@@kqtiecxre._. Sakura? Please bfr. When ppl have criticism she came out giving an arrogant response with no intent of improving. She hasn’t been stable for over a decade, she won’t be stable anytime soon, especially when she said that the group tried their “best”.
I dont understand why are the comments so cruel? They actually sound pretty decent. Whats with the unnecessary hate train? Why cant we just criticize them constructively? Hating on them wont help them improve vocally at all. Only constructive criticism.
이전에 앵콜무대로 욕 디지게 먹어서 그러는 거 아냐;; 그러니까 최근 앵콜무대로 비교하는 거지. 춤추고 하는 거 뭐 어차피 arㅈㄹ빵빵해서 분간도 안 가는 거랑 비교하겠냐. 아이돌은 이미 완성형으로 나왔어야지 무대를 거치며 성장하는 게 말이되냐라고 하고싶겠지만, 뭐 어떡함 이미 데뷔한 거. 돌이킬 수도 없는 거 곱씹으며 한탄해봤자 속만 답답하지. 저들이 발전해나가면 많이 발전했다 격려하고 여전히 머물러 있음 본업이면 노력 좀 하는 게 좋겠다는 쓴소리 정도 할 수 있지. 이제 대중의 피드백은 저들이 노력을 하냐 안 하냐가 기준임. 쟤들도 이미 회사를 통해서 데뷔되어 버린 상태에서 이젠 자신들의 부족함을 대중의 피드백을 통해 몸소 깨달음으로서 발전해나가는 수밖에 없지. 솔직히 저번 개망한 앵콜무대에 비하면 많이 발전했네.
Compare to their Unforgiven encore This is much better......i said This is much better.....ya cause look at sakura u can see a little improvement same to zuha.....they are not off key
I disagree this song requires more technique while singing while Unforgiven they pushed their voices more but also this wasn’t a bad encore people are just jealous. It’s what happens when you get up there in fame.
@@AD20918 i just said that, it is better than Unforgiven encore!!!chill!?yes ik this is not good... especially kura and zuha's vocals they need so much improvement.....
Tell me you are kidding Cheawon and yujin Compared to others, they are a little better But other members just no I love their songs but their real voice....
@@atosadlv3644 when I say talent its not only voice and kazuha Sakura and eunchae getting better from their debut and eunchae is also talented in dancing :) But yes I don't think that much is ok for Coachella idk what they will do 🙂
@@sofficial6262 people haven't forgotten Jinni and Soojin, why should I forget garam? In a short time he stayed in the group he showed his importance in it, bringing softness to the songs
I all are really hating on all of them for this, when the only one who couldn't sing well or was lacking was clearly sakura! Love her but she clearly needs training. But anyways i think this isn't overly bad
Everyone talking about how they improved… 🙄🤦🏻♀️ they are already idols who win a lot of money, they have a lot of prestige… they are going to coachella… they shouldn’t have the necessity to improve, they should be a minimum good just to debut but with all the prizes they are winning being this bad!! ..This must stop.. people who have the minimun talent to sing should debut…. And people mist stop glorifing visuals who give presentations like this….
@@ARVINI0.0then try to sing yourself, i bet their vocals are better and how you’re saying that they still can’t sing ? Like Chaewon’s vocals are nothing ?
@@Hi-ou4qngirl i’ve been a fear not since debut, i can watch so many clips to justify that chaewon is the only one who has some what of a technique yujin is ok
@@nwrhhh”give them time” HAAHHAAH sakura had being in the industry for TEN WHOLE YEARS AND SHE STILL CANT SING. Yujin was an opera singer she sounds good but she still lacks. Eunchae and Zuha are new so they have an excuse. so don’t say “give them time” when there’s been time to give. Chaewon and Yujin are the only ones who can sing.
뉴진스는 그래도 영어권 애들이 많아서. 영어로 노래해도. 가사가 귀에 박히는데. 르세라핌은 영어권 두명인데 그중 하나는 맥그도나르도. 일본애. 나머지는 국산이라 영어가사가 책읽는 수준으로 귀에 안들리는게 제일 큰 문제다. 노래연습이고 뭐고 중요한게 아니라 발음좀 어캐 고치면 안되겠냐?
울겠다 울겠어
ㅋㅋㅋ😂
??
은채 툭 치면 울겠노
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
나는. 이걸 실드쳐주는 펜들이 더 신기함 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
라이브할때 제일 우울해....
