Was the Last Supper a Passover meal or not?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 29 бер 2017
- There is some controversy about if Yeshua's last supper was a Passover meal or not. This is due to a question about the timeline presented in the gospels. Some people think there is a conflict between the synoptic gospels and the gospel of John, because the Synoptics say that Yeshua ate the Passover at the last supper, while John says that Yeshua died on the preparation day for the Passover.
There is a saying that, "an honest but mistaken man once shown the truth either ceases to be honest or ceases to be mistaken." My desire is to be an honest man who is willing to correct my mistakes. That's why I chose the name UNLEARN for this ministry. We must always be humble enough to admit when we make mistakes, and willing to repent and make the appropriate changes. When we are presented with new information, we need to be willing to re-evaluate what we believe about that topic.
I have recently been presented with new information that has changed my understanding about the Last Supper. I am now convinced that the last supper was in fact a Passover meal, and in this video I am going to explain why.
The argument really boils down to a question about when the Passover meal is supposed to be eaten. Some say it is to be eaten at the evening beginning the 14th, while others say it is to be eaten the evening beginning the 15th.
I previously believed the Passover was to be killed at the end of the 14th and eaten on the 15th. This is how most modern Jews celebrate Passover, and I assumed they were correct in their observance. However, after a closer examination of the Scriptures, I'm convinced that the Passover must be eaten at the evening beginning the 14th, because Yahweh passed over their houses during the night of the 14th. That is why the 14th day is called the Passover.
Numbers 28:16-17
So we see from this verse that the 14th day is the Passover and the 15th day begins the Feast of Unleavened Bread. There is a distinction made between these two days. Passover is not the first day of Unleavened Bread, Passover takes place the day before the Feast begins.
The Synoptics tell us that Yeshua and His disciples ate the Passover the night beginning the 14th day.
Matthew 26:17-19
Now, we just discussed that Passover is on the 14th and the Feast of Unleavened Bread begins on the 15th, so why does Matthew say on the first day of unleavened bread they asked where to kill the Passover? The word translated as "first" is the Greek word prōtē which means "before", "best", or "what comes first". So, it could be translated "before the day of Unleavened Bread", which makes more sense, because if it was already the Feast of Unleavened Bread they would have been a day late.
We know the meal Yeshua ate with His disciples took place on the evening beginning the 14th, because Yeshua died the evening beginning the 15th according to John's Gospel. John tells us it was the preparation day for the High Sabbath, which is on the 15th.
John 19:31
This was not the preparation day for the weekly Sabbath, it was the preparation day for the High Sabbath beginning the Feast of Unleavened bread.
Now, back to Matthew 26. These verses really cause problems for those who say the Passover is eaten on the 15th, because they say that Yeshua died before the Passover was to be eaten, but all three Synoptic Gospels say that Yeshua ate the Passover before He was killed.
Notice that Yeshua made an emphatic statement that He was going to eat the Passover at that place with His disciples.
Matthew 26:18-19
If you say that this was not a Passover meal, then you are disagreeing with the words of Yeshua. Not only that, but the Bible also says the disciples "prepared the Passover", indicating that they prepared the lamb. All three synoptic Gospels are in agreement on these points, but Luke includes something that the others do not say.
Luke 22:13-16
Yeshua again calls this meal the Passover and says that He has been looking forward to eating it with them before He suffers. He had eaten Passover every year of His life, but this Passover was special, because this was His Passover. He knew that this was the Passover when He would establish the New Covenant in His blood.
Matthew 26:26-28
Passover is a covenant meal and Yeshua ate the Passover with His disciples explaining that it is the New Covenant in His blood. This connects with the covenant that Yahweh made with Israel before they left Egypt, when He covered them with the blood and protected them from the destroyer.
Exodus 12:23
So, we see the 14th day is the Passover beginning at sunset, because Yahweh passed over them that night, and the 15th day is the High Sabbath. Yeshua ate the Passover covenant meal with His disciples on the night beginning the 14th, then He died at the end of the the 14th, finalizing the salvation and sealing the New Covenant in His blood.
I was a catholic before and recently converted... and now I was able to celebrate THE PASSOVER on March 27, 2021! 🙏
Easter day was Sunday, 2 May 2021.
@@elliotdavies1418 what righteousness is in the recognition of a pagan holiday where God was not born.
For those saying that they thought Judas went to go buy a lamb, you need to understand that the lambs had to be bought on or before the 10th of Aviv. No way he was going to buy a lamb this late.
I love that you stated how we can be in disagreement and still have fellowship. Many would do well to take this stance. I agree that if it does not pertain to the foundational truth of the gospel we should be able to reason with each other without contention. Unfortunately some people are arrogant and spew insults at people who don't agree with their every belief. We are all continually learning through studying the Word and letting the Ruach lead us into all truth. Thank you for your insights. I always appreciate them.
Thanks Nika
VERY WELL SAID.
@@victhewrangler Well put. Agree 100% that it's should in no way be confusing. If he says not to. Don't. If he say do. Do. And if he says Remember. I think its best to Remember.
@@unlearntheliesthe Passover meal and the Last Supper were *two different* meals on that same night after Sundown and when the TWILIGHT was over,with Jesus and his Apostles!!
The first meal was the last valid(from Jehovah's standpoint) and actual Passover meal where Jesus ate it with all his 12 Apostles, and after the episode with them with the washing of their feet and stuff is when then now Jesus *dismissed...* Judas Iscariot to go and do what he had to do in reference to his betray him(Jesus)and then after he instituted the New Covenant by means of that Last Supper with his now 11faithful Apostles on that same night of Nisan 14th 33C.E.
Thanks Lex, I appreciated your humility and hope that we can all be willing to admit when we might have been misguided about something.
I have a question:
• Jesus ate the Passover with his Disciples,
• then was arrested and tried by the Jews,
• then they then took Jesus to Pilate and they would not enter the Praetorian that they might not be defiled so they could eat the Passover (John 18: 28)
I see a timeline problem. How did Jesus eat the Passover and the Passover is yet future for these Jews?
