The Last Samurai - The True Story

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 вер 2010
  • You want more about French History ? Follow this link:
    / thecajuncutthroat
    VIDEO:
    The story of Jules Brunet, who inspired the character of Nathan Algren, played by Tom Cruise in the 2003 movie "the Last Samurai".
    The French officer Jules Brunet played an active role during the Boshin War, leading the rebellion against the Imperial Nippon, in 1868-69.
    "A revolution is forcing the Military Mission to return to France. Alone I stay, alone I wish to continue, under new conditions, the results obtained by the Mission, together with the Party of the North, which is the party favorable to France in Japan. Soon a reaction will take place, and the Daimyos of the North have offered me to be its soul".
    - Jules Brunet, Letter to Napoleon III
    en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jules_Br...
    For more videos about History of France :
    / thecajuncutthroat
    Jules Brunet fut était un officier français qui a inspiré le personnage du Capitaine Nathan Algren dans Le Dernier Samurai.
    fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jules_Br...
  • Фільми й анімація

КОМЕНТАРІ • 2 тис.

  • @felixblanchard7349
    @felixblanchard7349 3 роки тому +235

    One of my ancestor, Léonce Verny was also a French engineer from Polytechnique that went to Japan to modernize it's Navy and built the port of Yokosuka, he still have a statue of him there and a park name after his name in the city of Yokosuka. Japan know how to honour the men and women that helped them. Thank you to present the role of thoose men, and thank you Japan to still honouring their memory.

    • @robguyton3577
      @robguyton3577 3 роки тому +17

      Thank you Felix, for your beautiful words.

    • @user-qh2vt2hm7i
      @user-qh2vt2hm7i Рік тому +16

      日仏関係の益々の発展を祈ります。日本万歳!フランス万歳!

    • @user-cp3ip3rw7r
      @user-cp3ip3rw7r 10 місяців тому +2

      ヴェルニーの子孫て凄いな。。
      横須賀製鉄所や横須賀海軍造船所を建設した人やろ。

    • @Yata-no-Garasu
      @Yata-no-Garasu 5 місяців тому +3

      He greeted Emperor Meiji at the Imperial Palace in Tokyo. At that time, it was difficult for even Japanese people to meet the emperor. Your ancestors achieved a great business in Japan

  • @patriciahayes7315
    @patriciahayes7315 3 роки тому +152

    I never knew the French were that involved in Japanese matters. So educational! Thanks for the video! :)

    • @raymondfrye5017
      @raymondfrye5017 2 роки тому +17

      The Japanese system of government is French

    • @trav2190
      @trav2190 2 роки тому

      They had there hands in many pies until germans ko them down

    • @tigernotwoods914
      @tigernotwoods914 2 роки тому +6

      @@raymondfrye5017 yup. Japanese law and it’s court system is based on the napoleonic code

    • @daniel_sc1024
      @daniel_sc1024 2 роки тому +8

      @@raymondfrye5017 Actually, it isn't. A government commission was set up to study constitutional governments. The U.S. Constitution was rejected as too liberal. The French and Spanish were rejected as tending more towards despotism. The Reichstag and legal system of Prussia proved to be the most useful to the Constitutional Study Mission. The British system was also useful, but they felt it gave too much power to parliament. "Ito Hirobumi's Constitutional Study Mission to Europe" National Diet Library, Japan.

    • @raymondfrye5017
      @raymondfrye5017 2 роки тому

      @@daniel_sc1024 Thanx.

  • @gkpompia
    @gkpompia 8 років тому +1201

    The real story is much more fascinating than the one in "Last Samurai". I think that the French and Japanese film-makers should consider making a film based on the the real historical facts and protagonists of this story.

    • @cpt.kisaragi1200
      @cpt.kisaragi1200 8 років тому +7

      ikr

    • @arthurvb2057
      @arthurvb2057 8 років тому +123

      The movie "the last samurai" is about the satsuma rebellion which took place in 1877, what you see in this video is the boshin war, which was in 1868, do not get them confused. The boshin war was the emperor vs the shogun, it was not "modern warfare vs tradition", as both sides used new military technology to win. The rebellion, seen in "the last samurai", is a bit more complicated, as samurais started to loose influence through new government reforms, the satsuma clan revolted, and although they did use traditional weapons, they also used guns, unlike the movie presents it.

    • @CottonBoxer
      @CottonBoxer 8 років тому +6

      i agree, but don't hold ur breath

    • @bremCZ
      @bremCZ 8 років тому +37

      Actually the movie is a combination of both the Satsuma rebellion and the Boshin war. But inverts reality and completely changes the real reason for the war. Meiji called for revocation of the sumptuary laws and this meant that the Samurai were less important, and they didnt like it. Basically the Samurai were upper class and the new govt wanted less class distinction and less preferential treatment. The Samurai were fighting to maintain the opulence, not for justice.

    • @CottonBoxer
      @CottonBoxer 8 років тому +17

      no one like to relinquish power.prestige, or privilege once they enjoy it. That is why the 1% continues to act as they do...grrr

  • @Kiritsun
    @Kiritsun 5 років тому +19

    The history of France and Japan is incredibly similar and linked despite their differences and their geographical distance.

    • @stynershiner1854
      @stynershiner1854 4 роки тому +1

      It is more that England and Japan's culture and history are similar.

  • @darfinger2
    @darfinger2 9 років тому +306

    Man I'm french and i wanted to thank you for this video, sadly it's true that everybody in France forgot his name, i only discovered him recently, he became the people i'm the most proud of in French History, and this video that you made is really a great honor. So thank you so much :)

    • @TwoFistsOneHalleluja
      @TwoFistsOneHalleluja 8 років тому +7

      +darfinger2 My fav is Bertrand Du Guesclin, aka "The Black Dog of Brocéliande". Even the name is badass.

