I personally feel that Brandon Brown is the reason for the success of he 2024 draft (his second year with the team) So I would prefer to move ahead with Brandon as the GM and get a head coach with experience
How do you come to that conclusion? It was Schoens draft. He came up through the personnel route starting as a scout. Player evaluation is how he got the GM job and what he's most comfortable with. Why would you assume he lets his underling make those vital decisions?
@@michaeldonnan6767 I don't mean Schoen made no decisions. But GMs have assistants and a scouting team for a reason. The others help the GM by giving advice and showing him evidence for why they believe a certain player is a good fit for the team. The GM cannot scout every player on their own. The best draft so far has been the 2024 one and I am just assuming since this was Brown's 2nd year, more of his ideas were trusted by Schoen and used to help make this draft a success. But yes, this is all theorizing. Personally, I heard reports of players not liking how Schoen treated departing players like Barkley and McKinney. So I am not expecting FA players to want to come here and that being my main reason to replace Schoen. If any change is going to be made, replace everyone so the "muck" that has been thrown on this team can be removed because right now, no one (players, other organizations, the media) respects this team.
Too soon to know the fate of Joe Schoen and Brian Daboll, predicting a Daboll firing is over speculation. I for one want two keep them together right here with the Giants. Team roster has improved, just need the obvious parts in the draft. No speculation, action. Keep it together’n
@@markmoore3923 I'm almost 70...I remember Dan's Giant stint. The lions deserve him after the half century of crappy football the fans had to endure. Go Lions!
It’s very simple!!!! How could Daboll explain that he did realize that DeVito could be serviceable enough to atleast win more games than the other QB’s currently on the team?!!! There’s no excuse … Daboll must go.. He also was the reason that Wink Martindale left!!!!
"How could Daboll explain that he did realize that DeVito could be serviceable enough to atleast win more games than the other QB’s currently on the team?!!! " Huh???
Dude I am totally baffled that John Mara is actually going to keep both Schoen and Daboll…. At this point, I can no longer stomach Daboll as HC.. Mara is going to destroy this Franchise…. Co owner Steve Tisch must step in. Mara is going to destroy this Franchise!!!
If Mara doesn't fire everyone, he'll look more look like aclown when he has to answer for the continued failures of Schoen next year! What does Mara want, continuity of incompetence and failure?
Bowen is not a downgrade to Wink. Pts/game 2023 23.9 26th in NFL. 2024 24.7 23rd in NFL. So about the same. They both stunk. Okereke and Banks are struggling with system and Schoen didn't get a DL2 next to Dex. Maybe next yr Bowen will be better.
He’s a downgrade for the media, particularly someone like Serby, who writes for quips instead of information. Wink was nice to them and fed them quotes
You want him emotionally abusing our next quarterback? Hiring co-offensive coordinators? Butting heads with the GM and demanding absolute personnel power from the owner? He did all that in Miami, and could never make the playoffs-something his replacement did immediately. Flores is a fine DC but a terrible HC. Thank God you’re not GM. Keep him and his lawsuit the hell away from this team.
@baxatakbaxatak2014 you got a better plan?? He got fired because he wouldn't tank. Looked pretty good on Pittsburg and minnesotta. People learn from past mistakes. Watch him go somewhere and have success.
@ Or watch him drive his next QB to a suicide attempt because he wanted someone else. He looks pretty good AS A DC. As an HC he was another Belichick failure.
We the people who support this franchise, win or loose, are screaming for a change.. Daboll is simply not the coach we need.. he waited this long to put in QB DeVito and wins.. As a HC for 3yrs how didn’t you know much B4 that DeVito could be good?? What is your excuse for not knowing his abilities…
Not much of a decision to be made…3 win season 3 years into a regime. Another season riddled with HS level football. Fire everybody. It’s IMPOSSIBLE to get worse…
I personally feel that Brandon Brown is the reason for the success of he 2024 draft (his second year with the team)
So I would prefer to move ahead with Brandon as the GM and get a head coach with experience
How do you come to that conclusion? It was Schoens draft. He came up through the personnel route starting as a scout. Player evaluation is how he got the
GM job and what he's most comfortable with. Why would you assume he lets his underling make those vital decisions?
@@michaeldonnan6767 I don't mean Schoen made no decisions. But GMs have assistants and a scouting team for a reason. The others help the GM by giving advice and showing him evidence for why they believe a certain player is a good fit for the team. The GM cannot scout every player on their own.
The best draft so far has been the 2024 one and I am just assuming since this was Brown's 2nd year, more of his ideas were trusted by Schoen and used to help make this draft a success. But yes, this is all theorizing.
Personally, I heard reports of players not liking how Schoen treated departing players like Barkley and McKinney. So I am not expecting FA players to want to come here and that being my main reason to replace Schoen. If any change is going to be made, replace everyone so the "muck" that has been thrown on this team can be removed because right now, no one (players, other organizations, the media) respects this team.