잘하는데 왜 까는거에요?
연애해서 그런건가요?
@@searchtiangcatㅋ
@@searchtiangcatㅋㅋㅋㅋ 번역기쓰는거 보솤ㅋㅋㅋ
@@searchtiangcat ...?
채원도 잘부르는게 아니다 다른 멤버들이 진짜
답없으니 잘부르는거같이 보이는거지
조작멤...
당연..
아이즈원 라이브 삼대장이 김채원 조유리 권은비다 ㅇㅇ
@@sac00 아이즈원이 뭐 소녀시대급도 아니고 그 안에 삼대장이 뭔데ㅋㄱㅋㄱㄱ뭐 ..돼?
채원이 노래 잘하는데?..그럼 요즘 아이돌 비교하면 채원이보다 오래 못하는 아이돌 뒤로 나열하면 너뮤 많은데..
라이브 자신없어 하는게 느껴지는데....
다 같이 지를때마다 자신감 되찾은거 킹받노
이게 존나 웃기네 ㅋㅋ
개욱김ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
이지! 바디!
chaewon's vocal is stable
bc shes not dancing
@@sanaahmad4994does it look like they interacted with their fans?? I dont think so..😂
@@sanaahmad4994 i know💀 its just how cant they be stable while not dancing
@@sanaahmad4994 i never hated them😭 they´re literally my 2nd fav girl group
Not just stable, she's really great vocalist since half year of IZ*ONE b4 disbandment😊😁
벌칙 수행 하느라 표정 안좋은거봐 ㅜㅜ 어떡해
찢고있다는 저표정 개빸침ㅋㅋ
솔직히 찢고있다는 거만한표정은 아닌거같고 초긴장상태+불안+우울함 이거인듯 너무긴장해서 표정관리가안됨지금
찢고있단 표정은 전혀 아닌데..
하이브 특인듯 원희가 젤 킹받음
@@user-yv5zm8en7p레쓰꼬 레쯔꼬!
허윤진 말하는듯 진짜 ㄱ족같긴해@@user-yv5zm8en7p
Ok but can we talk about Kazuha’s encore improvement. It also helps that this song is more in here range than songs like unforgiven.
kazuha is definately improving but i really see no improvement in sakura. She embarrass lesserafim everysingle time.
@@SonalGupta-el7vvshe improved now
@@kqtiecxre._.No, in fact she became even more arrogant.
@@stantxtstraykidsandseventeen No? She sounds pretty stable and good now
@@kqtiecxre._. Sakura? Please bfr. When ppl have criticism she came out giving an arrogant response with no intent of improving. She hasn’t been stable for over a decade, she won’t be stable anytime soon, especially when she said that the group tried their “best”.
살다살다 앵콜 후보정영상은 첨보노
mr제거예요😮
????
@@NOONG__EE 카즈하 홍은채 목소리에서 기계음 다 느껴지는데 뭔소리임
아~ 혼란스러운 대한민국 k-pop…
도대체 뭐가 맞는거야…
튠 깐 거 개얼척없노
새로나온 개그 코너임?
진짜 은채는 11시반 픽업 어쩌구하면서 학생들 무시하면서 지 본업도 못하면 어카냐 다 소속사빨,선배들빨로 인지도 올렸으면 그에 맞게 노력해서 실력도 높여야지 뭔 저 지랄로 부르냐
그러니 개꿀이라한거지 ㅋㅋ 학생은 공부를 잘해야 성공하지만 아이돌은 걍 운이좋으면 되니까 개꿀!
라이브할때마다 독기가 사그라드나보네
I dont understand why are the comments so cruel? They actually sound pretty decent. Whats with the unnecessary hate train? Why cant we just criticize them constructively?
Hating on them wont help them improve vocally at all. Only constructive criticism.
Woah, yunjin has a deeper sounds for real 😮
Chaewon and kazuha are amazing esp chaewon she's great in everything
1위 앵콜 하면서 표정 안좋은 아이돌 처음본다
It’s those haters who f*ucking ruined it
@@yassminaiqich It was lit before all the hate, fym? 😂🙏
@@wsgbru..you comment too much on this channel, we can see it.
@@zoinith Its almost like cmts arent that hard to make lil bro, nd u rlly thought u sound cool. 😭🙏
@@wsgbru.. chronically online 🤥
Zuha improved so much
Are u kidding?
@@user-mc8eo1vj3dNo .