    • @darfinger2
      @darfinger2 8 років тому +4

      The name is really bad ass indeed :o however i have no clue on who he is, i'll do some research on him :)

    • @corsehaigazia
      @corsehaigazia 6 років тому +9

      je n'ai pas oublier son nom Jules Brunet un homme d'honneur

    • @paulmucha4833
      @paulmucha4833 5 років тому +18

      We have the same issue in Canada. Not enough recognition of the French,Native Indians and settlers whom were the real heroes in building our country!

    • @lahire4943
      @lahire4943 5 років тому +7

      @@paulmucha4833 When you want to suppress a people, suppress its roots.

  • @milvipes
    @milvipes 5 років тому +517

    Tell me how he died.
    I'll tell you how he lived.

  • @josereyesburgos4548
    @josereyesburgos4548 4 роки тому +16

    Hello there. I do really thank you for this video. Now, besides I learned more about the real story of "the last samurai", i can tell you proudly this man was in my country.
    I'm Mexican. France invaded Mexico from 1862 to 1867, so Jules was here, fighting against our army. What an honor.

    • @fotiskoutsoupas7787
      @fotiskoutsoupas7787 3 роки тому

      ok i lost you!!! you feel honor for someone who invade you country and kill your people back then??? if that is honor you people are far from logic....

    • @jmbig
      @jmbig 3 роки тому +8

      @@fotiskoutsoupas7787 I understand that because it is an honor to fight against courageous soldiers. And even today, the Mexican army presents arms in front of the Camaron monument where less than 60 French soldiers have resisted more than 2000 Mexican soldiers, they are practically all dead except the last 5 who charged with the bayonet despite their injuries, and that Mexicans spared

    • @jmbig
      @jmbig 3 роки тому +3

      I understand that because it is an honor to fight against courageous soldiers. And even today, the Mexican army presents arms in front of the Camaron monument where less than 60 French soldiers have resisted more than 2000 Mexican soldiers, they are practically all dead except the last 5 who charged with the bayonet despite their injuries, and that Mexicans spared

  • @mrgoob76
    @mrgoob76 11 років тому +19

    i may not be french but as time goes on i have more and more respect for them, with stuff like this, and the fact that the french helped the US in the revolutionary war. then gifted the statue of liberty to the states when the US was first starting out. You don't hear it very often of other countries doing that, and for that i salute them fully

  • @setsuna7618
    @setsuna7618 3 роки тому +30

    We need anime version of Jules Brunet's journey. This is such an awesome history stuff

  • @cheekibreeki7058
    @cheekibreeki7058 8 років тому +87

    Damn that cry war at 4:10 It's very powerful that gave me chills down my spine!!

    • @haloborn6785
      @haloborn6785 8 років тому +5

      woah it gave me chills too! xd

    • @TheHalo2fan
      @TheHalo2fan 8 років тому +1

      That war cry go outside and act like a samurai hahaha

    • @TheHalo2fan
      @TheHalo2fan 8 років тому +1

      made me*

    • @drg8687
      @drg8687 7 років тому +1

      It's pretty intense and kind of comes out of no where, but it's awesome.

    • @drg8687
      @drg8687 7 років тому +13

      Also, 99% certain it's the song from The Last Samurai.

  • @markarnold2257
    @markarnold2257 4 роки тому +157

    To be fair, French history is vast and rich with stories like this.

    • @cloudman8911
      @cloudman8911 4 роки тому +7

      Yeah specially losing against the English or betraying native americans.

    • @benjaminlucas9991
      @benjaminlucas9991 4 роки тому +24

      scalping forever Do you want us to talk about Guillaume the conqueror, the invasion of the england, the Kings of england were French, 40% of words in english langage comes from french language and suprematie of France in Europe for many centuries?
      And France participated in 185 battles, won 132 battles, lose 43 and 10 was indecisive, the last 800 years. France won the most battles in the world.
      And do you know the 100 years war or Napoléon ?

    • @benjaminlucas9991
      @benjaminlucas9991 4 роки тому +15

      scalping forever If the history of english was Better and more glorious than french history, the americans would not change the french history to make the english or american history better in the movies ( dunkirk, the king on netflix, the Last samurai, ect...)

    • @bobinounet4767
      @bobinounet4767 3 роки тому +15

      @@cloudman8911 you are that one kid missing school right ?

    • @cloudman8911
      @cloudman8911 3 роки тому +1

      @@bobinounet4767 no. You don t like facts?

  • @mikimiyazaki
    @mikimiyazaki 5 років тому +21

    My father is close to 80 and his grandfather was a Feudal Lord, and my father's side were all samurai. He still has the hilt of a katana that's been in my family for hundreds of years. He showed it to me once, it was amazingly still in good condition other than several nick's and a few deep gouges. I rented the movie years ago and immediately knew who he was and said he's greatly respected and revered in Japan, which is a remarkable trait for a foreigner especially back then to be accepted and admired in Feudal Japan.

    • @unisic3789
      @unisic3789 3 роки тому +2

      that's really interesting. Is there any legacy of the samourai's time in the modern japan?

  • @user_____M
    @user_____M 4 роки тому +57

    I was thinking it was weird, in the movie, to hire US experts when the French and Prussians were far more famous, they even helped train the US army during the independence war.

