and appreciating himself
Now I would love to see someone Actully make this all into a movie with all the episodes cutting back and forth.
Bro this is the kind of shit I LIVE for, continuity in shows that don’t usually have it that prominently really tickles my brain.
I would LOVEEE to see you try and work out S21, JBS and S22, I don’t think it’s actually that hard now I think about it, maybe I’m wrong though idk lmao
Such a good video mate!
I love how S19 has this continuity. I wish we got more like this in later seasons and movies
When it's put in a more subtle way, it was like a giant movie.
JBS and S21 though, that continuity is all out of place (and it's mostly due to the show now being a yearly-released property since 2002/03).
@thesudriana016 it's definitely it's best when it's more subtle. That way it feels episodic but still carrys nice continuity
Oh titan yeah JBS and S21s continuity was an absolute nightmare
disgusting pfp@@amitysluzara2022
The consistency in this season is absolutely insane
This was such an interesting and mind-blowing timeline! I had no idea these events connected together like this and I find it so intriguing! After seeing this, I feel like it makes A LOT more sense as to why Sir Topham Hatt was so angry at Thomas. For one thing, in 'Who's Geoffrey', Thomas lies and makes a big mess of things, another thing is that Sir Topham Hatt must've been so overwhelmed with all of these engines out of service or away that he had to buy 2 new engines. It just makes more sense now and I really enjoyed watching this! Amazing job!
Now I REALLY wanna see someone combine ALL of these episodes and SLOTLT
Maybe a supercut of it probably does exist out there.
Officially my favorite Thomas Theorist video of 2023! One of, if not the, best year you’ve had man!
S19 is honestly a underrated season. Yes, it has flaws like Henry is a scaredy-cat in his S19 episodes and a few bad episodes. But animation is much better as the animation from S13-18 and S22-S24. It has a lot of good or even great episodes. We learn new sides for characters like Edward , Cranky and Salty. Even James has his moments in this season.
Ngl season 19 is MUCH better than season 17 and 18 if you ask me
@@wishbonefanyour totally right there
@@wishbonefan fr
Yh I'm so glad someone said it I swear only unlucky tug talked about it and he said it perfectly,the animation was at it's peak and we get to learn so much about the side characters Caitlin is self conscious about her skirt, den and dart have separation anxiety, cranky covers up his mistakes, salty is horrified of the sea Timothy works really well at the docks,victor has a strong hatred for the snow and the episodes just aren't talked about enough I mean look at snow place like home does anyone ever talk about it.
You’re video on the timeline for season 19 is 🤯, fantastic job & I thought all at sea & no help at all are the only two episodes that are connected. But you sure found more of that & I agree with you that sir toppen hat purchase Philip after legends lost of the treasure. Well done 👍🏻👏👏👏
Woah, there is so much I have to say about this video!
Firstly, I 100% agree with S19 being one of the best CGI seasons. It makes my top 10 seasons list for sure.
Secondly, man this timeline is more complex than I thought. I thought I was a genius for understanding the references in NHAA, but I didn't expect THIS much continuity!
This timeline analysis rivals Unlucky Tug's timeline vids on all of the eras, an-maith!
This complex timeline continuity of these episodes just downright brilliant! I couldn’t believe I never noticed it before.
I didn’t even know this season’s continuity was so tight and planned but man it’s gonna make my rewatch all the more interesting
Great video Adam!
Even though S19 is my least favorite of the Brenner seasons, there's still some solid gems in it, and I'm glad you made this. Seeing how much forethought went into this season by Brenner & Co. really makes me appreciate how smart things were handled back then in the writers room, and makes me appreciate S19 a lot more.
In the case of this era, least favourite isn’t saying a lot.😛No Help At All is a super fun episode, with great character combos, a fun musical montage and of course this batch of continuity.
The most confusing part of the “Emily is at the Steamworks” part is that she was also at the Steamworks in “Snow Place Like Home”, which is also a series 19 episode. Does Snow Place Like Home happen at the tail end of winter, and Salty all at Sea at the start of spring? That could be the reference as well.
Also, Salty was in Lost Treasure which makes this even more confusing…
Adam your mind scares me with how deep your thoughts go...
and I love it. reminds me of what me and my friends do.
This is insane, you have officially become a mad man
i swear on EVERYTHING every 45 seconds, a new detail was explained and every single time you BLEW MY MIND. These all seem so obvious in retrospect, but as an average veiwer of these eps, i NEVER picked up on ANY of this/ WELL F'ING DONE!!!
