Funny thing is that they uploaded the explainer on Albedo before they talked about making an explainer about it in this video. Neil Tyson is a freakin Dr. Who
That's the result of quantum communication between quarks. They can communicate instantaneously across unlimited distances. Their idea of the explainer was immediately communicated to quarks which were to come into existence at a future moment. Or... They uploaded the wrong clip at the wrong time. But I like my flawed hypothesis a little more. lol
Chuck (out of completely NOWHERE): "Stereopsys!" Neil (completely ignoring what was probably the smartest, quickest thing Chuck has EVER said):"Yeah, yeah, yeah..So..." Lolol...Poor Chuck!! Lolol
"Just stand on Earth...You're in space." USSR : So you conned us into space race ? USA : So we did not lie that those photos were from space Neil deGrasse Tyson enter the chat : Let me make a StarTalk on this topic Yuri Gagarin left the chat NASA left the chat
Could you do a video debunking the hollow moon theory? I think that'd be really interesting, also, I bet a title about the hollow moon would be catchy enough to get a lot of views.
The chemistry between Chuck and Neil is magical. Chuck is the kind of guy I'd love to have as a friend -- very intelligent and very funny. And of course Neil is just awesome.
Neil is wrong! So in the video Neil says there’s no blood moon anymore. The earth’s sky is much clearer. Then what have we seen today?! November 8th - blood moon as it is! Either Neil is wrong or help me understand what’s happening anyone please.
I would have to agree with you on that one. He's definitely picking up a lot from Neil and some of the guests. I imagine he is probably doing more research on his own and of course that's just speculation. Either way... Love em both. Dr Neil deGrasse Tyson is or should say he was the catalyst the inspiration for me to get back into astronomy physics and everything quantum. I love it. Confusing a fair amount of the time but I love it.
I wonder what Neil would call a Blood Moon if he could rename them? 🌙🤔 Also, what do moons with thicker atmospheres and different surface structures/materials look like from other planets? Awesome episode btw, I was thinking about this just the other night while taking a walk after dinner, cheers!
I was told the horizon illusion is because we perceive the sky (incorrectly) as a disk. Our eyes tell us the sky near the horizon is farther away than the sky overhead, so the moon looks closer by comparison.
Grab a paper. Whenever the moon is up in the sky, make a hole of its size. Whenever the "big" moon arises, it will feel like it will exceed the margins of the paper. Place the paper in front of it. It will magically shrink and perfectly fit the small paper hole. Mind blown.
This explains why back in 1980 after the eruption of Mount St. Helen we had the most brilliantly red/orange sunsets all the way down South in Louisiana. I haven't seen anything like that since.
The face on chuck when Neil tells him to put his head between his legs and look at the moon… You know he’s thinking “and I’m the crazy one pretending to carry an airplane through the sky,”
I can't say I have ever experienced the horizon moon illusion. The moon has always looked the same size to me for my whole life. When people talked about the moon looking larger at some times when I was a child it really confused me.
where i live, it definitely (appears) to start off large and then get smaller as it rises.. have you ever seen moon pics from say Africa? where the moon can look Enormous!
I keep saying this to people too. Funny to see them confused. Then when I explain we all stand in an xyz coordinate in space, it just has an atmosphere because we are standing on earth, the give me the grunt and the eye hahaha
Hate to admit this.. but I never knew who chuck was before getting with Neil 😅 but I want to see him do stand up comedy so bad it's unreal 🤣😂🤣 absolutely hilarious
I once saw an orange moon on Halloweeen some time in the late '90s. I called it the pumpkin moon. Then I remembered that it was supposed to have a face (I've never seen the man in the moon) and quickly changed it to the jack-o-lantern moon.
I try beating Chuck in answering science questions but I'll admit he has answered more and faster than I can. I don't feel bad after watching his standup. Both men are worthy of my admiration for their brilliance.
Neil deGrasse Tyson, Thank you so much for this video! I would love to know more about craters and marias. (I do not believe in young earth), but I read recently that some who believe in a young earth argue that marias are proof that the moon is not billions of years old because it would have craters everywhere without an atmosphere to protect it. I'd love to hear your thoughts.
