Hey Sarge. I don't think I've ever commented on your videos before today, but wanted to let you know I finally built my first real amazing dynasty over the last few days in OOTP23 since OOTP19. There has been so much development that I fell behind on and was too lazy to read up on and just enjoyed the challenges. Your videos are to thank for my amazing fun over the last few days, so wanted to give you a shout out and say thanks! I was looking in all the wrong places and you got me back on track. Please keep making these videos and let us know any way we can support you.
@@JHS7 Sorry I've not been checking UA-cam comments for awhile. I don't play much OOTP GO. I do have it on my phone and bought the updated rosters, but I find myself gravitating back to the laptop. Sorry I can't help out much on this one. Wish you luck buddy! I'll update this if I jump in the mobile platform in coming weeks.
Love your vids... do you have any tips on how to improve the records of lower milb teams? Everything below AA seems to always have a .300 record for me. Does milb team record negatively impact development?
I am in a league where actual ratings are hidden but we are shown their potential rating. We have to evaluate talent based on our scout's ability, the player's stats, and the current and potential star ratings relative to each league level. Any pointers you can give me for this scenario?
Hey sarge, love your content. Playing ootp23 and I'm noticing my scouting devolopment updates constantly showing me minus signs. I have a bad scout, but I feel like I have the best coaching available for me in this run. Have you noticed any differences from the previous games based on developments? Should I prioritize developing mechanics, or teach hit/pit more? Thanks again for your great content
Hey Sarge! Can we expect new videos for 24? Any updates you'd suggest? I'm implementing a lot of the same strats as 23 and if I don't see videos from you in a few weeks I'll create some and let folks know how it goes. Hope you're enjoying the beta either way. Thanks again my friend!
Hello! Yes, you can expect new videos for 24. I plan to release at least 1/2 videos some time this weekend and keep a somewhat regular content schedule going forwards. That said, if you think you've got something to offer the community that isn't out there right now and you'd like to create videos, by all means go for it. It's absolutely impossible for me to create enough content to cover everything (I'd estimate even back in 22 when I was releasing regularly, I hit maybe about 25% of the things I wanted to, and that's not even counting stuff I haven't thought of). Let me know if there's anything I can do to support you!
Question: How badly does demoting a player to AAA affect their ability? I run into a logjam at times where I've developed too much talent, I'm not prepared to trade it away as they're younger players, but temporarily sending a talent down (let's say a Potential 60 for shorthand) to AAA results in a reduction of their growth potential. This has happened to me several times and I don't think it was a function of the staff or lack of playing time. AAA in general seems to hold a lot of average players no matter who I stock it with. Just an observation, maybe I've just had bad luck. Also, so glad to see a new video, I can't stress enough how much I've learned from your material.
Generally, here's how I'd approach it: if you have a logjam, and you can't move one player to a different position, give yourself 1 year to deal one of the players. There's no reason to support a logjam with several talented players, no matter how good or young. If their talent level is similar, I'd deal the one in the majors, as trade value will generally be better (and you'll have more control of the younger player). You can generally get a good return. Demoting players or keeping them down to long does hinder development. That's why I generally recommend not waiting too long to trade.
Hello, when you mean fully developed what do you mean for hitters and pitchers? Does that mean maxing out all hitting ratings and pitching ratings before promoting to MLB or their overall rating? Love your content thank you 🙏
I just drafted a player who’s 46 of 80 coming out of HS. His expectations is playing in the majors. I placed him in AAA immediately and he’s unhappy. I assume it’s because he isn’t up in the big leagues. Have I messed up his development because I didn’t start him lower? Also, I’ve been following the green and red arrows to guide me whether I should move my prospects up. I assume that’s a no no? Thanks for all the videos.
@@supersloth003 them being unhappy cause of not being in majors isn’t the end of the world, you can offset them wanting to be up by making sure that they’re getting a lot of playing time and playing well
Technically, with feeder leagues, it is possible to develop players that are actually MLB ready (even this isn't super common though). I would need to see more than just an overall rating to be able to advise you. I would recommend going to the player's morale tab at the bottom left to see WHAT is causing them to be unhappy (if it's role, they probably want to be in the majors. If it's performance, I'd demote him so he can hit better in AA or A+). NEVER use those arrows for promotions/demotions. They just show if a player is improving or dropping ratings, not if they're ready for the next level.
I would never start a kid right out of high school in AAA even if he was mickey mantle or ken griffey jr. AAA fielding and pitching is too advanced for players with no pro ball experience. Send him to A ball.
new here and to game. i apologize if it's been explained elsewhere, but how do you allocate so much to the Development Budget? i'm playing as Seattle and that's way more than their total budget.
I try to allocate as much as I possibly can to development budget. When you're playing a small market team, it can be worth it to sacrifice the development budget early so you can spend and therefore increase your overall budget.