Yes there is a contradiction on the timeline or even the assumption that the Messiah did not celebrate it Passover but only had a meal with his disciples.
The Passover narrative have nothing to do with the Messiah. The festival of Passover was never intended or predicted to be replaced by another festival or covenant. or even modified in any way. It was a permanent festival ( forever) . Did the Most High God forget to mention it? lol Deut. 12:14,42
Where is that Scripture that says that it would be replaced by a human blood sacrifice in the Exodus narrative? Using as a parallel is merely an "assumption" not a true understanding of the intent of the narrative. I mean in the Tanakh not NT. Specially speaking of Messianic prophecies.
Where in the Deut chapter 12 says that the future Messiah will parallel that festival?
The meaning of the Passover was not intended for the forgiveness of sins of the Israelites nor blood covenant.
Abba did not make the covenant with Israel until the Law given by Moses but not in the Passover narrative my friends.
The Messiah was not Passover by Jews in the first century. Why? Because all Jews including Yeshua himself remembered that festival as a deliverance of Slavery in Egypt and receiving an inheritance as a nation when they entered the promised land. BUT Christianity claims otherwise and interpreted as the last supper lamb only as a blood covenant for the forgiveness of sins.
.
According to Deuteronomy 12 , it could've been also "goat" not a lamb. See Deut 12:5
That's the assumption of Christian pastors and clergy.
brother! i SO appreciate you sharing what you've sought out and learned about this! you have cleared up all my questions with this video and other Passover videos of yours!
I just want to thank you. We have been so confused about timing on Passover and when to keep it. This is our third Passover and studying this topic is difficult since there's so many opinions out there. Last night we had a Passover marathon with all of your Passover videos. I especially like the one with Zach Bauer, because we watch him too. I really respected the way that you put his opinion and your opinion out there, it addressed many issues we had. I also learned some new things I had never considered before. Eye opening and inspired much discussion on our upcoming Passover. You're videos are definitely binge worthy!
The true meaning of Passover narrative have nothing to do with the Messiah. The festival of Passover was never intended or predicted to be replaced by another festival or covenant. or even modified in any way. It was a permanent festival ( forever) . Did the Most High God forget to mention it? lol Deut. 12:14,42
Where is that Scripture that says that it would be replaced by a human blood sacrifice in the Exodus narrative? Using as a parallel is merely an "assumption" not a true understanding of the intent of the narrative. I mean in the Tanakh not NT. Specially speaking of Messianic prophecies.
Where in the Deut chapter 12 says that the future Messiah will parallel that festival?
The meaning of the Passover was not intended for the forgiveness of sins of the Israelites nor blood covenant.
Abba did not make the covenant with Israel until the Law given by Moses but not in the Passover narrative my friends.
The Messiah was not Passover by Jews in the first century. Why? Because all Jews including Yeshua himself remembered that festival as a deliverance of Slavery in Egypt and receiving an inheritance as a nation when they entered the promised land. BUT Christianity claims otherwise and interpreted as the last supper lamb only as a blood covenant for the forgiveness of sins.
.
According to Deuteronomy 12 , it could've been also "goat" not a lamb. See Deut 12:5
That's the assumption of Christian pastors and clergy.
There is one problem in your explanation sir. Acc to Exo 12:7 the Passover lamb should be sacrificed on 14th evening. Exactly Jesus died on the 14th evening 3pm when the Passover lamb was supposed to be sacrificed.
If Jesus took a pass over meal, the lamb should have been sacrificed on 13th evening which contradicts Exo12:7.
Plz correct me if I am wrong
Awesome. A very clear teaching on what is where. I use to understand it this way u have put it. But as the years past, I unwittingly fell for the confusion. Thank you brother. YHVH bless you and your family.
Very sound and thank you! I was stumped on this one because someone said according to the mishna He ate as a peace offering. But now I know the mishna can’t be relied upon for truth.
I think you were right the first time. I didn't hear anything in this video that say he ate the Passover meal, but desired to eat. May eat and will eat is two different things. There are too many other verses that say this was not a Passover meal. How can you eat the Passover lamb before you are killed/die and become our Passover lamb?
I appreciate your channel! Thank you for your teaching!
I've got to say that I struggle with this one! Reading through Exodus, it seems clear to me that the Passover is eaten on the night of the 15th. Exodus clearly talks of the feast being seven days long, and it begins on the 14th day at evening (which begins the 15th day) (Ex 12:17-19). It becomes eight days, if you count the actual 14th day too.
Exodus 12:51 states that they left their homes the same day of the Passover meal, which is made clearer in Numbers 33:3. In 2 Chronicles 35:1, Josiah clearly killed the Passover on the 14th (the meal obviously that night).
In Luke 22:15, I see Yeshua is saying that I desire to eat this [upcoming] Passover with you, but I will not eat it anymore [this time and onwards, until ...]. *He* was to become the Passover Lamb, so wouldn't be attending the meal.
Anyway, just some of my thoughts on the scriptures involved. I think the Tanakh makes it clearer. I certainly agree that it's not worth fighting over, but we all still need to strive for the truth. It took me a few years of frustrating study to come to my conclusion, but as you say, if any of us are wrong (myself definitely included!), we need to humble ourselves and change accordingly! YHWH bless you - and us all as we look to Him for our guidance!!
Marcus G Very good remarks. thanks.
My next video will address some of the most common arguments that people use to try to say that the last supper was not a Passover.
UNLEARN the lies
Looking forward to it. ☺
Marcus G, follow the scriptures in the post I left for Lex. Everything will become clear.
Lex, It should rightfully be called the last Passover.
I am torn between your teaching and 119 Test Everything “Was the Last Supper a Passover Meal?” Perhaps you could address these arguments? Btw I am really enjoying your teachings. Keep up the good work and thank you for all the research and work you pour into them.
another good video brother, interesting that you mentioned the destroyer at the end of your video, this is another interesting study for another day perhaps, Revelation 9:11. looking forward to your next video. shalom:)
Thanks brother
So jesus ate the passover (unleavened bread bitter herbs and lamp) on the night 13 beginning 14.He died 14 at noon and on the 15 the Passover was to be eaten?So jesus ate the passover before 15.Does not that contradict the law?
