Peter Gabriel - Dancing with the Moonlit Knight (Genesis) 2016
Вставка
- Опубліковано 25 лип 2016
- For the first time in 34 years, Peter Gabriel performs a Genesis song live.. taken from Sting & Peter Gabriel on their Rock, Paper, Scissors Tour at Rexall Place in Edmonton July 24 2016. Original video by Ryley Bauer ( • PERFECT AUDIO - Moonli... )
Damn shame that 99% of the audience had NO idea what they were witnessing.
I was thinkin the same thing ...
I would have lost my shit if i was there.
I've never so much not wanted to hear Message in a bottle in my life
I want Peter to cover old Genesis songs with an orchestra.
He considered Suppers Ready for the orchestral tour back 10, 11 years ago but opted against it.
As many others may feel, this is bittersweet, as it appears he’s putting his Genesis work to bed for himself, creating a sense of closure.
SHHHH STING, PETER IS SINGING
Thank you Steve Hackett for your Genesis revisited!!!!!
Legendary moment. Peter Gabriel's final farewell to that wonderful era of music.
I prefer to think of it as his re-embracing of this music. For many decades he has more or less shunned it (dismissed it as youthful folly).
Hey, he's going on tour again this year. Let's keep our fingers crossed...
nah, more like he and Stingo didn't approve of ordinary folk voting for brexit
First time he sang a genesis song in public since 1983. Think about that.
In 1999 carpet crawlers
1983? 1982 was the last time for the “Six Of The best “ one off reunion.
@@fabiohana7530 Do you have a link?
@@giovannigobbi4832 he recorded the song in studio with the other four
@@fabiohana7530 Wasn't it just an edit?
mindblowing then Sting started singing......
i all most cried
Jimmy Smith don't know
I cried like a baby
Who cares if no one cheers, that way you can hear the song! This is only twice in a lifetime!
I have to believe this was not an easy thing for PG to do after 34 years. That being said, he did it slowly, and with incredible emotion in each word. He feels his music much more than many others do, and it showed. Breathtaking for those that know what they witnessed and heard.
👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻✨
well said!
Phil did it justice during the Last Domino tour
I could care less how low his voice is.I'd listen to him do Genesis stuff anyday.
I must be dreaming...
Bought a tear too my eyes no one sings Genesis like Peter Gabriel
Just found this clip.I feel like crying.I miss him so much.I was shocked that the video was so short.No one in any tribute band holds a candle to PG. I still listen to Genesis almost daily but only from the PG era
This is history making... Fuck I just cried.
This is one of those serious goose bump moments, really wish they'd done the whole track. Really is an emotional version with the irish style fiddle playing. Just makes me think of the relentless passing of time...
Was that so hard, Mr Gabriel?!
I think it was indeed
Better than he sang it live in the original days. He's been practicing on his vocals in the last 40+ years. ;-)
Gabriel is obviously hiding from the others.
As I understand it, there are two factors behind his "Not Gonna Sing Genesis No More" stance. First, he wanted to make a break from Genesis, and didn't want to be "stuck" rehashing the same old hash. Second, there are (I expect) rights and licensing issues at play - it's not "his" music, it's "their" music, and so on, and so forth - so, simpler on the whole not to sing "the old stuff".
Of course, as a fan of Genesis in its Gabriel years I think this is all a bunch of crap, but then I'm not Peter Gabriel and he is.
@@jarvisfamily3837 i don't think you have pay licensing to perform. Plus he sang Genesis in his early solo years -- Back in NYC, The Lamb Lies Down. I think it's mostly attributable to pride and "that was then, this is now" mindset -- it's nice to seem him a little nostalgic at last.
Although Phil Collins did a sterling job in carrying on in Gabriel's shoes, Genesis were never really
quite the same after PG left.
.
One could argue the same with the split of Pink Floyd. Or Yes... Or Supertramp.
.
Gabriel's voice was quintessentially English - Garden of England in fact. No one has come as close, not even FIsh.... And this very brief expose was chilling, yet lovely to behold.
.
Such a dear, dear man - Peter Gabriel.
I agree nothing touches PG w Genesis ….and I loved Trick of the Tail album…but see if u can find PG singing ‘Washing of the Waters” love….
At a big festival by himself on piano…he s bald ,old, w his grey goatee…
And his singing is beyond grasp…it’s a very hard song to sing…and he absolutely kills it…what a vocalist…the emotions and tone are uniquely his…spiritual
I could only imagine the anticipation if Gabriel got back with his fellow band mates for a one-off concert. Everyone thinks U2 rules the stage. Genesis with Gabriel/Hackett would blow them out of the water.
Who tf thinks U2 rules the stage? lmfao U2 is ass. Genesis w/Gabriel and Hackett would rule and so would a Pink Floyd reunion.
With crippled Phil?