Ernie acrosi did an excellent job drafting. It was the player he drafted that were the sole key to the two superbowls 2007 & 2012.
when you come across a house that is falling apart , First you have to Destruct before you can Con struct
Too soon to know the fate of Joe Schoen and Brian Daboll, predicting a Daboll firing is over speculation. I for one want two keep them together right here with the Giants. Team roster has improved, just need the obvious parts in the draft. No speculation, action. Keep it together’n
Thank God, somebody is now talking and making sense and speaking truth they need to both go
***This interview was taped last Friday, before the Giants won their game against the Colts.***
yeah we can tell, which makes this vid somewhat outdated (and misleading)
Absent co-owner Steve Tisch owns some blame for not getting more involved. John Mara is a clown.
Clowns make clown comments, do they not?...Who says the HC is on the way out?....
Let's go get this Campbell guy in Detroit! He seems like a leader of men! 🤔I'd vote for Steve and Patti for new GM/asst GM!!!
Dan Campbell was our former tight end playing behind Jeremy Shockey
@@markmoore3923 I'm almost 70...I remember Dan's Giant stint. The lions deserve him after the half century of crappy football the fans had to endure. Go Lions!
U act like a little kid. Thats Campbell guy is under contract and DET is not letting him go
@@Rodrod6689 I'm joking einstein! It's called sarcastic humor!
Do just like the Commanders Sell the dang team and Press the Reset button!
It’s very simple!!!! How could Daboll explain that he did realize that DeVito could be serviceable enough to atleast win more games than the other QB’s currently on the team?!!! There’s no excuse … Daboll must go.. He also was the reason that Wink Martindale left!!!!
"How could Daboll explain that he did realize that DeVito could be serviceable enough to atleast win more games than the other QB’s currently on the team?!!! " Huh???
We have too many holes trade back and get multiple picks a first round qb pick won’t help this team
Dude I am totally baffled that John Mara is actually going to keep both Schoen and Daboll…. At this point, I can no longer stomach Daboll as HC.. Mara is going to destroy this Franchise…. Co owner Steve Tisch must step in. Mara is going to destroy this Franchise!!!
💯 need to fire HC and GM and start fresh with both + new QB on the same timeline
If Mara doesn't fire everyone, he'll look more look like aclown when he has to answer for the continued failures of Schoen next year! What does Mara want, continuity of incompetence and failure?
How many times do they have to "fire everyone" before you realize that's not the answer? It takes time to build a team.
Serby for GM!
Serby meant clinched playoff birth in the Colts game from 2022. Giants won 9 games that year and were 3rd in division.
Should have had Belichick lined up !
Blew it
Mara needs to fire himself
trade Schoen & Daboll to the Jets for Rogers; promote Brown & Kafka
we at 4 though see last week end up with
Bowen is not a downgrade to Wink. Pts/game 2023 23.9 26th in NFL. 2024 24.7 23rd in NFL. So about the same. They both stunk. Okereke and Banks are struggling with system and Schoen didn't get a DL2 next to Dex. Maybe next yr Bowen will be better.
He’s a downgrade for the media, particularly someone like Serby, who writes for quips instead of information. Wink was nice to them and fed them quotes
Unfortunately this was taped before the Giants just won
What about them getting rid of Daboll and signing Kafka for two years while Shoen is there?
I don't get the sense that Kafka wants to stay here regardless.
Just hire Brian Flores and get it over with. We succeed with tough minded coached like Parcells and Coughlin. Problem solved. Maybe I should be GM 😅
You want him emotionally abusing our next quarterback? Hiring co-offensive coordinators? Butting heads with the GM and demanding absolute personnel power from the owner? He did all that in Miami, and could never make the playoffs-something his replacement did immediately. Flores is a fine DC but a terrible HC. Thank God you’re not GM. Keep him and his lawsuit the hell away from this team.
@baxatakbaxatak2014 you got a better plan?? He got fired because he wouldn't tank. Looked pretty good on Pittsburg and minnesotta. People learn from past mistakes. Watch him go somewhere and have success.
@ Or watch him drive his next QB to a suicide attempt because he wanted someone else. He looks pretty good AS A DC. As an HC he was another Belichick failure.
We need to make our d line coach our head coach or get justin tuck@@baxatakbaxatak2014
@@baxatakbaxatak2014 He sounds like Parcells, I would support Flores too!
We the people who support this franchise, win or loose, are screaming for a change.. Daboll is simply not the coach we need.. he waited this long to put in QB DeVito and wins.. As a HC for 3yrs how didn’t you know much B4 that DeVito could be good?? What is your excuse for not knowing his abilities…
Speak for yourself. We are not of one mind.
Not much of a decision to be made…3 win season 3 years into a regime. Another season riddled with HS level football. Fire everybody. It’s IMPOSSIBLE to get worse…
I see jones still living rent free in fans heads. …. He may win a SB 😂