Salute you Bab Bhembre,you are a true Goemkar,let us learn from this great personality,YES, never ever insult our Maim Bhas Konkani,Jai Goem ,Jai Konkani Bhas
Absolutely correct. MGP created all this mess. Sudin ulayta konkani..ani party che nav Maharashtrawadi Gomantak Party. Problem aso ki konkani ami fakt ulavpa partyant urle..Schoolani Konkani literature was never encouraged..
Recognition as an independent language edit With the continued insistence of some Marathis that Konkani was a dialect of Marathi and not an independent language, the matter was finally placed before the Sahitya Akademi. Suniti Kumar Chatterji, the president of the Akademi appointed a committee of linguistic experts to settle the dispute. On 26 February 1975, the committee came to the conclusion that Konkani was indeed an independent and literary language, classified as an Indo-European language, which in its present state was heavily influenced by the Portuguese language.
Btw Uday Bhembre Baba I have learnt a lot from your explanation. But I must also listen to the otherside to digest what both say. I await an answer to my question. Thank you once again.
Bab Uday Bhembre systematically explained the various facets of Konkani Language which lead to be accepted as State's official language of Goa. Let's hope that Dr Anuja Jhosi listened to the arguments put forward to neutralize her contention that Konkani is a dialect without studying the reasons why Konkani had to be the Goa's Official and that Marathi language may be used only if government wished to do so
VALORACHEA TUZE UTTREA SIR BAB UDHY. THE MOST EXPERIENCED PERSON.WHAT HE HAS SPOKEN IS THRUSTING TRUTH.MAY ALMIGHTY KEEP HIM ALWAYS HAPPY HEALTHY LIFE TO FIGHT FOR RIGHT ❤❤❤❤❤
Konkani is our language of all Goans. Whether we are Christians or Hindus... Our ancestors have sacrificed a lot for this soil. They didn't think of religion. they protected our language. We have to do the same. That's what we i think.
वेगळी कोकणी लिपी पहिली करची पटलीमागीर कोकणी मराठीकुमी उच्च जातली अशे तिचे म्हणणे असा...such videos have the potential to create unrest...matter should go in court...as we may to get Bhat for puja at home devkarya
I know of one thing for sure ...when upbringing falters n faults...every ejjjuketed😂 person turns brut😂...n more so when they mingle with stray minds...
@@augustinealbertsouza9434even previously Turkey was using Arabic script now they have also Roman script but language is Arabic. So why Devnagri followers are scared of Roman script as everyone is writing English in Roman script.
Sir, I respect you but I completely disagree with you and all Only Devnagari lovers not to recognise and implement ROMI as equal status wherein all Native Christian follow it, don't you think it is not justifiable??.
Konkani chya fudara dishen ami Konkani chem standardisation (like how Kannada has various dialects but one standard language called "Grantha Kannada" ) as well as teaching the kids to read and write in one common script preferably Dev Nagari is necessary. Else most of the future generation will adopt either English or Marathi
उदय भेंब्रे बाब, तुमचं भाषिक तत्त्वज्ञान आम्ही अनेकदा ऐकलंय. उदय बाब आपल्या वडिलांच्या भाषिक भूमिकेबद्दल आपण काय सांगाल? आपले वडीलही महाराष्ट्रातूनच आले होते काय? 'अस्मिता मधील गोव्याची मराठी भाषेची परंपरा सांगणाऱ्या आपले वडील लक्ष्मीकांत प्रभू भेम्ब्रे यांना काय संबोधणार? २) एका बाजूनं आपण म्हणता की कोकणीला बोली भाषा म्हणू नये व दुसऱ्या बाजूने आपण म्हणता की गोव्यात ९५ टक्के लोक कोकणी बोलतात म्हणून तिला राजभाषा केली. म्हणजे बहुसंख्य लोकांची ती बोली भाषाच आहे ना? मग कोकणीला बोली भाषा म्हटल तर राग का यावा? गोव्यात वेगवेगळ्या तालुक्यात वेगवेगळी कोकणी बोली बोलली जाते व काही प्रमाणात लिहिली पण जाते, मग गोव्याची प्रमाण कोकणी कुठली व बोली कुठली ते तरी सांगा. ३)तुमची कोकणी तर १९१०साला नंतर शेणै गोयबाब ने निर्माण केलेली,मग पोर्तुगिजांनी कोकणी नष्ट केली तिच्यावर बंदी घातली असे आपण कसे म्हणता? हा,आणि ख्रिचन समाजालां मराठी विरुद्ध भडकावून त्यांचा वापर करून त्यांना रस्त्यावर आणल नसत तर देवनागरी कोकणी राजभाषा झाली असती का?