John 18:28
Then they led Jesus from Caiaphas to the Praetorium, and it was early morning. But they themselves did not go into the Praetorium, lest they should be defiled, but that they might eat the Passover.
According to this verse the last supper was not the passover meal...
DAYUM! LEX NEED TO UNLEARN THE LIES
Yes that right!
Thank you lex for your videos, really awesome stuff, I've been encouraged deeply to follow the whole bible and pursue The Almighty with all that I am. I do have a question for you, in reference to the captives that Jesus set free I have heard many interpretations. I've heard that the captives were old testament saints, fallen angels, or even that it applies to us today saying that we, the living believers, are slaves to sin and he freed us. I know we were once slaves and he indeed has freed us I just don't know if that scripture is saying that specifically. Just wanted to ask thank you again for your wonderful ministry.
Can you be more specific about what verse you are referring to? There are several that speak about setting the captives free.
to Abrupt Decay: Lex addressed that in a previous video. (Sorry, can't tell you which one) He suggested that they were recently dead (rather than major figures from the past.) which would help explain why not one name is mentioned. And that they afterward died again. That is, they did not rise to eternal life, but their resurrection was a temporary continuance of our temporal life.
Shaloom, brother.. could you please discuss about Luke 22:38? About the swords and the word "enough". Thanks a lot. God bless
There are two ways that people look at that verse. Some say that Yeshua was scolding them for bringing swords, while others say that He was telling them that they don't need any more swords. I think He was saying that they have enough swords and do not need any more, because in verse 36 He told them to get a sword.
That's so much better, I'm glad you see what I have seen and much more in agreement with Zachary Bauer. He is a careful teacher, not perfect, I have disagreed with him, but went to him in love and he accepted and agreed that my objection was not considered in his teaching, perhaps not for everyone, but acceptable to YHWH for some in need.
Thank you brother!!! Shalom
In a show called unlearn the lies, we are learning a lie I feel like, Go figure. How can Yeshua partake of the passover lamb when he is the passover lamb. Not only that, but if he is the passover lamb for us, then this would mean that he either died on the wrong day or did passover on the wrong day. The only possible conclusion (which also comes from John as he is a primary source) is that the last supper wasn't the passover seder.
UPDATE: Another reason k have trouble with this is because the synoptics all say that the pharisees wanted him dead before the passover lest a riot break out among the people. So they have a motive and a reason to do it beforehand anyway, I also feel that Yeshuas words are still consistent even if the meal they are eating is not a passover meal.
U right Cause we cant celebrate it over ALL MEANS
Your right. The last supper was prep day for the passover. Jesus died on passover day. Being our passover lamb.
If i may ask why Did you change John 19:31
Now it was the day of Preparation, and the next day was to be a special Sabbath. Because the Jewish leaders did not want the bodies left on the crosses during the Sabbath, they asked Pilate to have the legs broken and the bodies taken down.
Adding the word NOT as Now it was Not the day of the preparation?
Answer me please,is it correct to say the translators or John were wrong?Thank u
Thank you Lex for your videos and your time. I’m learning and unlearning the lies with your videos. God bless you
One question I’m struggling with this.
Is Yahweh the same as Yeshua?
Thank you for the informative video.
I am glad you found it helpful
At first I was wondering if you're to support the 15th Abib Passover. This is exactly what I see in my researched. Thank you so much for clarifying the first (prote) -day in Hebrew.
Thank you! Thank you ! I have been studying this same thing
Thanks for you work.
Hello Sir, when you say on the night of the 14th are your referring to Jewish time where the day starts the evening of the 13 which would be the 14th or our time calendar, the 14th evening being on the 14th evening
Passover has to be the evening of the 14th because the Israelites were not allowed to leave their homes until the morning, and then they had to go and spoil the Egyptians the next day--the daytime of the 14th. They then leave Egypt on the evening of the 15th which was the beginning of Unleavened Bread. If Passover was the evening of the 15th, then that means they left Egypt that same night, which does not make sense, because they were not to leave their homes until morning and they needed time to spoil the Egyptians.
The Greek language has 2 words for bread: one word for leavened and a different word for leavened. The Gospels all used the word for leavened bread- which is not eaten at the Passover meal.
That year: Preparation day 13th, Passover 14th, unleavened 15th, Shabbat 16th, Firstfruits 17th
As for me, I try to remember & do what is written in Luke 22:19-20, AND do so sometime in the first hour of the 14th of Abib AND keep the 7 days of unleavened bread BEGINNING on the 15th of Abib.
See John 18:28. The High Priest etc wanted Yahshua killed before they ate the Passover at sundown (Feast of Unleavened Bread). They did not eat it on the night of the 14th. Hence Yahshua's last supper was not a Passover meal because the lambs were only killed the following afternoon-around the time Yahshua The Passover Lamb was killed! See Jn 19:14.
I'm curious, did the disciples have to take the lamb to the Levites so they could spill the blood properly?
If so, would others think they arrived early?
Or maybe it was such a long tedious process of waiting in line with your lamb, that no one would blame them if they were 1st in line?
Good day Sir... I am of the same view as you, but the scripture that brings doubt to the view we both hold is John 18:28. How can we reconcile this? It basically says Jesus was taken to Pilate early (morning I assume) and the high priest did not enter the judgement hall because they still wanted to eat the passover...........
The first seder is on the eve of the 15th as Biblically mandated and as established according to the Jewish calendar. The Passover offering was brought on the afternoon of the 14th, but the Seder was held and the holiday of Passover began, on the 15th which is why the Seder is then.
could you able to give explanation on second coming of christ.. especially Mathew 24,Mark 13 and luke 21
garsh darn it Lex! I already requested the wrong days off!
LOL... that comment made me laugh :D
Dear brother. Your channel is a real blessing. Are you a member of a Hebrew Roots grouup or a Messianic group? Just curious about these things.
I am not a member of any particular group, but I do associate with both Hebrew Roots and Messianic Jews.
@Amado Escobar yes it is.
