So brave of him to change Comfortably Numb. I think its a beautiful version. And works perfectly with the ambience of the show. Well done again Roger for pulling off yet another masterpiece in visual and audio effect. Can't wait to see the show. Scott Warner thanks for sharing my friend.
On his Us and Them Tour, he had Lucius as his backup vocals and they were absolutely incredible. These two women are equally amazing. Like all PF music, there is so much importance on the background vocals, this is no different. Incredible video, thanks for posting.
Thank you for capturing this! Roger has never disappointed when it comes to the creative surprises, and this this time around was right up there with all the best of them. I was hoping somebody would capture that really haunting and cool version of comfortably numb that started the show that was just so awesome.
This was an amazing rendition of Comfortably Numb LIVE. I was at the show it was beautiful Great Show as usual from Roger. Thank u Roger Waters for all the great music over the years and just Stunning Live performances especially the Pink Floyd years Thank you Love Ya !!!!
I usually don´t like when artists change their music to much live but this version och Comfortably numb is fantastic. I hope there will be a livealbum from this tour.
@@kingtrance307 Changed?? I wasn't taking to you, fool. In fact, I am never talking to anyone who hopes there will be "at least a blu ray" of anything.
Esse show foi demais, pelo visto!!!!!! Se vier pro Brasil, pretendo ir....amo o Roger Walters e seu Pink Floyd....não podem faltar na minha playlist, de final de semana ❤
I like the version of Comfortably numb a lot. But, how is it for the people sitting behind the stage? Is it always like that, that he is singing only in front of the people lucky enough to be on that corner? I don't know if I wanna go if I am just going to see their backs
I had third row seats on the floor. They do a good job of trying to play to all sides of the arena. That screen is only lowered to the stage for the opening number. Roger and the band work the stage, hitting all four sides. It's only when he is at piano that he seems to be still.
@@natemurray311 - The concept is 💯% his as Waters wrote all of it. You can assume whatever bullshit you like but he certainly reserves the right to do what he likes. He doesn’t give a shit what anybody else thinks!
he did all happiest days of our lives, then both parts of another brick, followed by some of his original songs. then stuff like wish you were here and sheep. He took a 20 minute break and then the second set was in the flesh, run like hell, some more original songs, then he did us and them and ran through the rest of dark side and eclipse was the finale. He did two suns in a sunset, is this the life we really want, and finished with outside the wall.
This 360 degree stage does not work. It is no fun going to a concert and looking at the back of their heads except an occasional presence......Seems to me money grubbing to try to sell all seatss. When I go to a concert I want a comprehensive experience of the WHOLE band, not having the singer come around once in a while and the drummer actually facing me for part of the concert. WHAT A JOKE! Moreover, what a jip! The music WAS GREAT, but as far as a concert experience, forget about it. You have video at home. Just not as big. Wow.......
grant arnold 23 hours ago i bought vip tickets and arrived only to find out i was behind the action. great. second row seats. he played to the other side and the stupid people around me clapped furiously when we were gracioulsy blessed with his presence. what a joke! and what a waste of money. the music was great but i felt like i spent a ton of money on a video. it was obscene. he talks a good game of the little man, but i cant help but seeing this stage setup as nothing more than a money grab. what a hypocrite! in fact, i bought not one but two tshirts prior to the concert starting because i was so jazzed. im' almost embarrassed to werar them. the fact that he sold out 360 degrees of viewership and actually made the comment during my concert that" it wasnt sold out, but we didnt sell out" was a laughable thing! put your fans in front of your show! we saw NOTHING mostly but videos! MoneyGrubber!!!!!!!!!! Im turned off!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Thank you for posting this. I had tickets to the LA show, but after the setlist was released I was skeptical and hearing that rendition of comfortably numb hurt. He replaced one of the greatest guitar solos of all time with keyboards, sound fx and vocals??? I LOVE Roger Waters political stuff.. thought US&THEM tour was incredible... but UGH. Sold my tickets this morning and will skip this tour.. Would've loved to have seen Sheep live, but I'm paying to go for one song at the end of 1 set.
I'm now looking for better seats! If you've been seeing him for 305 or more years I can not understand your thinking. This version is a great departure. Did you REALLY want to see the same arrangement - again and again?
