What ive noted even Goa origin Muslims population has declined. Most of the Goa origin Muslims have been migrating abroad. While Muslims from other states have migrated into Goa and settled here.
Govenor is right to some extent. Suppression in recruitment in govt offices, social field, Economic status, culturally and religious wise have badly felt & suffered to the minorities.
Well said cleofas bab, what I would say that the Goans are welcomed in any part of the world because of our known culture and identity left by Portugal. But now we see that the corrupt politicians has made the program with the system for Catholics to leave. Even for highly qualified youth, just study and leave the country, no well paid jobs.
❤no matter people going to work anywhere in the world. But don't live Goa forever always remember St Francis Xavier came to Goa for the love of Goa n its people ❤he is always with goans❤
cm wants bhikakars to settle in goa for vote banks goan hindus muslims and christians population has decreased due to unemployed goans shifted abroad and bombay
@@abcxyz-re7lf Clearly Goans are not enterprising enough. They prefer salaried positions. If they had been more enterprising, they would have created more high-paying jobs for Gaoans in Goa.
@@prashanthkamath7437 Running a business is not a joke especially if you have a family to feed. Also have to consider the corrupt govt that extorts bribes for any paper work and permission.
"Due to the civilized upbringing of Goans, which emphasizes respect for others over the ages, people from around the world can relax peacefully in even the remotest parts of Goa. However, Goans themselves often feel uncomfortable or unstable outside the borders of Goa. The refinement of Goans is a welcoming factor that has contributed to the influx of migrants to Goa."
Thats a fact. There has been a decline in our Catholic population in Goa, and it's coz they go in search of betterment. Wish to see our Goan catholic brothers and sisters back in Goa, happy and prosperous and flourish in everything they do.
Goans are always United irrespective of caste creed and religion. Nothing to do with Christianity and Hindus or Muslims, mind you we Goans will never get divided, always remain united nothing to worry. We will remain firm, so also our land of Goa. If Christianity decreases, there are mighty Hindu brothers and sisters to defend the Goa .After all, it is the Goyekar means Goyekar. Once a Goan is forever Goyekar.
● *Is Christianity growing or Shrinking* ? ● Population experts are predicting a higher population in certain religions. Why ? ● This subject has to be treated with great caution. ● A higher fertility rate with certain communities/religions ● The Natality rate among Christians is low due to late marriages. ● Some are tempted by new faiths and cultures. You observe Intermarriages too.Thus waves of conversions ● Yes. People always migrated for various reasons. ● *DUAL NATIONALITY* could bring Goan Catholics to be a part of the Goan Christian COUNT.
More catholic population will migrate because less job opportunities, inflation very high, housing prices are out of reach for middle class, health sector is falling, old age person is not eligible for elderly persons and technical education institutions are very less , corruption is in every hook of government office, no governance satisfaction, there lot more reasons not come back to goa
100% corruption in all govt sectors this is one of the reasons people don't want to stay in goa and ministers bought migrants for vote bank nd ruling Goa on there support
Not only goans migrate but even non goans migrate to other foreign countries. At present so many indians are migrating to other countries as they are Not Happy with India.
Goa needs special status to protect our land identity and culture which unique in the whole of India and the World being a very special beautiful n smatt state.
It's because ' London calling' 'Ireland calling ' Australia and Canada calling'. Pre- liberation it was 'Portugal calling ' Mozambique calling' 'Africa calling'.
It's time catholic voters plays a important role in safeguarding the Goa's lifestyle culture and state language, If you notice North Goa beach belt konkani language and lifestyle had declined and kannada, Marathi and Hindi has overtaken. Previously North Goa beach belt was mostly catholic voters speaking konkani language and Goan lifestyle and culture Goan catholic should come back to their roots and increase catholic voters majority to safeguard Goan culture, lifestyle and language.
Adv.Cleofacio please correct yourselves. Goans taken up Portuguese nationality because since 1992 European union allowed 19 European countries to work in these countries like Uk, Germany,france ... So most Goan Christians migrated to Uk with Portuguese nationality since 1992...previously most people could not educated much in English and Portuguese...this a fact.
I think vacant houses of Catholics, be it palaces, bunglows, flats or otherwise , which are used for a few days when they come down for holidays ( Christmas or Summer) should be kept apart from the conversation. Certainly Real Estate prices have skyrocketed in Goa, but the masses should put pressure on the Government to brink in housing schemes, let the companies provide accommodation for migrant workers etc.