허윤진 저 오글거리는 제스처 좀 못하게해라
핫걸이시자나~
진짜 공감성수치 미치겠음 핫걸호소인
외국인임..미국인은 숨쉬는 제스처하는데
은채는 구라안까고 60세 우리엄마보다 못함
연준이한테 배워서그럼
CHAEWON ✨✨✨✨
그나마 잡고있던 동앗줄을 막내가 끊어버렸죠.. 걍 다 하찮아보임..
오냐 오냐 우리 막내 거리다가 그 막내가 팀원 전체 수장 시킬만한 개발언하고 라이브 대참사까지 ㅡㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ😂결말 맘에 든다
chaewon ❤️
춤을 추는 것도 아닌데…
이전에 앵콜무대로 욕 디지게 먹어서 그러는 거 아냐;; 그러니까 최근 앵콜무대로 비교하는 거지. 춤추고 하는 거 뭐 어차피 arㅈㄹ빵빵해서 분간도 안 가는 거랑 비교하겠냐. 아이돌은 이미 완성형으로 나왔어야지 무대를 거치며 성장하는 게 말이되냐라고 하고싶겠지만, 뭐 어떡함 이미 데뷔한 거. 돌이킬 수도 없는 거 곱씹으며 한탄해봤자 속만 답답하지. 저들이 발전해나가면 많이 발전했다 격려하고 여전히 머물러 있음 본업이면 노력 좀 하는 게 좋겠다는 쓴소리 정도 할 수 있지. 이제 대중의 피드백은 저들이 노력을 하냐 안 하냐가 기준임. 쟤들도 이미 회사를 통해서 데뷔되어 버린 상태에서 이젠 자신들의 부족함을 대중의 피드백을 통해 몸소 깨달음으로서 발전해나가는 수밖에 없지. 솔직히 저번 개망한 앵콜무대에 비하면 많이 발전했네.
@@Woohnf-bb8ev 아,,네
뒤에 아이돌 에게 내가 미안할뿐이네~내가
Chaewon!✨
긴장한게 눈에 보이네...솔직히 보는 사람도 불안함
That’s completely fine for me
Wow Kazuha is being stable in live!🤩🥰👏🏻👏🏻
they improved so much
저런것들이 가수라고
이노래가 이렇게 슬픈노래였구나
So good❤
툭 치면 울겠다
뉴진스는 배꼽인사 90도로 박으면서도
음정흔들림같은거 하나없이 앵콜라이브하던데ㅋㅋ
르세라핌 쟤네는 멀뚱히 서있으면서도
음정 박자 다 무시하고 쳐 부르면서도
표정 자신만만한거 개킹받음
My girls slaying as always ❤🎉 love you lesserafim
쇼츠로 머 이렇게 많이 올라오는건지...
Chaewon's vocal
@ricardobertuldo9744 lol you're trash 🗑️
@ricardobertuldo9744 are you talking about your whole existence?
Chaewon's, Eunchae's and Yunjin's vocal is stable❤
And others?😢
Kazuha and Sakura improved so they can all sing
Compare to their Unforgiven encore This is much better......i said This is much better.....ya cause look at sakura u can see a little improvement same to zuha.....they are not off key
I disagree this song requires more technique while singing while Unforgiven they pushed their voices more but also this wasn’t a bad encore people are just jealous. It’s what happens when you get up there in fame.
@@AD20918 i just said that, it is better than Unforgiven encore!!!chill!?yes ik this is not good... especially kura and zuha's vocals they need so much improvement.....
@@AD20918bejill dia cuma ngomong kalo suaranya zuha Ama kura lumayan meningkat
Chaewon. ❤❤❤❤ Le sserafim ❤❤
they are so good
Lesserafim is really a group of both visual and talent and yes every member improved a lot ❤
Yeah sakura & kazuha's vocals are amazing❤
Tell me you are kidding
Cheawon and yujin Compared to others, they are a little better
But other members just no
I love their songs but their real voice....
@@atosadlv3644 when I say talent its not only voice and kazuha Sakura and eunchae getting better from their debut and eunchae is also talented in dancing :)
But yes I don't think that much is ok for Coachella idk what they will do 🙂
@@Bini515 baby they are singers after all they need to have a good voice wich they don't have it
Nowadays, anyone who can move it body becomes an idol
@@atosadlv3644then why arent u an idol??? bc u cant move ur body as curved as them hah💀
댓글들도 다들 숙연해진거 개웃기네 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
이 쉬운 노래를 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
Kazuha 🎉🎉❤
This sounds good. They just don't look comfortable.