@@JustMe-ed1cq When I go to Concerts I like to say "They just sounded like the Album" and they put on a good show! Sorry I can't do it with this so called Drill..Have Fun
just a question- how can you hate his politics while enjoying pink floyds music? do you not understand the meaning behind each lyric in each song? or do you just turn a blind eye because it’s a nice sound? it just makes no sense to me how one can call themselves a fan and yet hate the reason they make music, to shed light on issues that no other artists want to shed light on in fear of losing their audience.
@@natemurray311 huh, it's almost like music, and art in general, can be interpreted in different ways as times change, and can be augmented to fit the problems of our current world
Really boring lack luster version of comfortably numb. Cheezy effects and depressing politically divisive video content. I saw pink Floyd in 1977 oylimpic stadium montreal. That was a show. This is watered down crap. 😆 🤣 😂
This is no longer about the music. It has become a gimmicky rerun of all his previous tours. I love pink Floyd but this is not about the music. If you truly love music and the experience of seeing the greatest band in the world go see Radiohead if you are lucky enough to have the opportunity.
All Waters' shows were much more exciting than every Floyd show without him. Floyd still was a good band, don' t get me wrong, but when Waters left this something special was gone with him. Gilmours, Wright' s and Mason' s ambition was just to sound good, Waters has the ambition to write something with a consistent message.
Yikes. Not sure I want to pay money to get words flashed in my face all night while RW lip-synchs his way through 50% of the show. Also, of all the songs to rework, you're going to cut the balls off of Comfortably Numb?
I think comfortably numb sounded so beautiful. I know it so very different but what a way to start the show. I thought like what the hell is this but it grew on me so very fast. It soooo damn beautiful!!!!!
The band was good, they held up. Roger just stood there and wasn't even doing anything during 2 songs. Comfortably Numb is my all time fav. So that was a let down.
I seen original Floyd 4 times including In the Flesh (Animals Tour) and Rogers solo 5 times this was the worst concert I've ever seen it was actually boring no bells or whistles just a big screen and a dead band if he thinks he's gonna change the world with his political view I got a bridge to sell ya, To me it was a night out but disappointing all around trust me he did better before this one.Save your money
I'm going to be really honest. I would not recommend going to this show. It was a non stop political message. I understand how Roger Waters feels about things and I actually agree with a lot of what he believes in. The whole time the videos were all depressing and were pushing political views. It would have been fine to show half of what they did but to push the human suffering and politics the ENTIRE show was just ridicuolous. *****below here was added the next day***** Looking back there was a section where he showed a lot of old clips of him and Syd Barrett during the early years. That was cool and Waters did leave the politics out of that. So it wasn't the entire show but it was easily 90% of it.
@@keithbarry3057 Animals tour (70's), The Wall tour (70-80's), Radio K.A.O.S. tour, In the flesh tour 2000's, The Wall tour 10's, Us+Them Tour... This guy never listened Pink Floyd/Roger before last night, I guess.
@@uz7097 I think he is referring to the visuals not just the music. Animals 1970's did not bombard the audience with doom and gloom projections. Neither did the original wall - all visuals related to the character of Pink. RADIO KAOS was also not overly political and apart from the strange concept and the threat of nuclear weapons - that's as political as it got. In the flesh didnt. It was not visually political at all. DSOTM tour , same applied. Just visuals that fitted the music. Most political it got was " leaving beirut" and " vote OBAMA " on the pig. The wall 2010 onwards was not over political either apart from anti war sentiment US and THEM tour is where the lecture became ridiculous with endless childish digs at Trump, but the visuals and gig still impressive, despite Roger recently releasing his worst album " is this the life we really want " I can't comment on this latest tour as i haven't seen enough of it. But hes had over 2 years to put this together. So far i'm not liking the middle of arena stage and songs hes done to death ( what the hell has he done to comf numb !) and if its a lecture fest i will be giving it a miss. I'm not being lectured by a champagne socialist millionaire selling sky high price tickets to watch him mime to vocal playback and $30 for a t shirt made by slave labour. I've heard 90% of the material played too many times and i won't be lectured on politics / human rights when Roger only cares about human rights that suit his politics. Maybe he should show the horrors going on in China , etc.....but i doubt it.