Yes it's true Goan christian population is declining. Main cause is that it's shortage in catholic girls to marry Christian guy. See the data how many catholic guys are single that too in Goa. In this matter even church & convent authorities can't help.
It's happening...... Islamic invasion... Christians are basically migrating to Europe and west for jobs.but Islam is increasing because of birth rates .while hindus and Christian birth rates are constant maybe an average of 2 per family unlike muslims having 4 wife's sometimes and more than 2 children..
Job is an big factor, I request to GNH rupesh bab to bring government jobs data as per constituency and how many Christians holding government jobs in every constituency dont think any thing bad in this. Bcoz soon after I passed my 12th examination I applied for employment card but I didn't got any call from them or got any opportunities for government job. And I'm now In London and I feel that due to lack of job opportunities for Christians community we are getting migrated.
Mr. Pillai should know that kerala has become empty as all the keralites have migrated to the other countries for work. I suppose he considers Yusuf Ali also a migrant or a brain drain due to the circumstances he was in. Muslims of goan origin too are not given job opportunities in the government sectors and are dicriminated against. And by luck if they do get a job they face harassment at the workplace. Muslims existed in Goa before the Portuguese conquest after which the converted Christians came into existence.
@user-wn5rz4ln7s your research is misguided. When the people from Goa accepted Christianity they took Portuguese surnames and the same applies in the case of Goan muslims too. Dont call them Moirs(immigrants) as they have their ancestral roots way before the portuguese. Adil Shah was ruling Goa before Portuguese. And goan Muslims don't speak urdu but a dialect which is a combination of hindi konkani and Portuguese. Some may have started speaking hindi or urdu because of other states influence.Their food habits are also the same as Goa's Hindus and Christians.
@user-wn5rz4ln7s What if the Muslims who don't have any other root other than Goa? Whose ancestors are from Goa only. Where do you think they are from?
@user-wn5rz4ln7s Goa did not have any boundaries before which you see today. It was a part of Kadamba rules, Adil Shah's rule and so on. The Goa which you see today is just a part of their land which was invaded by the Portuguese. History is very deep. You have to consider Ashoka dynasty, Mughal dynasty, Chola dynasties, Morya dynasty Maratha dynasty and so on. All were invaders. Thank God we are a Republic now. Let's not dicuss about dead people any more.
0:26 While there are several reasons for migration into Goa, one of the most important reasons is that Goa has been free from communalism and also there has been so far good communal harmony between the three religions communities of Hindus , Christians and Muslims. This peaceful atmosphere has attracted many non Christian outsiders into Goa However this should not be allowed to go on indefinitely, as Goans will be in the minority in their own land..
Sir 2 major factor why people are scared to come back to retire as today's law in Goa deprive our own property rights etc and too many outside Goa are ruling and changing Goa and now our Christian brothers are crying for Muslim population increase etc.
Vast topic.. N numbers of reasons for migration.. Not only opportunities.... 1)Politics.. 2) Most of Catholics who are mostly religious just don't want to interfere in such social activities strikes etc... ( they will particularly come out when their head of church calls them) or maka kitea podla?? 3) catholics bound to change as per time as per situation . They always are willing to get adapted as per latest trends. 4) they think they are superior in terms of others... So if non goans come they will leave that place and will move instead of fighting. 5) unity is what they are lacking. 6) Muslims have a great unity. If there is a small accident of bike involving muslim with an other community. Than there will be a crowd full of muslim and later will be left alone ( I m not referring to goan Muslims..) 7) hindus and catholics prefer not to leave with migrated Muslims.... So there certain areas are dominated with muslim population.
Migration of goans n shrinking of population, these r two different issues I don't why this issue is mixed up secondly why don't discuss the issue of equal opportunities to all communities
The only reason goans specially leaving goa is they don't have better job opportunities.... So that's why one have to to live for a better prospects n proper living of standard.....
This reporters have no time to ask questions to ministers regarding the hill cuttings and Delhi builders destroying our Goa ,so they bring other people to divert the attentions of goans ,this channels should be boycotted
The tourism has dipped also in Goa. Thats why it has had to promote cheap alcohol for tourism. Catholics are better suited in civilized countries and nobody would like their house with reptiles.