Sir Bembre God bless you, you are a true Goan konkani lover, some opportunists took the people, especially the youth for a ride
Salute you Sir Uday Bhembre . Very nicely explained . Hope this message goes deep into the heart and mind of the people who disturb the peace .
Valor tuka Sir Uday Bhembre konkani bhas amchi maim bhas!
Salute you Bab Bhembre,you are a true Goemkar,let us learn from this great personality,YES, never ever insult our Maim Bhas Konkani,Jai Goem ,Jai Konkani Bhas
Jay gomantak
@@damodarverekar2659 No Sthan
A sua lingua e português...
The problem is the newly migrated maharashtrisns couldn't leave behind Marathi, but their next generation accepted and learnt local Konkani language.
Did you outsiders of Portuguese descent leave Portuguese language?
We must be proud of our mother tounge konkani. Its our identity as Goan.
Absolutely correct. MGP created all this mess. Sudin ulayta konkani..ani party che nav Maharashtrawadi Gomantak Party.
Problem aso ki konkani ami fakt ulavpa partyant urle..Schoolani Konkani literature was never encouraged..
Very good Explanation Bab Uday Bhembre really you are true god bless you and give you good health peace and protect you 👌💪💪💯 true 🙏
Thank you, Sir coming back , we like to know more from you about our Goa and konkani , God bless you
Nicely explained sir....thanks
God bless you in good health and wisdom Mr. Uday Bhembre, your speak the truth ❤
Thanks sir for this information.Very clear explanation.This was necessary.
Thank you babBhembre and God bless you
Long live, Sir. UDAY BEMBRE.
Recognition as an independent language
edit
With the continued insistence of some Marathis that Konkani was a dialect of Marathi and not an independent language, the matter was finally placed before the Sahitya Akademi. Suniti Kumar Chatterji, the president of the Akademi appointed a committee of linguistic experts to settle the dispute. On 26 February 1975, the committee came to the conclusion that Konkani was indeed an independent and literary language, classified as an Indo-European language, which in its present state was heavily influenced by the Portuguese language.
पोर्तुगीजुय तांतुंतल्यांत काडून हुडयलें म्हळ्यारुय , कोंकणी ही समेस्त विंगड भास। कोंकणी ही शौरसेनी प्राकृतातल्यान आयल्या उपरांत ताजेर व्होडा प्रमाणांत माग्धी प्राकृताचोय प्रभाव दिसुन येता , कोंकणेंत मराठे परस चड संस्कृत शब्द आसा । कोंकणेंत अनेक मुंडारे भाशेंचोय प्रभाव दिसता। म्हाराठ्ठी ही तांचे थंयच्या प्राकृतातल्यान म्हळ्यारुच म्हाराठ्ठी प्राकृतातल्यांत आयल्या।
Goa needs you. May god give a long and healthy life .
Namaskar udaybab nicely explained
Very factual and logical as well.
Yes sir you are right God bless you🙏 always
I love you for your love of konkani & intelligence & history. Thank you very much .
Very logical explanation and clarification.
Btw Uday Bhembre Baba I have learnt a lot from your explanation. But I must also listen to the otherside to digest what both say. I await an answer to my question. Thank you once again.
Bab Uday Bhembre systematically explained the various facets of Konkani Language which lead to be accepted as State's official language of Goa.
Let's hope that Dr Anuja Jhosi listened to the arguments put forward to neutralize her contention that Konkani is a dialect without studying the reasons why Konkani had to be the Goa's Official and that Marathi language may be used only if government wished to do so
VALORACHEA TUZE UTTREA SIR BAB UDHY. THE MOST EXPERIENCED PERSON.WHAT HE HAS SPOKEN IS THRUSTING TRUTH.MAY ALMIGHTY KEEP HIM ALWAYS HAPPY HEALTHY LIFE TO FIGHT FOR RIGHT ❤❤❤❤❤
Very nicely explained. Thank you sir.
God bless you
You are absolutely right Sir .
God bless you with good health .
You sre absolutely right sir. Thankyou bab Bhembre.
Well said sir
Thank you for taking straight from the heart ❤
Keep going Uday sir👍
Very well Explained, but will it enter into the heads of those who are interested in disturbing peace n digging the past with half knowledge?
Very good explanation, Sir Bhembre let this all the authorities take note properly and act accordingly.
