The music video was dropped out of the blue ...it was a total surprise to fans, and it is a huge fan favorite. It really is an artistic masterpiece. I think most of us would agree we wish Black Swan was the song that had been nominated for a Grammy rather than Dynamite. I'm not sure the Grammy's will ever nominate a non-English song by them, though. =\
Black Swan deserves more recognition, not only by the lyrics, or the melody, but the music video itself is a masterpiece... I really don't know what Gramshit is thinking overlooking this as it were nothing. Western music videos really lack of all the things Black Swan has.
“A dancer dies twice -once when they stop dancing, and this first death is more painful” (Martha Graham) The song is inspired by this quote and BTS is telling us they never want to feel that, their wish is to always enjoy and live their passion for music and performance. It is a fear and they are sharing it with us...
I love watching people fall in love with BTS... And it's akways fun watching someone who is so knowledgeable about the art form being used... Through such a newbie to the world of BTS. . You taught me something and I think you learn something... I'm going to subscribe
"You can tell he loves to dance" Yoongi: "He asked me to join the group and promised I didn't have to dance. He lied..." but i think he overcame that, even though his biggest passion is music and his 2nd biggest passion is lying down lol
Just wanna precise something though: they are talking about the 'fear of losing passion' for what they are doing but when they were asked the question in interviews, they all said that it was not the case right now, they are still loving what they are doing. They just wanted to express those recurrent thoughts that all performers must have: what if I don't like it anymore, what if it all just becomes a job?
@@isaviveros1194 I think it had more to do with the actual situation with covid19 than with their love for music. It was mostly a burnout: being exhausted by their work or the way they had to do it (online concerts without crowed, not being able to see Army etc.) doesn't mean they didn't like it anymore...
@@jessicaelle0988 Nono, Tae said that he was having a hard time because he doubted he enjoyed being an artist and that sometimes he felt like it was just a job. He also said that it was normal for an artist to think about that sometimes. Blue & gray was written before covid and during covid, and it was only about him in his darkest moments, but he fixed it to be about all of them.
Hi, I think that you got part of the message of the song right with dancing, but not fully. I believe BTS is talking about their love for music and performing overall. This song talks about the heartbreak/fear of losing passion for one's art--sacrificing oneself for their art to the point of no longer finding joy in it
Yeah! And imagine doing something to the point of indifference. Becoming numb, so there’s no longer a fear because you don’t Care/have any passion left. Woah, this song is just SOO good!
I was wondering when someone was going to tell him especially when he said it about suga i cracked up He didn't even want to dance in the first place he accepts it now but if he had to chose it will always be the music
I watched black swan so many times that I thought I had fully experienced it. But the way you explained their use of cinematography really added depth. Thank you so much, your insights made me love the video even more. 💜
Your interpretations are beautiful not only for this mv but for the others too, you expressed them with such depth and your perception about the meaning of every scene is amazing
So true - hard to see a reactor who actually sees the true beauty in the MV's. Many of BTS MVs actually move me to tears with their beauty.... the combination of audio and visual becomes almost a spiritual moment.... 7 angels here from heaven
ikr! finally found a reactor who actually understands the depth of their music videos. and that is why i subscribed ❤ i want his audience to grow so bad.
5:57 Decided to give my take on this scene as a writer/poet since you struggled with it so much lmao So you see Jimin sitting in the middle of this large, empty concert hall. The lights in the background are black and white, which symbolizes regality and power. And then, contrasting the dark background, there's that really harsh light reflecting on him. When you think stage lights you think of a performer, someone in the public eye. However, he's not standing up on stage, so he feels like he isn't even supposed to be in the spotlight. He's crouched down, his face away from the camera, trying to hide himself as best as he can but it's no use. He still feels that overwhelming sense of loneliness and pressure that his fame has placed on his shoulders. And even the lyrics, "Do you hear me", kind of tie into that. He's calling out but he's all alone. There's no one there to support him or guide him along his journey. BTS have tried to describe how their fame effects them so many times over, but it's shots like these that really make it hit home.
This is why they rely so heavily on each other (their brotherhood) and their families to keep them humble and grounded. They don't ever want to lose each other to the machine..
@@seokjinshiddenabs2194 cuz in the MV he has a solo, he is the shadow through all the video. Al ser un bailarín contemporáneo, le dieron ese rol a él, dar todo de sí en el baile para trasmitir elegantemente el dolor por la posibilidad de algún día perder su pasión o no ser capaz seguir manifestándola.
From a 68 year old Army who never listened to rap until AGUST D, 'DAECHWITA' the MV. Ive watched it at least 50 times, but thats only cause i just now found it. Incredible. The production is epic.
The whole thing is all about dancing, it's a contemporary/ballet like choreography with another dance group. I know he's not really into dancing so I don't know if he'll like it but they're definitely telling a story throughout the video.
I think you missed that music is their passion. There are three of them who are dancers who I would say it's both dancing and music, but for everyone else it's music.
@@marialeahragadio1635 I agree with you that V dances very well! In my opinion, they all do! But that doesn't mean it's his passion. I have a friend whose voice is so beautiful and she sings occasionally but has absolutely no desire to be a singer or do anything in the singing field. My comment was based off what I've heard from JK, Jimin and JHope. But if you've heard V talk about his passion for dance (I haven't) then that's great! I just want them all to be happy, whatever they decide to do!
I see you becoming a fan of Park Jimin (the dancer who did the shadows in the background, the one doing the solo dancing trough the video). I mean, what can we say, he's one of the best performers in the industry. Park Jimin has an stage presence otherworldly.