"Due to the civilized upbringing of Goans, which emphasizes respect for others over the ages, people from around the world can relax peacefully in even the remotest parts of Goa. However, Goans themselves often feel uncomfortable or unstable outside the borders of Goa. The refinement of Goans is a welcoming factor that has contributed to the influx of migrants to Goa."
What ive noted even Goa origin Muslims population has declined. Most of the Goa origin Muslims have been migrating abroad. While Muslims from other states have migrated into Goa and settled here.
Mus lims of other states have migrated to Goa? No, of that was the case then their population would not decline.
The main reason why the catholic population in goa has fallen is for better opportunities and also lack of well paid jobs than abroad.
We are not pro life like Our ancestors
Govenor is right to some extent. Suppression in recruitment in govt offices, social field, Economic status, culturally and religious wise have badly felt & suffered to the minorities.
Well said cleofas bab, what I would say that the Goans are welcomed in any part of the world because of our known culture and identity left by Portugal. But now we see that the corrupt politicians has made the program with the system for Catholics to leave. Even for highly qualified youth, just study and leave the country, no well paid jobs.
❤no matter people going to work anywhere in the world. But don't live Goa forever always remember St Francis Xavier came to Goa for the love of Goa n its people ❤he is always with goans❤
Sawant will be happy, if more christians miggrate
He has no spine, he is only taking orders from his high command, who in turn r taking orders from Nagpur.
cm wants bhikakars to settle in goa for vote banks goan hindus muslims and christians population has decreased due to unemployed goans shifted abroad and bombay
Sawant,samant,all the kar's are all from maharashtra...now they are Nizachem goemkar..😂😂😂@@abcxyz-re7lf
@@abcxyz-re7lf Clearly Goans are not enterprising enough. They prefer salaried positions. If they had been more enterprising, they would have created more high-paying jobs for Gaoans in Goa.
@@prashanthkamath7437 Running a business is not a joke especially if you have a family to feed. Also have to consider the corrupt govt that extorts bribes for any paper work and permission.
"Due to the civilized upbringing of Goans, which emphasizes respect for others over the ages, people from around the world can relax peacefully in even the remotest parts of Goa. However, Goans themselves often feel uncomfortable or unstable outside the borders of Goa.
The refinement of Goans is a welcoming factor that has contributed to the influx of migrants to Goa."
Rupesh thank tou just a beautiful and informative interview. Thank you.🎉
Thats a fact. There has been a decline in our Catholic population in Goa, and it's coz they go in search of betterment. Wish to see our Goan catholic brothers and sisters back in Goa, happy and prosperous and flourish in everything they do.
Goans are always United irrespective of caste creed and religion. Nothing to do with Christianity and Hindus or Muslims, mind you we Goans will never get divided, always remain united nothing to worry. We will remain firm, so also our land of Goa. If Christianity decreases, there are mighty Hindu brothers and sisters to defend the Goa .After all, it is the Goyekar means Goyekar. Once a Goan is forever Goyekar.
Now more will go because of CM pramod sawant & his fugitive velingkar
Now that the figures are out, please send it to those particular people who claim that there is conversion. 😊3:36
Yes it's declining because they are intrested in going to London with the help of prortuges passport.
Please note that the others non Christians are also migrating to other countries.
@@elliven17 but the topic is not on non Christian 😂🤣
Ya should they???? Ur going from 3rd world country to 1st country??
Thats the most logical step.
● *Is Christianity growing or Shrinking* ?
● Population experts are predicting a higher population in certain religions. Why ?
● This subject has to be treated with great caution.
● A higher fertility rate with certain communities/religions
● The Natality rate among Christians is low due to late marriages.
● Some are tempted by new faiths and cultures. You observe Intermarriages too.Thus waves of conversions
● Yes. People always migrated for various reasons.
● *DUAL NATIONALITY* could bring Goan Catholics to be a part of the Goan Christian COUNT.
One day a day will come when we will find difficulty in finding actual Goans..khya he goans
More catholic population will migrate because less job opportunities, inflation very high, housing prices are out of reach for middle class, health sector is falling, old age person is not eligible for elderly persons and technical education institutions are very less , corruption is in every hook of government office, no governance satisfaction, there lot more reasons not come back to goa
100% corruption in all govt sectors this is one of the reasons people don't want to stay in goa and ministers bought migrants for vote bank nd ruling Goa on there support
Not only goans migrate but even non goans migrate to other foreign countries. At present so many indians are migrating to other countries as they are Not Happy with India.