True son of the soil. Calmly and intellectually destroyed the brute mentality. Dev borem korun tuka, bab bhembre.
My dear brothers please learn from his great person, awesome......
Good point sir
Kokni Aamchi Maibhass. Ami suddha Marathi boroitaa Marathi'n Xiklya munn. Pun Aamchi Sanskriti, Aamche Jiney, Aamchi XittKodee Hee Kokninuch. Jai Goem, Gomantak
ऊदय सरांनी पु ल देशपांडेंचा दिशाभूल दिशाभूल म्हणतात ती हीच कळ्ळे मूं भेंब्रेबाब.हा महाराष्ट्र टाइम्स वरचा 1975 मधील लेख पुन्हा वाचावा ...
I salute you sir. God bless you and long live.
God bless you sir, the fake Goemcars should listen to your wise words and learn the reality of konkani bhasha of Goa.
Long live Sir God bless you
Well spoken Sir
Correct sir Uday Bhemhre little knowledge is dangerous amchem goemchem montri Zalat te sogle annaphabet munche tankam kainch somzonam.😂
Govem lootpachem aplim bolsam bhorpachem, hem dison ieta... Cholta tea pormonnem... Goenchem ani goekaranchem podlelem nam.
You are right Uday bab
I really appreciate ur thoughts sir 🙏
All ias and ips officers are nominated by Centre, we need change them first , as they not understand konkani
बरोबर सर
Va Uday bab valor tuka
Well said sir god bless you
Well said sir..god bless u
Valor tuka Dev Borem Korum. Bab Bhembre 🎉🙏
Devnagri konkni Hinduank Marathi bi Hinduank. Christaum Goenkar Nhoim?
Konkani is our language of all Goans. Whether we are Christians or Hindus... Our ancestors have sacrificed a lot for this soil. They didn't think of religion. they protected our language. We have to do the same. That's what we i think.
@@bangtanarmy4243 yes you are right 👍.
Christavank khoinchi script, Devnagri borounk einam.
Devnagari script Sogleank somjona, pun Roman script Sogleank kolta. Ekuch disalem "Sunaprant, devanagrint aslem thein bhi bondh zalem, kiteak?
Pun Roman Sript magazines zaitin assat, Kiteak?
Amche theatre /Gaeonam/Churchin vaspam azun Roman scriptin cholta. Kiteak?
Tor Konkani script Devanagrint/Roman kiteak donuin barabor cholonk zaina.?
@@augustinealbertsouza9434Marathi shikpak Jay.
Apoap. Koani shiktalo anik kokani shikpa chi garaj na
@@damodarverekar2659 Portuguese tempar unch jaticha lokani Marathi escolam gatlim, kiteak ? Lahan jatiche lokanc konkni sicpak sompem podtelem mhun? Ani uprant Devlani Dhol vazop, saron marop, fugdi galop/nachop ani devlanchi sapai korop ani offisani peon / guards/helper anchi nokri korop? Ani English/Portuguese sikclair teh unch jatichea hata bair vosot mun tankam bhirant distali.
Unch jatiche lok, don classi Marathi sikon, English/Portuguese sicpak aplea burgeank vodle, vodle iscolani dadop., ani maguir tankam Dotor, Advocat, Engineers ani eir toreche officers javpak, apleam burgeank encourage korop.
Konkani/Marathi/English xicop to jaun asah zon ekleacho personal choice. Sodeak English ani Portuguese zaun assa amchi pot borpachi bass, hakach lagon amche burghe apli citizenship passun sodun baile gavani vetat, kiteak konkani/Marathi ancho faido fokot amchea politicianank melta.
By the way, tuvem maka mojea prosnank xabab diunkna?
Maka Konkani nuim mun Marathi sickpachi goroz nam, nuim mun mojea burgeank.
Uday Bhembre Sir, tumi advogad, muntoch koxem kittem ullounk zai tem tumi bhes-borem zanna. Bhayee'k tumi boro prothisad dila. GPA he sonsthe khala tumi axile, pun tumi kednach ''Devnagri 'bhaxe' khatir ami zogodtat, oso ullek kednach kelo'nam. Romi bhaxeak, kiteak dorzo magunk nam; hem matxe spoxt korun sangxi?
सविस्तर खंय आनि केन्ना किते जाले हे कळन आयले. आमचे भितर जी उणीव आसा ती कसल्या लढ्यातल्यान मुक्त जातले होय विचार जावचो....आशा.