@@unlearnthelies How do we observe Passover if we have no community to observe with. I am finding "quartodecimans" on line, but no congregations.
Simple, succinct video!
If MESSIAH chose fishermen as apostles, an explanation of this topic needn't be complex or convoluted.
I came to the conclusion you have, and it only took two years! 😳
Thanks for this and peace.
The Passover meal cannot be eaten prior to the sacrifice being killed. Yeshua Messiah's blood covering must come first. Therefore, the Last Supper could not have been Pesach .
To conclude that the Last Supper was not Passover, one has to ignore the fact that Yeshua and the disciples called it Passover 4 times in Matthew, 5 times in Mark, and 6 times in Luke. You also have to ignore the fact that Yeshua specifically said that He was going to eat the Passover with His disciples, and ignore the text that says "on the day the passover was to be killed" and ignore the text says "the disciples prepared the passover".
I respectfully disagree. Yeshua did not eat the Passover meal because he was crucified and died at the very time the unblemished lambs were killed for the Passover. He is our Passover. He cannot both be the meal and eat the meal prior to being crucified and 3 days in the grave prior to his resurrection.
The timeline of Matthew 26:2 and Mark 14:1 is the 12th day.
Matthew 26:17 -18 is on the 13th.
Yeshua expresses his fervent desire to eat the Passover meal with his disciples in Luke 22:15 . However, nowhere in These verses are the required parts of the Passover meal of the bitter herbs, lamb, and unleavened bread mentioned. John 13:2 simply calls it a supper. See also John 18:28 in regard to the timeline of Passover not yet having occurred.
I think we can agree that Yeshua, being sinless, kept the Passover and Passover meal perfectly during his lifetime. Therefore, he would not have broken leavened bread (Strong's #740) with his disciples as he did in Luke 22:19, were it the Passover meal.
17 Now on the first day of the Feast of Unleavened Bread the disciples came to Jesus, saying to Him, “Where do You want us to prepare for You to eat the Passover?”
He ate it. He wasn't a literal lamb, learn what symbolism is. Only the gospel falsely called John called him a symbolic lamb. The first three gospels never do
to Bonnie Blue: I believe you are correct. It is challenging to work to 'harmonize' many accounts which don't seem to be amenable to being harmonized. (Then there is the addition of layers of 'tradition' which further confuses the matter.) Add to all of that the fact that we are working with a translation of a translation. (The original was written in Hebrew) and the water is muddied almost beyond hope. (Our Hope is that the Spirit of YAHUSHA is promised to guide us into all truth, so we can do what is pleasing to the Savior) While it is humanly impossible to harmonize all the stories, It is my understanding that the original had not 'prepare the Passover' but rather 'prepare FOR the Passover'-- which is actually how Matt 26:17 is rendered in the translation I use --(ISR)-- which leads me to your conclusion, and in contradiction to Lex"s.
Better touch up on your studies. The gospels are GREEK not Hebrew
Nicely done, Lex. I appreciate your humble attitude. I too believe Jesus ate the Passover meal on the 14th and died just before sunset that same day. UB begins on the 15th and is the (high) Sabbath, not the Weekly Sabbath, that has so many confused. I have a feeling many of the disagreements we experience are due to mistakes in our English translations.
Hypothesis for you:
- Nisan 10 (the day Jews were to select their Passover sacrifice): Jesus is hailed (selected) as King at his triumphant entry.
- Nisan 11
- Nisan 12: Jesus is anointed
- Nisan 13
- Nisan 14: Passover, arrest, trial, crucifixion. This is also Preparation Day.
- Nisan 15: 1st day of Unleavened Bread (high Sabbath)
- Nisan 16: UB
- Nisan 17: UB
- Nisan 18: UB
- Nisan 19: UB
- Nisan 20: UB
- Nisan 21: UB (high Sabbath)
Note: First Fruits falls on the 1st day of the week. Jesus rose on that day.
If that timing is correct, then:
- Nisan 10 was Sunday
- Nisan 14 was Thursday
- Nisan 17 was Sunday
so we eat on the 14 of April until the 21?
Thanks for correctly translating the greek word because that is confusing.
What date is the last supper 2020?
Image one word was added to this scripture to change the entire understand. This word is "again" in the final sentence. Now read the scripture again. I am very confused as the earlier bible translations don't have this word "again" in them.
I like your character, yes we are growing and must accept correction
How does them preparing prove they ate it that night?
But.. wouldn't His blood had to have been shed on the night of the 14th to mirror image the first Pesach?
If I am not circumcised can I still celebrate the passover.
Atos, means leavened bread, there are two evenings on the 14th Abib-Nissan, on the 13th afternoon was done the preparation and on the evening 13/14 after sundown was the last Souper, late that night he was apprehended and in the morning on the 14th before Pilates, at midday on the Cross and at 03.00pm he gave his spirit to the father, he was the perfect lam slaughtert on the 14th at the exact time the lams would be slaughtert at the tempel, at sundown 14/15th Abib-Nissan, unleavened bread and peshach, so our Ha Masiach could only have his meal without the lam been slaughtert in the tempel and with leavened bread, Atos, the last Souper was a old tradition from Egypt, they remembered the first borns who died by the angel by having each year the last Souper , lots of Egyptians went with the Hebrews, even after loosing they're firstborns, this I how they remembered them, now we do the same to remember our king of kings and to take part of his covenant with bread and wine,. Why do you think he says the leavened bread, Atos is his body, and not the lamsflesh?!?! Love you brother, you do tremendous good work!!!
May YHWH's face be shining on you with grace and keep you!!! Love from Spain-Barcelona!
Joaquin Marti
very good 👍
I will be addressing that argument (and a few others) in my next video.
@@unlearnthelies yes I think what this brother says may be true. They talked about preparing for Pesach but didn't mention eating lamb or bitter herbs. Wouldn't Y'shua have said the lamb was his body and blood sacrificed for us at the table and not the bread and wine? They reclined at the table - yet we are to eat in haste. We aren't to leave the house yet they rose up and left.
Y'shua desired to eat this Pesach with them but knew he would be crucified.
