Which Guide Is Better? Wings of Fire Dragon World vs Warrior Cats Ultimate Guide
Вставка
- Опубліковано 23 січ 2024
- Long story short:
Wings of Fire
By a long shot.
🐾🐾🐾
FAQ
Editing software: Vegas Pro 17, Camtasia 2021
Drawing/Animation Software: Clip Studio Paint, Opentoonz
Thumbnail editor: Photopea, Sketchbook
🐾🐾🐾
Twitter🐾 / 5rcane
Tumblr🐾www.tumblr.com/blog/5rcane
Wattpad🐾www.wattpad.com/user/5rcane
Instagram🐾 / rogan_4rcane
Discord🐾 4rcane#9513
TikTok🐾 vm.tiktok.com/ZSeurHLYM/
Reddit🐾 / 5rcane
🐾🐾🐾
Please do not reupload my works on any other sites, claim it as your own, or if an art piece trace it for any purposes other than education. My animations are allowed in tributes and other compilations though please ask for permission beforehand.
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use. - Фільми й анімація
In my opinion, the AGDW is better by a long shot. It contains so much new information on the tribes, characters, objects and events, and the Warriors Guide just doesn't have that. The Warriors Guide is a mistake-riddled reprint, while the WoF Guide is a new masterpiece! Praise for AGDW!!!!
Yeah, and it even shows how smolder interacted with rose/flower. The warriors guide is mire like a guide to the characters.
would it just be AGDW?
@@BotanRice yeah but that would be a guide dragon world i think-
@@Sillies009 yeah but when doing abbreviations you don’t use “to” and “the”
@@BotanRice true
i've read both, i def like the wings of fire guide more, i think its a more enjoyable guide, it reads like a story, but the warriors one isn't really a story, it just is listing their life. only 1 thing was 'new', the other stories where in the old guide. the wings of fire guide- i liked most things about it
Alternative title: Dissing the warrior cat guide book
The Warrior Cats guide is more informative. But there's a high chance that the information in it will be false, forgotten or retconned by the books themselves.
At least with WoF, you know that the lore is consistent; and any changes will have an in-story explanation.
It's already pretty full of mistakes on release, imagine what time'll do to it
In the dragon guide, I was a little disappointed that the scorching and 'legend of the hive' segments were rather plain and seemed more like a copy-paste of what was already given in earlier books. Obviously it makes sense in canon as these things were so long ago and there wouldn't be many, if any, surviving records from then. But, still, I didn't really like them.
The only real 'new' information we get is that rainwings and seawings were among the refugees to Pantala, who then either get wiped out by the breath of evil, return home, or are so few in number that their bloodlines get subsumed by the other two tribes... Like how technically Sunny is part icewing and a distant relative of Prince Winter, on account of having animus dragons in her family tree..
I what to pet the birds to also yes humans are the size on dragons spoons.. wait so dragon's also have cup,plates wait i wonder if dragons have wine..beer etc.. Because man scarlet would be having that stuff
Your videos make me so happy during the week, it really gives me something to look forward to when you post. Thank you for continuing to improve and for making awesome content! I don’t think I’ve skipped a video from you since I found your channel:)
I haven't bought either but I'll probably end up buying the WoF one. I just can't get past the errors in the Warriors one, it's ridiculous. Plus, the art is uninspired. Other countries get such wonderful art for their Warriors books!
Warriors seems like they need a good editor to look over their books. Even the main series books are filled with errors (and some just simple spelling errors that could easily be fixed by anybody). CARE about your books writing team, PLEASE.
AGREED. and the wof guide will definitely be worth your money!
@@Scytalis it looks gorgeous, I'm definitely getting it
6:01 THE BOOK OF CLEARSIGHT INTRODUCED WHAT?
Yep. Krakens are confirmed to be a species in this world. With hall the dragons, I'm not that suprised
@@tabbystar2011DO THEY DO ANYTHING COOL?
I wholeheartedly agree! AGDW is so much better and the fact that it's CHEAPER is wild to me. This inspired me to go read AGDW again, it really is so fun to read which is something I absolutely cannot say for the warrior's guide.
I haven’t bought either book yet, but I’m thinking that I may get A Guide to the Dragon World after hearing people’s opinions. I have a hard time justifying buying supplemental material for book series (that’s why I stopped buying the wof graphic novels) but if it’s mostly new content, I’m interested.
I have both the guide to the dragon world and the warriors ultimate guide(which, fun fact, I was given after reading BOOK ONE of the series. Never in all my time reading the books or being in the fandom have I been unable to read any content without foreknowledge of what will happen), so this was fun to see! Wings of fire for the win :3
I've only read the WoF guide, and after having been hyped up for a year I found it kinda underwhelming. Like, it wasn't bad, but it was a lot shorter and more condensed than I was expecting. And while the expanded lore was nice it sorta came off more as a handful of anecdotes.
That being said, I've been following the fandom on and off for nearly a decade and am almost certainly outside of the target demographic by now.
I love the wings of fire guide
Faxxx
Hello 4rcane, how are you doing?
Brave mother 39
Hallo!
"Qora qunduz 41"
Pin plz
Warriors and wings of fire!?!?! Both my fav books 😊but I was really mad that wings of fire won. I guess it’s probably better (I’ve never read the wings of fire one) but I just love warriors so much better. I would give wings of fire a 8/10 but I would give warriors a 9.5/10 so I’m kinda mad
Wings of Fire it better
What is it with people and wings of fire I don’t get it. The book series literally get so boring after you finished half of them
The books actually get very interesting and if you have only read half of them your missing out by a long shot I do love warrior cats to but mabey try reading all the books then stating your opinions on the internet
The first two arcs are actually quite solid and are good reads, it’s just the third arc that is more flawed but even then it’s not that bad
Personally, I really love WoF, and if you don't that's alright.
What I like is there's moments where you can feel that one mistake a character makes could potentially harm many dragons. The writing style for the series is quality and the events of the series are paced very well.
Some gimmicks are really cool, like the idea of animus dragons, mind control, and the Eye of Onyx.
I've been following WoF off and on for almost a decade now. I've seen both the best and worst it has to offer and the bottom line is: it's a fun teen fantasy series with well written leads in an immersive world that does a decent job of combining character development with the plot. And it has a lot of thought-provoking ideas buried below the surface.
It does have its fair share of issues though. My main grievance is the author's tendency to get tunnel vision. It's not so bad in individual books, but when you step back and look at the bigger picture, the tone and pacing is a little inconsistent between installments and cross-book subplots are left without proper build-up/payoff sometimes.
But overall I think it's a pretty decent series whose parts are better than the whole.
@@pyronuke4768Oh yes, I completely agree with you! I love wings of fire so much though, I'm so glad this series was recommended to me. It's not for everyone but I've loved the hell out of it for years and I'm in love with Tui's writing. I love how she makes nearly every pov unique and her characters and how she develops them are brilliant. I can always read her books over and over again and never get bored (other than the third arc, that is). I've probably read Darkstalker over 20 times and it's still such a thrilling book!