U.2,,,they could carry. Genesis',,gear//
@@manco828 No. Just one song, Peter and Steve's band.
@@whoarethebrainpigs It's a matter of personal tastes. I totally dislike U2.
No one comes close to Peter/Genesis.He sings every word like he effing means it to the bones.
so amazing---Peter says his voice is now too deep to reform with Genesis but this proves how unbelievable the 5 of the would be---he sound sublime.
I’ve never once heard him say that
That sounds so great, gave me chills. I wish Gabriel would do more of these
Pete has not done Genesis songs since his 1978 solo tour......enough time has passed my friend let’s hear it for classic Genesis!
does anyone else get pissed when message in the bottle starts?
Sting moveeeeeeeeeee peter is singinggg
Me
I get depressed
MIAB or Driven To Tears?
yes. it's a special moment for us die hard old genesis fans.
When he sings carpet crawlers I tear up a little
Oh my God!! Well done Peter!!
It’s my dream to see Peter to perform some songs from Genesis again❤, considering that maybe this year’s tour maybe his last tour and I think I will cry during the concert.
Kids of today, we are witnessing history!
You do realise that humans over the age of 9 are not kids
GOOSEBUMPS
I was at this show, and this song was incredible.
where was it??
Beautiful, the Master sings........................
2 words could help Peter & Phil. Ray Wilson
I can't stop listening at it since yesterday. It's like as if the Krakatoa erupted again! :)
Genesis reunion before is too late, please!!!!!!!
YESSSSS
As much I will like to see Peter on stage with Phil, Tony, Mike, and Steve, it will never happen: Phil cannot play the drums anymore.
If only Phil Collins could find a way to play the drums again, we can see him, Peter, Tony, Mike, and Steve on stage again.
I'm afraid this will always be a dream (a long-lasting one that has went on for years) that will never come to fruition. They've reached an age and physical state (at least with Phil Collins) in which it's really not possible.
The only way I can see it working is if they do a 1 hour set with Phil fronting the band, and then 1 hour with Peter fronting the band. And then, for an encore, both singers fronting the band together for I Know What I Like, or maybe even Carpet Crawlers. This way, fans of both eras of the band can be satisfied simultaneously. I'd love to see this, and would pay any sum of money to see Genesis in 2018.
I have watched this video more than than ten times. I have dreamed all my life after his departure from Genesis, to hear his more educated voice singing one of the Genesis classics. I wish he would be invited by Hacket to one of his Genesis revisited concerts to perform at least a couple of songs.
I think Steve would love to reunite with Peter, I believe Peter is the one who is still reluctant to reembrace his past with Genesis (his best work in my view), also because he is rightfully proud of his solo work. I wish it happens one day...
Dang, I love him so much.
I'm blown away by your love, you are loved as well. It seems you are a great fan. kindly message me privately on
Hangouts mail:
petergabriel.connects@gmail.com
@@petergabriel7032 🙄
Now I understand why Genesis ended their career with this as the opening to the last song they played live. As Peter Gabriel/Phil Collins/Genesis, damn you UA-cam for not showing me this sooner.
glad to know its not just me crying... just a bit mind....weird, the beginning of that song always gets me..
My God, I would have been in tears...
All hail the king!
I wish he would get with Hackets band... they nail it Imagine Nad and Gabriel doing the Collins confusions... those would be good old future days.
I was at Milton Keynes in 1982. I never thought he would perform another Genesis track. We have got to have a full reunion before it is too late. Please.
Don't forget Carpet Crawlers 1999
Yup, me too! It pissed down that day, and we drove overnight from Glasgow to watch it. Wish they had done a video of it. They said they didn't want to coz the were worried they wouldn't remember some of the words. It didn't matter coz 60,000 Genesis fans did!! ☺️☺️☺️
And I was there too. Talk Talk got pelted with bottles. God did it rain. I'd do all again without hesitation. Great night.
@@MattLathrum I really would like to forget Carpet Crawlers 1999.
@@alexstewart1770 I am now 61 and can truly say, hand on heart, the best gig I have seen EVER.
Short yes! But what a joy to hear pg singing this again.. his voice now serves it well and I would love to hear the whole thing. Sorry but I just can’t warm to sting
Prog Rock history being made again
To all those who were in the audience, you lucky buggers!
Imagine if he did the Lamb reunion tour with Genesis in 2007. After finishing the whole Lamb setlist, they bow to crowd and go backstage, crowd goes bonkers doing the "We want more" thing, they go back on stage. Encore 1: Watcher Of The Skies, The Musical Box, The Knife. All in its entirety. They bow again, go backstage, crowd going even more insane, they go back out. Encore 2: Dancing With The Moonlit Knight, I Know What I Like. All in its entirety. Everybody can die in peace. Imagine.
Well, this is the dream😊. Peter now goes on tour again this year and probably is his last tour. If he can add some genesis songs into setlist, I am sure I can die peacefully ❤.
