Being an Indian Punjabi, now I know ke Nehru aur Gandhi partition ke liye agree kaise ho gye. They were afraid of Punjabi Domination on whole Indian Subcontinent. 😂😂
Karachi dominating Pakistan doesn't makes any sense. Just because some business elites belong to urdu speaking people does not makes Karachi and its people privileged. In fact most of the Karachi's elite class has generational wealth that has little to do with the tax money and state resources. Karachi and its people have been serving and contributing to this nation since 47 despite the fact that the city had and was provided with little resources ( now it is deprived of even basic infrastructure). Please discuss that how the racist and discriminatory policies of Ayub Khan and quota system of Bhutto has marginalized the urdu speaking community. How much percentage of people holding Karachi domicile/urdu speaking hold positions in national & provincial assemblies, civil services, , forces or any public offices? Considering these facts do you still believe that Karachi in some way dominates Pakistan??
@@mehwishjameel6738lahore was also developed by hindu Sikh businessman what happened when these people got controll of this city they ruined it nowcit is bankrupt lahore and karachi were respectively 4th and 5th richest city of British India respectively
To be honest most business was in Punjabi and Gujarati hands. North Indian Muslims were generally in bureaucracy and in professional jobs. The majority were skilled labour though.
@@RoseBenjamin-e4b if your Sindhi or Pashtun and working for the system and just colonial and your identity has nothing to do with it. If you're a Punjabi or Muhajir working for the system then you'll be identified as a Punjabi or a Muhajir
This dude has something against urdu speaking people. Also the urdu speaking elite in karachi consists of educated people who are contributing to society and have opened their businesses through their own hardwork. Yet despite contributing to Pakistan instead of free loading off the economy like the other provinces karachi people have zero facilities. High utility rates, loadshedding , crime,poor infrastructure and poor waste disposal are the issues plaguing karachi because ppp doesn't want to spend a penny on this city. Even our airport looks so outdated.
Babe . PPP doesn't spend anything on anyone but themselves. And I have lived in Karachi and interior Sindh and in Punjab. Bro if karachi doesn't have any facilities. Then the other cities don't even exist
If people of subcontinent unite we won't be spending on our defense that budget could be used towards health infrastructure uplifting poverty etc. For that to happen peace between India Pakistan Bangladesh China is vital A decade of normalcy will lead to opening of trade relations Two decades post opening of trade relation businesses should ask for common markets in subcontinent like the EU and privatize non strategic industries
@@FondyachoThen it will raise questions on the existence of the Pakistani army and what's the need of it. And they will not allow peace. They are the main hurdle.
@@RahulMishra-ld2bo nobody is the hurdle if they are made part of it Army of both nations aren't any different they consist of the same people. If both nations agree on cutting spending on imports of weapons we would have less non state actors today our weapon exports mainly US Russia China have interest in both countries not being at peace
Too early to comment, but thumbnail is weird. Dominated by Karachi? Karachi is literally one of the worst city of Pakistan. Not only Pakistan, but it is in top5 least livable cities in world. Yeah Karachi gets more coverage but the condition of the city and it's residents is miserable ....
you missed Pathan... last 10 to 15 years me Muhajir replaced by Pathan. AFA resources is concerned, Maazrat k sath wo resources bad me Sindhis or Pathan ko bhi mile but Sindhis wo kamyabi hasil nhi ker sake.
@@ThePakistanExperience whoever introduced the google system first, does not matter any more, you are living in past or now ??? What it’s doing now, how it’s exploiting and marginalizing the section of society? When you defend quota system you bring a racism out, because inside you, you don’t consider Urdu speaker as Sindhi !
@@ThePakistanExperience bhai, I am a Urdu speaker, and criticize them the most in private and public circles. We came from India and Sindhi people gave their land, my uncle did a study back in 60s and found that there 35 villages in the area that is now PECHS, the local poor Sindhis not only forcefully evicted but also never given any compensation. My only beef is quota system, and it’s not doing what it was intended for , hope you can understand!
Don't you think Punjab is dominating due to their: 1. Cosmopolitanism ( accepting outsiders in their capabilities and giving them opportunities) 2. Adaptibility to the changing world in becoming less aggressive despite their historical warrior nature 3. No racism in giving jobs to fellow Pakistanis 4. Contribution to the nationalism for Pakistan ( abandoning their ethnical heroes like bhagat singh, sardar udham singh, who played a crucial role in partition, and treating them like nobodies) 5. Leaving their connection with the Hindu Punjab just for Pakistan ( leaving punjabi culture and a history expanding from Ranjit Singh to Raja Porus) 6. Despite the exploitation in southern punjab nobody firing rockets on security forces 7. Not being violent and radicalized even after the slogans of " jaag Punjabi jaag teri pag nu lag gya daag" ( provincial card was always a flop against the punjabis) So I think the exploited ones should question their leaders ( tribal ones, sardars) who charge their cut but do nothing for the development of underdeveloped and underprivileged people. We should ask our immediate leaders to solve our problems and should not hold others responsible for our problems especially after passing of 18th amendment.
Karachi is the country's biggest cash cow only, contributing a significant amount of tax revenue, yet it has no say in any matters. The middle class of this city has always been hated by the Punjabi mafia aka Punjabi army. This country is run by the uneducated duffers of the army, recruited mainly from the dusty towns of Punjab. It's a fact, and anyone who disagrees is simply denying reality.
Am working in civil am born here in.islamabad and i have friends from all provinces but i never saw a punjbi used a racist word ordo anything like that which shows and felt like that.but i saw this from pashtuns people they are racist i have many friends but in reality am not such aracist and biased person but reality is reality. and punjabi is no more punjabis their culture is changed language changed bcoz of sacrifices they are not snatching any money and doing anything from anyone but area of punjab is traditionally non violent for anyone that is why it is the place of opportunity and investment without any fear and racism. Now punjab is dominted by kashiris who migrated here like butts khwajas meers sheikh they are stronger than local Punjabis jutt gujjarand rajput.(Rana)big tribe of punjabs.wven you can see that in.politics no big real.punjabi leader..
Karachi is hub. People have moved from all over Pakistan. Developing karachi isn’t like exploiting the country…. Pakistan should develop one city as hub for all Pakistan.
The hub was exploited and now is in no condition to be named as one. I wish the same mistake is not repeated with Gwadar. if you live in Karachi, you would know many things, Karachi suffers from Gareeb capture more than Elite capture.
The Pakistan ExperienceShehzad Ghias Shaikh Dear Shahzad, Perhaps you should also consider doing a podcast on racially biased and highly discriminatory Quota System in Sindh which has led to resentment by the other ethnic groups in the Sindh Province. As a suggestion, please make title of your podcast, “Does Sindh use Quota System as a tool to subjugate minorities in Sindh? “
@@ThePakistanExperience Shahzad Bhai, when you frame your race based narrative towards Punjabis then you call it fact. When we point out similar narrative towards Sindhi Feudal and Quota System then you call it race profiling. Why the two standards?
The domination of any group over state structures is determined by its overall population. The Punjabis constitues around 60 percent population of the Pakistan so there majority in govt institutions is a natural but to mitigate this tendency to some extent, there are quotas in federal jobs for other provinces such as Fata, rural Sindh and Balochistan. But there is a catch, according to some stats the Pathan's representation in Pakistan military is more than their average share of population. Similarly, the rural Sindhis are the great beneficiary of the Civil service jobs as there's a separate quota for rural Sindh which I think put the urban youth of Karachi and Hyderabad at a great disadvantage. You mention in your video that Karachis are dominating the state structures, this is argument is factual incorrect in contemporary times although it's relevant during initial days of Pakistan. This video really disappoints me because you're using the same identity politics as other pusedo intellectuals are doing in Pakistan to be recognize in intellectual circles. Don't focus on these assumptions, come up with facts and majority on the basis of population is natural thing, why it's wrong on moral and principle grounds?
Punjab is also into 3 parts. North south and central. North is wealthies central also have wealthy people and people are happy on their life. South is deprived like kpk , sindh , balochistan . Karachi is harted and deprived on another level 😅
Very misleading and racist video, facts are mostly true but they way he presented was to paint Urdu speaker and Punjabi as evil, how conveniently you forget about Sindhi elite and Waderas who are exploiting the poor Sindhis, plus mixing elite gujrati and memons with Urdu speakers of UP, Bihar or central India who are mostly poor middle class, hardworking people. The way you describing paint one ethnic group evil, then this lead killing poor Punjabis by BLA. Hope you can also talk about Sindhi elite exploitation!
@@ThePakistanExperience bhai Jan , hum tu bewaqof log hein Kay app ko neutral or izzat kartay hein, pehlay Khoob jee bhar Kay Urdu speaker or Punjabi ko gali day do phir later in the for 5 sec apni Sindhi ko token baat Kar lo. Acha formula hai !
@@ThePakistanExperience by the way I thought you will delete my comment, but at least you let me vent my frustration against quota system and bardasht my comment, thank you.
So, you see, the thing is, in bureaucracy and in public services jobs ( practiced internationally) that a person doesn't get appointments in their own district due to personal biases may affect the decisions . I know this may come as a surprise but most people in Sindh specifically in interior Sindh speak Sindhi And government jobs, especially in police and bureaucracy such as Assistant Commissioner, DSP, SHO, they are the jobs that are connected with the local people. They need to be connected with the locals to solve their problems. When one does not even understand or does not even know what the problems of the people are, he or she can't even understand what locals are saying. You might say that why don't they learn Urdu. You want the whole village/ possibly city to speak a new language to accommodate a new guy who came to city hmmm 🤔 says a lot about narcissism. So the thing about this is you want us to learn your language ( assuming you speak Urdu ) but u don't want to take effort to learn ours. ( No relation to this but recently a new DSP got posted in my city he is from karachi comes from an Urdu speaking background. But he learned Sindhi to understand locals and their problems)
@@khalilismail1396 I am no expert on quota system. If this channel makes a video to discuss quota system it would give people like me the opportunity to learn more about its merits and demerits. My point was that if Karachi really dominated the government power structure wouldn't they have gotten rid of the quota system in 40 years? By the way I think Commissioners and Dy. Commissioners are from the federal government not provincial government. They can be from any province. But as I said quota system itself is not the topic here.
@@SayVeritatis okay so quota system on largely is practiced by civil superior services ( css ) it allocates these percentages to the province. Punjab-50% , Sindh -19% , Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (KPK): 11.5% , Balochistan: 6%Federal Tribal Areas (FATA) and Gilgit-Baltistan (GB): 4%Azad Jammu & Kashmir (AJK): 2%Minorities: 5%. While Sindh. Does have an extra partitioning between the 19% . Between urban Sindh (which inculdes cities like: karachi, Hyderabad, sukkar ,mirupurkhas , larkana, nawabshah etc ) and rural Sindh. ( which includes cities like. Badin, ghotki , hala, sanghar , DADU , mithi, and others ) . Dividing 7.6% and 11.4% respectively. So now let's see why this is historically even after independence. There was little to no development in rural Sindh.( This was the Time there was little to no provincial autonomy) Most development was being done in Karachi and Punjab ( specifically northern Punjab) whether it's in education, infrastructure, and overall living was better in this part due to institutional bias towards these areas ( I wonder why 🤔) . ( Watch the video bro ) So these factors do put the people in rural Sindh at a big disadvantage and at the time they were a majority in the province so the percentage of css jobs were distributed accordingly. And actually now there is talks in parliamentary circles about taking off this partitioning of quota percentage. As there are more resources available in rural areas ( this one is bull crap it's because many Punjabis < not generalizing> come to Sindh< other provinces too> buy land get the domicile of there and get jobs based of that quota because somehow whole 50% is not enough and there are also reports of ppl doing it from urban Sindh areas too ) . Hopefully this will end. But won't until the PPP goes away ( comuninst revolution chahiye muhje)
Who says that punjab is dominant? There's nothing that's been given to punjab just they're more educated from the start but the people in villages and side areas are still living in worst conditions just because shareef family (whom are kashmiri by origin)😂and some generals are of punjab so others casts hate them despite all the generals in napak army during 190's were of pashtun origin like general tikka khan,general,yahya khan,gul hassan khan,ayub khan,musa khan who were these people? So the answer is it was never about cast it was about the one whose in power whether he belongs to any cast💔💔
@@arsheenzahid1972 I agree with you 100%, what Shahzad doing is just painting some ethinicity as evil, in order to placate a little he says ‘ oh ghreeb Punjabi or Urdu speaker are also victims’ but Keep mentioning Punjabi and Urdu speaker as ghasab, he conveniently forget about Sindhi elite atrocities!
Your presentation of the problems in Balochistan as black and white is also myopic. Akbar Bugti and the people of Dera Bugti claimed that the gas was their property and that they would not pay a single rupee for it. Instead, they argued that the government should pay royalties or a "jagga tax" to Akbar Bugti for using "their gas," a demand that successive governments complied with, although their demands for money kept increasing along with their attacks on Chinese, attacks on gas pipelines, attacks on fuel pipelines, destruction of road and railway bridges etc. Najam Sethi mentioned this point in a recent interview on Sama TV, but you wouldn’t include that because it contradicts the anti-Punjab narrative you are trying to build. . Lol
He also mentioned how the state dealt with Akbar Bugti directly instead of the awaam and continued the sardari nizam but you won’t mention that because it would negate your entire point. Mai nay bhi woh show dekha hay dost
@@ThePakistanExperience Thank you so much for replying. First of all, I am a big admirer of your work. I totally agree that the state's (specifically the military establishment's) policies were wrong, and the people of Balochistan have genuine grievances that should be addressed by the state. However, why and how is Punjab responsible if Musharraf bombed Akbar Bugti's cave? How are resources being extracted (other than punjab's due share) and diverted to Punjab specifically after the 18th Amendment? Who is doing this? Could you please provide exact facts, figures, reports, research articles, or any specific and substantial information on this? Thank you
Tum dono ki English khatam hogae ho to mujhy batao, Balochistan or Sindh ko apna haq kab milyga? Hamary logon ko equal positions Wafak my kab mialain ge? Hamary province my hamary logon ko jobs kb milainge? Balochistan or Sindh kab built hoga? Average quality of life of those 2 province kb Panjab jusy hoge? Or buhat sare chezain?
@@User00571 balochistan aur sindh ko unky share say zada he mil raha hy abi b as compared to punjab bhai. Jhuty propaganda ky asar sy niklo bhai. Balochistan aur sindh mai taraqi Q nahi ho rhi? To sabsy pehly unka gareban pakro jo wahan elections jeet kr government bnaty hain, unkay pas billions of rupee k hisab say budget hota hy usay use krny ki authority hoti hy. Apky halat punjab ny nai kharab kiye aapky apny logo ny apky apny province ki elite class ny, politicians ny, wadero jy, jageerdaro ny kahrb rakhy hain. Punjab waly sindh aur Balochistan mai jaa kr jobs ni krty bhai, na he punjab ny wahan apky provinces mai infrastructur, roads, schools, universities banan roka hua hy
@@User00571 apky sab sawalo ka jawab apko apny ghr say he milaingy, dusro ko qusoorwar krh kr rony ki bajae jo log apky province mai government bna kr ayashiaa. Kr rhy hain aur unki total incompetence aur corruption ki wajh sy apkay provinces ki yeh halat hui hy aap log jaa kr unsay sawal pucho sabsy pehly. Sirf jhutaa propaganda hy yeh baat k sind aur Balochistan ky logo ko jobs ni milten wifaq mai aur unky apny provinces mai. Apky provinces mai quality of life behtr aapky apny hukmaran he kr skty hain punjab k log ni.