The first Passover instructions do not all apply to every subsequent one.
I can't believe there is so much confusion over this. With all the passages. How is it possible?
I heard they often ate a meal before Passover (the Chagigah) and they still called it a pesach....
Any thoughts?
@Zechariah12.10 I believe Jesus was crucified exactly when the passover was to be slaughtered. How could he have eaten the passover if the lamb was not slaughtered yet?
@Zechariah12.10 I agree. So when out churches are teaching Jesus ate the passover meal with his disciples is it worded wrong or should it just be called the last supper?
@Zechariah12.10 thank you. And Jesus said he would not be eating the passover meal as well.
Luke 22:15-16 (ESV): 15 And he said to them, “I have earnestly desired to eat this Passover with you before I suffer. 16 For I tell you I will not eat it until it is fulfilled in the kingdom of God.”
@@travislee1012 - Let's read it in KJV, shall we "16 For I say unto you, I will not any more eat thereof, until it be fulfilled in the kingdom of God."
Aparently no, prote is the first, the most important of a secuence, not the before of somerhing. Your old Belief was more accurate
Thank you
Its the pass over for the forgiveness of sin? Is Jesuschrist physically in the breaking of thr bread and wine every Sunday at mass or is just symbolic?
How could Yeshua be the Passover lamb and eat a Passover meal?
The Passover is a type and shadow of the Messiah, in the same way the day of Atonement is a type and shadow of Him. How could He be the atonement sacrifice if He didn't die on the day of atonement? The fulfillment does not have to be done in the exact same way as the shadow. The shadow simply points us to the fulfillment.
@@unlearnthelies that is, what it's called forced typology.
lies insert trump "wrong" gif here.
Because the scripture says so. Luke 22
If it was a passover meal, it wasn't on a Friday night. This counters the idea that Shabbat is from Friday night to Saturday night. And you've stated Shabbat are these days and not by the luni-solar method. I think we all still need to delve deeper into the moe'dim.
Im confused he ate the passover on the 14th at night after sunset, then was betrayed and died on the cross also on the 14th night Didn't he died before sunset? or are you saying he died on the 15th day this timing docent matcha scripture but id like to understand more
It is written in Exodus 12: 6, that the passover is to be killed in the evening of the 14th day of Nissan. Now I know that the Fathers day begins in the end of the day when the sun goes down and the night of the next day begins. So, when the sun goes down at the end of the 13th day, is that the evening of the 14th day?
What translation of scripture are you reading from Lex? Thanks!
It is the ISR Scriptures (Institute for Scriptural Research)
Jason McGinnis I was about to ask! Lol
Thank you Lex. I purchased one and am ready to start studying this translation.
#1: About the Pharisees, they followed what was practiced based from what was written in the book of Jubilees chapter 49 that was written in the year 113 BC that was written by a Pharisee. This is seen in John 18:28. #2: Read Luke 22:7-8; Mark 14:12; Matt. 26:17. The reason why I mention this is (read) Jashar 81:15-16. #3: Read Matt. 27:62-66, this event took place during the daytime portion of the day (the 15th).
Key difference: he didn't say I am to CONSUME the passach... But to perform the passach. He wasn't taking the place of the person BEING passed over, but taking the place of the lamb who's death allows others to be passed over.
The only thing I'm not super clear on is whether Passach itself is the high sabbath, the first day of the feast. Or if Passach wasn't a sabbath at all, and the day AFTER passach is the start of unleavened bread, and the high sabbath.
119 ministries teaching on this is good, also Michael Rood's series prophecy in the spring feasts. I think we should be observing the second passover, if you ask me. Even people who live in Jerusalem can't observe it correctly though, but since Yeshua is our Cohen Gadol, they don't need to
I agree with one comment in other video. You are a great teacher but may be think about dropping "the lies" from the title. No one is trying to "lie". We are all trying to understand God's word the best we can. Other then that thank you for your time and effort.
I do believe that a lot of the confusion is caused by not correctly placing the Sabbath *day*. If you believe that the Sabbath goes from evening to evening (and most erroneously do), then it throws the whole count off. If instead you understand that the Sabbath is only the daylight hours of the 8th, 15th, 22nd and 29th days of the lunar month (as evidenced in ALL the Scriptural dates), then you will also understand that the 14th day of the first month is Passover and also the day that Yahushua died. The next day (15th), is a _High_ Sabbath because it is not only the weekly Sabbath, but also the first day of the Feast of Unleavened Bread. This makes the 16th the first day of the week and the Day of First Fruits when Yahushua arose.
If you read the account of those who took His body, bought burial linens and spices, and worked all night in preparing His body, only laying it in the tomb as the *dawn* of the High Sabbath was breaking, you will understand that this is _the key_ to your confusion. The Scriptures bear the Truth and should be read literally and without preconceived assumptions and prejudice.
All us Truth seekers are admonished to "unlearn the lies" of our fathers before us. We are all at different stages of this path.
I am compelled, as you are, to share the Light and Truth that I have received.
Scripture states that only fools discount information before investigation, and of course we know what Scripture says about those who turn their backs on Truth.
I will be glad to answer any question you may have about my above statement.
Ever your sister in the Christ Yahushua, Shalom
U right have read the book of JUBLIEE SISTER?..VERY IMPORTANT INFO ON WHY WE CANT CELEBRATE THE FEASTS NOR KNOW WHT TIME & DATE TO EVEN DO SO
I LIKE IT! THANKS
Thanks. I am glad you like it
So are we supposed to eat the lamb for passover or not? I'm so confused.
No.
Like some have said before, they have left Egypt on the 15th, NOT the 14th. (On unleavened bread Exo12:17 17 And ye shall observe the feast of unleavened bread; for in this SELFSAME DAY have I brought your armies out of the land of Egypt: therefore shall ye observe this day in your generations by an ordinance for ever.)
(on the 15th Numbers 33:3
3 And they departed from Rameses in the first month, on the fFIFTEENTH DAY of the first month; on the morrow after the passover the children of Israel went out with an high hand in the sight of all the Egyptians.)