    • @andrewsmith9174
      @andrewsmith9174 3 роки тому +7

      That was 100 years in difference. The USA at this time was the rising economic power in the world until the Civil War put the country on pause.

    • @MH-kc1eu
      @MH-kc1eu 3 роки тому +1

      Nope, the prussians aided the UK fighting against America, there was only one French general sent by king Louis to help train some Americans.

    • @bizybliztaverage9414
      @bizybliztaverage9414 3 роки тому

      @@MH-kc1eu No, everyone in Europe hates their gut, ally my arse

    • @daniel_sc1024
      @daniel_sc1024 2 роки тому

      @@MH-kc1eu I think you are thinking about the Hessian mercenaries hired by George III. Prussia remained neutral during the American Revolution. Prior to that war, Prussia had been allied with Great Britain against France, but GB changed their foreign policy in favor of France, and Frederick the Great felt betrayed. America did try to get Prussia to recognize them and enter into a treaty during the Revolution, but Frederick was weary of antagonizing England. He did allow them to buy Prussian arms through a third party, though.
      A former Prussian army captain, Baron Frederick Wilhelm von Steuben, was instrumental in training Washington's Continental Army during the Revolutionary War.

    • @danemon8423
      @danemon8423 Рік тому

      @@MH-kc1eu the french shipped guns, canons, powder and uniforms. And sent almost 20 000 men when it entered the conflict militarly. Prussia remained neutral. And let's not forget the spanish

  • @Tifredi
    @Tifredi 7 років тому +36

    I own the original 1870 book where this story was published, "Le Tour du Monde" it's a collection of travel stories of French people around the world. The one who told this story was Eugène Collache, a subordinate of brunet. He was actually the swordman who fought along with the Shinsengumi. He is the French man in samurai outfit represented on the drawing in your video. Brunet was a modern military man. Collache was more of a traditional swordman. He planned to steal the ships of the emperor "pirate style" with the help of the samurais of the Shinsengumi. But their boat was caught in a typhoon between Hakodate and the Miyako bay ... They arrived too late at Miyako bay and the boats were ready to sail and filled with the entire army. Thus they failed their commando mission ... The samurais of the Shinsengumi decided to surrender. Collache refused but was authorized to keep his sword until they brought him to prison. In Edo, he was judged and condemned to death. When he was called from his cell he thought his last day had come, he said good by to his japanese brother in arms ... and left the prison with the conviction he would be beheaded soon ... But at the exit, his French Brother in arms were waiting for him on a boat, diplomacy had worked, and he would not be condemned to death, but would never be able to come to Japan ever again. Back in France, he published his 10 pages story in the periodical "Le Tour du Monde." It seems the illustrations were also based on his drawings.
    I did some research about it and, his Japanese brothers in arms, also sentenced to death, were finally not executed either ... They were the elite samuraï of the Shogun's police after all ...

  • @nome8705
    @nome8705 3 роки тому +16

    He is one of the renouwned and respected French figures in Japan, who loved the Samurai spirit and lived in the midst of turbulent times in the modern history of the nation.

  • @akajd5907
    @akajd5907 3 роки тому +8

    ✊🏼/🇯🇵 Fascinating, thank you for posting.
    "They say Japan was made by a sword. They say the old gods dipped a cold blade into the ocean, and when they pulled it out four perfect drops fell back into the sea, and those drops became the islands of Japan."

  • @jetaddicted
    @jetaddicted 3 роки тому +53

    The French are said to be quite proud of their culture, yet there are two places they treat with utmost respect, on this subject: Italy and Japan.
    I’d even call it a fascination.
    We are five in my (French) family to speak Japanese to some extent, me being the worst, a cousin is a graduate in this language, my three nephews, manga addicts, can hold a conversation quite fairly.

    • @YK36Deadezio
      @YK36Deadezio 2 роки тому

      Malheureusement aujourd’hui les français fièrent de leur culture, etc.... se font traiter de facho, raciste, etc... car les wokes veulent imposer une culture complètement opposé à la France... en France.

  • @hellsing507
    @hellsing507 9 років тому +44

    RIP Jules you where a great warrior may your name be remembered forever.

  • @autumnhomer9786
    @autumnhomer9786 9 років тому +110

    Thank you for the history lesson. Have a great week.

  • @MarekUtd
    @MarekUtd 9 років тому +100

    What an amazing and courageous man Brunet was!!!
    Wow! Just wow!!!

  • @theemperorofman6740
    @theemperorofman6740 8 років тому +36

    "The greatest story never told" - more knowledge in that documentary than 10 years of television!

  • @Sporelo
    @Sporelo 9 років тому +338

    This is a fascinating story, but in reality the Last Samurai is actually based upon the Satsuma Rebellion which took place ten years after the end of the Boshin war, and was led by Saigo Takamori, who funny enough led the Imperial forces to victory in the Boshin war, but when swords were outlawed on the streets of Japan and Samurai were mistreated by police, they took up arms and the Last of the samurai fought to the last man against the Imperialists at the battle Shiroyama.

    • @TheGuyfromValhalla
      @TheGuyfromValhalla 6 років тому +16

      Gypsy Ace *sabaton intensifies*

    • @cyncus1
      @cyncus1 6 років тому +30

      Absolutely correct!! People of Satsuma which is modern day Kyushu is famous for doing their part for Japanese history and for being a warrior state, specifically the Shimazu clan.

    • @nicksmith-rz2dl
      @nicksmith-rz2dl 6 років тому +2

      And q sabaton

    • @talesnevertold
      @talesnevertold 6 років тому

      Gypsy Ace a

    • @Cpcp9696
      @Cpcp9696 5 років тому +3

      This is the right comment..