I cried with this song a LOT. They're talking about the fear of falling out of love with one of your passions. There's a phrase at the beginning of the black swan art film that says: "a dancer dies twice, once when they stop dancing, and this first death is the more painful."
I got so much out of what you had to say and everything you pointed out. It gave me an even greater appreciation for this MV, stopping at so many interesting points. It all goes by so fast when you watch it without stopping. Every frame is a masterpiece. Thanks for sharing yourself! In their speech at the UN, RM encouraged us all to "Speak Yourself", and you're doing just that making these videos.
I am Korean and I like your reaction. Your view is very interesting. I will continue to watch your videos. Please fall for the charm of bts. I use the translator. I hope my meaning is conveyed well.
did you know that the curtain behind SUGA in 7:32 is a 3D theater curtain? the hairs of the main figures were stuffed to give them depth. the idea of "the hair gently billowing as the curtain moves up or down" is like putting on a persona to cover up your shadow (Jungian psychology referenced in their album 'Map of the Soul: Persona' & 'Map of the Soul: 7')
This was the third sing of theirs I discovered in my own race journey into their catalog and it cemented me as hugely impressed and a fan. Thank you for the reaction and viewpoint it’s really insightful from the artistic cinematographic angle (yes a deliberate bad pun).
Black swan and blood sweat and tears are next level in cinematography. 2 of my fav MVS. They're art in songwriting and cinematography. I know this was done a while ago and people probably commented on this but Yoongi doesn't love dancing lol. And that's def not Namjoons original look. Their look was what they perceived as hip hop in the beginning. They've evolved a lot throughout the years. The song is about the loss of excitement and love that popularity and constant work causes. I'm going to watch all your videos because your breakdowns are fantastic.
"Black Swan" is a term used to describe a life changing event. To qualify as a Black Swan it must meet three criteria, 1. It must come as a shock or surprise, 2. It must cause a change in life, a negative life changing event, 3. Looking back on the event it will appear obvious that it should have been predicted. The Art Film is jaw dropping. Visually stunning and completely different. Thanks and stay well
And when millions of us are called out for being "teenage fangirls" and loving them only for their "looks"... No. The reason is music. We came for music and will forever stay for their music and them. Amazing reaction, enjoyed it a lot. Thanks for checking the masterpiece out 💜
11:20 yeah but ironically, Black Swan was the last song they performed in front of a live audience before the pandemic happened. their first last dance.
I Iove your breakdowns, and yes their writing is exceptional because some of the members like RM, Suga, J-Hope, may have a hand in writing and they write from within. 💜 Please keep going, I hope you continue to enjoy the diversity of their music. Highly recommend you look into the Bangtan Universe too.
Thank you so much. I have seen this MV lots of times, but because of what you shared I saw so many things that were new to me. That was so exciting - I love that you pause and explain what you are seeing. You really seem to like the story so some of the MV explained videos might be helpful - especially for Blood Sweat and Tears (although that one packs so much in from different perspectives a single video can only capture some of the references in the various details). I think you would really like to see Daechwita by Augst D (aka Suga of BTS).
this is one of my favorites bts' songs, i cry every time i listen to it bc it makes me miss figure skating which i couldn't do for over a year now due covid-19, i lost the passion for it for a while but this song literally reminded me how much it means to me and connected me to it again, so now it makes me WAY too emotional. I'm thinking about making a choreography to this song as soon as I can get back :( awesome reaction i loved it
As an artist myself, though not in music, this song speaks to me SO much. It manifests their fear that one day, their passion (music) will no longer give them any joy and shows them battling with their shadow (the white vs black clothes), before accepting that as a possible eventuality and moving forward, learning to embrace the darkness. Not because this is something they face, but because it's a fear that everyone who is truly passionate about something has, even if they don't know it. I really do think Jimin's solo dance bits throughout the MV brought it together; you can't talk about losing something without showing what that something can be, and his training in contemporary was perfect because I've never been able to imagine the song working the same in another genre. The movie Black Swan, which I watched after this song was released, is actually a really fascinating psychological thriller and if you're at all into that I recommend it. They also released an Art Film, with an orchestral version of the song (hits 7× harder than this one, imo) performed by MN Dance Company which beautifully embodies the message of the song.
Really appreciate watching these videos through your lens. I’ve learned to appreciate the videos that much more! Thank you. Also love your transparency and vulnerability.
I would really love your opinion of ‘l need you’ by BTS. It was a very low budget video when they didn’t have money to spend on MV’s, never the less it really was filmed well and the acting is great. (No dancing ) it is the start of the storyline but please don’t start that yet as it is extremely involved and complicated and l don’t think you really are interested in going down that path just yet but ‘l need you ‘ shows what can be done with no money, using their staff to play extras etc…I am sure you will be amazed at what they were able to do.
I love watching you react because you often point out things in the videos that I completely missed (and I've seen these A LOT), and, I love watching people who know what they're talking about react (musicians, actors/film makers, video editors etc) because odds are I'll learn something. So, thank you.
I love how to dissected almost each and every frame of this video. I am so obssessed with Black Swan not only because of Jimin's elegance and poise when he dances but because this video in particular is almost like a masterpiece. Everything ties in together, the camera angles, the dance.. it's a whole vibe. One of my favorites from BTS. Thanks for reacting!! I'm enjoying the rest of your videos too. 💜
here from the tiktok you posted about quitting starbucks. this video is so fitting to your situation because ur chasing ur passion and taking a huge leap and i want u to know how inspiring and amazing that is. i wish u the best and i’ll be watching all your videos to support your journey :)
No it's the music , the music is their passion not dancing ( well some of them really love dancing ) , Suga's line ( This is my workroom it's my studio ) represents how passionate he is about production and making music
@@iampigoinkoink5185 Yes Jimin too and jk . But Suga and V and RM are passionate about music , and jin was passionate about acting . But the song was more focused on music
I like your interpretation “success without happiness” is exactly right, unhappiness to the point of losing the passion for their art. This song has very deep connotations especially because it can apply to anyone’s passion for something in general being lost and how one reminiscent of what one used to love is now lost. Btw, interlude Shadow is another masterpiece. Is Suga’s solo song from this album.