Brilliant analysis. Very true, truth to the core. You didnt mention Ayub sold three rivers to India. Nothing in the world you could find such an example where rivers are sold for money and ending up with water shortages for rest of the life!
Taking the last name of Khan doesn't make one Pashtun/Pathan. Ayub Khan was from Hazara and spoke Hindkowan and Yahya Khan was Punjjabi from Chakwal- probably a converted Sikh. Both of them have no dead or alive Pashtun relatives in Pakistan or Afghanistan.
@@sabrinakhan8217madam just living in punjab doesn't makes anyone punjabi he was of pashtun origin he just lived in chakwal and also ayyub khan was also of pashtun origin wheter he lived in hazara or not search well about your people and not every cruel one of your cast is a cosidered Punjabi🤣 their blood line is pashtun stop denying the fact and also not every punjabi is sikh,punjab is so vast ethnically
@sabrinakhan8217 ask omar ayub if he is Punjabi or pashtun. Also tell us what is imran khan? Also yahya is buried in his ancestral peshawar not chakwal..he was a qazalbash.
You point that Punjab dominates Pakistan, YES i agree. 90% employees in federal government are Punjabis. But your point Karachi dominates, NO dont agree. See the situation of Karachi where we dont get water, worst law and order situation and Urdu speaking people are almost out of government jobs. In Federal government, 90% are Punjabis and in Sindh government, more than 95% are sindhi speaking
Even if more Punjabis are employees the reason is that Punjabis are greater in number, provide the most jobs and exports through businesses, most number of martyrs in army, most of the tax and electricity bills, were massacred in lacs of the numbers in 1947. Hint: now you will start crying saying the illiteracy of your people is caused by Punjabis, which I say are Punjabi elite and don't represent all of the Punjab. If Obama became the president of America , doesn't mean the blacks are equal to whites in wealth and power there
i am saraiki from rahim yar khan but i consider myself as punjabi saraiki there are four kind of saraikis such as saraiki punjabi saraiki baloch saraiki pathan sindhi saraiki All the other ethnic groups in south punjab mostly belongs to baloch tribes they speak saraiki as their mother tongue ....
#TPE I m watching your videos since 2 years or more Your way of narration, pointers while narrating has improved a lot 😊 I don't know it's deliberate or ( I guess) it's with experience your narration now has Thehrav 👍🏻👌🏻 Good 👍🏻 Best wishes 😊 Edit: I found your National Anthem related video quite enlightening . Your narration, expressions,body language while putting your points everything was excellent 😊 'Dil se' nikali aawaz thi apki😊
Punjabi Muslims were least interested in creating Pakistan fact of the matter none of the existing state in current Pakistan wanted a muslim state reason was simple. 1. Muslims in this region were always in majority and hence were never insecure of democracy. 2. This region's never lost any empire as such or has any islamic empire like the UP Muslims who lost power influence after fall of mugals. It was insecurity of UP, Bihar and Bengali Muslims who wanted the seperate state but Punjabis,pashtuna,Baloch and Sindh never had these insecurity.. Unfortunately now they have live with it 🙌
@@ThePakistanExperience there is saying goes "Hate consumes everything" you can't switch off your hatred you will find something else to hate unfortunately now we see it is consuming whole nation 😔
I want to understand how does this mean exploitation that you keep saying if gas is coming to Karachi from somewhere else and that place is not getting gas then is it Karachi's fault? Government failure to deliver equally on all fronts in not the fault of people residing in cities! It is the will of the people of Karachi to hold whom they have elected to accountability if utility services or road maintenance are not met in this city, just like it is the right of the people of different cities, towns or villages to hold their elected people accountable for failing to deliver basic utilities in their respective regions.
If the Establishment decides to give resources to North Punjab and Karachi and that Establishment primarily consists of North Punjabis and Karachites then whose fault is it? I am just pointing out what’s happening
MA was ? a Punjabi ? Ayub Khan a Punjabi ? ZA Bhutto ? Musharraf a Punjabi ? Zardari a Punjabi ? Imran khan a Punjabi ? Nawaz calls himself a Kashmiri. Even now Urdu speaking, Sindhis etc ruled Pakistan. Punjabis just got the bad name as what ? They aren’t even Punjabi anymore. They left their original language, culture etc and adopted fake languages imposed by Urdu elite. Punjabi name should belong to Indian Punjab only. You should change the name of Punjab to whatever Pakistan wants. This name doesn’t even belongs to you. With regards from Indian Punjab.
But you don't point out the fact that one of the reasons Punjabis dominate army is large population. That is one of the reasons more Punjabis are in army. Agree with rest of the points...
Syed Muzammil made a video that said there are 38 million beggers in Pakistan of a total population of 240 million people,that amounts to 14 % of the population, don't u think this is the biggest problem of Pakistan. This is alarming.
@@ThePakistanExperience 14% of the population? Can't u just do a gareeb Kalyan yojana with the benajir income support and deliver free rations and grains. This solves the need to work for food, and people will work for wealth, security or future health Corpus. Instead of begging with predictable income to working with unpredictable pay.
Posting this video At a time when Punjabis Are been targeted by the BLP doesn’t seem like the best idea. And as a comedian you know timing is everything. Read the room.
This reads like Israelis commenting that now is not the time to talk about Palestine after October 7th. More Baloch have died since that attack on Punjabis. We shouldn’t not talk about that just because Punjabis were targeted also. I made a whole video on that already.
@@ThePakistanExperiencei saw this video already. But when tensions are high, making a general video about the punjabi advantage is Pakistan seems in poor taste. And my point was the timing of this video is insensitive. The content is debatable. Also, as much as you talk about unifying the nation or the idea of social equality and tolerance, simultaneously you are churring out US vs THEM videos. Challenge - Make a video/ video series of what unites us as a nation not today, but since the start. Id like nothing more to be wrong
The only province whom have given govt jobs to outsiders meanwhile the most populous province of Pakistan,the only province where everyone of pathan,baloch or sindhi origin can come and do business,take education,do visit and tour but the only province who only recieve hate, murdered when move to other states and still being blamed,the only province whose labours are killed for belonging to that province even from the busses,now it's time for punjabi to start taking stand for themselves punjab is for punjabis only don't allow any outsider
@@ThePakistanExperienceI agree with the comment above. I’m a non Punjabi living in Punjab & I’ve never face any systemic racism. Not everything is black & white. A Baloch like Buzdar can be CM Punjab but can a Muhajir ever be CM Sindh? I don’t think so.
During partition era, two generators, Rasheed Maseeh and Bota were on duty near Data Darbar. There was a rally in the same area and people were chanting. Rasheed asked to Bota, YAR AAY MUSLIA.N NOO KEE CHAIE DA AAY? Bota replied, AAY “SADAY” KOOLON AZADI MANG DAY PAY NAYIEN. It’s all about elite and AWAAM, but unfortunately intellectuals turned it to “We and Them”.
Apne kaha ky punjabi nay exploit kara ha pakstan ko , or sindhio ny bhi to sindh ky logo ko exploit kara ha unko gulam bana kr rakha ap us pr bhi baat karen or establishment ka hisa sindhi bhi hai PPP bhi foj ki goud may rehti ha any time ap log bhi elite ka hisa ho or Pakistan ko loot rahe ho , Sirf punjabi ko blame karna sahi nahi ha isme sab involve hai
Dominated by karachi?? Are you crazy??? Karachi people aren't even able to get government jobs due to the quota system placed by people's party. There is no place for Karachi people in police. Thumbnail shows your hatred against karachi
So, you see, the thing is, in bureaucracy and in public services jobs ( practiced internationally) that a person doesn't get appointments in their own district due to personal biases may affect the decisions . I know this may come as a surprise but most people in Sindh specifically in interior Sindh speak Sindhi And government jobs, especially in police and bureaucracy such as Assistant Commissioner, DSP, SHO, they are the jobs that are connected with the local people. They need to be connected with the locals to solve their problems. When one does not even understand or does not even know what the problems of the people are, he or she can't even understand what locals are saying. You might say that why don't they learn Urdu. You want the whole village/ possibly city to speak a new language to accommodate a new guy who came to city hmmm 🤔 says a lot about narcissism. So the thing about this is you want us to learn your language ( assuming you speak Urdu ) but u don't want to take effort to learn ours. ( No relation to this but recently a new DSP got posted in my city he is from karachi comes from an Urdu speaking background. But he learned Sindhi to understand locals and their problems)
Or baaqi hum ne dekhe hain k wo kitna kaam kartay hain. Na Bijli ka bil do, Na Gas Ka, Na income tax do, na custom duties, Musafiro ko Loto, Bachay paida karo or so jao. Jinn Bacho ko Newspaper bhi nahi parhna ata, wo hi 600, 600 number leke CSS karkay unki beurocracy mein ajatay hain. Unki cabinet ko Punjab se compare karke dekh lo. Baaqi unko bhalay PM banado ya President. Punjab unke bina survive kar jayega apni ability pe.
@@_abdullah_jatthmesha punjabio pe zulam hua Phir b punjab bura kya punjabi kahte dera bugti mai gas na do ? Jo other province extra electricity ke bill pay krta punjab uska kya ? Sara burden punjab pe hai phir b punjab bura ..Jo elite hai usko pakro chahy punjab se ho karachi se ho ya balochistan se
@@hassanzaka1156 KPK mein adhey ziyada log bijli chori kartey hein aur bill Punjab deta hai, Balochistan mein jo gas banti hai woh ziyada kpk waghera hi jati hai Punjab sindh se gas khareed k istimal karta hai ya phir log cylinder bharwatey hein, Kashmir aur Gilgit ki larayi mein hum log har waqt india se jung mein rehtey hein na trade kartey hein ulta khud jaibo k taxes k paisey laga rhey hein takey indian foji inhein modi aur yogi k hathey na charha dein, sindh mein sara wadera system aur kachey k dakku paley huey hein aur phir rotey hein sindh k halaat kharab hein humne taraqi nahin ki, Punjab aaj jo bhi hai apney sar pe hai ulta agar hum in sab k saath na hotey tau aaj Punjab ne had se ziyada taraqi kar jani thi lekin phir bhi in logo ki jalan nahin khatam hoti Punjab ko taraqi karta dekh k kyun k in k khoon mein dhokeybazi aur badnasli hai, Punjab sirf atta, chawal, namak, cheeni, sabzia aur fruit rok de tau yeh phir mitti aur ghaas khayenge Punjab Zindabad 🙌🏻 Punjabiat Zindabad ✊🏻
What a racist comment, first off CSS is no benchmark for education or intelligence, it's a remnant of colonization. Sindh would survive without Punjab, it has its own gas, own coal, own shores and port and sufficient crops. Half the power plants making power from gas in Ghotki district are sending that electricity to Punjab and Punjabi fauj has made sure the C suite in all those companies is Punjabi. Stop trying to play the victim if you live in north Punjab .
Your understanding of the Indian social system is rudimentary, unless you have lived experience you cannot even imagine to comprehend the complexity of the country. Best you stick to an analysis of Pakistan.
@@ThePakistanExperience other comment section? mate I don’t even comment that much, on any channel. And no I’m not trolling you, just genuinely thought this video was kinda “filler content”
Please at least don't say this that karachi has dominated the country instead it is the most ignored city which produces almost 70% of the country's GDP.
Bolna kya chahta aur sune wala kaun hai...... Primary criteria is education which is not available in Balochistan/ Sindh / KP / FATA / Wazaristan / South Punjab / karachi.... If you deprived them from education they can't never come and stand up against the elite 😅😅😅
These people here want to target punjabi indentity which majority of the elite belongs to according to you maybe but what is the basis of their punjabi identity ? Their race or their language majority of elite dont want to associate with punjabi language and they dont even speak punjabi. Now if this is based on race than how come a rajput in south punjab is saraiki according to so called saraiki intellectuals but a rajput in central is punjabi? Majority of people who are behind the saraiki movement are baloch who migrated here at some point how do they have a right to divide our identity? . Punjabs one city alone produces 2.5 billion of exports called sialkot. You guys dont want to associate those baloch pashtoon or sindhis who support establishment with their respective identity but want to associate a punjabi elite which doesn’t even speak punjabi with punjabi identity?
Shezad's bias against karachi continues. Kp and bolachistan just having a border makes them strategicly important but karachi's port is dose not. How he clearly paints a picture that karachi has exploited kpk through afghan war, and jokes about poor roads in karachi. Let me remind him that due to that war karachi has faced and infllux of drugs weapons and terorism. In that period every week there was a bomb blast in karachi and a thousands of killings. Unlike Shezad bhai's clear racist atitude against mahajir community I will accept that people in kpk balochistan and interior sindh have a way more difficult life. They have not been given there rights. Lastly maybe shezad's keen itnrest in history has made him forget for the past 30 years straight PPP (inarguably a sindhi party) has had a government in sindh(elected by sindhi people). It is the people of karachi that are being kept out of burecracy and politics. Karachites strenght that your unable to see is our skilled people. We are open to all communities and religions. We are more professional and skilled than anyother city in pakistan.There's a reason why unilver and png have offices in karachi.
Yes I should focus on how a war that happened on Khyber Pakhtunkhwa affected Karachi rather than focusing on where the war actually took place. Mujhay racist bolnay say pehley apnay prejudice dekho. Did you even watch the video
Is hee colonial attitude aur superiority complex kee waja say peripheries exploit hoti hain Asli racist toh tum ho who thinks you are racially superior to everyone else
@ThePakistanExperience hahaha wow Shezad you’re so smart. Jawab Nahi to bus Ghussa karo. Firstly I didn’t call you a racist I said your attitude is. Secondly why do you want to compare people and their suffering.Yes speak for the people in Baluchistan and Kpk and sindh but don’t divide people. Have the courtesy to attest acknowledge what people in Karachi have gone through. I’m not trying to say peripheries me Zulm nahi hua, bohat hua hai but to put it on people living in other regions is stupid. I did see your video and maybe it was not your intention but you were being biased against Karachi not recognising their suffering. I get it’s not a video about Karachi but at least don’t ridicule us.
Major complain about people of punjab is that they never feel the pain of other people, if they are happy or living their lives with ease they never ever concern about three other provinces. When Imran said about Hazaras dead bodies that they are blackmailing him no one in punjab got offended by that comment of imran khan.😢😢
@@ThePakistanExperience Taking the last name of Khan doesn't make one Pashtun/Pathan. Ayub Khan was from Hazara and spoke Hindkowan and Yahya Khan was Punjjabi from Chakwal- probably a converted Sikh. Both of them have no dead or alive Pashtun relatives in Pakistan or Afghanistan.
@@sabrinakhan8217Ayub Khan is ethnically still a pashtoon. Yahya Khan is ethnically Qazilbash pashtoon. Niazi clan also claims to be ethnically pashtoon as well. Imran Khan's maternal side is from Barki family of Waziristan in Ex FATA. You need to read history and Pakistani culture plzzzz
@@ThePakistanExperienceI don't know how can you say that punjabis have no empathy? We still are not killing people after checking their CNIC's. Come on get some common sense before you comment about 100 Million people.