  • @umarfaruqui308
    @umarfaruqui308 10 місяців тому +3

    Jules was a great warrior by most historical accounts. He built his reputation on the battlefield in Mexico before he continued his exploits in Japan. The fact he was allowed to join the military soon after his return to Paris in 1870 shows the French government was not particularly upset with him. He went on to fight in the Franco-Prussian war and eventually retired as a General.

  • @VisionsDark
    @VisionsDark 6 років тому +5

    Well done mate, the shout at 4:10 timed with the story of the last stand gave me goosebumps 😀

  • @Ghost-ed2sb
    @Ghost-ed2sb 5 років тому +3

    Moved me To tears such a Beautiful story And all inspiring

  • @hayastan4779
    @hayastan4779 5 років тому +312

    For those complaining about the movie try and remember that Hollywood is in the money making business.

    • @STEVEPOKE
      @STEVEPOKE 5 років тому +5

      True

    • @skrktk5675
      @skrktk5675 4 роки тому +33

      And it was still a great movie

    • @eick474
      @eick474 3 роки тому +7

      It was a great Movie, but as always US always take all the glory transforming real history in pièces...boring!!!

    • @Imblu95
      @Imblu95 3 роки тому +1

      @@eick474 still a great movie

    • @EnFyr
      @EnFyr 3 роки тому +9

      I don't care what people say. That movie is a masterpiece. And Zimmer's soundtrack is legendary.

  • @thomasmorris9022
    @thomasmorris9022 9 років тому +24

    Wow! Not really a samurai but - damn that is truly amazing - thanks for that contribution to my knowledge!

  • @adumbassroomba
    @adumbassroomba 3 роки тому +7

    Amazing video talking about the Boshin War my friend. It is a really important part of history of Japan as a nation, but I thought that The Last Samurai was actually based in the Satsuma rebellion, a few years after the Boshin War ended. Still an amazing video, explains really well the tales of an era of rapid change and the forging of a new Empire

  • @MarsheyTV
    @MarsheyTV 10 років тому +95

    The bodies of the Samurai are gone. But the Samurai way of life still remains. Long live Bushido and all that the Samurai stood for.

    • @DSB_SF
      @DSB_SF 9 років тому +21

      They stood for feudalism. Nothing more. The privilege of living a parasitic life off of the peasants whilst fighting and plotting for more power and privileges from the other clans. Nothing different or special from any other feudal landowning class in history, apart from the over-romantization of it by uneducated fanboys who never opened an actual historical book in their lives. Anime and hollywood isn't education...

    • @ZER0Artdiary
      @ZER0Artdiary 9 років тому +1

      Jag giello Japanese people need to be more educated and more loving towards World history and their country, or if it's not they would be sucks at everything. Japanese people should be more educate themselves and helping each others (for this race). They must be prepare at all cost (24 hours) for Everything, it is to avoid before SHITS going to be happening again and again but in different days made by the enemies. The Men is made by the quality of the enemies, but the Foolish humans is made by the influences of Lucifer&Satans/Anti God.

    • @DSB_SF
      @DSB_SF 9 років тому +10

      ZER0Artdiary Your statement made zero sense. It's like random words put together. Please try using google translate or some other programme.

    • @nagyzoli
      @nagyzoli 8 років тому +1

      +Jag giello Bushido has nothing to do with plotting for power. Read friend, you are the uneducated one. www.artofmanliness.com/2008/09/14/the-bushido-code-the-eight-virtues-of-the-samurai/ Bushido teaches mercy, determination, the duty of self-education and above all honor.

    • @DSB_SF
      @DSB_SF 8 років тому +6

      nagy zoli A lot of ideologies teach these things, it's the actions of the people that matter. Samurai acted like power-hungry, barbarous, cruel and sadistic gangsters, who burned the country numerous times for the sake of power and exploited the peasants to the brink of famine. They were no different than the modern organised crime, with Daymios = bosses and the samurai = the mobsters, who racketeer the peasants and kill each other for power. The ammount of "noble" bullshit they claimed they follow in Bushido is irrelevant when they acted the way they did.

  • @Adulars
    @Adulars 7 років тому +66

    he made me so proud to be French

    • @messire9837
      @messire9837 5 років тому +5

      M T:
      You wanna be even prouder than Steven? Check out Bayard / Garigliano bridge. Bayard wasn't 300 hundred in phalanx formation against an army on the Italian border. He was only just the one.

    • @brandonbentley8532
      @brandonbentley8532 5 років тому +2

      France like any country has great heros both male and female.

    • @Brixstoned
      @Brixstoned 4 роки тому +1

      proud but still idiots😂

    • @taylormyers237
      @taylormyers237 4 роки тому +3

      And William Adams, the English samurai made me happy to be English

    • @nl396
      @nl396 3 роки тому

      @@Brixstoned Okay boomer

  • @peterlaikc
    @peterlaikc 3 роки тому

    Applause to the music editor. A very nice story telling approach with most appropriate mood expressions.

  • @choister420
    @choister420 11 років тому +1

    This was great, thank you for the time you gave into making it.

  • @mithweth
    @mithweth 11 років тому +8

    I think there's plenty of mistakes. As a French man, I can say that Jules Brunet's not longer known in France but I recently went to Hokkaido (precisely Hakodate) and the most well-known "Last Samurai"'s name is Toshizo Hijikata. Jules Brunet appears on only one photo in the whole museums. Moreover, Brunet's built Goryokaku neither. It was built from 1857 under Iesada Tokugawa's reign.