You were spot on with the meaning. This song is about an artist's fear of losing passion for their art. Martha Graham, a famous choreographer, said, “a dancer dies twice, once when they stop dancing, and this first death is the more painful.” This quote is used in Yoongi's rap at 2:36 and then later mentioned again in Namjoon's rap at 3:35
I wish you knew more about them as people and a group so you’d understand their personalities. There’s a reason why Jin was given the room with the mirrors and why Jimin was the black swan. Please watch a video about them as individuals and a group. Like maybe: A beautiful life goes on
Ahhh my brain kinda broke when you said it's showing Suga's vulnerability through the camera angles showing all sides of him that's so cool AHH idk if I even rephrased that correctly but I really like ur reaction videos I've watched like 5 in a row
I am a new subscriber and i love your reactions, insights and the additional knowledge that you share coming from a creative background. I really love the cinematic approach BTS and their team have with their MVs. As well as the meaning behind every creative output and the references they keep through out their songs and MVs that tie all of their output into such a historical landscape of the BTS universe.
“I feel what they are telling me to feel but I can’t describe it.” I get this a lot with BTS’s work. True art that is conveying emotions and meanings beyond the confines of words. We’re blessed to have BTS, to have this beautiful art to enjoy. Their work is such contribution to humanity.
@@charityhooper2377 no it was bad and he knows it now, the past is in the past. My man looked like a toothbrush, so glad he got over that phase. The best glow up ever.
@@-amel-9896 No, it really wasn't bad. It's a hairstyle in the African American community which I'm a part of. So calling it bad...is kind of like an insult to the early hip-hop culture. I think a better word may be outdated because Black men were wearing those haircuts in the '80s and '90s. I think RM meant it was a bad choice for him to be wearing it but the haircut itself is not bad.
At 6:03 when you talk about the aisle shot, I think it’s also referencing the fact that even when they aren’t performing, they are being watched. So even when they are off-stage they are under the spotlight. And they are also alone. Because of their fame, they haven’t had many opportunities to meet people and to just go out. So I feel that it symbolizes the result of their success and the reason why it’s difficult to find the “light” in their ocean
This is one of the result of yoongi's saying "If you listen to our music without prejudice, you will like it" What a beautiful reaction there and I love it because you are starting to like them. You gained another subs here! :)
I really love hearing your insights as a filmmaker some of which I'm hearing for the first time. I've been constantly amazed by their lyrics, choreography, and the total aesthetics of their MVs, and I know they're really rich on details but now it makes me appreciate the whole work behind these MVs on a whole different level cause most of what you're saying makes perfect sense. Even with that 360 camera angle, I didn't think there could be more than just the beauty of the angle. I'm learning a lot from your reactions actually so thanks! 💜
This song is so so important to me. The idea of seeing who you are entirely, seeing all your fears and shouting that none of it can devour you... I literally tell myself that on dark days ever since I listened to this song. And the video is just perfect to convey that emotion. Jimin’s dancing is so expressive, has so many emotions and it’s so beautiful. The online concert they did he had a dance solo at the end of black swan and it was one of the most beautiful things I’ve ever seen in my life. That reminds me, I don’t know if you’d be interested in stage design at all, but the stuff they do is madness. Their performances at Melon music awards (MMA) in 2018 and 2019 are just amazing.
somehow, watching a filmmaker gush over this validates how much i love the black swan mv (im close to obsessed with it 🥵) the artistry, lighting, angles, transitions, lyrics, everything coming together to make something so beautiful
As an aspiring filmmaker myself i'm so happy to finally find someone who breaks down this song's visuals and correlates them with the lyrics! I've always loved BTS' mvs because of this exact reason, every frame is intentional and tells a piece of the story they want to tell. An absolute masterpiece and your reaction really captured it too! You got yourself a new subscriber! 💜
Love how the last video you said you don’t connect with dancing at all but this one touched you in a whole different way. This was such a great reaction :)
The way you can watch a video like this and just really understand and appreciate the meaning and story of it really amazes me. BTS has so many incredible aspects of their work and lives, and its really neat seeing someone so interested and skilled in their filmmaking aspect. Thx for such a great explanation and breakdown!
Besidea the fact that this song is a masterpiece ....ur analysis is amazing....everything thats dazzling about this video u mentioned... the best reaction ive seen....so in depth
Black swan is one of the songs that i relate so much , i cried so much why i heard it . The pain of loosing passion for things you love. At the time i was really disconnecting with my art and after black swan i got back into it . I love them so much
9:28 HOW MANY TIMES I'VE SEEN THIS MV AND NEVER NOTICED THAT JIN'S REFLECTIONS WERE STILL LOOKING AT HIM WHEN HE TURNED AROUND?? Wow. Your reaction honestly give me so much more depth to their videos, because you see and feel things that I wouldn't notice, but when you describe them it just makes so much more sense. Like I appreciate their MV's from the visual side so much, but I won't get a lot of stuff that's in it. I'm so glad your doing these reactions and that you're enjoying them. I'm looking forward seeing more.
I just noticed that at the start of the mv we're looking at them from the perspective of the audience and slowly the perspective switches. By the end of the video during the last chorus we're on stage with them, looking at the lights that are shining down on them and all the seats in the audience. Wow.
