Watercolor Comparison Lunar, Mars, and Oxide Black PBK11 and Daniel Smith Primatek Blacks and Darks

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 29 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 18

  • @rebeccaneef6070
    @rebeccaneef6070 8 місяців тому +1

    Love this series! You might also try the Winsor & Newton version; it's my favorite of the ones I have. It doesn't turn to stone on the palette like my DS did, and granulates very nicely. Also, weirdly enough, I have both the Rembrandt and the Van Gogh versions, and I find the Van Gogh much nicer, and just as granulating. Their Van Gogh line has much less of the gummy, gloopy texture and less binder separation.

  • @brendavankranenburg3868
    @brendavankranenburg3868 3 роки тому

    I think you will like the Van Gogh. They work wel

  • @mojasmine8841
    @mojasmine8841 2 роки тому

    thank you the DS has the most granulation!

  • @BB-nz5sk
    @BB-nz5sk Рік тому

    I like Kilimanjaro better too!

  • @morgenmachen2400
    @morgenmachen2400 3 роки тому +2

    I'll admit I'm still of the opinion that black should be mixed, not come out of a tube. Yet, for no reason I can explain I have the three DS you show here lol. I love the Bloodstone but the most I've done with these three is just to mix with one pigment at a time. It's fascinating to me, the mixes you can get from these.
    Side note: I have four 100% cotton paper brands I use regularly but I'm getting really frustrated with the rate at which they dry. Of course it's winter here and I feel the lack of humidity in every atom of my being . It's not the papers fault. You'd say the kilimanjaro dries slower than arches cold press, all else being equal?

    • @morgenmachen2400
      @morgenmachen2400 3 роки тому

      Also, I wanted to ask - do you have any tips for cataloging and storage ? Maybe a video idea for the future ?

    • @jaimeanderson9238
      @jaimeanderson9238  3 роки тому +1

      I know what you mean about mixing blacks yet owning seemingly black colors lol. That is why I have them, for the mixes. I do like bloodstone on it's own for the violet that comes out, though.
      Yes the kilimanjaro dries slower. I couldn't have done this video on arches without pre wetting. I think there is still a better blend with arches but for me it's not enough to make up for the fast drying.

    • @jaimeanderson9238
      @jaimeanderson9238  3 роки тому

      @@morgenmachen2400 I currently use tiered paper trays that slide so I can separate by color family. It's worked really well for me. Mine has 4 tiers but isn't in stock. This looks the same except for the extra tier:
      amzn.to/3oqR9qq

  • @morgenmachen2400
    @morgenmachen2400 3 роки тому +1

    Hi Jaime
    I found myself back here to help with making a decision on pigment for something I'm currently working on. This video and others of yours are so helpful. Fantastic resource for education and practical applications.

  • @VanmeterFL
    @VanmeterFL 3 роки тому

    After watching this great demonstration, I was inspired. I just finished painting an "old-world" balcony with vining flowers flowing from flower boxes. I used Hermatite and Piemontite Genuine on the architectural features. I LOVED the way they granulated. It was an amazing contrast to the quin rose I used for the flowers and the Verditer Blue I used for the reflection off the windows.

  • @stephaniereed8869
    @stephaniereed8869 3 роки тому +1

    What is the tape you are using?

  • @mskhartwatercolourwithmisu8598
    @mskhartwatercolourwithmisu8598 3 роки тому

    Thank you for sharing. It's interesting.

  • @v.mishrasart43
    @v.mishrasart43 3 роки тому

    Very nice

  • @heelerjustheeler879
    @heelerjustheeler879 3 роки тому +3

    That was a great demo! It was interesting to see how different they are, even the three PBk11 pigments! I got a new appreciation for the DS Lunar Black from this - it's helpful to see how neutral it is. It would be fun to use 2 or 3 of the most different-looking of these together for monotone studies (e.g., in the style of Chinese ink or Japanese sumi-e paintings).
    I haven't used Primateks yet. I have heard they often don't mix well and are best used unmixed with other colors. Is that your experience?

    • @jaimeanderson9238
      @jaimeanderson9238  3 роки тому +1

      Thank you:) It would be a fun challenge to do a monotone study with such a granulating color as Lunar Black. I haven't used sumi ink yet.
      Some Primatek's mix really muted colors and even really light colors depending on what one you pick. There's a fair amount of binder in them and they aren't as concentrated. Otherwise I think they mix fine.