For ancient cultures, there would be a very deeply red blood moon and it would be mysterious and menacing when there was a very large volcanic eruption somewhere around the world at least in the same hemisphere if not the same latitude within a few months before the blood moon. Given the jet stream in the northern and southern hemisphere, the exact latitude would not necessarily be a critical part of that effect. The volcanic dust particles in the atmosphere would cause a lot of pollution in the atmosphere causing a very prominent blood moon. As an ancient people, one might postulate that the volcanic eruption was interrelated with the moon bleeding and being a sign that "the gods" where angry or telling one group of people to go to war with another neighbouring group of people. All kinds of superstitious beliefs arose from natural phenomenon being miss interpreted simply because they didn't have the knowledge to truly understand what they were seeing.
After watching this I googled moon on the horizon photos. Flipping the photos upside down didn’t change my perception of it size in relation with its surroundings. How is this illusion affected by looking at the moon via photography? Thanks.
My dad as a pilot told me that the red moon/ sun was from forest fires in our area. And a big white ring in the sky around the moon meant it would snow the next day. Or at least be cold enough to snow.
I witnessed a perfect lunar eclipse in '94. I expected to see the shadow slowly cover, but the Moon instead got redder as time passed, but became almost entirely black. There was only just enough light to make it appear as a umbral orb in the sky. It was truly a marvel to behold.
Neil. I read Carl Sagan's Demon Haunted World (Science as a Candle in the Dark) in 1996. It changed my life, yet The Baloney Detection kit did not Emphasize the "Excluded Middle" with enough precidence. It's profound within the Context of Language.
Love all the explainer videos, but I was kinda hoping to hear about how and why the Moon only ever shows us one side of itself...I've heard it before, but it never seems to stick in my ancient brain...
Wow. I enjoy this. To imagine everyone sharing an illusion seems wild, especially, with no drugs involved...& while seeing the sky, from between one knees, as we bend forward, & look. BaddaBing! Thank you!
"The full moon in June stays low in the sky and it holds on to sunset sort of amber colour which takes a look of a kind of honey colour. So, of all the moons of the year and they all have names, the name of the full moon in June is HONEY MOON" ~Neil Tyson
So say, for instance, the moon-on-horizon is taking up the same width (in my vision) as a nearby building... and then I look at the moon while I'm upsidedown... does the moon miraculously take up less space in my vision?
I really love star talk and what you teach Neil but isn't the apparent distance hypothesis in relation to the moon illusion still just one of many theories? I have become a little fascinated by this as there seems to be no absolute answer to the moon illusion...is this true?
My name is Yoshikage Kira. I'm 33 years old. My house is in the northeast section of Morioh, where all the villas are, and I am not married. I work as an employee for the Kame Yu department stores, and I get home every day by 8 PM at the latest. I don't smoke, but I occasionally drink. I'm in bed by 11 PM, and make sure I get eight hours of sleep, no matter what. After having a glass of warm milk and doing about twenty minutes of stretches before going to bed, I usually have no problems sleeping until morning. Just like a baby, I wake up without any fatigue or stress in the morning. I was told there were no issues at my last check-up. I'm trying to explain that I'm a person who wishes to live a very quiet life. I take care not to trouble myself with any enemies, like winning and losing, that would cause me to lose sleep at night. That is how I deal with society, and I know that is what brings me happiness. Although, if I were to fight I wouldn't lose to anyone.
That’s incredible, I love where I can see the ocean and I still get those huge moons. Does even having other reference points in your Peripheral vision cause that effect?
I do remember a night in july riding in the James Bay road at full moon it was so bright that I could drive with out any light we could see almost like in day light.
I will say, it's really something watching the moon right before a lunar eclipse. Just watching the shadow move backwards until it's almost blocked, and then it lights up again when it's almost covered, in this lovely red. I think the one I saw was the strawberry moon? It was only slightly pink but it was still very pretty
Question: Is the moons rotation predictable to a point we know what day a full moon will rise from horizon and look super huge? Some days its over here some days its over there some days its in the sky all day
Neil, this is youtube. Take as much time as you need. We love hearing you explain things.
Neil, this is youtube. You may have to explain it several dozen times!
@@nobodyknows3180 lol
neil this is youtube, you forgot to remind us to like and subscribe
Neil this is UA-cam. We will listen for four hours and not blink an eye....44....