I do like season 19 and I did realize that things like Salty all at sea and no help at all being on the same day in a way. Or how James referenced Arlesburg. And well I technically knew about this in a way I didn't realize how much more there really was to it. Season 20 will always be my favorite of the CGI seasons but I think this comes pretty close. And the fact that all the stuff was able to be woven together like a sweater is impressive. Now all we have to do is wait for someone to put all the episodes and special in chronological order lol. Fantastic job with this video Adam keep up the good work and have a Happy New Year!
Incredibly tight continuity. The writers were masters with that. Would love to see a full series timeline
My head hurts, but that is so freakin coool! the brenner era truly is the best renaissance of thomas and friends!
Really great video! I always loved and had a soft spot for Season 19, mostly because it was the newest season when I got back into watching Thomas & Friends again after stopping for several years.
I think STH's office was blown up before SLOTLT as all of his equipment including his phone seem to be unharmed and not even damaged (9:21) I have a hard time believing dynamite would go off in a small office like that and not damaging anything
You're say STH's office was blown up before the events of SLOTLT, have you ever thought what and who blew up his office
This is one of the reasons why Season 19 is my favorite season.
Grasshopper Baked Alaska
Ingredients:
1/2 cup butter, cubed
2 ounces unsweetened chocolate
1 cup sugar
1 teaspoon vanilla extract
2 large eggs, room temperature
3/4 cup all-purpose flour
1/2 teaspoon baking powder
1/2 teaspoon salt
2 quarts vanilla ice cream, softened
1 package (4.67 ounces) mint Andes candies, chopped
2 tablespoons creme de menthe
1 tablespoon creme de cacao
Green food coloring, optional
MERINGUE:
8 large egg whites
1 cup sugar
1 teaspoon cream of tartar
Directions:
1. In a microwave-safe bowl, melt butter and chocolate; stir until smooth. Stir in sugar. Beat in vanilla and eggs, 1 at a time, beating well after each addition. Combine flour, baking powder and salt; stir into chocolate mixture.
2. Transfer to a greased 8-in. round baking pan. Bake at 350° for 30-35 minutes or until a toothpick inserted in the center comes out with moist crumbs (do not overbake). Cool for 10 minutes before removing from pan to a wire rack to cool completely.
3. Meanwhile, in a large bowl, combine the ice cream, Andes candies, liqueurs and, if desired, food coloring. Transfer to an 8-in. round bowl (1-1/2 qt.) lined with plastic wrap; freeze until set.
4. In a large heavy saucepan, combine the egg whites, sugar and cream of tartar. With a hand mixer, beat on low speed for 1 minute. Continue beating over low heat until egg mixture reaches 160°, about 8 minutes. Transfer to a bowl; beat until stiff glossy peaks form and sugar is dissolved.
5. Place brownie on an ungreased foil-lined baking sheet; top with inverted ice cream mold. Remove plastic wrap. Immediately spread meringue over ice cream, sealing to edge of brownie. Freeze until ready to serve, up to 24 hours.
6. Bake at 400° for 2-5 minutes or until meringue is lightly browned, or use a kitchen torch to carefully toast the meringue. Transfer to a serving plate; serve immediately.
Also, to stay on topic, I like the part where the time was lined.
WHAT ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT ALSO WHERE ARE MY KEYS
You’re 100 years too early to challenge me for your keys.
"Oh yeah. It's all coming together." - Kronk 2000
This timeline sure is fun!
Loved the video Adam! There was something i think you missed, I'm pretty sure in no help at all there is a "We make a team together" motif when salty and porter arrive at the clay pits to help. i feel like that would have also been some foreshadowing to SLOTLT! all in all I loved the video. you did an awesome job on piecing it together!
13:03
Oh shoot, i can’t believe i missed that little bit of text on screen. Thanks for pointing that out!
Ok this is awesome, I never realized most of this
This video was a nice birthday present for me.
Happy Birthday 🎂
I remember when these episodes came out and I tried to piece the events together myself. But I never factored in SLOTLT. Now that you've pointed all this out, I don't think any of us can't see them now.
'And then Philip arrives on Sodor' Unfortunately...
I feel like the reason people didnt realise this is because the episodes of this season are strangely really hard to get access to
Great video, keep going😊
The fact that you make this make sense is amazing
Amazing video man, would love to see you do the same with S21, JBS & S22
I’m never gonna see S19 the same way again, aren’t I?