Today's undivided India was a creation of the central Asian Mughals. Before them, the Afghans ruled from Kabul to Dhaka for few centuries. The Afghans and Turks from central Asia ruled India between 500 to 700 years. Descendants of these people consider themselves the ruling elite in Pakistan, India and Bangladesh. Today's Pakistan is a creation of the nawabs of UP, CP, Bihar and Bengal whose ancestors came from outside the subcontinent as invaders like the British. After 1947, these people were the ruling elite. Gradually they are being replaced by the sons of the soil. This loss of position and power causes intense resentment among those who are no longer part of the power structure.
Your knowledge is correct in some ways but wrong in many ways. Quaid e Azam belong to Lohana Rajput's family.Allama Muhammad Iqbal belonged to Kashmiri Pandits family titled Sheikhs of Kashmir.Liaquat Ali Khan belonged to the family of Jutts of Punjab .Chaudhary Rehmat Ali belonged to Gujjar Clan of Punjab.Sir Syed Ahmed Khan had an Arab Ancestory although his ancestory maybe doubtfull because many people of the time had no real ancestory check so many people faked to be Syeds.Sikandar Hayat Khan belonged to Khattar Tribe of Jutts.Chaudry Muhammad Zafarullah Khan belonged to Sahi Jaats of Sialkot. A. K. Fazlul Huq belonged to Bengali Family of Qazis.Khawaja Nizam ud din was Bengali Nawab Muslim with roots in Kashmir.His ancestors moved from Kashmiri to Bengal.
Bro lemme clear u up ur facts about Kp r totally wrong u hvnt read any history of kpk .Nwfp name was given by britishers it had its own identity before it was called a princely state Yaghistan province of Afghanistan before 1893 when it got seperated due to Afghans own integeral wars it got seperated from Afghanistan on leash nd was given to britishers but it was not controlled fully except peshawar 30 years we fought Britishers nd got freed in 1920 nd the status was given as Pashtunistan by Bacha Khan. Get ur facts right u hv totally wrong info about Kp.
It was dominated by Karachi for various reasons some of them are as below: 1) Karachi was the Capital and the only port of Pakistan. 2) People who migrated to Karachi were already held office and finance positions whereas people in Pakistan at that time were mainly farmers 3)Muhajirs were well educated again not because there were universities in Karachi then Ghari Khuda Baksh but becaused they migrated from cities in India where the infrasture and education was better (which we have come to realise since the economy of India is far bigger than Pakistan even though our resources to people ratio is low against India) 4) India abolished the British system and brought in land reforms whereas here we still folow the same colonial system. This system was practiced in Rural Pakistan almost everywhere but not in Karachi and hence equal opportunity in the field of education and establishing new business etc. I also noticed that you did not mention quota system even once which show your bias so next time when you do a podcast please do your thoroughhomework
Karachi kee saray achay schools pre partition hain and you’re claiming yahan education nahee thee? 😅 Bhai racism choro toh batao if education was the only difference government say free loans aur sari resources kyon lee? Please grow out of your misconceptions and read the actual history.
@@ThePakistanExperience Bhutto introduced Quota system to bring least educated system to "Quomi dhara" which was only for 10 years but is still in play
Religion for Elites is d same in both India nd Pak. In a standup show, the comedian asks any body who has inter-caste marriage; 1 guy says his is inter-religion and there wasnt any problm frm both families; the comedian asks laughingly " arrey bhai aap-log bahot Ameer-vameer ho kya??? Thisz a real incident. I saw this show on youtube.
Come on, man. Your justification for why Punjab produces more agricultural products is, to say the least, hilarious. It further reinforces your anti-Punjab narrative. Punjab was producing significantly more agricultural products compared to Sindh, Balochistan, and KPK even before partition. Punjab also had more cultivable land before partition. But you have to prove somehow that punjab "Extracts" more water as compared to its due share so that is why you are presenting such flimsy arguments. Bhai zabardasti punjab ko villian sabit krny mai lgy huy hain aajkal. Beshak hawai batain he krni parain.
If you bothered to watch and learn instead of ranting about me being anti Punjab you have heard me talking about how the British also invested in Punjab and did not develop the peripheries
@@ThePakistanExperience Sir, there is a basic difference between fact and claim 🙏, the article you referred to states that the Provincial Assembly was "informed" about the alleged theft of Sindh's water share by "Punjab/federal govt." But who exactly was making these claims? The same landlords and feudal lords who make people in rural Sindh believe that Punjabis would extract electricity from the water of the Indus River that's why we have to oppose the construction of the Kalabagh Dam? The same landlords who have their private jails and treat their tenants worse than animals? I do not consider their claims as "facts". Could you please provide a scientific and credible report from a reputable institution, either local or international, that discusses such a large-scale "theft" by Punjab with the help and support of federal government?
@@ThePakistanExperience Okay, so should the blame be placed on the British, then? Once the land was populated and the population grew due to various factors, Punjab became the most populated province . Now, why should we deny the people of Punjab their fair share in the National Assembly? Punjab has already sacrificed its share by allowing equal representation of the smaller provinces in the Senate. So why do you and other anti-Punjab guests you invite want to take away their rightful representation in the National Assembly still? There are already considerably more voters per NA seat in Punjab compared to Balochistan, KPK, and rural Sindh, yet you still claim that Punjab is being favored everywhere! How and why? Punjab has the most cultivable land and produces the most agricultural products in Pakistan, feeding the entire country. So why shouldn't Punjab get a larger share of water? Infrastructure development in Punjab started by the Sharifs in the 1990s really picked up pace during Shehbaz Sharif's consecutive terms as Chief Minister of Punjab, as Dr. Umar Saif mentioned on your podcast. So why haven't the governments of Balochistan, KPK, and Sindh been able to match or even come close to Punjab's development during the same period? Is this because the so-called resources were being diverted to Punjab even after the 18th Amendment? I humbly request you to please provide credible facts and figures, data, and details on how Punjab supposedly restricted the smaller provinces from building roads, hospitals, schools, universities, IT centers, infrastructure, and digitizing provincial departments ? Thank you very much
@@Techuser704 I think you didn't read my actual comment. Shehzad in his video mentioned that dams were made by aid that we were getting from becoming part of US alliance. My point was that it is not true, because the money for the dams came after 3 rivers of Punjab were sold to India. I hope you get my point now.
@@Techuser704 I don't want to be rude But let me make this clear to you, you don't know history and just going on and on upon the same thing. There is no point in talking to you who have no clue about International Laws & International Treaties
@@AhsanSaleem99 You are not rude but the worst type of idiot. Every single word of english has its own meaning whihc forms a sentence. You are using "sold" again and again. You can't sell when you didn't own is what I am saying. Pakistan did not own a single river.
Brother Pakistan is an Ethnocracy dominated the Punjabi speaking parts of Pakistan.Pakistan constution is a western parliamentary Majoritarian democracy where Punjab dominates in the National Assembly and also the distribution of resources is on the basis of population where again Punjab takes the lion share including that of the Sarakis of Punjab.Count top military generals who make defence and security policies which are mostly exercised in Balochistan and Pakhtunkhwa almost all of them are Punjabis....count the top 40 plus powerful federal secretaries almost most if them are Punjabis.....now just imagine their imprint on major state policies especially of security and defence......State apparatus is dominated by Punjabis and it's policies are biased in favour of them.1973 Constution perpetuates the hegemony of Punjab forever......
Also, taking the last name of Khan doesn't make one Pashtun/Pathan. Ayub Khan was from Hazara and spoke Hindkowan and Yahya Khan was Punjjabi from Chakwal- probably a converted Sikh. Both of them have no dead or alive Pashtun relatives in Pakistan or Afghanistan.
@@ThePakistanExperience yes brother agreed with you but times have changed immensely and Pakistan need a new social contract or we have to add some elements of Consociational democracy to our constution like the empowerment of the senate on the model of ideal federal systems like that of USA etc.....Brother even the 1973 constution was thrown into dustbin many times by the Punjab dominated state instutions.Constutional and instutional hegemonic preservation of Punjab in Pakistan is harming Pakistan on daily basis.Punjabi elite and Punjab dominated state instructions have to realise it and let go some of their might and power for the better tomorrow of Pakistan and it's All people from all ethnicites.
@@ThePakistanExperience Concurrent list went on for a long time.18th Amendment devolved many things to the province and Punjab benefited from this 18th amendment the most which previously was reluctant to go for any such devolution.No award of NFC has been held since NFC award and in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa action in aid of civil power since past one plus decade had diluted the spirit of that devolution.....this action in aid of civil power was extended to the entire province in 2019 by the pti government.....I don't know it's financial repurcussions for the province when it requisitiones the services of the federal law enforcement agencies.....Hybrid experimentation of the Punjabi military elite was a brazen attack on the provincial atuonomy and ex Army chief Mr Bajwa Sahb once called 18th amendment more dangerous than Shekh Mujeeb 6 Points.The political DNA of Punjab is pro domiantion and centralization since the beginning unfortunately.Our Beloved brother need to learn some basic things about the goods of decentralisation.......
i don't know if this is an editing difference after 24 mins podcast when audio only! displaying just thumbnails. shayad firewall chalu hogaya hai! shahzad bhai tassdiq karain?
ایلیٹ کی ایلیٹنس پر بات کرو ایلیٹ کی پنجابیت پر نہیں ۔ خود مان بھی رہے ہو کہ عام پنجابی کا اس سارے کھیل سے کوئی لینا دینا نہیں بھر بھی فریمنگ پنجاب اور باقی "مظلوم" قوموں کی کر رہے ہو
Bhai ka bass chaly Punjabi hi mita dy jub sy dekha hai Punjabi Punjabi ka raag alapta hai bhai elite elite hota hai wo chahy kisi bhi ethnicity ka ho ayub khan ky bary main keh rha hai wo pushton representation nahi thi to yaar Punjab ka elite bhi to punjabi representation nahi hai na
I think thumbnail is not appropriate especially with respect to pakistan dominated by karachi.I want to make clear that karachi doesn't not dominate pakistan but it is dominated by ruling elite of sindh and to some extent punjab's elite which controls military and federal government.It should be clear to everyone that karachi doesn't get its in government jobs including bureaucracy because of non meritorious system of quota which divides rural and urban sindh so it weird to see the thumbnail stating karachi dominates pakistan.Bureucracy and most of ruling elite is from north punjab and upper sindh(land lords and peers) including military elite and political elite
How much representation does Karachi have in Federal jobs ? What about the Karachi domicile holders ,how much representation in Sindh Government jobs .Ur video is biased with regard to Karachi as the dominant city .
@@ThePakistanExperienceyou should present these facts given you’re the one making a misinformed video. Otherwise why should your opinion be considered over the real life experiences of someone.
Sir from tbe time of British govt., it was decided that development of infrastructure in Balochistan and KPK will be very difficult, the main reason was geography and population density, railway road from Lahore to Karachi and Lahore to Rawalpindi were historically profitable, runing transport lanes, building and maintaining infrastructure in this area was easy as there was a potential consumer for it. Building and maintaining infrastructure in Balochistan is extremely difficult, so Britain decided that they will divert a portion of resources from Punjab and try to support development in Balochistan, after Pakistan came into being, people in power lacked any vision to address this vital issue, an easy solution is to relocate population into Balochistan under govt supervision but that can affect demography adversely and turn Balochs minority in their own province so it requires careful planning, for which govt of Pakistan totally lack capacity. Best solution is giving autonomy to all provinces but we know answer about it. Another solution is let corporations take hold on the resources of Balochistan and let them drive development. It is complex issue. It is not like resources are only diverted from Balochistan to central Pakistan. Historically resources has been diverted from common Punjabis for development of Balochistan and KPK as well. But no Punjabi talk about that, there is no nationalist movement in Punjab, the identity of being Punjabi was drowned under the identity of being Pakistani.
Your vlogs at times teach me more about the real history of partition than what our history books do of our school curriculum here in India!! That's why I try not to miss any of your videos!! Thanks for educating people like us!!
Sir what is the use of talking history always, talk in future, implemented solutions, as a indian i feel Pakistan stuck in past,your army, media, judge, oppositions part, and mostly people should think about future not on every time historical timlines
@@ThePakistanExperience Sir, last 2 years I am watching your videos, I suggest take department wise, subject wise, or topic wise like (Education, health, digital, infrastructure, jobs, police, waterways, budget, women empowerment, kids’ education, revenue, Agriculture, Housing, Real time governance, civil& food supplies, Municipal Administration & Urban Development etc) and put the problem facing, and put the solutions by observing how others are doing or updating in the US, UK, China & if u like India. Check the south Indian states like Andra Pradesh, Telengana etc and check their govt websites to understand the programs, plans,etc are planned.
Bhai aap batai jo bijli kpk me milti hai kia aus ke bill wo log bhartay hain?? Nahi wo log kunday laga ke araam kartay hain to aus hisaab se wahan development nahi hoti
Because they want to frame it as a racism issue which it is not. It is an establishment/elite vs the rest of Pakistan issue. Why they are doing it? Because that kind of narrative is easy to sell in the West because of the own history of racism in West.
It's absolutely true that punjab and islamabd takes a bigger share of the pie, but here in KP the incompitent PTI govt have used the ethnicity card to hold onto power, they have presented themeselves and IK as the soul spoksmen of the pakhtoon community but are part of that same elite status quo and have looted millions from the same pakhtoon's, resorting to the same devide and rule stratgey like their fathers and grand father's ayub khan and ghulam ishaq khan's of the world did.
Pakistan was demanded by " All india Muslim league" in british india not muslim league but you all haven't study the truth of your history 😉 so Rest in future 😊
You led him to go this extent?? If all india congress elected m.a.jinnah as party leader rather than jawarlal nehru this partition never happens and india not divided by on religous bases.
Kinda Yes , Seraiki Movement has been destroyed by Punjabi Generals from Lahore and Pindi who have set up madressas to radicalise our People now there is lot of hate for Shias here even though We were sufis. Junobi Punjab Soba Please , There are floods and None talks of it
Yedi deo ghulami tum logon ne phir Gilanion, Legharion, Mazarion, Gurchanion aur Dareeshakon ki krni hai. South Punjab se 5 representative bata do jo jageerdar na hon. Naya suba bund men lo ge?
Janoobi Punjab Sooba idea only used by Janoobi Punjab politians at election time and selling it out to "win" the seats and forgotten till next election 🥴
And the preachers with that mentality usually come from Punjab and KPK. They have been dismantling the fabrics and developing their own to create secure job space in exchange of religious card. Punjabis get religiously excited when they see non-Muslims of Sindh, beginning to ruin the existing resonance, where the others capitalize on the opportunities.
