Bon Iver - For Emma, Forever Ago REACTION/REVIEW

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 15 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 100

  • @KarK1ttyy
    @KarK1ttyy Рік тому +110

    this album like changed my life i genuinely dont think anything sounds like this

    • @KarK1ttyy
      @KarK1ttyy Рік тому +18

      also bon iver is a band but when this album was made it was just Justin vernon the singer, he recorded this in a cabin in the woods

  • @aldo34
    @aldo34 Рік тому +40

    'Re: stacks'...gets me. Every time. EVERY time. Just literally the first few bars of guitar is enough.

    • @Am3r1Kan0
      @Am3r1Kan0 11 місяців тому

      Same... It's the way in which he comes to terms with that chapter of his life being over. And it's a lot more minimalistic than everything else on the record, just one vocal layer and a guitar. It's really the perfect like postscript after he closes it off on For Emma.

  • @Spookee
    @Spookee Рік тому +17

    i love how deep the message hit for you whilst wearing a fortnite llama tshirt

  • @bloodbuzzohio7924
    @bloodbuzzohio7924 10 місяців тому +24

    I had bought this album on August 7, 2017 just hours hours before my dad passed away. He was hospitalized and i liked sending him music to listen to. I had heard skinny love and For Emma before but never listened to the whole album until that day. I loved and still love it. I like to think the last thing my dad heard from me was Justin Vernon saying, "Your love will be safe with me"

  • @benw0400
    @benw0400 Рік тому +80

    tracktimes:
    flume - 0:54
    lump sum - 3:15
    skinny love - 4:54
    the wolves - 7:05
    blindsided - 9:38
    creature fear - 11:39
    team - 13:14
    for emma - 14:53
    re:stacks - 18:13
    also fun fact, he made this all on his own, in a cabin in the woods and also hunted for his own food, after some pretty sad life events he needed to deal with, and to do so he made this album, he didnt plan on releasing the album to the public, but his friends encouraged him enough to do it :) also his other albums like "i,i" and "22, A Million" are fantastic as-well so u should give them a listen!!!

    • @raywid6493
      @raywid6493 Рік тому +5

      If I remember correctly his band broke up, broke up with his gf, and got mono and then went to a cabin for a few months and wrote this masterpiece

    • @benabel7326
      @benabel7326 Рік тому +4

      @@raywid6493 The story behind the album is almost as intriguing as the album itself.

  • @JoshHinrichs-vv2ft
    @JoshHinrichs-vv2ft Рік тому +59

    Dude this is THE format that I’d love to see someone react to all the albums I love. So excited to see what you do

  • @nicklare5823
    @nicklare5823 Рік тому +5

    For Emma is quite literally one of the most beautiful songs ever produced. The fact that it’s literally a conversation between two people, and those trumpets in the background just solidify it as the best song on this album, and maybe his discography.

  • @villagelanding
    @villagelanding Рік тому +29

    it's crazy you also mentioned listening to this in the winter. I totally agree! I've never heard an album capture a season better than this one, and I think that only compliments the feelings of isolation in the music.
    I like to hear your thoughts on music, you seem very open-minded. Hope even more subscribers come your way soon! :)

  • @Justin-pd8io
    @Justin-pd8io Рік тому +26

    Bon Iver self titled and 22, a million would make for really good reactions aswell. Also, meant to comment this a while back but given how much you liked Jeff Buckley I really think you should give his father, Tim Buckley, a shot. Happy Sad, Lorca, and Starsailor are all fantastic albums 🙏

  • @XxSOSxX9
    @XxSOSxX9 Рік тому +9

    This was so cool / nostalgic watching a reaction to an album that changed my life.. Now I am re-obsessed with Bon Iver, and I thank you for that

  • @lizardman7718
    @lizardman7718 Рік тому +7

    So glad you started off with this one. THATS WHY HES THE GOAT‼️

  • @audr3yaudr3y
    @audr3yaudr3y Рік тому +3

    “this one’s a lot more lowkey.” famous last words.