I am so happy to see someone who reacts to their music and truly understanding the depth in every lyric.... not a lot of people understand this from BTS.
Watched this MV dozens of times, but watching it with you and hearing your interpretation made me tear up at that sad part in the end. Thank you for helping me see their art in a new light.
This is the first time I’m not annoyed whenever youtubers just pause too much just to say things like ”wow I like this!, so cool” . This is the reaction I want to watch ☺️ I really like you keep up the good work!
I just want to thank you for really taking your time with these videos and providing really thoughtful, insightful and poignant perspectives. It’s really beautiful to see someone who was previously mostly unfamiliar with BTS be moved and show such appreciation for their work in all of its facets. The moments where you’re at a loss for words, I very much felt the same way each and every time and so it’s great to see someone else feel things deeply in this way. Thank you!
the feeling that come to mind when it shows the scene of him couched in the audience with the harsh-edge spotlight is desolation in grandeur. A space that is empty and devoid, but meant to be full of life and love. Black Swan is one of the BTS videos that really brought me into ARMY and I hold a lot of love for it.
What they did with black Swan is incredible. I'm a dancer and this video feels when we go to the theater for our rehearsals. Watching this video I can smell how the empty theater smells and feels. It also brings memories of how many hours of rehearsal we go through. This video feels so nostalgic
shadow, hourglass, water, fire, wing, light, ego, persona, are key words for BTS. Your interpretation and technical explanation are super helpful and give us a new perspective, thank you very much
Randomly found your channel on recommendations and I should admit that I LOVE your reactions. You literally trying to understand everything and I dont mind pausing MVs often. It makes sooo much sense for me. I actually a bit sad that I haven't find your channel earlier since I was writing my bachelor graduation project about BTS and struggling a lot when I was analyzing MVs (especially, when it was about cinematic part). But anyway I quit like your reactions so keep going ;)
One of the things i really love about BTS music videos is that you can feel their passion through the screen just by looking at them dance or hearing them sing. It captures so many beautiful emotions
Black Swan is a masterpiece. You made me fall in love with the song even more. Thank you.
Of course!
Saaame 💜
@@LoveTheBasics thank you for your reactions!!! I love your analysis!
Amen!
If Black Swan was by any Western artist it could have easily got a Grammy
The music video was dropped out of the blue ...it was a total surprise to fans, and it is a huge fan favorite. It really is an artistic masterpiece. I think most of us would agree we wish Black Swan was the song that had been nominated for a Grammy rather than Dynamite. I'm not sure the Grammy's will ever nominate a non-English song by them, though. =\
Facts
couldn't agree more. we wish Black Swan gets more attentions it deserves
Black Swan deserves more recognition, not only by the lyrics, or the melody, but the music video itself is a masterpiece... I really don't know what Gramshit is thinking overlooking this as it were nothing. Western music videos really lack of all the things Black Swan has.
It's a sad fact.
@@seec4856 an absolutely devastating fact because Black Swan in it’s entirety is such a masterpiece
“I’m a sucker for back lighting” me: “I’m a sucker for jimin...”
“A dancer dies twice -once when they stop dancing, and this first death is more painful” (Martha Graham) The song is inspired by this quote and BTS is telling us they never want to feel that, their wish is to always enjoy and live their passion for music and performance. It is a fear and they are sharing it with us...
RM wrote the lyrics after he watched the movie black swan.
I love watching people fall in love with BTS... And it's akways fun watching someone who is so knowledgeable about the art form being used... Through such a newbie to the world of BTS. . You taught me something and I think you learn something... I'm going to subscribe
@@gratiakarmes6916 you didn't yet
the fact that bangtan always sharing their feeling with us, makes me happy :)
"You can tell he loves to dance"
Yoongi: "He asked me to join the group and promised I didn't have to dance. He lied..."
but i think he overcame that, even though his biggest passion is music and his 2nd biggest passion is lying down lol
"BANG PD-NIM!" 😂
His second biggest passion is lying down. You're not wrong. 🤣🤣🤣🤣
🤣🤣🤣🤣
Blame the fan account for this.
Just wanna precise something though: they are talking about the 'fear of losing passion' for what they are doing but when they were asked the question in interviews, they all said that it was not the case right now, they are still loving what they are doing. They just wanted to express those recurrent thoughts that all performers must have: what if I don't like it anymore, what if it all just becomes a job?
Ohhhh
Yeah and Tae actually having a hard time because of that… then it came blue & grey
@@isaviveros1194 yoongi says something about it too on the vlive about d-2, it's something I think every artist goes or fears going through
@@isaviveros1194 I think it had more to do with the actual situation with covid19 than with their love for music. It was mostly a burnout: being exhausted by their work or the way they had to do it (online concerts without crowed, not being able to see Army etc.) doesn't mean they didn't like it anymore...
@@jessicaelle0988 Nono, Tae said that he was having a hard time because he doubted he enjoyed being an artist and that sometimes he felt like it was just a job. He also said that it was normal for an artist to think about that sometimes. Blue & gray was written before covid and during covid, and it was only about him in his darkest moments, but he fixed it to be about all of them.
this is one of their greatest masterpieces
It really is
Hi, I think that you got part of the message of the song right with dancing, but not fully. I believe BTS is talking about their love for music and performing overall. This song talks about the heartbreak/fear of losing passion for one's art--sacrificing oneself for their art to the point of no longer finding joy in it
Those make sense. Performing makes sense especially with this video being on a stage
Yeah! And imagine doing something to the point of indifference. Becoming numb, so there’s no longer a fear because you don’t Care/have any passion left. Woah, this song is just SOO good!