Pink Floyd's always been political this is true but they have not always been activist especially not their concerts. Im out! Honestly David gilmour in Chicago is way better! And Nick Mason's saucerful of secrets is great because they just want to play Floyd music and not stuff garbage down your throat. He's the real pink. The only one on every Pink Floyd album.
@@scottystatic I saw him in 2019 at the Paramount in Denver here and they honestly were amazing! Nick Mason just wants to play Pink Floyd, he didn't talk about politics once. Just that he wanted to play Pink Floyd music but the other band members just want to bicker still unfortunately.
@@kingtrance307 like I said I've been a die-hard Pink Floyd fan for more than 40 years. I know their history pretty well I've read about them watch documentaries and everything. I'm just saying this sounds like shit.
So brave of him to change Comfortably Numb. I think its a beautiful version. And works perfectly with the ambience of the show. Well done again Roger for pulling off yet another masterpiece in visual and audio effect. Can't wait to see the show. Scott Warner thanks for sharing my friend.
In 7 days I'm heading to Chicago to see the show,my first time and I grew up listening to Pink Floyd. I'm super stoked. Awesome video!
On his Us and Them Tour, he had Lucius as his backup vocals and they were absolutely incredible. These two women are equally amazing. Like all PF music, there is so much importance on the background vocals, this is no different. Incredible video, thanks for posting.
Thank you for capturing this! Roger has never disappointed when it comes to the creative surprises, and this this time around was right up there with all the best of them.
I was hoping somebody would capture that really haunting and cool version of comfortably numb that started the show that was just so awesome.
Roger Waters is the greatest musician he always was and always will be to me he is my baby love
What I love the most is how he firmly puts up the middle finger to the establishment…without fear of getting “cancelled.” I’m w you Roger. FK em ALL!
A superb version. Thanks , mate.
This was an amazing rendition of Comfortably Numb LIVE. I was at the show it was beautiful Great Show as usual from Roger. Thank u Roger Waters for all the great music over the years and just Stunning Live performances especially the Pink Floyd years Thank you Love Ya !!!!
good evening roger and pink floyd and friends, thank you for this concert/video.......wonderfulll again
have a look on UA-cam at METAL GIRLS REACT TO PINK FLOYD
Great job I love it so creative
Thank You So Much for this Mr. Warner!
Damn it looks great. I dont mind the politics as i agree with him on a lot of stuff so it shouldnt be bad.
I usually don´t like when artists change their music to much live but this version och Comfortably numb is fantastic. I hope there will be a livealbum from this tour.
Indeed sir. I also hope there will be a 4K Ultra Disc or at least a Blu Ray of the TINAD tour released! 👍
One day you'll see how hard it is to be you the same way every day and I hope you like changing yourself.
@@tvviewer4500 - Well you changed into a troll so how hard can it possibly be?
@@kingtrance307 Changed?? I wasn't taking to you, fool. In fact, I am never talking to anyone who hopes there will be "at least a blu ray" of anything.
@@tvviewer4500 - What’s wrong with concert blu rays. Get off your f*cking high horse.
Amazing! Thank you, Scott. I’ve got to get tickets.
Damn, this is a good angle--and pretty good sound!
I’m seeing Roger in Las Vegas in October. Can’t wait.
that intro speech lmao he's a legend
my dream is to watch this live
Esse show foi demais, pelo visto!!!!!! Se vier pro Brasil, pretendo ir....amo o Roger Walters e seu Pink Floyd....não podem faltar na minha playlist, de final de semana ❤
Great sound!
Благодарю за панораму питсбурского концерта, - теперь вполне понятно как впадают в комфортное оцепенение.
Amo...admiro Roger Waters desde sempre...❤️😍
What a killer Stage
Thanks! finally a steady shot.
Is it Lachy Doley playing the Hammond? Wishing this tour to come to Brazil. Spetacular!
Sounds like he’s “pouring his derision” on everybody
🤣🤣
That is wild.
Canada \ Toronto\
!
Merci 😀👍
I didn't know you can make Comfortably Numb a more depressing song
And more relevant.
After listening to this Numb boom effects version, I'm gonna write a trailer version
Word !
Where is Roger Waters during the song? I havê seen differents vídeo but i can not really where he is
In what seat and section were you?