@@NoalFarstrider yeah, you're right, we would!
🤪🤪🤪🤪
Please do a video on the Doppler Effect & Cosmic Red Shift
In Sheldon's words:
"It's the apparent change in the frequency of a wave caused by relative motion between the source of the wave and the observer."
Yes that would be a nice Video
@@carultch That's pretty interesting , I would love to see Neil and Chuck do video on that.
Yes I would love to see a startalk episode on the doppler effect too
Neil has a viral meme of him demonstrating the Doppler effect
Star talk is about the only thing left in media that I have come to appreciate for its entertainment AND educational value. We love star talk
Imagine hanging out, cracking jokes and at the same time learning science with Neil each and every week. Aaah, Dream Job!!!
"Wanna go to space?..just stay on earth.. the earth is in space "
My little Spaceship lol...
Neil should do live streams in which he simply lectures on different scientific topics. I would bet he could attract a very large audience.
I could watch this all day
me too
Blood Moon: happens every few nights, and it’s when all the monsters you’ve defeated get resurrected by Calamity Ganon’s powers
My thoughts exactly. 😆
As well as felled trees, fruits, and other such items. Ganon's magic may be powerful but it's not terribly precise in what comes back.
I was waiting for that reference. :P
Hahahaha
Zelda!
"No, you didn't. You only thought it was big."
That's what she... oh wait.
This is the best middle school Friday special you could ever provide. You would learn more every Friday than the whole week combined.
After getting a BS in Physics its still amazing how in each of these videos I learn atleast one thing new or interesting
Funny thing is that they uploaded the explainer on Albedo before they talked about making an explainer about it in this video. Neil Tyson is a freakin Dr. Who
Yoo its all coming together
That's the result of quantum communication between quarks. They can communicate instantaneously across unlimited distances. Their idea of the explainer was immediately communicated to quarks which were to come into existence at a future moment.
Or... They uploaded the wrong clip at the wrong time. But I like my flawed hypothesis a little more. lol
Am I imagining explainer videos, or did one about albedo already happen recently?
This was recorded before the albedo video
This was what I was thinking.
ua-cam.com/video/pJ0GQYiBg_U/v-deo.html
I was questioning the same thing
they uploaded the albedo vid before this which is weird. and also Neil said the Blood Moon topic is actually for their next video. weird lol
Chuck, you're amazing! Still child at heart!
Chuck (out of completely NOWHERE): "Stereopsys!"
Neil (completely ignoring what was probably the smartest, quickest thing Chuck has EVER said):"Yeah, yeah, yeah..So..."
Lolol...Poor Chuck!! Lolol
Neil did acknowledge by saying "right"
I think chuck is getting smarter every time he does a episode with Neil 💡
Fun way to learn imo
I am as well
Hahaha, I think your right about that.
I actually knew most of this. But always enjoy the two . In my youth some people in my neighborhood, said a blood moon meant a war was coming .
it means zombie horde night
A 3 mana enchantment that turns all nonbasic lands into mountains. Easy next question
😂😂😂
🎵 It's Magic, you knowww! Never believe it's not sooooo🎵
A card that shuts the whales down. It is beautiful when someone plays dual/fetch/pain lands right into a bloodmoon.
Are we talking Terraria here?
@@marcus.thoren no magic the gathering
"Just stand on Earth...You're in space."
USSR : So you conned us into space race ?
USA : So we did not lie that those photos were from space
Neil deGrasse Tyson enter the chat : Let me make a StarTalk on this topic
Yuri Gagarin left the chat
NASA left the chat
So many jokes all in one.
You, my friend, are a genius.
@@Li01018 you are so right......
Oh wow! I never thought about that from the moon's perspective. A lunar eclipse, if are watching from the moon is a solar eclipse. That's pretty cool.
It’s crazy I’m 33 now and this is what i like to watch…y couldn’t I have this same energy in high school😔
Neil saying "full frontal", was totally a free joke ticket that chuck just totally missed XD
Could you do a video debunking the hollow moon theory? I think that'd be really interesting, also, I bet a title about the hollow moon would be catchy enough to get a lot of views.