I was wondering when someone was going to tell him especially when he said it about suga i cracked up
He didn't even want to dance in the first place he accepts it now but if he had to chose it will always be the music
I like how you summarized the meaning, detailed enough
@@quewilliams6884 Suga was a background dancer in his early years.
I watched black swan so many times that I thought I had fully experienced it. But the way you explained their use of cinematography really added depth. Thank you so much, your insights made me love the video even more. 💜
Of course!!
I thought this too, Thank you
Yes
Agree!
SO TRUEEEE
I totally agree !!
Your interpretations are beautiful not only for this mv but for the others too, you expressed them with such depth and your perception about the meaning of every scene is amazing
Thank you! 💕
Yeah true
Yes it's true 😍
So true - hard to see a reactor who actually sees the true beauty in the MV's.
Many of BTS MVs actually move me to tears with their beauty.... the combination of audio and visual becomes almost a spiritual moment.... 7 angels here from heaven
ikr! finally found a reactor who actually understands the depth of their music videos. and that is why i subscribed ❤ i want his audience to grow so bad.
“this is probably how he did his hair a couple of years ago”
2013 rm with a perm mohawk
That's what i was thinking!!! ahhhh old rm hair is wild lol
Kid n Play RM 🕶️🫰🏾💜
My thoughts too lolllll
5:57 Decided to give my take on this scene as a writer/poet since you struggled with it so much lmao
So you see Jimin sitting in the middle of this large, empty concert hall. The lights in the background are black and white, which symbolizes regality and power. And then, contrasting the dark background, there's that really harsh light reflecting on him. When you think stage lights you think of a performer, someone in the public eye. However, he's not standing up on stage, so he feels like he isn't even supposed to be in the spotlight. He's crouched down, his face away from the camera, trying to hide himself as best as he can but it's no use. He still feels that overwhelming sense of loneliness and pressure that his fame has placed on his shoulders. And even the lyrics, "Do you hear me", kind of tie into that. He's calling out but he's all alone. There's no one there to support him or guide him along his journey.
BTS have tried to describe how their fame effects them so many times over, but it's shots like these that really make it hit home.
Ooof 🥺
That was really beautiful and I feel like it's accurate for them as well. Thanks for putting that into perspective.
This is why they rely so heavily on each other (their brotherhood) and their families to keep them humble and grounded. They don't ever want to lose each other to the machine..
Blackswan solo dancer is jimin. He is beautiful god of dance.
Dont care
@@Me-tp6ll then why are you here? lol
Solo dancer?? Wdym by that??
@@seokjinshiddenabs2194 cuz in the MV he has a solo, he is the shadow through all the video. Al ser un bailarín contemporáneo, le dieron ese rol a él, dar todo de sí en el baile para trasmitir elegantemente el dolor por la posibilidad de algún día perder su pasión o no ser capaz seguir manifestándola.
@@B__SadiaSiddiquaShaheen oh ok
From a 68 year old Army who never listened to rap until AGUST D, 'DAECHWITA' the MV. Ive watched it at least 50 times, but thats only cause i just now found it. Incredible. The production is epic.
Love how bts hits senior army deep... Im 40 yr old army myself.
Ddaeng is so good too and ugg and tears💜
We are the Silver Army....gray hair and all 😆 I'm 61 and love these guys!!!
@@KathySwampQueen woahhh I purple uuuuu btw I'm 14 lol 💜😂
@@sleepyhead0007 my grandson is 14 😆 I purple 💜 you too!!!
Music is their passion...I think that's what Suga and RM was rapping about.
i love the emotional connection you get when you watch these
There's actually another video for this song (Black Swan Art Film) if you're interested! It's pretty amazing!
Yess yes yess pleaseeeeee
The choreo tells a story, but you won't see BTS in that video
The whole thing is all about dancing, it's a contemporary/ballet like choreography with another dance group. I know he's not really into dancing so I don't know if he'll like it but they're definitely telling a story throughout the video.
＋1
I guess... Spring Day MV is coming
The queen of all MVs of BTS ~
I think you missed that music is their passion. There are three of them who are dancers who I would say it's both dancing and music, but for everyone else it's music.
Well I mean yea I’d say so too
@@LoveTheBasics Four dancers...
@@kalita02puja Yeah but I don't think dance is V's passion though. Jimin, Jungkook and J-Hope have all expressed that dance is their passion
@@charityhooper2377 Oh? How come V is dancing quite well too? Thanks for that info :)
@@marialeahragadio1635 I agree with you that V dances very well! In my opinion, they all do! But that doesn't mean it's his passion. I have a friend whose voice is so beautiful and she sings occasionally but has absolutely no desire to be a singer or do anything in the singing field. My comment was based off what I've heard from JK, Jimin and JHope. But if you've heard V talk about his passion for dance (I haven't) then that's great! I just want them all to be happy, whatever they decide to do!
I see you becoming a fan of Park Jimin (the dancer who did the shadows in the background, the one doing the solo dancing trough the video). I mean, what can we say, he's one of the best performers in the industry. Park Jimin has an stage presence otherworldly.
J-Hope's the Shadow for RM (since they're closer in height)
I cried with this song a LOT. They're talking about the fear of falling out of love with one of your passions. There's a phrase at the beginning of the black swan art film that says: "a dancer dies twice, once when they stop dancing, and this first death is the more painful."
I got so much out of what you had to say and everything you pointed out. It gave me an even greater appreciation for this MV, stopping at so many interesting points. It all goes by so fast when you watch it without stopping. Every frame is a masterpiece. Thanks for sharing yourself! In their speech at the UN, RM encouraged us all to "Speak Yourself", and you're doing just that making these videos.