  • @user-gx7df8ji1y
    @user-gx7df8ji1y 4 роки тому +29

    I will disagree that Japanese people know this guy. Even my friends who are guides in Hokkaido never knew him. This is really nice and informative. Thank you. As I am a professional guide and have lived here in Japan for many, many years, I will continue to tell his story. I agree with the person that stated that this story is more fascinating. I winder if he drank sake...... lol

    • @Prathynan
      @Prathynan 3 роки тому

      Which country you're?

    • @user-gx7df8ji1y
      @user-gx7df8ji1y 3 роки тому

      @@Prathynan Japan 38 years.

    • @user-gx7df8ji1y
      @user-gx7df8ji1y 3 роки тому

      @@Prathynan Japan

    • @kerrygamer9359
      @kerrygamer9359 3 роки тому

      @@user-gx7df8ji1y no, location city your live he saying

    • @スキピオ
      @スキピオ 3 роки тому +3

      大阪出身の私でも、この人の話は知ってるんですが・・・。

  • @raphaeln.1483
    @raphaeln.1483 5 років тому +1

    Merci pour cette excellente video-hommage 👍

  • @kaanarslan9270
    @kaanarslan9270 Рік тому +1

    Great video, every now and then 8 come back to watch it again and I'd like to honor jules brunet for his courage.

  • @danielgonzalez2042
    @danielgonzalez2042 8 років тому +7

    fascinating story. thanks for sharing

  • @mzambo666
    @mzambo666 10 років тому +4

    What a great video thank you so much! Dōmo arigatō!

  • @michaelglucksman147
    @michaelglucksman147 7 років тому

    Very interesting. I loved the movie and now I love the real story even more. Thank you for this post!

  • @Alex13501
    @Alex13501 7 років тому +1

    The true stories from the history will be always the most touching and epic.

  • @Japonicasian
    @Japonicasian 3 роки тому +5

    I got to admit these guys are the real samourais. big respect from Japan

  • @robg521
    @robg521 6 років тому +278

    As usual, Hollywood changing history to depict an all American hero.
    I still enjoyed the movie though. 😕

    • @ianburns6218
      @ianburns6218 3 роки тому +3

      All American anti-hero

    • @Babushka_82
      @Babushka_82 3 роки тому +6

      The movie wasn't famous because they was telling the truth about Red Indian, which Hollywood hated..
      for example Marlon Brando didn't came to collect the Oscar and he sent a red Indian lady to represent him with the speech about the red Indian and most of crowd was disliking her.
      This was my thought..

    • @hapaharley1706
      @hapaharley1706 3 роки тому +2

      *white hero

    • @Jack-xy4fy
      @Jack-xy4fy 3 роки тому +11

      If the movie had been made in French you wouldnt have ever seen it lol

    • @Itachi951000
      @Itachi951000 3 роки тому +9

      @@Jack-xy4fy Nice strawman. They could have made the character Tom Cruise played and his men French to actually stay true to history was the point. They absolutely had to make him a Yank though. Typical! lmao

  • @marykathleensapp6937
    @marykathleensapp6937 6 років тому

    Well done...music was extraordinary and so suited the flow of this video!

  • @HAZE553
    @HAZE553 6 років тому

    Fascinating possibilities with magnificent combinations! Thank you...

  • @sondelanibeja7847
    @sondelanibeja7847 8 років тому +3

    Love and honour. . . .Great inspiring story

  • @steveroger3669
    @steveroger3669 2 роки тому +4

    A real Legend 🇨🇵👍🇯🇵

  • @dasarislavo
    @dasarislavo 10 років тому +2

    just brilliantly done man!

  • @michaelkavanagh932
    @michaelkavanagh932 5 років тому +1

    Brilliant video thanks for this! Great to see the real story behind it

  • @Narcissus7
    @Narcissus7 8 років тому +3

    I was watching this at 3AM and fell asleep around the 2nd minute.
    Then 4:10 came and the soundtrack got so loud I woke up terrified lol. Thanks for the heartattack, goodnight

    • @spitngames6225
      @spitngames6225 8 років тому +1

      same here lol.

    • @selami32
      @selami32 8 років тому +2

      dont sleep next time while watching videos ok?

  • @MishimaYukio17
    @MishimaYukio17 11 років тому +7

    The Emperor looks too young in the film to be the Emperor Meiji of the Satsuma Rebellion. Though the Satsuma Rebellion involved the final significant rebellion in Japanese history, and therefore the "Last Samurai," as it were, the story is definitely based on this Frenchman, just as the film is centred around 'Captrain Algren.'
    I also got the impression, watching the film, that it was set in Japan's isolated northern reaches, and not in the South West (Satsuma Rebellion).

  • @LoneRising
    @LoneRising 9 років тому +1

    This was awesome :) thank you for the video.

  • @CM-zl3fk
    @CM-zl3fk 9 років тому +2

    Wonderful documentary...thanks a lot

  • @blaster1426
    @blaster1426 9 років тому +4

    wow! the true story is even better. thanks for the vid info. more! more!

  • @staceylewis5660
    @staceylewis5660 9 років тому +299

    The true story is more fascinating than the movie. They should have just stuck to the facts. Thank you for the truth.

    • @zims50
      @zims50 8 років тому

      +Buk Lau well said

    • @tokwanang
      @tokwanang 8 років тому +7

      Stacey Lewis 2 different story about shogun and satsuma rebellion , this video about the last shogun , if u watch the last samurai (tom cruise) that happen after 10 year boshin war ! (shogunate\france commander vs emperror\satsuma clan ) ! I make simple for u , the satsuma clan is the last samurai after fall of shogunate , learn more history in wiki

    • @jimo5564
      @jimo5564 6 років тому +3

      Sam Lee, Of course an American movie for the most part is for American audiences. To think otherwise is just stupid. Collect your pennies and make your own move. Wonder love story as well snowflake.