@1:55 Well, we know of at least ONE person who doesn't know how to follow instructions...
I just missed this show in Toronto. Now I hate myself.
FOCUS!!!!
Awesome
GGGRRRR! Even watching a video of a show I'm distracted by some schmuch in the next row on his phone.
Demais! (Brasil)
How was show?
And we have become "Comfortably Numb" to the destruction of our planet; will the next generation have a planet?
Rod, You worry about leaving a better Planet for our kids? How about leaving better Kids for our Planet.
Do you think there's a BETTER part of the arena where to sit? Did Roger or the band stay more on one side or another? Or it's the same all-around?
Most members moved around the stage Roger the most only the drummer was stationary
@@s.r.345 Selfish drummer! 😆
@@davidrobertson3633 🤣🤣🤣
I like the version of Comfortably numb a lot. But, how is it for the people sitting behind the stage? Is it always like that, that he is singing only in front of the people lucky enough to be on that corner? I don't know if I wanna go if I am just going to see their backs
Don't know where to sit either?
Don't know where to sit either?
I had third row seats on the floor. They do a good job of trying to play to all sides of the arena. That screen is only lowered to the stage for the opening number. Roger and the band work the stage, hitting all four sides. It's only when he is at piano that he seems to be still.
@@karinroberts4920 Sit at home this was his worst concert ever and I seen him 5 times before and Floyd 4 times, nothing to write home about..
🤘💕🤘💕
I believe one, if not the reason that he changed 'Comfortably Numb' was to spite David.
Obviously it can be done w/o guitars, he also sang David's lines. I think he is reclaiming a LOT here.
Yep, that was my instant thought as well. He doesn't realize how important the other members in the band were regardless of who had the concept.
@@natemurray311 - The concept is 💯% his as Waters wrote all of it. You can assume whatever bullshit you like but he certainly reserves the right to do what he likes. He doesn’t give a shit what anybody else thinks!
Omg I NEED A BODYGUARD
David Gilmour!!!!!!!!
What were all the songs that he sang?
he did all happiest days of our lives, then both parts of another brick, followed by some of his original songs. then stuff like wish you were here and sheep. He took a 20 minute break and then the second set was in the flesh, run like hell, some more original songs, then he did us and them and ran through the rest of dark side and eclipse was the finale. He did two suns in a sunset, is this the life we really want, and finished with outside the wall.
@@trevorclark7985 Ohh okk perfect. I'll wait for him in Miami. Thx.
Did they played Pigs?
Yeah, a little bit.
They played Sheep, not Pigs.
The Wall (part 74)
This 360 degree stage does not work. It is no fun going to a concert and looking at the back of their heads except an occasional presence......Seems to me money grubbing to try to sell all seatss. When I go to a concert I want a comprehensive experience of the WHOLE band, not having the singer come around once in a while and the drummer actually facing me for part of the concert. WHAT A JOKE! Moreover, what a jip! The music WAS GREAT, but as far as a concert experience, forget about it. You have video at home. Just not as big. Wow.......
Do they ask for proof of vaccination to attend to this concert?
Apart from his wishes it depends on the venue.
They did not at PPG in Pittsburgh.
Hahahahahah that was a good one mate
Would’ve been great to see the best Pink Floyd cover band of all time…..but I f’d off to the bar.
Thanks for that
grant arnold
23 hours ago
i bought vip tickets and arrived only to find out i was behind the action. great. second row seats. he played to the other side and the stupid people around me clapped furiously when we were gracioulsy blessed with his presence. what a joke! and what a waste of money. the music was great but i felt like i spent a ton of money on a video. it was obscene. he talks a good game of the little man, but i cant help but seeing this stage setup as nothing more than a money grab. what a hypocrite! in fact, i bought not one but two tshirts prior to the concert starting because i was so jazzed. im' almost embarrassed to werar them. the fact that he sold out 360 degrees of viewership and actually made the comment during my concert that" it wasnt sold out, but we didnt sell out" was a laughable thing! put your fans in front of your show! we saw NOTHING mostly but videos! MoneyGrubber!!!!!!!!!! Im turned off!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
He’s a bitter old millionaire now
And you are a bitter... who are you, BTW?
Multi Millionaire….