You can tell every filmmaker like this video a lot😂 from this reaction..they even pause and mention the same things..lol💜
Well you know what
black swan is masterpiece. music, lyrics, cinematography, the dance...... IT'S AMAZING
I am Korean and I like your reaction. Your view is very interesting. I will continue to watch your videos. Please fall for the charm of bts. I use the translator. I hope my meaning is conveyed well.
It is! Thank you
@@LoveTheBasics 🥰❤️
Woah
did you know that the curtain behind SUGA in 7:32 is a 3D theater curtain? the hairs of the main figures were stuffed to give them depth. the idea of "the hair gently billowing as the curtain moves up or down" is like putting on a persona to cover up your shadow (Jungian psychology referenced in their album 'Map of the Soul: Persona' & 'Map of the Soul: 7')
This was the third sing of theirs I discovered in my own race journey into their catalog and it cemented me as hugely impressed and a fan. Thank you for the reaction and viewpoint it’s really insightful from the artistic cinematographic angle (yes a deliberate bad pun).
Black swan and blood sweat and tears are next level in cinematography. 2 of my fav MVS. They're art in songwriting and cinematography.
I know this was done a while ago and people probably commented on this but Yoongi doesn't love dancing lol. And that's def not Namjoons original look. Their look was what they perceived as hip hop in the beginning. They've evolved a lot throughout the years.
The song is about the loss of excitement and love that popularity and constant work causes.
I'm going to watch all your videos because your breakdowns are fantastic.
I believe it references Swan Lake, the ballet, not specifically the movie Black Swan. The ballet contrasts the white and black swans.
It references both. RM has talked about the movie in particular.
@@AngelaSealana ok thanks
Of course, the movie references the ballet.
"Black Swan" is a term used to describe a life changing event. To qualify as a Black Swan it must meet three criteria, 1. It must come as a shock or surprise, 2. It must cause a change in life, a negative life changing event, 3. Looking back on the event it will appear obvious that it should have been predicted. The Art Film is jaw dropping. Visually stunning and completely different. Thanks and stay well
And when millions of us are called out for being "teenage fangirls" and loving them only for their "looks"... No. The reason is music. We came for music and will forever stay for their music and them.
Amazing reaction, enjoyed it a lot. Thanks for checking the masterpiece out 💜
I'm 57 & it's so exciting to be considered a teenage girl again! These young men are amazing. I'm so proud of them.
This is still my fave BTS MV, everything about it is just so perfect and on point.
"shadow" "success without happiness" ...
everything you explained was in their song titled SHADOW ... I hope you see it
11:20 yeah but ironically, Black Swan was the last song they performed in front of a live audience before the pandemic happened. their first last dance.
I Iove your breakdowns, and yes their writing is exceptional because some of the members like RM, Suga, J-Hope, may have a hand in writing and they write from within. 💜 Please keep going, I hope you continue to enjoy the diversity of their music. Highly recommend you look into the Bangtan Universe too.
Thank you so much. I have seen this MV lots of times, but because of what you shared I saw so many things that were new to me. That was so exciting - I love that you pause and explain what you are seeing. You really seem to like the story so some of the MV explained videos might be helpful - especially for Blood Sweat and Tears (although that one packs so much in from different perspectives a single video can only capture some of the references in the various details). I think you would really like to see Daechwita by Augst D (aka Suga of BTS).
I think dancing is only a part of it, it’s about them losing their love for music and everything that comes with it(dancing, composing, performance).
this is one of my favorites bts' songs, i cry every time i listen to it bc it makes me miss figure skating which i couldn't do for over a year now due covid-19, i lost the passion for it for a while but this song literally reminded me how much it means to me and connected me to it again, so now it makes me WAY too emotional. I'm thinking about making a choreography to this song as soon as I can get back :( awesome reaction i loved it
As an artist myself, though not in music, this song speaks to me SO much. It manifests their fear that one day, their passion (music) will no longer give them any joy and shows them battling with their shadow (the white vs black clothes), before accepting that as a possible eventuality and moving forward, learning to embrace the darkness. Not because this is something they face, but because it's a fear that everyone who is truly passionate about something has, even if they don't know it.
I really do think Jimin's solo dance bits throughout the MV brought it together; you can't talk about losing something without showing what that something can be, and his training in contemporary was perfect because I've never been able to imagine the song working the same in another genre.
The movie Black Swan, which I watched after this song was released, is actually a really fascinating psychological thriller and if you're at all into that I recommend it.
They also released an Art Film, with an orchestral version of the song (hits 7× harder than this one, imo) performed by MN Dance Company which beautifully embodies the message of the song.
Really appreciate watching these videos through your lens. I’ve learned to appreciate the videos that much more! Thank you. Also love your transparency and vulnerability.
I would really love your opinion of ‘l need you’ by BTS. It was a very low budget video when they didn’t have money to spend on MV’s, never the less it really was filmed well and the acting is great. (No dancing ) it is the start of the storyline but please don’t start that yet as it is extremely involved and complicated and l don’t think you really are interested in going down that path just yet but ‘l need you ‘ shows what can be done with no money, using their staff to play extras etc…I am sure you will be amazed at what they were able to do.
Pretty please.
yeah I agree.. I think u should first know more about BTS as a group and each member's personality.. if u r interested
And don't forget to watch the right version! Tgere are two versions
I love watching you react because you often point out things in the videos that I completely missed (and I've seen these A LOT), and, I love watching people who know what they're talking about react (musicians, actors/film makers, video editors etc) because odds are I'll learn something. So, thank you.