Often when I try to keep prospects at the appropriate level for their talent, they get super mad about “transactions” and I think angry morale hurts development. I feel like I’m in a Catch 22
So i've used this method now, and i have guys who should wreck @ the league there in, and they're doing completely terrible...one guy i have in High A ball, and (i know stars aren't important but to save time) 3/4.5 stars there with solid ratings but is doing absolutely terrible... recommendations?
A few things to keep in mind here. First of all, in addition to how bad stars are as a general evaluation tool, keep in mind that defense heavily affects it too. If your player is a really strong shortstop/CF, they could be a garbage hitter. Secondly, 3/4.5 stars compared to a level is not necessarily even a GOOD hitter, let alone a dominant one, at a given level. The batting profile could be inefficient, he could just not be well developed yet, there's a number of factors that could contribute. Thirdly, keep in mind small sample size is a LEGIT thing. Even if this player is truly quite good for the level, in small amounts of time they can struggle. Here is my recommendation. If the player is not actually ready, demote him. It hurts his development some, but less than sinking in a league he won't play in effectively. If the player is good enough, keep him in the league and give him more time to sort things out. If he continues to struggle over a larger sample size (usually half a season to a full season), it's time to demote him and let him get some success behind him.
I'm working on something big at the moment, so not until OOTP 24. I will post a review of the game and a general "State of OOTP" update on the engine (probably one soon after release and one a while after that), but other than those, I don't really have a date for when I'll be back on youtube. I'll probably release a video around then though explaining why my content has been on pause.
Rushing a prospect through the system is bad. Majority of players need at least 2-3 seasons in the minors. Spencer Torkelson in real life was rushed in my opinion. check out his performance with the tigers this season.
What if your prospect is 80/80 and all his individual ratings are maxed out at mlb level? Do you move them up to AAA or still trudge trough the minors?
@@bmla88 that's impossible in the real world. Is he a batter or pitcher? this player sounds exceptional in your game. start him in AA. play him for 20-30 games and promote him to majors if he dominates AA.
This was an awesome video. Explains a lot. Thank you for your continued efforts sarge
Thank you for posting quality content
Hey Sarge. I don't think I've ever commented on your videos before today, but wanted to let you know I finally built my first real amazing dynasty over the last few days in OOTP23 since OOTP19. There has been so much development that I fell behind on and was too lazy to read up on and just enjoyed the challenges.
Your videos are to thank for my amazing fun over the last few days, so wanted to give you a shout out and say thanks! I was looking in all the wrong places and you got me back on track.
Please keep making these videos and let us know any way we can support you.
If your on mobile do you know how to promote/demote people? I just got it today lol
@@JHS7 Sorry I've not been checking UA-cam comments for awhile. I don't play much OOTP GO. I do have it on my phone and bought the updated rosters, but I find myself gravitating back to the laptop. Sorry I can't help out much on this one. Wish you luck buddy! I'll update this if I jump in the mobile platform in coming weeks.
Love your vids... do you have any tips on how to improve the records of lower milb teams? Everything below AA seems to always have a .300 record for me.
Does milb team record negatively impact development?
I am in a league where actual ratings are hidden but we are shown their potential rating. We have to evaluate talent based on our scout's ability, the player's stats, and the current and potential star ratings relative to each league level. Any pointers you can give me for this scenario?
Hey sarge, love your content. Playing ootp23 and I'm noticing my scouting devolopment updates constantly showing me minus signs. I have a bad scout, but I feel like I have the best coaching available for me in this run. Have you noticed any differences from the previous games based on developments? Should I prioritize developing mechanics, or teach hit/pit more? Thanks again for your great content
Hey Sarge! Can we expect new videos for 24? Any updates you'd suggest?
I'm implementing a lot of the same strats as 23 and if I don't see videos from you in a few weeks I'll create some and let folks know how it goes.
Hope you're enjoying the beta either way.
Thanks again my friend!
Hello! Yes, you can expect new videos for 24. I plan to release at least 1/2 videos some time this weekend and keep a somewhat regular content schedule going forwards.
That said, if you think you've got something to offer the community that isn't out there right now and you'd like to create videos, by all means go for it. It's absolutely impossible for me to create enough content to cover everything (I'd estimate even back in 22 when I was releasing regularly, I hit maybe about 25% of the things I wanted to, and that's not even counting stuff I haven't thought of). Let me know if there's anything I can do to support you!
Question: How badly does demoting a player to AAA affect their ability? I run into a logjam at times where I've developed too much talent, I'm not prepared to trade it away as they're younger players, but temporarily sending a talent down (let's say a Potential 60 for shorthand) to AAA results in a reduction of their growth potential. This has happened to me several times and I don't think it was a function of the staff or lack of playing time. AAA in general seems to hold a lot of average players no matter who I stock it with. Just an observation, maybe I've just had bad luck. Also, so glad to see a new video, I can't stress enough how much I've learned from your material.