4:56 This conversation went n a very strange direction. 🤣 🌝
Kudos to Chuck for maintaining a straight face.
and the ending lol
The chemistry between Chuck and Neil is magical.
Chuck is the kind of guy I'd love to have as a friend -- very intelligent and very funny. And of course Neil is just awesome.
Great explanation. Please do an explainer on the theory of relativity!
Neil is wrong!
So in the video Neil says there’s no blood moon anymore. The earth’s sky is much clearer.
Then what have we seen today?! November 8th - blood moon as it is!
Either Neil is wrong or help me understand what’s happening anyone please.
One of my favorite co-stars 1/3.
•F•O•R• •M•O•R•E• •G•U•I•D•A•N•C•E••
{• W••H••A•T•S••A•P•P!}
{•+ • 4 •4 •7 • 8 • 6 • 8 • 7 • 0 • 6 • 7 • 6 • 4.!}
Is it only me, or does everyone see that Chuck is much more sciency than a few years ago? I feel like we are both learning from Neil 😃
I would have to agree with you on that one. He's definitely picking up a lot from Neil and some of the guests. I imagine he is probably doing more research on his own and of course that's just speculation. Either way... Love em both.
Dr Neil deGrasse Tyson is or should say he was the catalyst the inspiration for me to get back into astronomy physics and everything quantum. I love it. Confusing a fair amount of the time but I love it.
I wonder what Neil would call a Blood Moon if he could rename them? 🌙🤔 Also, what do moons with thicker atmospheres and different surface structures/materials look like from other planets? Awesome episode btw, I was thinking about this just the other night while taking a walk after dinner, cheers!
I was told the horizon illusion is because we perceive the sky (incorrectly) as a disk. Our eyes tell us the sky near the horizon is farther away than the sky overhead, so the moon looks closer by comparison.
guys everywhere now thinking "how can I turn that to my advantage?" :D
since i was a child neil was my idol. that is until i found star talk. now is only chuck. chuck rules everything.
Chuck is the perfect cayenne pepper to go with Nerdy Prof. Neil.. Love them both!!
Excelent! I need this info this past week for an argument
Chuck gets genuinely excited over these facts. It’s so cute! 🎉😂😂
Grab a paper.
Whenever the moon is up in the sky, make a hole of its size.
Whenever the "big" moon arises, it will feel like it will exceed the margins of the paper.
Place the paper in front of it.
It will magically shrink and perfectly fit the small paper hole.
Mind blown.
depending on the distance from your eyes the moon wouldn't always appear to fit the hole
Hi Neil, love your videos very interesting. I hope you never run out of topics. Tell Chuck I said what’s up doesn’t work without him.👍🏽
This explains why back in 1980 after the eruption of Mount St. Helen we had the most brilliantly red/orange sunsets all the way down South in Louisiana. I haven't seen anything like that since.
This channel is an absolute treasure!
A video on the Doppler Effect would be very interesting
I Agree they should definitely do one on the Doppler effect including cosmic red shift
@@JACK-OMARI I know right
@@bandiledube1546 Yeah
Hearing Neil say the word “draws” was surprisingly refreshing. ☺️
10:51 "There's a shadow that's always there"
If it weren't for the moon, we wont appreciate Sun's shadow. Wow!
Fun Fact: Stars cannot cast a shadow, but flames can.
@@MrT------5743 yes I can see it on a candle
The face on chuck when Neil tells him to put his head between his legs and look at the moon…
You know he’s thinking “and I’m the crazy one pretending to carry an airplane through the sky,”
Can you make an explainer about heat lightning? How it’s different from regular lighting. And also lightning you see, but never hear.
I thought he mentioned it in a video.. 🧐
I'm here for the science, but also Chuck's smile... 😍
I can't say I have ever experienced the horizon moon illusion. The moon has always looked the same size to me for my whole life. When people talked about the moon looking larger at some times when I was a child it really confused me.
where i live, it definitely (appears) to start off large and then get smaller as it rises..
have you ever seen moon pics from say Africa? where the moon can look Enormous!
I love this channel. When Neil said " in the summertime" my brain immediately played that Mungo Jerry song.