Of course of course
They’re really good at storytelling, and you could see it in their short films of the Wings era
the shadows are Jimin and J-hope
I love how to dissected almost each and every frame of this video. I am so obssessed with Black Swan not only because of Jimin's elegance and poise when he dances but because this video in particular is almost like a masterpiece. Everything ties in together, the camera angles, the dance.. it's a whole vibe. One of my favorites from BTS. Thanks for reacting!! I'm enjoying the rest of your videos too. 💜
here from the tiktok you posted about quitting starbucks. this video is so fitting to your situation because ur chasing ur passion and taking a huge leap and i want u to know how inspiring and amazing that is. i wish u the best and i’ll be watching all your videos to support your journey :)
Thank you so much!!
I wish he can react to the wings films tho
I will
No it's the music , the music is their passion not dancing ( well some of them really love dancing ) , Suga's line ( This is my workroom it's my studio ) represents how passionate he is about production and making music
I really think j hope's passion is dancing
@@iampigoinkoink5185
Yes Jimin too and jk . But Suga and V and RM are passionate about music , and jin was passionate about acting . But the song was more focused on music
I like your interpretation “success without happiness” is exactly right, unhappiness to the point of losing the passion for their art. This song has very deep connotations especially because it can apply to anyone’s passion for something in general being lost and how one reminiscent of what one used to love is now lost.
Btw, interlude Shadow is another masterpiece. Is Suga’s solo song from this album.
i love when an intelligent man understands an intelligent's work. I think a lot of armys also should watch you.
You were spot on with the meaning. This song is about an artist's fear of losing passion for their art. Martha Graham, a famous choreographer, said, “a dancer dies twice, once when they stop dancing, and this first death is the more painful.” This quote is used in Yoongi's rap at 2:36 and then later mentioned again in Namjoon's rap at 3:35
Love your analysis. Have fallen in love with Black Swan all over again. Every time they performed this piece was art. The sets, lighting, them...
I wish you knew more about them as people and a group so you’d understand their personalities. There’s a reason why Jin was given the room with the mirrors and why Jimin was the black swan. Please watch a video about them as individuals and a group. Like maybe: A beautiful life goes on
Ahhh my brain kinda broke when you said it's showing Suga's vulnerability through the camera angles showing all sides of him that's so cool AHH idk if I even rephrased that correctly but I really like ur reaction videos I've watched like 5 in a row
5:54 YESS that's the point “a dancer dies twice - once when they stop dancing, and this first death is the more painful.”
I am a new subscriber and i love your reactions, insights and the additional knowledge that you share coming from a creative background. I really love the cinematic approach BTS and their team have with their MVs. As well as the meaning behind every creative output and the references they keep through out their songs and MVs that tie all of their output into such a historical landscape of the BTS universe.
“I feel what they are telling me to feel but I can’t describe it.” I get this a lot with BTS’s work. True art that is conveying emotions and meanings beyond the confines of words. We’re blessed to have BTS, to have this beautiful art to enjoy. Their work is such contribution to humanity.
I never thought about the mirror. I love your interpretation 💜
If you want to see what RM's hair was like, I would suggest you watch their very first music video "No More Dream".
omg no pls lmao
🤭🤣you'll get a surprise in your life🤭😉💜
@@sarap2974 I like it, I think he looks bada**! But that's the way guys wore their hair when I was growing up. 🥰🥰😊
@@charityhooper2377 no it was bad and he knows it now, the past is in the past. My man looked like a toothbrush, so glad he got over that phase. The best glow up ever.
@@-amel-9896 No, it really wasn't bad. It's a hairstyle in the African American community which I'm a part of. So calling it bad...is kind of like an insult to the early hip-hop culture. I think a better word may be outdated because Black men were wearing those haircuts in the '80s and '90s. I think RM meant it was a bad choice for him to be wearing it but the haircut itself is not bad.
At 6:03 when you talk about the aisle shot, I think it’s also referencing the fact that even when they aren’t performing, they are being watched. So even when they are off-stage they are under the spotlight. And they are also alone. Because of their fame, they haven’t had many opportunities to meet people and to just go out. So I feel that it symbolizes the result of their success and the reason why it’s difficult to find the “light” in their ocean
This is one of the result of yoongi's saying "If you listen to our music without prejudice, you will like it"
What a beautiful reaction there and I love it because you are starting to like them. You gained another subs here! :)
I really love hearing your insights as a filmmaker some of which I'm hearing for the first time. I've been constantly amazed by their lyrics, choreography, and the total aesthetics of their MVs, and I know they're really rich on details but now it makes me appreciate the whole work behind these MVs on a whole different level cause most of what you're saying makes perfect sense. Even with that 360 camera angle, I didn't think there could be more than just the beauty of the angle. I'm learning a lot from your reactions actually so thanks! 💜
The lights and shadows in this MV are amazing. They have so much control.
When I watched the MV the first time, I couldn't stop crying, IT'S A MASTERPIECE
Its refreshing when you mainly aim to look at the cinematography bt start resonating with the lyrics as well ...
This song is so so important to me. The idea of seeing who you are entirely, seeing all your fears and shouting that none of it can devour you... I literally tell myself that on dark days ever since I listened to this song. And the video is just perfect to convey that emotion. Jimin’s dancing is so expressive, has so many emotions and it’s so beautiful. The online concert they did he had a dance solo at the end of black swan and it was one of the most beautiful things I’ve ever seen in my life.
That reminds me, I don’t know if you’d be interested in stage design at all, but the stuff they do is madness. Their performances at Melon music awards (MMA) in 2018 and 2019 are just amazing.