In the begining i think was time
Thank you for posting this. I had tickets to the LA show, but after the setlist was released I was skeptical and hearing that rendition of comfortably numb hurt. He replaced one of the greatest guitar solos of all time with keyboards, sound fx and vocals??? I LOVE Roger Waters political stuff.. thought US&THEM tour was incredible... but UGH. Sold my tickets this morning and will skip this tour.. Would've loved to have seen Sheep live, but I'm paying to go for one song at the end of 1 set.
"Sold my tickets this morning and will skip this tour" Smart
I'm now looking for better seats! If you've been seeing him for 305 or more years I can not understand your thinking. This version is a great departure. Did you REALLY want to see the same arrangement - again and again?
@@JustMe-ed1cq Yes... very much so. This sounds like radiohead covered it poorly. You take out one of the best guitar parts in history???
"Sold my tickets..." = madness!!!!
@@JustMe-ed1cq When I go to Concerts I like to say "They just sounded like the Album" and they put on a good show! Sorry I can't do it with this so called Drill..Have Fun
I was thinking of going to see him but after seeing how political he’s making the shows I’m out. It’s about music not his political views!
just a question- how can you hate his politics while enjoying pink floyds music? do you not understand the meaning behind each lyric in each song? or do you just turn a blind eye because it’s a nice sound? it just makes no sense to me how one can call themselves a fan and yet hate the reason they make music, to shed light on issues that no other artists want to shed light on in fear of losing their audience.
I love Roger best of British 🇬🇧
I was excited about potentially going to this show but the fact that Comfortably Numb was totally destroyed is enough to tell me to save my money
it was good quit whining
@@icypick1001 No, he's changed the meaning of the Pink Floyd songs. Goodbye old blues skies.
@@icypick1001 Your 'opinion'.
Completamente de acuerdo!!!
@@natemurray311 huh, it's almost like music, and art in general, can be interpreted in different ways as times change, and can be augmented to fit the problems of our current world
That looks like a horrendous stage set up.
Bit difficult to think of this as anything other than a box ticking virtue signalling (for profit) exercise. Shame, I had higher hopes
Lame. I’d ask for a ticket refund
Wow, he starts the the set with a Dave Gilmour song, interesting at least.
Really boring lack luster version of comfortably numb. Cheezy effects and depressing politically divisive video content.
I saw pink Floyd in 1977 oylimpic stadium montreal. That was a show. This is watered down crap. 😆 🤣 😂
No, Sir: don't like it... 🤷
R.I.P PINK FLOYD
Since 1994
@@uz7097 1985
@@jansenmann 1968
2006
Since 1985
This is no longer about the music. It has become a gimmicky rerun of all his previous tours. I love pink Floyd but this is not about the music. If you truly love music and the experience of seeing the greatest band in the world go see Radiohead if you are lucky enough to have the opportunity.
Are you serious? Radiohead?
This whiney band is perfect for to lay down in a bath tub and slash the wrists artery.
how loud was it?
Normal concert volume
maybe 100 db, not like metallica loud but loud enough
@@scottystatic gotcha thank u. I think im going def lol. my decibel volume is usually at 80-90 with earbuds eek
A rip off again...
A giant cross that is tied to idolatry and the Jesus agenda?
Big mistake!
Ahh, the socialist/capitalist at it again🙄
Just go to the f*cking bar, mate. And don't come back.
All Waters' shows were much more exciting than every Floyd show without him.
Floyd still was a good band, don' t get me wrong, but when Waters left this something special was gone with him.
Gilmours, Wright' s and Mason' s ambition was just to sound good, Waters has the ambition to write something with a consistent message.
One of the best PF song but one of the worst version😥
Zero interest going now.
So tired of the political bS.
So you can go to the f*cking bar, mate. You and your bS.
Yikes. Not sure I want to pay money to get words flashed in my face all night while RW lip-synchs his way through 50% of the show. Also, of all the songs to rework, you're going to cut the balls off of Comfortably Numb?
I think comfortably numb sounded so beautiful. I know it so very different but what a way to start the show. I thought like what the hell is this but it grew on me so very fast. It soooo damn beautiful!!!!!
The band was good, they held up. Roger just stood there and wasn't even doing anything during 2 songs. Comfortably Numb is my all time fav. So that was a let down.