Generally, here's how I'd approach it: if you have a logjam, and you can't move one player to a different position, give yourself 1 year to deal one of the players. There's no reason to support a logjam with several talented players, no matter how good or young. If their talent level is similar, I'd deal the one in the majors, as trade value will generally be better (and you'll have more control of the younger player). You can generally get a good return.
Demoting players or keeping them down to long does hinder development. That's why I generally recommend not waiting too long to trade.
Hello, when you mean fully developed what do you mean for hitters and pitchers? Does that mean maxing out all hitting ratings and pitching ratings before promoting to MLB or their overall rating?
Love your content thank you 🙏
Definitely more focus on the individual ratings than overall.
Is there a point or age at which you would push a prospect?
I just drafted a player who’s 46 of 80 coming out of HS. His expectations is playing in the majors. I placed him in AAA immediately and he’s unhappy. I assume it’s because he isn’t up in the big leagues. Have I messed up his development because I didn’t start him lower? Also, I’ve been following the green and red arrows to guide me whether I should move my prospects up. I assume that’s a no no? Thanks for all the videos.
Oh another question, sorry. Will him being held down and being upset about it hinder his development?
@@supersloth003 them being unhappy cause of not being in majors isn’t the end of the world, you can offset them wanting to be up by making sure that they’re getting a lot of playing time and playing well
Technically, with feeder leagues, it is possible to develop players that are actually MLB ready (even this isn't super common though). I would need to see more than just an overall rating to be able to advise you. I would recommend going to the player's morale tab at the bottom left to see WHAT is causing them to be unhappy (if it's role, they probably want to be in the majors. If it's performance, I'd demote him so he can hit better in AA or A+). NEVER use those arrows for promotions/demotions. They just show if a player is improving or dropping ratings, not if they're ready for the next level.
@@supersloth003 Potentially. Given he just got drafted though, I doubt it will be a super large issue.
I would never start a kid right out of high school in AAA even if he was mickey mantle or ken griffey jr. AAA fielding and pitching is too advanced for players with no pro ball experience. Send him to A ball.
new here and to game. i apologize if it's been explained elsewhere, but how do you allocate so much to the Development Budget? i'm playing as Seattle and that's way more than their total budget.
I try to allocate as much as I possibly can to development budget. When you're playing a small market team, it can be worth it to sacrifice the development budget early so you can spend and therefore increase your overall budget.
I see you have 36M for player development budget. How much of impact would that have compared to a default 12M budget? Simply 3 times?
will you be posting a long-term sim for OOTP 23?
Don't currently have a plan to, but we'll see what comes in the upcoming months.
Often when I try to keep prospects at the appropriate level for their talent, they get super mad about “transactions” and I think angry morale hurts development. I feel like I’m in a Catch 22
So i've used this method now, and i have guys who should wreck @ the league there in, and they're doing completely terrible...one guy i have in High A ball, and (i know stars aren't important but to save time) 3/4.5 stars there with solid ratings but is doing absolutely terrible... recommendations?
A few things to keep in mind here. First of all, in addition to how bad stars are as a general evaluation tool, keep in mind that defense heavily affects it too. If your player is a really strong shortstop/CF, they could be a garbage hitter. Secondly, 3/4.5 stars compared to a level is not necessarily even a GOOD hitter, let alone a dominant one, at a given level. The batting profile could be inefficient, he could just not be well developed yet, there's a number of factors that could contribute. Thirdly, keep in mind small sample size is a LEGIT thing. Even if this player is truly quite good for the level, in small amounts of time they can struggle.
Here is my recommendation. If the player is not actually ready, demote him. It hurts his development some, but less than sinking in a league he won't play in effectively. If the player is good enough, keep him in the league and give him more time to sort things out. If he continues to struggle over a larger sample size (usually half a season to a full season), it's time to demote him and let him get some success behind him.
Do you have asst gm managing your minors? Or do you do all promotions/demotions?
Can tutorials for 23 use on 22?
Yes, everything except specific analysis tips are probably backwards applicable throughout my OOTP content.
If your on mobile do u know how to promote/demote players, I just got it today lol
When you coming back? Miss your OOT vids
I'm working on something big at the moment, so not until OOTP 24. I will post a review of the game and a general "State of OOTP" update on the engine (probably one soon after release and one a while after that), but other than those, I don't really have a date for when I'll be back on youtube. I'll probably release a video around then though explaining why my content has been on pause.
BaseBALLS
I notice your game has more minor league levels than mine. Is this something you recommend doing
Rushing a prospect through the system is bad. Majority of players need at least 2-3 seasons in the minors. Spencer Torkelson in real life was rushed in my opinion. check out his performance with the tigers this season.
What if your prospect is 80/80 and all his individual ratings are maxed out at mlb level? Do you move them up to AAA or still trudge trough the minors?
@@bmla88 that's impossible in the real world. Is he a batter or pitcher? this player sounds exceptional in your game. start him in AA. play him for 20-30 games and promote him to majors if he dominates AA.
learned nothing