  • @AquaticDot
    @AquaticDot Рік тому +11

    Great reaction. This album, and really all of their albums, are absolutely beautiful. If you like this kind of vibe, their self-titled is very similar in aesthetic, but more polished. 22 a Million incorporates a lot of electronic elements and is probably their most experimental album, and in my opinion it's their best by a mile.

  • @tavonkacey5201
    @tavonkacey5201 Рік тому +3

    I love that you reacted to this album outside. The trees in the background beautifully capture this albums rawness since BonIver recorded this album in the woods

  • @yoauntcarsey
    @yoauntcarsey Рік тому +3

    Re:stacks is one of the best songs ever made

  • @Bringadingus
    @Bringadingus Рік тому +6

    Yellow Swans - Going Places
    Xiu Xiu - Girl With Basket of Fruit

    • @joshuadoty4682
      @joshuadoty4682 Рік тому +1

      I love xiu xiu but that might be the worst album to start with lmao, would make for a funny reaction though.

    • @neromxxn2252
      @neromxxn2252 Рік тому

      it would be best to start with a promise for xiu xiu

    • @joshuadoty4682
      @joshuadoty4682 Рік тому +1

      @@neromxxn2252 a promise or forget are both more accessible starting points

  • @dfkdb6249
    @dfkdb6249 Рік тому +2

    Your channel overwhelms me in the best way possible, the selection of albums is exactly my taste

  • @naomisdiary9835
    @naomisdiary9835 11 місяців тому +2

    i think the don’t bother me like complements the what might’ve been lost as a phrase, like “what might’ve been lost don’t bother me” but it’s him tryna convince himself that he doesn’t feel bothered by losing what he thought was the love of his life and much more that he actually lost at that time, while actually working as him begging these thoughts to not bother him… one of my favorite songs of all time and after all these years i simply can’t listen to it without crying

  • @lucaslpy5507
    @lucaslpy5507 Рік тому +3

    Yes I love Bon iver ❤ my favorite album is his third, 22 a million. I would love a reaction of this one, because it's quite experimental and very different from his first album 😊

  • @irishdruidess7391
    @irishdruidess7391 11 місяців тому +1

    Kumran is where they excavated the Dead Sea scrolls.

  • @mememan3799
    @mememan3799 Рік тому +1

    4k Baby let's gooo!

  • @rojurr
    @rojurr Рік тому +1

    FOR EMMA STANS RISE UP

  • @jamieconley4913
    @jamieconley4913 Рік тому +1

    I love these reactions you do so much!

  • @robinfinetto5871
    @robinfinetto5871 5 місяців тому

    My favourite Bon Iver record and I think his best has to be his second "Bon Iver, Bon Iver", feels like it retains the rawness of the first record but a lot more confident and interesting in instrumentation . Def worth a listen.

  • @cooliobeanie2055
    @cooliobeanie2055 Рік тому +2

    never listened to a bon iver before but after this might have to check some more of his stuff tbh

  • @inlimboteque
    @inlimboteque Рік тому +1

    i really enjoy your reactions man good stuff

  • @SeparatedFromSociety
    @SeparatedFromSociety Рік тому

    man i love your reaction especially how you react to teams transition. Hope you do more Bon Iver!

  • @dawnnicholson9675
    @dawnnicholson9675 Рік тому

    I love that you said it just feels so warm.. I love Justin Vernon.. such an amazing musician. Justin made this album alone then posted it on SoundCloud... he create the band Bon Iver after this album took off. The voices are all Justin's in this first album. In an early interview with Justin, he said the album wasn't about breaking up with a girl. Hope you plan on more Bon Iver albums.