    • @martyvenkman860
      @martyvenkman860 5 років тому +2

      It's fascinating BECAUSE it is a trye story but the movie version is much more entertaining. Plus the movie is a masterpiece, terribly underrated thou.

    • @Jartisann
      @Jartisann 5 років тому

      @@martyvenkman860 i really agree

  • @arphaksad01
    @arphaksad01 6 років тому +1

    Thank you so much for fascinating history lesson.

  • @MrHusseinMoussa
    @MrHusseinMoussa 7 років тому

    Useful information of course. new to me. I also want to note that I like the choice of music cuts in the video. fits well. great work. chapeau! :)

  • @Pomme843
    @Pomme843 10 років тому +7

    GTC1958 "So where did you get the music for this video?? I really love it."
    00:00 A Man's Destiny
    04:54 Journey to the Village
    Both tracks are from Hans Zimmer's soundtrack for the film "The Last Samurai". They can be found on the "Expanded Soundtrack".

  • @camzpras3435
    @camzpras3435 5 років тому +17

    French had some bad ass generals back then

  • @donotneed2250
    @donotneed2250 5 років тому

    I very much appreciate tid bits of history like this. Thanks...

  • @JonnySublime
    @JonnySublime 2 роки тому +1

    Tears in my eyes. A life lived like no other.

  • @christopherwhitney2711
    @christopherwhitney2711 3 роки тому +4

    A true story, a magnificent story

  • @lebarondeminuit3580
    @lebarondeminuit3580 Рік тому +5

    Vive la France, vive le Japon

  • @janegak
    @janegak 10 років тому

    amazing video, love it! very well made.

  • @timhugens8280
    @timhugens8280 7 років тому

    Love that you used the music from the last samurai in parts of your video

  • @flipingboredcritic
    @flipingboredcritic 9 років тому +1292

    Kinda messed up they made him American in the movies.

    • @Briselance
      @Briselance 9 років тому +89

      Well, considering the usually bad reputation of the the French military in the American civilian population, the director and Co. probably thought the US audience wouldn't like the movie as much.

    • @user-vipgxpn
      @user-vipgxpn 9 років тому +168

      Briseur De Lance The French has the longest and most glorious military history in term of battles win/loss and wars win/loss in Europe xD

    • @thekuan7002
      @thekuan7002 8 років тому +71

      +flipingboredcritic in murcah movies if it's not white we turn them white (last airbender, 21). And if they are already white turn them into murcans.

    • @flipingboredcritic
      @flipingboredcritic 8 років тому +9

      Carlo Enad MERICA! XD lol oh yeah the main character in 21 was actually Asian in real life. Merica... Only in a... Merica! XD

    • @thekuan7002
      @thekuan7002 8 років тому +2

      you should check out the video from film theory about forest gump.

  • @robertmiller5217
    @robertmiller5217 6 років тому +6

    "The Last Samurai" with Tom Cruise is one of my favorite movies. I had no idea that the film was based in fact.

  • @Tengaii
    @Tengaii 8 років тому

    Great video! Love the pictures.

  • @diro9655
    @diro9655 3 роки тому +2

    A beautiful piece of history.
    A time better than ours.

  • @kenney9120
    @kenney9120 9 років тому +94

    I saw the movie a few weeks ago and do not approve of the fact that it replaced France with America. The people who fought side by side with the Japanese were French and that is what they should have been in the movie, but movies are always embellished to make them more popular. I prefer documentaries which portray the real story. .

    • @indexelbow
      @indexelbow 9 років тому +21

      Make a movie with an American is not a problem (business, I think). But they should have specified in the generic that the character was inspired from Jules Brunet.

    • @filipvelkov6829
      @filipvelkov6829 9 років тому +4

      *****
      Exactly.

    • @ninoflores2018
      @ninoflores2018 9 років тому

      +Blackmagicboy

    • @nicolasferracci8462
      @nicolasferracci8462 9 років тому +5

      I really enjoyed the movie, and only just discovert that the true story. Im french and to be honest, it doesnt really matter, a movie is a movies, especially that this one does not claim to be a true story. A metion about Jules Brunet could have been done in the generic but it would probably have created more problems. We should be carful about what we beleive throught what we see on screen, and if a story really intrests us, its our job to go look it up. On that matter, you should watch "operation lune" of William Karel(its a french film but a subed version can probably be found). It explicitly shows that you need to be carful about what you beleive and what images can make you beleive.

    • @indexelbow
      @indexelbow 9 років тому +8

      nicolas ferracci
      Ce que tu dis pourrait faire sens si les cultures étaient égales dans la puissance de production d'imaginaire. Ce n'est pas le cas. Quand un héros est assimilé Américain dans un film, il le reste et personne ne fera l'effort d'aller chercher si c'est vrai ou pas. C'est ce qu'on appelle le "soft power" ou le pouvoir de suggestion par la culture populaire. Culture populaire qui, par essence, n'incite pas à la recherche.

  • @michelmariegautier7270
    @michelmariegautier7270 4 роки тому +5

    Merci de rendre un homage aux derniers Samourai pour leur bravoure en ces temps difficiles ou nous perdions tous,nous avons incris un dernier homage dans l'histoire de l'empire; mais il reste toujours quelque chose par les arts.
    vous me trouvez dans la photo à 1'43 tous à droite debout. gloire à l'honneur des Samourai(s).