Season 19 sure has an interesting timeline
I'm generally skeptical about claims of TVS continuity and such, but you convinced me about the James/Arlesburgh and the construction materials/Brendam connections
i love how bil and ben are just goofy shunting at knapford
People actually forgot about this? How many people actually remembered from the start? Wow, some are more ignorant of the Brenner era than I thought. Series 19 is so good and I easily forgave and got over some of the flaws. Justice for worried Henry.
And I thought David Mitton's map of Sodor in the Classic Series was complicated but interesting to understand, but even that was amazing yet confusing to learn about S19 and Lost Treasure.
The part where you mentioned Sam Wilkinson's statement about the production team being sick and frustrated how each season keeps spoiling the movies before and after their initial releases does explain these weird/set up and payoff continuity stuff regards to the animation or events. Truth be told I can understand where he was coming from given how each new season was aired first before the events of each new movie released in the same year occurred which often gives confusion and spoilers to younger viewers about the new locations and characters (then again, Shining Time Station also had the same problem when airing the Thomas episodes such as Two Old Hands for example, am I right?). At the same time, all of these things up until JBS kinda throws every event off when the latter and S21 had a massive continuity problem until BWBA somehow fixes all that (minus the Thomas traveling around the world and back on Sodor issue).
Then again, even the Railway Series is not strictly perfect within its continuity like Stanley (No. 2) being turned into a pumping engine in 1928 even when Duke mentioned the events that happened PRIOR to Stuart and Falcon a few years later after they arrived on the railway (even that illustration error in Bulldog's second page shows that). I guess you can say writing a series of talking trains is not all easy when continuity is the most top priority to keep consistent with, but can also cause such a headache to try and piece together.
IM SO EXCITED OMG
What a good timeline video.
*timeline
"Wibbly wobbly, timey-wimey....stuff"
- Doctor Who
Such clever writing
3:11 Marion shunting looks so cursed to me
Brilliant and really interesting video! Would love to see the series 21 analysis :)
Well, I must say, that is a fascinating video of the Season 19 timeline with the episodes and Sodor's Legend of the Lost Treasure. A bit puzzling but very great. Also, I think Philip would be at the other shunting yards during the crash scene off screen since his episodes are before the special, I'm sure of it. Overall, you're very impressive at these kind of stuff. Keep up the good work for the new year.
Thanks for explaining some of Series 19's confusing mess. I'm in the midst of working on a proper CGI timeline that includes every single episode from this era, so having at least some things cleared up can definitely help fix some things up. And hey, maybe I could help with the possibility of fixing up the Series 21 timeline. It's been a mind boggle for me, which is why I started working on the timeline in the first place. That, and how Henry is the main protagonist for the CGI era, but that's a different can of worms.
The season three parallels all over again
It makes sense, but what a damn coincidence.
It was a busy day
So much to learn 9in Thomas and friends video. Even as huge Thomas and friend fan.
You forgot something unless I missed it. Who's Geoffrey has Thomas lie. In SLOTLT Thomas lies again and Sir Topham Hatt is really mad. That episode could explain it and give reason to any fans who argue he is out of character by being too angry.
This is almost as crazy as The Theorizer's Pixar timeline.
That is interesting and I think Season 19 is a good series and hearing you say that these episodes take place during the same time, you can say like these episodes take place in Real Time. Andrew Brenner is one of the best Thomas writers that the show had and I can see what he was doing.
I think that goodbye fat controller takes place before lost treasure because the tnt would have most likely damaged most if not all the stuff in sir Topham's office and also because it's ironic/funny but hey
that's just a theory
a Film Theory thanks for reading
This is something that is great for a timeline video
confusing but amazing
I noticed how some episodes had been taking place over each other more specifically Salty all at see and No help at all but I'm now kicking myself for not realizing more of this
Can i have a list of all the episodes (and special) in order??
im looking to watch all of the seasons in order and ive come up to s19 so i would like to know :)
(time order like this vid)
You’d kind of have to cut them up into a big movie, which gives me an idea…
Check my community tab! A timeline is on there!
oh my god thank you so much! @@ThomasTheorist
Can you ask Sam W how he feels about the fandoms thoughts of his map?
I am already watching it
This is like the storm arc in season 7 (correct me if I'm wrong) but bigger
I think you should do a video about what type of real life steam locomotives does each character look like the most. I know that the Sodor Island Book explains what class of engine each character is and most of the illustrations of the characters in The Railway Series look like their actual basis but characters like Thomas, Edward, James, and Percy don’t really look like their actual basis. This is just a suggestion but I would really like it if you could make a video about it.
I don't know whether to call this insanity or genius.