KPK mein adhey ziyada log bijli chori kartey hein aur bill Punjab deta hai, Balochistan mein jo gas banti hai woh ziyada kpk waghera hi jati hai Punjab sindh se gas khareed k istimal karta hai ya phir log cylinder bharwatey hein, Kashmir aur Gilgit ki larayi mein hum log har waqt india se jung mein rehtey hein na trade kartey hein ulta khud jaibo k taxes k paisey laga rhey hein takey indian foji inhein modi aur yogi k hathey na charha dein, sindh mein sara wadera system aur kachey k dakku paley huey hein aur phir rotey hein sindh k halaat kharab hein humne taraqi nahin ki, Punjab aaj jo bhi hai apney sar pe hai ulta agar hum in sab k saath na hotey tau aaj Punjab ne had se ziyada taraqi kar jani thi lekin phir bhi in logo ki jalan nahin khatam hoti Punjab ko taraqi karta dekh k kyun k in k khoon mein dhokeybazi aur badnasli hai, Punjab sirf atta, chawal, namak, cheeni, sabzia aur fruit rok de tau yeh phir mitti aur ghaas khayenge Punjab Zindabad 🙌🏻 Punjabiat Zindabad ✊🏻
@@ThePakistanExperience Sindh se aati hai aur tax bhi lagta hai sindh hakumat ko iske paisey bhi miltey hein mein bhi utni hi mehnat karta hun jitna aik sindhi ya balochi karta hai Hum ne tau itna sab diya hai kabhi ginwaya nahin hala nakey usmein hum apni mehnat bhi kartey hein aur mein agriculture ki baat kar rha hun aap logo k paas aik gas nikal ayi hai woh bhi thori sii aur aap log samajhtey ho azad hokar Saudi sheikho ki tarah Lamborghini rakh lo ge aisa nahi hai bhukey reh jaoge sab kuch punjab se import karoge sirf sindh hi hai jo thori bohut wheat production karleta hai baakio ki zameen pe channey bhi nahin ugtey aur jo aaj balochi rorhey hein inhein yeh bhi batao k gawadar tum balochio k baap ka nahin hai yeh aik Punjabi ne hi Oman se khareeda tha Ajeeb drama banaya hua hai aap logo ne
great video. The problem and narratives are so deep rooted that it needs a major critical rethink by masses to understand the real problems. Yes punjabis and karachiites and even pathans dominate pakistan.....Balochs and sindhis have been kept underprivileged for so long that it has become an emergency matter to uplift these people for the federation to be viable.
Baaqi Punjab k yehi bachay jinhe yahan oppertunities nahi milti wo poori dunia mein apni mehnat se apna naam banate hain. Jinn Punjabi bacho ko Pakistan reject kardeta hai wohi Western Universities, Beurocracy, Buissness Community or highly professional logo mein shamil hote hain. Victim Card k bajaye wo hr system mein adjust ho k excel karte hain. Victim Card hi play karna hota to Sialkot or Faislabad jo apne paaun pe khud khara hua hai kisi or illaqay ki tarha ro raha hota. Albata choro hum to khud jald iss system se nikal kr kisi doosre mulk k system mein adjust hone jarhay hain. Khuda Hafiz
Yehi punjabi pori dunya mai budnaam hai.. click karo uk, uae, saudi usa australia loxal news, jhoot scam, voilance,crimes.... i,migratiin walo ko punjani word tak pata hai.. khuda hafiz
@@missahmed2220 G bhai blkl Afghani Pushtoons sy zayada civillized society to exist hi nahi kerti na puri duniya main aur sindh main to Animals lover rehty hain Balochistan main freedom Fighters hain aur Kpk ki to kia hi baat hai wahan pr to Pakky Muslim hain momin hai bacha baazi ka to naam nishan hi nahi hai
It’s like offering a feast to someone who hasn’t eaten in weeks, only for them to reject it because the food isn’t from their culture. People need time bro, they have been in the dark since they were born, and its ain't easy digestion as well.
خود ہی کہا ہے کہ ایلیٹ ہو کر پنجابی پنجابی نہیں رہتا بنگالی بنگالی نہیں رہتا ایلیٹ ایک الگ ہی کیٹگری ہے۔ پھر لفظ پنجاب پر اتنا فوکس کرنے کی کیا ضرورت ہے ؟ @@ThePakistanExperience
Us ka podcast bike ga jb tk wo jaan boojh kr ultey seedhey caption nhi lagae ga. Jinnah, Ayub Khan, Iskender Mirza, aur Bhutto men se koi bhi Punjabi nhi tha.
The very fact that you’re saying all this means that someone in the ESTABLISHMENT or the establishment has realised the main problem with Pakistan and that bodes well for the Southeast Asia.
@@ThePakistanExperience Bhai these kind of educated thoughts were unheard of emanating from Pakistan and the fact that you are so easily discussing it on your podcast.I respect journalists from Pakistan.
At the start you mentioned that you didn't mean ordinary Punjabi and Muhajir when you're referring to elite in this video, which is fine if you hadn't abandoned that principle mid way and blamed Punjabis and Muhajirs by the end for sth as gigantic as American Hegemony on the US. You're quick to point out the ethnicity of industrialists but not of the landholding Elite of Sindh that not only engage in the agricultural and irrigational exploitation of their own people? I'm someone who recognizes the plight of the Baloch people and the atrocities the army committed on them but if you can attach an ethnicity to the industrial elite of Pakistan then you can surely attach it to theP Pashtun dictators and Sindhi Prime Ministers until the 70s who played a very aggressive role in the exploitation and killing of Baloch. You can't have your cake and eat it too
I am a fan of your podcast I listen to it a lot. I even agree to many of the points in your videos but if we're going by military elites then Chakwal is more privileged than rest of Punjab , which is absurd
@@firstnamelastname6976 yeah, even though in the current scenario, Baloch sardars are very much in bed with the army. That includes the Bhugtis. They ARE a part of the structure
@@ThePakistanExperience who argued that their power comes from the people? Do you think that the power of the so called Punjabi establishment of industrialists and army come from the Punjabi or Muhajir people? It absolutely does not. Remember shehzad, the British also had another tool of repression against their colonial subjects and that was Divide and Conquer. By trying to pin different ethnicities against the other, you're playing very much into it
Sir you have spinned the topic quite well. It can be a way to look at it but unfortunately what you mentioned is not true. Regarding Karachi, it has always been neglected despite its importance as an economic hub.
Itna tasub bhu acha nahi hai dost, pichle 2 decades se Sindh pe sindhio ki hukumat hai or paisa bhi theek thak banalia hai, corruption or kache k dako se fursat mile tub lagalo industry dedo logo ko naukria barhado mulk ki gdp
Before formation of Pakistan, Jinnah send his emissary to America that you should support us with money and arms and we will protect your interests in middle east etc
You did not mention sindhi elite. Like bhutto and zardari . you mention the dams you didn't mentioned the reasons after selling which province rivers dollars was given to Pakistan.
Your topic is interesting for the real fact of ground...But your podcast title question should be : Is it real that the system of whole Pakistan is totally control in majority by PUNJAB (not punjabi) and a small part of elites of KARACHI ? Keep it up😊
The strategy of making wealthy elites, basically routing money into fewer hands is a well thought out economic strategy that most of the successful countries have followed. The SAMSUNG, AMBANI, MITSUBISHI, Standard Oil are some examples. This is necessary for investment in big and riskier projects - that small business won't or can't get into. Governments are inefficient in doing businesses. Regarding wealth staying in fewer hands, this issue is sorted out in few generations where ownership of business goes into different hands and family involvement deteriorates. The issue with Pakistan is that whatever strategy it makes, it is cancelled out by next Leaders in Power, that is why see good economic conditions when the period of leadership extends beyond few years.
You talk about lower caste let me tell you 2 presidents belong yo lower castes 5 cm have came from lower castes tribal community have 3 cm they have proper representation in goverme.t jobs and private sectors we have done far better job in uplifiting our weaker section of society unlikre pakistan which legally discrimnates against ahmsdiyas hindus sikhs christians
Shehzad i agree with you on most things and i maybe am biased as a punjabi I have a few points 1. There are 250 milion children in punjab who don't go to school in punjab. How is that privilege 2. Please go to a public hospital in Punjab at any time. See how many people are there.there is literally no pre-op st nishtar multan and people go to masjid instead.Yes they are better than other 3 provinces but my point is are they really that good Same for that education point yes punjab is much better than other 3 but is it really that good 3. Believe it or not we are actually receptive to other 3 provinces more than they are to us and rightly so. I don't hate a pakhtoon or a baloch but they openly hate me Infront of my face in Lahore. I can't do this in swat valley. I know they have grievances and honestly I understand where they are coming from but what i am saying is There is a difference between punjabi people and punjabi establishment. Establishment is less than 1% and you hate us. How does this make sense Why are you hating on me? What wrong did I do to you . And is it my fault being born in punjab. We are 40% of population, maybe one percent of us is that elite, still almost 80 million of us are here who are just like you people.just a little bit better. Bhai mujhe to routine mai ni pata tha na k state aisi ghatiya hai. Ab hum acknowledge krte hain. Aur ap kehte hain dekha tum kitne bure ho. And we again acknowledge that (atleast i do) and everytime this repeats k dekha tum kitne bure ho. An american being born is america is not his/her mistake just like a Punjabi being born in Punjab . Btw Punjab is no USA this is what people need to understand . What i want to say to my dear people is that please get to the solution end. Nothing will come out of this. I think we are enlightened enough and now it is becoming virtue signaling more than anything else . This is my problem with other 3 provinces( btw i have always loved pathans. Balochistan to kya hi baat aur sindh se mujhe nayi nayi fascination hui hai) but i have seen maybe this is a natural reaction but people other than punjabis that i know of just complain and do nothing. Don't want to provoke anyone but this is my only grievance that there is no nobility in masquerading your tough circumstances as moral supreriority. You people have it rough. More rough than i can imagine but trust me nothing will come out of bashing Punjabi people. . Please try to do your best
Who is saying it is their fault? Or blaming the common people? Just like homelessness in America doesn’t disprove American hegemony on the world or the privilege that comes with being American, out of school children in Punjab doesn’t negate anything I’ve said
Take a look at the comment section and tell me then who is right,it seems like a lot of people felt the same , unless you are the only sane person and everyone else is delusional, what you said was certainly not perceived the way you believe it to be ,@ThePakistanExperience
Being an Indian Punjabi, now I know ke Nehru aur Gandhi partition ke liye agree kaise ho gye. They were afraid of Punjabi Domination on whole Indian Subcontinent. 😂😂
Karachi dominating Pakistan doesn't makes any sense. Just because some business elites belong to urdu speaking people does not makes Karachi and its people privileged. In fact most of the Karachi's elite class has generational wealth that has little to do with the tax money and state resources. Karachi and its people have been serving and contributing to this nation since 47 despite the fact that the city had and was provided with little resources ( now it is deprived of even basic infrastructure). Please discuss that how the racist and discriminatory policies of Ayub Khan and quota system of Bhutto has marginalized the urdu speaking community. How much percentage of people holding Karachi domicile/urdu speaking hold positions in national & provincial assemblies, civil services, , forces or any public offices?
Considering these facts do you still believe that Karachi in some way dominates Pakistan??
Karachi was developed by Parsis and Hindus pre partition.I agree with your point of view.
Majority of urdu speaking leadership has always sided with establishment i.e what they said they obeyed and the result is today's karachi or Pakistan.
@@mehwishjameel6738lahore was also developed by hindu Sikh businessman what happened when these people got controll of this city they ruined it nowcit is bankrupt lahore and karachi were respectively 4th and 5th richest city of British India respectively
To be honest most business was in Punjabi and Gujarati hands. North Indian Muslims were generally in bureaucracy and in professional jobs. The majority were skilled labour though.
@@RoseBenjamin-e4b if your Sindhi or Pashtun and working for the system and just colonial and your identity has nothing to do with it. If you're a Punjabi or Muhajir working for the system then you'll be identified as a Punjabi or a Muhajir
This dude has something against urdu speaking people. Also the urdu speaking elite in karachi consists of educated people who are contributing to society and have opened their businesses through their own hardwork. Yet despite contributing to Pakistan instead of free loading off the economy like the other provinces karachi people have zero facilities. High utility rates, loadshedding , crime,poor infrastructure and poor waste disposal are the issues plaguing karachi because ppp doesn't want to spend a penny on this city. Even our airport looks so outdated.
Me “‘nobody should hate any common Punjabi or Mohajir”
Random hater: “Isko Urdu speaking logo say nafrat hay”
Babe . PPP doesn't spend anything on anyone but themselves. And I have lived in Karachi and interior Sindh and in Punjab. Bro if karachi doesn't have any facilities. Then the other cities don't even exist
It was also Sr Gangaram contribution that lead to development of Lahore
These clowns didn't do anything
Chup bay Tauday!
If people of subcontinent unite we won't be spending on our defense that budget could be used towards health infrastructure uplifting poverty etc.
For that to happen peace between India Pakistan Bangladesh China is vital
A decade of normalcy will lead to opening of trade relations
Two decades post opening of trade relation businesses should ask for common markets in subcontinent like the EU and privatize non strategic industries
@@Fondyacho peacefools nahi manenge
@@FondyachoThen it will raise questions on the existence of the Pakistani army and what's the need of it. And they will not allow peace. They are the main hurdle.
@@RahulMishra-ld2bo nobody is the hurdle if they are made part of it Army of both nations aren't any different they consist of the same people. If both nations agree on cutting spending on imports of weapons we would have less non state actors today our weapon exports mainly US Russia China have interest in both countries not being at peace
Too early to comment, but thumbnail is weird. Dominated by Karachi? Karachi is literally one of the worst city of Pakistan. Not only Pakistan, but it is in top5 least livable cities in world. Yeah Karachi gets more coverage but the condition of the city and it's residents is miserable ....
You might regret this comment after watching bro.
@@ThePakistanExperience that's why I said too early to comment bro, Just started watching and enjoying it 🙌🏼
Yea 20% of the economy might ring a bell?
Karachi dominate kr raha hota tuo Na Pakistan TOTTA Na Pakistani economy ki yea halat hoti
Why all MNC head offices are in Karachi if it's worst... Karachi is a big city might be you are living at worst side 😂
you missed Pathan... last 10 to 15 years me Muhajir replaced by Pathan.
AFA resources is concerned, Maazrat k sath wo resources bad me Sindhis or Pathan ko bhi mile but Sindhis wo kamyabi hasil nhi ker sake.
Dude we can't even get a govt job in Karachi and you said we are dominated
He intentionally left out rural sindh as they dominated beraucracy from Sindh. This shows his bias towards karachi people
Lol same.
The quota is cringe.
Hope you can talk about exclusively about quota system and Sindhi elite corruption
Can you Google who introduced the quota system first
@@ThePakistanExperience whoever introduced the google system first, does not matter any more, you are living in past or now ??? What it’s doing now, how it’s exploiting and marginalizing the section of society? When you defend quota system you bring a racism out, because inside you, you don’t consider Urdu speaker as Sindhi !
Ab roye bhagyr comment kar Kay dekhao. 10 racist comments karnay baadh victim ban rahay ho 😅
@@ThePakistanExperience bhai, I am a Urdu speaker, and criticize them the most in private and public circles. We came from India and Sindhi people gave their land, my uncle did a study back in 60s and found that there 35 villages in the area that is now PECHS, the local poor Sindhis not only forcefully evicted but also never given any compensation. My only beef is quota system, and it’s not doing what it was intended for , hope you can understand!
So you’re happy stealing property from poor people?