I wonder what David Gilmour thinks of this version?
@@dixienormous2440 👎 Dave has just entered the chat
@@dixienormous2440 Dave doesn’t do anything nowadays. He has no backbone to speak his mind like RW.
I seen original Floyd 4 times including In the Flesh (Animals Tour) and Rogers solo 5 times this was the worst concert I've ever seen it was actually boring no bells or whistles just a big screen and a dead band if he thinks he's gonna change the world with his political view I got a bridge to sell ya, To me it was a night out but disappointing all around trust me he did better before this one.Save your money
The more videos I see of this tour....makes me not want to go
@@rayjohnson2387 good
nobody gives a shit what you say. positive feedback to your negative bullshit outnumber you a billion to one.
@@rcpsammy7186 bite me
So why didn't you go to the f*cking bar, mate?
I'm going to be really honest. I would not recommend going to this show. It was a non stop political message. I understand how Roger Waters feels about things and I actually agree with a lot of what he believes in. The whole time the videos were all depressing and were pushing political views. It would have been fine to show half of what they did but to push the human suffering and politics the ENTIRE show was just ridicuolous.
*****below here was added the next day*****
Looking back there was a section where he showed a lot of old clips of him and Syd Barrett during the early years. That was cool and Waters did leave the politics out of that. So it wasn't the entire show but it was easily 90% of it.
First time in a Roger's show?
Sounds not too different from Us and Them tour no?
@@keithbarry3057 Animals tour (70's), The Wall tour (70-80's), Radio K.A.O.S. tour, In the flesh tour 2000's, The Wall tour 10's, Us+Them Tour...
This guy never listened Pink Floyd/Roger before last night, I guess.
@@uz7097 I think he is referring to the visuals not just the music. Animals 1970's did not bombard the audience with doom and gloom projections. Neither did the original wall - all visuals related to the character of Pink.
RADIO KAOS was also not overly political and apart from the strange concept and the threat of nuclear weapons - that's as political as it got.
In the flesh didnt. It was not visually political at all.
DSOTM tour , same applied. Just visuals that fitted the music. Most political it got was " leaving beirut" and " vote OBAMA " on the pig.
The wall 2010 onwards was not over political either apart from anti war sentiment
US and THEM tour is where the lecture became ridiculous with endless childish digs at Trump, but the visuals and gig still impressive, despite Roger recently releasing his worst album " is this the life we really want "
I can't comment on this latest tour as i haven't seen enough of it. But hes had over 2 years to put this together. So far i'm not liking the middle of arena stage and songs hes done to death ( what the hell has he done to comf numb !) and if its a lecture fest i will be giving it a miss. I'm not being lectured by a champagne socialist millionaire selling sky high price tickets to watch him mime to vocal playback and $30 for a t shirt made by slave labour. I've heard 90% of the material played too many times and i won't be lectured on politics / human rights when Roger only cares about human rights that suit his politics. Maybe he should show the horrors going on in China , etc.....but i doubt it.
Should have went to the bar
Pink Floyd's always been political this is true but they have not always been activist especially not their concerts. Im out! Honestly David gilmour in Chicago is way better! And Nick Mason's saucerful of secrets is great because they just want to play Floyd music and not stuff garbage down your throat. He's the real pink. The only one on every Pink Floyd album.
I'm headed to see Nick Mason in Sept. Can't freaking wait.
@@scottystatic I saw him in 2019 at the Paramount in Denver here and they honestly were amazing! Nick Mason just wants to play Pink Floyd, he didn't talk about politics once. Just that he wanted to play Pink Floyd music but the other band members just want to bicker still unfortunately.
David gilmour is on tour again?
@@tjprptchable 2016. Shortly after, he sold most of his Floyd guitars.
@@tjprptchable Not yet.
This is just horribly unlistenable! And Pink Floyd is my favorite band since 40+ years!
You have never been to a Waters show then right? This isn’t a PF concert. Waters wrote The Wall along with everything else when he was a member.
@@kingtrance307 like I said I've been a die-hard Pink Floyd fan for more than 40 years. I know their history pretty well I've read about them watch documentaries and everything. I'm just saying this sounds like shit.
@@kingtrance307 David wrote a lot of it as well.