They struggle a little with lower notes, but I think they did pretty good
1위 했는데 왜 저리 불행해 보일까
I know now the need for the garam in this group, only chaewon and yunjin for the vocals is difficult
but eunchae is kinda good too tho
Garam is LONG GONE, everyone just needs to forget her 😭
@@sofficial6262 people haven't forgotten Jinni and Soojin, why should I forget garam? In a short time he stayed in the group he showed his importance in it, bringing softness to the songs
Eunchae should have more lines, she was really stable and truly has potential
Garam wasn’t even that good a singer either like please be for real. Source should have got better singers in the first place before they debuted
처음엔 화나다가 이젠 보면 걍 재밌음 ㅋㅋㅋ 이정도면 개그 프로그램 없어도 됨
아니 얘네 공식유튜브 댓 막힌거 다들 앎?
Chaewon voice so good
Kazuha improved so much🎉 i love kazuhaa❤
진짜 국가망신이다….채원이 안정적이라고?ㅋㅋㅋㅋ저런 음은 걍 일반인이 불러도 안정적임
이건 좀 억까임 ㅋㅋ 채원은 원래 아이즈원때도 노래 잘하는 편이였음
@@hyeonjikim4676ㅈㄹ하고있네 ㅋㅋㅋ
ㄹㅇ 난 카즈하가 진짜 못부르는듯
잘하는 꼴을 못봤는데 앉아서 부르는것도ㅠ립싱크하다가 걸리고 ㅋㅋㅋ
@@hyeonjikim4676 애초에 아이즈원은 주작아님?
실체를 몰랐을때 보컬 기대주 : 허윤진
실체 : 김채원이 최고실력자...?
I all are really hating on all of them for this, when the only one who couldn't sing well or was lacking was clearly sakura!
Love her but she clearly needs training.
But anyways i think this isn't overly bad
hate…a little strong word
Le Sserafim is such a talented group,I love them!! 💗💗
😂😂😂
Lol
Lol
the standard of their fans
this comment sections r TOXIC as hell. and they think its funny ppl support them. not a real fearnot naah yall r fake
노래는 르세라핌이지 ~ ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 얼마나 잘부르고 이쁘냐 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
zuhaa❤️❤️❤️
라이브만 하면 표정 다 굳네...
벌 받는거 마냥;;;;;
너무 몰아가는것같다..이때 앵콜은 그렇게 못하진 않았는데...
놀람
이게 못하지 않은 거라구요~! 그럼 얼마나 더 못 하는거야 도대체
@@차이이-m7r못한건 아닌것 같은데?...
언포기븐때보단 낫긴 햇죠 노래가 쉽기도 하고
문제는 코첼라..
코첼라 보면 이야기가 달라질텐데..
@@KimHaengbok24 솔직히 코첼라 보고 넘 충격 임
ㅋㅋㅋㅋ은채는 그냥 수능특강 펴라
Twice was very friendly while congratulating them
Everyone talking about how they improved… 🙄🤦🏻♀️ they are already idols who win a lot of money, they have a lot of prestige… they are going to coachella… they shouldn’t have the necessity to improve, they should be a minimum good just to debut but with all the prizes they are winning being this bad!! ..This must stop.. people who have the minimun talent to sing should debut…. And people mist stop glorifing visuals who give presentations like this….
근데 얘들이 이정도로 욕먹는게 이해 안가네요.
그냥 분위기에 휩쓸려서 보다 더 욕먹는 느낌 소속사랑 대처의 문제같은데... 트레이닝 받고 성장하는 모습 보여줬으면 합니다.
저거 자체만 보면 연습하면 해결될 일인데 몇몇 멤버는 연습해도 전혀 달라진게 없고요. 그 이후로 태도 논란에 뻐큐 사진 올렸고 겸손해지기는 커녕 배째라 시전해버리는데.. 코첼라 라이브 보고 오세요. 이 그룹은 이미 회생불가에요
친일 사이비 논점 흐리지마세요 어찌됐든 그 소속에 속해있습니다
Suka heran kalo sambil ngedance suaranya bagus, giliran nyantai suaranya kocak
Kazuha ❤❤
Zuha sayanggg , and serrafimm semangattt
how the hell are they gonna perform LIVE for coachella
let go of that damn coachella oh my god we already understood your jealousy
You can’t keep defending them, be honest, they got better but they still can’t sing
@@ARVINI0.0then try to sing yourself, i bet their vocals are better and how you’re saying that they still can’t sing ? Like Chaewon’s vocals are nothing ?