Don't you think Punjab is dominating due to their:
1. Cosmopolitanism ( accepting outsiders in their capabilities and giving them opportunities)
2. Adaptibility to the changing world in becoming less aggressive despite their historical warrior nature
3. No racism in giving jobs to fellow Pakistanis
4. Contribution to the nationalism for Pakistan ( abandoning their ethnical heroes like bhagat singh, sardar udham singh, who played a crucial role in partition, and treating them like nobodies)
5. Leaving their connection with the Hindu Punjab just for Pakistan ( leaving punjabi culture and a history expanding from Ranjit Singh to Raja Porus)
6. Despite the exploitation in southern punjab nobody firing rockets on security forces
7. Not being violent and radicalized even after the slogans of " jaag Punjabi jaag teri pag nu lag gya daag" ( provincial card was always a flop against the punjabis)
So I think the exploited ones should question their leaders ( tribal ones, sardars) who charge their cut but do nothing for the development of underdeveloped and underprivileged people. We should ask our immediate leaders to solve our problems and should not hold others responsible for our problems especially after passing of 18th amendment.
No
@@ThePakistanExperienceyou are wrong in so many ways. Dividing your country to get views 😂😂
@@ThePakistanExperience Provincial autonomy is a thing isnt it?
Title should be is Pakistan dominated by Lahore and Karachi not punjabi and Karachi
Karachi is the country's biggest cash cow only, contributing a significant amount of tax revenue, yet it has no say in any matters. The middle class of this city has always been hated by the Punjabi mafia aka Punjabi army. This country is run by the uneducated duffers of the army, recruited mainly from the dusty towns of Punjab. It's a fact, and anyone who disagrees is simply denying reality.
Am working in civil am born here in.islamabad and i have friends from all provinces but i never saw a punjbi used a racist word ordo anything like that which shows and felt like that.but i saw this from pashtuns people they are racist i have many friends but in reality am not such aracist and biased person but reality is reality. and punjabi is no more punjabis their culture is changed language changed bcoz of sacrifices they are not snatching any money and doing anything from anyone but area of punjab is traditionally non violent for anyone that is why it is the place of opportunity and investment without any fear and racism.
Now punjab is dominted by kashiris who migrated here like butts khwajas meers sheikh they are stronger than local Punjabis jutt gujjarand rajput.(Rana)big
tribe of punjabs.wven you can see that in.politics no big real.punjabi leader..
Karachi is hub. People have moved from all over Pakistan. Developing karachi isn’t like exploiting the country…. Pakistan should develop one city as hub for all Pakistan.
The hub was exploited and now is in no condition to be named as one. I wish the same mistake is not repeated with Gwadar. if you live in Karachi, you would know many things, Karachi suffers from Gareeb capture more than Elite capture.
The Pakistan ExperienceShehzad Ghias Shaikh
Dear Shahzad,
Perhaps you should also consider doing a podcast on racially biased and highly discriminatory Quota System in Sindh which has led to resentment by the other ethnic groups in the Sindh Province.
As a suggestion, please make title of your podcast, “Does Sindh use Quota System as a tool to subjugate minorities in Sindh? “
Bangladesh Student Protests vs 9th May and Protests in Pakistan - History of Revolution #TPE
ua-cam.com/video/mJGYsNxvKCk/v-deo.html
@@ThePakistanExperience
I really liked your podcast but it doesn’t cover the Quota System in Sindh.
It talks about it without the racist framing you put it in the original comment.
@@ThePakistanExperience
Shahzad Bhai, when you frame your race based narrative towards Punjabis then you call it fact.
When we point out similar narrative towards Sindhi Feudal and Quota System then you call it race profiling. Why the two standards?
Agreed @@omersaeed1533
Shehzaaaaaddddd loved this video. Much needed one.
❤️
The domination of any group over state structures is determined by its overall population. The Punjabis constitues around 60 percent population of the Pakistan so there majority in govt institutions is a natural but to mitigate this tendency to some extent, there are quotas in federal jobs for other provinces such as Fata, rural Sindh and Balochistan. But there is a catch, according to some stats the Pathan's representation in Pakistan military is more than their average share of population. Similarly, the rural Sindhis are the great beneficiary of the Civil service jobs as there's a separate quota for rural Sindh which I think put the urban youth of Karachi and Hyderabad at a great disadvantage. You mention in your video that Karachis are dominating the state structures, this is argument is factual incorrect in contemporary times although it's relevant during initial days of Pakistan. This video really disappoints me because you're using the same identity politics as other pusedo intellectuals are doing in Pakistan to be recognize in intellectual circles. Don't focus on these assumptions, come up with facts and majority on the basis of population is natural thing, why it's wrong on moral and principle grounds?
I'm from Punjab, from a relatively privileged background (there are levels to privilege), and I wholeheartedly endorse this message.
🙌
Who do you blame? Your ethnicity? or Elites?
@@firstnamelastname6976 watch the video
@@YousufAhmad0 I did. That is why i am asking.
Punjab is also into 3 parts. North south and central. North is wealthies central also have wealthy people and people are happy on their life. South is deprived like kpk , sindh , balochistan . Karachi is harted and deprived on another level 😅
Very misleading and racist video, facts are mostly true but they way he presented was to paint Urdu speaker and Punjabi as evil, how conveniently you forget about Sindhi elite and Waderas who are exploiting the poor Sindhis, plus mixing elite gujrati and memons with Urdu speakers of UP, Bihar or central India who are mostly poor middle class, hardworking people. The way you describing paint one ethnic group evil, then this lead killing poor Punjabis by BLA. Hope you can also talk about Sindhi elite exploitation!
Sunay may masla hay aap ko ya comprehend karnay mai? Ya poori video dekhay bhagyr Bilawaja comment kardia?
@@ThePakistanExperience bhai Jan , hum tu bewaqof log hein Kay app ko neutral or izzat kartay hein, pehlay Khoob jee bhar Kay Urdu speaker or Punjabi ko gali day do phir later in the for 5 sec apni Sindhi ko token baat Kar lo. Acha formula hai !
Self awareness 10/10 hay aap kee 🤣
@@ThePakistanExperience by the way I thought you will delete my comment, but at least you let me vent my frustration against quota system and bardasht my comment, thank you.
Karachi dominates? Is thay why there is quota system in Sind? Because of Karachi's domination?
Why comment without watching
So, you see, the thing is, in bureaucracy and in public services jobs ( practiced internationally) that a person doesn't get appointments in their own district due to personal biases may affect the decisions . I know this may come as a surprise but most people in Sindh specifically in interior Sindh speak Sindhi
And government jobs, especially in police and bureaucracy such as Assistant Commissioner, DSP, SHO, they are the jobs that are connected with the local people. They need to be connected with the locals to solve their problems. When one does not even understand or does not even know what the problems of the people are, he or she can't even understand what locals are saying. You might say that why don't they learn Urdu. You want the whole village/ possibly city to speak a new language to accommodate a new guy who came to city hmmm 🤔 says a lot about narcissism. So the thing about this is you want us to learn your language ( assuming you speak Urdu ) but u don't want to take effort to learn ours. ( No relation to this but recently a new DSP got posted in my city he is from karachi comes from an Urdu speaking background. But he learned Sindhi to understand locals and their problems)
@@khalilismail1396
I am no expert on quota system. If this channel makes a video to discuss quota system it would give people like me the opportunity to learn more about its merits and demerits. My point was that if Karachi really dominated the government power structure wouldn't they have gotten rid of the quota system in 40 years?
By the way I think Commissioners and Dy. Commissioners are from the federal government not provincial government. They can be from any province. But as I said quota system itself is not the topic here.
@@SayVeritatis okay so quota system on largely is practiced by civil superior services ( css ) it allocates these percentages to the province. Punjab-50% , Sindh -19% , Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (KPK): 11.5% , Balochistan: 6%Federal Tribal Areas (FATA) and Gilgit-Baltistan (GB): 4%Azad Jammu & Kashmir (AJK): 2%Minorities: 5%. While Sindh. Does have an extra partitioning between the 19% . Between urban Sindh (which inculdes cities like: karachi, Hyderabad, sukkar ,mirupurkhas , larkana, nawabshah etc ) and rural Sindh. ( which includes cities like. Badin, ghotki , hala, sanghar , DADU , mithi, and others ) . Dividing 7.6% and 11.4% respectively.
So now let's see why this is historically even after independence. There was little to no development in rural Sindh.( This was the Time there was little to no provincial autonomy) Most development was being done in Karachi and Punjab ( specifically northern Punjab) whether it's in education, infrastructure, and overall living was better in this part due to institutional bias towards these areas ( I wonder why 🤔) . ( Watch the video bro ) So these factors do put the people in rural Sindh at a big disadvantage and at the time they were a majority in the province so the percentage of css jobs were distributed accordingly. And actually now there is talks in parliamentary circles about taking off this partitioning of quota percentage. As there are more resources available in rural areas ( this one is bull crap it's because many Punjabis < not generalizing> come to Sindh< other provinces too> buy land get the domicile of there and get jobs based of that quota because somehow whole 50% is not enough and there are also reports of ppl doing it from urban Sindh areas too ) . Hopefully this will end. But won't until the PPP goes away ( comuninst revolution chahiye muhje)
By the way, Narendra Modi himself is from a "lower caste". Which is not to say that it is not tough to get into the elite for a lower caste.
Who says that punjab is dominant? There's nothing that's been given to punjab just they're more educated from the start but the people in villages and side areas are still living in worst conditions just because shareef family (whom are kashmiri by origin)😂and some generals are of punjab so others casts hate them despite all the generals in napak army during 190's were of pashtun origin like general tikka khan,general,yahya khan,gul hassan khan,ayub khan,musa khan who were these people? So the answer is it was never about cast it was about the one whose in power whether he belongs to any cast💔💔
Very true
@@arsheenzahid1972 I agree with you 100%, what Shahzad doing is just painting some ethinicity as evil, in order to placate a little he says ‘ oh ghreeb Punjabi or Urdu speaker are also victims’ but
Keep mentioning Punjabi and Urdu speaker as ghasab, he conveniently forget about Sindhi elite atrocities!
He’s the ‘cut the clutter’ of Pak. The guy breaks it down like it should. Super job
🙌
Your presentation of the problems in Balochistan as black and white is also myopic. Akbar Bugti and the people of Dera Bugti claimed that the gas was their property and that they would not pay a single rupee for it. Instead, they argued that the government should pay royalties or a "jagga tax" to Akbar Bugti for using "their gas," a demand that successive governments complied with, although their demands for money kept increasing along with their attacks on Chinese, attacks on gas pipelines, attacks on fuel pipelines, destruction of road and railway bridges etc.
Najam Sethi mentioned this point in a recent interview on Sama TV, but you wouldn’t include that because it contradicts the anti-Punjab narrative you are trying to build.
. Lol
He also mentioned how the state dealt with Akbar Bugti directly instead of the awaam and continued the sardari nizam but you won’t mention that because it would negate your entire point. Mai nay bhi woh show dekha hay dost
@@ThePakistanExperience
Thank you so much for replying.
First of all, I am a big admirer of your work. I totally agree that the state's (specifically the military establishment's) policies were wrong, and the people of Balochistan have genuine grievances that should be addressed by the state. However, why and how is Punjab responsible if Musharraf bombed Akbar Bugti's cave?
How are resources being extracted (other than punjab's due share) and diverted to Punjab specifically after the 18th Amendment? Who is doing this?
Could you please provide exact facts, figures, reports, research articles, or any specific and substantial information on this?
Thank you
Tum dono ki English khatam hogae ho to mujhy batao, Balochistan or Sindh ko apna haq kab milyga?
Hamary logon ko equal positions Wafak my kab mialain ge? Hamary province my hamary logon ko jobs kb milainge?
Balochistan or Sindh kab built hoga?
Average quality of life of those 2 province kb Panjab jusy hoge?
Or buhat sare chezain?
@@User00571 balochistan aur sindh ko unky share say zada he mil raha hy abi b as compared to punjab bhai. Jhuty propaganda ky asar sy niklo bhai.
Balochistan aur sindh mai taraqi Q nahi ho rhi? To sabsy pehly unka gareban pakro jo wahan elections jeet kr government bnaty hain, unkay pas billions of rupee k hisab say budget hota hy usay use krny ki authority hoti hy. Apky halat punjab ny nai kharab kiye aapky apny logo ny apky apny province ki elite class ny, politicians ny, wadero jy, jageerdaro ny kahrb rakhy hain. Punjab waly sindh aur Balochistan mai jaa kr jobs ni krty bhai, na he punjab ny wahan apky provinces mai infrastructur, roads, schools, universities banan roka hua hy
@@User00571 apky sab sawalo ka jawab apko apny ghr say he milaingy, dusro ko qusoorwar krh kr rony ki bajae jo log apky province mai government bna kr ayashiaa. Kr rhy hain aur unki total incompetence aur corruption ki wajh sy apkay provinces ki yeh halat hui hy aap log jaa kr unsay sawal pucho sabsy pehly.
Sirf jhutaa propaganda hy yeh baat k sind aur Balochistan ky logo ko jobs ni milten wifaq mai aur unky apny provinces mai.
Apky provinces mai quality of life behtr aapky apny hukmaran he kr skty hain punjab k log ni.
Brilliant analysis. Very true, truth to the core.
You didnt mention Ayub sold three rivers to India. Nothing in the world you could find such an example where rivers are sold for money and ending up with water shortages for rest of the life!
🙌
Taking the last name of Khan doesn't make one Pashtun/Pathan. Ayub Khan was from Hazara and spoke Hindkowan and Yahya Khan was Punjjabi from Chakwal- probably a converted Sikh. Both of them have no dead or alive Pashtun relatives in Pakistan or Afghanistan.
@@sabrinakhan8217
yahya khan was pushtun pls check the facts
@@sabrinakhan8217madam just living in punjab doesn't makes anyone punjabi he was of pashtun origin he just lived in chakwal and also ayyub khan was also of pashtun origin wheter he lived in hazara or not search well about your people and not every cruel one of your cast is a cosidered Punjabi🤣 their blood line is pashtun stop denying the fact and also not every punjabi is sikh,punjab is so vast ethnically
@sabrinakhan8217 ask omar ayub if he is Punjabi or pashtun. Also tell us what is imran khan?
Also yahya is buried in his ancestral peshawar not chakwal..he was a qazalbash.
You point that Punjab dominates Pakistan, YES i agree. 90% employees in federal government are Punjabis. But your point Karachi dominates, NO dont agree. See the situation of Karachi where we dont get water, worst law and order situation and Urdu speaking people are almost out of government jobs. In Federal government, 90% are Punjabis and in Sindh government, more than 95% are sindhi speaking
You didn’t watch the video
Even if more Punjabis are employees the reason is that Punjabis are greater in number, provide the most jobs and exports through businesses, most number of martyrs in army, most of the tax and electricity bills, were massacred in lacs of the numbers in 1947. Hint: now you will start crying saying the illiteracy of your people is caused by Punjabis, which I say are Punjabi elite and don't represent all of the Punjab. If Obama became the president of America , doesn't mean the blacks are equal to whites in wealth and power there
You haven't visited federal then.
i am saraiki from rahim yar khan but i consider myself as punjabi saraiki there are four kind of saraikis such as
saraiki punjabi
saraiki baloch
saraiki pathan
sindhi saraiki
All the other ethnic groups in south punjab mostly belongs to baloch tribes they speak saraiki as their mother tongue ....
Saraiki punjabi se alag h kya totally ?
@@Jarvis12-m9e no saraiki can be punjabi ethnic baloch ethnic pahtoon ethnic and sindhi ethnic saraiki is a bond of four to five ethnic groups
@@shahzadtameem2388 oh
Saraiki to hai he punjabi language 😮
Saraiki language is a mix of Punjabi/Sindhi language .