You got it, dude! Yes, the 14th is for PASSOVER, and UB is a completely different day, for a different event. A lot of encyclopedias, do speak of the two days, later being merged.
I doubt if you will ever, "Unlearn" on this subject, again. Blessings!
I wonder if the Hebrew Matthew is in sync with the Greek Matthew...
I believe in what you say Lex but just clarify this Passover feast that Yeshua ate was in the hours JUST after the sun set of Nisan 13... OR was it just before sunset on Nisan 14..
It would have been at the beginning of the 14th after sunset. Then He died during the afternoon on the 14th.
Much confusion is cleared up easily when you realize that a day starts in the morning (boqer: dawn, daybreak, firstlight). Evening (ereb: means going toward darkness) requires light first, so evening is the transition from the day into the night, but cannot start a day. Just the words 'tonight' and 'tomorrow' show you this simple truth.
That does not clear it up at all. If that was the case, then Yeshua and the disciples would have been eating the Passover on the wrong day.
UNLEARN the lies Yahusha kept the True Passover and elevated it spirituality, as He did the Commandments in Matt 5. He made a New Covenant and then died the next day on the 15th of the dark moon (total solar eclipse).
He didn't make a new anything, he RENEWED the previous covenant
Don't we have the Passover meal on the evening of April 10th?
No the 10th is when the Passover lamb is chosen and then kept in the house 4 days until the 14th.
Could it be that it was the beginning of the 14/Passover after sun down but was not a passover meal? Since the passover meal would be killed and eaten at "twilight" as the sun was going down at the end of the 14th and the meal/feast continue into the feast of unleavened bread after sundown?
John Bottone, I left a very revealing post to Lex that will answer your question. Check it out.
Edwynn Kelley check it out- where is it? Can you repost?
Twilight is the beginning of the new day. So, if you wait until the end of the 14th and kill it at twilight, then you would be eating the Passover on the 15th. But the Bible says the Passover is to be eaten on the 14th. There is not a single Scripture that says the Passover is eaten on the 15th.
I'm not sure which one I sent it to, but I sent it to UNLEARN the lies.
No you are misunderstanding me. They killed it late in the afternoon Passover day began eating it at the end of the 14th day but culminated the gathering and feast after sunset, the 15th.
How could Yeshua BE the Passover lamb for us and ALSO be eating the Passover sedar at the same time? The lamb that was eaten during the meal was the actual Passover lamb. I appreciate your humbleness in stating that you corrected yourself, but it does not make sense. If your right, then either Yeshua died on the wrong day OR He observed Passover on the wrong day.
I am going to do a video to address this question as well. "How could Yeshua eat the Passover and also be the Passover?"
@@unlearnthelies Sounds like YOU need to unlearn the lies bruh.
Everyone who falls for Bart Ehrman's accounting of inconsistencies in the accounts of Jesus's last Passover needs to see this video. It confirms my sense of Ehrman's surface-level "scholarship." You must begin with respect for the Old Testament and with the understanding that the authors and audience embraced the Old Testament. The gospels were written by and primarily for Jews. Absent this context, you will see disparate accounts. I feel that a faithful Jew who knows the Old Testament well would have more insightful things to say about the synoptic gospels than the professor of religious studies at UNC.
Does The Seventh Day Adventist Church keep The Passover once a year?
The seventh day Adventists don't keep any feasts.
@@belle42; not entirely correct, they keep the first Feast, the weekly Sabbath. 😁
Mar 15:42 And when evening had come, because it was the Preparation Day, that is, the day before the Sabbath,
Mar 15:43 Yosĕph of Ramathayim, a prominent council member, who was himself waiting for the reign of Elohim, came, boldly went in to Pilate and asked for the body of יהושע.
You can see that Yosĕph wanted to put our Masiach in the tomb before sabbath. What sabbath can this be? this sabbath cant be the weekly sabbath and must me the high sabbath of the first day of Chag HaMatzot. WHY? if this was the weekly sabbath we know that the first fruits must be after the weekly sabbath>
Lev 23:11 ‘And he shall wave the sheaf before יהוה, for your acceptance. On the morrow after the Sabbath the priest waves it.
So if that sabbath was weekly sabbat that ment our Masiach wasn't resurrection on first fruit (like prophecy states) that would have been on evening begining of day 1
1Co 15:23 And each in his own order: Messiah the first-fruits, then those who are of Messiah at His coming,
So day 4 at evening they laid him in the tomb:
day 4 evening to day 5 evining 1night and 1day. day 5 evening to day 6 evening 2nights 2days. day 6 evening to day 7 evening 3nights and 3days.
Joh 20:1 And on the first day of the week1 Miryam from Mag¯dala came early to the tomb, while it was still dark, and saw that the stone had been removed from the tomb.
the tomb of YAHUSHUA was already empty! Do not miss this point, the tomb was already empty, meaning HE did not arise on Sunday Morning! this making it 3 nights and 3 days = Matthew 12:40
This making imposible to have been te Pesach they ate. Remember when Yahushua came in to the city they asked where to prepare the Passover because they were on the 13th knowning preparation day will start at evening.
Searth for the Qumran calendar.
Enjoyed the video. Only just started looking at this. Problem I have is that John 19:14 clearly states that it was the prep day of passover week at about the 6th hour (midday?) so the Passover meal would have been eaten in the evening (day 1 of unleavened bread) . This is when Yeshua is already captured and so it couldn’t have been the Passover meal as he is about to be crucified on the prep day.
Some factual inaccuracies here. He was killed on the afternoon ending the 14th. This coincides with the lamb being slaughtered on the 14th in OT. Then, the Passover is eaten on evening beginning the 15th, the same night that the Israelites fled Egypt.
I do get it. But if so, then why was the perfect passover lamb slayn a day later?
You can't use roman/ america time to calculate scriptures . You must understand Gods time...