  • @AlexB-zb4gd
    @AlexB-zb4gd 2 роки тому +1

    Magnifique ! Merci

  • @toddjonathanbradshaw3945
    @toddjonathanbradshaw3945 6 років тому

    Honor is timeless. From age to age. And there are some that remember it and dare to repeat it or mirror that same story again to the very end.

  • @JINATAHISAKAZU
    @JINATAHISAKAZU 9 років тому +19

    日本・フランス国交開始150周年となる2008年に、日仏両国の代表的な人物の記念切手が発売された。ブリュネはその「幕末シリーズ」10人の中に選ばれ 
    彼は、日本で 切手に描かれている。

    • @obewanbenkendoki
      @obewanbenkendoki 9 років тому +2

      Traduction humaine
      Traduire
      ありがとうございました

    • @obewanbenkendoki
      @obewanbenkendoki 9 років тому +1

      Traduction humaine
      Traduire
      長い間の友情・フランコ日本ライブ

    • @obewanbenkendoki
      @obewanbenkendoki 9 років тому +2

      Traduction humaine
      Traduire
      The March 11, 1895, Japan which has just come out of a stressful war "modern" with China, will recall this former "samurai" which contributed to the extinction of the caste to which, by 1876 it had been forbidden to wear the sabre, by raising to the rank of grand officer of the Sacred Treasure of the Mikado.i spoke well of jules BRUNET

    • @phil-sv1on
      @phil-sv1on 5 років тому +2

      The Japanese are particularly appreciated by the French for the refinement of their culture and their sense of honour and panache .

    • @user-ou9ln4vl2n
      @user-ou9ln4vl2n 3 роки тому +1

      ブリュネは有名ですよね。

  • @ahkhan5092
    @ahkhan5092 9 років тому +8

    Highly informative in a dramatic way.

    • @absyahwa7698
      @absyahwa7698 8 років тому

      +Abdul Haleem Khan Khan ALLAHU AKBAR

    • @ALR1275
      @ALR1275 4 роки тому

      A H Khan Highly dramatic in an informative way :)

  • @AtribecalledQ
    @AtribecalledQ 8 років тому

    Very good use of the soundtrack from the movie...I also learned something. well done

  • @JohnHlavaty
    @JohnHlavaty 8 років тому

    Excellent historical storytelling. The problem with history is that we rarely hear anything about the individual dramas that create the whole.

  • @neurodermatitis
    @neurodermatitis 8 років тому +20

    Keep in mind this is a completely different story than the one in the movie. This is during the Boshin War, whereas in the movie, the story happens nearly ten years after the civil war, during the Satsuma Rebellion. The rebellion is led by Saigo Takamori, who in the movie is known by the name Katsumoto and is a former general that led nearly all Imperial victories (both in movie and history). The American soldier is added only to develop the beginning of the story even better, leading into the plot, to the climax and the end. The movie is not about Algren or Katsumoto, its about the respect of the Japanese ancient and longlasting culture.

  • @wongjefx980
    @wongjefx980 7 років тому +6

    How dare you offer history outside of the Hollywood cinematic universe... and with a French guy instead in this UA-cam universe. Tom Cruise will forever be my hero😁

  • @Star-gr4fk
    @Star-gr4fk 6 років тому

    thank you for this video, you did it great!

  • @johnpenn3385
    @johnpenn3385 4 роки тому +2

    Wonderful story; truly heroic.

  • @tonyhawk94
    @tonyhawk94 4 роки тому +71

    USA basically : mocking French for being "cheese eating surrender mokeys", litteraly stealing French heroes to make movies.

    • @NapoleonBonaparde
      @NapoleonBonaparde 4 роки тому +2

      The movie is about the Satsuma rebellion which takes place 7 years after this

    • @vedhilombok9697
      @vedhilombok9697 4 роки тому +1

      Because there's no hero from there, well except Indians

    • @unai_asecas9070
      @unai_asecas9070 3 роки тому

      Is that a Jeremy Clarkson quote?? He’s a Brit

    • @wirelessone2986
      @wirelessone2986 3 роки тому

      Well it's better than stealing Polish hero's

    • @robertborders2228
      @robertborders2228 3 роки тому +3

      Right... Because America is why the French are still speaking French instead of German. Fuckin lop.

  • @negativezero3107
    @negativezero3107 2 роки тому +3

    I think the French surrendering has tarnished them more than they deserve, they were the most powerful military force in the world for a very long time, the USA would not exist without them tbh, it is something as an American I am proud of that we answered the call when they needed us. Side note in WWI the Indian soldiers need more recognition, they had vastly more soldiers fighting for the UK compared to mainland British.

  • @coleburns5497
    @coleburns5497 6 років тому

    Best documentary of anybody in the history of the world Dude, please make more. Because I’m more interested in history!

  • @youenn2180
    @youenn2180 8 років тому +2

    Nom de d... !! I can 't help feeling proud as a frenchman ,such great times ..

  • @Tbonyandsteak
    @Tbonyandsteak 5 років тому +13

    "The man is too strong" Dire Straits
    Who would had thought it was written of real experiences

  • @paulsackley4119
    @paulsackley4119 3 роки тому +3

    Super impressive compilation, and what an interesting life Jules had. Traditional Japanese culture is very fascinating.
    Was a great flick, and amusing the Americans claim credits.
    History is full of more things Americans would prefer to ignore, much like Australia.