Hhmm and here I thought that the blood moon is when Madara is attempting to cast the infinite tsukuyomi 🤦 ... oh well
Hahaha I wish more people get this Naruto reference because this is hilarious 😂
So it’s not made of cheese?
It is, don't listen to these crazy people. :)
No, it’s a “Cheese Product” like American cheese and cheese wiz
Mmmm cheese.
@Readaholic I always suspected some such like...
Not made of cheese, that is why we never go back.
"Just stand on Earth...You're in space." ☠️
I keep saying this to people too. Funny to see them confused. Then when I explain we all stand in an xyz coordinate in space, it just has an atmosphere because we are standing on earth, the give me the grunt and the eye hahaha
The saying 'shoot for the moon cause if you miss you will fall amongst the stars'. We are already amongst the stars here on earth.
Ha, yeah. I usually tell people "we don't really know how to be anywhere else" (yet)
phew, at least I don't have to pay $250K just to stand.
@@MrT------5743 hahahaha and "among the stars" is pretty damn desolate and lonely compared to what the saying implies 🤣
One of the only positive programs on social media.
Neil: [says something extremely nerdy and/or pedantic]
Chuck: That is so cool!
The thing I enjoy most in startalk:
The view of the two pictures in Neil's background which are each other's negative!!!!! XD
Chuck is hilarious at 2:09 😂😂😂
Neil is an amazing educator
Hate to admit this.. but I never knew who chuck was before getting with Neil 😅 but I want to see him do stand up comedy so bad it's unreal 🤣😂🤣 absolutely hilarious
I once saw an orange moon on Halloweeen some time in the late '90s. I called it the pumpkin moon. Then I remembered that it was supposed to have a face (I've never seen the man in the moon) and quickly changed it to the jack-o-lantern moon.
I try beating Chuck in answering science questions but I'll admit he has answered more and faster than I can. I don't feel bad after watching his standup.
Both men are worthy of my admiration for their brilliance.
Neil deGrasse Tyson,
Thank you so much for this video! I would love to know more about craters and marias. (I do not believe in young earth), but I read recently that some who believe in a young earth argue that marias are proof that the moon is not billions of years old because it would have craters everywhere without an atmosphere to protect it. I'd love to hear your thoughts.
When they finally set up a research base or something on the moon it will be amazing if they put a lunar eclipse from the moon on youtube
Wow now I feel lucky to have seen several lunar eclipses, the first one was actually a red moon in early to mid 90's.
I still always enjoy watching any lunar eclipse I can.
For ancient cultures, there would be a very deeply red blood moon and it would be mysterious and menacing when there was a very large volcanic eruption somewhere around the world at least in the same hemisphere if not the same latitude within a few months before the blood moon. Given the jet stream in the northern and southern hemisphere, the exact latitude would not necessarily be a critical part of that effect. The volcanic dust particles in the atmosphere would cause a lot of pollution in the atmosphere causing a very prominent blood moon. As an ancient people, one might postulate that the volcanic eruption was interrelated with the moon bleeding and being a sign that "the gods" where angry or telling one group of people to go to war with another neighbouring group of people. All kinds of superstitious beliefs arose from natural phenomenon being miss interpreted simply because they didn't have the knowledge to truly understand what they were seeing.
I truly like those two men out there. By watching their videos one will learn sth and laugh a lot. Great hug from 🇧🇷
After watching this I googled moon on the horizon photos. Flipping the photos upside down didn’t change my perception of it size in relation with its surroundings.
How is this illusion affected by looking at the moon via photography? Thanks.
My dad as a pilot told me that the red moon/ sun was from forest fires in our area. And a big white ring in the sky around the moon meant it would snow the next day. Or at least be cold enough to snow.
I witnessed a perfect lunar eclipse in '94. I expected to see the shadow slowly cover, but the Moon instead got redder as time passed, but became almost entirely black. There was only just enough light to make it appear as a umbral orb in the sky. It was truly a marvel to behold.
I always thought that humidity and the atmosphere were a factor to the size of the moon on the horizon, because it looks so big... so weird
This is standup astrophysics ! You guys are so cool and funny !
When you live in a major US city and actually seeing the horizon is a treat 😥😥😢
Well now I know why I've never seen a blood moon. I was looking for a red moon while seeing an amber moon! Thanks Neil, you've saved my childhood.