@@blackneck77 I do use God's time. Our Messiah, the perfect passover lamb was sacrificed for us nearing the dusk between Aviv 14 and 15. That's God's time. So, please elaborate
@@advex4428 Your original comment says he was killed a day later not true.Jesus ate the passover with deciples at the beginning of the 14th =evening... evening begins the day Genesis 1:5 ..The Evening and the morning completes a day. Jesus died at 9th hour around 3:00 on 14th of Nisan morning/ day time... 12 hours of nite and 12 hours of day... sun goes down 15th of Nisan a new day....
I was taught by my community rabbi that the Passover is a time not a day. In the first century the Passover and the feast of unleavened bread are synonymous. It's the same way amongst the Jews of today.
The Jews eat Passover on the 15th according to the Pharisees tradition. However, the Bible says the Passover is on the 14th.
Some say he couldn't have eaten the passover and be the sacrificial lamb which justifies them eating leavened to represent his body.
Could you explain the high Shabbat then because this makes no sense. Are we to treat the high Shabbat like any other day? Where the people breaking the high Shabbat just to have Yeshua crucified? How can you have a high Shabbat and also a cruxifixction? Also they aren't to leave the house based on exodus since they didn't leave the house why did they leave the house? Mostly how does a high Shabbat works based on this concept
Passover is on the night beginning the 14th. The High Sabbath is on the 15th. They are separated by the daylight portion of the 14th day. The last supper took place at the beginning of the 14th, then Yeshua was crucified on the afternoon of the 14th (the preparation for the High Sabbath), and buried just before the High Sabbath began.
UNLEARN the lies makes sense. However still remains why would they leave the house to go pray up in the mountain. Aren't they supposed to stay in the house as it says in exodus?
I am also making a video that will address some of the most common objections to the Last Supper being a Passover.
Dont bother because you have it wrong dude.
@@jeezed2950
I'm starting to thing so too... 119 ministries' video on this makes way more sense of the timeline presented in the Bible.
Lex has yet to site any proof that shows that the Pharisees kept the Passover a day late. *Besides if the Passover really was on the 14th at the beginning of the day when would the 1st lamb (Exodus **29:38**) be killed?*
@@gravityfallscanada; hey, I'm in Ontario.
119 makes some very good points to be sure, as does Unlearn. However, it's you that needs to be satisfied and you who needs to test all things. Start by studying Ex. 12, the first Passover. Pay close attention to the word "twilight".
Shalom
Knowledge aawaits
I agree with this video but I struggle with one thing still. Where was the Pesach lamb slaughtered and burnt? That's my only hang up with it.
The Gospel writers did not feel that information was important to mention, so they did not include it.
Psalm 40 6.
It was not the Passover meal because the bread they ate at the last supper was ordinary bread, not unleavened bread. Check it out in Strong's concordance G106 is azymos (unleavened), but G740 (artos) is ordinary raised bread which was eaten at the last supper, and whenever believers met and broke bread in the New Testament. Jesus was the Passover lamb that died at that time.
You said it right there at the End he brought the New Covenent and the only thing he says remember is his last Supper wouldn't that be what we Christians should be remember his resurrection and holy communion wether you use that word or not!!
You lost me. Yeshua and His disciples were eating Passover, and during the Passover He takes the Passover bread and says this is my body, and then He took the Passover wine and said this is my blood, then He commanded His followers to do this (Passover) in remembrance of Him.
How exactly do you make the leap from Biblical Passover to a Catholic communion?
Also, He instructed them to proclaim His death, His broken body and poured out blood. He did not tell them to institute an Easter sunrise service. He said to keep Passover in remembrance of His sacrifice.
Yeshua died as Passover lamb; The Passion week is not for him to have Passover meal (Seder). Not a single text in the N.T. say he had Passover meal before His deal. He died on Abib 14 Passover day, Pilate's sentencing was Abib 13 (around midday), Last Supper was on Abib 12. Resurrection was Abib 16 (dawn). 'Day' in the bible is that which begins at dawn, not at sunset.
Is it possible that those who followed Pharisaical Judaism - that Yeshua often pointed out was in error - WERE keeping Passover (not according to God's instruction in Exodus 12 and elsewhere) on the 15th at the temple but many in the land were keeping the biblical Passover on the 14th in their homes? At any rate, God himself who gave the instructions, when come in the flesh, would certainly be consistent and obey his own commands regarding the Passover.
Many have erroneously equated the command in Exodus 12:6 to keep the Passover lambs “until the fourteenth” and slay them “at even” with the command in Exodus 12:18 to observe the Feast of Unleavened Bread “on the fourteenth day of the month at even.” But understanding these two commands in the Hebrew text show they do not refer to the same time of day on the fourteenth.
In Exodus 12:6, the words “at even” are translated from bin e-orbim (ben ha arbayim), (literally between the evenings) which occurs at the beginning of the 14th.
In Exodus 12:18, the words “at even” are translated from b'orb (ba erev), and refer to the end of the 14th at sunset.
This is further proof that the 14th from sunset to sunset is the Passover day and the 15th from sunset to sunset is the 1st day of Unleavened Bread. There is no confusion when one begins with the scripture and applies exegesis. Confusion always arises when people begin with a human idea (perhaps with good intention or not and remember the father of lies loves to twist scripture) and apply eisegesis.
Finally Levitcus 23:32 clearly states a Sabbath is from sunset (erev) to sunset (erev). In fact every day runs from sunset to sunset. Always begin with scripture and let other scriptures clarify and expound. Don't rely on Catholic/Protestant Priests of Pharisaical Judaic Rabbis who teach commandments and traditions of men instead of the commands of God.
I agree totally, 👍.
The Lord;s supper was on Tuesday evening where he washed the disciples feet. Afterwards Jesus went to the garden to pray. He KNEW he was to BE THE PASSOVER LAMB. prayed from 6 - 9 am) when he was taken by the mob. That would have been on wednesday morning AM on the 14th of Nisan) Wednesday. His trial ended with him being put on the cross at 9 am - he died at 3:00 pm WHEN THE LAMBS were Killed!. That is WHY he is called our passover lamb. IF he had ate the passover meal late on Wednesday (preparation day) and then face the trial his crucification would have been on the DAY OF UNLEAVEN BREAD Thursday - a DAY of rest no work was to be done. He could NOT have ate the passover meal and been the passover lamb. During the Last Supper he TOLD Judas to do what he must. Judus went to petrayed him during the course of the last supper. There is no mention of a cooked Lamb, or bitter herbs. Did the disciples prepare the Lamb on a Tuesday the 13th before the 14th of Nisan? I believe you are dead wrong in more ways than one!!!