Awesome video! Adam this is why Emily at the steamworks which was a reference to best engine ever and Mavis at the dieselworks which was a reference to Den and Dart and Salty being sent to the mainland which was a reference to Salty all at sea 🌊 and also In no help at all sir topham hatt mentioned about getting a new engine I honestly don't know if this engine sir topham hatt's mentioned is Ryan or Philip because Philip is a new character for season 19 but in sodors legend of the lost treasure thomas was the station 🚉 pilot after the accident sir topham hatt had brought Philip and also in best engine ever James said that he was going down the harwich branch line and also Marion was going down the coast to the new branch line
But how could the crash with the coaches happen after “lost treasure”? Because that crash directly led to Thomas working on the construction of the new branch line, which led into the whole story
Bill and Ben nocking a truck of the track was very naughty
will you make a headcanon lore rambeling/facts siries about your own headcanon?
What was meant by “a few days later” in Best Engine Ever? I’d also say that that episode’s intro might have been from earlier when the Vicarstown Bridge was functional
I was lost at 6-7 mins
No break for sir topham hat “bother that telephone…”
Can you do the great discovery next?
Thats clever i didnt even think about the episode and the movie being connected
I wish there was a chronological year Thomas and and friends
When’s your Chuggington video coming?
Confirmed my mind is blown.
If I am being honest I think it goes like this Toad and the Whale, Phillip Arrives, The next day Phillip to the rescue Sir Topham Hatt's office gets redesigned and the strike happens (Conicendially it got blown up 3 days later) Salty All at Sea, Best Engine Ever (beginning) Den & Dart (Beginning), No Help at All (Beginning) Sodor's Legend of The Lost Treasure (Day 1)/Best Engine Ever rest of the episode) Then the docks get busy again and Timothy comers to help out.Thomas goes to the Harwick Branchline, Mavis comes back, Salty Come Back (This explains how he is there the next morning in lost treasure, Thomas meets Sailor John, Then he finds the treasure then later the chase then the end of SLOTLT.
However that is just me and it is completly fine to have a different interpatation on it.
This might not be too in depth, but I heard Series 12 had a rather consistent timeline. For example, ‘Arry and Bert being at the works after being crashed in Don’t Go Back. This probably isn’t in depth enough to warrant a video, but maybe a quick short. What do you think?
We need the S21 timeline!
But in Snow Place like Home Emily is still at the steam works and it's winter so how many accidents/troubles did she have? I mean its says in Snow place like home shes waiting for new Pistons which looked like what her reasoning for her being took to the steamworks as the crew are scene working on her while she waited for Caitlin
Good times.
Someone needs to put a video out there that is all of these episodes minus SLOTLT in real time
9:10 more funny let stick with that one lol
Thomas theorist next video is how the railway series stories were thought
And I like to know Donna Douglas and Emily family tree
*Donald
I like to know is about thomas he family tree
there is none lol
@@Mr.NeilOfficialwelp, that’s sad…
Can you do the timeline of seasons 1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16,17,18,20,21,22,23,24 and your cgi season 25 like in your video on what happened next please
It makes sense I just can't repeat it.
And they still manage to run a railway
Goodbye, Sir Topham Hatt being after Lost Treasure because Sir Tophatt's office was blown up is not 100% working for me. When I think of the aftermath of STH's office being blown up, I think of his office being decimated and not really fit for work, but in Goodbye Sir Topham Hatt, Topham is seen working in his office and during the Sir Topham Hatt Song montage we see Topham looking out his office window at James, showing that the wall Sailor John blew up is fine.
Perhaps workmen rebuilt Sir Topham Hatt's office after the explosion from Sailor John, but it was a bit of a rushed job and wasn't 100% to Topham's liking, so he decided to have the office properly redecorated during the events of Goodbye Sir Topham. Or the episode takes place before Sodor's Legend of the Lost Treasure, idk.
Besides that, most other things presented in this video work for me. Good job piecing this all together.
Hi
honestly why was Thomas even shunting gordon’s train in the first place he’s no longer station pilot for knapford ever since thomas and the breakdown train.
Thomas has appeared shunting Gordon’s coaches plenty of times since season 3 and nobody bats an eye there. My guess is this was a rare occasion.
I think his sir Toppom hats 🎩 office was redecorated before SLOTLT because all his stuff is in tact. If it was blow up wouldn’t it all be destroyed? And wouldn’t the engines know that?
Just know but don’t know wat season. There was like 5 episode that take place in movie
Season 19 is a good season, it just has a couple of crappy episodes
Too much focus on the Steam Team and not enough focus on returnees as well.