Modi ki gaurantee asa
A stage will come in Goa when all the MLAs and CM will be Basappas,Ellappas, Pillai, Abdul Udgattys.
Family planning is another reason in both communities
Goa needs special status to protect our land identity and culture which unique in the whole of India and the World being a very special beautiful n smatt state.
Very good interview hope these corrupt Politicians will get advice from this interview
Last part off debeat is fruitfull thank you sir and Rupesh
It's because ' London calling' 'Ireland calling ' Australia and Canada calling'.
Pre- liberation it was 'Portugal calling ' Mozambique calling' 'Africa calling'.
i met hindu Goans in UK as well as Ireland. no one talks of these and as Cleofato says yes we Christian Goans are appreciated wherever we go.
Its true .. lots of people settled abroad .. not thinking of going back
And other reason is Family planning ( hum dho hamare ek) Osem kristao familyin zalam.
It's time catholic voters plays a important role in safeguarding the Goa's lifestyle culture and state language,
If you notice North Goa beach belt konkani language and lifestyle had declined and kannada, Marathi and Hindi has overtaken.
Previously North Goa beach belt was mostly catholic voters speaking konkani language and Goan lifestyle and culture
Goan catholic should come back to their roots and increase catholic voters majority to safeguard Goan culture, lifestyle and language.
Adv.Cleofacio please correct yourselves.
Goans taken up Portuguese nationality because since 1992 European union allowed 19 European countries to work in these countries like Uk, Germany,france ...
So most Goan Christians migrated to Uk with Portuguese nationality since 1992...previously most people could not educated much in English and Portuguese...this a fact.
I think vacant houses of Catholics, be it palaces, bunglows, flats or otherwise , which are used for a few days when they come down for holidays ( Christmas or Summer) should be kept apart from the conversation.
Certainly Real Estate prices have skyrocketed in Goa, but the masses should put pressure on the Government to brink in housing schemes, let the companies provide accommodation for migrant workers etc.
All were Hindus in govt offices.. Thts y ppl left goa
Yes it's true Goan christian population is declining. Main cause is that it's shortage in catholic girls to marry Christian guy. See the data how many catholic guys are single that too in Goa. In this matter even church & convent authorities can't help.
IF YOU GIVE THEM DUAL CITIZENSHIP NUMBER OF CATHOLIC WILL BE IN GOA SO PLEASE SOLVE THIS ISSUE ASAP TO STAY IN PEACE GOA FOREVER 🙏👏🤝💪🙌
Our Sawantwadi CM will never allow this to happen.
Well explained
dual citizenship is the only solution.
It's happening...... Islamic invasion... Christians are basically migrating to Europe and west for jobs.but Islam is increasing because of birth rates .while hindus and Christian birth rates are constant maybe an average of 2 per family unlike muslims having 4 wife's sometimes and more than 2 children..
Ya Muslims believes in having wives but not mistresses.
Job is an big factor, I request to GNH rupesh bab to bring government jobs data as per constituency and how many Christians holding government jobs in every constituency dont think any thing bad in this. Bcoz soon after I passed my 12th examination I applied for employment card but I didn't got any call from them or got any opportunities for government job. And I'm now In London and I feel that due to lack of job opportunities for Christians community we are getting migrated.
Mr. Pillai should know that kerala has become empty as all the keralites have migrated to the other countries for work. I suppose he considers Yusuf Ali also a migrant or a brain drain due to the circumstances he was in. Muslims of goan origin too are not given job opportunities in the government sectors and are dicriminated against. And by luck if they do get a job they face harassment at the workplace. Muslims existed in Goa before the Portuguese conquest after which the converted Christians came into existence.
@user-wn5rz4ln7s your research is misguided. When the people from Goa accepted Christianity they took Portuguese surnames and the same applies in the case of Goan muslims too. Dont call them Moirs(immigrants) as they have their ancestral roots way before the portuguese. Adil Shah was ruling Goa before Portuguese. And goan Muslims don't speak urdu but a dialect which is a combination of hindi konkani and Portuguese. Some may have started speaking hindi or urdu because of other states influence.Their food habits are also the same as Goa's Hindus and Christians.