There is one (most important) thing that you do not even address here, brother. In Jerusalem, aren't ALL the Passover lambs sacrificed by the Levitical Priests at the Temple? How then does THE Passover Lamb eat A passover lamb the day before He offers Himself as THE Passover Lamb...in perfect fulfillment of the rehearsal (moed) of Pesach (Passover)?
Aren't you also forgetting to mention the feast of the Firstborn?
This is particularly poignant and very interesting when we consider the prophecy of Ephraim-My-firstborn (of the Spirit) who KNOWS MESSIAH when He returns and is happy as with wine in Zechariah10:7 vs 12:10 which prophesies Judah will NOT know Him and mourn AS FOR AN ONLY SON when Messiah is finally recognized as the Passover LAMB OF YHVH when He returns as the King of kings! This is confirmed by the Ezekiel 37 "two sticks" of Ephraim OR Judah that any tribe or nation can "associate with."
In any case, we are wise to be honest...whether mistaken or not! ")
Shalom bshem Yeshua HaMashiach tsidkenu †
(Jer23:6)
The Passover lamp did not presents Himself the day after. The 14th 06:00PM (Sun down) marked the start of Passover. The next day (that is the 15th on our calender)06:00AM till 06:00PM marked the end of the 14th.
Genesis tells us that God created night and day
When in doubt go back to the instructions in TORAH I say. Lev 23:5 ‘In the first month, on the fourteenth day of the month, between the evenings, is the Passover to יהוה. Now if you are going to eat the Passover rememberance meal on the evening of the 13/14 then that means that you HAVE to slaughter the lamb between the evenings on the 13th, thus breaking the distinct command to to keep it on the 14th. I see you did not address the issue of WHEN between the evings is ON the 14th.
So Jesus was crucified on the true Sabbath during Passover ( Saturday) and was resurrected on Wednesday because he was 3 days and nights in the earth. So Good Friday and "Easter" are on the wrong days.
Searth for the Qumran calendar.
He didn’t address the verse that states the pesach has to be eaten on the 15th though, plus the word protos like he said can be used in the synoptic gospels to show that the pesach had not begun until after Yeshua died. The only argument he makes I can’t seem to refute yet is how the gospels clearly say Yeshua had them prepare the pesach meal, which is strange because Yeshua hadn’t died yet and He is the meal himself. But yet he said this is my body and my blood, so In a weird way maybe the right answer is both are true. Maybe they did eat the pesach on the 14th in the bread and wine(body and blood) of Yeshua. Yet they also ate the normal pesach on the 15th as prescribed in the Torah.
The only think I find strange about this explanation is they technically don’t fulfill the Torah by eating Yeshuas pesach on the 14th, but maybe I’m missing something.
I just know the pesach must be eaten on the 15th, as Torah clearly states. So I wonder why our friend here didn’t mention that verse, and puts more weight on the synoptic Gospels rather than the Torah. Especially when the synoptic gospels if translated slightly differently can 90% accommodate the Torah without contradiction.
"Also on the tenth day of this seventh month there shall be a day of atonement: it shall be an holy convocation unto you; and ye shall afflict your souls, and offer an offering made by fire unto the Lord.
It shall be unto you a sabbath of rest, and ye shall afflict your souls: in the ninth day of the month at even, from even unto even, shall ye celebrate your sabbath."
Leviticus 23:27, 32 KJV
According to this, Atonement is on the 10th of Nisan, but it says, "in the ninth day of the month at evening, from evening to evening". So, that's the 10th day.
So, when it says this,
"In the fourteenth day of the first month at even is the Lord's passover.
And on the fifteenth day of the same month is the feast of unleavened bread unto the Lord : seven days ye must eat unleavened bread."
Leviticus 23:5-6 KJV
It makes me think it's the 14th day at even, from even to even, which would actually be the 15th day of Nisan, which is also what Google says, if you Google which day Passover is on. It does not say the 14th of Nisan (not that Google is any kind of authority).
Also, Passover is supposed to be on the full moon, if I'm not mistaken...
The 15th of Nisan is on March 28th, this year, starting at sundown, and is also the full moon.
So, it is most likely actually on Nisan 14, at sundown, from even to even, meaning the 15th of Nisan. Seems to line up, Biblically, as well as lining up with the lunar calendar, and the full moon.
The Passover Lords Supper was the fulfillment of the Lords Passover Supper. For Christ our Passover Lamb has been sacrificed 1 Corinthians 5:7. There is only one perfect sacrifice and one continuous celebration supper until Jesus returns. Israel participated in the Passover Supper by eating of the Lamb and applying the cup.We get the same benefits as Israel did by eating the Passover bread and cup which is health and protection etc.When Israeli ate the Passover Lamb And applied the cup it was imputed to them that they were participating in the future Calvary sacrifice. When we eat the Passover bread and apply the cup then we get the same benefits and greater because we are under a better covenant.and we are participating in Jesus Calvary sacrifice.
Jesus prepares a table before us in the presence of our enemies (sickness,diseases). The early believers participated in the Lords Supper daily from house to house Acts 2:41-46.
I now have great video teachings on the Lords Supper by Sean Rath on my youtube channel. The titles of the videos are Participate with me in the Lords Supper by Sean Rath and the Passover Lords Supper by Sean Rath. Kindly subscribe share and comment and participate with me in the Lords Supper in Jesus name
❤If we go with John alone, it all make sense. The preparation day for the festival of the unleavend bread and the Passover day are the same.
The first day of the unleavend bread is on the 15th, that is a high sabbath.
Seventh day of the unleavend bread is on the 21st, that is a high sabbath too.
Yahusha is the Passover lamb.
They not ate passover, becase they ate bread and wine.. Not unleavend bread and lamb.
They mistransalated many things.