  • @collinbeal
    @collinbeal Рік тому +4

    Easy 10. There are two albums made by people dumped by their girlfriends who went and isolated in a cabin to write an album that are perfect. The other is Adrianne Lenker - songs. Adrianne Lenker is the lead vocalist of Big Thief, but I think she shines even more brightly on her own. Hit that one up after you listen to the best album ever made, Ys by Joanna Newsom. I love your videos. Keep up the grind Mr. Reliable o7

  • @parkourguy4567
    @parkourguy4567 Рік тому

    I believe the shimmery metal noise you liked on flume is a guitar device called an ebow

  • @embe2268_
    @embe2268_ Рік тому +1

    Love this album. ❤ thank you for the reaction.

  • @Andrew-cy7jo
    @Andrew-cy7jo Рік тому +1

    Funny you mention winter with this album, that’s the season I correlate with his 3rd studio album, 22, a million. I think Bon Iver is a good artist to go in chronological order to hear how his sound and style has progressed through the years since he gets more and more experimental.

  • @DocHikes
    @DocHikes Рік тому +1

    Great album! I feel like their follow-up is even better.

  • @antiplanetary
    @antiplanetary Рік тому

    fav winter album

  • @audr3yaudr3y
    @audr3yaudr3y Рік тому +1

    flume drives me wild

  • @91790.victoriaa
    @91790.victoriaa 17 днів тому

    this album makes me feel the tears in my throat

  • @GusZiliotto
    @GusZiliotto Рік тому

    nice chill lowkey good vibes letsgooo

  • @i.am.frog.man777
    @i.am.frog.man777 Рік тому +1

    Fun Fact: He created this album alone in a cabin for a straight year after his girlfriend broke up with him, his band broke off, and losing his job.
    The vulnerability in the atmosphere, his voice, his lyrics, his production, and melodies make this to personally be one of my favorite albums of all time. sorry to admit that I relate to his words in this project, but this album has helped me a tone to get through it.
    Recommend his album i,i (heavy kanye influence!)

  • @Cam-rm1wn
    @Cam-rm1wn 10 місяців тому

    Awesome dude cool to see someone hear this fantastic album for the first time (: i recommend listening to their self titled next of u haven’t 👏

  • @wyattboyatt
    @wyattboyatt 11 місяців тому

    Gotta check out his newer stuff i,i or 22, a million both albums are so full of production and insane vocal layering

  • @dantebordi4122
    @dantebordi4122 Рік тому +2

    when is live at bush hall!!??

  • @lathenisbreathing
    @lathenisbreathing Рік тому +1

    what a great album oml😭

  • @Lleimzjames
    @Lleimzjames Рік тому

    A masterwork.

  • @nuggetthemarshmallow
    @nuggetthemarshmallow Рік тому +1

    bon iver is sort of a tame impala or nine inch nails situation where it’s only one guy on the record, but he plays with a band live. at least for this record.

  • @DailyRepentance_
    @DailyRepentance_ Рік тому

    Kilo Kish - American Gurl
    Sudan Archives - NBPQ
    Jean Dawson - Chaos Now*
    I'm new to experimental music and these are one of the few I actually liked.

    • @joshuadoty4682
      @joshuadoty4682 Рік тому

      It seems you’re into some poppier stuff I would personally recommend I love you Jennifer B by Jockstrap. It was my favorite album of last year

  • @jaaqob2
    @jaaqob2 Рік тому

    I just listened to this album so I can watch this video

  • @rainydaydreamawy
    @rainydaydreamawy Рік тому

    Many nights after the divorce in a dark house with this album engulfing me time and again. Only way I could sleep some nights.

  • @brent5728
    @brent5728 Рік тому +1

    Love this album. You have to do Amy winehouse back to black. Not only is it a classic but it is a real “that relationship f’ed me up album. Lol

  • @MayorBrownn
    @MayorBrownn Рік тому

    Please do more!

  • @gummiaudun
    @gummiaudun Рік тому

    Great stuff! More Sigur Rós please❤

  • @francoberardi5696
    @francoberardi5696 Рік тому

    Bon Iver is a genius. Listen to Far Caspian, another genius.

