Is Scottish Football "A One-Horse Race"?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 12 вер 2024
- Is Scottish football "a one-horse race"? The Journos dive into Scottish football and the current state of top clubs like Rangers, Aberdeen, Hearts, and Hibernian and if they can compete against Celtic FC.
We look at the widening gulf between Scottish teams and European teams at Champions League, Europa League and Europa Conference League level, the challenges of managerial turnover, and the pressures from fans and social media. We also explore the stability of clubs like St Mirren and Kilmarnock under experienced management and strong board support.
We also talk about young managers in the Scottish Premiership and whether they can thrive under pressure, how boardroom decisions influence team success, and what the future holds for Scottish football.
Is Scottish football in decline? Leave a comment below.
#celticfc #rangersfc #spfl
Is Scottish football in decline? Leave a comment below or send us a video - we might feature you on The Football Show or The Journos!
Playing each other 4 times makes it less likely a team outside the Old Firm would have a chance.
they want the money
Let's see if Celtic can continue to keep up with Aberdeen this season before making headlines like this! 🙃🙄
You mean keep up with Celtic 🇮🇪🍀
Teams like Hibs , Hearts, and Aberdeen should be competing for the title every season instead of thinking 3rd place is good enough.
Celtic fan; BR keeps harping on about it and he is right, the league is too small for progression and Rangers are really struggling. They both need to be firing with the Edinburgh clubs, Dons and Dundee to make it at least decent. So there are two options from what I can see, A Northern European Super League with Scandinavia, Belgium etc. The easier and best option and the Rangers fans won't like it, a Scottish and Irish League, 16 teams, ten from Scotland, Belfast, Derry, Dublin(2), Cork, Limerick with a supporting national league system in each country with play-offs. It would be exciting, with fierce rivalries and much room for growth. The infrastructure is almost already there is Ireland through GAA grounds that are not used in the winter. Easily done and good for all 3 leagues. The 11m odd people in Scotland and Ireland would follow and stop supporting the premier league. It is time!
Send us a video about this and we might feature you on The Football Show or The Journos!
@@PLZSoccer Thanks for the response, how do I send you a video, through email?
@@peterquinn7774 if you download the app then go to contact. Let me know if you have any problems and looking forward to seeing it!
Our game has been on life support for over 30 years now
Shock Tim TV
We need a bigger league, and reserve league brought back to help younger players, my opinion is that there to many clubs nothing the spfl is helping
This would just result in the reason why leagues die without sponsors: meaningless games
The reserve league is a must would benefit every club
@@CraigWhyteCSC Young players will only benefit from playing meaningful and competitive matches against seasoned professionals. For me, Reserve Leagues are about as useful as practicing penalties in training: you cannot replicate the pressure and scrutiny of a 'real life' scenario where the outcome matters in front of thousands of baying fans, TV etc
@@exitthelemming145 they'll be coming up against some senior pros coming back from injury etc it'll be a much better standard than the pish there playing in the now
As much as it hurts to say it can’t see any other team than Celtic for the next 20 years the rest of us can’t financially compete with them they are the Man City of Scotland now
Yes it is. We need to dump winter footy, too many call offs, we're up against Euro teams well into their seasons. Get summer footy, shut us down in winter.
Send us a video about this and we might feature you on The Football Show or The Journos!
Playing each other 4 times a year no wonder players don't want to come to Scotland a12 team league
Would love to see a 16 team league but it will never happen as money talks and sky will never accept anything less than 4 old firm games a season which is crazy because it’s a one sided affair most of the time now
Aye. And it's all Celtics fault because they're a well run club.
Shocker that there's only 12 watching your channel at the time of this post.
4mtir
Why not send us a video with your thoughts?
Exactly
Peter a tad off with his assertion that "since 2000 Celtic have been completely dominant". His chronology or blocking timelines of chronology not very astute here. Rangers won 6 titles from 2000-2011, as many as Celtic in the same period. Celtic's utter dominance is very easily defined as being from 2012 onwards.
At moment league is about money, if they make top league bigger then top clubs can bleed on in young players. BUT it might take years to get level back to what it is at moment.
At least it's not the EPL, which is the 'pantomime horse' of football leagues. Our game functions well within our means and population.
Our league is a pantomime the refs are shocking and Celtic are Man City
@kiezorfc8559 how are celtic man city lol?
Ha home growing what club couldn't afford to run a reserve team eh reserve teams was good for bringing players threw but a certain club couldn't afford to
Talking down our game again, only focusing on the top two (hearts had a great run in the season, yes not sustained].
Taking the words (derided at the time) by the ex county manager and letting that set the narrative.
If Aberdeen and hibs don't make the top six doesn't that show its competitive mid table!
Yes and it is glorious
I think Celtic still have a chance!
Celtics dominance will only be broken when we get better prize money or some Arab buys one of the other teams
It’s been a one horse race for years.Scottish football is mince
It's all about Celtic Hail Hail 🇮🇪
The league was far more competitive when it didn’t have rangers. This is a fact. No trebles and no Celtic complete dominance
Celtic were still dominant. So what would you think if rangers and celtic left?
Why is his wife sitting on set????
Can see sky pulling the plug on us they not gonna want to throw money at a one sided old firm game and one sided league difference with England is it’s more competitive yes Man City are dominating it but the title race’s are marginal
Did the English say the same when man united was always winning eh is this all about rangers getting beat nothing said about when rangers was winning 10 in a row was there hail hail gfuy
naw😆
When we won 6-0
The cross border league wouldn't be up for consideration until a European Super League came into being. That said, I do think both Celtic and Rangers would survive in a British League shorn of the top 6/7: Man City, Arsenal, Liverpool, Chelsea, Man Utd, Spurs/Newcastle. Hearts/Hibs and Kilmarnock should survive a British 2nd tier while the rest of the SPL would sit in the 3rd and 4th tiers of British football. If Wrexham can attract multi-million dollar investment from hobbyist sugar daddies, why not a Scottish club outside the Old Firm? (I've been to Wales....)
Celtic would struggle the first few seasons that's a guarantee , don't doubt that. BUT so do every club that gets promoted.. but over space of few years they could compete. Take Chelsea club that's down the road from me, historically they actually dont have massive fan following, even now you could argue its partly the league that helps them. They often had empty seats at champs league games not that long ago. It's all about money, which I think over time Celtic wouldn't have a problem with, it's the initial 2-3 seasons, but a lot of clubs from top 5 leagues would struggle in Eng Prem League, not just Celtic & they already have money.
Is the epl a one horse race???what a boring subject good Grief
Send us a video about this and we might feature you on The Football Show or The Journos!
ball
Scottish Premier league is the worst in the world. No competition whatsoever. Boring.
A say it before and say it again Sevco fucked scottish football..END OFF.
How did rangers screw it up it’s not our fault you lot couldn’t capitalise on our demotion down the leagues