I came after reading that.
In 78 at Madison Square Garden@ Genesis show w Phil as the front man…Gabriel came out and sang the encore…’I Know What I Like” people didn’t know what was going on unless u were sitting close.
Last Gabriel performance w Genesis…I was there in disbelief
Peter still sings so good man damnnnn a genesis reunion would be something epic
For some reason, the genesis era with Phil Collins was more popular. I had no doubt that Peter would come back with Genesis, since they did announce that they’re splitting up permanently.
I was expecting a bigger reaction from the audience. I mean, come on!
they were in Canada... in Europe he would have received a totally different reaction
I think Canada has actually been quite Genesis-friendly since the beginning. But I think the problem is that half (or more than half at the concert I went to) of the audience are Sting fans who don't know the difference between Gabriel singing this and, say Rhythm Of The Heat. It's just another Gabriel tune they aren't familiar with. And even a good portion of the Gabriel fans only became fans after So was released and don't have a clue about his work with Genesis...so the significance is lost on them. And the ones who do know were the few cheering or maybe sitting back and listening and soaking it all in.
the East Coast of Canada like Montreal - which is a HUGE Genesis hotbed - would have lifted the roof off of the building.
I thought that as well, and then I thought perhaps they were all fairly quiet so they could hear
this special moment.
I'm glad they didn't so I could hear Gabriel's magnificent voice performing for the first time in 34 years one of the most iconic lead vocals in history.
easily the best version. i just wish we got more.
Peter
goosebumps....absolutely magnificent
Absolutely beautiful
Dreams come true.
A Beautiful Song. Great ❤❤❤
I didn't even know he did this ..
Glad he still has some original Genesis in his heart .
How couldn't he ?
From Argentina Genetics, performing with Mr. Steve Hackett in Buenos Aires.
Thanks for the upload!
Best thing he’s done since 76 🥲
,🔥💓♥️ Fantastic!!..I have 63 yars..no comment..
My musical live..
Grazie Grazie....Grazieeee Piter
It's like having Gravis Mushnik back at the old flower shop again!
So beautiful, would be cool if he revisited other Genesis songs in a style more suited to his current voice
i was there. glorious.
After gabriels singing mr sting can go at the playground with the other kids and have fun
Danke Peter
Thank you for recording this---I am crying right now
Good God that sounds so gorgeous. Imagine all of the places he could take his beautiful, epic vocal melodies from Genesis days. Anyone familiar with their first album Trespass? A song like Dusk, or Stagnation... even all the way up to "The Lamb..." with songs like Cuckoo Cocoon, Fly On A Windshield, The Lamia (maybe have to down tune that one a step but damn its well suited for his raspy older voice). I hope he considers revisiting something like that at least once, but what I'd really like is a tour with new stuff, 1 from each album, and a few Genesis selections. Most of the members have never said "No" outright to a reunion with Peter, including Peter. In interviews, it's usually left at "maybe/probably not but who knows", so it kind of feels like 2 or 3 songs on one of his last tours isn't a big ask as a fan. He doesn't have to hit the high notes. I mean listen to this. Just such a textural, unique sound. fuck sake
Beautiful
Chills down my spine...
I cry out loud!!!!
great song. can't understand why the snub
This version of the song where it’s cut short is always referred to as just Selling England By The Pound.
Perfect melody.
I dream of a reunion with Anthony Philips
Mitico!
E.M.O.T.I.O.N.
pelle d'oca!
Brividi lungo la schiena
It lies with me...
Wooooooow 👏👏👏👏
Beautiful!!! Thank you!
You just know Sting urged him to include a Genesis number’’
I saw Sting sing that opening with Peter in Detroit
Sting sang it in Seattle, as well.
Thank you so much for posting this rare event!
It's a gift !
Love it
Goose bumps!
I wish he had been singing it the whole time. would've been amazing to see it in Hollywood. Sting did a good job tho
Great !!!
They both need to go in an record this while they both still have their voices. Cement this in history as a tribute to Genesis.
❤️
Had no idea he did this, thought it was only Sting that sang the intro. Wish Gabriel played this on the current I/O tour, even if just the intro part. This or another Genesis number would've been a nice little nod to the past
Cudowne...
This sounds fantastic. I was hoping PG would take this on during this tour rather than leaving it to Sting (who BTW did a great job with it).
I was there!!!
Yesss
i never understood why he refused to perform Genesis songs.
Probably because he has his own stuff to do. Why live off the back of something you're no longer a part of?
woww, this is interesting!!!!
Fuck, I cried.
It doesn't seem like the crowd had any idea of what they were lucky enough to be seeing.
Why he doesn't sing anything from his Genesis era? 😭 Just imagine how awesome that would be, he was not in big conflicts with anyone, why he is ignoring his early work