My go to sleep videos are you guys!
Thanks for the daily knowledge!! Professor Neil, you’re the best🌖🌌🪐
Yo! Love the show and you guys!
Could we capture the energy from a volcano?
It is already being done in iceland. Seen it in a few documentations.
wikipedia entry: Geothermal power in Iceland
Neil. I read Carl Sagan's Demon Haunted World (Science as a Candle in the Dark) in 1996. It changed my life, yet The Baloney Detection kit did not Emphasize the "Excluded Middle" with enough precidence. It's profound within the Context of Language.
2:10 😂 I haven’t done that but I always imagined Sonic the Hedgehog running along the side of my parents car as I was as in the backseat lol
At 10:52 and 11:01 there's a scream in the background of the video. I thought my kids were tearing each others heads off when I heard it. Lol
Love all the explainer videos, but I was kinda hoping to hear about how and why the Moon only ever shows us one side of itself...I've heard it before, but it never seems to stick in my ancient brain...
Awesome guys. Love it
Funny and deeply informative! The blood moon. I'm blown away! And edumacated.
Wow. I enjoy this. To imagine everyone sharing an illusion seems wild, especially, with no drugs involved...& while seeing the sky, from between one knees, as we bend forward, & look. BaddaBing! Thank you!
"The full moon in June stays low in the sky and it holds on to sunset sort of amber colour which takes a look of a kind of honey colour. So, of all the moons of the year and they all have names, the name of the full moon in June is HONEY MOON"
~Neil Tyson
I love you guys ! National treasure !
So say, for instance, the moon-on-horizon is taking up the same width (in my vision) as a nearby building... and then I look at the moon while I'm upsidedown... does the moon miraculously take up less space in my vision?
I really love star talk and what you teach Neil but isn't the apparent distance hypothesis in relation to the moon illusion still just one of many theories? I have become a little fascinated by this as there seems to be no absolute answer to the moon illusion...is this true?
So friends, just moon the moon to make it stop playing tricks on you! I love it!
My name is Yoshikage Kira. I'm 33 years old. My house is in the northeast section of Morioh, where all the villas are, and I am not married. I work as an employee for the Kame Yu department stores, and I get home every day by 8 PM at the latest. I don't smoke, but I occasionally drink. I'm in bed by 11 PM, and make sure I get eight hours of sleep, no matter what. After having a glass of warm milk and doing about twenty minutes of stretches before going to bed, I usually have no problems sleeping until morning. Just like a baby, I wake up without any fatigue or stress in the morning. I was told there were no issues at my last check-up. I'm trying to explain that I'm a person who wishes to live a very quiet life. I take care not to trouble myself with any enemies, like winning and losing, that would cause me to lose sleep at night. That is how I deal with society, and I know that is what brings me happiness. Although, if I were to fight I wouldn't lose to anyone.
That’s incredible, I love where I can see the ocean and I still get those huge moons. Does even having other reference points in your Peripheral vision cause that effect?
I think certain times of year the moon looks bigger
These explanations are what I didn't know that I needed. Thank you 🙏🏽😉 From Brazil
Chuck actually wrestled the convo away from Neil, nice!
The moon is red (ish) when viewed through the smoke of s large fire.
I do remember a night in july riding in the James Bay road at full moon it was so bright that I could drive with out any light we could see almost like in day light.
“OK, Alright. Moving on, moving on... " - Chuck 2021 I cried
I will say, it's really something watching the moon right before a lunar eclipse. Just watching the shadow move backwards until it's almost blocked, and then it lights up again when it's almost covered, in this lovely red. I think the one I saw was the strawberry moon? It was only slightly pink but it was still very pretty
Just saw a blood moon a couple of weeks ago in NJ, mid July. Nice Amber color. Very cool.
Genuine question when chuck says 'the lack of reference' should the correct way to phrase that be 'relative'?
Chuck is my spirit scientist. I swear his curiosity rubs off on me lol
10:40 “I want to go to space” “Just stay on Earth; Earth is in space” 😂
Question: Is the moons rotation predictable to a point we know what day a full moon will rise from horizon and look super huge? Some days its over here some days its over there some days its in the sky all day
I would like a video that goes more in depth about the blood moon.