#TPE I m watching your videos since 2 years or more
Your way of narration, pointers while narrating has improved a lot 😊
I don't know it's deliberate or ( I guess) it's with experience your narration now has Thehrav 👍🏻👌🏻
Good 👍🏻 Best wishes 😊
Edit: I found your National Anthem related video quite enlightening .
Your narration, expressions,body language while putting your points everything was excellent 😊
'Dil se' nikali aawaz thi apki😊
Punjabi Muslims were least interested in creating Pakistan fact of the matter none of the existing state in current Pakistan wanted a muslim state reason was simple.
1. Muslims in this region were always in majority and hence were never insecure of democracy.
2. This region's never lost any empire as such or has any islamic empire like the UP Muslims who lost power influence after fall of mugals.
It was insecurity of UP, Bihar and Bengali Muslims who wanted the seperate state but Punjabis,pashtuna,Baloch and Sindh never had these insecurity..
Unfortunately now they have live with it 🙌
The Punjabi elite fully and wholeheartedly owned the Pakistan project post partition.
@@ThePakistanExperience yeah that's after partition before partion it was a different story.
Same hee tha. Landed elite of Punjab was with the Muslim league.
And a sizeable portion of Punjabi Muslims engaged in violence in Punjab pre partition to make Pakistan happen
@@ThePakistanExperience there is saying goes "Hate consumes everything" you can't switch off your hatred you will find something else to hate unfortunately now we see it is consuming whole nation 😔
I want to understand how does this mean exploitation that you keep saying if gas is coming to Karachi from somewhere else and that place is not getting gas then is it Karachi's fault? Government failure to deliver equally on all fronts in not the fault of people residing in cities!
It is the will of the people of Karachi to hold whom they have elected to accountability if utility services or road maintenance are not met in this city, just like it is the right of the people of different cities, towns or villages to hold their elected people accountable for failing to deliver basic utilities in their respective regions.
If the Establishment decides to give resources to North Punjab and Karachi and that Establishment primarily consists of North Punjabis and Karachites then whose fault is it?
I am just pointing out what’s happening
MA was ? a Punjabi ? Ayub Khan a Punjabi ? ZA Bhutto ? Musharraf a Punjabi ? Zardari a Punjabi ? Imran khan a Punjabi ? Nawaz calls himself a Kashmiri. Even now Urdu speaking, Sindhis etc ruled Pakistan. Punjabis just got the bad name as what ? They aren’t even Punjabi anymore. They left their original language, culture etc and adopted fake languages imposed by Urdu elite. Punjabi name should belong to Indian Punjab only. You should change the name of Punjab to whatever Pakistan wants. This name doesn’t even belongs to you. With regards from Indian Punjab.
Dekhay bhagyr comment kar Kay kya milta hay?
Elites don’t represent masses.
Tu parhe baghair dekhne pe zor de raha hai?
@@user-gv5mo1rd2p absolute genius reply.
@@ThePakistanExperience bhai right stats ke liye zaroori nahin Banda time waste kare. Though I like your podcast. Learn to some on the chin.
But you don't point out the fact that one of the reasons Punjabis dominate army is large population. That is one of the reasons more Punjabis are in army. Agree with rest of the points...
Syed Muzammil made a video that said there are 38 million beggers in Pakistan of a total population of 240 million people,that amounts to 14 % of the population, don't u think this is the biggest problem of Pakistan.
This is alarming.
No bro there are 28 Million beggars in Pakistan
Is this Pakistans biggest problem? No
@@ThePakistanExperience Biggest problem of Pakistan is PMLN and PPP, and one institute 🤣
@@ThePakistanExperience 14% of the population? Can't u just do a gareeb Kalyan yojana with the benajir income support and deliver free rations and grains.
This solves the need to work for food, and people will work for wealth, security or future health Corpus.
Instead of begging with predictable income to working with unpredictable pay.
Beggars at best are a symptom not the root cause
Posting this video At a time when Punjabis Are been targeted by the BLP doesn’t seem like the best idea. And as a comedian you know timing is everything.
Read the room.
This reads like Israelis commenting that now is not the time to talk about Palestine after October 7th.
More Baloch have died since that attack on Punjabis. We shouldn’t not talk about that just because Punjabis were targeted also.
I made a whole video on that already.
Punjabis targeted in Balochistan BLA - Are problems in Pakistan Punjab's fault? - #TPE Daily
ua-cam.com/video/jsDAa0LBzgE/v-deo.html
@@ThePakistanExperiencei saw this video already. But when tensions are high, making a general video about the punjabi advantage is Pakistan seems in poor taste. And my point was the timing of this video is insensitive. The content is debatable.
Also, as much as you talk about unifying the nation or the idea of social equality and tolerance, simultaneously you are churring out US vs THEM videos.
Challenge - Make a video/ video series of what unites us as a nation not today, but since the start.
Id like nothing more to be wrong
The forced unity is what divides us
The only province whom have given govt jobs to outsiders meanwhile the most populous province of Pakistan,the only province where everyone of pathan,baloch or sindhi origin can come and do business,take education,do visit and tour but the only province who only recieve hate, murdered when move to other states and still being blamed,the only province whose labours are killed for belonging to that province even from the busses,now it's time for punjabi to start taking stand for themselves punjab is for punjabis only don't allow any outsider
Yehi soch problem hay
@@arsheenzahid1972 baby tum kdr rehti ho
@@ThePakistanExperienceI agree with the comment above. I’m a non Punjabi living in Punjab & I’ve never face any systemic racism. Not everything is black & white.
A Baloch like Buzdar can be CM Punjab but can a Muhajir ever be CM Sindh? I don’t think so.
@@apainting4658agreed , establishment is bad ,this doesn't give you a license to hate on punjabis for their ethnicity
Phr Lagao Naaraa: "Jag Punjabi jag, teri pag nu lag gaya daagh"
During partition era, two generators, Rasheed Maseeh and Bota were on duty near Data Darbar. There was a rally in the same area and people were chanting. Rasheed asked to Bota, YAR AAY MUSLIA.N NOO KEE CHAIE DA AAY? Bota replied, AAY “SADAY” KOOLON AZADI MANG DAY PAY NAYIEN.
It’s all about elite and AWAAM, but unfortunately intellectuals turned it to “We and Them”.
Apne kaha ky punjabi nay exploit kara ha pakstan ko , or sindhio ny bhi to sindh ky logo ko exploit kara ha unko gulam bana kr rakha ap us pr bhi baat karen or establishment ka hisa sindhi bhi hai PPP bhi foj ki goud may rehti ha any time ap log bhi elite ka hisa ho or Pakistan ko loot rahe ho , Sirf punjabi ko blame karna sahi nahi ha isme sab involve hai
lol
Dominated by karachi??
Are you crazy???
Karachi people aren't even able to get government jobs due to the quota system placed by people's party.
There is no place for Karachi people in police.
Thumbnail shows your hatred against karachi
He is crazy fan of bhutto and PPP
So, you see, the thing is, in bureaucracy and in public services jobs ( practiced internationally) that a person doesn't get appointments in their own district due to personal biases may affect the decisions . I know this may come as a surprise but most people in Sindh specifically in interior Sindh speak Sindhi
And government jobs, especially in police and bureaucracy such as Assistant Commissioner, DSP, SHO, they are the jobs that are connected with the local people. They need to be connected with the locals to solve their problems. When one does not even understand or does not even know what the problems of the people are, he or she can't even understand what locals are saying. You might say that why don't they learn Urdu. You want the whole village/ possibly city to speak a new language to accommodate a new guy who came to city hmmm 🤔 says a lot about narcissism. So the thing about this is you want us to learn your language ( assuming you speak Urdu ) but u don't want to take effort to learn ours. ( No relation to this but recently a new DSP got posted in my city he is from karachi comes from an Urdu speaking background. But he learned Sindhi to understand locals and their problems)
Or baaqi hum ne dekhe hain k wo kitna kaam kartay hain. Na Bijli ka bil do, Na Gas Ka, Na income tax do, na custom duties, Musafiro ko Loto, Bachay paida karo or so jao. Jinn Bacho ko Newspaper bhi nahi parhna ata, wo hi 600, 600 number leke CSS karkay unki beurocracy mein ajatay hain. Unki cabinet ko Punjab se compare karke dekh lo. Baaqi unko bhalay PM banado ya President. Punjab unke bina survive kar jayega apni ability pe.
Good bro its time to stand for Punjab ❤✊🏻
Humein yeh sab sirf isliye pagal bana rhey hein kyun k hummein qoum parasti nahin hai
@@_abdullah_jatthmesha punjabio pe zulam hua Phir b punjab bura kya punjabi kahte dera bugti mai gas na do ? Jo other province extra electricity ke bill pay krta punjab uska kya ? Sara burden punjab pe hai phir b punjab bura ..Jo elite hai usko pakro chahy punjab se ho karachi se ho ya balochistan se
@@hassanzaka1156 KPK mein adhey ziyada log bijli chori kartey hein aur bill Punjab deta hai, Balochistan mein jo gas banti hai woh ziyada kpk waghera hi jati hai Punjab sindh se gas khareed k istimal karta hai ya phir log cylinder bharwatey hein, Kashmir aur Gilgit ki larayi mein hum log har waqt india se jung mein rehtey hein na trade kartey hein ulta khud jaibo k taxes k paisey laga rhey hein takey indian foji inhein modi aur yogi k hathey na charha dein, sindh mein sara wadera system aur kachey k dakku paley huey hein aur phir rotey hein sindh k halaat kharab hein humne taraqi nahin ki,
Punjab aaj jo bhi hai apney sar pe hai ulta agar hum in sab k saath na hotey tau aaj Punjab ne had se ziyada taraqi kar jani thi lekin phir bhi in logo ki jalan nahin khatam hoti Punjab ko taraqi karta dekh k kyun k in k khoon mein dhokeybazi aur badnasli hai,
Punjab sirf atta, chawal, namak, cheeni, sabzia aur fruit rok de tau yeh phir mitti aur ghaas khayenge
Punjab Zindabad 🙌🏻
Punjabiat Zindabad ✊🏻
What a racist comment, first off CSS is no benchmark for education or intelligence, it's a remnant of colonization.
Sindh would survive without Punjab, it has its own gas, own coal, own shores and port and sufficient crops. Half the power plants making power from gas in Ghotki district are sending that electricity to Punjab and Punjabi fauj has made sure the C suite in all those companies is Punjabi.
Stop trying to play the victim if you live in north Punjab .
Your understanding of the Indian social system is rudimentary, unless you have lived experience you cannot even imagine to comprehend the complexity of the country. Best you stick to an analysis of Pakistan.
Tell me you’re running out of content without telling me you’re running out of content
Tell me you got embarrassed in the other comment section so you came here to troll without telling me that.
@@ThePakistanExperience other comment section? mate I don’t even comment that much, on any channel. And no I’m not trolling you, just genuinely thought this video was kinda “filler content”
Weren’t you the same guy who was commenting on the post about this video?
If not I am sorry I confused your username with someone else’s
My bad
This topic is actually quite important.
Please at least don't say this that karachi has dominated the country instead it is the most ignored city which produces almost 70% of the country's GDP.
Please don’t comment without watching
@@ThePakistanExperienceAllow Karachi to secede.....and see how the sons of soil fare, if any better
Bolna kya chahta aur sune wala kaun hai...... Primary criteria is education which is not available in Balochistan/ Sindh / KP / FATA / Wazaristan / South Punjab / karachi.... If you deprived them from education they can't never come and stand up against the elite 😅😅😅
These people here want to target punjabi indentity which majority of the elite belongs to according to you maybe but what is the basis of their punjabi identity ? Their race or their language majority of elite dont want to associate with punjabi language and they dont even speak punjabi. Now if this is based on race than how come a rajput in south punjab is saraiki according to so called saraiki intellectuals but a rajput in central is punjabi? Majority of people who are behind the saraiki movement are baloch who migrated here at some point how do they have a right to divide our identity? . Punjabs one city alone produces 2.5 billion of exports called sialkot.
You guys dont want to associate those baloch pashtoon or sindhis who support establishment with their respective identity but want to associate a punjabi elite which doesn’t even speak punjabi with punjabi identity?
Shezad's bias against karachi continues. Kp and bolachistan just having a border makes them strategicly important but karachi's port is dose not. How he clearly paints a picture that karachi has exploited kpk through afghan war, and jokes about poor roads in karachi. Let me remind him that due to that war karachi has faced and infllux of drugs weapons and terorism. In that period every week there was a bomb blast in karachi and a thousands of killings.
Unlike Shezad bhai's clear racist atitude against mahajir community I will accept that people in kpk balochistan and interior sindh have a way more difficult life. They have not been given there rights.
Lastly maybe shezad's keen itnrest in history has made him forget for the past 30 years straight PPP (inarguably a sindhi party) has had a government in sindh(elected by sindhi people). It is the people of karachi that are being kept out of burecracy and politics.
Karachites strenght that your unable to see is our skilled people. We are open to all communities and religions. We are more professional and skilled than anyother city in pakistan.There's a reason why unilver and png have offices in karachi.
Yes I should focus on how a war that happened on Khyber Pakhtunkhwa affected Karachi rather than focusing on where the war actually took place.
Mujhay racist bolnay say pehley apnay prejudice dekho. Did you even watch the video
Is hee colonial attitude aur superiority complex kee waja say peripheries exploit hoti hain
Asli racist toh tum ho who thinks you are racially superior to everyone else
@ThePakistanExperience hahaha wow Shezad you’re so smart. Jawab Nahi to bus Ghussa karo. Firstly I didn’t call you a racist I said your attitude is. Secondly why do you want to compare people and their suffering.Yes speak for the people in Baluchistan and Kpk and sindh but don’t divide people. Have the courtesy to attest acknowledge what people in Karachi have gone through. I’m not trying to say peripheries me Zulm nahi hua, bohat hua hai but to put it on people living in other regions is stupid. I did see your video and maybe it was not your intention but you were being biased against Karachi not recognising their suffering. I get it’s not a video about Karachi but at least don’t ridicule us.
Major complain about people of punjab is that they never feel the pain of other people, if they are happy or living their lives with ease they never ever concern about three other provinces. When Imran said about Hazaras dead bodies that they are blackmailing him no one in punjab got offended by that comment of imran khan.😢😢
Yes! Empathy nahee hay
@@ThePakistanExperience Taking the last name of Khan doesn't make one Pashtun/Pathan. Ayub Khan was from Hazara and spoke Hindkowan and Yahya Khan was Punjjabi from Chakwal- probably a converted Sikh. Both of them have no dead or alive Pashtun relatives in Pakistan or Afghanistan.
yeah, the playboy Khan is an accurate representative of 11 crore Punjabis. Everybody booed Khan's comments. What can a normal person do ?
@@sabrinakhan8217Ayub Khan is ethnically still a pashtoon. Yahya Khan is ethnically Qazilbash pashtoon. Niazi clan also claims to be ethnically pashtoon as well. Imran Khan's maternal side is from Barki family of Waziristan in Ex FATA. You need to read history and Pakistani culture plzzzz
@@ThePakistanExperienceI don't know how can you say that punjabis have no empathy? We still are not killing people after checking their CNIC's. Come on get some common sense before you comment about 100 Million people.
Brilliant ❤
Next video Pashtun Adalat 11 October please
❤️
Today's undivided India was a creation of the central Asian Mughals.