  • @ambroiseperret6460
    @ambroiseperret6460 Рік тому

    this video is amazing , such great story should be a movie

  • @healerdragon
    @healerdragon 11 років тому

    This is really cool. I did not know this. Thank you.

  • @willshaolin1
    @willshaolin1 10 років тому +4

    I want to congratulate the initiative for this video! Nice work, very well-done! But if I may say, i'm afraid the shogunal faction during the Boshin War was not in favour to carry on Sakoku. It was the Bakufu itself who oppened the ports under pression of the imperialism more than a decade before! The question of seclusion was already settled at this moment. The Boshin war was a consequence of a couple d'etat. (And sorry for my bad english, it is not my native language)

  • @alexyd.8715
    @alexyd.8715 8 років тому +20

    Beautiful, it's very interessant know one French fought for the last samourais

    • @joshtheavocado2103
      @joshtheavocado2103 8 років тому +1

      samuraus are kinda selfish u know... read a history book instead of anime. jesus.

    • @bremCZ
      @bremCZ 8 років тому +2

      The Samurai were fighting to maintain the class distinction and status. It is is hardly beautiful to fight for a group of people who want to maintain the subjugation of a population who wanted greater equality.

    • @alexyd.8715
      @alexyd.8715 8 років тому

      +JoshTheAvocado And you read a dictionnary dude :)

    • @bremCZ
      @bremCZ 7 років тому +5

      Dude... you misspelled dictionary.

    • @jonyrockstar444
      @jonyrockstar444 7 років тому

      He put in extra N in the word.. you fucking pleb, how does that constitute as spelling the word wrong vs just a typo? an extra letter.. people will do ANYTHING to correct spelling..

  • @ursulapainter5787
    @ursulapainter5787 4 роки тому

    Thank you for this video. It's just sad that some people who commented never paid full attention to all of the facts and then wrote insults to one another based on their own ignorance.

  • @CrazyGuyinThailand
    @CrazyGuyinThailand 11 років тому

    Cool he was French. If the text"This is based on a true story" would have come up the first time I saw the Movie. I would have respected it for ever. Now I found out many years later just clicking around on UA-cam. Thanx uploaded. I guess its time to see it once again, now with an awesome "True Story" feeling.

  • @randolphvictorconstantine7765
    @randolphvictorconstantine7765 9 років тому +4

    Now that is COOL....

  • @varanid9
    @varanid9 7 років тому +41

    The ironic thing is, Hollywood could have made a movie about Frederick Townsend Ward, an American mercenary who trained Chinese troops during the Tai Ping rebellion, instead of fucking up the story of this Frenchman. Typical Hollywood, opportunities missed and mistakes jumped on.

  • @billskelton3701
    @billskelton3701 2 роки тому

    Very interesting and informative. Thank you,

  • @archeryvibes
    @archeryvibes 3 роки тому

    Oh my..thank you for uploading this.. i never knew about him after reading some books about the shinsengumi and the last shogun.. maybe i slipped..

  • @hughcipher6229
    @hughcipher6229 9 років тому +50

    Wow I never knew about this guy.....the movie is highly fictionalized. Tom Cruise plays an American officer

    • @pmzqabel
      @pmzqabel 9 років тому +9

      Your profile picture cracks me up.
      "We buld da peermids nigga fuk u whitey"
      "We pharoah now"

    • @hughcipher6229
      @hughcipher6229 9 років тому +15

      pmzqabel oohhh another internet arse so caught up in his racist delusions he cant resist making a comment on something NOT REMOTELY RELATED TO THE VIDEO. o__0 YOU cant imagine how much you humor me....

    • @gundam12p
      @gundam12p 9 років тому +1

      Hugh Cipher yeah most of hollywood makes small changes.

    • @JINATAHISAKAZU
      @JINATAHISAKAZU 9 років тому +2

      Hugh Cipher 外国人で 初めのサムライは、アフリカ系 です。(First foreign samurai is African )織田信長の家来でした。( It is a subordinate of Nobunaga Oda )弥助と いいます。 (The Yasuke his name) 引用:@2織田信長は、クーデターで 亡くなったのは、惜しまれる。(Nobunaga Oda, and was killed in the coup, be missed.)信長は、能力主義    (Nobunaga Oda = merit-based system )農民も 武士している  「The First Samurai 」 映画を 作ってほしい。

    • @JINATAHISAKAZU
      @JINATAHISAKAZU 9 років тому +1

      JINATAHISAKAZU en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yasuke

  • @akiyoshi0610
    @akiyoshi0610 10 років тому +12

    Very interesting.
    I'm Japanese ,but I didn't know this story.

    • @cloudman8911
      @cloudman8911 4 роки тому +1

      Really? Why? What about Saito and Okita?

    • @hapaharley1706
      @hapaharley1706 3 роки тому

      it's really not a story. Just white people trying to make themselves feel important

    • @felixblanchard7349
      @felixblanchard7349 3 роки тому +2

      @@hapaharley1706 1) That's video is a fact
      2) Your comment is racist
      3) If you are not happy with the west why you are on UA-cam, you make us richer

    • @hapaharley1706
      @hapaharley1706 3 роки тому

      @@felixblanchard7349 your parents named you after a house cat

    • @felixblanchard7349
      @felixblanchard7349 3 роки тому +2

      @@hapaharley1706 1) Félix mean fortunate and happy in Latin
      2) It's the name of dozens of pope and heroes of european History
      3) That have nothing to do with the debate and only prove your lake of argument

  • @willlatino
    @willlatino 10 років тому

    Thank you for providing informative fact!!!

  • @johnshepherd9849
    @johnshepherd9849 4 роки тому

    Great video. Thanks!