@user-wn5rz4ln7s What if the Muslims who don't have any other root other than Goa? Whose ancestors are from Goa only. Where do you think they are from?
@user-wn5rz4ln7s Goa did not have any boundaries before which you see today. It was a part of Kadamba rules, Adil Shah's rule and so on. The Goa which you see today is just a part of their land which was invaded by the Portuguese. History is very deep. You have to consider Ashoka dynasty, Mughal dynasty, Chola dynasties, Morya dynasty Maratha dynasty and so on. All were invaders. Thank God we are a Republic now. Let's not dicuss about dead people any more.
Many are migrating. Youngsters are leaving for better opportunity
Catholic population is declining is because there are now only one or two children per family
0:26 While there are several reasons for migration into Goa, one of the most important reasons is that Goa has been free from communalism and also there has been so far good communal harmony between the three religions communities of Hindus , Christians and Muslims. This peaceful atmosphere has attracted many non Christian outsiders into Goa
However this should not be allowed to go on indefinitely, as Goans will be in the minority in their own land..
Sir 2 major factor why people are scared to come back to retire as today's law in Goa deprive our own property rights etc and too many outside Goa are ruling and changing Goa and now our Christian brothers are crying for Muslim population increase etc.
his pulling words from your mouth to say something against... you are carefully explaining to him is enough to understand
Even the person who is interviewing you Mr samant is basically a maratha now thier are NIZ GOEMKAR😂😂😂😂
The exodus has multiplied post 2014
Why some always stay in slumps? Birth is every year, way they think is also the reason.
Time to count British n Portuguese citizens
Vast topic.. N numbers of reasons for migration.. Not only opportunities....
1)Politics..
2) Most of Catholics who are mostly religious just don't want to interfere in such social activities strikes etc...
( they will particularly come out when their head of church calls them) or maka kitea podla??
3) catholics bound to change as per time as per situation . They always are willing to get adapted as per latest trends.
4) they think they are superior in terms of others... So if non goans come they will leave that place and will move instead of fighting.
5) unity is what they are lacking.
6) Muslims have a great unity. If there is a small accident of bike involving muslim with an other community. Than there will be a crowd full of muslim and later will be left alone ( I m not referring to goan Muslims..)
7) hindus and catholics prefer not to leave with migrated Muslims....
So there certain areas are dominated with muslim population.
Migration of goans n shrinking of population, these r two different issues I don't why this issue is mixed up secondly why don't discuss the issue of equal opportunities to all communities
The only reason goans specially leaving goa is they don't have better job opportunities....
So that's why one have to to live for a better prospects n proper living of standard.....
If goans can go to england and take up any jobs and work hard what stops them from doim the same im goa?life is not easy in england anyway.
@christinleitao3894 it is big difference in west even educated people are not paid well in goa
It's because of Modi not giving better opportunity
This reporters have no time to ask questions to ministers regarding the hill cuttings and Delhi builders destroying our Goa ,so they bring other people to divert the attentions of goans ,this channels should be boycotted
Government gatia service bori dita
Stop making aadhaar card of migrants and save minority becoming to majority voters.
Ani thode vorsani Goem.. Goem urpana goemche christi lokani konkani sambalia.. Kitya amche hindu goemkar bhav marathi uluapak laglia.. Goemkar kabar Goem ani konkani kabar bhava.. 😢
In goa goan don't get job. Obviously people will go abroad.
Tell him to taouck Konkani
Arey...Amchea Goenkar soglem ghelea London ... Magir Goaen..borlea Ghante... actually ...Ami Christian's ..zalea Ghante..😂😂😂
Take interview with real Goan
May be they are leaving india
The tourism has dipped also in Goa. Thats why it has had to promote cheap alcohol for tourism. Catholics are better suited in civilized countries and nobody would like their house with reptiles.
%might b low but jesus is allways high❤
Goa christians kuthun aale
"Due to the civilized upbringing of Goans, which emphasizes respect for others over the ages, people from around the world can relax peacefully in even the remotest parts of Goa. However, Goans themselves often feel uncomfortable or unstable outside the borders of Goa.
The refinement of Goans is a welcoming factor that has contributed to the influx of migrants to Goa."