Before them, the Afghans ruled from Kabul to Dhaka for few centuries.
The Afghans and Turks from central Asia ruled India between 500 to 700 years.
Descendants of these people consider themselves the ruling elite in Pakistan, India and Bangladesh.
Today's Pakistan is a creation of the nawabs of UP, CP, Bihar and Bengal whose ancestors came from outside the subcontinent as invaders like the British.
After 1947, these people were the ruling elite.
Gradually they are being replaced by the sons of the soil.
This loss of position and power causes intense resentment among those who are no longer part of the power structure.
Your knowledge is correct in some ways but wrong in many ways. Quaid e Azam belong to Lohana Rajput's family.Allama Muhammad Iqbal belonged to Kashmiri Pandits family titled Sheikhs of Kashmir.Liaquat Ali Khan belonged to the family of Jutts of Punjab .Chaudhary Rehmat Ali belonged to Gujjar Clan of Punjab.Sir Syed Ahmed Khan had an Arab Ancestory although his ancestory maybe doubtfull because many people of the time had no real ancestory check so many people faked to be Syeds.Sikandar Hayat Khan belonged to Khattar Tribe of Jutts.Chaudry Muhammad Zafarullah Khan belonged to Sahi Jaats of Sialkot. A. K. Fazlul Huq
belonged to Bengali Family of Qazis.Khawaja Nizam ud din was Bengali Nawab Muslim with roots in Kashmir.His ancestors moved from Kashmiri to Bengal.
😂
Bro lemme clear u up ur facts about Kp r totally wrong u hvnt read any history of kpk .Nwfp name was given by britishers it had its own identity before it was called a princely state Yaghistan province of Afghanistan before 1893 when it got seperated due to Afghans own integeral wars it got seperated from Afghanistan on leash nd was given to britishers but it was not controlled fully except peshawar 30 years we fought Britishers nd got freed in 1920 nd the status was given as Pashtunistan by Bacha Khan. Get ur facts right u hv totally wrong info about Kp.
It was dominated by Karachi for various reasons some of them are as below:
1) Karachi was the Capital and the only port of Pakistan.
2) People who migrated to Karachi were already held office and finance positions whereas people in Pakistan at that time were mainly farmers
3)Muhajirs were well educated again not because there were universities in Karachi then Ghari Khuda Baksh but becaused they migrated from cities in India where the infrasture and education was better (which we have come to realise since the economy of India is far bigger than Pakistan even though our resources to people ratio is low against India)
4) India abolished the British system and brought in land reforms whereas here we still folow the same colonial system. This system was practiced in Rural Pakistan almost everywhere but not in Karachi and hence equal opportunity in the field of education and establishing new business etc.
I also noticed that you did not mention quota system even once which show your bias so next time when you do a podcast please do your thoroughhomework
1) Karachi was made the capital.
2) wrong
3) because the rich elite graduated. Poor Muslims in India were left behind.
4) bhai kyon nahee Kia land reform? In power kaun tha? Un sab nay kyon nahee Kia? Kyon Kay feudals aur landlords Kay puppets thay ruling class?
Next time you listen to a podcast do it with an open mind without your prejudices. Now tell me homework kar ke who introduced the quota system
Karachi kee saray achay schools pre partition hain and you’re claiming yahan education nahee thee? 😅
Bhai racism choro toh batao if education was the only difference government say free loans aur sari resources kyon lee?
Please grow out of your misconceptions and read the actual history.
@@ThePakistanExperience Bhutto introduced Quota system to bring least educated system to "Quomi dhara" which was only for 10 years but is still in play
Religion for Elites is d same in both India nd Pak.
In a standup show, the comedian asks any body who has inter-caste marriage; 1 guy says his is inter-religion and there wasnt any problm frm both families; the comedian asks laughingly " arrey bhai aap-log bahot Ameer-vameer ho kya???
Thisz a real incident. I saw this show on youtube.
It's worse in India .
Not generally but particularly .
For you , Khalistani .
LoL ... Khalistani is now an expert on India
Stupid case built. Non directional commentary
Come on, man. Your justification for why Punjab produces more agricultural products is, to say the least, hilarious. It further reinforces your anti-Punjab narrative. Punjab was producing significantly more agricultural products compared to Sindh, Balochistan, and KPK even before partition. Punjab also had more cultivable land before partition.
But you have to prove somehow that punjab "Extracts" more water as compared to its due share so that is why you are presenting such flimsy arguments.
Bhai zabardasti punjab ko villian sabit krny mai lgy huy hain aajkal. Beshak hawai batain he krni parain.
If you bothered to watch and learn instead of ranting about me being anti Punjab you have heard me talking about how the British also invested in Punjab and did not develop the peripheries
Somehow prove?
Ye lo facts dekh lo
www.dawn.com/news/amp/1614822
Numbers cannot be denied because facts make you angry dost
It is not enough for Punjabi lobby. That's it.
@@ThePakistanExperience
Sir, there is a basic difference between fact and claim 🙏, the article you referred to states that the Provincial Assembly was "informed" about the alleged theft of Sindh's water share by "Punjab/federal govt." But who exactly was making these claims?
The same landlords and feudal lords who make people in rural Sindh believe that Punjabis would extract electricity from the water of the Indus River that's why we have to oppose the construction of the Kalabagh Dam?
The same landlords who have their private jails and treat their tenants worse than animals? I do not consider their claims as "facts".
Could you please provide a scientific and credible report from a reputable institution, either local or international, that discusses such a large-scale "theft" by Punjab with the help and support of federal government?
@@ThePakistanExperience
Okay, so should the blame be placed on the British, then?
Once the land was populated and the population grew due to various factors, Punjab became the most populated province .
Now, why should we deny the people of Punjab their fair share in the National Assembly?
Punjab has already sacrificed its share by allowing equal representation of the smaller provinces in the Senate. So why do you and other anti-Punjab guests you invite want to take away their rightful representation in the National Assembly still?
There are already considerably more voters per NA seat in Punjab compared to Balochistan, KPK, and rural Sindh, yet you still claim that Punjab is being favored everywhere! How and why?
Punjab has the most cultivable land and produces the most agricultural products in Pakistan, feeding the entire country. So why shouldn't Punjab get a larger share of water?
Infrastructure development in Punjab started by the Sharifs in the 1990s really picked up pace during Shehbaz Sharif's consecutive terms as Chief Minister of Punjab, as Dr. Umar Saif mentioned on your podcast. So why haven't the governments of Balochistan, KPK, and Sindh been able to match or even come close to Punjab's development during the same period? Is this because the so-called resources were being diverted to Punjab even after the 18th Amendment?
I humbly request you to please provide credible facts and figures, data, and details on how Punjab supposedly restricted the smaller provinces from building roads, hospitals, schools, universities, IT centers, infrastructure, and digitizing provincial departments ?
Thank you very much
Please read the Indus Water Treaty again,
How Ayub sold 3 rivers of Punjab to make Tarbela and Mangla dam.
Please don't spread misinformation.
@@Techuser704 IT doesn't change my point that Dams were built after selling rivers to India
@@Techuser704 I think you didn't read my actual comment.
Shehzad in his video mentioned that dams were made by aid that we were getting from becoming part of US alliance.
My point was that it is not true, because the money for the dams came after 3 rivers of Punjab were sold to India.
I hope you get my point now.
@@Techuser704Don't you think it was punjab right that dam should be built in punjab because punjab rivers were sold.
@@Techuser704 I don't want to be rude
But let me make this clear to you, you don't know history and just going on and on upon the same thing.
There is no point in talking to you who have no clue about International Laws & International Treaties
@@AhsanSaleem99 You are not rude but the worst type of idiot.
Every single word of english has its own meaning whihc forms a sentence. You are using "sold" again and again.
You can't sell when you didn't own is what I am saying. Pakistan did not own a single river.
Not all PUNJABIS (especially Southern Punjab), hum se pooch k thodi na policies banti hain jo BLA humen aa kr maar de
Brother Pakistan is an Ethnocracy dominated the Punjabi speaking parts of Pakistan.Pakistan constution is a western parliamentary Majoritarian democracy where Punjab dominates in the National Assembly and also the distribution of resources is on the basis of population where again Punjab takes the lion share including that of the Sarakis of Punjab.Count top military generals who make defence and security policies which are mostly exercised in Balochistan and Pakhtunkhwa almost all of them are Punjabis....count the top 40 plus powerful federal secretaries almost most if them are Punjabis.....now just imagine their imprint on major state policies especially of security and defence......State apparatus is dominated by Punjabis and it's policies are biased in favour of them.1973 Constution perpetuates the hegemony of Punjab forever......
You’re right but the 1973 Constitution was a massive upgrade on what was happening before it.
The provincial lists devolved a lot of powers
Also, taking the last name of Khan doesn't make one Pashtun/Pathan. Ayub Khan was from Hazara and spoke Hindkowan and Yahya Khan was Punjjabi from Chakwal- probably a converted Sikh. Both of them have no dead or alive Pashtun relatives in Pakistan or Afghanistan.
@@ThePakistanExperience yes brother agreed with you but times have changed immensely and Pakistan need a new social contract or we have to add some elements of Consociational democracy to our constution like the empowerment of the senate on the model of ideal federal systems like that of USA etc.....Brother even the 1973 constution was thrown into dustbin many times by the Punjab dominated state instutions.Constutional and instutional hegemonic preservation of Punjab in Pakistan is harming Pakistan on daily basis.Punjabi elite and Punjab dominated state instructions have to realise it and let go some of their might and power for the better tomorrow of Pakistan and it's All people from all ethnicites.
@@ThePakistanExperience Concurrent list went on for a long time.18th Amendment devolved many things to the province and Punjab benefited from this 18th amendment the most which previously was reluctant to go for any such devolution.No award of NFC has been held since NFC award and in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa action in aid of civil power since past one plus decade had diluted the spirit of that devolution.....this action in aid of civil power was extended to the entire province in 2019 by the pti government.....I don't know it's financial repurcussions for the province when it requisitiones the services of the federal law enforcement agencies.....Hybrid experimentation of the Punjabi military elite was a brazen attack on the provincial atuonomy and ex Army chief Mr Bajwa Sahb once called 18th amendment more dangerous than Shekh Mujeeb 6 Points.The political DNA of Punjab is pro domiantion and centralization since the beginning unfortunately.Our Beloved brother need to learn some basic things about the goods of decentralisation.......
i don't know if this is an editing difference after 24 mins podcast when audio only! displaying just thumbnails. shayad firewall chalu hogaya hai! shahzad bhai tassdiq karain?
ایلیٹ کی ایلیٹنس پر بات کرو ایلیٹ کی پنجابیت پر نہیں ۔ خود مان بھی رہے ہو کہ عام پنجابی کا اس سارے کھیل سے کوئی لینا دینا نہیں بھر بھی فریمنگ پنجاب اور باقی "مظلوم" قوموں کی کر رہے ہو
Bhai ka bass chaly Punjabi hi mita dy jub sy dekha hai Punjabi Punjabi ka raag alapta hai bhai elite elite hota hai wo chahy kisi bhi ethnicity ka ho ayub khan ky bary main keh rha hai wo pushton representation nahi thi to yaar Punjab ka elite bhi to punjabi representation nahi hai na
Agreed, dual standards ke pasthun dictator unki representation nhi mgr Punjabi dictator punjabion ki representation hai ,
Yh dogla pan aur munafqat hoti@@MuhammadAbdullah-ug8gd
But now in last 30 years punjab is dominating the country with Islamabad area and lahore on top
I think thumbnail is not appropriate especially with respect to pakistan dominated by karachi.I want to make clear that karachi doesn't not dominate pakistan but it is dominated by ruling elite of sindh and to some extent punjab's elite which controls military and federal government.It should be clear to everyone that karachi doesn't get its in government jobs including bureaucracy because of non meritorious system of quota which divides rural and urban sindh so it weird to see the thumbnail stating karachi dominates pakistan.Bureucracy and most of ruling elite is from north punjab and upper sindh(land lords and peers) including military elite and political elite
Why are you commenting without watching?
Facts don’t change based on your beliefs. Watch the video
The video is showing only one side of the coin .Look at the other side too .
How much representation does Karachi have in Federal jobs ? What about the Karachi domicile holders ,how much representation in Sindh Government jobs .Ur video is biased with regard to Karachi as the dominant city .
Present evidence. If I am wrong refute with facts.
@@ThePakistanExperienceyou should present these facts given you’re the one making a misinformed video. Otherwise why should your opinion be considered over the real life experiences of someone.
Sir from tbe time of British govt., it was decided that development of infrastructure in Balochistan and KPK will be very difficult, the main reason was geography and population density, railway road from Lahore to Karachi and Lahore to Rawalpindi were historically profitable, runing transport lanes, building and maintaining infrastructure in this area was easy as there was a potential consumer for it. Building and maintaining infrastructure in Balochistan is extremely difficult, so Britain decided that they will divert a portion of resources from Punjab and try to support development in Balochistan, after Pakistan came into being, people in power lacked any vision to address this vital issue, an easy solution is to relocate population into Balochistan under govt supervision but that can affect demography adversely and turn Balochs minority in their own province so it requires careful planning, for which govt of Pakistan totally lack capacity. Best solution is giving autonomy to all provinces but we know answer about it. Another solution is let corporations take hold on the resources of Balochistan and let them drive development. It is complex issue. It is not like resources are only diverted from Balochistan to central Pakistan. Historically resources has been diverted from common Punjabis for development of Balochistan and KPK as well. But no Punjabi talk about that, there is no nationalist movement in Punjab, the identity of being Punjabi was drowned under the identity of being Pakistani.
"اپنی identity کو shed کر کے سسٹم کو سمجھیں" اور پھر اپنی identity کو ہی کوسیں ۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔یہ کہنا چاہتے ہیں ہمارے پوڈکاسٹر۔۔۔۔۔
@@firstnamelastname6976 wo khud confused hi ..bus usko topic chiya tha video bnany k lia
Bt tum pakio ka pahchan qya hai??
Bo sach bol Raha haiv😂😂😂
Your vlogs at times teach me more about the real history of partition than what our history books do of our school curriculum here in India!! That's why I try not to miss any of your videos!! Thanks for educating people like us!!
❤️🙌
Sir what is the use of talking history always, talk in future, implemented solutions, as a indian i feel Pakistan stuck in past,your army, media, judge, oppositions part, and mostly people should think about future not on every time historical timlines
How do you implement solutions without knowing the problems?
@@ThePakistanExperience Sir, last 2 years I am watching your videos, I suggest take department wise, subject wise, or topic wise like (Education, health, digital, infrastructure, jobs, police, waterways, budget, women empowerment, kids’ education, revenue, Agriculture, Housing, Real time governance, civil& food supplies, Municipal Administration & Urban Development etc) and put the problem facing, and put the solutions by observing how others are doing or updating in the US, UK, China & if u like India.
Check the south Indian states like Andra Pradesh, Telengana etc and check their govt websites to understand the programs, plans,etc are planned.
Bhai aap batai jo bijli kpk me milti hai kia aus ke bill wo log bhartay hain?? Nahi wo log kunday laga ke araam kartay hain to aus hisaab se wahan development nahi hoti
Aap akelay aisy sawal jawab kartay hai. Kia kisi ke sath debate nahi kiya kisi sahi punjabi ke sath jo aap ko asal haqeeqat bayan karay
Kia aap ko nahi pata kpk me majority of people afghanistan jana chahtay hain ya Afghanistan ke sath khud ko zam karna chahtay hain
Why the sudden rise is talks about Punjabi Dominance after BLA attacks?