Now you have to watch black swan mv shooting sketch and black swan Jimin behind the scenes
somehow, watching a filmmaker gush over this validates how much i love the black swan mv (im close to obsessed with it 🥵) the artistry, lighting, angles, transitions, lyrics, everything coming together to make something so beautiful
As an aspiring filmmaker myself i'm so happy to finally find someone who breaks down this song's visuals and correlates them with the lyrics! I've always loved BTS' mvs because of this exact reason, every frame is intentional and tells a piece of the story they want to tell. An absolute masterpiece and your reaction really captured it too! You got yourself a new subscriber! 💜
Love how the last video you said you don’t connect with dancing at all but this one touched you in a whole different way. This was such a great reaction :)
The way you can watch a video like this and just really understand and appreciate the meaning and story of it really amazes me. BTS has so many incredible aspects of their work and lives, and its really neat seeing someone so interested and skilled in their filmmaking aspect. Thx for such a great explanation and breakdown!
The way you use cinematography to understand the whole story is so amazing. Thank you for making me love this song even more.
I could listen to you explain their MVs all day. Can't wait for the behind the scenes and Spring Day
Besidea the fact that this song is a masterpiece
....ur analysis is amazing....everything thats dazzling about this video u mentioned... the best reaction ive seen....so in depth
Black swan is one of the songs that i relate so much , i cried so much why i heard it . The pain of loosing passion for things you love. At the time i was really disconnecting with my art and after black swan i got back into it . I love them so much
Thank you for letting me see this video with fresh eyes!
I’m so glad I could do that!
9:28 HOW MANY TIMES I'VE SEEN THIS MV AND NEVER NOTICED THAT JIN'S REFLECTIONS WERE STILL LOOKING AT HIM WHEN HE TURNED AROUND?? Wow. Your reaction honestly give me so much more depth to their videos, because you see and feel things that I wouldn't notice, but when you describe them it just makes so much more sense. Like I appreciate their MV's from the visual side so much, but I won't get a lot of stuff that's in it. I'm so glad your doing these reactions and that you're enjoying them. I'm looking forward seeing more.
I just noticed that at the start of the mv we're looking at them from the perspective of the audience and slowly the perspective switches. By the end of the video during the last chorus we're on stage with them, looking at the lights that are shining down on them and all the seats in the audience. Wow.
I totally get what you mean about not being able to describe it exactly but being able to feel it. I get that feeling a lot with BTS' music.
I am so happy to see someone who reacts to their music and truly understanding the depth in every lyric.... not a lot of people understand this from BTS.
Watched this MV dozens of times, but watching it with you and hearing your interpretation made me tear up at that sad part in the end. Thank you for helping me see their art in a new light.
This is the first time I’m not annoyed whenever youtubers just pause too much just to say things like ”wow I like this!, so cool” . This is the reaction I want to watch ☺️ I really like you keep up the good work!
I just want to thank you for really taking your time with these videos and providing really thoughtful, insightful and poignant perspectives. It’s really beautiful to see someone who was previously mostly unfamiliar with BTS be moved and show such appreciation for their work in all of its facets. The moments where you’re at a loss for words, I very much felt the same way each and every time and so it’s great to see someone else feel things deeply in this way. Thank you!
The amount of times I've seen BTS videos and NEVER understood the things you say.. wow THNAK YOU so much for putting their art into words!
I never would have thought I could love black swan and bts more but the way you explained all the little details made me appreciate them so much more
there’s things i haven’t noticed in their music videos until i watched your videos and now i’m kind of obsessed with all of the details that they put
Your analysis just made me fall in love with black swan all over again! You're amazing!
Black swan is a masterpiece. The song, the lyrics and the mv
the feeling that come to mind when it shows the scene of him couched in the audience with the harsh-edge spotlight is desolation in grandeur. A space that is empty and devoid, but meant to be full of life and love.
Black Swan is one of the BTS videos that really brought me into ARMY and I hold a lot of love for it.
You will be shocked if you base your thinking that the hair of RM is the same when they debut...LOL
LOL
Oh
@@LoveTheBasics yup sirrrr way way out of your mind...LOL Bulletproof Pt. 2 was their debut MV watch it if you have time :)
@@michelledamiles8865 the debut song was No More Dream but Bulletproof pt 2 is also awesome 😁
Your passion for our passion is felt so much. Thank you... and you're welcome :)
Jimin is the black swan. Jimin's passion and drive to excell in his artistry is unmatched and so moving!
this song is everyone's special song in the whole fandom, and this mv too its just hits where no one else did
this and film out makes me so so emotional everytime. doesn't matter how many times i hear and watch it
What they did with black Swan is incredible. I'm a dancer and this video feels when we go to the theater for our rehearsals. Watching this video I can smell how the empty theater smells and feels. It also brings memories of how many hours of rehearsal we go through. This video feels so nostalgic
shadow, hourglass, water, fire, wing, light, ego, persona, are key words for BTS. Your interpretation and technical explanation are super helpful and give us a new perspective, thank you very much
I also recommend you to watch the Black Swan performance video on the James Corden show.
That performance is a masterpiece.
Randomly found your channel on recommendations and I should admit that I LOVE your reactions. You literally trying to understand everything and I dont mind pausing MVs often. It makes sooo much sense for me.
I actually a bit sad that I haven't find your channel earlier since I was writing my bachelor graduation project about BTS and struggling a lot when I was analyzing MVs (especially, when it was about cinematic part). But anyway I quit like your reactions so keep going ;)
Bro your analysis is giving me literal chills omg
I hate reaction videos but yours are definitely worth watching
One of the things i really love about BTS music videos is that you can feel their passion through the screen just by looking at them dance or hearing them sing. It captures so many beautiful emotions