Fr
@@itzmemin they were trained for this not me. That group only has chaewon and yunjin who sound great
Chaewon carrying the encore as usual
i love them but it seems as tho only chaewon can sing 🫤
Are u basing it over this one clip?
@@Hi-ou4qnthey lipsinc in 99% of their performance 😂
Why are you judging based on this one video? Theyre improving, give them time.
@@Hi-ou4qngirl i’ve been a fear not since debut, i can watch so many clips to justify that chaewon is the only one who has some what of a technique yujin is ok
@@nwrhhh”give them time” HAAHHAAH sakura had being in the industry for TEN WHOLE YEARS AND SHE STILL CANT SING. Yujin was an opera singer she sounds good but she still lacks. Eunchae and Zuha are new so they have an excuse. so don’t say “give them time” when there’s been time to give. Chaewon and Yujin are the only ones who can sing.
Pero si cantan precioso
and they are going to perform at Coachella 😬
and so?
@@리아도따따 in few years Coachella will be joke 😂
If kpop idols going to perform 😂😂
Just say that youre jealous of them going to coachella despite being a 2 year old group lol
@@nwrhhh still they can't sing and that's the fact
@@siddhartharya1750 since you think you can sing better than them... try to sing infront of hundreds of people! :3
Yunjin is stable as always
그래도 용기내서 크게 불러주는것만으로도 만족! 앞으로도 용기내서 화이팅! 노래 못하면 뭐 어때요? 저렇게 하는것만으로도 좋은데! 열심히 해서 1위한거구 1위해서 떨리고 긴장할수도 있는거니까 오래 했어도 사람이라면 긴장하죠 그래도 참고 잘 해줘서 고마워 르세라핌!!!
Chaewon always good but all members can sing verry well ❤
뉴진스는 그래도 영어권 애들이 많아서. 영어로 노래해도. 가사가 귀에 박히는데. 르세라핌은 영어권 두명인데 그중 하나는 맥그도나르도. 일본애. 나머지는 국산이라 영어가사가 책읽는 수준으로 귀에 안들리는게 제일 큰 문제다. 노래연습이고 뭐고 중요한게 아니라 발음좀 어캐 고치면 안되겠냐?
솔짃니 노래난이도는 이게 더 어려움 살리기힘든 노래 이거보단 음을 높여야지 춤추면서도 부를수있을거임 대신 지르는부분은 채원 윤진한테 몰빵해야 욕 안먹을듯
김채원 의상 고정한거 신기해서 계속 보게됌
어떻게 고정했는지는 안 궁금하지만
대체 왜까이는거임? 음원이랑 존나 비슷한데?
다 트와이스봉들고 있는거 진짜 웃기다ㅋㅋ
Of course they need to sing live every idol is on their back hah
저 빨간머리는 왜케뭉개지냐고
eunchae is rlly good ngl
왜 단 한명도 창피함을 모를까??ㅠㅠ
완전 학예회 이하수준!!ㅠㅠ
은채야 진짜 수능특강 책 피자 가수로서는 희망이 없다 진짜
Chaewon: ".... I'm the real one ...." yeah girl you are the real one that can sing tbh 😂
얘네 왜케 다운 되어있나용??😢
흥얼흥얼 맥아리없는 쇼츠용 릴스용 챌린지용 스밍용 노래를 뽑으니까 라이브에서 이꼴나지 보컬이 사는 노래 들고 나오면 라이브 훨 듣기 좋을듯 그래도 은채는 가망이 없겠지만...
이상한 인신공격 댓글쓰는 애들이 많네
다른건 몰라도 떼창만 안했으면 좋겠다..
The only problem before is that they sang it like not their key or their range so this song is much better
르세라핌 : 아 씨.. 삑사리 나면 어뜨카지 > 1위 했다~
Lmao they look like they are all being held hostage
Are they singing or reading?
Haha very savage you ate
아니 춤안추면 아무 재미도 없는 이걸 라이브로 듣는 지금 케이팝의 원흉은 누구일까😂
they sing well here. It is simply their energy and performance that indicates their lack of confidence in their abilities
They atte specially Chaewon
Continue playing the flute until the end
Twice is in the back 😭😭😭💗