  • @spirittheythemvanished
    @spirittheythemvanished Рік тому +1

    a great album if you wanna continue this vibe is "I Want That You Are Always Happy" by The Middle East

  • @Yayeti
    @Yayeti Рік тому

    I's recommend Windswept Adan by Ichiko Aoba, my favorite album from the 2020s so far

  • @l-_-l6277
    @l-_-l6277 Рік тому +1

    I would recommend Pornography by the Cure, since you liked their other album

  • @elunelle1174
    @elunelle1174 Рік тому

    You should definitely check out Tago Mago by Can, I think you’d love it or at least find it very interesting. I listened to it for the first time recently and it blew my mind. Love your videos btw!

  • @anmts5565
    @anmts5565 Рік тому

    i’m surprised you still haven’t done wish you were here by pink floyd, elite album

  • @gabrielestobar3818
    @gabrielestobar3818 Рік тому

    Wating for more interpol album reviews 😔

  • @gussigris
    @gussigris Рік тому

    Yoo man, if you really enjoyed this Bon Iver album, you should do a live reaction/review on Bon Iver's '22 A Million' album. That shit will freak you out. Honestly the greatest work of art made on earth.

  • @AEF95
    @AEF95 5 місяців тому

    This album is the only thing that keeps me going. I dont say sht like this but this time its true.

  • @ALLHAILSUNSETYOUTH2
    @ALLHAILSUNSETYOUTH2 Рік тому +1

    This was recorded by one man in a log cabin with an old busted guitar

  • @dtiptoemusic
    @dtiptoemusic 2 місяці тому

    This song is kind of about... *proceeds to read the lyrics aloud*

  • @frankhoey2454
    @frankhoey2454 11 місяців тому

    By the way, for context he recorded the entire album by himself in a cabin in the woods!

  • @delilahmiller-uo6dy
    @delilahmiller-uo6dy Рік тому

    hey, i'm a new fan and i'm loving all your content, seriously good work. would you ever do a ween album? they're my favorite band

    • @smags1082
      @smags1082  Рік тому

      Quebec review tomorrow lol

  • @meindolfreinar4141
    @meindolfreinar4141 Рік тому

    Do us and mostly YOURSELF a favor and listen to Downward Spiral by Nine Inch Nails if you never heard before👏🏼

  • @AtomicVampire1
    @AtomicVampire1 Рік тому

    I think you would like Tindersticks

  • @mogwaibalenciaga
    @mogwaibalenciaga Рік тому +1

    fortnite shirt is crazy

  • @busboy20and1
    @busboy20and1 Рік тому

    yo could you give "brighter wounds" by son lux or "ma hill" by incredible polo a listen? they're both sick albums and i think you'll enjoy hearing them

  • @Emmanuel19994
    @Emmanuel19994 Рік тому +1

    death grips or jpegmafia

  • @nothingreally6680
    @nothingreally6680 Рік тому

    their albums only get better from here. much less one dimensional both musically and emotionally, inherits all that sentimentality but puts it towards something a lot less hackneyed. the music on this album leaves a lot more to be desired.

  • @vSmoKv
    @vSmoKv Місяць тому

    the saddest greatest album of all time

  • @apharms
    @apharms Рік тому

    Bro listen to Helplessness Blues

  • @ajv1437
    @ajv1437 Рік тому +3

    bro is ignoring me😢😢

    • @smags1082
      @smags1082  Рік тому +3

      Ween within the next 3 I got y’all cuzzo 🤞

  • @bymaxxie
    @bymaxxie 8 місяців тому

    Depression the album

  • @merpinmyderp447
    @merpinmyderp447 8 місяців тому

    ethan chlebowskis music channel

  • @patrickoneil3277
    @patrickoneil3277 Рік тому

    is the title an aot reference

  • @nostalgia_clinic
    @nostalgia_clinic Рік тому +1

    PANDA BEAR - BUOYS

  • @iethergy
    @iethergy Рік тому

    🅱️

  • @creaturefear1340
    @creaturefear1340 Рік тому

    I will send you money to react to the rest of BI's discography.