Because they want to frame it as a racism issue which it is not. It is an establishment/elite vs the rest of Pakistan issue.
Why they are doing it? Because that kind of narrative is easy to sell in the West because of the own history of racism in West.
It's absolutely true that punjab and islamabd takes a bigger share of the pie, but here in KP the incompitent PTI govt have used the ethnicity card to hold onto power, they have presented themeselves and IK as the soul spoksmen of the pakhtoon community but are part of that same elite status quo and have looted millions from the same pakhtoon's, resorting to the same devide and rule stratgey like their fathers and grand father's ayub khan and ghulam ishaq khan's of the world did.
Spot on
Karachi Has Been On The Fringes Since The Rise Of MQM
No
Pakistan was demanded by " All india Muslim league" in british india not muslim league but you all haven't study the truth of your history 😉 so Rest in future 😊
Moh Ali Jinnah made Pakistan only for 20families and some feudal even they doesn't concerned about Lehman.
Worry about your own country..
Where cows are safer than women.
You led him to go this extent?? If all india congress elected m.a.jinnah as party leader rather than jawarlal nehru this partition never happens and india not divided by on religous bases.
Lord McCauley's children...
Let's talk about dream mall.... And your opinion?
Kinda Yes , Seraiki Movement has been destroyed by Punjabi Generals from Lahore and Pindi who have set up madressas to radicalise our People now there is lot of hate for Shias here even though We were sufis.
Junobi Punjab Soba Please , There are floods and None talks of it
😂 even sraiki has not yet born
Yedi deo ghulami tum logon ne phir Gilanion, Legharion, Mazarion, Gurchanion aur Dareeshakon ki krni hai. South Punjab se 5 representative bata do jo jageerdar na hon. Naya suba bund men lo ge?
Saraiki is a gane played to cut the punjabi language into parts
Janoobi Punjab Sooba idea only used by Janoobi Punjab politians at election time and selling it out to "win" the seats and forgotten till next election 🥴
Campaign for Kalabagh Dam.
Also do you know who is forcing the Hindu women to convert to Islam... Happens only in interior sindh!! Anything on that?
Whataboutism say behtar hay insaan meri purani videos dekh lai
And the preachers with that mentality usually come from Punjab and KPK. They have been dismantling the fabrics and developing their own to create secure job space in exchange of religious card.
Punjabis get religiously excited when they see non-Muslims of Sindh, beginning to ruin the existing resonance, where the others capitalize on the opportunities.
Jhoot bolne ki BHI had hoti hai@@kohyaaransari9069
KPK mein adhey ziyada log bijli chori kartey hein aur bill Punjab deta hai, Balochistan mein jo gas banti hai woh ziyada kpk waghera hi jati hai Punjab sindh se gas khareed k istimal karta hai ya phir log cylinder bharwatey hein, Kashmir aur Gilgit ki larayi mein hum log har waqt india se jung mein rehtey hein na trade kartey hein ulta khud jaibo k taxes k paisey laga rhey hein takey indian foji inhein modi aur yogi k hathey na charha dein, sindh mein sara wadera system aur kachey k dakku paley huey hein aur phir rotey hein sindh k halaat kharab hein humne taraqi nahin ki,
Punjab aaj jo bhi hai apney sar pe hai ulta agar hum in sab k saath na hotey tau aaj Punjab ne had se ziyada taraqi kar jani thi lekin phir bhi in logo ki jalan nahin khatam hoti Punjab ko taraqi karta dekh k kyun k in k khoon mein dhokeybazi aur badnasli hai,
Punjab sirf atta, chawal, namak, cheeni, sabzia aur fruit rok de tau yeh phir mitti aur ghaas khayenge
Punjab Zindabad 🙌🏻
Punjabiat Zindabad ✊🏻
Cylinder mai jo gas daalti hay woh jhelum say atee hay? 🤣
@@ThePakistanExperience Sindh se aati hai aur tax bhi lagta hai sindh hakumat ko iske paisey bhi miltey hein mein bhi utni hi mehnat karta hun jitna aik sindhi ya balochi karta hai
Hum ne tau itna sab diya hai kabhi ginwaya nahin hala nakey usmein hum apni mehnat bhi kartey hein aur mein agriculture ki baat kar rha hun aap logo k paas aik gas nikal ayi hai woh bhi thori sii aur aap log samajhtey ho azad hokar Saudi sheikho ki tarah Lamborghini rakh lo ge aisa nahi hai bhukey reh jaoge sab kuch punjab se import karoge sirf sindh hi hai jo thori bohut wheat production karleta hai baakio ki zameen pe channey bhi nahin ugtey aur jo aaj balochi rorhey hein inhein yeh bhi batao k gawadar tum balochio k baap ka nahin hai yeh aik Punjabi ne hi Oman se khareeda tha
Ajeeb drama banaya hua hai aap logo ne
great video. The problem and narratives are so deep rooted that it needs a major critical rethink by masses to understand the real problems. Yes punjabis and karachiites and even pathans dominate pakistan.....Balochs and sindhis have been kept underprivileged for so long that it has become an emergency matter to uplift these people for the federation to be viable.
Elites dominate Pakistan. No Punjabi, sindhi, pathan, or balochi dominate Pakistan
Yes
Baaqi Punjab k yehi bachay jinhe yahan oppertunities nahi milti wo poori dunia mein apni mehnat se apna naam banate hain. Jinn Punjabi bacho ko Pakistan reject kardeta hai wohi Western Universities, Beurocracy, Buissness Community or highly professional logo mein shamil hote hain. Victim Card k bajaye wo hr system mein adjust ho k excel karte hain. Victim Card hi play karna hota to Sialkot or Faislabad jo apne paaun pe khud khara hua hai kisi or illaqay ki tarha ro raha hota. Albata choro hum to khud jald iss system se nikal kr kisi doosre mulk k system mein adjust hone jarhay hain. Khuda Hafiz
Yehi punjabi pori dunya mai budnaam hai.. click karo uk, uae, saudi usa australia loxal news, jhoot scam, voilance,crimes.... i,migratiin walo ko punjani word tak pata hai.. khuda hafiz
Punjjjjj aibiiiii
@@missahmed2220 G bhai blkl Afghani Pushtoons sy zayada civillized society to exist hi nahi kerti na puri duniya main aur sindh main to Animals lover rehty hain Balochistan main freedom Fighters hain aur Kpk ki to kia hi baat hai wahan pr to Pakky Muslim hain momin hai bacha baazi ka to naam nishan hi nahi hai
It’s like offering a feast to someone who hasn’t eaten in weeks, only for them to reject it because the food isn’t from their culture.
People need time bro, they have been in the dark since they were born, and its ain't easy digestion as well.
مختصر یہ کے مسئلہ ایلیٹ اسٹیبلشمنٹ کا ہے لیکن ہم نام پنجاب کا لیتے ہیں کیونکہ اس سے ہمارے بلوچی یا پشتون قومیت پرست بیانیہ کو تقویت ملتی ہے ۔۔۔۔۔
No because that elite establishment is dominated by Punjab
خود ہی کہا ہے کہ ایلیٹ ہو کر پنجابی پنجابی نہیں رہتا بنگالی بنگالی نہیں رہتا ایلیٹ ایک الگ ہی کیٹگری ہے۔ پھر لفظ پنجاب پر اتنا فوکس کرنے کی کیا ضرورت ہے ؟ @@ThePakistanExperience
Us ka podcast bike ga jb tk wo jaan boojh kr ultey seedhey caption nhi lagae ga. Jinnah, Ayub Khan, Iskender Mirza, aur Bhutto men se koi bhi Punjabi nhi tha.
Dekhay bhagyr comment?
@@ThePakistanExperienceدیکھا ہے بھائی ۔
The very fact that you’re saying all this means that someone in the ESTABLISHMENT or the establishment has realised the main problem with Pakistan and that bodes well for the Southeast Asia.
Meray khenay say establishment ka kya taluq
@@ThePakistanExperience Bhai these kind of educated thoughts were unheard of emanating from Pakistan and the fact that you are so easily discussing it on your podcast.I respect journalists from Pakistan.
baatein hi krta rhta hy tu kuch practical kya agy aa k
?
Next time bohat practical kaam karo ga
UA-cam par comments karo ga!
At the start you mentioned that you didn't mean ordinary Punjabi and Muhajir when you're referring to elite in this video, which is fine if you hadn't abandoned that principle mid way and blamed Punjabis and Muhajirs by the end for sth as gigantic as American Hegemony on the US. You're quick to point out the ethnicity of industrialists but not of the landholding Elite of Sindh that not only engage in the agricultural and irrigational exploitation of their own people?
I'm someone who recognizes the plight of the Baloch people and the atrocities the army committed on them but if you can attach an ethnicity to the industrial elite of Pakistan then you can surely attach it to theP Pashtun dictators and Sindhi Prime Ministers until the 70s who played a very aggressive role in the exploitation and killing of Baloch. You can't have your cake and eat it too
I am a fan of your podcast I listen to it a lot. I even agree to many of the points in your videos but if we're going by military elites then Chakwal is more privileged than rest of Punjab , which is absurd
On top of all that he thinks criticizing Baloch sardars is racist.
@@firstnamelastname6976 yeah, even though in the current scenario, Baloch sardars are very much in bed with the army. That includes the Bhugtis. They ARE a part of the structure
Not when they are agents of the state. Baloch Sardar ya Sindhi waderay kee power awaam say nahee arahi woh arahi hee is hee establishment say
@@ThePakistanExperience who argued that their power comes from the people? Do you think that the power of the so called Punjabi establishment of industrialists and army come from the Punjabi or Muhajir people? It absolutely does not.
Remember shehzad, the British also had another tool of repression against their colonial subjects and that was Divide and Conquer. By trying to pin different ethnicities against the other, you're playing very much into it
Sir you have spinned the topic quite well. It can be a way to look at it but unfortunately what you mentioned is not true. Regarding Karachi, it has always been neglected despite its importance as an economic hub.
No. I presented facts.
Itna tasub bhu acha nahi hai dost, pichle 2 decades se Sindh pe sindhio ki hukumat hai or paisa bhi theek thak banalia hai, corruption or kache k dako se fursat mile tub lagalo industry dedo logo ko naukria barhado mulk ki gdp
Before formation of Pakistan, Jinnah send his emissary to America that you should support us with money and arms and we will protect your interests in middle east etc
Great video!
🙌
You did not mention sindhi elite. Like bhutto and zardari . you mention the dams you didn't mentioned the reasons after selling which province rivers dollars was given to Pakistan.
Fantastic video regarding structure of our system…. I loved it 👍👍
🙌
Your topic is interesting for the real fact of ground...But
your podcast title question should be :
Is it real that the system of whole Pakistan is totally control in majority by PUNJAB (not punjabi) and a small part of elites of KARACHI ?
Keep it up😊
Punjabi or any other ethnicity should not be in the question at all. talk about establishment, elites all you want.
Jani you are doing what I want❤ the way you are covering Pakistan. Amazing
❤️
Very informative ❤
The strategy of making wealthy elites, basically routing money into fewer hands is a well thought out economic strategy that most of the successful countries have followed. The SAMSUNG, AMBANI, MITSUBISHI, Standard Oil are some examples. This is necessary for investment in big and riskier projects - that small business won't or can't get into. Governments are inefficient in doing businesses. Regarding wealth staying in fewer hands, this issue is sorted out in few generations where ownership of business goes into different hands and family involvement deteriorates.
The issue with Pakistan is that whatever strategy it makes, it is cancelled out by next Leaders in Power, that is why see good economic conditions when the period of leadership extends beyond few years.
Incredibly realistic.
🙌
some elites from UP and Gujrat cannot represent whole muhajir and whole karachi
You talk about lower caste let me tell you 2 presidents belong yo lower castes 5 cm have came from lower castes tribal community have 3 cm they have proper representation in goverme.t jobs and private sectors we have done far better job in uplifiting our weaker section of society unlikre pakistan which legally discrimnates against ahmsdiyas hindus sikhs christians
From land to the sea balochistan will be free.
Shehzad you talk absolute sense on most ot the things except on israel -gaza issue and a little bit less information about Indian Muslim. .
Vote for a podcast with Syed Muzammil Shah✅
Shehzad i agree with you on most things and i maybe am biased as a punjabi
I have a few points
1. There are 250 milion children in punjab who don't go to school in punjab. How is that privilege
2. Please go to a public hospital in Punjab at any time. See how many people are there.there is literally no pre-op st nishtar multan and people go to masjid instead.Yes they are better than other 3 provinces but my point is are they really that good
Same for that education point yes punjab is much better than other 3 but is it really that good
3. Believe it or not we are actually receptive to other 3 provinces more than they are to us and rightly so. I don't hate a pakhtoon or a baloch but they openly hate me Infront of my face in Lahore. I can't do this in swat valley. I know they have grievances and honestly I understand where they are coming from but what i am saying is
There is a difference between punjabi people and punjabi establishment. Establishment is less than 1% and you hate us. How does this make sense
Why are you hating on me? What wrong did I do to you . And is it my fault being born in punjab.
We are 40% of population, maybe one percent of us is that elite, still almost 80 million of us are here who are just like you people.just a little bit better. Bhai mujhe to routine mai ni pata tha na k state aisi ghatiya hai. Ab hum acknowledge krte hain. Aur ap kehte hain dekha tum kitne bure ho. And we again acknowledge that (atleast i do) and everytime this repeats k dekha tum kitne bure ho.
An american being born is america is not his/her mistake just like a Punjabi being born in Punjab . Btw Punjab is no USA this is what people need to understand
. What i want to say to my dear people is that please get to the solution end. Nothing will come out of this. I think we are enlightened enough and now it is becoming virtue signaling more than anything else . This is my problem with other 3 provinces( btw i have always loved pathans. Balochistan to kya hi baat aur sindh se mujhe nayi nayi fascination hui hai) but i have seen maybe this is a natural reaction but people other than punjabis that i know of just complain and do nothing. Don't want to provoke anyone but this is my only grievance that there is no nobility in masquerading your tough circumstances as moral supreriority. You people have it rough. More rough than i can imagine but trust me nothing will come out of bashing Punjabi people. . Please try to do your best
Who is saying it is their fault?
Or blaming the common people?
Just like homelessness in America doesn’t disprove American hegemony on the world or the privilege that comes with being American, out of school children in Punjab doesn’t negate anything I’ve said
@@ThePakistanExperienceyou have said this ,at least,this is how you have made a lot of people feel
I said the common people are at fault? I repeatedly say ghareeb Punjabi kee koi ghalti nahee. Which video did you watch?
Take a look at the comment section and tell me then who is right,it seems like a lot of people felt the same , unless you are the only sane person and everyone else is delusional, what you said was certainly not perceived the way you believe it to be ,@ThePakistanExperience
@@ThePakistanExperienceIt is the title of your video. 😅 You think we are fools?
Nothing beats karachites domination attitude
What's the percentage of revenue from import duties out of the 70% that karachi claims of the total revenue?
www.brecorder.com/news/40251211#:~:text=KARACHI%3A%20The%20Large%20Taxpayers%20Office,collection%20by%20Rs%20391%20billion.