वेगळी कोकणी लिपी पहिली करची पटलीमागीर कोकणी मराठीकुमी उच्च जातली अशे तिचे म्हणणे असा...such videos have the potential to create unrest...matter should go in court...as we may to get Bhat for puja at home devkarya
I know of one thing for sure ...when upbringing falters n faults...every ejjjuketed😂 person turns brut😂...n more so when they mingle with stray minds...
The best explanation but I don’t think so some idiots will not understand
Uday Bhembre Baba 59 % konkani Goenkars. How many 1. Devnagiriwale 2. Romiwale ? I would appreciate if you anwer my question. Thank you.
Christavank konkani khoinche scriptachean borouchi?
अभ्यास ना ते मणीस विरोध करता
Saarke tumche!! Konkani amchi maybhaas. Ti ami shikap. Tichi udargat amchya, Goykaranchya, hatin asa.
Sir,tumi uloillem ek ek utor sarkem assa. Valor tumkam. Niz Goemkar ami khass koknnim amchi maibhas, sni rajbhass
Bab. Uday Bhembre tuca zaito mog Goencho assa ani aiz passun zante piraier tujea moladik zanvaien amche goenkaranche kann ani dolle ugddunk vavurtai... Devan tuca bore boliken dourunk mhojem magnem.
Are baba khaynche newspapers govyan chad vachlee vaitat tee pai, kokani va English newspaper are not even 25% of marathi newspapers
Savant not goan😅
Niz Goemkar fakt konkani uloitat.. Kityak Goemchi raz bass konkani..
Irespectivee of which script he/she follows., no matter whether one wears Sari/skirt, blouse, pant shirt, suit boot, or dhoti langoti.
@@augustinealbertsouza9434no original Christian in Goa
@@augustinealbertsouza9434even previously Turkey was using Arabic script now they have also Roman script but language is Arabic. So why Devnagri followers are scared of Roman script as everyone is writing English in Roman script.
Christavank English Raj Bhas?
uday bab hanka kitle sanglear ekuch nimanem umtea kolshar udok
Salute bembre bab you are niz goenkar chodd Ani chodd valor devan tujer besanv galun Ani tuka bori bolaiqui diun
Koslo bovall
Bigar goiyakarani goyancha rajkarnat dhumakul ghalcho nhay.Tumchya rajyat Vachun tumi Thai ravpak shaknat? Tumche Sarkar tumchakhatir kaich Karina?
Sir, I respect you but I completely disagree with you and all Only Devnagari lovers not to recognise and implement ROMI as equal status wherein all Native Christian follow it, don't you think it is not justifiable??.
Konkani chya fudara dishen ami Konkani chem standardisation (like how Kannada has various dialects but one standard language called "Grantha Kannada" ) as well as teaching the kids to read and write in one common script preferably Dev Nagari is necessary. Else most of the future generation will adopt either English or Marathi
उदय भेंब्रे बाब, तुमचं भाषिक तत्त्वज्ञान आम्ही अनेकदा ऐकलंय. उदय बाब आपल्या वडिलांच्या भाषिक भूमिकेबद्दल आपण काय सांगाल? आपले वडीलही महाराष्ट्रातूनच आले होते काय? 'अस्मिता मधील गोव्याची मराठी भाषेची परंपरा सांगणाऱ्या आपले वडील लक्ष्मीकांत प्रभू भेम्ब्रे यांना काय संबोधणार? २) एका बाजूनं आपण म्हणता की कोकणीला बोली भाषा म्हणू नये व दुसऱ्या बाजूने आपण म्हणता की गोव्यात ९५ टक्के लोक कोकणी बोलतात म्हणून तिला राजभाषा केली. म्हणजे बहुसंख्य लोकांची ती बोली भाषाच आहे ना? मग कोकणीला
बोली भाषा म्हटल तर राग का यावा? गोव्यात वेगवेगळ्या तालुक्यात वेगवेगळी कोकणी बोली बोलली जाते व काही प्रमाणात लिहिली पण जाते, मग गोव्याची प्रमाण कोकणी कुठली व बोली कुठली ते तरी सांगा. ३)तुमची कोकणी तर १९१०साला नंतर शेणै गोयबाब ने निर्माण केलेली,मग पोर्तुगिजांनी कोकणी नष्ट केली तिच्यावर बंदी घातली असे आपण कसे म्हणता? हा,आणि ख्रिचन समाजालां मराठी विरुद्ध भडकावून त्यांचा वापर करून त्यांना रस्त्यावर आणल नसत तर देवनागरी कोकणी राजभाषा झाली असती
का?